Thank you sooo much for the 12-hour wear test. I really appreciate longer wear tests. I work 12 hour shifts, so I need to know if makeup is going to play me by the end of the day
Little FYI: the Benefit liner comes in a brown shade, as well. I'm into more brown liners lately because as you said, black can sometimes be too harsh.
I bought the Benefit eyeliner a few weeks ago and had a really hard time putting it on. I went and exchanged it for the better than sex eyeliner and loved it.
I've bought a lot of stiff eyeliners which makes it so hard to apply especially for a beginner. Once I bought something from Ulta and I got the Major Must-Haves Makeup Set as a free gift and intently fell in love with the eyeliner. I love colourpop make up and I wish they would make there eyeliner softer so its easier to apply.
Has anyone else had the NYX epik liner smudge in the inner corner but not the outer one? I'm still testing it but I was confused lol I'm planning on continuing my "best of drugstore" series so I'll have a list soon hopefully!
i found after a couple of weeks of using the benefit roller liner that it would dry out really quickly. if you can afford to re purchase one every 4 or 5 weeks then go for it, if not i suggest you spend your money elsewhere.
Always store your liquid eyeliner upside down it makes a big difference. I used the kvd one and thought it went dry quick til I realised this trick. I currently have the too faced and that was the same.
I feel like stila is really missing out by not having a matte version of their liquid liner. That's been my favorite for a long time. That, and the clinique easy liner. So glad you did this review this helps me so much!
I love your review and Ido agree the Benefit one is a bit better just for the fact that it is a bit more intens on the color. I also did a review of it and I also love it. The Too Faced seems similar in brush and in color with the one from Physician's formula , that one is also more wet. I did not tried the Too faced one but I have had the PF. Love to see you again !
Looks great on you! A tip is to use the BTS waterproof mascara instead, since I have the same problem with the flaking, the waterproof one don’t flake at all but still looks just as good on the eye as the non waterproof one 😊
oh nooo i wanted the benefit one but i adoooore brush tip so i might get the too faced instead. or, if too faced is slever enough to have minis, i'll get both of them in mini versions and enjoy both since i am an eyeliner fiend who has yet to find her holy grail.
I thought I remembered reading that the Benefit one is supposed to be waterproof (back before it officially launched), so I double checked the Benefit cosmetics website & it does say it's supposed to be waterproof & last 24 hours!
@@beautywithemilie It's weird that they wouldn't have that info on their packaging. As for that info not being on the Sephora site, I'm not all that surprised. I've sadly noticed they sometimes miss little details like that, which is why I also check the brand's website before buying. I NEED waterproof eye products (oily lids & watery eyes), so details on whether something is actually waterproof or not is important to me!
Hi Emily, what is the wetnwild eyeliner that you said would not come off? I have extremely watery eyes and have NEVER had any luck with waterproof eyeliners.
Hi! I also have pretty watery eyes. If I remember correctly the H2O waterproof smudged onto on lower lash line. I have yet to find an eyeliner that doesn’t smudge or just completely come off. But I do prefer the liner just completely coming off rather than smudging and my fav for right now is the stila stay all day.
I have that same problem with brush tips, but I love the lorac one...never have a problem with that one. Thought I was the only person in the world that hates the kat von d eyeliner
I don't really use pen eyeliners because 1. They always always are super difficult for me to apply because of my eye shape that's pretty similar to yours 2. They fade away very easily maybe because I've teary eyes and no matter what I do they still fade away. My all-time favourite would be gel eyeliners but I'm quite shocked at tye results of today's video I'll definitely give it a try.
Thank you for doing this comparison, I was just trying to compare these myself last night. And I'm totally with you there on the Better than Sex mascara flaking on me, glad it's not just me!
Hi emily pls review the mark Anthony shampoo for volume the one u bought new pls I want to try that shampoo but I’m waiting for ur review n thoughts on it plsss
Oui je l'aime toujours (c'est vrai qu'il pourrait être plus mat :P)! Meme chose pour celui de Stila, mais ces deux ci sont nouveaux donc j'étais curieuse de voir s'ils étaient bons ou non!
Ouais c'est sûr 😉 Non je disais ça parce que tu disais avoir de la difficulté avec les eyeliners avec une pointe en pinceau 😊 Mais le Stila, je l'ai déjà essayé et je ne suis pas capable d'avoir un trait assez fin et il "skippait" aussi!
benefit and two faced always seem to be competing with eachother, the products ive noticed go head to head were the roller lash and the bts and now they have competing eyeliners 🤔
What's your favorite high end eyeliner? :)
Early! OMG! My faves are the stila and kat von d!!! Super long lasting!
Innisfree - brush tip
Just by the swatches the benefit looks amazing. Favorites are KvD tattoo liner and Clinique pretty easy
KVD brush tip 😊
Stila is my favorite high-end eyeliner. But the Catrice waterproof liquid liner is amazing also!
