I met an old Polish man once, in the operating theatre of the spinal unit of the hospital i worked in. He had a number crudely tattooed into his forearm. He had marched from Auschwitz to Germany, barefoot in the winter of 1944-45 as a young boy. He lost both of his feet to frostbite. He was the jolliest soul you could hope to meet. Love emanated from his every fibre.
@@gabecarlos61 You must be from the equator & don't understand the span of the passing seasons. The spring equinox begins in March in Europe. Do you see your mistake now ?
@@gabecarlos61 No need to apologise. If anything your comment inspired my edit, in stipulating 44-45 . The March took place in the January of 45. It's not a well known subject after all. So further clarity came of it . Have a good day.
in 1976 as a grammar school kid we moved to West Los Angeles in a highly Jewish area. we were the only Latino Catholic's in our neighborhood...we used to go to the donut shop where 2 older ladies worked and always gaves us free donuts etc..I noticed that they both had tattoo serial numbers on their arms..when I asked them about it they said...its too horrible for little boys to understand...years later in ugh school I finally realized what they meant...decades later it gets me everytime thinking about it
My first cousin married a lady who is a holocaust survivor. They were from Poland. Her mom and dad moved back in the mountains of southeast Kentucky when my cousin got out of the army. Her dad learned some English. I remember hearing him talk when I was little. I wish I had payed more attention to what he was saying. Edit: RIP Diane Belcher. You were one fine lady. We were blessed to have you in the family. ✌
I am a German and 19 years old.Nowadays, we are informed and educated about this at a very early age in school. Of course, there are still people who deny the Holocaust.... Monsters will always exist. But when I look at that, when I look at documentaries and reports like that, it always brings tears to my eyes and I'm disgusted with Germany. Even as a German and even though I know that Germany was in a desperate situation at that time.... Nobody has the right to treat others like that.
At least they educate you about the horrors of NAZI Germany. In America, many schools try to romanticize the Civil War and slavery as the Lost Cause. You ban any NAZI paraphernalia and we celebrate any remnant of the Confederacy in many states still.
When she speaks about the indifference of their "neighbors" who never asked any questions it only reminds me of the reason this was allowed to happen in the first place. The people turned their heads and closed their eyes.
@@HAbarneyWK the community n population will always out number those in power. The sad part is the common man only cares when their life is inconvenienced
God bless you Schindler. Your story brought me to tears. My mother always taught me that there is good and bad n every race and u were an example of the good
@SuperBiking1340 you said and claimed, and I quote: "Ah Shindlers Ark you mean .A novel written by an Australian in 1984. Nothing in that "book" is real. Dont believe me look it up. Spielburg hijacked it and turned it into "fact"." Given all survivor witness accounts, all the war time pictures, all the documents, Schindler's grave in Israel, et cetera, I consider that an extraordinary claim. Can you please present your solid, scrutinized and verifiable evidence supporting your claim. Much obliged. Reference: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schindler%27s_Ark
I definitely think it's because questioning WAS suppressed, and how/why would you question nazis right in front of them? I'd still be intimidated, you just can't interrupt a bunch of brutes with guns...
Probably to frightened of being arrested by the Gestapo who would charge them with dissent against the Nazi regime which would get them and possibly their families sent to a concentration camp. Many Germans were sent to the camps for this and some didn't survive.
I think it’s because not enough people verbalize their questions. It’s very frightening if you fight alone, even if you want to fight. A lot of time people are disconcerted, gruntled, angry. But it’s no good murmuring in private.
In the darkness of a denier's mind, logic has never been welcome. But hatred grows freely there. The lack of logic is shown in their denial. As a character in a play said "If there was no holocaust, where are my sister and brother?"
People believe that earth is flat , learned about Holocaust in school (Catholic school) Israel wanted to bring charges about these people still alive because they didn't want the their Country's youth to forget about the Holocaust (I Think in the late '60's) and they wanted him to face the judge in Israel Adolf Eichman, that made the angel of death Mengele nervous died of a strock
When they all shook her sweet hands and spoke of their love and respect for her, I LOST it. What a kind heart of this woman and of course kind heart of Schindler 💜💚💛💙❤ May God hold him in eternity forever.
@@weatherman68 DoEs It MaTtEr ThAt A sMaLl GrOuP oF 6 mIlLiOn PeOpLe DiEd In HoRrIfFiC wAyS bY bIgOtEd RaCiSt AsShOlEs? Yes. Why? Well you see, it's because ThEy MaKe It AlL aBoUt ThEmSeLvEs! Are you fucking listening to yourself? what a dick.
Why do some people say the Holocaust didn’t happen or that it was exaggerated? How can they say this? Almost complete genocide if not for the survivors. It must never be forgotten!!
Maybe the cause is, those who say that their neighbors were "indifferent"; What could they do??? Who could they have asked??? Classes in School? Poles were forbidden by the Nazis from studying in proper schools. At the same time, the non-Jewish pharmacist, who worked in the center of what became the Ghetto (not in the center of Krakow, but on the relatively new neighborhood of Podgorze, which exists on the other side of the river), stayed with his Jewish clients and helped them. The lives of many Jews were saved by their Polish neighbors. These facts should be mentioned and remembered.
@@InjusticeGoldstone Schindler spent his entire fortune on saving Jews. He had to bribe NAZI officials and acquired supplies on the black market for the Jews to escape.
@@easyenetwork2023 I know, and that was great. But I talk about the Polish population, who bravely fought a war with poor weapons, and couldn't do anything under occupation.
Idiots and trolls most of them, some though see the panzers the tiger tanks the uniforms the skulls and feel like they want to be a part of it, I was once like them, NAZI propaganda was and IS still to this day very powerful.
Thank you, Rena, for sharing your testimony about how Oskar Schindler rescued you and the more than 1100 other Jews, and at great risk to his own life.
Oscar risked his own life to save so many innocent lives. He intentionally messed up the war machine through faulty ammunition and other things. God bless his memory.
Don't worry bart van Huslt, the Lord sees it all and it is written, "Every idle word that a person has spoken, they shall give account thereof in the Day of Judgment." Jesus spoke those words. No doubt, that includes "long range speaking" by internet. Psalm 37: "When the wicked spring forth as grass, it is only so they shall be cut down as in a moment." They will not always strut around mouthing off, God will destroy them.
I met an Auschwitz survivor and that was the best time in my life hearing her stories. I just off duty with the Navy so I was in uniform and I wanted to cry but I couldn't. We stay in contact and have coffee from time to time.
Theres a portuguese man that save a lot more lifes ,didnt get much recognition and lost everything ,living in poverty for issuing visas against goverment policy ,provably the single person who saved more jewish lifes around 10.000 during ww2 ,makes me very proud that i am portuguese his name is ARISTIDES DE SOUSA MENDES. A GREAT MAN GOD BLESS YOU .
Your comment is off base even if some of that is true. Schindler's jews themselves have testified to how he actually cared a lot about them. The little girl in the movie who kissed him at his birthday was a real person, whom he had approached on the train when she first arrived at the camp. She was very sick and lying on the floor of the train, arms covered in puss, and he went in with his fancy clothes, feather on his hat, picked her up and said, "Don't worry, my angel, you will live," and carried her out of the train. He then would take his sandwhiches that were made by his wife to her so she would recover. On his birthday, he gave half a loaf of bread to every family in the camp. He also went to prison for the little girl kiss at the birthday, because she was a jew kissing him. Finally, a man actually did donate his gold teeth bridge so they could make him a ring. The survivors testified that no one died at his camp.
Yes but let's be fair that this guy and Schindler isn't an apples to apples comparison. Schindler operated a work camp for Nazi Germany and could have worked those people to their death. The other guy issued Visas for another country.
I look and listen at this video and then I look at what is going on in the USA at this time. Nobody listens for long and nobody learns. It breaks my heart.
I've heard it said that third of the German people supported Hitler, a third were indifferent and a third opposed him but were afraid to speak out for fear of reprisals. It sounds plausible.
Rena, you are an inspiration to the world. Thank you so much Rena. I can't find the right words to convey what I feel after hearing your testimony.............
I am a native indian of what's now called america and I may not understand Jewish language or culture but I do understand being seen as less as I also have african descendents in my family and GOD truly bless those of any race that stood up for those that were helpless rip Mr schindler.
