Undertale Genocide Package - Star
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 окт 2017
- Socials: motiproductions.carrd.co/
Frequently Asked Questions: bit.ly/moifaq
Song Ballot: bit.ly/MOISongForm
Help us fund ambitious projects like this for a dollar a month! / manontheinternet , ko-fi.com/manontheinternet
---
Track 8/10 for the Genocide Package from Man on the Internet.
Credits:
Music by Toby Fox
Chara: Eissibee ( / eissibee ) ( / theissiebean )
Lyrics by Alex Beckham ( / alexandervonkoopa )
Special Thanks to Lindsay Bolin (mloreley.tumblr.com) ( / magicklorelai )
Mix by Steel (0chromat.tumblr.com) ( / @stelyost )
(drive.google.com/file/d/0B4uD...)
Art by Lindsay Bolin (mloreley.tumblr.com) ( / magicklorelai ) and Kristen Trawczynski (miss-goggles.tumblr.com)
Art (Without Lyrics) can be found here: www.dropbox.com/sh/giiwbbuqgc...
Visit our social media!
/ manontheinternet
/ monetproduction
/ user-812591599
/ manontheinternetproduc... 
Видеоклипы
FOR THOSE WHO WILL INEVITABLY ASK: "Star" is an unused track. It was supposed to play in the CORE if you stood against a Madjick's chaser orb attack long enough to make the attack turn into hearts that recover health. It messed with the regular CORE background music and caused errors, so Toby removed it. So yes, not related to Chara. However, some fans theorize that Star was originally meant to be Chara's theme. There isn't any real confirmed evidence of this in the game or from Toby Fox. That being said, Chara is the name of the second brightest star in the constellation "Canes Venatici". If you google the “Star is Chara’s theme” theory, there’s some fun stuff that isn’t necessarily supported by canon and no, I am not going to type the whole theory out in this youtube comment. TL;DR Star is often associated with Chara in fanon, along with the obvious buttercups and the heart locket.
ANYWAY on to this song. So uh. This is my absolute favorite song on the scratch track list. When the scratch tracks came out in April, I was BEYOND hyped. So I went through the songs one by one, and when I got to Star I was absolutely blown away. I had been working on illustrations for a book at the time, and when it came to this one, I had no choice but to stop what I was doing and just listen while the song overtook me. I kept playing it over and over. By the second listen I had dozens of images in mind, but the one that stood out strongest was the picture of Chara with all the constellations and the game menu circle. I had to stop everything I was doing and draw it, I couldn’t NOT. Everything about it came so naturally, it was a burst of inspiration like I haven’t felt in years. That only continued when I got to work with Lore on the rest of the art, we both adore this song and it was such a treat to get to work together. I just adore the way Lore draws both Chara and Frisk, illustrating their differences while still making their connection obvious-- I love Chara's shoes so much. Also the way Lore draws legs, hands, faces, and hair is just delightful and I ADORE how her pictures of the starry sky came out. I love the subtle red coloring to Chara's hair and eyes while still making them look natural. The mirror image is also great, it’s just such a good concept. The star backgrounds on Lore's pieces are so beautiful, the shot of Chara with their hands turned upwards as they look at the audience has SUCH GREAT COLORS and I adore it so much. Also Alex, the little touch of static in Chara’s eyes when they switch to the creepy face is just SO GOOD.
It’s been months and I’m still listening to this song almost daily, and I’m BEYOND excited that other people get to hear it as well. Eissibee really knocked this one out of the park, the scratch track is beautiful but GOD Eissibee’s voice. The way they hit such high, clear notes gives me chills The opening of the song just feels so sharp and clear, crisp, it feels to me like Chara has finally found their voice and is ready to speak. The opening with Chara’s story, “hoping that someone would find me” says so much right there. They threw themselves down for a very sad reason, but deep down, they wanted to be loved, they wanted someone to find them and be there for them. And then just as quickly as they open that chapter of their life, they close it, “it’s over now”, like they had this one moment of honesty and now they can’t bring themselves to go deeper into details. They fell, they were found, there was a life but it’s done now and there’s no point in discussing it further.
The first point where the song hits that dark note that seems so vast and wide, that weird thrum that you can feel deep in your chest, it just hits so perfectly with “When they call my name, the demon comes, but am I to blame? I tried to be good, I really did.” This is my ABSOLUTE FAVORITE part in the song, the sheer remorse in “I tried to be good” that comes from Eissibee’s voice, the way these lines drive home just how badly Chara wanted to do the right thing. How this line right here debunks the “Chara was always a demonic villain”, how this one line humanizes them so thoroughly. The sorrow in how Eissibee sings “Not sure I could”, how it echos the hinted fact that they fell for a sad reason, how that one line seems to hint that Chara has always worried deep down they could never be a good person.
“Leaving two worlds broken, unfurled” is such a beautiful line, the acknowledgement that Chara knows by doing what they did, in spite of their best efforts, they truly believe they ruined what the Underground was. They didn’t just screw things up on the surface, they screwed up below as well. I adore the way “take” in “couldn’t take anymore crying” is barked out, that small bit of frustration with Asriel in that single line. The way that line can reference how they clearly pushed Asriel to not cry over this and not let his emotions get in the way of their plan, but then the fact that it’s just “crying” in general can also reference their own buried emotions on the subject. “Been disposed of” is just such a low line after everything else, so plainly spoken of, and it’s such a sharp contrast with the hard line of “Learned about LOVE”, the broken mention of “stars slowly dying”. I feel like this line speaks more to the stretch of time, of waiting, and then there’s such LONGING in Eissibee’s voice in “I once knew light, burning bright, shadows invade.” I adore the line “I’ve lost the dawn, sunlight’s gone”, how BROKEN these words sound, how wonderfully they echo the dramatic language of the original musical and how the dawn and sunlight were constant references.
I love the transition after this where Chara states their determination, the harshness in the words “There’s no point now.” It’s such an excellent statement of the moment where they give up, that there’s nothing they can do, and then the way that twists to “I finally see neither world cares for me.” When you’re that deep in the hole, when everything feels so hopeless, eventually it feels like there’s no choice but to lash out. Even if they put themselves there, it’s so easy for that to get twisted, and it hurts because OF COURSE the Underground cared for Chara and of course Asriel cared but it wasn’t enough to save to them and look, no one really knew them anyway. It’s the moment where their pain goes from external to the knives turning outward, they are in so much pain and they can’t see anything else anymore. I love how final “no one can stop me now” is, how it’s sung with a bit of a flourish. It feels like Chara planting their feet on the ground, as if they’re going “FINE, screw it, this is who I am, I accept it.”
“No hopes, no dreams, I have nothing. Death is all that can define me.” This line is sung with such pain, it seems so bitter, it’s such a stark contrast to the original UTM and it hurts. “Death is all that can define me” is SO GOOD. 'This is all I was good for in life and this is all I am good for now' Chara says. They wanted to do good, but in the end, all they can do is hurt people. The finality to “the end’s calling, no more stalling” is so good but then in the end Chara’s voice shakes on “Stars will fade, but I’ll keep shining”, as if they too are burning out in this single moment of brilliance.
...Suffice to say, this song means so much to me. It captures the feeling of self-destruction so well. It’s a song about how Chara feels they got a second chance and they squandered it. It’s a song about how far they’ve fallen, how they could have done it right but they didn’t and they’re in so deep now, there’s no crawling out now. It’s a song about crying out from the lowest point and it hurts so much because they put themselves there and they know they did. There is so much regret and pain in every line, moments of hope, moments of loss. There is depth and a sense of time passing, just this all-encompassing vastness of the starry sky and it makes Chara’s voice seem so small against it. This isn’t a song about Chara the demon, this isn’t all those evil giggles and mocking villain speeches against our heroic sans undertale. This is a song about Chara the PERSON, and it means so much to me. I just. I dunno. Something about the line “I tried to be good, I really did” nearly brings me to tears every time. I know that feeling, kid, it’s okay.
Dear lord this comment is nearly as long as my Bring It In, Guys comment. Sorry I just. This song means everything to me-- not just because Undertale. This song makes me see myself in Chara, and that is SO important. The Genocide route doesn’t happen because you were taken over by some demon. It happens because… well, you’re human.. Humans fall sometimes and when you’re in that deep, it’s so easy to feel like there’s nowhere to go and even the stars have faded. This song is about that moment where it feels like your mistakes have swallowed you and it’s very poignant to me.