Just realized the music I put during the application isn't there... well then enjoy the silence of me trying not to screw up my eyeliner haha
I didn’t even notice haha
Thank you sooo much for the 12-hour wear test. I really appreciate longer wear tests. I work 12 hour shifts, so I need to know if makeup is going to play me by the end of the day
Always! I feel like for mascaras and foundations, the real test is what happens after 6/7h! Smudging or oily mess haha
I’ve found that the fenty fly liner doesn’t budge on 12 hour shifts or 12plus hours either if I’m lazy after a long shift. It’s literally still there.
For me it's a plus that the Too Faced one is not that dark. Most of black liners look to harsh on me. Definitely trying it 😊
That's a very good point!
Little FYI: the Benefit liner comes in a brown shade, as well. I'm into more brown liners lately because as you said, black can sometimes be too harsh.
I want to know which wet n wild eyeliner you were talking about. My oily eyelids are the best eyeliner removers on the planet.
Wet n wild H20 proof. It's great
& I use neutrogena makeup remover with it.
I've tried the roller liner and I find it's hard to use it to make a wing. I've been using the clinique pretty easy liner and it's so much easier!
I bought the Benefit eyeliner a few weeks ago and had a really hard time putting it on. I went and exchanged it for the better than sex eyeliner and loved it.
2 videos in the space of 2-3 days?!?! You’re spoiling us Emily!!! ❤️❤️❤️
If everything works out I should be back to a fix schedule (Wed-Sat) every week ❤️
Thanks so much! Was considering buying the Too faced, but at the price, really wanted a good worthwhile review. This was great, and helpful!
I've bought a lot of stiff eyeliners which makes it so hard to apply especially for a beginner. Once I bought something from Ulta and I got the Major Must-Haves Makeup Set as a free gift and intently fell in love with the eyeliner. I love colourpop make up and I wish they would make there eyeliner softer so its easier to apply.
Omg finally someone put these head to head!!
Can you do a wear test of the Too Faced vs your fav?
I love the new Too Faced eyeliner.Stays all day and super easy to apply :) good review
I've heard very mixed reviews on the BTS eyeliner...so the question is should I buy it
do you have any drugstore eyeliner recommendations?
and will you be doing your everyday simple makeup routine?
love ya
Shusmita Tasnuva Nyx x
Nyx and physicians formula are really good!
Physicians Formula Eye Booster!
Has anyone else had the NYX epik liner smudge in the inner corner but not the outer one? I'm still testing it but I was confused lol
I'm planning on continuing my "best of drugstore" series so I'll have a list soon hopefully!
maybe try the essence one the ink one in a brush tip it's better than nyx
i found after a couple of weeks of using the benefit roller liner that it would dry out really quickly. if you can afford to re purchase one every 4 or 5 weeks then go for it, if not i suggest you spend your money elsewhere.
Always store your liquid eyeliner upside down it makes a big difference. I used the kvd one and thought it went dry quick til I realised this trick. I currently have the too faced and that was the same.
I dont wear eyeliners. But I love Emily so... 😂😂😂
❤️😂
I feel like stila is really missing out by not having a matte version of their liquid liner. That's been my favorite for a long time. That, and the clinique easy liner. So glad you did this review this helps me so much!
100%! Have you tried their mini version? I didn’t think much of it at first but now I can’t live without it!!
I didnt even know there was a TF BTS Eyeliner 😳
It's coming out tomorrow so you won't be the only one lol
I love your review and Ido agree the Benefit one is a bit better just for the fact that it is a bit more intens on the color. I also did a review of it and I also love it. The Too Faced seems similar in brush and in color with the one from Physician's formula , that one is also more wet. I did not tried the Too faced one but I have had the PF. Love to see you again !
I think you should try the Clinique pretty easy eyeliner. Super easy to use, smudges after 6 hours of wear.
Looks great on you! A tip is to use the BTS waterproof mascara instead, since I have the same problem with the flaking, the waterproof one don’t flake at all but still looks just as good on the eye as the non waterproof one 😊
never been this early 🤯 always love your videos Emily 💗
oh nooo i wanted the benefit one but i adoooore brush tip so i might get the too faced instead. or, if too faced is slever enough to have minis, i'll get both of them in mini versions and enjoy both since i am an eyeliner fiend who has yet to find her holy grail.
im_so_ bored try the balm schwing! The best eyeliner and it’s extremely matte! Lasts all day, but it isn’t waterproof.
Your contact lenses color and brand please?
I love the benefit one and the bh cosmetics one
I thought I remembered reading that the Benefit one is supposed to be waterproof (back before it officially launched), so I double checked the Benefit cosmetics website & it does say it's supposed to be waterproof & last 24 hours!
