This man truly provided the soundtrack of my teenage years. Each song was a Christmas gift as each was unbelievably unique. It is almost hard to imagine that one person wrote so many incredibly beautiful presents in the form of songs. I'm convinced that Bernie and Elton's songs kept many of us alive and moving forward.
This host and this series is unbelievable! So many articles and videos only cover one type of instrument and one genre of music, but he covers instruments other than guitar (which he is very well educated in) and other types of music, such as country and early R&R. This channel is among the very best and he explains everything in a easy to understand way!
This is also why I am such a fan of this channel - being very busy and working full-time like everyone, I don’t have a lot of time to listen to a lot of channels. I only subscribe to a very few, but this is one that I get notices for and love to listen to. I love the positivity that Fil brings to these analyses. I have introduced him to others who have said the same thing. With so much on social media being so critical, it is refreshing to hear the positivity here. The only thing Fil ever criticizes is autotune LOL
dapinelli, he really is something special. What is most amazing is he does 100% of his research and production to such a high degree of professionalism.
I've been a guitarist for decades but I would never be able to do analysis like you do. Your explanations are so deep and clear, it's just amazing. Not sure how you were able to develop that skill but really appreciate it. Keep it up.
So glad you’re doing this review. I have been listening to Elton John these past 2 weeks, his complete discography. Love the way Bernie Taupin creates images with his lyrics. Been an Elton fan since the 70’s. The entire band is brilliant.
For myself,I never liked the narrating voice in first person that is-I - changes tribes first an Iroquois, then runs the 'gauntlet of the Sioux' then hears ' Geronimo (an Apache.America SW.) was dead' when laying down his weopens. This is not historically accurate. HOWEVER after hearing this live version I got a different perspective with the spacing Elton John gives the lyric. The room to be referring to more than one person is more evident. Point in the end of 2 new times listening I like this much more. Thanks letting me post. I like Levon, No sacrifice' 'Good Bye Yellow Brick Road' Is an All time favorite. Crocodile Rock was my intro to R and Roll.
You can always tell a confident performer: he/she is not scared to fluently use the full range of sounds as a palette for a song. From very soft piano keys through to the very energetic, Elton has the full range of expression on the piano. His passionate singing then gives the songs another extra edge.
I simply adore Elton...all his music makes me happy, even when he makes me cry. Empty Garden, Skyline Pigeon, My Father's Gun, Sacrifice, so many amazing songs.
Elton John, all class, all legend, all the time. A very powerful song from one of the masters of storytelling.. such a special time it was from 1965-1977 when the men, women and bands who could tell a real story with real emotions and real power. I wish music could still sound like this. Great analysis as always my brother. Keep it up!!
I don't care what people today say about Elton, but he, like you said was hit after hit after hit, much like Billy Joel, both extremely proficient at their learned musical instruments, but more than that, their feeling, their voices in vocal expression. Both John and Joel ultimate performers...besides tremendous recording artists. And for both, hard work to get there! I just HATE when people don't get the amount of hard work to become as good as they were/are.
Bernie and Reg, a match made in heaven, wonderful evocative lyrics set to beautiful music. Saw Elton 3 times in 1971, he was wonderful then as he is now. Respect to Sir Elton John and Bernie Taupin.
I saw him was by accident the first time. I went to see Leon Russell at the Swing Auditorium (a small venue in California) in 1970 and Elton was the opening act … such an amazing talent … he was fabulous.
Fil you are a GENIUS at bringing focus to what is great about particular musicians or performances. Well done. PS I don’t remember ever hearing this particular song before but it brought tears to my eyes. Well done Bernie, Elton
Great video, Fil. Elton is my all time favorite artist. This Sounds For Saturday concert is one of the finest sets I've ever heard done. Elton says his 11-17-70 live album was probably his best ever show, but I believe he might be forgetting this one!
I've heard Elton say that when he first reads Bernie's lyrics he can already hear the melody that fits them; it usually doesn't take even 20 minutes to get the music written. I saw his "Don't Shoot Me" concert back in '73. F'ing AMAZING show! Literally almost brought down the reinforced concrete balcony of St.John's Arena at Ohio State - the University closed it to rock concerts after that.