Yes....but today is not like then. TODAY people use rascism so that they can sit on their fat asses and eat doritos saying POOR ME...back then jews, indians, black bless their hearts for what they endured and overcame. But i hate people drawing comparisons to today... Today is just a bunch of whiny poor me bitches ( with the exception of 9/11 and what Putin is doing)
This has to keep being taught in schools , every single generation must be educated to the horrors of unspeakable acts of evil committed by the nazis and never , ever let anything like this happen again . Education is vital to stop evil before it begins , God bless all the people who perished , and God bless Oscar schindler , a true and real humanitarian
It is taught in school. And in media. And circulates socially all the time through every generation. It's why every westerner on the planet thinks nazis should be brutally murdered even if they don't know how to read.
I had to jump a big wall to visit his grave to pay my respect, as I was deciding to jump the wall due to the gates being locked, I met an American fellow who looked upset as it was his last day in Israel and he wanted to visit the grave, I told him my plan to which he was very unsure of, as I climbed over the wall I looked at him and said last chance and I reached out to help him up and over the wall. Then in a panic we rushed about looking for the grave, then I recalled it was covered in stones, and climbed to a high point and saw it, we rushed towards the location and I grabbed his camera as he paid his respects, so he had the pictures of this moment to share with his friends and family plus the fact we over come a locked gate by jumping a large wall and could have been shot at any moment. We parted outside and I know I made his day :)
Pastor neimoller said, when they came for the homosexuals I did not speak put. When they came for the doctors I did not speak out. When they came for the teachers I did not speak out. When they came for the Jews I did not speak out. When they came for me there was no one left to speak out.
I can't understand how anyone can deny the holocaust happened? I'm Scottish and not of any religion, both my parents fought during the WW2 dad in the Royal Navy partaking amongst other duties in the Atlantic Convoys and was at "the taking of Rangoon" against the Japanese who'd invaded Burma. My mum lined up predictors to shoot down German aircraft invading Britain. Neither knew about the holocaust until after the war was over and both were horrified by what they saw on the news reels showing the liberation from the concentration camps. My parent went on to have 4 children, my 3 much older brothers and myself the baby girl by 7 years to the youngest brother. My father thought it important that we grew up knowing about the horrors of war and the concentration camps. I recall being about 7 or 8 and on Sunday's the BBC would show "The World at War" one I remember stood out more than some of the others was the Nuremberg Trials. One of my first trips abroad from Scotland was to Munich, there I found out from other travellers that one could visit Dachau Concentration camp. My camera had a roll of coloured film 35mm and I'd used about 10 pictures on it, but all the pictures I took in Dachau came out overcast and hazy/misty even though it was a beautiful sunny day with no clouds in the sky. I also took photo's outside the camp and when developed as I said the ones inside grey/misty/hazy and outside this place of evil bright clear sunny, the settings hadn't been altered and it was spooky. Going round the exhibition seeing ceiling to floor photo's of women and small children being lead by a nazi soldier towards a mass grave where they were obviously going to be shoot was an awful thing to witness, there were implements of torture on display and at the end an explanation about why the camps are still there- To prevent man's inhumanity to man from ever happening again. I also saw the ovens one could still see the grey clinging to the walls and oven floor from use of these ovens. I also recall not hearing any bird song whilst in this place of evil.
SuperBking1340 Stop being offensive. You are incredibly opinionated. Your mentality is "if they're not with you, they're against you" Don't believe everything you read or that people post online.Respect that my option is different to yours, I accept you don't believe what others have seen.
this makes one question the fall of the Berlin wall, there are hidden meanings for everything, that usually make a lot more sense than the reasons given to the public.
when i took a trip to washington dc in 2018, i saw a holocaust survivor in a holocaaust museum giving autographs for her book she had published. the museum was kinda dark, not just for the lack of light but because everywhere you walked into, there was nazi symbols, jewish personal items, recreation of the guetto, names and photographs of people, etc.
That is the point. It's dark in order to remind people how much Hell the Holocaust survivors went through. It's definitely not meant to be a trip to Disney Land.
Not truly righteous man, Schindler was a German spy who arranged the uniforms that caused the possibility for Hitler to declare war, under false pretext to start war.
What she said will give nightmares i had never thought about it, all those professionals all those well mannered people studies doctors poets talented people who lived around them Kept silence, no one helped them, huge part of that germany in those years are all guilty some for pulling the trigger and other for simply not saying anything, but i too just being a human being i feel embarresed of my own kind just humans in general we are a disgrace for this planet..
I’m so confused as to what I’m reading in this comment section! I have scene at least 20 plus comments that are denying the holocaust even happens and denouncing the truths of the survivors!!! This is real life and the fact that people are saying to “get over it” are actually horrible! If u saw your mother,father,kids,friends etc get shot how could you ever forget that? You wouldn’t! It’s ptsd and grief these people are still going threw and they have the COURAGE AND STRENGTH to even speak about it and EDUCATE people on what happened!!! Another thing people are stating that Oskar Schindler wasn’t a real person when he WAS and in every movie that is based off of true events adds some dialogue because it’s a movie! I bet everyone who is belittling and denouncing what these people really experienced are idiots with the same mindset of Nazis and klan members
The people who come on here and say dumb shit like this, I just trying to start stupid crap. They’re nothing but a bunch of control. That is what they do. They are a bunch of bullies. I’m sure they’re great great great grandparents are a bunch of fucking bullies which is why they are bullies too.
If you can afford to do so, please visit a concentration some time in your lifetime. To think that real people were subjected to that treatment is horrifying.
My father in law has many pictures of those horrible camps he was a young man drafted in the clean up over there. When he first showed me the and explained what he saw it broke your heart, how horrible it truly was and that anyone could such horrible things to another one. Yet today we see the same kind of evil being done around the world.
So true. It is sad because the Holocaust is to be an example to to never repeat. Yet it goes on, and no one is speaking out who can make a difference. It is heartbreaking to think that now even after over a half century there is the extinction of the people in the middle east as I watch this video and make this comment.
Konan,,,, WE CAN MY FRIEND!!!!! BELIEVE AND HAVE FAITH, AND WITH THISE SPIRITUAL TOOLS PRAY FOR THE WORLD.... WE ARE ON A SPIRAL ROLLERCOASTER MY FRIEND, AND ARMAGEDDON WILL COME.. GOD BLESS WITH MUCH PRAYERS.....
When I visited Poland the guide told us not to talk about Oscar Schindler only in postive ways, most Polish people appeared to dispise him, her argument was that schindler probably only saved the jews because he knew the Nazi's were falling. I was really confused, after a year I watched the Schindlers lists and can relate to some parts but for me it matters more that he had maybe a change of heart.
Well he could have easily fled with the amount of money he had if he was a real Nazi his hatred and greed would have not given a dam about the Jews .The polish people suffered probably the worst of all Europe getting batted like a tennis ball between the Germans and the Russians and no one was coming to their aid but they also had a lot of hatred for the Jews so maybe their views of Schindler have been muddied by that fact .
@@Skies133 Antisemitism was rampant throughout Europe by the time Hitler came to power. The Jewish people have long been accused of cultural invasion in whatever nations they occupied. Then, after WWI the victors brutally punished Germany for their active involvement in the war. Their military was disbanded, they weren’t allowed to manufacture war materials, and were burdened with crushing repatriations. Their economy was destroyed, their currency was made almost worthless (a single loaf of bread required a literal wheelbarrow full of paper bills to pay for), and they were angry and resentful. Adolf Hitler, with the help of many supporters, came to power promising to fix everything unilaterally. His friend, Joseph Goebbels, put out a steady stream of well written propaganda extolling the importance of Aryan supremacy, and labeling Jews as the lowest form of trash who were secretly plotting to take over the world. In anger and desperation, and after hearing Joseph Goebbels’ puff pieces, they eventually came to believe it all.
@@JustSomeGuyNotAnAlien That's exactly the way you stupid Brits and Americans think. Who do you think you are??!! You disgusting scumbags!Palestinians were driven out of their country and are being terrorised by fascist Jews up to the present day, you stupid ignorant piece of shit.
