Wallahi, you blow my mind. I am in shock, I just can't believe that i was being misguided for so long. I am 43! What you're saying makes sense. i was always confused by some meanings of words that change according to verses.
Based on your premise, that it is not a ritual action, can you explain this verse: Quran 4:102. "O Messenger!) If you are among the believers and rise (in the state of war) to lead the Prayer for them,134 let a party of them stand with you to worship, keeping their arms.135 When they have performed their prostration, let them go behind you, and let another party who have not prayed, pray with you, remaining on guard and keeping their arms..."
Brother, I'd stopped responding to you because it was clear you hadn't watched the series. This + all other ayahs ARE covered in the series. Start from the beginning
Why do you waste yr time with this batini zindiq who distorts every aspect of islam and brings his own fantasy- a real moron. You can also saythe quran is not a recitation or book - its a collection of objects !!
Thank you so much for this. Really appreciate your deep dive into these aspects of Quran. With regards to the equality in Masjid, even during the prayer their is no equality because women aren’t allowed to be in the front.
@@AlMosesPhD @user-ln4vy2ly5e *Do you drink?* your Sanatana is Arabic word you Hin du is Arabic word *You know what it means??* This means!!! After Arabs came to this land you got your name and identity and your Toy and Zoological gods are not more that 500 years old,,,,, *Do you know age of Islam?* Go and see Noah Ark / Ship / Naav🛳 that started from India Tanur Kerala 23;27 and landed in Turkey Mount⛰ Judy 11;44 and buried 3000 feets below the earth *How this 1 Km long 1/2 Km wide and 3 floored huge ship / Naav, went 3000 feet below earth and in how many million years??* *And How Quran and Prophet* *Mohammed PBUH knows this history of India and Turkey??* *Explore and find the truth??* *You have very few years of life left.* Go and see Dwarka then Under water temple city drowned in this flood of Tanur 11;40 *What more proof you want??* Save yourself and your family from Monky 🐵and elephants🐘 and rats🐁
There are two meanings of "sujud" in the Quran; -One is "to OBEY", as you mentioned; eg Q22:18 Do you not see that Allah is He, Whom obeys whoever (يَسْجُدُ لَهُ مَن) is in the heavens and whoever is in the earth,... -The other is to physically PROSTRATE, e.g Q41:37 And among His signs are the night and the day and the sun and the moon; do not prostrate (لَا تَسۡجُدُواْ) to the sun nor to the moon (وَلَا لِلۡقَمَرِ); and prostrate to Allah Who created them,... While one can envisage a physical prostration to the sun and moon, there is no logical meaning to "obeying" them. Q27:24 I found her and her people prostrating (يَسۡجُدُونَ) to the sun (لِلشَّمۡسِ) instead of Allah, .... Again, it has to be prostrating here, since it is quite meaningless to "obey" the sun. Seems to me as the Quran text go, while one obeys Allah, one is also required to prostrate to Him. People who does physical sujud also do the sciences, tech, sports, etc. The world has changed in part due to the people who do sujud too, for they do sujud for a total of only half an hour a day, while for the rest of the day they work for betterment ("to obey") like everyone else.
No You can obey the sun and the moon if you follow man made religions based on worshipping the sun and the moon which is done through symbolic words like jesus, amen, ameen, crescent moon symbolism, false prayer times according to the sun.
@@Shahiau "Muhammad is Allah’s Messenger, and those who are with him are firm with the unbelievers but compassionate with one another. You SEE (تَرَىٰهُمۡ) them occupied in bowing (رُكَّعٗا) and prostrating (سُجَّدٗا) and in seeking Allah’s bounty and good pleasure, Their mark is on their faces (فِي وُجُوهِهِم) from (مِّنۡ) the trace (أَثَرِ) of prostration (ٱلسُّجُودِۚ)... " Part of Q48:29 One can only "see" a physical object/action (ruku' or sujud)... one can "see" traces or marks on a face or a physical surface, if there are any. One cannot "see" matters of the heart or mind
@user-ln4vy2ly5e *Do you drink?* your Sanatana is Arabic word you Hin du is Arabic word *You know what it means??* This means!!! After Arabs came to this land you got your name and identity and your Toy and Zoological gods are not more that 500 years old,,,,, *Do you know age of Islam?* Go and see Noah Ark / Ship / Naav🛳 that started from India Tanur Kerala 23;27 and landed in Turkey Mount⛰ Judy 11;44 and buried 3000 feets below the earth *How this 1 Km long 1/2 Km wide and 3 floored huge ship / Naav, went 3000 feet below earth and in how many million years??* *And How Quran and Prophet* *Mohammed PBUH knows this history of India and Turkey??* *Explore and find the truth??* *You have very few years of life left.* Go and see Dwarka then Under water temple city drowned in this flood of Tanur 11;40 *What more proof you want??* Save yourself and your family from Monky 🐵and elephants🐘 and rats🐁
Salamun alayk. If you can give some explanation of the trilateral root word "sajada", the your proposition will be better supported. But this is a good work. Thank you
peace how can you use this translation with the verse that talk about Satan prostrate to adam?? "We told the angels, "Prostrate to Adam", and they prostrated, except Iblîs (Satan), he refused to be of those who prostrate.'"