For some reason it's not on the Sephroa website and I couldn't find it on their packaging! It didn't move so it's all that matters :)
@@beautywithemilie It's weird that they wouldn't have that info on their packaging. As for that info not being on the Sephora site, I'm not all that surprised. I've sadly noticed they sometimes miss little details like that, which is why I also check the brand's website before buying. I NEED waterproof eye products (oily lids & watery eyes), so details on whether something is actually waterproof or not is important to me!
i went to check your channel out as i watch this video bevuase i’m in need of a new eyeliner and blush. luckily i saw your video on blushes under $10!
Hi Emily, what is the wetnwild eyeliner that you said would not come off? I have extremely watery eyes and have NEVER had any luck with waterproof eyeliners.
I think it's called H2O waterproof? It's a the type you dip the brush in the liquid eyeliner! It's almost a tattoo lol
True. I tried that one. I had the brown color before and it is the most waterproof liner I have ever tried. It scared me a bit. :)
Hi! I also have pretty watery eyes. If I remember correctly the H2O waterproof smudged onto on lower lash line. I have yet to find an eyeliner that doesn’t smudge or just completely come off. But I do prefer the liner just completely coming off rather than smudging and my fav for right now is the stila stay all day.
so, i bought the benefit one more than once and the thinner piece of the brush gets dry after a few uses
does this happen with other people?
I went to apply it for the first time and barely any product comes out. I just end up with a very faint line
Wonderful video❤❤
I have that same problem with brush tips, but I love the lorac one...never have a problem with that one. Thought I was the only person in the world that hates the kat von d eyeliner
I don't really use pen eyeliners because 1. They always always are super difficult for me to apply because of my eye shape that's pretty similar to yours 2. They fade away very easily maybe because I've teary eyes and no matter what I do they still fade away. My all-time favourite would be gel eyeliners but I'm quite shocked at tye results of today's video I'll definitely give it a try.
Thank you for doing this comparison, I was just trying to compare these myself last night. And I'm totally with you there on the Better than Sex mascara flaking on me, glad it's not just me!
This mascara sucks I was so annoyed as everyone said it was amazing for years
Beautiful per always Emily. Always enjoy your reviews!
I just checked on the net and the Too Faced eyeliner is not available in the UK yet 😢
I know it won't come out until tomorrow for the US (at Ulta) too so you're not alone!
Are my eyes playing tricks on me? I swear that Too Faced looks like it’s brown on your hand. Like a dark brown.
Hi emily pls review the mark Anthony shampoo for volume the one u bought new pls I want to try that shampoo but I’m waiting for ur review n thoughts on it plsss
Found this super helpful thanks!
Just a quick question to any Canadians, can we find “Catrice or L.A girl” products in Canada and if so where? ... thx 🤓🇨🇦
I can find Catrice at my Loblaws. You can also get it from the Shoppers website!
The darker black of the Benefit Roller eyeliner made your eye look brighter
The stila liquid liner pen.
Tu n'aimais plus le Pretty Easy de Clinique? Moi je me le suis procuré grâce à toi et je l'aime beaucoup! Ça serait bien s'il était un peu plus mat 😉
Oui je l'aime toujours (c'est vrai qu'il pourrait être plus mat :P)! Meme chose pour celui de Stila, mais ces deux ci sont nouveaux donc j'étais curieuse de voir s'ils étaient bons ou non!
Ouais c'est sûr 😉 Non je disais ça parce que tu disais avoir de la difficulté avec les eyeliners avec une pointe en pinceau 😊 Mais le Stila, je l'ai déjà essayé et je ne suis pas capable d'avoir un trait assez fin et il "skippait" aussi!
C'est mon exception (avec TF maintenant!)
Stila a maintenant une version mini, je ne peux plus m'en passer!
Je pense que je vais essayer le Too Faced maintenant 😉 Moi aussi j'avais des réserves parce que le mascara Better Than Sex s'effrite pour mou aussi! 😂
Thank you for making this video!!!!!
Thanks for sharing! 😘😘
may you be blessed ma'am👑
Thanks!!
I love your videos
Hooded brows girl
The too faced !brush tip everyday
I’m trying to find an eyeliner that dries down matte, not glossy. Any suggestions? c:
Milani and Sephora both have a liquid 24h liner that are very matte!
I love bobby brown pot eyeliner. Super dark matte black.
Jenn B Anything as long as it’s matte. I have very oily eyelids. :/
BeautywithEmilyFox Thank you!! ❤️ We don’t have Milani in Asia but I’ll try my luck with the Sephora one.
Noor Azimah I’m more comfortable with liquid pens but thank you for sharing!
If only BTS...x mascara had a different formula!!!!That brush is the BEST!!!So I hate Too Faced!!!
benefit and two faced always seem to be competing with eachother, the products ive noticed go head to head were the roller lash and the bts and now they have competing eyeliners 🤔
I love your hair....beautiful....😍😍
The real question is: Is it actually better than sex? 🤔
💖💖💖
😊😊😊💞👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