I just googled "Schindler's List" the novel by Australian author Thomas Keneally upon which the movie is based. There are many articles stating that the book was based on REAL EVENTS AND PEOPLE. According to the author, it is listed as a fiction novel because he used "fiction techiques" such as character development and invented dialogue to make the story read like a novel, just as "The Right Stuff" by Tom Wolfe is FICTION BASED ON REAL EVENTS of. NASA's Mercury project. Do not worry about the deniers, they either cannot read or most likely are just trying to spread lies and misinformation. I consider them accessories after the fact in the Nazi crimes of torture and genocide, because they are anti-semitic, or express approval for the crimes while denying them, or they try to make excuses by citing the 60 millions killed under Stalin. They are not worth wasting precious time to argue with them, they will not see reason and do not care about the truth.
@@WillyEckaslike couldn't find it on youtube. However, if it's a video denying the holocaust it has to contend with a consensus from historians, living witnesses, both jew and nazis and liberations of the camps. The actions to save jews from the camps taken during, by the end and after the war by people from other countries, neutral or otherwise. To ignore it is ignorance. I don't know your life so I can't know how you ended up down that path but I do hope you start re-mapping your brain. Anyone can create a conspiracy theory that sounds convincing (it's easy when you don't have to take facts into account), however, that doesn't make them true. It's different to be critical of your sources of information than it is to simply listen to someone saying what you want to believe is real. Again, I don't know your story, or why you feel the need to belive the holocaust did not happen, or who planted that seed in you from the beginning, but here I am wishing you start taking back controll of your life and well being. Why? Beacuse we're in this togehter. You, me and everybody else.
The nazies were open about their antisemitism and thus were envied by the politically correct antisemities. Nazism is not the only expression of antisemitism.
I do not agree with the statement that no one cared about the Jews in those terrible times. Lots of Poles risked the lives and lives of their relatives for helping and sometimes hiding entire Jewish families. I am not making excuses to anyone, but saying that nothing was done and nobody cared is not entirely true and fair.
And some nazi (not a lot obviously, just a few) did change their mind and apologized and other defected when they had the chance. I say it just because it makes me less desperate to think there is always a little spark of hope even in the darkest times
Well not enought did... think about that... more kept silence than the ones who did something... the sentiment that you see on the last scene of the movie where he says, I could of saved one more just one or 2 maybe i could have will always be in the minds of those who helped but more in the ones who looked away, very few stories of soldiers standing up to the ss you dont hear them often or never, they were animals.
While it is true that some cared for the Jews during the genocide, we cannot say that it is unfair for her, a survivor of the Holocaust, to say that no one cared for them at the time. At that moment, it actually seemed that no one did care to help them and save them as they were surrounded with atrocities; it was what she felt at that moment until Oskar Schindler came in the picture. Looking back, there were a few who tried to help these Jews but before they were saved, everything and everyone around them was against them.
Its so easy 4 us 2 judge in retrospect and from a comfortable armchair, but let's try 2 imagine ourselves in such circumstances. What would we do? How would we behave?
I'm not comparing the current political climate to WW2 but I think it is very important to hear these words. It's easy to find yourself somewhat jaded and apathetic. The disconnect between the atrocities of the holocaust and our daily lives and routines is vast. Dismissal and a brief couple of chapters taught in school are not enough. America does things now that would astound the majority of the population if they took the time to look into the various conflicts we insert ourselves into. Willful ignorance, behind a comforting curtain. Once again I'm not comparing these 2 time periods to each other. I just find it disturbing how comfortable people are with just assuming that the government has the best interests of the people in mind. The majority of the German people as a whole didn't know the full extent of what was happening (although many had an idea) and they had that same confidence in the nazi hierarchy. The evidence is always there, and failing to put it together is a bullshit excuse for ignoring the victims suffering. Complicity, guilt by association, by omission. It's easy to ignore the unpleasant things and put them in the back of your mind. Moral cowardice and unwillingness to keep the leadership in check always leads to a horrible conclusion. The most horrible things are sometimes done with the best of intentions.
Now 2020, i hope we the young keep proetesting, teach eachother of warning signs and vote if we could. despite in my average public school we studied the ww2 holocaust extensively from middle school and highschool (learning the culture, politics, mindsets and the leading topics of the war and the people and connect it to modern spotting of fake news,ect). we even read the stories of survivors (Anne frank's diary and the night by elie wiesel) and our library makes sure to put ww2/holocaust topic in front page pick when we enter (my favorite pick yet tragic graphic novel is Maus by art spiegelman) then visited in our school fieldtrip of the washington D.C Holocaust museum (i even seen relating topics like khmer rouge/cambodia massacres and middle east warcrimes, then got my card of a holocaust survivor identity & her life description). then our school gave us knowledge despite having an underfunded/terrible reputation but diverse & friendly with great quality teachers despite us aloof studenst we got these topics seriously by watching documentaries and immersing ourselves to it even talking on modern topics of BLM and Persepolis,immigration and hope it continues to teach such issues and its lessons
If you weren't 14 or older than children younger than that were either sent to the merciless 'doctors' or the flames. The "doctors" were unit 731 and the Sadistic inhuman demon Josef mengle. I myself am not a Holocaust survivor but my grandpa had to grow up during those times and I am grateful that I am alive.
Many sent to die if they were sick. Other to do house work finally.to concentration camps, all those twins and plenty of others to do experiments on them if they died during yhe experiment they would dispossed of them and bring a new one, after all they had alot of children... it makes me sick just to think about that.. doctors people that studied scientist and more opening up children to do their reaserch.
naah doesbt prove anything, the scientific believe and research showed that for certain information of jewish extermenation was obtained by allis only in 1944 and when asked if they should bomb aushwitz the main concern that churchill expressed was that most likely all of the prisoners will die , and if they dont bomb but eliberate it( which was clear by then , because everyone knew germany is losing) some of the prisoners have a chance to survive. As harsh as this may sound he wasnt actually wrong on that, and the survival of somebody like primo levi wouldnt be possible . The thing is even if aushwitz would be bombed there would prolly still be mass killings regardless, but i do think it was a mistakr
So much resemblance with today's America. He who does not learn from the mistakes of the past is destined to repeat it. This is not about politics, this is about human lives.
@Henry Avila Are you serious? You are comparing Nazi Germany where 6 million innocent people were systemically murdered with contemporary United States? Last I checked, we don't have concentration camps murdering 6 million people. Last I checked, EVERYONE in the United States has rights that are afforded to them by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. So, please explain your comparison.
IF YOU LIKE WHAT YOU SEE ON "VIDEOCOLLECTABLES," HELP THE CREATOR LAUNCH HIS COMPANION CHANNEL - "VIDEO SCRAPBOOK" ( www.youtube.com/@VideoScrapbookOfOurTimes/ ). THIS IS A CALL TO ACTION. WE NEED 30 SUBSCRIBERS TO BE VIABLE. YOU CAN MAKE THIS MILESTONE A REALITY, WHICH WILL ENCOURAGE MORE UPLOADS. A CLICK COSTS YOU NOTHING BUT A MOMENT OF YOUR TIME. THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
It's always the most tragic events that have the conspiracy theorists and deniers. But its always the most weak minded ppl living in their basements. And unfortunately they will never change their mind. So just ignore them. 'The list is life. All around its borders lies the gulf.'
Our history books have been wholly inaccurate. (GOOGLE- IMPORTANT QUOTATIONS FOR A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF WW II.) The truth is in the real written words of prominent men of the 20s through 40s. "We butchered the wrong pig". Winston Churchill. "We defeated the wrong enemy". Gen George S Patton. Do the rest of the research yourself.
God bless of those people protect the innocent and reward them a freedom of everlasting life, and good paradise for them to God almighty one and holy immortal one.
Ok?!? Think of this. One person saved is incredible. 10 people is beautiful. He saved over a thousand. One thousand people who were able to blink, love, marry, and live. Ok is atp disrespectful. He is an incredible man.