Thanks for your detailed presentation. There is something missing in your explanation. You mentioned everything/everyone does Sajda to Allah. 1. Then why Maryam or anyone have to do Sajda willingly , are you suggesting there are multiple kinds of Sajda? 2. If there is only one kind of Sajda, then it has to be done only willingly. That means everyone/everything are not part of heaven and the earth. May be only good people are between heaven and the earth. Possibly heaven and earth are not physical. 3. Why in 3:43 Sajda come before Ruku and 22:77 it comes after. There has to be a reason for that 4. in 17:107 it says even non believer when recited to then , then they do Sajda. If Sajda means an action to make a change, why would a non-believer make a change without believing?
Pray as every prophet of Allah prayed.. Quran has all the details read it and you will know .. for example here is an ayah for you.. Recite what is sent of the Book by inspiration to thee, and establish regular Prayer: for Prayer restrains from shameful and unjust deeds; and remembrance of Allah is the greatest (thing in life) without doubt. And Allah knows the (deeds) that ye do. (Ankebût 29:45)
salam brother its a great explenation, but why adding more word at the translation, theres no "gods system" or any more word there, its only said sjd = "carryin out", theres no gods sytem word or any other word there, we better not adding or decrease word like those people did adding tafseer, even at the translated version, anyway keep up the good work n jst put out any tafseer from the translation salam
13:15- Everyone does sajdah willingly or unwillingly. 27:24,25- I found queen of Sheba and her people prostrating to sun, instead of Allah. These 2 verses are contradicting. And if everyone is doing sajdah willingly or unwillingly, then why are we commanded to do sajdah as in verse 25:60? Please give me answer.
Sir verse 41:37 ke baare mein kya kahenge? Usme الشمس and القمر ke lie sajad ka use ho rha hai? Kya wha pe physical prostration hai matlab sajdah ka? Samjhaie...😢
@@AlMosesPhD sir traditional translations padhne ke baad to yhi smjh aa rha hai ki sun and moon ko prostrate mt kro but Allah ko kro...PHYSICALLY! !!! lekin ek cheez ka farq dikh rha hai...لا تسجدوا ko translate kia gya hai "dont prostrate" And اسجدوا لله ko translate kia gya hai " Prostrate to Allah" Dono farq yeh hai ki ek jagah prefix "ت" lga hai aur ek jagah "ا" To dono ko ek hi translate krna...Kuch to bataie sir....jawab sab ke lie ho jaega...Bhut puzzling answer dia aapne..
what about 50:40 (Qaf, 40)? "It says And [in part] of the night exalt Him and after prostration." The arabic wording they use there translates as "prostrate".
Again in 7:206, it's the same: "Surely those ˹angels˺ nearest to your Lord are not too proud to worship Him. They glorify Him. And to Him they prostrate.", and they have the same exact arabic word.
What is Quranic Sala and how do I do. I am not very well educated and I don't understand some of what you are saying. How pray to Allah SWT to be close to him
Brother, Can you let us know how Prophet use to pray every day? did he pray 3 times, 5 times? how he prayed physically? how he led the prayer with Sahabas?... As far as my understanding from Quran: An-Nur 24:58: On 3 occasions before the dawn, at noon when change clothes and after evening prayer:- We can take that these are Fazar, Duhur and Isha prayer. Israr 17:78: Perform prayer at the decline of the sun, until the darkness of the night and Quran at dawn :- We take as this is for Magrib prayer.. Baqara 2: 238: Guard your prayers and the middle prayer and stand before Allah in devotion:- We take as this for Asr Prayer As per Quran if we pray/connection to the Allah in those set times Allah mentioned and if we read verses from Quran and do the Sajda.. Is that Allah will be angry on us for Sajda and they way we prayed physically? Yes, you can argue that how many Rakat we will pray during the each prayer time? As we understand from centuries that Prophet has let to prayer with Shahabs only those Farz prayers and rest he prayed silently in his own. So, regardless of your kind of explanation of the Quranic word which is Arabic and nor you are an Arabican nor Arabic is your language nor you did PHD on Arabic language to get all these specific meaning of the words from Quaran other than what we have in today's translation. Hope Allah will guide you to the righteous and not advocate people not to do physical pray as we do today.. Btw, do you know the physical pray's scientific benefits to your health and brain apart from praying for Allah? if not please search in Google.. Thanks..
so what next? no need to pray 5 times and fast? whats the conclusion. its just that videos take a lot of time and i cant get the conclusion. can you please help me understand?