Elton John is an unbelievably talented singer, pianist, and entertainer. I'm dating myself again, but I saw him perform at Madison Square Garden too many years ago, when he was touring with Kiki Dee. Their duet, "Don't Go Breaking My Heart," was so well done and fun! He and Bernie Taupin made such magical music together.
Talk about a captivating performance! This was a joy to watch. Love the points you brought up - especially in bringing out emotion using dynamics even without vibrato. Once again, a great job with the analysis, Fil! It was very fitting that you played this one until the end...
For a few years during the 70's Elton John was the biggest thing on the radio, everywhere. Whenever a new single would come out people would go nuts. I remember bringing home Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy and playing it over and over and over......He was/is amazing.
I saw Elton during his Yellow Brick Road tour. It was a hell of a show but I was too young to realize his genius. About 8 years ago I saw him again. It was wonderful but his piano playing was incredible. Levon is my favorite . I read an interview with him years ago and he was asked why he didn't have a piano in his house. He said he didn't like them around and all they're good for is standing on. Thanks Fil !!
I have pondered the greatest popular music composers/creators of all, and am grateful that I was placed on the earth in the time period to have them. Even had I been born 20 or so years later, I would probably have completely missed it. On the list I currently have the top 3 as Stevie Wonder, Paul McCartney and Quincy Jones. Elton I have as fourth. But that's absolutely still in god territory. I am stunned at his creations. And his piano skill is criminally underappreciated - he is a master. My head spins at his clear effortlessness with his playing.
@@Bill_Woo Someone (probably a good judge) was once pondering in print as to which bands would still be remembered 200 years from now. The view expressed was The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Elvis, ABBA and Elton John. As for the greatest performers live, the list was Freddie Mercury, Prince and Michael Jackson.
@@tullfan7872 Have you ever seen the rehearsal/behind the scenes show of Michael Jackson's final [unperformed] performance? Itg's called This Is It. It gave me a great appreciation, even though I wasn't broadly crazy about him until that.
The early Elton concerts were an EVENT not to be missed! The trio of Elton, Dee Murray on bass and Nigel 'so many drums he can't miss' Olsson were amazing.
Playing and singing like that is the equivalent of standing naked on stage. Pianos are particularly unforgiving and unless you approach them with the utmost in performance confidence they will betray every hesitancy and weakness. His playing is great while not the most adventurous, mostly block and broken chords but still he commands that instrument and it sings right along with him. His songs, along with this one, are some of the first rock and roll songs I learned on the piano. Great analysis and thanks for doing this one.
Beautiful. 🎼✒🎹🎤 Vocally and creatively speaking, my favorite time of both Sir Elton and Bernie's careers. "Where To Now, St. Peter?" ... That's my favorite!!! Thank you Fil. 🙂
My da loved classical music, but expanded outside of that to the Beatles and later John Lennon's plastic ono-band album. I still remember his reaction to me playing "Sorry seems to be the hardest word" on the stereo in the living room though. He stopped reading, put his book down, closed his eyes, moved a bit to the music. When it was over he asked if I could play it again and if I could do him a favour and just listen with him. We listened to it a couple of times and it always stayed his favourite song and "whatever gets you through the night" remained one of his favourite Lennon songs. I had a bootleg with Lennon's last live performance with Elton.
Wow. So appreciative of you analyzing and reviewing this Elton John performance! What's cool about this song is how I happened upon it via a friend who had a significantly greater exposure to early Elton at the time. I was really just beginning to discover the depth of Elton's artistry when we used to listen to the Madman across the Water album exhaustively in the late 80's. That album is one of my favorite early Elton albums along with Tumbleweed Connection and Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. There is so much significantly fantastic, emotive music throughout all three of those albums. This song, remains especially significant, as there are times I find myself trying to belt out and sing this song (without a piano, as I can't play one) given how strongly I've connected with it, so many years ago. Truly brilliant reflections and insight by you again! Thank you!
