The scene is beautiful from both actresses. Honestly, it's great. The attitude of the interrogator is wonderful for this scene: "You dont know me. I know every single thing about you, and everything you know. I know everyone you know. And if you don't wanna know me, which, you don't; i suggest you speak."
All she did was galvanize the terrorist (according to this scene.) she accomplished nothing and likely hosed any chance of a legitimate conviction due to the failure to respect her Miranda rights. Complete failure of an interrogation. Though understandable given the interrogator was very emotional from all the murders taking place.
@@chad2522 Why do you think giving the government unlimited power through the suppression of basic human rights is a good idea? Are you really that naive to think it will never affect you or that they are never gonna exploit that power beyond terrorists?
When she said "he didn't even kiss you..." the wife snaps out of it, is reminded that he did indeed kiss her and why she loves her husband, and gives her speech.
The wife should’ve been arrested for complicity. They made the bombs right in front of her in the house with her daughter. Seriously do you think anyone would believe she didn’t know if she were put on trial? Also, her daughter should’ve been taken away from her. She is clearly an unfit mother. She should be in prison right now 10 years later.
At first that interrogator is trying to earn her trust in the women when that failed fresh tactics she scared the shit out of me with her change in voice and and facial expressions then shows picture of her former husband’s corpse that is cold but necessary.
It will be interesting to know if the bombers wife actually was aware or in on the attacks. The film makes it clear at the end that there is no absolute confirmation if she was or not.
It pisses me off knowing the wife still lives her life as she did before this. She definitely had some kind of involvement in the attacks, probably helped plan it or bought the stuff. She’s not ignorant of what her husband was doing. And she’s living with a new husband and her kids pretending she can erase the past
@@joewhitehead3 If ... as is likely .. she knew her husband was planning an attack that would kill numerous people, then she was not just "standing idly by"
@@joewhitehead3 It is extremely unlikely that she would have been married to him and living with him and yet did not know that he was building a bomb or planning something extreme like he clearly was.
For those of you that don’t know this is a type of interrogation that cannot be used in the court of law, they can interrogate them however they want, but when she goes to trial, they can’t use that as evidence
This isn’t an interrogation… she hasn’t been accused nor has the verbiage indicated she is a suspect. Miranda is not required. This is just fact finding for the sake of national interest and to protect the interest of citizens.
These movies really give you a sense of how "safe" America is. In most parts of the world, wars, bombs, explosions, terrorisms, it's all daily normal life. Allot of times it's caused by soldiers from out nation. But 1 bomb goes off in America and it becomes a Holiday. People always talk about the guns in America, but when you think about it, most Americans alive today, are probably going to live very very safe lives.
Katherine maintains innocence…not sure if she was in on it..but she had to of heard…or been told…something.. the brothers got ready at her residence… she’s a coward as much as her husband & brother in law…😠
My favorite part is at the end the CIA agent takes off the head scarf. EVERYTHING she did could have been a lie. She doesn’t wear the scarf because she actually doesn’t believe it. He story about being born in a tent could have been completely made up.
Could be. Cops do tend to lie during interrogations in order to get answers. Although, she did know the prophet. Those words she spoke when she first started talking to her
As much as I love this movie and dislike how Homeland Security abuses their powers. I have never understood how you can say " I am an American Citizen with Constitutional Rights" while at the same time trying to take down the government. It makes as much sense as the idiots who want secession from the government but still want their Social Security Checks
I cannot image how the daughter must feel, knowing her father was a terrorist and her mother supported it, how could survive her home, school, relationships, it can't be easy.
She was actually a cia interrogator part of the cia interrogation squad, they use black site and brutal tactics against any known traffickers or terrorists, one of the best and the scariest
the suspect is a suspect , if you try and charge someone with no proof enough that she did it your case will get thrown down the window , there are laws for a reason. explosive residue in her apartment means nothing when her husband killed himself , you cant proove she cooperated or knows of more bombs if she doesnt admit it.