My dīn is solo. No congregational association. Groups eventually disagree and splinter. My islam would label me a kafir in the eyes of sunni and Shia. I label myself an atheist to the secular public. Cheers from Vermont USA 🇺🇸
Is there any source on the Internet that has the same translation of sajda like yours? Also what about the salah, can I find the definition anywhere on the Internet? Selaam
Because i want to learn from the correct translations. Couldn't it be that you make a mistake too? So that's what Im trying to know.I try to verify what you said so I can be sure about it.
Salamun alykoum. The stories of the Quran provide the context wherein the words Allah uses in the Quran are defined. Meaning we have to look for context and understand that Allah is the master of his own book and can use the language as he chooses.
People are falling on their 'chins'? Skipping all the other parts of the 'ritual' namaz and going directly to sajda? Let's give some credit to the verses and admit there is no ritual in these ayahs
The first verse (101): وَلَقَدْ آتَيْنَا مُوسَىٰ تِسْعَ آيَاتٍ mentions the bestowal of nine clear signs on Sayyidna Musa (علیہ السلام) . The word: آیَہ ('ayah) carries the meaning of miracle or sign as well as that of the آیَت : ayat or verses of the Qur'an, that is, the divine injunctions. At this place, the probability of both meanings exists. Therefore, a number of commentators have taken the word 'ayat' to mean miracles - and the number nine does not make it necessary that they will not be more than nine - but, at this place, the figure 'nine' has been mentioned on the basis of some particular importance it has. Sayyidna ` Abdullah ibn ` Abbas ؓ has enumerated these miracles as follows: 1. The staff of Sayyidna Musa (علیہ السلام) which turned into a huge snake. 2. The hand that emitted light when placed under and taken out of the armpit. 3. The removal of stammering from his tongue. 4. The splitting of the water barrier in two sections to give safe passage to the Bani Isra'il to cross it. 5. The sending of the punishment through locusts in unusual circumstances. 6. The sending of the storm. 7. The clothes on their bodies were infested with countless lice they had no escape from. 8. The punishment of frogs was released on them when frogs would appear in everything they ate or drank. 9. The punishment of blood was sent that filled every utensil and mingled with whatever they ate or drank. And a Sahih Hadith tells us that the word 'ayat' used here means divine injunctions. This Hadith has been reported in Abu Dawud, an-Nasa'i, Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah on the authority of Sayyidna Safwan ibn al-` Aththal. He says that a Jew asked one of his friends to take him to 'that' prophet. The friend said, 'do not call him a prophet. If he finds out that we too call him a prophet, he will have four eyes on him (that is, he will have an opportunity to wallow in his pride and glee).' Then they came to the Holy Prophet ﷺ and asked him as to what were the nine clear signs given to Sayyidna Musa (علیہ السلام) . He said: 1. Do not ascribe any partners to Allah. 2. Do not steal. 3. Do not fornicate. 4. Do not unjustly take the life of the one whose killing has been forbidden by Allah. 5. Do not falsely impute anyone innocent with charges liable to the sentence of death or any other punishment. 6. Do not practice magic. 7. Do not devour interest. 8. Do not level a false accusation of fornication on a chaste woman. 9. Do not desert the battlefield in Jihad for fear of being killed. And he also said, '0 Jews, it has also been specially enjoined on you that you shall not contravene the particular injunctions of the observance of the day of Sabbath (Saturday) given to you.' Hearing what the Holy Prophet ﷺ said, they both kissed his hands and feet and declared, 'We bear witness that you are the prophet of Allah.' He said, 'What is it, then, that stops you from following me?' They said that Sayyidna Dawud (علیہ السلام) had prayed to his Lord for prophets to always keep appearing from among his progeny - 'and we are scared that the Jews will kill us if we started following you.' Since this explanation of the verse stands proved on the authority of Sahih Hadith, therefore, this is what many commentators have preferred to go by.
Good video. Interestingly, you ended the video with the verse: 84:21 And when the Quran is read to them, they do not _"sujud"_ But the Sunnis, Shiites and all the Sectarians have been taught by their "revered religious holy men" to read the Quran back to God! No wonder they go down on all fours with their foreheads firmly pressed to the ground, all the while muttering some man-invented Arabic words pieced together, like pagans worshipping their stone idols. Poor lost misguided souls self-believing that they are the guided ones! salam.
Why not just do what God tells us to do, by not twisting the meaning of each word. However if its necessary to change, why dont we do it so long not to distruct the idea. Just like enter the gate humble. How will u picture out people entering the gate prostrating. This time we have to use our intelligence. By just submitting to Allah.
﷽ The translation you have is wrong. Your understanding of Arabic is limited and it's giving wrong meanings. The article من specifies who is doing the verb يسجد which obviously excludes your guitar. This is a basic Arabic concept. I stopped watching your video after seeing this mistake in the second minute.
@@kinanlaham744 What/who is/are دابة in the Quran? Who are الملائكة? I'm not asking for an answer from Fusha or Fiqhi Arabic. What are these terms in the Quran?
