Pour moi Philippe Hirshorn était un violoniste qui était le meilleurs et ne se prenait pas comme certains, il était humble, il jouait à merveille et ne se prenait pas pour un Dieu, ors il était un Ange du violon, pour moi la perfection. Merci Philippe tu es parti trop tôt mais tu reste mon violoniste préféré.
Phillipp Hirschhorn was since 1967, when he came to the Netherlands, my favorite violinist. I want to share my memory of his playing. I remember his vibrance during that concert!
un grand merci. Philippe Hirshhorn est un musicien hors du commun, certainement le meilleur violoniste du XXème siècle!!!! Malheuresement son destin était tragique. Grand Musicien!!!!!
There's no possible way to cheat! You play the way you play, and no one can deny that. People who say he 'cheated' were obviously jealous, envious, and very, very petty. And IGNORANT, because there is simply NO WAY to fake good playing, although anyone can fake poor playing.
I can think of only another violinist that had this explosive,emotional, intensely expressive temperament,Joseph Hassid. Mischa Maisky understood the temperament of this great master artist that was Hirschhorne.
His Thommaso Balestrieri violin was on sale before 20 years (or like that) in Europe. It was not very expensive but I could not buy it. My friend S.G. was student of him and he should buy it. But he didn't. Because he had already a beautiful Tononi violin. It would be a very interessant story if he got the violin.
Я искренне прошу вас не счесть мои слова обидными но если Вы к 2021 году ещё не выучили английский то скорее всего не сможете понять о чём он говорил даже если бы он говорил по-русски. Чтобы начать понимать таких людей как он, нужно куда больше ума чем чтобы выучить английский.
Это очень хорошо, что он вернулся - Филипп ХИРШХОРН. Сейчас его можно подавать каким угодно - европейским человеком или невозвращенцем...это вовсе не умаляет его уникального дарования. Идеология правителей никогда не помогала расцвету талантов - это факт. Нынче будто бы полно свободы для музыкантов - бери любое гражданство или подданство...вон, как Илья ГРУБЕРТ или Илья КАЛЕР - а толку от того !?! Разве они стали от этого великими !?!
I never liked Gidon Kremer's playing -- but now I really have no respect for him. You lost against a person that was meant to lose, and a humble person -- he's disgusting. I would spit on him if I ever see him. Disgusting -- a shame on classical music.
Not a fan of his playing or reaction either, but it is intersting to imagine what led him to believe that! Consider how well hirschhorn played, should there be any doubt that he would win; and even so, he and gidon were classmates iirc. The stakes being as high as they were (I read somewhere that kremer was chosen as the soviet reperesentative) and how he chose to be honest so many years later about these ugly sentiments. It cannot be easy to recall such easily regrettable feelings.
Pour moi Philippe Hirshorn était un violoniste qui était le meilleurs et ne se prenait pas comme certains, il était humble, il jouait à merveille et ne se prenait pas pour un Dieu,
ors il était un Ange du violon, pour moi la perfection. Merci Philippe tu es parti trop tôt
mais tu reste mon violoniste préféré.
Phillipp Hirschhorn was since 1967, when he came to the Netherlands, my favorite violinist. I want to share my memory of his playing. I remember his vibrance during that concert!
What else do you remember from that concert?
Моцарт из Риги!!!!! БРАВО! Изумительно!!! Настоящий Музыкант!
Unique documentary, thank you 🙏
Thanks for this excellent documentary beveiks, I've been looking for this piece of art for years !
un grand merci. Philippe Hirshhorn est un musicien hors du commun, certainement le meilleur violoniste du XXème siècle!!!! Malheuresement son destin était tragique. Grand Musicien!!!!!
Thanks so much for posting this!
There's no possible way to cheat! You play the way you play, and no one can deny that. People who say he 'cheated' were obviously jealous, envious, and very, very petty. And IGNORANT, because there is simply NO WAY to fake good playing, although anyone can fake poor playing.
Make portuguese subtitles please 😱😱... very important documentary!
Lhano Eventos, I am sorry but I do not speak portughese, unfortunately and would not know how to insert subtitles anyway.
Portugal does not have any good violinists. Greece has at least one.
I can think of only another violinist that had this explosive,emotional, intensely expressive temperament,Joseph Hassid.
Mischa Maisky understood the temperament of this great master artist that was Hirschhorne.
Janine Jansen too!
Where is the full clip of the beginning performance?
ruclips.net/video/7Zs6LBhA9u4/видео.htmlsi=akCX0-1WfvTBvC5q
the rest if the 1st movement is on the same youtube channel - Anastasija Violin
@@brixu Omg ily thanks so much! Would you also happen to know where I can find the mp4 of the performance? Thanks in advance
Lo cierto es que pudo ganar Philip o Kremer, los dos son unos grandes violinistas, pero esta vez ganó hirskorn
His Thommaso Balestrieri violin was on sale before 20 years (or like that) in Europe.
It was not very expensive but I could not buy it.
My friend S.G. was student of him and he should buy it.
But he didn't.
Because he had already a beautiful Tononi violin.
It would be a very interessant story if he got the violin.
What was the price?
@@valeripopov5334 Sorry! I forgot it!
@@AllrounderMaximus Thanks, that would have interested me.
GK should d have stood by the side and cheered as the winner went by. Not a good look.
Нет ли на русском? Пожалуйста!
Вы не нашли на русском , случайно?
Я искренне прошу вас не счесть мои слова обидными но если Вы к 2021 году ещё не выучили английский то скорее всего не сможете понять о чём он говорил даже если бы он говорил по-русски. Чтобы начать понимать таких людей как он, нужно куда больше ума чем чтобы выучить английский.
@@alexivanov6776 Музыку "понимают" сердцем, а не словами, на каком-бы языке не рассказывали о ней....
Это очень хорошо, что он вернулся - Филипп ХИРШХОРН.
Сейчас его можно подавать каким угодно - европейским человеком или невозвращенцем...это вовсе не умаляет его уникального дарования. Идеология правителей никогда не помогала расцвету талантов - это факт. Нынче будто бы полно свободы для музыкантов - бери любое гражданство или подданство...вон, как Илья ГРУБЕРТ или Илья КАЛЕР - а толку от того !?! Разве они стали от этого великими !?!
I never liked Gidon Kremer's playing -- but now I really have no respect for him. You lost against a person that was meant to lose, and a humble person -- he's disgusting. I would spit on him if I ever see him. Disgusting -- a shame on classical music.
?
Not a fan of his playing or reaction either, but it is intersting to imagine what led him to believe that! Consider how well hirschhorn played, should there be any doubt that he would win; and even so, he and gidon were classmates iirc. The stakes being as high as they were (I read somewhere that kremer was chosen as the soviet reperesentative) and how he chose to be honest so many years later about these ugly sentiments. It cannot be easy to recall such easily regrettable feelings.