Okay I’ll shoosh now. But um. Thank you for making this, MOTI crew. This is one of my favorite songs of all time.
"This is way too long I'll never read it blah blah and miss out greatly on this in depth character analysis and adorable gushing and sweet words over something that someone put so much time into because my time is so valuable that I'm going to waste it by telling you that I'm not gonna read your comment"
haha ilu
Please pin this
Kristen Trawczynski I love your essay You get an A+
That's a long comment ._.
Kristen Trawczynski The Stars represent the Monsters. When you kill one, another star flickers out of existence.
When they say “learned about LOVE!” You can hear a growl to the word learned. It's incredible.
Pretty sure that was a mistake with her throat.
@@justyouraveragegamerx1495 no way it was, why would they have kept it in? that was an intentional growl
@@tealwashablemarker8886 Bro I forgot I even made this comment lol
If you want to hear growls, listen to megalovania
I love the regret and pain you can hear in Chara's voice because it really highlights them as a character. They're not the main "villain" of Undertale, they're not a sadistic, crazed knife murderer, they're a traumatized kid who doesn't think they will ever have love-- or even deserve it. And didn't their death just prove them right? Now, they know that no one is going to be there for them except for themself. No one is ever going to push them down again, because they've made themself unstoppable.
Kelly W. I know right people need to stop makeing him out as the bad guy wheb you the player stated the genocide route to begin with.
Edit wheb to when
People mostly blame Chara due to Genocide Route but they dont know whats the cause, also it happens on Asriel too. Its because its been a long time feeling no love (Not the Lv of Violence tho)or any other feelings, it is like when a person has gone really mad, they forgotten who they were and they became different.
Well I guess its due to insanity what had cause Chara gone mad.
Mostly likely the villain is the *Player* (Aka us.) *=\*
Fun Fact: Chara is an Irish name that means Star. (It also means Friend and it has some other meanings in other languages)
It also comes from "character"
And what colored shirt is Chara wearing? (stripe discounted)
And in Polish it's Punishment (when pronounced Khara)
WOW
Reading all these comments... Wow, Chara is a really dynamic character.
I’m . . . actually in tears. This song just captures who Chara is perfectly.
They’re a troubled child who went through something _so horrible_ on the Surface, they wound up hating their own species altogether. They climbed Mt. Ebott for an “unhappy reason,” potentially suicide, but then, Asriel found them. They had a family, they had a best friend, and they were loved by all of monsterkind, and yet their attempt to pay back that kindess not only put themself through an agonizing death, it got their brother killed, it split apart their parents, and it essentially destroyed the kingdom.
And now Frisk’s here.
And so are *_you._*
Sure, you have the ability to achieve the happy ending Chara tried so hard to give everybody without killing anyone. They helped you with their snarky narration, and now that the job’s done, they can presumably rest in peace.
But, of course, you can also slaughter everyone they know and care about.
At first, they were so confused. Why are you doing this? _Why were they brought back to life for _*_this?_*
But, well, they’re a child. Children are impressionable. So this must be the right thing to do. There’s no other reason why you’d do this, right?
After a while, they begin to *enjoy* it. They say that Monster Kid looks like “free EXP”, they demand to know where the knives are, and they even make a few kills themself.
And then, at the end, you finally meet them.
They thank you for showing them the purpose of their new life. They congratulate you for doing what they now think is right. They offer to erase the world, because now that everybody’s dead, there’s nothing left for them here.
And then you refuse.
They’re in shock. You just killed everybody, even their mom. They killed their dad to appease you. You even made them kill their brother in one last fit of violent rage.
And that is the straw that broke the camel’s back. They _turn on you_ because you just killed their whole family, and now you’ve just admitted that there wasn’t even a reason. From now on, they hate you and everything you stand for.
Good going, asshole, you broke a ten-year-old.
Wow.... Man that's deep.
Chara didn't kill Asgore, Flowey did. But otherwise, you're spot on.
You Understand me =D
I always thought that Chara was the one killing all the monsters. The person who’s doing it all is *Y O U* Chara took over in the end, they wanted it to stop so the only way they thought to end it all was to destroy the timeline.
Khloe G
Not to be a nit-picker on details, but it was kind of both the player and Flowey together that killed Asgore in the genocide run.
The player lands the first and already fatal strike. Which is followed by Flowey with his overkill bullet ring.
Man on the internet = the only channel who understood who Chara really is.
It's nice to see, and I'm really glad to see MOTI go that route, it really relieved me listening to that song. :) My group is doing something like that too and, well, you'll see. ;)
hows that going anyway, i was worried it might have died
+Ryan Williams Not in the slightest! :) In fact, if all goes according to plan EchoFlower Productions will have The Narrator's Musical's version of Your Best Friend put up on Halloween! (I know Halloween is on a weekday this year so it won't be on our weekly schedule day, which will likely be Saturday, but hey, why not put a creepy song up on a creepy day?) :)
Looking forward to it : )
More like MOTI: House of the biggest trolls.
There is an odd truth with the line "When the stars fade, I will keep shining".
The "stars" of the game, the characters we know and love, are dead. Chara remains.
The "star" of the game's narrative, its very story, is over. But the meta commentary of Chara remains.
Even when people will eventually get bored of the franchise, the fact that you are still playing more games with the same mentality of a genocide run is still true. Chara remains.
woah
3 years later, and Deltarune Chapter 2 behind us. This is funny in retrospective
when you play anything
the sadism that comes with blood
the satisfaction that comes from stats going up?
hi chara
"No one can stop me now.."
DON'T STOP ME NOW
Chara is having a bad time
ruclips.net/video/3ILdpuQMW74/видео.html
Emma T me too 😂
@@Koala990 and isn't having a ball.
DON’T. STOP. ME, CAUSE I’M _HAVING A GOOD TIME!_ *HAVING A GOOD TIME!!*
At least this channel doesn't consider Chara as "a Demon".
At least they still conserved the other aspect of the character, and why they get called "demon".
Literally, the entire fandom forgets this one specific line
Asriel: (name) was never a good person. I see that now...
Irl, I'm not the greatest person too... I did a lot of bad thing. But, I'm not a psychopatic murderer, ya know?
Last Year
Actually, the line was “Chara was never the greatest person.” He then proceeds to claim that Frisk is the friend that he wished he had.
The reason for this was because Frisk had the power to reset and fix their flaws and mistakes... making them look better by comparison.
Btw, Asriel never said he didn’t love Chara. He just idealised them too much. Same case with Undyne and Monster Kid. Kid just idealised her too much. But we all still love Undyne. So why can’t we show the same love to Chara...?
You people defend Chara's alignment as if you can't love a villain.
Ever heard of a lil' Marvel Comics/MCU Frost Giant turned Asgardian by the name of *_Loki?_*
@@SylvainCosmos go away with this mcu crap :/
What I personally want to know is, besides Chara and Frisk, just _who_ were the other six humans who fell into the Underground? What were they like before they fell in? What motivated them to scale a mountain that had a legend that stated that those who climb it never return? How did they die? Did they even have names? I know that there are several fan theories out there, but I want to hear it from Mr. Fox himself.
What I want to know, did they fight or show mercy?
Heracross X
They were all killed by Asgore. They all reached him, but none of them made it past him.
Asgore knows about resetting and saving. He reacts sadly when you die over and over, so the children might have tried to get past him. Soon enough, they would give up, and he'd collect their souls.
The snowball mini game also shows their soul colors and their traits. Justice, Bravery, Integrity, Patience, Kindness, and Perseverance.
Chara/Frisk is Determination.