Freedom of speech right is just too strong in the US. Very hard to charge people with sedition unless the said speech really resulted in the suspect and/or others engaging in subversion, terrorism or other criminal acts then that's more probable cause to charge.
"They" are real. The FBI and CIA do employ these types for these exact types of interrogations. Probably not a black woman named Veronica pretending to be a muslim born in a tent... But maybe a slight black woman named Vicky pretending to be a muslim born in a mud hut... Yea they exist. Im also pretty sure the FBI and CIA employ authentic patriots who are muslim, or women, or gays, or whoever and they use their true identity to manipulate suspects and prisoners. Thats also probably pretty true.
She’s not a detective. Pretty sure she is CIA. Since this movie is known for being pretty accurate, I would probably say that this scene is somewhat true…
Likely clandestine FBI unit that works hand in hand with the FBI’s Behavioural Analysis Unit or another government agency that deals in intelligence, national security and terrorism.
@@u.s.m.c.fewproudthemarines2987 possibly the FBI. They were in the United States (not overseas where the CIA was more likely to operate), and the 1984 Quarles case allows them to skip reading Miranda in public safety exigency cases. It's possible they were implying she was with the CIA, but more likely was in a special FBI counterterrorist unit that responded to high risk cases like that.
@@u.s.m.c.fewproudthemarines2987why? Freedom of religion. It wasn’t the Muslims who came to this country and slaughtered millions. Then slaved millions
I think her husband fed her some bullshit about America that made her decide that killing them off was a good thing. Her husband was very anti American and voiced his beliefs frequently
lol lawyer? It’s one thing if you’re the Enemy from an opposing country and you kill people in warzone but it’s a whole other type of thing when you commit terrorism especially against your own citizens
It coulda been a simple yes, no or I don’t know answer, but instead, she was more willing to protect her dead husband, who hurt & murdered innocent people including a child, than the lives of more innocent people & her own child? & she really thought he woulda been allowed in heaven? On a more positive note, this was definitely a hell of departure for Melissa Benoist. From Supergirl to a terrorist’s Muslim wife
She’s wasn’t being “accused” or even being “suspect,” therefore it’s an interview not an interrogation and Miranda does not apply. For the sake of this scene, it was information gathering for the sake of public safety and national security.
I think and this is an educated guess. Since it is classified as terrorism, it falls under the Patriot Act, which does allow some parts of the due process to be skipped. Particularly if the interview is being done by the CIA
@@richardmurillo5928 She didn’t commit any crimes and they are violating her constitutional rights. She’s an American citizen and the movie is romanticizing her detainment
That woman ain't got sh*t and she knew about what her husband and her brother in law were about to do and now her daughter will grow up knowing her father was a monster
@@richardmurillo5928 So her constitutional rights as an American citizen should be violated based off the crimes other people did? They had no evidence she knew what was going to happen. Can’t pick and choose when you want to follow the law.
the idea I think was she wasnt actually muslim, just a cia interrogator. the cia has done this before with a bin laden colleague, where they studied the Quran/had someone who understood the Quran interrogate the suspect.
Betray their religion? Terrorist don't have a religion. It's just an excuse to try and stroke power onto people. I met people who follow Islam. Great people. Terrorist are trying to take Islam and force it into something that's not even close to it. Like how evangelicals try and chance Christianity into something they would agree with.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
The scene is beautiful from both actresses. Honestly, it's great.
The attitude of the interrogator is wonderful for this scene:
"You dont know me. I know every single thing about you, and everything you know. I know everyone you know. And if you don't wanna know me, which, you don't; i suggest you speak."
Melissa Benoist & Khandi Alexander.
Better known as Marley Rose & Supergirl & Alex Woods from CSI: Miami
That change of her tone of voice is chilling!
Same
All she did was galvanize the terrorist (according to this scene.) she accomplished nothing and likely hosed any chance of a legitimate conviction due to the failure to respect her Miranda rights. Complete failure of an interrogation. Though understandable given the interrogator was very emotional from all the murders taking place.