@@AlMosesPhD No, we are questioning * your * ability to understand Qur'anic Arabic. In your video you claim "everything" يسجد based on ما. I corrected you and pointed to the part of the verse where it limits the subject of the verb and reduces it with the article من. At this point you need to agree you did make a mistake before we can move to anything else.
Dont listen to these so called scholars we pray the way the orophet taught us with clean intentions .didnt the prophet sat these scholars will put you on wrong tracks
You blatantly ignore so many verses, to then interpret the Namaz in your own way. It's just an ignorant and blind way. You want to divide Muslims even more, that is your goal
Quran use karna misguide karna nahi. 19:58 mein konsi 'namaz' hay jis mein wo direct sajday mein gir jatay thay? Namaz ki assumption nikal ke batayi. Btw, is ayah mein nabiyoon kya hay, anbiya kyon nahi? Zuriya ka matlab 'bachay' hain? Kisi ki niyat pe bat karnay say acha hay insan aik ilmi ikhtilaf bayan kare
Sajda is not putting forehead on the ground... Let me help you with ideas for future videos: Salah is not pray Hajj is not pilgrimage Zina is a good deed Alcohol is not haram Muhammad is not a prophet Quran is not a holy book Allah is not a god There's no god at all
Good point. -Alcohol isn't haram. No where in the Quran does Allah says it is. The word khamar doesn't mean alcohol but 'cover'. In Persian however, Khamar or Khamuri means Alcohol not Arabic. -Salat isn't a ritual prayer. It means adherence and/or connection. According to the Quran birds do Salat as well and "establish prayer" doesn't mean anything. -Hajj isn't pilgrimage. That Black Building in Mecca wasn't built by Abraham. The people of Mecca where Ummiyeen before Muhammad which means they haven't received a messege or a prophet according to the Quran. -Muhammad? The fictional Muhammad of the Hadith was not a prophet. He was a very horrible person. If you read Dr.kashif khan's article, "Muhammad" is an adjective not a name. It means 'praiseworthy'. The real Arabian prophet could've been named Muhammad but its not clear what his actual name was. -As for Allah, yes he is God.
I think you are most likely Jewish, fear of Islam rising , yet muslim believe in Torah, Bible & Quran, we fear only Allah Swt. You fear who? We all die to stand before one God. Practice your own faith, learn as a student , studying Quran you forget your faith& who God really is, your mission to divide and conquer is failed before starting , Truth always wins . Devious ,devil,play has consequences ,you will come to know , it’s only time .
Praise be to Allah. Thanks for a clear and precise explanation
hamdulillah
Mashallah my brother, clear concise and the true message sent from Almighty Allah for all of mankind.
Wallahi, you blow my mind. I am in shock, I just can't believe that i was being misguided for so long. I am 43! What you're saying makes sense. i was always confused by some meanings of words that change according to verses.
Keep reading, keep learning brother
Both of u 😢 Alas
I never thought like this before! Now the question comes to my mind that are the six books wrong which mentioned how to pray?
We have a one Muslim scholar in Burma who said about real Swalah from Quran , Thanks god you are the another minority who is presenting the truth
Excellent analysis... I'll be recommending your videos for sure.
Point well presented!!!
Salaamun Alaykum Alhamdulillahh MaashaAllahh very clear
alhamdulillah
I wish you would number the series. Yhat way it will be so easy for us to follow the lectures
I believe that each Allah's creation has their own way of performing salat.
Salamun Alaikum. Loud n clear.
SA, :)
Willingly or unwillingly
Very interesting
This we can also apply to many destructive harmful weapons and so many other
Indeed
Salamun alaikum
Salamun alaikum
Based on your premise, that it is not a ritual action, can you explain this verse: Quran 4:102. "O Messenger!) If you are among the believers and rise (in the state of war) to lead the Prayer for them,134 let a party of them stand with you to worship, keeping their arms.135 When they have performed their prostration, let them go behind you, and let another party who have not prayed, pray with you, remaining on guard and keeping their arms..."
Brother, I'd stopped responding to you because it was clear you hadn't watched the series.
This + all other ayahs ARE covered in the series. Start from the beginning
Why do you waste yr time with this batini zindiq who distorts every aspect of islam and brings his own fantasy- a real moron. You can also saythe quran is not a recitation or book - its a collection of objects !!
Thank you so much for this. Really appreciate your deep dive into these aspects of Quran. With regards to the equality in Masjid, even during the prayer their is no equality because women aren’t allowed to be in the front.
Because our religious men have no trust in men
@@AlMosesPhD @user-ln4vy2ly5e *Do you drink?*
your Sanatana is Arabic word
you Hin du is Arabic word
*You know what it means??*
This means!!! After Arabs came to this land you got your name and identity
and your Toy and Zoological gods are not more that 500 years old,,,,,
*Do you know age of Islam?*
Go and see Noah Ark / Ship / Naav🛳
that started from India Tanur Kerala 23;27
and landed in Turkey Mount⛰ Judy 11;44
and buried 3000 feets below the earth
*How this 1 Km long 1/2 Km wide and 3 floored huge ship / Naav, went 3000 feet below earth and in how many million years??*
*And How Quran and Prophet* *Mohammed PBUH knows this history of India and Turkey??*
*Explore and find the truth??*
*You have very few years of life left.*
Go and see Dwarka then Under water temple city drowned in this flood of Tanur 11;40
*What more proof you want??*
Save yourself and your family from Monky 🐵and elephants🐘 and rats🐁
I am bit confused ,so what about following prophet Muhammad way of doing salah .