The other souls were, Patience, Integrity, Kindness, Justice, Bravery and Perseverance. I don't know much but each patch of buttercups in the game is where a child died, I know that Justice died against Undyne and is the one that make here blind from her left eye with a bullet, Integrity died in Waterfalls stuck in sea weed and drowned but that's all I know. Each of them represents an object from the game, patience : Toy knife, Intergrity : the ballet shoes, Kindness : The skillet, Justice the empty gun, Bravery : The gloves and Perseverence : The notebook
An Echo In here
Yup. About as close as it gets. Since the other humans (at the time they had fallen) had the most determination (in the sealed confines of the underground, where nothing could escape), they could save and reset. We know that because of this power, they all made it to Asgore. However, why they gave up then and there is still a mystery. Could it have been out of guilt for the monsters? Or could Asgore have been too strong? (I doubt the latter because he was one of the easiest bosses to beat for me. However, in defense of that statement, I could say that Asgore was still fueled by rage then) Either way, we still know very little of them. And we probably never will know much more. However, we can understand a general idea of their personality, through their items and the omega flowey fight. Other than that, there isn't much else about it. Something else that we do know is that Flowey and the amalgamates have about as much determination as a normal human soul, seeing as determination was extracted from souls past captured.
no hopes,
no dreams,
_consumed_
*_by memes_*
Relatable
Oh hecc 😂
Do u no da whey to leave the memes
Yes 👌
melancholy starlight OMG😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I love the times where her voice cracks on the verge of tears, the genocide package brings so much emotion to it all. Megolovania is filled with actual rage and anger, with him giving his all to it. In this song, Star, you can hear the tears in her voice. Well done MOTI Team. You've really given this your all.
𝒴ℯ𝓈 𝒾 𝒶𝓂 𝒶 𝒻ℯ𝓂𝒾𝓃𝒾𝓈𝓉.
Isn't Chara non-bianary?
@@justkris1105 Source?
@@kawaiifun2264 They could be referring to Chara's voice actor.
@@justkris1105 When I asked for your source, I was asking for conformation/decisive evidence.
*as a person on the side of “chara isn’t evil, the player is” this song is a very nice example.*
Confusion Noises even tho they killed alphys and all the survivors had no care for any of the monsters just wanted to use them to get back at the humans and when 1 of them almost died she laughed
@@youthoughiwasanamebutitwas8263 does that make toreil a bad person when she was dying? Does it made snowdrakes dad a bad person for laughing at his sons failure but regretting it? DOES IT MAKE SNOWDRAKES MOM A HORRIBLE PERSON WHEN SHES IN PAIN. Chara tried laughing it off and when she saw how deadly buttercups are she ate them to try and save monster kind with a plan Asgore should’ve done
I agree! Everyone seems to excuse every other characters' awful deeds but only see Chara for the ones she hasn't done
@@youthoughiwasanamebutitwas8263 oh, it's ok to kill most of the population, but if you wanna kill off the few hundred (probably less) monsters left THAT'S too far?
@@manwith80dads29 that barely does make any sense tho
> "no hopes, no dreams, i have nothing. death is all that can define me"
excuse me while i cry over this line because it really showcases that the genocide run really takes everything away. they sound so resigned when they sing it.
whether it's their own death or the death of other people, that's all chara thinks they're good for now, causing death. there's no point in trying to stop it, it's literally impossible for them so they've had to resign to their fate to deal with it.
i really really love this song because it really shows how tragic their situation is and how determined they are to think that causing death is their only purpose in life now, and it's like nothing i've seen the fanbase do for chara before.
sparklingdemon they looked like they enjoyed it in the game "that was fun let's finish the job" and that they didn't want to stop the hate and the dying "the comedian got away. failure"
well, if anything, it definitely shows how far they've fallen from the kid who once offed themself just to free all monsters.
the effects of LOVE are very powerful. LOVE is "a way of measuring someone's capacity to hurt. the more you kill, the easier it becomes to distance yourself. the more you distance yourself, the less you will hurt. the more easily you can bring yourself to hurt others."
and that feeling of LOVE increasing goes straight to chara.
this isn't like flowey who willingly did it, chara was dragged along for the genocide run and had to accept their role in it.
not denying the possibility of chara enjoying murdering people, but when you don't have a choice you'll do anything to cope with the situation, even if that means laughing it off.
sparklingdemon they don't say "EXP LV HP ATK DEF G every time a number increases i become Eviler" they say "EXP LV HP ATK DEF G every time a number increases that's feeling that's me chara" they weren't saying that they become corrupted by some soul bonding non-sense their no such thing in the game called "link through Determination" what they saying is that they are the feeling that you get when your EXP,LV HP etc increase
- Flowey was awakened through the DT from the six human souls but they weren't effected by his LOVE even when he absorbed them
-also how it's Frisk's DT that a awakened chara? with asriel he needed to have DT that was extracted through injected in the flower that his essence was infused with. all of what Frisk has done was fall with (physical body not soul or DT) on the golden flowerbed that was on chara (so they didn't even tach them let alon inject them with any thing) and even if that what had happened chara would be soulless sense DT revive people without their soul and thus evil (regardless of how they ware revived chara is likely soulless sense they can take your soul and they can poss frisk on multiple cases
AW98 you don't show them LV. the LV you gain in genocide only goes to you as frisk
"YOU earned (?) exp and (?) G"
"YOUr LOVE increased
In the game you can look at your stats, now, in your stats you can see your LV, Hp, Gold, Weapon, Armor... and Chara's (or however you named them) name. This shows that SOMEHOW your LV ,EXP, etc goes to Chara and not you, somehow even your armor is displayed there.
No matter how you put it, either Chara is the one suffering from the LV Frisk gains, or it's Frisk's stats with Chara's name on it which leaves us with nothing to blame Chara anymore since they aren't involved.
See, I have read the diaglogues and theorized with people a lot and I think that Chara has no real evil to them. While I can't prove Chara to be good, I can prove that they aren't completely evil: After completing genocide multiple times (forgot how many) Chara says something along the line of "Maybe another path would be suited better" meaning that they want you to stop doing genocide.
Also Chara "was the hope of the entire underground" and "was like a sibbling to the prince" which we can both agree, isn't anything you would say about a bad person.
Chara is like most characters in Undertale good AND bad, with flaws and some good things to them, this goes for everyone, no matter if Flowey or Papyrus, everyone has a side to them you can like, and some bad things to them, why would Chara be an exception?
In the end I have to say 2 more things:
1.: It is up to you how you see Chara and what you think of them, but please don't try to prove that you are right, every argument you have against them can be countered by a fact that speaks for Chara and counterwise
2.: This comment is way to long and I put a lot of spelling mistakes in it becouse English is not my first language and I am really tired, sorry!
This song is unused but it fits really well
@@Gabs-bags technically he IS killing Frisk
@@Gabs-bags Frisk is genderless.
@@LukeSaward The gender of frisk is up to the person who makes a comic and includes them or speaks of them while frisk is genderless people can still say what gender they believe or want them to be
Plus it’s catchy
Chara Dreemurツ it’s the player not frisk
I like this song, it gives more depth to Chara's character. Not to mention Elise's vocals give Chara life. Good job!
EmberTheVixen a.k.a Ember "Elise's voice gives life to chara" the irony
الحسن يوسف XD
EmberTheVixen a.k.a Ember soo true, I adore her voice!!
Elise!!!!!
(Sonic 06 reference)
*blood pours out of chara’s eyes*
“I finally seeeeeeeee”
Me: How can you see with blood in your eyes
[Inhale] welp... have a good after life.
found it
I don’t think it’s blood but rather a inky substance
@@runeday4784 I misread inky at first for... You know what I am going to stop speaking now.
Not blood, strange black stuff
You know, seeing all people rage, makes me actually hope that they jump over mega-you-know-what. Seriously, HOW CAN YOU PEOPLE IGNORE THESE OTHER MASTERPIECES JUST BECAUSE ITS NOT THE SONG YOU WANTED?
/rant
I know right.
/crash
R/annoyingpeople
holly i loved thissssssss. Chara is one of the best characters of undertale, combine this amazing character with a aweasome voice and MAN THE ART!!! you will get this piece of heaven
How's she an amazing character....she's kinda just evil cuz why not...and only appears like, 3 times?
She is an amazing character, that doesn't mean she's good. I love her backstory that they tell in the game, and the way they left to you think, chara was good but her past in the human world was so freaking horrible or she is just evil because she wants(I don't like this idea)
Piece of heaven? Wouldn't it technically be a more lighter shade of hell?
Chara has no actual gender.
• Michael Mell. • my bad
"Stars will fade, but I'll keep shinning"
That's poetic if you ask me
This was obviously unintentional since it came out before then, but "power of will" and all the references to "shining" make for interesting parallels to some of the language used in Deltarune, especially considering how Kris is so similar to Chara.