@@channieszoo4342 seriously what this man did is insanly heroic. The amount of lives that lived, let alone were created because of this man is astounding. A true hero in such a dark fucking time
think about about it this way … you are 1 human being so unique, magnificent, loving, with your own personality and relationships and way of thinking Now multiply that to x1100 … it’s not little amount of people, this man saved generations of jews also he had to pay for each and every single jew … this man threw away his entire fortune … to todays equivalent of 10’s of millions of dollars it’s no chump change and at a time like that … this man was an angel … he sacrificed everything
How many people would choose to throw away a comfortable life of luxury ...to live in poverty??? NOT YOU. this man did it to give 1200 people the chance to continue their stories and to have kids and their kids had kids. He was the ultimate hero
Read about the Talmud and what it says about non Jews. Look up the Transfer Agreement. We've been lied to. Even Jesus called them the synagogue of satan. Do you research.
I did my research, and here's what I found. Jesus did not call Jews "the synagogue of satan." You seem to be talking about Revelation 2:9 : “‘I know your tribulation and your poverty (but you are rich) and the slander[a] of those who say that they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan. As it turns out, this is actually a criticism of the church at Smyrna, where some people claimed to be "Jews" but only outwardly and not inwardly. Basically, he was saying that some of the people there were only going through the motions of being Jews/faithful/worshipping God, and so those people were not truly "Jews" or believers in God. This was not a condemnation of Jews on the whole, or as separate from Christianity, only some specific people at Smyrna who didn't have God in their hearts. Here are three separate interpretations of Revelation 2:9 that explain that Jesus is not equating Jews as a religion/race with evil. 1. www.biblestudytools.com/commentaries/revelation/revelation-2/revelation-2-9.html 2. www.biblestudytools.com/commentaries/gills-exposition-of-the-bible/revelation-2-9.html 3. bradkelly.wordpress.com/2009/06/10/who-is-a-true-jew-revelation-29-39/
From the third source in my previous comment (bradkelly.wordpress.com/2009/06/10/who-is-a-true-jew-revelation-29-39/) If you heard someone say, “he says he is a professional baseball player, but he is not,” what could you safely assume? I believe you could safely assume two things: 1. There really is such a thing as a professional baseball player: such a person actually exists. 2. The person making the claim is not truly a professional baseball player. So returning to the text we can safely assume two things: 1. There really is such a group as Jews: true Jews. 2. Those making the claim to be Jewish are not truly Jews.
Just before Germany invaded Poland there were around 800000 German refugees who had lived in and around the boarder of Poland and Germany. These civilians fled their homes because of increasing Polish violence against them. I can see why Rena would have had "problems with the [German] bystanders" after her countrymen had treated so many innocent Germans as "sub human".
Having the Jews taken a lifetime lesson from the Holocaust to coexist and live in a peaceful environment with others. Unfortunately, you don't. Instead, you oppressed other people need to live and have a good life. Stop your aggression and inhumane act like the evil Nazi have done onto you. Be grateful. Be kind. Be helpful to others. I know you can't do it.
Are you saying all Jews are the same? you're generalizing the entire population and that's just like if some one were to say "All Muslims are terrorist", or "Or blacks are robbers" or "All whites are Plantation owners". To believe those things is true evil and you know it.
@@SAFbikes I mean honestly people today can go on circle jerks about Israeli crimes against Palestinians but then turn right around and call you a nazi if you bring it up to make a point.
Spielberg: "... being a Jew was a death sentence." Hand goes to chin, hiding nothing because you can't cover lies with your hands, only showing great sadness at the thought of his own mortality and those who died.
Selfish because she didn't play in a movie about something she already had to live through once? Unfortunately what I think she knows is real suffering.
I met an old Polish man once, in the operating theatre of the spinal unit of the hospital i worked in. He had a number crudely tattooed into his forearm. He had marched from Auschwitz to Germany, barefoot in the winter of 1944-45 as a young boy. He lost both of his feet to frostbite. He was the jolliest soul you could hope to meet. Love emanated from his every fibre.
War in Europe was over by winter 1945
@@gabecarlos61 You must be from the equator & don't understand the span of the passing seasons. The spring equinox begins in March in Europe. Do you see your mistake now ?
@@anvilbrunner.2013 yes I do now actually. Sorry I didn’t see winter of 44. My apologies
@@gabecarlos61 No need to apologise. If anything your comment inspired my edit, in stipulating 44-45 . The March took place in the January of 45. It's not a well known subject after all. So further clarity came of it . Have a good day.
in 1976 as a grammar school kid we moved to West Los Angeles in a highly Jewish area. we were the only Latino Catholic's in our neighborhood...we used to go to the donut shop where 2 older ladies worked and always gaves us free donuts etc..I noticed that they both had tattoo serial numbers on their arms..when I asked them about it they said...its too horrible for little boys to understand...years later in ugh school I finally realized what they meant...decades later it gets me everytime thinking about it
My first cousin married a lady who is a holocaust survivor. They were from Poland. Her mom and dad moved back in the mountains of southeast Kentucky when my cousin got out of the army. Her dad learned some English. I remember hearing him talk when I was little. I wish I had payed more attention to what he was saying. Edit: RIP Diane Belcher. You were one fine lady. We were blessed to have you in the family. ✌
I am a German and 19 years old.Nowadays, we are informed and educated about this at a very early age in school. Of course, there are still people who deny the Holocaust.... Monsters will always exist. But when I look at that, when I look at documentaries and reports like that, it always brings tears to my eyes and I'm disgusted with Germany. Even as a German and even though I know that Germany was in a desperate situation at that time.... Nobody has the right to treat others like that.
I heard from my friends that younger ppl in your country have a hatred toward older ppl because of them following the nazi is that true?
@@Nier.nguyen it is not true. Otherwise people would have to hate their own grandparents
At least they educate you about the horrors of NAZI Germany. In America, many schools try to romanticize the Civil War and slavery as the Lost Cause. You ban any NAZI paraphernalia and we celebrate any remnant of the Confederacy in many states still.
It’s not monstrous to ask questions. Truth fears no investigation.
When she speaks about the indifference of their "neighbors" who never asked any questions it only reminds me of the reason this was allowed to happen in the first place. The people turned their heads and closed their eyes.
Yep, and just like in China today.
Evil prevails when good men do nothing.
It's not as simple as them not caring. They had families to think about.
@@HAbarneyWK white, blond, blue eyed Germans were in no danger, it is they who should have risen up against the horror.
@@HAbarneyWK the community n population will always out number those in power. The sad part is the common man only cares when their life is inconvenienced
God bless you Schindler. Your story brought me to tears. My mother always taught me that there is good and bad n every race and u were an example of the good
Then you and your Mother shot read about wat a man he realy was. A war profetere and spy for Abwehr
I'm a man's man I don't cry at funerals but Schindler's List was heartbreaking
@@SuperBking1340 No, I believe he was talking about the movie. Your "argument" will be dismissed.
@@meryatathagres1998 Just like the truth no doubt.
@@SuperBking1340 your an idiot
I've watched some of the videos on the concentration camps and the Richard Dimbleby one for the BBC is devastating.
@SuperBiking1340 you said and claimed, and I quote:
"Ah Shindlers Ark you mean .A novel written by an Australian in 1984. Nothing in that "book" is real. Dont believe me look it up. Spielburg hijacked it and turned it into "fact"."
Given all survivor witness accounts, all the war time pictures, all the documents, Schindler's grave in Israel, et cetera, I consider that an extraordinary claim.
Can you please present your solid, scrutinized and verifiable evidence supporting your claim.
Much obliged.
Reference: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schindler%27s_Ark
The part about the neighbors not asking questions was chilling.
I definitely think it's because questioning WAS suppressed, and how/why would you question nazis right in front of them? I'd still be intimidated, you just can't interrupt a bunch of brutes with guns...
It is the same thing now. Who really fights and questions the government today?
Probably to frightened of being arrested by the Gestapo who would charge them with dissent against the Nazi regime which would get them and possibly their families sent to a concentration camp. Many Germans were sent to the camps for this and some didn't survive.
Maybe bc their families would be shot in front of them if they did ask...
I think it’s because not enough people verbalize their questions. It’s very frightening if you fight alone, even if you want to fight. A lot of time people are disconcerted, gruntled, angry. But it’s no good murmuring in private.
Now we also have many deniers of the October 7 massacre in this day when information travels faster than the speed of light.
We must fight together to keep our people around even today.
Too true, some things never change.
How can the deniers live with themselves? They must be infected with supreme ignorance.