Pls explain
Salamun Alaikum
SA
There are two meanings of "sujud" in the Quran;
-One is "to OBEY", as you mentioned;
eg
Q22:18
Do you not see that Allah is He, Whom obeys whoever (يَسْجُدُ لَهُ مَن) is in the heavens and whoever is in the earth,...
-The other is to physically PROSTRATE, e.g
Q41:37
And among His signs are the night and the day and the sun and the moon; do not prostrate (لَا تَسۡجُدُواْ) to the sun nor to the moon (وَلَا لِلۡقَمَرِ); and prostrate to Allah Who created them,...
While one can envisage a physical prostration to the sun and moon, there is no logical meaning to "obeying" them.
Q27:24
I found her and her people prostrating (يَسۡجُدُونَ) to the sun (لِلشَّمۡسِ) instead of Allah, ....
Again, it has to be prostrating here, since it is quite meaningless to "obey" the sun.
Seems to me as the Quran text go, while one obeys Allah, one is also required to prostrate to Him.
People who does physical sujud also do the sciences, tech, sports, etc. The world has changed in part due to the people who do sujud too, for they do sujud for a total of only half an hour a day, while for the rest of the day they work for betterment ("to obey") like everyone else.
No You can obey the sun and the moon if you follow man made religions based on worshipping the sun and the moon which is done through symbolic words like jesus, amen, ameen, crescent moon symbolism, false prayer times according to the sun.
@@Shahiau
"Muhammad is Allah’s Messenger, and those who are with him are firm with the unbelievers but compassionate with one another. You SEE (تَرَىٰهُمۡ) them occupied in bowing (رُكَّعٗا) and prostrating (سُجَّدٗا) and in seeking Allah’s bounty and good pleasure,
Their mark is on their faces (فِي وُجُوهِهِم) from (مِّنۡ) the trace (أَثَرِ) of prostration (ٱلسُّجُودِۚ)... "
Part of Q48:29
One can only "see" a physical object/action (ruku' or sujud)... one can "see" traces or marks on a face or a physical surface, if there are any. One cannot "see" matters of the heart or mind
@user-ln4vy2ly5e *Do you drink?*
your Sanatana is Arabic word
you Hin du is Arabic word
*You know what it means??*
This means!!! After Arabs came to this land you got your name and identity
and your Toy and Zoological gods are not more that 500 years old,,,,,
*Do you know age of Islam?*
Go and see Noah Ark / Ship / Naav🛳
that started from India Tanur Kerala 23;27
and landed in Turkey Mount⛰ Judy 11;44
and buried 3000 feets below the earth
*How this 1 Km long 1/2 Km wide and 3 floored huge ship / Naav, went 3000 feet below earth and in how many million years??*
*And How Quran and Prophet* *Mohammed PBUH knows this history of India and Turkey??*
*Explore and find the truth??*
*You have very few years of life left.*
Go and see Dwarka then Under water temple city drowned in this flood of Tanur 11;40
*What more proof you want??*
Save yourself and your family from Monky 🐵and elephants🐘 and rats🐁
Salamun alayk. If you can give some explanation of the trilateral root word "sajada", the your proposition will be better supported. But this is a good work. Thank you
Thanks
Maujuda Namaz kesay aur kab Salat bani, kia aap apna opinion batain gay....
Last video of the series
@@AlMosesPhD Thank you, and please also mention how the prophet established Salat (specifics if you know) and the generations after that.
peace how can you use this translation with the verse that talk about Satan prostrate to adam?? "We told the angels, "Prostrate to Adam", and they prostrated, except Iblîs (Satan), he refused to be of those who prostrate.'"
Thanks for your detailed presentation. There is something missing in your explanation.
You mentioned everything/everyone does Sajda to Allah.
1. Then why Maryam or anyone have to do Sajda willingly , are you suggesting there are multiple kinds of Sajda?
2. If there is only one kind of Sajda, then it has to be done only willingly. That means everyone/everything are not part of heaven and the earth. May be only good people are between heaven and the earth. Possibly heaven and earth are not physical.
3. Why in 3:43 Sajda come before Ruku and 22:77 it comes after. There has to be a reason for that
4. in 17:107 it says even non believer when recited to then , then they do Sajda. If Sajda means an action to make a change, why would a non-believer make a change without believing?
Thoughtful questions.
When I talk about mashyat Allah, will cover these in detail
So how to pray now?)😮
Pray as every prophet of Allah prayed.. Quran has all the details read it and you will know .. for example here is an ayah for you..