Public safety exemption and post 9/11 laws means they can be questioned without regard to constitutional rights.
Obama, didn’t mind using it.
When she turned that way she lost her rigths ishahalla broda
so in real life, what will her daughter do when she finds out her father wasa. terrosits
@@kevin88338 lmao okay and?
She can sue after the fact for civil rights violations but for the meantime finding if there are more bombs is more important
'You ain't got shit, sweetheart'
Loved that quote.
She does, indeed have rights though.
@@theslowevo9303 not really
@@teakytube7179 Yes, really. Everyone has rights in the USA.
@@theslowevo9303 not in hat case
“He’s no martyr he’s a fn coward” every single one of them
Funny half the world sees them as freedom fighters
I’m Muslim and 100% agree with u
@@kingdon5240 😲😲 Respect friend ✌️✌️✌️✌️ 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Both of them*
That’s what they all! They aren’t anything but people who used excuse after excuse to hurt innocent people
“You ain’t got shit, sweetheart”
Fucking love it
You love Fascism?
Yet it backfired and she didn’t tell them a thing
@@FeiLi-i9z islam is cancer
@@FeiLi-i9z Why should terrorists have rights?
@@chad2522 Why do you think giving the government unlimited power through the suppression of basic human rights is a good idea? Are you really that naive to think it will never affect you or that they are never gonna exploit that power beyond terrorists?
How this woman was not charged as an accomplice is beyond me.
I agree. I believe they charged other accomplices.
Isn't she is Guantanamo for life? Charges don't matter no more.
She still lives in the US today
Pretty sure they even gave her a new identity and US citizenship.. it’s bs
@@nickz5849probably living better then ever
Holy shit, I’ve never seen this movie but damn Veronica is a BOSS
She’s basically a half CIA half FBI interrogator. They’re called High Value Detainee Interrogation Group.
She got schooled in this scene the second she showed “wife “ husbands dead body . The tide turned right there
@@bigsmilereviews100and you never mess with them, they’re willing to do a lot of things the law can’t do
“Patriot’s Day”. It’s worth a look.
Was on Netflix for a very fat minute , one of the best movies Ive watched in my lifetime so far
When she said "he didn't even kiss you..." the wife snaps out of it, is reminded that he did indeed kiss her and why she loves her husband, and gives her speech.
He didn’t kiss her, she kissed him. He would’ve left without kissing her.
The wife should’ve been arrested for complicity. They made the bombs right in front of her in the house with her daughter. Seriously do you think anyone would believe she didn’t know if she were put on trial? Also, her daughter should’ve been taken away from her. She is clearly an unfit mother. She should be in prison right now 10 years later.
I don’t think it was that simple. They woulda had to prove her complicity
Did someone say it was simple? She’s guilty as hell!
@@tominmtnvw Why the fuck did that stupid Trever Martin AKA Tmartn2 kill Alex Mason for no reason at all?!
She had no miranda. If the US government really wanted to they could have found a chair or chamber within hours
Khandi Alexander. I loved her in ER and CSI Miami. Terrific actress.
What a scene! So powerful. So focused!
At first that interrogator is trying to earn her trust in the women when that failed fresh tactics she scared the shit out of me with her change in voice and and facial expressions then shows picture of her former husband’s corpse that is cold but necessary.
It will be interesting to know if the bombers wife actually was aware or in on the attacks. The film makes it clear at the end that there is no absolute confirmation if she was or not.
Of course she knew...it's how they work.
Well of course she knew and was in on it😂
@@MrHammerman97 what department of the FBI do you work in?
@@TriggerG59 what department of the FBI do you work in?
@@FeiLi-i9z they lived in the same place. The chances that she knew is pretty high.
It pisses me off knowing the wife still lives her life as she did before this. She definitely had some kind of involvement in the attacks, probably helped plan it or bought the stuff.