How can you deny an event that has more evidence to prove it than any other event in history?
In the darkness of a denier's mind, logic has never been welcome. But hatred grows freely there. The lack of logic is shown in their denial. As a character in a play said "If there was no holocaust, where are my sister and brother?"
Not ignorance, hatred. Ignorance is curable through knowledge. Hatred requires a commitment and change that most cannot make.
People believe that earth is flat , learned about Holocaust in school (Catholic school) Israel wanted to bring charges about these people still alive because they didn't want the their Country's youth to forget about the Holocaust (I Think in the late '60's) and they wanted him to face the judge in Israel Adolf Eichman, that made the angel of death Mengele nervous died of a strock
Publius because they're full of shit duh
Liam Neeson was a fine choice to play the role of Oskar Schindler.
When they all shook her sweet hands and spoke of their love and respect for her, I LOST it. What a kind heart of this woman and of course kind heart of Schindler 💜💚💛💙❤ May God hold him in eternity forever.
I broke into tears when I was listening to this I couldn't watch even the movie scenes. Oskar Shchindler God Bless You!
Daniel Österman Burn Hollywood,burn!!
Ricardo Fernandes 👍
@@weatherman68 DoEs It MaTtEr ThAt A sMaLl GrOuP oF 6 mIlLiOn PeOpLe DiEd In HoRrIfFiC wAyS bY bIgOtEd RaCiSt AsShOlEs? Yes. Why? Well you see, it's because ThEy MaKe It AlL aBoUt ThEmSeLvEs! Are you fucking listening to yourself? what a dick.
Why do some people say the Holocaust didn’t happen or that it was exaggerated? How can they say this? Almost complete genocide if not for the survivors. It must never be forgotten!!
They are more lost then the nazis.
Maybe the cause is, those who say that their neighbors were "indifferent"; What could they do??? Who could they have asked??? Classes in School? Poles were forbidden by the Nazis from studying in proper schools.
At the same time, the non-Jewish pharmacist, who worked in the center of what became the Ghetto (not in the center of Krakow, but on the relatively new neighborhood of Podgorze, which exists on the other side of the river), stayed with his Jewish clients and helped them. The lives of many Jews were saved by their Polish neighbors. These facts should be mentioned and remembered.
@@InjusticeGoldstone Schindler spent his entire fortune on saving Jews. He had to bribe NAZI officials and acquired supplies on the black market for the Jews to escape.
@@easyenetwork2023 I know, and that was great. But I talk about the Polish population, who bravely fought a war with poor weapons, and couldn't do anything under occupation.
Idiots and trolls most of them, some though see the panzers the tiger tanks the uniforms the skulls and feel like they want to be a part of it, I was once like them, NAZI propaganda was and IS still to this day very powerful.
Thank you, Rena, for sharing your testimony about how Oskar Schindler rescued you and the more than 1100 other Jews, and at great risk to his own life.
"the one who saves one life, saves the world entirely"
Oscar risked his own life to save so many innocent lives. He intentionally messed up the war machine through faulty ammunition and other things. God bless his memory.
How can people make such rude comments.
Lack of information, bad parenting. What a shame people like that are in the same world as me.
bart van hulst what brain dead you think you know something we dont?
Don't worry bart van Huslt, the Lord sees it all and it is written, "Every idle word that a person has spoken, they shall give account thereof in the Day of Judgment." Jesus spoke those words. No doubt, that includes "long range speaking" by internet.
Psalm 37: "When the wicked spring forth as grass, it is only so they shall be cut down as in a moment."
They will not always strut around mouthing off, God will destroy them.
bart van hulst pray for those people
That’s exactly what the Nazis said
I met an Auschwitz survivor and that was the best time in my life hearing her stories. I just off duty with the Navy so I was in uniform and I wanted to cry but I couldn't. We stay in contact and have coffee from time to time.
I hope this lady had a long and joyous life for the rest of it ❤❤❤
great story that goes into the history. A great hero, pleased to know that heroes still exists, let's spread the news.
Theres a portuguese man that save a lot more lifes ,didnt get much recognition and lost everything ,living in poverty for issuing visas against goverment policy ,provably the single person who saved more jewish lifes around 10.000 during ww2 ,makes me very proud that i am portuguese his name is ARISTIDES DE SOUSA MENDES. A GREAT MAN GOD BLESS YOU .
Woah, you learn something new every day.
Such an unfair world we live in.
But at least his memory can live on, and he will be remembered as a hero...
He’s Righteous Among the Nations. While he didn’t get a book or movie he still got the same treatment as Schindler from the sate of Israel.
Your comment is off base even if some of that is true. Schindler's jews themselves have testified to how he actually cared a lot about them. The little girl in the movie who kissed him at his birthday was a real person, whom he had approached on the train when she first arrived at the camp. She was very sick and lying on the floor of the train, arms covered in puss, and he went in with his fancy clothes, feather on his hat, picked her up and said, "Don't worry, my angel, you will live," and carried her out of the train. He then would take his sandwhiches that were made by his wife to her so she would recover. On his birthday, he gave half a loaf of bread to every family in the camp. He also went to prison for the little girl kiss at the birthday, because she was a jew kissing him. Finally, a man actually did donate his gold teeth bridge so they could make him a ring. The survivors testified that no one died at his camp.
Yes but let's be fair that this guy and Schindler isn't an apples to apples comparison. Schindler operated a work camp for Nazi Germany and could have worked those people to their death. The other guy issued Visas for another country.
Aaaah, um português de cultura, Aristides de Sousa, o cônsul de Bordéus
This lady has a mind as sharp as a steel trap. No note cards or teleprompter. Just words from her history
I look and listen at this video and then I look at what is going on in the USA at this time. Nobody listens for long and nobody learns. It breaks my heart.
I've heard it said that third of the German people supported Hitler, a third were indifferent and a third opposed him but were afraid to speak out for fear of reprisals. It sounds plausible.
Rena, you are an inspiration to the world. Thank you so much Rena. I can't find the right words to convey what I feel after hearing your testimony.............
🙏Thank you for sharing your story Rena. Wherever you are, may God keep you in eternal love and peace ❤
Thank you for uploading this vdo.
I am a native indian of what's now called america and I may not understand Jewish language or culture but I do understand being seen as less as I also have african descendents in my family and GOD truly bless those of any race that stood up for those that were helpless rip Mr schindler.
Yes....but today is not like then. TODAY people use rascism so that they can sit on their fat asses and eat doritos saying POOR ME...back then jews, indians, black bless their hearts for what they endured and overcame. But i hate people drawing comparisons to today... Today is just a bunch of whiny poor me bitches ( with the exception of 9/11 and what Putin is doing)
You understand it? Did you live through it or did your ancestors?
I cried when i watched schindlers list and i cry like a baby when i watched oskar's documentaries!
This has to keep being taught in schools , every single generation must be educated to the horrors of unspeakable acts of evil committed by the nazis and never , ever let anything like this happen again . Education is vital to stop evil before it begins , God bless all the people who perished , and God bless Oscar schindler , a true and real humanitarian
It is taught in school. And in media. And circulates socially all the time through every generation. It's why every westerner on the planet thinks nazis should be brutally murdered even if they don't know how to read.
Teach about your own crimes and atrocities or about the ones your British friends committed. Or Russia. Or Japan.. More than enough to do then!
7
We will never forget.
That look the woman gave at 0:50
😂😂😂 I think she was very nervous about the camera pointed in her direction.
I had to jump a big wall to visit his grave to pay my respect, as I was deciding to jump the wall due to the gates being locked,
I met an American fellow who looked upset as it was his last day in Israel and he wanted to visit the grave, I told him my plan to
which he was very unsure of, as I climbed over the wall I looked at him and said last chance and I reached out to help him up and over the wall.
Then in a panic we rushed about looking for the grave, then I recalled it was covered in stones, and climbed to a high point and saw it, we rushed towards the location and I grabbed his camera as he paid his respects, so he had the pictures of this moment to share with
his friends and family plus the fact we over come a locked gate by jumping a large wall and could have been shot at any moment.
We parted outside and I know I made his day :)
Pastor neimoller said, when they came for the homosexuals I did not speak put. When they came for the doctors I did not speak out. When they came for the teachers I did not speak out. When they came for the Jews I did not speak out. When they came for me there was no one left to speak out.