Yeah. I think Kris is an untold story of Chara. We really know little about Chara in Undertale but they weren't real focus of the game. Toby had an Idea for Deltarune before undertale was made so probably they are kinda the same with similiar issue and personality.
@bruhmanofyear2647 I have an alternative theory. Deltarune seems like exactly the kind of world Chara would want - monsters live happily on the surface, their brother is alive, and aside from them, there isn't a human in sight. Furthermore, there's a couple of other facts to consider - at the end of the genocide route, Chara says "Let us destroy this world and move on to the next." Then, they later recreate the world in exchange for our soul. This leads me to believe that Deltarune is actually a direct sequel to Undertale's genocide route, where Chara uses determination to create their idea of a perfect world, then assumes a new name that the player didn't choose - Kris - as a way to distance themselves from us. This theory would explain a lot of things. Firstly, viewed through this lense, Chara's motivation on the genocide route makes much more sense. Certainly they aren't exactly happy with the world in Undertale, but it doesn't make sense that they would support us killing the very monsters that showed them so much compassion in life just to destroy it - unless, of course, their real goal was to create a new world where those same monsters could be happy. It also explains why Chara turns on us if we choose not to destroy the world - they assumed that destroying the world and creating a new world and creating a new one was our goal from the start, so when they discover that that wasn't the case - that we intend to leave behind a world where everyone is dead - they recognize just how evil we are and assume control. Furthermore, this is also why we take control of them in Deltarune - their soul is, after all, the one we gave them - and part of why they are so resistant to that control. Not only are we violating their autonomy, they're also afraid that we'll ruin the perfect world they've created just like we did to Undertale.
"ADLKANSDALSKNDASKLNDASKLB YOU LIED YOU SAID MEGALOVEGALO WAS NEXT YOU LIED TO US I HOPE YOU DIE"
No, I never said that.
"BUT ON STAR-"
I said I added "MEGALOVANIA IS NEXT" and similar phrases to the spam filter because so many people weren't actually watching the videos and were instead commenting that on every video, regardless of logical placement or not (like, come on people. Megalovania doesn't come after Papyrus' death.)
Those mothafockas need to shut da fuk up!
The question now is... Do we get a reprise of the beginning or do we get mogolovonio... or might we be surprised again. Also this was great it really caught me off guard.
This Comment Makes sense I Do Like Megalovania and i would like to see it but you are right they need to calm down megalovania is a good song but still there are other great songs like Power of Neo and Battle Against A True Hero
@DaRkKilLEr A song could be made for the "Since when were you the one in control?" scene.
DaRkKilLEr um.... I mean mettaton dies immediately. I guess he does have at least a song unlike asgore. But I hope megalovania is the last. It would be a GREAT finale. I'm so scared that they are gonna troll us again though but I'll stay optimistic, I'LL STAY DETERMINED
Hell yeah. This is my favorite song, and it was posted on my birthday.
. . .two years ago.
WHO CARES!?
coughs* dont mind me
dubstep45280 you coughed. Go isolate yourself from humanity and pray you don’t die, go insane, or both.
I really shouldn’t be joking about this type of thing... I occasionally get panic attacks because of it, btw my mom’s a nurse
y e s !
@@Artist-128 i got my coront test and it was negative uwu turned out i just had a chest infec
WHO CARES?!
WHO CARES?!
WHO CARES?!
-The Mad Dummy
This song really humanizes Chara in a way people misunderstand. I relate to them so much here. Feeling unloved, uncared for, like you have nothing left in your life, like there’s nothing for you here, like you’re swallowed up by helplessness and regret and the only thing you can do is keep standing.
0:54
Anyone else get the reference to Papyrus' message? You know, the one where he says that anyone can be a good person if they tried.
Holy hell! I didn't see this reference until i saw your comment, thanks dude :D
Thx for letting me know!
Im actually like chara because my name is also like a constellation "lyra"
And my name is Lyrah and i have anger issues and suicide wanting and i want to feel safe when i cry but someone keeps bothering me and im like a psychopath when im mad.
So it explains "Lyrah" the h means "hell" for how my negative pesonality is...
Im sorry if you people just ignore this this IS real. My real life.
Or probably Toriel, she told the player to be a *good* child......
Sans brings it up, too. Let's face it, it's a theme within the story.
Only a few seconds in and I have chills. This looks amazing.
I love Chara’s voice, Eissibee was amazing, and these lyrics are beautiful great job MOTI
Muffin Cat This feels...familiar.
It's the Chara song everyone's been waiting for!
The Calm Before The Storm...
You mean before MeGalov..... Right?
ToxicRadiation GF reference?
No dont speak the word this comment might be deleted
GET TO F##KING MEGALOVANIA ALREADY
Kobe Williams Not true, I've seen many comments looking for a chara song!
Here’s the lyrics:
I fell below.
Left the world I’ve known
Hoping that someone would find me
Life underground
It’s over now
When they call my name
The demon comes
I tried to be good
I really did
Not sure I could
Leaving two worlds
Broken, unfurled
Couldn’t take anymore crying
Been disposed of
Learned about LOVE
Lights above, from stars slowly dying
I once knew light
Burning bright
Shadows invade
I’ve lost the dawn
Sunlight’s gone
Left this dismal grave
I remain still
Power of will
Leaves me here to keep on trying
I know, somehow
There’s no point now
To try and stop the hate, the dying
I finally see
Neither world
Cares for me
I’ll stand my ground
No one can
Stop me now
No hopes, no dreams
I have nothing
Death is all that can define me
The ends calling
No more stalling
Stars will fade, but I’ll keep shining =)
Thanks creamcake now i know the lyrics
I know you didn't do much but thanks anyway
>The demon comes
>I tried to be good
You skipped a line there, it should be The demon comes, but am I to blame?
Copy and paste moment
The lyrics are literally shown in the video 💀
When the song said “no one can stop me now” I started to hear the police in my neighborhood
*hi, chara.
Chara go to jail
Chara be committing crimes
@@e.m1122 lol
@@e.m1122 for attenpted murder
Suspect got shot on sight with a goat man holding the child
*Two left*
Long Elevator and Groose's Theme.
John Sears thank you my child
I can see this.
The Groose is *LOOSE*
The Sloppy Seconds Bros.
Long Elevator but it's the most emotional song in the package.
The Genocide run's not Chara's fault, it's the people who press 'Fight' while playing Undertale. If it WAS Chara's fault, then I think their soul was filled with Hate mostly and just wanted to get over it.
@BIGSHOTCHEEMS wdym the player isn’t part of the lore? lmao if that was the case undertale wouldn’t exist
@@ren858 same for deltarune where we are legit showed kris knows we are there
“Hate” isn’t canon, Camila made it up
@@lasagna3289 yeah, technically they got the love from fights, shown by their name
@@lasagna3289 finally... Black dont mean hate, hate dont exist in the canon game there is only:
White upside down: monster soul
Red/gold: determination
Green: kindness
Blue: integrity
Light blue: patience
Purple: perseverance
Yellow: justice
And Orange: bravery
The way their voice cracks on “learned about love” is so visceral and haunting, I love this song so much
(I didn’t wanna say that cause it sounds like I’m calling out the singer, but I swear I mean this as a genuine compliment)
I especially like the line “When they call my name the demon comes but am I to blame?” I like it because it shows that most fans think Chara is just an embodiment of evil and hunger to kill but they are much more than that. I love the art and the circle with Chara in the middle. The vocals are phenomenal and I can’t really express how good they are because I’m just some loser leaving a dumb comment no one will read. I’ve real fell in love with the geno songs and I don’t know if it’s a good or bad thing. And yes like most people I was expecting The M-word but I was surprised by this new song id never heard and it took a couple listens to get the feel of the song and hear every word and I loved it. The reason it surprised me is that I didnt get the scratch tracks in April and didn’t hear any of these...
i dont know if im just dumb but what dose the M-word mean (im a kid please understand im a fricken idiot)
@@tammymomoftwo Murder
@@tammymomoftwo megalovania
It's been one year since this came out. It's been months since I last heard this song. It took seconds for me to love it even more than I did before. Guess we're two losers now leaving comments even though they are pretty sure they will get lost among the hundreds, if not thousands of other comments. But at least we said what we needed to say.
You just changed my mind..