She’s not ignorant of what her husband was doing. And she’s living with a new husband and her kids pretending she can erase the past
I’m pretty sure her only involvement was standing idly by while the brothers were planning it
@@joewhitehead3 If ... as is likely .. she knew her husband was planning an attack that would kill numerous people, then she was not just "standing idly by"
@@michaelthomas2916 What do you think she did do exactly?
@@joewhitehead3 It is extremely unlikely that she would have been married to him and living with him and yet did not know that he was building a bomb or planning something extreme like he clearly was.
@@michaelthomas2916 That’s pretty much what I said before. Stood by & did nothing
That cop knows how to annoy. That voice will drive anyone nuts.
Melissa benoist did absolutely amazing
they lady that plays Veronica deserves a goddamn Oscar
It took me awhile, but it's the lady from NewsRadio!
Khandi Alexander, better known as Alex Woods, M.E. from CSI: Miami.
Melissa Benoist was chillingly brilliant as the wife.
I know. It's hard to see her as an antagonist, because I'm so used to seeing her play good-natured protagonists like Marley Rose & Supergirl.
WTF is going on with john goodmans eyebrows 🤣🤣
Allah gave him the bushy black brows, so he could frown like the Prophet. As it says in the Abasa 1-11 🥸
Khandi Alexander absolutely crushed this role
Like in Butch and Sundance, “Who are those guys?”
For those of you that don’t know this is a type of interrogation that cannot be used in the court of law, they can interrogate them however they want, but when she goes to trial, they can’t use that as evidence
It’s sorta scary how our government has to do this to get info, they should already have it. 😅
Yes it seems the objective here was information to prevent future attacks. not conviction.
This isn’t an interrogation… she hasn’t been accused nor has the verbiage indicated she is a suspect. Miranda is not required. This is just fact finding for the sake of national interest and to protect the interest of citizens.
That CIA lady means business
They’re FBI.
No the lady in the interrogation room was CIA. The FBI phoned them in for a favour
CIA
@@theblueboxtardis it's been a while since I seen the movie
@@MAnuscript421 I mean even the FBI agents didn't know who they were 😂😂😂
Its too bad, she would enjoy the weather in GITMO at that time of the year.
These movies really give you a sense of how "safe" America is. In most parts of the world, wars, bombs, explosions, terrorisms, it's all daily normal life. Allot of times it's caused by soldiers from out nation. But 1 bomb goes off in America and it becomes a Holiday.
People always talk about the guns in America, but when you think about it, most Americans alive today, are probably going to live very very safe lives.
Katherine maintains innocence…not sure if she was in on it..but she had to of heard…or been told…something.. the brothers got ready at her residence… she’s a coward as much as her husband & brother in law…😠
She was in on it. It was impossible for her not to be. Makes me sick she’s not in jail or deported to a Muslim country
Having Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross do the score for this movie was a genius move on top of the brilliant acting.
Only Khandi Alexander can take down Supergirl! ❤
My favorite part is at the end the CIA agent takes off the head scarf. EVERYTHING she did could have been a lie. She doesn’t wear the scarf because she actually doesn’t believe it. He story about being born in a tent could have been completely made up.
Could be. Cops do tend to lie during interrogations in order to get answers. Although, she did know the prophet. Those words she spoke when she first started talking to her
Members of the High Value Detainee Interrogation Group are experts at psychology, religion, culture, & profiling....
great performance. stole the scene!
That's supergirl...she should have just busted out of there
Oliva should have told her DON'T MESS WITH MOMA POPE.
That last part with khandi Aleixer was a cool image
The interrogator is creepy.
Black site interrogations are no joke
As much as I love this movie and dislike how Homeland Security abuses their powers. I have never understood how you can say " I am an American Citizen with Constitutional Rights" while at the same time trying to take down the government. It makes as much sense as the idiots who want secession from the government but still want their Social Security Checks
While wearing a hijab. 😂
I cannot image how the daughter must feel, knowing her father was a terrorist and her mother supported it, how could survive her home, school, relationships, it can't be easy.