I can't understand how anyone can deny the holocaust happened? I'm Scottish and not of any religion, both my parents fought during the WW2 dad in the Royal Navy partaking amongst other duties in the Atlantic Convoys and was at "the taking of Rangoon" against the Japanese who'd invaded Burma. My mum lined up predictors to shoot down German aircraft invading Britain. Neither knew about the holocaust until after the war was over and both were horrified by what they saw on the news reels showing the liberation from the concentration camps. My parent went on to have 4 children, my 3 much older brothers and myself the baby girl by 7 years to the youngest brother. My father thought it important that we grew up knowing about the horrors of war and the concentration camps. I recall being about 7 or 8 and on Sunday's the BBC would show "The World at War" one I remember stood out more than some of the others was the Nuremberg Trials. One of my first trips abroad from Scotland was to Munich, there I found out from other travellers that one could visit Dachau Concentration camp. My camera had a roll of coloured film 35mm and I'd used about 10 pictures on it, but all the pictures I took in Dachau came out overcast and hazy/misty even though it was a beautiful sunny day with no clouds in the sky. I also took photo's outside the camp and when developed as I said the ones inside grey/misty/hazy and outside this place of evil bright clear sunny, the settings hadn't been altered and it was spooky. Going round the exhibition seeing ceiling to floor photo's of women and small children being lead by a nazi soldier towards a mass grave where they were obviously going to be shoot was an awful thing to witness, there were implements of torture on display and at the end an explanation about why the camps are still there- To prevent man's inhumanity to man from ever happening again. I also saw the ovens one could still see the grey clinging to the walls and oven floor from use of these ovens. I also recall not hearing any bird song whilst in this place of evil.
SuperBking1340 You are so deeply entrenched in your beliefs that regardless of which ever facts were presented to you, you'd deny and denounce.
SuperBking1340 Stop being offensive. You are incredibly opinionated. Your mentality is "if they're not with you, they're against you" Don't believe everything you read or that people post online.Respect that my option is different to yours, I accept you don't believe what others have seen.
You just said 'nothing to do with anti-semitism' but then you call Jews 'scum?' Correct me if I'm wrong but you just contradicted yourself completely
SuperBking1340 And u still couldn't give me any sources, embarrassing
International red cross or are they nazis too.
why do you can't it hard to believe that this happened? My father was in Buchenwald and I believe him, he didn't talk about it much.
this makes one question the fall of the Berlin wall, there are hidden meanings for everything, that usually make a lot more sense than the reasons given to the public.
Uh huh. I don't believe a damn thing. I believe what I learned in this video though. ruclips.net/video/hXY__lz16v8/видео.html
when i took a trip to washington dc in 2018, i saw a holocaust survivor in a holocaaust museum giving autographs for her book she had published. the museum was kinda dark, not just for the lack of light but because everywhere you walked into, there was nazi symbols, jewish personal items, recreation of the guetto, names and photographs of people, etc.
That is the point. It's dark in order to remind people how much Hell the Holocaust survivors went through. It's definitely not meant to be a trip to Disney Land.
Liam Neeson good job playing this part
He saved generations
A righteous man, who helped and saved a lot of innocent people, what a scar on the annals of history, a truly righteous man
Not truly righteous man, Schindler was a German spy who arranged the uniforms that caused the possibility for Hitler to declare war, under false pretext to start war.
What she said will give nightmares i had never thought about it, all those professionals all those well mannered people studies doctors poets talented people who lived around them Kept silence, no one helped them, huge part of that germany in those years are all guilty some for pulling the trigger and other for simply not saying anything, but i too just being a human being i feel embarresed of my own kind just humans in general we are a disgrace for this planet..
I’m so confused as to what I’m reading in this comment section! I have scene at least 20 plus comments that are denying the holocaust even happens and denouncing the truths of the survivors!!! This is real life and the fact that people are saying to “get over it” are actually horrible! If u saw your mother,father,kids,friends etc get shot how could you ever forget that? You wouldn’t! It’s ptsd and grief these people are still going threw and they have the COURAGE AND STRENGTH to even speak about it and EDUCATE people on what happened!!! Another thing people are stating that Oskar Schindler wasn’t a real person when he WAS and in every movie that is based off of true events adds some dialogue because it’s a movie! I bet everyone who is belittling and denouncing what these people really experienced are idiots with the same mindset of Nazis and klan members
The people who come on here and say dumb shit like this, I just trying to start stupid crap. They’re nothing but a bunch of control. That is what they do. They are a bunch of bullies. I’m sure they’re great great great grandparents are a bunch of fucking bullies which is why they are bullies too.
Thank you for sharing
Thanks for watching!
If you can afford to do so, please visit a concentration some time in your lifetime. To think that real people were subjected to that treatment is horrifying.
My father in law has many pictures of those horrible camps he was a young man drafted in the clean up over there. When he first showed me the and explained what he saw it broke your heart, how horrible it truly was and that anyone could such horrible things to another one. Yet today we see the same kind of evil being done around the world.
Right now there are the same atrocities happening in the middle east, but no Schindlers to help. I wish I could do something. 😢
So true. It is sad because the Holocaust is to be an example to to never repeat. Yet it goes on, and no one is speaking out who can make a difference. It is heartbreaking to think that now even after over a half century there is the extinction of the people in the middle east as I watch this video and make this comment.
Konan,,,, WE CAN MY FRIEND!!!!! BELIEVE AND HAVE FAITH, AND WITH THISE SPIRITUAL TOOLS PRAY FOR THE WORLD.... WE ARE ON A SPIRAL ROLLERCOASTER MY FRIEND, AND ARMAGEDDON WILL COME.. GOD BLESS WITH MUCH PRAYERS.....
Happening in China too.
When I visited Poland the guide told us not to talk about Oscar Schindler only in postive ways, most Polish people appeared to dispise him, her argument was that schindler probably only saved the jews because he knew the Nazi's were falling. I was really confused, after a year I watched the Schindlers lists and can relate to some parts but for me it matters more that he had maybe a change of heart.
Well he could have easily fled with the amount of money he had if he was a real Nazi his hatred and greed would have not given a dam about the Jews .The polish people suffered probably the worst of all Europe getting batted like a tennis ball between the Germans and the Russians and no one was coming to their aid but they also had a lot of hatred for the Jews so maybe their views of Schindler have been muddied by that fact .
@@carolinecarmichael8732 why did they resent the Jews?
@@Skies133 Antisemitism was rampant throughout Europe by the time Hitler came to power. The Jewish people have long been accused of cultural invasion in whatever nations they occupied. Then, after WWI the victors brutally punished Germany for their active involvement in the war. Their military was disbanded, they weren’t allowed to manufacture war materials, and were burdened with crushing repatriations. Their economy was destroyed, their currency was made almost worthless (a single loaf of bread required a literal wheelbarrow full of paper bills to pay for), and they were angry and resentful. Adolf Hitler, with the help of many supporters, came to power promising to fix everything unilaterally. His friend, Joseph Goebbels, put out a steady stream of well written propaganda extolling the importance of Aryan supremacy, and labeling Jews as the lowest form of trash who were secretly plotting to take over the world. In anger and desperation, and after hearing Joseph Goebbels’ puff pieces, they eventually came to believe it all.
I believe long back 3000 years ago too they got enslaved by Egyptians .. then in WWll by Nazis.. Give Jews a break people.. correct me if I am wrong !
Give Palestinians a break!!!
@@Lazendra they can give break themselves by not attacking Israel. Simple logic
@@Lazendra not even close to the same. You had a country and could share but choose not to peacefully.
@@JustSomeGuyNotAnAlien That's exactly the way you stupid Brits and Americans think. Who do you think you are??!! You disgusting scumbags!Palestinians were driven out of their country and are being terrorised by fascist Jews up to the present day, you stupid ignorant piece of shit.
They were enslaved by the Babylonians as well.
It is true people become monsters in the name of hate.
it's the 'quiet' one's you have to worry about...
I just googled "Schindler's List" the novel by Australian author Thomas Keneally upon which the movie is based. There are many articles stating that the book was based on REAL EVENTS AND PEOPLE. According to the author, it is listed as a fiction novel because he used "fiction techiques" such as character development and invented dialogue to make the story read like a novel, just as "The Right Stuff" by Tom Wolfe is FICTION BASED ON REAL EVENTS of. NASA's Mercury project.