Recite what is sent of the Book by inspiration to thee, and establish regular Prayer: for Prayer restrains from shameful and unjust deeds; and remembrance of Allah is the greatest (thing in life) without doubt. And Allah knows the (deeds) that ye do. (Ankebût 29:45)
I am shocked to see this but how can we pray? Thanks
Pray= dua
You can make dua in your own language or there are so many duas from quran too. For ex- dua of prophets mentioned in Quran
salam brother its a great explenation, but why adding more word at the translation, theres no "gods system" or any more word there, its only said sjd = "carryin out", theres no gods sytem word or any other word there, we better not adding or decrease word like those people did adding tafseer, even at the translated version, anyway keep up the good work n jst put out any tafseer from the translation salam
Can a term or word in the quran have two sets of meanings or different translation? Or is it used universally and doesn’t change on context. Thanks.
The mafhoom never changes
13:15- Everyone does sajdah willingly or unwillingly.
27:24,25- I found queen of Sheba and her people prostrating to sun, instead of Allah.
These 2 verses are contradicting. And if everyone is doing sajdah willingly or unwillingly, then why are we commanded to do sajdah as in verse 25:60?
Please give me answer.
Sir verse 41:37 ke baare mein kya kahenge? Usme الشمس and القمر ke lie sajad ka use ho rha hai? Kya wha pe physical prostration hai matlab sajdah ka? Samjhaie...😢
same comment spam na karain
@@AlMosesPhD Sirf jawab jaane ke lie kia tha..sorry...Aap bata dijie..jawab
@@its_hammad_vloges980 isi mein answer hay.
Allah kay physics ke laws follow karte hain
@@AlMosesPhD sir traditional translations padhne ke baad to yhi smjh aa rha hai ki sun and moon ko prostrate mt kro but Allah ko kro...PHYSICALLY! !!! lekin ek cheez ka farq dikh rha hai...لا تسجدوا ko translate kia gya hai "dont prostrate" And اسجدوا لله ko translate kia gya hai " Prostrate to Allah" Dono farq yeh hai ki ek jagah prefix "ت" lga hai aur ek jagah "ا" To dono ko ek hi translate krna...Kuch to bataie sir....jawab sab ke lie ho jaega...Bhut puzzling answer dia aapne..
what about 50:40 (Qaf, 40)? "It says And [in part] of the night exalt Him and after prostration." The arabic wording they use there translates as "prostrate".
ٱلسُّجُودِ --------> this is the arabic word they use
Again in 7:206, it's the same: "Surely those ˹angels˺ nearest to your Lord are not too proud to worship Him. They glorify Him. And to Him they prostrate.", and they have the same exact arabic word.
What is Quranic Sala and how do I do. I am not very well educated and I don't understand some of what you are saying. How pray to Allah SWT to be close to him
Please watch the whole series until the end
I am struggling so hard brother...
With what?
Brother, Can you let us know how Prophet use to pray every day? did he pray 3 times, 5 times? how he prayed physically? how he led the prayer with Sahabas?... As far as my understanding from Quran:
An-Nur 24:58: On 3 occasions before the dawn, at noon when change clothes and after evening prayer:- We can take that these are Fazar, Duhur and Isha prayer.
Israr 17:78: Perform prayer at the decline of the sun, until the darkness of the night and Quran at dawn :- We take as this is for Magrib prayer..
Baqara 2: 238: Guard your prayers and the middle prayer and stand before Allah in devotion:- We take as this for Asr Prayer
As per Quran if we pray/connection to the Allah in those set times Allah mentioned and if we read verses from Quran and do the Sajda.. Is that Allah will be angry on us for Sajda and they way we prayed physically? Yes, you can argue that how many Rakat we will pray during the each prayer time? As we understand from centuries that Prophet has let to prayer with Shahabs only those Farz prayers and rest he prayed silently in his own. So, regardless of your kind of explanation of the Quranic word which is Arabic and nor you are an Arabican nor Arabic is your language nor you did PHD on Arabic language to get all these specific meaning of the words from Quaran other than what we have in today's translation.
Hope Allah will guide you to the righteous and not advocate people not to do physical pray as we do today.. Btw, do you know the physical pray's scientific benefits to your health and brain apart from praying for Allah? if not please search in Google.. Thanks..
Brother, start the series from the 'beginning'. Your particular questions are answered at the 'end' of the series.
@@AlMosesPhD Pls provide the link of that video that you cover the how the Prophet has prayed..
Look in playlists
I never thought like this before! Now the question comes to my mind that are the six books wrong which mentioned how to pray?
so what next? no need to pray 5 times and fast? whats the conclusion. its just that videos take a lot of time and i cant get the conclusion. can you please help me understand?
The alternative is you pick up the mushaf and read yourself
Yup. No need to pray 5 times and fast which are Hindu and Zoroastrian practices.