Eissibee
You did an amazing job and reduced me to tears
That was the plan, unfortunately, I cannot cover insurance for tissues ;)
Ok, I can say this now that all of the genocide package is out. This one is my favorite of the genocide songs. I haven't even heard of it before you guys did it, but now I love it sooo much! I am sooo glad you did this unexpected song!
Same!!
It's an unused track
It's just so beautiful and broken in a way I've never heard in any other musical.
Love your channel miamouse :3 just saying
Most likely because it's an unused track
God, everytime Chara sings I just cry, I just love them so much
SAME
Julieta Yapura It gives depth and pity to the character.
Thanks🥰
Understandable
you fool i dont love myself
I'm glad Chara gets some more singing. I really love their voice.
me to
same
SO TRUE
nordic fatcheese I want to know who was singing...I wish I could sing like that
"I remain still, power of will, leaves me here to keep on trying. I know, somehow there's no point now, to try and stop the hate, the dying"
This has to be my favorite line in the track since at least in my interpretation of it, it represents the determination in every human being, and how no matter the aching disparity, or the confusion and dissonance within ourselves that agony causes we still move on.
Even if there is no point; the lyrics later bring on a sort of umbra, as Chara sings that there is no point in trying to stop the hate and the "dying". In their character this shows the gradual change brought in from their feelings of abandonment and failure. Even in the sense of the game no matter what you're determination will keep pushing you to the end for better or for worse no matter what's in the way. Lastly, death is not only seen as the end of something but the beginning as well, its so interesting how the idea of continuing and death come consecutive to each other in this line :D
I love this tune ;~;
Something I bet you didn't notice, both napstablook and Chara spoke of "losing the dawn"
Everyone in the fandom: Gaster is so mysterious!!!
Star: Am I a joke to you?
I wonder how many parents got mad when they saw the "when they call my name, the demon comes."
My mom will not care lmao
Who the fuck is watching this with their parents
@@zhiracs Nah, it's because parents have a seventh sense called: "Being able to hear everything and anything in their house"
2:12
Chara looks like she's playing rock, paper, sissors with herself
😂😂😂😂😂
MineBloxGaming Pie she’s that lonely
İs chara girl
No but serously😄👏✋👊✌
@@cips35 Chara's gender is not confirmed, but in MOTI's version of Undertale Chara's a girl
KRISTEN YOUR ART IS AMAZING AAAAA I'M SO PROUD OF YOU
Don't reply to people who are banned, Cello
People these days. The fact that someone would even think of that is just sad.
Man on the Internet touché Alex, touché.
Kristen is a blessing on this world.
Cellochicita I didn't see the comment but i can guess what it was about and i agree some b*****s like those don't understand anything...it's just maddening and sad......i'm so happy Alex banned them.....
This song gave me chills. It shows how unstable Chara is and how broken she is. It makes me shiver when she starts to break.
Even Chara needs their song, and damned if it isn’t one of the most heartbreaking
That was fantastic! Well done!
Was I the only one who expected a jump scare at the end?
Eh+ Gamer nope it's chara we all expected it
Bruh.
Sans, Flowey and Asgore are still alive and Frisk still did not refuse to erase.
So no Chara Jumpscare for now.
But I'm legit hyped for Sans and Asgore
I feel like that would have ruined the point of Chara's utter regret and suffering the song conveyed, so I'm glad there was no jumpscare.
Ferox don't forget about Alphys! ( Sorry she's my favorite character and I don't like it when people seem to put her in a shadow)
+CP93 Archive .... *headdesk* Dumb typo. XD
Wow...I've never actually heard this track, thanks Kristen for explaining. That's amazing that you incorporated it, and it's really warmed on me. I smiled hearing Eissibee after so long who knocked the performance out of the park, and it's amazing to finally see Kristen's art here, she and Lore did a great job :D
QueenCreeps Yep
Here’s my theory. Maybe they were suffering from abuse. One hint may be when you check the faded ribbon:
If you're cuter, monsters won't hit you as hard.
That may imply Chara was abused by humans, and that's what caused them to hate the humans in their village.
People may say Chara was abused by their parents, but the faded ribbon description may imply chara was abused by everyone in their village. Referring to the line in this song “Couldn’t take anymore crying”
Another line that refers to this song is
Greetings. I am . "." The demon that comes when people call its name. Meaning the line in this song makes sense.
But the buttons turning into just fight means our control because we forced a 10 year old kid to see her friends and family die.
Of course another one of those "abuse theories", what's the point of even making these anymore? So many people have already made them. It's getting beyond repetitive.
I MADE THIS A YEAR AGO 💀
Yeah, this is actually my story. Gg
@@charadreemurr1759 goh dayum
?
"Chara hated humanity. Why they did, they never talked about it. But they felt very strongly about that.
Maybe...the truth is...Chara wasn't really the greatest person.
They were the one who picked up their own empty body. And when we got to the village, they were the one who wanted to...to use our full power."
-Asriel Dreemurr
Can anyone really blame Chara for hating humanity? Humanity in general really sucks and in that universe humanity waged war on the monsters and locked them all underground and they probably don't treat other humans that well either like in real life.
@@ZaxorVonSkyler that isn't an excuse for wanting to kill all the humans
@@ZaxorVonSkyler, there are such persons. But they are fundamentally wrong. In addition to irrational fear and racism, humans drove Chara to attempt suicide. And who knows what the reason for the fall of the rest of the people.
@@ZaxorVonSkyler That was like a thousand years ago. While it is true that humanity as a whole is oppressive, the goal of any racial advocacy movement should be equality and liberation, not revenge that only perpetuates the cycle of violence. Anyway, it's not as if monster society is any utopia either.
Humanity hate the things they dont understand or trying to understand
I've been avoiding these genocide tracks for weeks and I suddenly came back today too see how you guys are doing and holy moly
this is a blast
Star is honestly my top fave yet
There's lots of genocide songs, most of them are just hard loud rock n roll music, that actually not covering up the word "genocide" itself...
This one gives us an opportunity to HEAR the TRUE genocide that happens inside Chara's mind, understand why they do it, what they're going through inside...Feels heavy actually, but I like it
Just Nixey how can a soulless bodiless creature "feel"?
Especially Megalovania ot was heavy metal
@@user-rc1vb1ho7m Chara is not souless, they just became corrupt
@@user-rc1vb1ho7m ;------;
@@user-rc1vb1ho7m i have a soul
I'm glad you went with a good Chara, or one that was originally good. Good Chara has so much more depth and is supported by more evidence such as Chara outright saying that YOU taught her that killing monsters was the right thing to do.
There’s no such thing as “good” or “evil” Chara.
Chara uses they them.
I agree that we teached chara to kill monsters
But for me chara is neutral
I still respect your opinion by the way
AGAIN, it's Chara's fault AND your fault, Chara kept track of how many Monsters to kill, and you killed them.
@@bruhmanofyear2647And how do you know that?
Now the UT fandom may be known as “oOoOoH yOu LiKe UnDeRtAlE? aRe YoU a SaNs FaNgIrL? dO yOu ShIp SaNs AnD pApYrUs? YoU kNoW tHeY’rE bRoThErS, rIgHt?” or something to that degree but _this_ is the kind of content that someone who takes the time to investigate if the fandom is that bad SHOULD find. It’s truly amazing and I love it, as do thousands of others. I hate that the worst side is shown in this fandom but then again I might be showing hypocrisy because there are other fandoms I only choose to see the bad side of -I admit it-
Onto the song, it’s perfect for Chara. Their voice is so... ominous and determined -hehe- and they have that perfect “yep my plan is going through perfectly” look on their face at the beginning. The lyrics truly describe their feelings of discrimination and hatred for humanity that they are implied to have (like the bow in the ruins). The music (I know MotI didn’t compose it but still) is scary to a point where it absolutely fits Chara better than just a theme in the CORE that one enemy type uses. If, instead of silence, Star was used at the end of Geno, it would likely have the same effect. And the lyrics near the end of the song are perfect for Chara in Geno. (The end’s calling. No more stalling. Etc.) It shows that they are ready to complete their plan and destroy your save, as well as the world and all of its inhabitants. They may be a child, but you, the player, have given them the power to do much more than possible before.
Edit: i was a dumb kid (I say lovingly, as I just simply didn’t know better), all pronouns have been changed to they/them rather than switching between he/him and she/her
but really, what has the undertale fandom become?