Do not worry about the deniers, they either cannot read or most likely are just trying to spread lies and misinformation. I consider them accessories after the fact in the Nazi crimes of torture and genocide, because they are anti-semitic, or express approval for the crimes while denying them, or they try to make excuses by citing the 60 millions killed under Stalin. They are not worth wasting precious time to argue with them, they will not see reason and do not care about the truth.
yea yea yea...more BS from a believer..Go watch "Europa the last battle part 6" then comeback after u seen the real truth
@@WillyEckaslike Fuckin Nazi
@@TheArkman360 truth is hate to those who hate the truth
@@WillyEckaslike couldn't find it on youtube. However, if it's a video denying the holocaust it has to contend with a consensus from historians, living witnesses, both jew and nazis and liberations of the camps. The actions to save jews from the camps taken during, by the end and after the war by people from other countries, neutral or otherwise.
To ignore it is ignorance. I don't know your life so I can't know how you ended up down that path but I do hope you start re-mapping your brain. Anyone can create a conspiracy theory that sounds convincing (it's easy when you don't have to take facts into account), however, that doesn't make them true. It's different to be critical of your sources of information than it is to simply listen to someone saying what you want to believe is real.
Again, I don't know your story, or why you feel the need to belive the holocaust did not happen, or who planted that seed in you from the beginning, but here I am wishing you start taking back controll of your life and well being.
Why?
Beacuse we're in this togehter. You, me and everybody else.
@@Ramdapanda u might want to start your deprogramming with this link
papermacheworld.wordpress.com/
Oskar, a living angel. Love and friendship from the Philippines.
The nazies were open about their antisemitism and thus were envied by the politically correct antisemities. Nazism is not the only expression of antisemitism.
I do not agree with the statement that no one cared about the Jews in those terrible times. Lots of Poles risked the lives and lives of their relatives for helping and sometimes hiding entire Jewish families. I am not making excuses to anyone, but saying that nothing was done and nobody cared is not entirely true and fair.
And some nazi (not a lot obviously, just a few) did change their mind and apologized and other defected when they had the chance. I say it just because it makes me less desperate to think there is always a little spark of hope even in the darkest times
Well not enought did... think about that... more kept silence than the ones who did something... the sentiment that you see on the last scene of the movie where he says, I could of saved one more just one or 2 maybe i could have will always be in the minds of those who helped but more in the ones who looked away, very few stories of soldiers standing up to the ss you dont hear them often or never, they were animals.
While it is true that some cared for the Jews during the genocide, we cannot say that it is unfair for her, a survivor of the Holocaust, to say that no one cared for them at the time. At that moment, it actually seemed that no one did care to help them and save them as they were surrounded with atrocities; it was what she felt at that moment until Oskar Schindler came in the picture. Looking back, there were a few who tried to help these Jews but before they were saved, everything and everyone around them was against them.
I think part of it was that Poland was under a Nazi militairy occupation. I imagine most Poles feared they would be killed if they spoke out.
Its so easy 4 us 2 judge in retrospect and from a comfortable armchair, but let's try 2 imagine ourselves in such circumstances. What would we do? How would we behave?
0:08 can anyone me where i can find the picture online, Thats diffenetly a rare pic because its the picture were Schindler had a party with the ss
I'm not comparing the current political climate to WW2 but I think it is very important to hear these words. It's easy to find yourself somewhat jaded and apathetic. The disconnect between the atrocities of the holocaust and our daily lives and routines is vast. Dismissal and a brief couple of chapters taught in school are not enough. America does things now that would astound the majority of the population if they took the time to look into the various conflicts we insert ourselves into. Willful ignorance, behind a comforting curtain. Once again I'm not comparing these 2 time periods to each other. I just find it disturbing how comfortable people are with just assuming that the government has the best interests of the people in mind. The majority of the German people as a whole didn't know the full extent of what was happening (although many had an idea) and they had that same confidence in the nazi hierarchy. The evidence is always there, and failing to put it together is a bullshit excuse for ignoring the victims suffering. Complicity, guilt by association, by omission. It's easy to ignore the unpleasant things and put them in the back of your mind. Moral cowardice and unwillingness to keep the leadership in check always leads to a horrible conclusion. The most horrible things are sometimes done with the best of intentions.
Now 2020, i hope we the young keep proetesting, teach eachother of warning signs and vote if we could. despite in my average public school we studied the ww2 holocaust extensively from middle school and highschool (learning the culture, politics, mindsets and the leading topics of the war and the people and connect it to modern spotting of fake news,ect). we even read the stories of survivors (Anne frank's diary and the night by elie wiesel) and our library makes sure to put ww2/holocaust topic in front page pick when we enter (my favorite pick yet tragic graphic novel is Maus by art spiegelman) then visited in our school fieldtrip of the washington D.C Holocaust museum (i even seen relating topics like khmer rouge/cambodia massacres and middle east warcrimes, then got my card of a holocaust survivor identity & her life description). then our school gave us knowledge despite having an underfunded/terrible reputation but diverse & friendly with great quality teachers despite us aloof studenst we got these topics seriously by watching documentaries and immersing ourselves to it even talking on modern topics of BLM and Persepolis,immigration and hope it continues to teach such issues and its lessons
The man is a legend !!! as a hair stylist and colorist !!!
Can I say this is the most powerful speech I have seen on the internet?
If there is a more profound speech please let me know in comments.
No one cared. That is the key to everything. Empathy or apathy.
Oscar the hero
that movie makes me cry
Thomas Ponzio that simply means you’re a human being
Love from Kerala, India 🇮🇳❤ Shalom. Love from the most pro-Israeli country in the world 🇮🇳 🇮🇱
Nie vergessen.
God’s richest blessings on the Nation of Israel.
bless you dear lady.
Thank you for posting this. When was this video made?
Tomorrow
Description says ‘94 so I think that’s when the interview is
What happened to all the kids they took away, 😢😢😢😢
If you weren't 14 or older than children younger than that were either sent to the merciless 'doctors' or the flames. The "doctors" were unit 731 and the Sadistic inhuman demon Josef mengle. I myself am not a Holocaust survivor but my grandpa had to grow up during those times and I am grateful that I am alive.
Many sent to die if they were sick. Other to do house work finally.to concentration camps, all those twins and plenty of others to do experiments on them if they died during yhe experiment they would dispossed of them and bring a new one, after all they had alot of children... it makes me sick just to think about that.. doctors people that studied scientist and more opening up children to do their reaserch.
@@LegoAventuras1718 😭😭😭😭
@@LegoAventuras1718 That is why many of those doctors were hunted down and out in trial or probably killed.
SOME HUMAN CHOOSE TO REMAIN HUMANS!
Movies like this prove the world knew.
naah doesbt prove anything, the scientific believe and research showed that for certain information of jewish extermenation was obtained by allis only in 1944 and when asked if they should
bomb aushwitz the main concern that churchill expressed was that most likely all of the prisoners will die , and if they dont bomb but eliberate it( which was clear by then , because everyone knew germany is losing) some of the prisoners have a chance to survive. As harsh as this may sound he wasnt actually wrong on that, and the survival of somebody like primo levi wouldnt be possible . The thing is even if aushwitz would be bombed there would prolly still be mass killings regardless, but i do think it was a mistakr
7
It's 5,1 million. Also Raul Hillberg.
Such a horrible event... And yet, something exetremely similar took place in Yugoslavia in the 90's.
Bosnia, right?
Whole life I haven't saved an ant ... You are holy Mr Schindler ...
Holy shit these comments...
go to any reliable source...look up Jewish population in Europe 1940 to 1950...make your own conclusion
Speer remarked that Hitler had Steel Blue eyes.
So much resemblance with today's America. He who does not learn from the mistakes of the past is destined to repeat it. This is not about politics, this is about human lives.
Uuhm…? What?
Yes because vaccines and death camps are the same thing.🙄 Go away Hitler lover.
@Henry Avila Are you serious? You are comparing Nazi Germany where 6 million innocent people were systemically murdered with contemporary United States? Last I checked, we don't have concentration camps murdering 6 million people. Last I checked, EVERYONE in the United States has rights that are afforded to them by the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.