My dīn is solo. No congregational association. Groups eventually disagree and splinter. My islam would label me a kafir in the eyes of sunni and Shia. I label myself an atheist to the secular public. Cheers from Vermont USA 🇺🇸
Deeds are far more important than labels
Salam but the wudu is inside 5:7
Salam, watch the series. It's covered
Is there any source on the Internet that has the same translation of sajda like yours? Also what about the salah, can I find the definition anywhere on the Internet? Selaam
Plenty.
But does it matter? The Quran offers its own dictionary by the way it uses these terms
Because i want to learn from the correct translations. Couldn't it be that you make a mistake too? So that's what Im trying to know.I try to verify what you said so I can be sure about it.
@@AlMosesPhD and if it offers its own dictionary, where can I look the correct one up?
Salamun alykoum. The stories of the Quran provide the context wherein the words Allah uses in the Quran are defined. Meaning we have to look for context and understand that Allah is the master of his own book and can use the language as he chooses.
@@DEMI-dh4qw You're right he did make a mistake. His knowledge of Arabic is limited. He knows ما، but doesn't know ما من إلا construct.
Did Ahle Bait & Sahabae Rasool understand SAJDA like Quraanic Sense ?
spam na karain
Whose English translation you use
Mine but I consult a few
Ye ahmed isa ki dawat he please replay
This is what the Quran says. It's no one's words.
@@AlMosesPhD denier of Hadith aren't you
@@Islamandjihad follower of the rasul's risala
Is jihad an obligation to fight the kuffar
What is jihad? Who is a kafir? Read the Quran my brother
Please see surah bani israeel verse no 17:107_109,)
People are falling on their 'chins'? Skipping all the other parts of the 'ritual' namaz and going directly to sajda?
Let's give some credit to the verses and admit there is no ritual in these ayahs
The first verse (101): وَلَقَدْ آتَيْنَا مُوسَىٰ تِسْعَ آيَاتٍ mentions the bestowal of nine clear signs on Sayyidna Musa (علیہ السلام) . The word: آیَہ ('ayah) carries the meaning of miracle or sign as well as that of the آیَت : ayat or verses of the Qur'an, that is, the divine injunctions. At this place, the probability of both meanings exists. Therefore, a number of commentators have taken the word 'ayat' to mean miracles - and the number nine does not make it necessary that they will not be more than nine - but, at this place, the figure 'nine' has been mentioned on the basis of some particular importance it has. Sayyidna ` Abdullah ibn ` Abbas ؓ has enumerated these miracles as follows:
1. The staff of Sayyidna Musa (علیہ السلام) which turned into a huge snake.
2. The hand that emitted light when placed under and taken out of the armpit.
3. The removal of stammering from his tongue.
4. The splitting of the water barrier in two sections to give safe passage to the Bani Isra'il to cross it.
5. The sending of the punishment through locusts in unusual circumstances.
6. The sending of the storm.
7. The clothes on their bodies were infested with countless lice they had no escape from.
8. The punishment of frogs was released on them when frogs would appear in everything they ate or drank.
9. The punishment of blood was sent that filled every utensil and mingled with whatever they ate or drank.
And a Sahih Hadith tells us that the word 'ayat' used here means divine injunctions. This Hadith has been reported in Abu Dawud, an-Nasa'i, Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah on the authority of Sayyidna Safwan ibn al-` Aththal. He says that a Jew asked one of his friends to take him to 'that' prophet. The friend said, 'do not call him a prophet. If he finds out that we too call him a prophet, he will have four eyes on him (that is, he will have an opportunity to wallow in his pride and glee).' Then they came to the Holy Prophet ﷺ and asked him as to what were the nine clear signs given to Sayyidna Musa (علیہ السلام) . He said:
1. Do not ascribe any partners to Allah.
2. Do not steal.
3. Do not fornicate.
4. Do not unjustly take the life of the one whose killing has been forbidden by Allah.
5. Do not falsely impute anyone innocent with charges liable to the sentence of death or any other punishment.
6. Do not practice magic.
7. Do not devour interest.
8. Do not level a false accusation of fornication on a chaste woman.
9. Do not desert the battlefield in Jihad for fear of being killed.
And he also said, '0 Jews, it has also been specially enjoined on you that you shall not contravene the particular injunctions of the observance of the day of Sabbath (Saturday) given to you.'
Hearing what the Holy Prophet ﷺ said, they both kissed his hands and feet and declared, 'We bear witness that you are the prophet of Allah.' He said, 'What is it, then, that stops you from following me?' They said that Sayyidna Dawud (علیہ السلام) had prayed to his Lord for prophets to always keep appearing from among his progeny - 'and we are scared that the Jews will kill us if we started following you.'
Since this explanation of the verse stands proved on the authority of Sahih Hadith, therefore, this is what many commentators have preferred to go by.
The Quran by itself is not enough to you? You need 'man-made' history to understand it.
Your choice.
Hadith is a manmade system
Good video.