Pretty much ships of every undertale character with sans, papyrus or frisk, and stupid pictures of sans lying on a bed with his tongue out saying some sort of stupid flirty message
ThatMilesGuy Ikr!
@@ThatMilesGuy he has 27....
Sans denied the bonzone to all the fan girls already
*"She* may be a child, but you, the player, have given *him* the power to do much more than possible."
I see what you did there. (And everywhere else in your comment, this line was just a good example.)
I'm glad they took more time on chara. Remember you are the one who teaches them about LOVE and killing
"My 'determination', my 'human soul', they were not mine, but YOURS."
"... *You.* With *your guidance.* I realized the purpose of my reincarnation. Power. *Together,* we eradicated the enemy and became strong."
Finally someone defends the true
Moonfeather the Shiny
"EXP,LV,HP,ATK,DeF,G every time a number increases that feeling that's me Chara" "you helped me realize (as in "achieve") the purpose of my reincarnation" "the demon that comes when people call it's name" " that was fun let's finish the job" "the comedian got away. failure" "strangely feel there are 2 left, we shouldn't pursued yet"and they even have an evil laugh.
الحسن يوسف
Well, I didn't mean Chara is an innocent roll, I meant they're completely 'demon that comes when people call its name' and all that only during genocide.
They're helping you to achieve the genocide ending, but they doubt it's the right thing to do
" You and I are not the same, are we? This SOUL resonates with a strange feeling. There is a reason you continue to recreate this world.There is a reason you continue to destroy it. You. You are wracked with a perverted sentimentality. Hmm. I cannot understand these feelings anymore. Despite this. I feel obligated to suggest. Should you choose to recreate this world once more. Another path would be better suited."
But the LOVE and killing that they see happening corrupts them, and they turn evil. They kill Sans, Asgore and Flowey.
But it's all because of the player's actions. and even when the corruption doubled, from another genocide run, they still 'felt obligated to suggest another path'
This is my theory: In the start of the Genocide Route, Chara was just a spirit who was awakened in Frisk's body. At first, they did nothing; they just looked at things around them. However, Frisk started killing monsters, and this corrupted Chara making them evil. Because Chara lived inside Frisk, the corruption and evilness Frisk caused in Chara backfired at them and made them evil as well. So basically Frisk turned Chara into a demon, who then made Frisk an evil and emotionless killer.
You know what's funny? On my first playthrough of the game, BLIND playthrough, I named my character Star. It shook me as the game went on how much the named fits. Now I see this. Damn.
Doctor Guayo OH MY GOD
Doctor Guayo they have became bamboozled
When the History class about URSS is ending: "The end's calling, no more Stalin."
The voice actor for Chara is absolutely amazing. I love this song. It perfectly captures Chara as a tragic character and her descent into madness
Beautiful! My poor little Chara.
Chara was confirmed to be good by Temmie Chang.
Temmie Chang said "Nah, Chara is chill" (or something very close to that). No "They are nice" nor "They are bad". There is no good and bad in Undertale, everyone, no matter if Papyrus or Flowey is just good or bad, they all have both in them and you can hate or love every character for what they are, Chara has some very bad things speaking against them, but also some good ones that back the "Nice Chara" theory, yet (warning opinion) I think Chara is not worse or better than Asriel or Asgore are, surely not an angel but also not completely evil.
This again is just my opinion.
Ok.
Apricot The Werewolf Not really, it seems like a sarcastic response to a sarcastic question.
Rare Commenter same.
So far, this is my favorite from the genocide package. Eissibee's voice for Chara is incredible. Just wow...
I also love the artwork. Amazing work everyone!
Parents heard me harmonizing with the lyrics. They thought I was singing something messed up.
You are not alone, my parents think I'm really sadistic and/or depressed.
Why would they think you sang something messed up? It's a beautiful song!
To try and stop the hate, the dying
My dad has gotten used to it by now lol 😂
To be fair.. ya kinda were.
0:42 just had a thought. Chara never explicitly calls themself the demon that comes when people call its name. To quote Chara themself
"Greetings, i am Chara. Chara. The demon that comes when people call it's name"
Chara isn't explicitly saying they're the demon, rather that the demon's name is the one you chose.
When you play any video game, you often insert your own name. As such, you are the demon, you simply share a name with the fallen child in every timeline and will always come because of that
*Notification pops up*
Me: AH IT'S FINALLY HERE IT'S H-
*Sees the Chara thumbnail*
Me: Wait... This isn't Megalovania... This ISN'T Megalovania... WHAT-
*Watches video*
This is even better than Megalovania.
Savannah Harris yes
yup
We will see
I was happy it wasn’t Megalovania because I hate Megalovania
Just some MTT Fangirl Honestly I was more excited for BAATH but the realisation that Megalovania was coming soon got me hyped
This is absolutely, breathtakingly beautiful and sad. I totally second everything Kristen said, and I love that you portray Chara as a broken, confused child rather than a demon like so many shallowly do. Eissibee really did an incredible job and captured Chara's emotions perfectly; I love how she enunciates certain words and how her voice breaks as Chara gets emotional and breaks as Frisk/the player kills everyone they loved, and they're finally pushed past the brink of believing and hoping for goodness and love and accepting the hate and LOVE that Frisk/the player has forced into their hands. Man, this song makes me emotional... could we by chance get a song Chara sings/takes part in post-pacifist? I really want to see them happy like they deserve.
Anyways, thank you so much, MOTI, for delving into Chara's personality and character and portraying them so amazingly well; this is by far one of my top favorite Undertale songs. I'm really so happy that you gave Chara their own song; they certainly deserve it for the huge part they play in Undertale. Thank you. ^^
Zuriel Productions chara knows about resets she probably had that power when they ware alive since they ware the only one with noticeable amount of determination at the time and she is likely to know that frisk have that power since they likely died multiple times which she remember that because (even more likely in genocide ware their are the two hard battles against undyne and sans how mentions many times that he had killed you Multiple times) which means that if chara doesn't want the world to erased why don't they just wat until you reset unkilling everybody what she does however is keep sure that you kill everyone in the area "18 left" "strangely feel 2 are left we shouldn't pursued yet" getting you to hire LV possible so you loss control over yourself and your save file for them to gain it. they describe herself as the feeling that you get when your stats increases "EXP LV HP ATK DEF G every time a number increases that feeling that's me chara" they are basically the embodiment of hunger for power. morale of the story? you do not control hunger for power,hunger for power control you. oh their is also this asgore dreemurr=Gore as murderer asriel deemurr=serial murderer chara dreemurr=friends murderer ("chara" means "friend" in Irish)
Yeah; there's a fair bit of evidence in-game supporting the fact that Chara had the ability to RESET and such, and the other fallen children had that power too to an extent at least too.
Are you trying to say that Chara's at fault for the genocide run? Forgive me if I'm wrong; your run-on sentence isn't very clear to me on what exactly you mean. And yes, of course Chara helps you, no matter which run you do; as she explains after a geno run, she was so confused as to why she was "alive" again, but then you, the player, showed her her purpose. She didn't decide to kill everyone or spare everyone or a mix of both; you did. As she clearly states, YOU teach her why she's come back, so she helps you obtain your goal.
Zuriel Productions
-no i didn't say that chara is to blame for everything in genocide (which is more like omnicide to be honest ) but they are the reason why it is permanent. also they destroy the genocide survivers and humanity but a big part of blame is on genocide players because they give them the power that they needed to.
-chara had possibly done naturel run when they still had their soul since they seem to have experience with EXP LV HP etc
-we don't corrupt we just let them corrupt us. the more LV you gain the more you distance yourself the less control you have over yourself the Easier it is to controlled by chara who is "EXP LV HP ATK DEF G every time a number increases that feeling that's me chara" which is why they Gian full control over frisk at LV 20.
Ah, okay.
Of course Chara makes it permanent; as she pretty much states, she wants us to know that we're not above consequences for destroying practically everyone in the Underground. Also, you can bail from a genocide run without any consequences at any point in time before you kill Flowey; Chara's giving you a ton of chances to turn back before it's too late. Another thing; there is no evidence whatsoever in the game that Chara wanted power.
There's no evidence about that, but sure. I'm pretty certain that Chara has knowledge of LV, EXP, etc. because of Frisk/the player, but that's my opinion.