What amazes me she was willing to lose her daughter just to defend her deceased husband of his crimes....thats just loss of words
I think she knew that they had nothing on her. At least not enough for her to lose custody of her child
@@joewhitehead3 they had the power to make her disappear right there
Shame they didn't use it on it. She still lives till this day smh
@@boundlessblade5205 Well she does live quietly
@@joewhitehead3 yeah not sure if she remarried or what. But it sucks she didn't get punishment for that day
@@boundlessblade5205 Couldn’t prove that she knew anything
Wow . that was an amazing scene by the female FBI interrogator
I think she was CIA.
She was actually a cia interrogator part of the cia interrogation squad, they use black site and brutal tactics against any known traffickers or terrorists, one of the best and the scariest
The suspect should be charged with sedition.
the suspect is a suspect , if you try and charge someone with no proof enough that she did it your case will get thrown down the window , there are laws for a reason.
explosive residue in her apartment means nothing when her husband killed himself , you cant proove she cooperated or knows of more bombs if she doesnt admit it.
Freedom of speech right is just too strong in the US. Very hard to charge people with sedition unless the said speech really resulted in the suspect and/or others engaging in subversion, terrorism or other criminal acts then that's more probable cause to charge.
It’s not sedition, it’s terrorism. They are very different
There are no laws , just the people who turn their heads
Wow so the wife broke up with the fanatical drummer from Studio Band and ended up with this guy, crazy
Anyone know if this woman who is the detective was real??
"They" are real. The FBI and CIA do employ these types for these exact types of interrogations.
Probably not a black woman named Veronica pretending to be a muslim born in a tent...
But maybe a slight black woman named Vicky pretending to be a muslim born in a mud hut...
Yea they exist. Im also pretty sure the FBI and CIA employ authentic patriots who are muslim, or women, or gays, or whoever and they use their true identity to manipulate suspects and prisoners. Thats also probably pretty true.
She’s not a detective. Pretty sure she is CIA. Since this movie is known for being pretty accurate, I would probably say that this scene is somewhat true…
They most certainly exist
High-Value Detainee Interrogation Group
Religion of peace moment
No religion or faith is peaceful. They're all cults. Don't think for a second that you're an exception to the rule.
What agency was she from
Likely clandestine FBI unit that works hand in hand with the FBI’s Behavioural Analysis Unit or another government agency that deals in intelligence, national security and terrorism.
CIA
@@u.s.m.c.fewproudthemarines2987 possibly the FBI. They were in the United States (not overseas where the CIA was more likely to operate), and the 1984 Quarles case allows them to skip reading Miranda in public safety exigency cases. It's possible they were implying she was with the CIA, but more likely was in a special FBI counterterrorist unit that responded to high risk cases like that.
@@michaelthomas2916 Makes sense. I always thought she was from Homeland Security.
They are out of their minds, huh? TF
Bat shit crazy
I forgot Supergirl was in this!
what is she doing in 2024? She needs to be watched
It's a zero% chance her or daughter won't do something in the future
this group was CIA
She's married again and living in New Jersey !
Is she still a muslim
Thank you for the update, I was wondering what happened to her
Is she still practicing her Faith
@@u.s.m.c.fewproudthemarines2987 Of course she is !!! Very difficult to convert a Muslim to the truth of the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ !
@@u.s.m.c.fewproudthemarines2987why? Freedom of religion. It wasn’t the Muslims who came to this country and slaughtered millions. Then slaved millions
I can tell you how a mother would do that to her children, Religion.
Religion has nothing to do with it
I think her husband fed her some bullshit about America that made her decide that killing them off was a good thing. Her husband was very anti American and voiced his beliefs frequently
@@FireWolf583& that’s how he justified damaging & murdering innocent people, including an 8 year old, who had nothing to with any of that?
Islam you mean
Melissa?
I KNOW RIGHT.
lol lawyer? It’s one thing if you’re the Enemy from an opposing country and you kill people in warzone but it’s a whole other type of thing when you commit terrorism especially against your own citizens
By the way, Watch ' ICHI THE KILLER ' there's a way to make her talk
What happened was they could not prosecute her or lose her child.