Interestingly, you ended the video with the verse:
84:21 And when the Quran is read to them, they do not _"sujud"_
But the Sunnis, Shiites and all the Sectarians have been taught by their "revered religious holy men" to read the Quran back to God!
No wonder they go down on all fours with their foreheads firmly pressed to the ground, all the while muttering some man-invented Arabic words pieced together, like pagans worshipping their stone idols.
Poor lost misguided souls self-believing that they are the guided ones!
salam.
That one ayah alone should be enough to shatter slumbers
Here is the link:
ruclips.net/video/6jHPJhEFlzM/видео.html
Why not just do what God tells us to do, by not twisting the meaning of each word. However if its necessary to change, why dont we do it so long not to distruct the idea. Just like enter the gate humble. How will u picture out people entering the gate prostrating. This time we have to use our intelligence. By just submitting to Allah.
Misleading research 🧐 all the main concepts of islam you are denying u are a kind of dajaal 😅
Read the Quran brother.
Consider the argument.
Argue with daleel
Dajjal doesn't exist
Iblish( shataan) usually do not follow the physical prostration commanded by Almighty Allah. So look yourself who r u..?
'Iblis' has a 'forehead'?
Brother, go back to the Quran
Shaytan isn't an entity. It's just the enraged/negative aspect of a human
﷽
The translation you have is wrong. Your understanding of Arabic is limited and it's giving wrong meanings.
The article من specifies who is doing the verb يسجد which obviously excludes your guitar. This is a basic Arabic concept.
I stopped watching your video after seeing this mistake in the second minute.
The second minute has 'maa' and not 'man'.
I don't see your objection.
@@AlMosesPhD من دابة والملائكة is the part the verse is referring to. If you fail to understand this, you need to work on your Arabic.
من دابة والملائكة
is the part the verse is referring to. If you fail to understand this, you need to work on your Arabic
@@kinanlaham744 What/who is/are دابة in the Quran? Who are الملائكة?
I'm not asking for an answer from Fusha or Fiqhi Arabic.
What are these terms in the Quran?
@@AlMosesPhD No, we are questioning * your * ability to understand Qur'anic Arabic. In your video you claim "everything" يسجد based on ما. I corrected you and pointed to the part of the verse where it limits the subject of the verb and reduces it with the article من. At this point you need to agree you did make a mistake before we can move to anything else.
Dont listen to these so called scholars we pray the way the orophet taught us with clean intentions .didnt the prophet sat these scholars will put you on wrong tracks
Consider the evidence with the Quran.
Or not.
You blatantly ignore so many verses, to then interpret the Namaz in your own way. It's just an ignorant and blind way. You want to divide Muslims even more, that is your goal
Which verses are ignored?
Did you see the series?
Did you compare with the Quran?
Pls read surah Maryam ayah no 58-59 about sajda in salah so pls dnt, mis guide innocent muslims for Allah sake and escape your self from hell.
Quran use karna misguide karna nahi.
19:58 mein konsi 'namaz' hay jis mein wo direct sajday mein gir jatay thay? Namaz ki assumption nikal ke batayi.
Btw, is ayah mein nabiyoon kya hay, anbiya kyon nahi? Zuriya ka matlab 'bachay' hain?
Kisi ki niyat pe bat karnay say acha hay insan aik ilmi ikhtilaf bayan kare
You sound misleading but there is sense in what you are trying to say
Sajda is not putting forehead on the ground... Let me help you with ideas for future videos:
Salah is not pray
Hajj is not pilgrimage
Zina is a good deed
Alcohol is not haram
Muhammad is not a prophet
Quran is not a holy book
Allah is not a god
There's no god at all
We can choose to listen to the Quran, restrict us to it, or not.
We all have that choice.
Good day
He literally shows proof and you guys still don't want to put the nonsense from Hadith aside
Good point.
-Alcohol isn't haram. No where in the Quran does Allah says it is. The word khamar doesn't mean alcohol but 'cover'. In Persian however, Khamar or Khamuri means Alcohol not Arabic.
-Salat isn't a ritual prayer. It means adherence and/or connection. According to the Quran birds do Salat as well and "establish prayer"
doesn't mean anything.
-Hajj isn't pilgrimage. That Black Building in Mecca wasn't built by Abraham. The people of Mecca where Ummiyeen before Muhammad which means they haven't received a messege or a prophet according to the Quran.
-Muhammad? The fictional Muhammad of the Hadith was not a prophet. He was a very horrible person. If you read Dr.kashif khan's article, "Muhammad" is an adjective not a name. It means 'praiseworthy'. The real Arabian prophet could've been named Muhammad but its not clear what his actual name was.
-As for Allah, yes he is God.
I think you are most likely Jewish, fear of Islam rising , yet muslim believe in Torah, Bible & Quran, we fear only Allah Swt. You fear who? We all die to stand before one God. Practice your own faith, learn as a student , studying Quran you forget your faith& who God really is, your mission to divide and conquer is failed before starting , Truth always wins . Devious ,devil,play has consequences ,you will come to know , it’s only time .