You've said that before. You realize it's Chara's name on the save file and not Frisk's, right? Those aren't Frisk's stats; they're Chara's (she was telling you that), which also shows you how violent she was in life (LV 1 with 0 EXP, so, not violent at all).
I don't want to argue with you and I doubt any minds will be changed, so can we just leave it at the fact that we have differing opinions? You can't change my mind on the subject here.
Zuriel Productions
no i wont stop! i am
DETERMINED
-chara's name is on the save file to misled us to think that the name we give at the start of the game is for our character
-they can't fully control us and erase the world unless we are LV 20 so they aren't really "giving us chance" they would hate us anyways even if they still had their soul because we are humans even in pacifist
-if they are "corrupted" then why do they want to punish us
-are you saying that in the soulless pacifist they punish us for killing monsters by killing monsters and in the genocide ending punish us for killing monsters by killing the survivers and the entire human race?
Player: *Kills everyone in the underground*
Also Player: "How could Chara do this"
Chara: Hold on, this whole operation was your idea!
Fck player
AGAIN, it's Chara's fault AND your fault, Chara kept track of how many Monsters to kill, and you killed them.
@bruhmanofyear2647 Why do you think so?
@bruhmanofyear2647 Deltarune might not have an in-universe narrator, or it might be narrated by Gaster or the person who says "Will now be discarded. No one can choose who they are in this world.".
There doesn't need to be the same save file narrator between games. If they are the same between games, it doesn't have to be the player.
Thank you for answering.
What is "the player"?
Why is my comment wrong?
I love how this shows Chara as who they are rather than the monster people make them out to be.
I am no monster, thanks for that😃😃😃😺
Yeeeeesss I was looking forward to this song. Not only do we get to hear Eissibee SHINE for an entire song (you have such a lovely voice and I love Undertale in part because it gave Chara a chance to sing) but it's also a really *interesting* song??? As it's an unused track, and I'm generally not the kind of fan to dig up all the secrets hidden in the games files (props to those who *do* it's pretty interesting stuff. Apparently there was another dog-guard and a female guard pair?) so I probably never would have heard this haunting track. It's very...forlorn sounding, with the echoing tones totally fitting with the sort of void-y space vibe the artwork seems to have gone with. The lyrics are great, beginning to start with Chara's loss and listlessness, they had willingly taken the plunge, only to find a new life, but that life is long over and chara is resigned to this emptiness and nothingness that is their existence. One where the only thing they know how to do is to destroy everything they cared about. Originally, yes, it was unintentional, and borne of a pure desire to free the monsters and save their family. But that decision led to their own death and the death of one they cared for.
Now all they have is this emptiness. All they have are the darkness and the stars. They were brought out by the acts created in the geno run, and it became the only thing that could reach them. The only thing they could do to effect the world beyond the mirror. It's all they have left. The only thing they can reach is this broken world.
Is it really their fault? I love that you ask that question. They aren't the one pushing the plot forward. They aren't the one who made that decision. Whether or not you ascribe to the narrator theory, the geno run is the only one where chara appears. Only when the human (and the player) decide to go down the route of violence does chara find the strength to stand on their own. Only then do they find the agency to take their fate in their own hands. They'll "stand their ground / no one can stop me now." They've died. They have nothing beyond that. I love how this last section is at the same time shaky, but also you can clearly hear the resolve in Eissibee's voice as Chara firmly decides on the path they are going to take.
I think this is a great point in the game for this song, actually. Originally I was a tad thrown off because the mirror scene obviously takes place in new home, and we hadn't yet made it to the judgement hall but then I looked up a map, and Asgore's home (where the It's Me mirror is located) is actually before the judgement hall. Plus thematically it's very important, as it's directly after Flowey's song, where he explained his motivations and backstory. It's only fair that Chara gets their voice heard, and since it's the one place where we find their related items (my locket. my knife. my bed.) it's just...the most fitting point. And it's also passed the point of no return.
OKAY. Now the art. Wow. Okay. The first image with Frisk and Chara and the mirror? Is genius. It mirrors (hah) the It's Me moment in New Home so perfectly, transferring the focus from the child we see, to the one who steps up and takes their fate and this world's fate in their hands. The shot with chara in the void, with the bright light directly behind them, looking down at the floor with their eyes shadowed--this just fits the early lost nature so easily. Chara is only allowed to see a small sliver of the world. They are lost in the darkness, in the indefinite void around them with only frisk and their actions to show them the world beyond. And they aren't ready to to accept it at first. "They tried to be good / I really did / not sure I could" but then they look up to the sky, into the darkness of the void above them , as they twinkle in the far distance Chara seems to find some solace in the fact that even the distant stars die. And then we transfer into the artwork used as the thumbnail. It is phenomenal. I remember seeing it *months* ago. Long before Kristen ever was interviewed for an artist position. It was so beautiful. Peaceful and surreal in a way that absolutely fit with the forlorn sounding nature of the song. I think Kristen called it a Kingdom Hearts stained glass window at one point? That's exactly how it feels. It matches that same surreal nature of a place out of time, where they are cut off from everything around them. The menu symbols surrounding them and the circles and lines and patterns that make up the background just add this element of non-diagetic feeling to the piece, like chara doesn't really belong in that world, and has a foot out of it into ours. The following sequences, as Chara makes their decision, are just chilling. The colors fade. They flowers wilt and die. And the menu options change to a single choice.
Attack.
Attack.
Attack.
There's only one way forward for them now. For you.
For everyone.
(I really wanna end it there because that's a fun ending spot, but I just *had* to mention that ending. Oh gosh giving chara the face. And turning the lines *red* and then fading into the darkness leaving only that face lingering as the last notes of the song ring out??? *Perfect* lore. Utterly perfect. You did a great job with the concept and storyboarding the art for this song, as well as the coloring/shading)
The point of no return is killing flowey.
You can kill sans and Asgore and back out when you get to flowey.
m4wh7eses7mgr7snrs msrgsmf8e7 theres 9 pharagraps ;w;
Faithful Chocobo oh no heaven forbid someone get really passionate about the song and want to express it through words XD
Connor Grant HAPPY BIRTHDAY! :D
Faithful Chocobo you. Must be new xD I've been writing these (some shorter some longer) since back when the end game Songs were being released. And Kristen was writing them before that.
As for the point of no return... I was speaking somewhat metaphorically. You are speaking about the player. I'm talking about frisk and if the narrative. Sure the player can give up and leave. But frisk can't really. The only option they have right now is to keep going, and this part of the game in particular is where Chara's influence is felt the strongest, and in my mind, where the choices are taken from frisk and attributed to Chara.
"No more stalling"
That lyric gives me chills...
Partner =)
"no one can stop me now"
Sans: Ahem
the player saying that through chara's corruption: changes files so sans has no attacks
player: *LOL*
Technically, Sans still died to them-.
the electricity right after i defeated sans that one time: Ahem
Me: *Proceeds to rage quit and never do a genocide run ever again*
Froggit:fools
Lol sans died in one hit by frisk,chara can easly break his bones
Previous vid: MOTI puts filter on the "you-know-what-song-is-next" to avoid spam.
Reality: MOTI tricked everyone to believing it's "that song to be next" when it be an unused track
this is nice break from all the super deep comments out there
I may have just thought of a new type of emotion specifically for MotI: MegaNOvania
-sorry-
These are such good and original genocide songs. And still, there are people who keep yelling for Megalovania.
1st off: ARE YOU BLIND?! READ THE DESCRIPTION!!!
2nd: Look at all the work that MOTI is putting in! It's awesome!
I just hope that those people just start understanding what MOTI is telling us...
megalovania
t.hank
Stroopwafel Man ikr. I don't even like megalovania that much. There are waaaayyyyyy better songs than megalovania.
@@Sammy_The_Umbreon agreed
like tem shop!
unpopular opinion: this is better than megalovania.
fite me sans fangirls
@@thabhu nop
you're right
(not a sans fangirl)
I mean the instrumental Megalovania is really lackluster compared to others in the OST, but Megalovania by MOTI is honestly one of the best songs I've heard so it's contested
No
Chaos King
Creepy, calming, mysterious and amazing. Wow, I'm speechless, this moved my heart with being more terrified of Chara and feeling sorry for them. I
love it! Thank you for all the effort that you put in so far and keep on doing it like you want to! because that is beautiful.