It coulda been a simple yes, no or I don’t know answer, but instead, she was more willing to protect her dead husband, who hurt & murdered innocent people including a child, than the lives of more innocent people & her own child? & she really thought he woulda been allowed in heaven?
On a more positive note, this was definitely a hell of departure for Melissa Benoist. From Supergirl to a terrorist’s Muslim wife
Patriot act violates the 4th so she had a point when she said she had rights
She’s wasn’t being “accused” or even being “suspect,” therefore it’s an interview not an interrogation and Miranda does not apply. For the sake of this scene, it was information gathering for the sake of public safety and national security.
No comment .I can give one everyday. My comment is sad
I feel bad for the actress who played the wife....
Melissa Benoist?
Except Russia warned the US about this guy months before.
So, no, no real excuse for dropping the ball.
Amazing that even under Obama I felt safer in this country. Compare that to July 4, 2024
This scene is a really good example of how the US was willing to toss aside due process in persuit of vengance. Rather disturbing honestly
I think and this is an educated guess. Since it is classified as terrorism, it falls under the Patriot Act, which does allow some parts of the due process to be skipped. Particularly if the interview is being done by the CIA
@@gamerswag2752 when they CIA launch Operation Northwoods 2.0 they will use the Patriot Act to take all our rights
@@gamerswag2752 Yes what you said. The Patriot Act is the ultimate example of tossing aside due process and liberties, due to blind fear
Your a clown.
@@travelsofmunch1476well the movie’s events show that is wasn’t all blind
☪️ancer
Wife should be with her husband right now
No lawyer? Why respect a country that doesn't even respect its own laws?
You don’t get a lawyer under this scenario
@@csdude35 Siht, really? When did they repeal the Sixth Amendment?
@@murrethmediait’s called the Patriot Act
@@ChickenJoe12 The Constitution is the supreme law of the land, no law supersedes it.
@@murrethmedia tell that to all the unconstitutional gun laws, ATF regulations, and the illegal mass surveillance exposed by Snowden..
Allah habibi '72
Imagine....biden let thousands of these in to our country
if the united states didnt obliterate their countries and homes im sure they would´ve never had a reason to do terrorist acts you know?
and trump millions.
@MeerkatADV you must be super woke
Biden and Democrats in general really don't know how to handle immigration.
Bush let them watch twin towers 9/11 in a hotel in NYC
This is a really stupid scene from a otherwise good movie
How is it stupid?😤😡
@@richardmurillo5928 She didn’t commit any crimes and they are violating her constitutional rights. She’s an American citizen and the movie is romanticizing her detainment
That woman ain't got sh*t and she knew about what her husband and her brother in law were about to do and now her daughter will grow up knowing her father was a monster
@@richardmurillo5928 So her constitutional rights as an American citizen should be violated based off the crimes other people did? They had no evidence she knew what was going to happen. Can’t pick and choose when you want to follow the law.
What kind of animal would betray their religion to work for the Imperialists?
the idea I think was she wasnt actually muslim, just a cia interrogator.
the cia has done this before with a bin laden colleague, where they studied the Quran/had someone who understood the Quran interrogate the suspect.
Betray their religion? Terrorist don't have a religion. It's just an excuse to try and stroke power onto people.
I met people who follow Islam. Great people.
Terrorist are trying to take Islam and force it into something that's not even close to it. Like how evangelicals try and chance Christianity into something they would agree with.
One with a brain
The kind that realizes that religion is insane
we'll you're on a watchlist now,congrats
Pretending to be Muslim to get info is her first mistake. What a joke. This is a good comedy film.
No she is Muslim, or born Muslim.
Normally I ignore low IQ bait posts but yours stood out. Wow.
Were you born stupid or did you have to work really hard at it.
You pretending to put sentences together correctly is comedy gold.
Both of them are pretending to be Muslim.