So, please explain your comparison.
Difference; you can pack up and leave Henry, no one will even ask to see your papers(maybe your vaccination doc.)
I am Indian and reside in Austria. Some time I ask my self, why I live with them?
mozart4128 it’s ok not everyone is bad
I live in Austria too....dont 'them' ppl.
IF YOU LIKE WHAT YOU SEE ON "VIDEOCOLLECTABLES," HELP THE CREATOR LAUNCH HIS COMPANION CHANNEL - "VIDEO SCRAPBOOK" ( www.youtube.com/@VideoScrapbookOfOurTimes/ ). THIS IS A CALL TO ACTION. WE NEED 30 SUBSCRIBERS TO BE VIABLE. YOU CAN MAKE THIS MILESTONE A REALITY, WHICH WILL ENCOURAGE MORE UPLOADS. A CLICK COSTS YOU NOTHING BUT A MOMENT OF YOUR TIME. THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT.
It's always the most tragic events that have the conspiracy theorists and deniers.
But its always the most weak minded ppl living in their basements.
And unfortunately they will never change their mind. So just ignore them.
'The list is life. All around its borders lies the gulf.'
I also think people use it as a coping mechanism because they can't fathom what humans can do to one another and have done
Our history books have been wholly inaccurate. (GOOGLE- IMPORTANT QUOTATIONS FOR A BETTER UNDERSTANDING OF WW II.) The truth is in the real written words of prominent men of the 20s through 40s. "We butchered the wrong pig". Winston Churchill. "We defeated the wrong enemy". Gen George S Patton. Do the rest of the research yourself.
God bless of those people protect the innocent and reward them a freedom of everlasting life, and good paradise for them to God almighty one and holy immortal one.
@20 seconds the video says "Remarkable True Story" Spielburg made this Movie from the Book which says it is FICTION
They had to prey on a generation and two out. They couldn't prey on the WW2 generation directly. This is for a reason. And she even states this.
Как не стыдно
Evghenii Cernopoli cho ne stidno?
This horrible murderous era can never be repeated. Never forget
It already repeated in former Yugoslavia and is repeating itself currently in North Korea and in Burma against the Rohingya.
Then it was bark eyes and dark hair now it's dark skin
❤🥰❤
💕💕💕
I thought 1600,it was 1,100.Its ok atleast
Ok?!? Think of this. One person saved is incredible. 10 people is beautiful. He saved over a thousand. One thousand people who were able to blink, love, marry, and live. Ok is atp disrespectful. He is an incredible man.
@@channieszoo4342 seriously what this man did is insanly heroic. The amount of lives that lived, let alone were created because of this man is astounding. A true hero in such a dark fucking time
think about about it this way … you are 1 human being so unique, magnificent, loving, with your own personality and relationships and way of thinking
Now multiply that to x1100 … it’s not little amount of people, this man saved generations of jews
also he had to pay for each and every single jew … this man threw away his entire fortune … to todays equivalent of 10’s of millions of dollars
it’s no chump change and at a time like that … this man was an angel … he sacrificed everything
How many people would choose to throw away a comfortable life of luxury ...to live in poverty??? NOT YOU. this man did it to give 1200 people the chance to continue their stories and to have kids and their kids had kids. He was the ultimate hero
Why do old women always wear those square earrings?
Because that makes them feel like themselves
"Let me tell you about the Holocaust. It was terrible!!!! When I'm done, follow me to the pro-abortion rally."
---- Stephen Spielberg
Who is Stephen Spielberg? 🧐
if your last name is schindler u are set for life
Read about the Talmud and what it says about non Jews. Look up the Transfer Agreement. We've been lied to. Even Jesus called them the synagogue of satan. Do you research.
I did my research, and here's what I found. Jesus did not call Jews "the synagogue of satan."
You seem to be talking about Revelation 2:9 :
“‘I know your tribulation and your poverty (but you are rich) and the slander[a] of those who say that they are Jews and are not, but are a synagogue of Satan.
As it turns out, this is actually a criticism of the church at Smyrna, where some people claimed to be "Jews" but only outwardly and not inwardly. Basically, he was saying that some of the people there were only going through the motions of being Jews/faithful/worshipping God, and so those people were not truly "Jews" or believers in God.
This was not a condemnation of Jews on the whole, or as separate from Christianity, only some specific people at Smyrna who didn't have God in their hearts.
Here are three separate interpretations of Revelation 2:9 that explain that Jesus is not equating Jews as a religion/race with evil.
1. www.biblestudytools.com/commentaries/revelation/revelation-2/revelation-2-9.html
2. www.biblestudytools.com/commentaries/gills-exposition-of-the-bible/revelation-2-9.html
3. bradkelly.wordpress.com/2009/06/10/who-is-a-true-jew-revelation-29-39/
From the third source in my previous comment (bradkelly.wordpress.com/2009/06/10/who-is-a-true-jew-revelation-29-39/)
If you heard someone say, “he says he is a professional baseball player, but he is not,” what could you safely assume? I believe you could safely assume two things: 1. There really is such a thing as a professional baseball player: such a person actually exists. 2. The person making the claim is not truly a professional baseball player.
So returning to the text we can safely assume two things: 1. There really is such a group as Jews: true Jews. 2. Those making the claim to be Jewish are not truly Jews.
who is your lord Satan!!!!!!
Jesus was jew
Just before Germany invaded Poland there were around 800000 German refugees who had lived in and around the boarder of Poland and Germany. These civilians fled their homes because of increasing Polish violence against them. I can see why Rena would have had "problems with the [German] bystanders" after her countrymen had treated so many innocent Germans as "sub human".
idiot who invade who?
Can you give other sources than Goebbels propaganda films?
About 40,000 Jews living in Poland and about 50,000 got evacuated in the first days
Yep.... been waiting for someone to point that out.
Mark Feka Fifteen obviously. Turn on captions if you need this kind of help.
How can she talk about all this with any sort of certitude. She must have been about 5 yrs old when anything she speaks of took place.
she's been trained to tow the line for the chosen ones.
the accompanying movie clips are fitting to the hollywood storytelling by the speaker.
Having the Jews taken a lifetime lesson from the Holocaust to coexist and live in a peaceful environment with others. Unfortunately, you don't. Instead, you oppressed other people need to live and have a good life. Stop your aggression and inhumane act like the evil Nazi have done onto you. Be grateful. Be kind. Be helpful to others. I know you can't do it.
Are you saying all Jews are the same? you're generalizing the entire population and that's just like if some one were to say "All Muslims are terrorist", or "Or blacks are robbers" or "All whites are Plantation owners". To believe those things is true evil and you know it.
Cryptonazisayswhat
@@SAFbikes I mean honestly people today can go on circle jerks about Israeli crimes against Palestinians but then turn right around and call you a nazi if you bring it up to make a point.
7
perhaps trump should watch this
WTF does Trump have to do with this?! I'm so f'n sick of that. He won. You lost. Get over it!!!!!
@@mitzimitzi2608 pffft.
Trumps a big fan of Jews and moved the embassy to Israel so why don’t you just stop
Huh?
Wow the pitch of her voice is really annoying.
🗿🗿the stupidity of this comment is more annoying
Spielberg: "... being a Jew was a death sentence." Hand goes to chin, distracting you, hiding from the lie that just came out of his mouth.
Spielberg: "... being a Jew was a death sentence." Hand goes to chin, hiding nothing because you can't cover lies with your hands, only showing great sadness at the thought of his own mortality and those who died.
Omg she's so selfish. She should have helped make the movie as an extra. What does she know??? Boring
Not so cool Kyle
Selfish because she didn't play in a movie about something she already had to live through once? Unfortunately what I think she knows is real suffering.
She can say anything she wants after the atrocities she endured.
What a disrespectful person you are Kyle. And shame to you that gave a thumb up to him. Not cool
You’re so gross. You should be ashamed
Why did she call that horrible time the blackness? It’s always black is bad while white is good but that isn’t fair.
Darkness dude. Not skin color.
probably due to a language barrier, she corrects herself with stating the darkness
cant blame her in this scenario imo
That was a dark time, my friend.
are u fucking serious…
7