OH MY GOD THIS IS MY FAVORITE UNUSED SONG AHHHHH
I never would have guessed that STAR would make it. Keep coming with the surprises, MOTI!
Personally, I don't see Chara as the one canonically in control in the genocide run. I think the player is still the one in control, and your actions corrupt Chara and that's what turns them into the demon at the end.
Yeah! Finally someone gets it!!!!!!!!!
Yeah, it's something similiar to Noelle in the Snowgrave run of Deltarune CH2.
@@riskyfrisk2282 I'm of the opinion that may have been an intentional parallel on Toby's part, after seeing the fandom misunderstand what happened with chara. Just to showcase what was going on again in a way they could better understand.
My opinion is that the genocide route isn't charas fault but Chara is still evil.
all of these are true and FALSE, THE MAIN PART OF UNDERTALE IS A.US
This changed my life
My word, Eissibee's voice is gorgeous :") The pure beauty of it almost brought me to tears
This is such a powerful and beautiful song. I really love how you showed us the feeling of rejection and neglect Chara feels, and how they gained a desire to kill go down this dark path. It almost makes you feel bad for them... I mean, yes they slaughtered a bunch of innocent monsters, as well as some monsters who were trying to protect them and others. But still, you've got to have at least some sympathy for Chara...
As for vocals... OH MY GOODNESS I DIDN'T REALIZE HOW MUCH I MISSED EISSIBEE'S VOICE UNTIL NOW!!! There's just such a lovely, beautiful tone to it. Like, I don't know why, but every time she sings, I get a little emotional... the purity and beauty is simply beyond description :'3 And I am THRILLED she has her own song in this Geno package!!! This one is definitely one of my top three, and I definitely would want to cover it someday (I doubt I could really do justice to the wonderfulness of this song or Eissibee's voice though). Honestly, I am so freaking glad you found her to be your Chara for the UT musicals!!! Once again, you have given me my canon voice for another character :3 Kind of (really) hope we get to hear at least a little more of her at some point in the last two songs... Stunning work, darling!!!
Not gonna lie, you did surprised me by creating a song from an unused track... not that I'm complaining, though!!! In fact, just the opposite- I am FANGIRLING over it!!! That is so freaking creative of you, and I am so glad you brought this song out from the dark so more people can know about it now :))) Honestly, it is so underrated, and I'm really glad you used it in the genocide package!!! A truly excellent choice- bravo, bravo
Every time you write stuff like this *I* get emotional, so I guess we're even! Thank you for all your kind comments, I'm glad you like the video!
Well actually YOU the player is pushing chara in genocide so she just kills YOUR the killer here not Chara
Call Me Mar same
please stop
+Kawaii Undertale While that is what I think as well, there is no proof to say that is completely true.
Top 10 Anime plot twists
Advanced Penguin XD
WHAT A TWIST!
LOL!
Directed by M Night Shyamalan
DIS IZ NUT AN ANIMMEY U STOUPIDDD
1:05 Look at you, making the child doubt themself because of your actions! Goat Mom is not proud.
*No one is happy with this.
It's so beautiful, I love Chara's deep voice.
Sadly, a ton of people will probably ignore the fact this is beautiful and rant because "YOu diDn'T PuT uP MegAloVaniK"
Distracted Author "I kNoW thIs iS a lIteRaL anGel sInGinG, bUt yOu diDnT upLoaD meGalOkInk"
yeah...the SPERG lords! :lol:
To be honest, I was definitely expecting a Chara song, but I thought that it would be at the very end - you know, at the part where they ask you to ERASE. So - two more. Megalovania, and...? Another Chara song? A reprise of Undertale or Once Upon A Time. Maybe even Gaster (probably not, but I can hope.)
Nicole Edelweiss Adella Well, Floweytale was technically the Genocide reprise of Undertale
Megolavainia and but nobody came
This track; mysterious...
Interlacing theories, woven in a confusing pattern of unknown voids of knowledge...
So much feeling infused into a track that was once a mistake...
Everyone decided to give it's meaning to Chara, a confused, twisted demon character who just wanted love and forgiveness...
Unloved...
Forgotten....
Much like
*A* *STAR* .
"I lost the dawn"
Then we'll use Ajax.
...
My apologies.
*When they call my name, the demon comes
In the previous song
Flowey
*Howdy Chara
*Oh Chara
*Chara I have seen it all
*Chara I can't predict you
*Only one thing that's left, Chara
*Chara, with you by my side
*Chara did you do all this
*WHEN YOU HEARD ME CALL YOUR NAME?*
*Looks like you made them angry
*You're filled with demons xD
P.s. Like?
Edit: Just a grammar mistake! xD
XDDDDDDDDD
EXDEEDEEDEEDEEE
DanyRPG
Chara: **smoke is literally coming out of nose and ears**
I HAVE THINGS TO DO TOO YA KNOW!!!!!!!!!
DanyRPG hahahahahah
DanyRPG XD ATBLEAST SOMEONE KNOWS FINALLY 😂😂😂
To those saying "Why isn't this megalovania?" PAP. Be glad they are even doing a genocide musical, I'm sure you can wait another Sunday.
UnitedGames11 I love your switch registeel profile pick
....I smell a dirty homestuck
I'm honestly hoping they do "The Choice" instead. It would have a much more powerful impact, I think.
I'm scared for Chara
Why?
;-;
She's not really scary, just misunderstood. I'd probably be friends with her if I could.
*+Minty Flores* Scared FOR Chara, not scared OF Chara.
*+Jean Dovey* Because they just sang an entire song about how they aren’t capable of being good, how there’s no hope for humanity, and how death is all they’re good for. That’s a tad concerning, don’t you think?
*singing to the uninformed masses*
🎶Chara isn’t the murderer it’s just you stop blaming her for your mistakes🎶
both frisk and chara are to blame
@@user-vp9ry3km2c neither of them did anything lol, it’s the player deciding to kill
@@tealwashablemarker8886 nah
@@user-vp9ry3km2c yes it was
I'M SO LATE GETTING HERE, but that was amazing. I was a little confused when I saw the title, but as soon as I heard the melody I recognized "Star". I couldn't remember what part of the game it was from, but thankfully Kristen Trawczynski explained thoroughly. I just want to say that Eissibee's singing was absolutely gorgeous. I don't want this comment to get too long since barely anyone will see it, so I'll leave it at that.
This song fully supports the genocide route curropting chara theory and I love it
Yes- I think Chara was unsure of themselves but, upon going along with the player's genocide, they thought they were doing what was meant to happen because it was what the player wanted...
2:16 I met the artist of this segment! They were super fun to talk to and they also have some awesome arts of other fandoms (especially The Owl House!)
Demon: *comes*
Chare: oh fuck the demon is coming
Ladies and gentlemen, the "star" of the show is singing!
No Mettaton died remember
Ayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
when i saw star i was expecting a mtt thing tbh
NO
ba bum bish
"MOTI"
The only one who can make a good song balanced with melody and creepiness.
I've been listening to this since it came out and I just noticed all the symbols in the background at 2:10 fade to become the FIGHT symbol during "I finally see neither world cares for me". Bravo
Odd little pause between "no one can" and "STOP me now"
The pause and the biting STOP is a little odd, isnt it? Like they're supposed to be separate statements.
YES YES YES! This was on my birthday, and I'm so glad that i was gifted with something other than the most over-memed song that people have been THREATENING you about. Thank you.
Edit: Okay, now that I've gotten over the initial shock, i must say the art, the vocals, the everything was amazing. The lyrics especially, it's funny that the fandom seems to be in this war about whether Chara is good or evil, and this interpretation of Chara seems to be having that same war within themselves. Congratulations to everyone, this was a wonderful birthday present.
Happy birthday
Lily Twinklenoodle happy birthday
Happy Birthday! Hope your OK... as in like not DEAD from birthday digs
Well happy birthday to ya!!🍨🍦🎂🍰🍬
Hey, happy birthday!
2:10 You could make a religion out of this.
no don't
Yee
+Madison Green no dont
Charasm
Yes plz
Before video: star? What’s this?
*clicks video*
After video: wow
Such a creepy song
I LOVE IT!!
Same.
*and why do you Level Of ViolencE it?
SCREW MEGALOVANIA THIS IS AMAZING