What a great analysis. Very interesting points about piano I never thought about, as well as Elton's American "accent"! He does sound very natural in his pronunciation as you said. And he seems like just such a nice guy too. Rock on, Sir Elton!
Fil, you needn't ever apologize for the length of your videos. I can't imagine that anyone who is into music would leave part way through one of these masterpieces of education and entertainment. If one does, it's certainly their loss. I would be there to the end if it took an hour. So then, when it comes to songs by Elton John for analysis, the choices are almost endless. Whoever submitted this performance of 'Indian Sunset' is brilliant. As an EJ fan since the release of 'Your Song' when I was in 6th grade, I consider this submission extremely impressive and your breakdown of the song masterful, as usual. Kudos to you both.
This is a really sad song, a little known masterpiece whose lyrics along with the dramatic presentation on the album are one of the few songs I've ever heard that grab me, and leave me sad and empty. The line "peace to this young warrior" is - well, you'll feel it ... or not. All this on Elton's finest work, by far, IMO, Madman Across the Water. He had about five monstrously tremendous albums from 70 to 74 - so I realize that I'm making a strong statement about Madman.
Elton's young voice was smooth as silk any one of the songs he and Bernie wrote Elton had a way of putting the Melody just where it needed to go . And when asked Nigel Olson and Dee Murray to join
Ah Nigel Olsen that's the name I was looking for. Thanks What I read or heard that Nigel was very key for any harmonies. Especially live. Some people who saw him live at that time(With Nigel and a then later say the show suffered without him.) Just trying to acknowledge him.
@@timmaxey148 yes I wouldn't forget Davey usually played a les Paul he joined a little after Dee and Nigel. On yellow brick road he layed down some fantastic licks on Saturday night s alright ,Bennie and the jets.
Elton John..... Courage to overcome tremendous obstacles and become the man he was meant to be.....an extraordinary musical gift that will continue to give for generations to come.....✌❤🤘
This man was my 70's childhood right here. 🥰 Two of my favorite songs from '74 ("Goodbye Yellowbrick Road" and "Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me") were from Elton. 🙂 He and "Macca" ruled much of the 70's American airwaves, and helped to foster my love for British musicians. *Love* this man, and have several of his earlier albums. 😊♥️ Thank you, Fil! xx
Not my favorite Elton John song from the 70's,, but he was definitely at the height of his talent during this time. Thanks also to Bernie Taupin he and Elton created meaningful songs unlike the pop stuff he did in later years.
cannonball666 ‘Daniel, ‘ and, ‘Your Song,’ were my favorite songs in the 70’s. Bennie and the Jets, played non stop in New England, when released. Thank you Fil, on this Very full information, On Elton, and his techniques. A lot of info on his vocals 🎤and piano 🎹😊
FIL, THANKS FOR THE GREAT VIDEO AND YOUR COMMENTS, I SAW HIM IN DETROIT IN 1970, I THINK IT WAS HIS FIRST AMERICAN TOUR, HE PLAYED THE ALBUM TUMBLEWEED CONNECTION, HE CAME OUT WEARING BIB OVERHAULS, NO FEATHERS YET AT THIS POINT, ELTON ACTUALLY DANCED ON THE KEYBOARD AND IT SOUNDED LIKE HE WAS PLAYING, I DO NOT KNOW HOW HE DID THAT, BUT IT SOUNDED GREAT!! IT WAS AN AWESOME SHOW, ROCK ON FIL, COUSIN FIGEL
My favorite Elton John album, and one that people who like this performance might enjoy, is 11/17/70 (US title) from a NYC live radio broadcast and featuring the stripped-down original 3 piece he started with before Davey Johnstone added his guitar. The main reason this album is so notable IMO is that it relies on those dynamics you talk about from all three of the musicians. As a guitarist/bassist who has alway admired great guitar-centered trio rock and blues groups, this Elton John album was an awakening, because I heard the power and excitement they could generate without necessarily getting loud or having the sustained instrumental voice that guitars are capable of, even in a trio. Thanks, as always, for sharing your insight on this great performance by one of THE great artists of my generation.
Gosh! I’m stunned...these two guys in a happy marriage making this amazing music together. Since my early youth, 12 yrs old in 1970, I have listened and loved and worshiped them two. The earlier material is to die for. Fil, u are such a great person to listen to. What u don’t know when it comes to the musicworld...its not for us to know✌️ Rock on ⚡️🎸⚡️
Yet another fantastic analysis, Fil! I saw Elton in 1972 for $4 in a small venue. One of the finest concerts I've ever seen! And Bernie wrote those lyrics when he was 19 years old- AMAZING!!! Thanks, Fil!
Thank you so very much for reacting to the video I requested. A truly fantastic, in depth analysis, there is no other channel like this. You cover every single point, in the way, I wish I could do without making people glaze over after 2 minutes! As a side note, I am actually the son of a jazz musician, who went on to be a trance music producer and DJ, so my outlook on music is very rounded. I love artists who perform solo, accomplished by themselves, something we just don't see enough of now. I guess my professional taste is somewhat contradictory of the music I request. I love electronic music that can provide layer upon layer of sound, that would be impossible to achieve in a live performance.
Hey Fil, very well done! Perhaps my fave video of yours. You always do your homework. Your passion as a musician came out in this one. Elton and Bernie are/were a match made in heaven. Bernie and Elton's early work is right up there with the Lennon & McCartney, Simon & Garfunkel, etc. Such great story tellers and talented performers.
Your getting close to 100 K followers Fil. You deserve the huge following. You do a great job! I love Elton. Thank you for this one. I also enjoy reading the comment section. So many people have interesting history wrapped around particular music.
Elton John inspired me to pick up the piano in my day. Elton John such a talented human being and a master on the piano. He's amazing but he wouldn't be amazing by himself, Bernie Taupin was a great song writer for Elton. The two had a chemistry that no one could replace. Elton provided the rhythm and Bernie would provide the lyrical content. Elton has a magical voice that catches your attention and his electrifying piano playing captivated his audience, easily. Thanks for a great analysis Fil. Cheers!!! I wonder how many sunglasses he has now. Lol.
I like how you smile so much while watching the videos yourself. It’s cool. I don’t know if you just really enjoy what you do or what it is. It really cool though to see someone seem to really appreciate the talent being displayed. Especially seeing how much talent you have yourself as demonstrated in your performance videos.
I agree. Watching someone who is obviously enjoying what they do makes it more enjoyable for me. I also like that you treat the musicians that you review with respect. You’re not out to build yourself up by tearing them down. You are sharing with us what makes these artists great. That is really what made me subscribe.
Funny you mentioned his smile, since I wanted to make a comment that this was one where he wasn't smiling until the end. This is the kind of song that you don't smile to, it is too powerful a performance, . But you are spot on about the respect that Fil has.
Lawrence Taylor He smiles right at the beginning. That’s when I started the comment. He does it on all the videos he watches though so as soon as I saw him start smiling at the beginning I started the comment.
Fil, one of my favorite songs, gonna ramble... when I was a little kid I lived close to an am radio station and I was their paperboy for years and it was a long hike through the transmission field with Minnesota snow and they would let me in to warm up and I got to watch the dj through the glass and music was always the topic and I was given 45s to take home, to me music was everything and so expressive and I like your channel because you have the mindset that was present in the 60s-70s where you sought out information on the band/ artist and followed all the connections, this channel brings me back home, a sense of peace and stability in the artistic expression of the truly great ones and your presentation is very good because you actually know what you’re talking about! Thanks again fil and I’ll stay tuned... jj
Omg. Love this song by Elton. Being Native American it is a great song for us. And the piano parts resemble drums and the flutes that the ancestors played. Elton has such a sway and makes me feel I am into the story much more than a song played on guitar. He just makes it come alive.
I had forgotten about this song until is started...had me in tears by the time he was finished. Dynamics...something a lot of performers forget about, but they're sooooo important to moving a piece, musically. Thank you, Fil, for reminding me of this wonderful song...heartbreaking as it is to hear and contemplate...
Elton John has ALWAYS been a fantastic musician and singer. I will never forget the first time I heard "Your Song." That's one of those songs that you always remember the exact moment you first heard it. I'm so glad he's still going strong. A TRUE virtuoso. . . . .
Thank you so much for featuring a pianist! I am such a fan of piano (I recently asked you during the super chat if you had any opinion on keyboards vs piano ☺️). Was not familiar with this particular song...such an emotional performance. I wish more current artists played piano! I’d like to make a request for an analysis of Billy Joel - not sure whether you need for us to cite a particular video, or just suggest an artist? I will look and see if I can find any versions of Billy singing New York State of Mind, which is such a great song. Will see if I can find any that might be copyright free. Thank you again for this wonderful analysis. One thing I wanted to mention was that to me the sign of any great performance of a more emotional song (rather than a rocking performance that gets people moving and singing) is how attentively the audience is listening. At first I wasn’t even sure if there was a live audience, given how quiet everyone was! You could hear a pin drop. Thank you again. Am proud to be one of your patrons - I can say honestly that you give great value!! Rock! 🤘
I love his wonderful voice and performance. What a genius. I also have to add when I found those old videos (there are quite a few of them form the 70s) after seeing his film Rocket Man and getting into his music again after years I cried. Grew up in the 1970s with his wonderful music.
That was such an interesting analyses comparing the piano & the guitar. Elton is a Legend! His shows today are just as great as the were back in the late 70s when I saw him for the first time. I always wondered why so many English singers lost their accent when they sang!
Yes. I just started playing the violin this month and I can tell how much I am actually thinking about each aspect of instruction. There is no expression in plucking, except maybe laughter. :) I couldn’t imagine being a master, perhaps one day. Thanks Fil!
One of the greatest performers of our times! I don’t think I could say much more about this man but a legend or musical genius! The amazing relationship he has with his piano is phenomenal and the result is pure magic! Excellent analysis Fil! Cheers Mario! 😀🤘🤘
While in the US Air Force stationed in Germany, they had a wreck room with a piano. I would take my cassette player with some of my favorite music and learned how to play. After I got out of the military I continued practicing. After I accepted Jesus as my Savior, I began to play at church for Him. Great analysis Fil, always liked Elton's music.
Always thought if I could play the piano that I would want to master it as well as Elton, the emotions of his songs came through the piano. No autotune needed for legends like him, original great voice and talent. Great review, :)
Playing both guitar & piano l found many of my most emotional songs l wrote l composed on piano and often transfered them onto guitar for use in the band while some had to remain piano songs with me behind the piano to keep the emotional impact in tact. What an iconic pairing in music history..Elton and Bernie. Such stunning incredible lyrics and Elton John's music and vocals! Elton John a true icon in Every sense of the word..larger than life. What a career and well deserved success! One of the few artists l never saw live and wish l had. Great Review as usual Fil! Thanks!😎🎼🎶🎵🇨🇦
The part I find most fascinating is, artists usually write songs from their own emotions, experiences & how they see life, but in his case, Elton had Bernie write the songs yet sang them as if it was from his own words.
I am musically smitten with him, but I have him as fourth. Before you fret, hear who are the other three - Wonder, McCartney, and Quincy Jones. I know, Quincy Jones? Yeah. But 4th place considering those 3 is definitely god territory.
Great review Fil. Ok, now that you've opened the piano door--Bill Joel. Endless material there for you going back to the early 70's with plenty of juicy guitar riffs!
Elton John another singer that you can tell is unique voice in 3 seconds ! What a tremendously talented artist for so many decades 😎🎹 Sweet video , analysis and back story... Thank-you Fil ! ✌😎 Request: Dr.John playing "Such A Night" w/ The Band from the Last Waltz concert 😎🎹 Another very unique voice....... I know "Right Place,Wrong Time was his big hit but I really love the "Such A Night" tune......,thanx Fil ! HAPPY HALLOWEEN 🎃 Fil & viewers ✌😎
I used to have a CD of EJ’s Tokyo 1971 concert (recorded from a radio broadcast) that I received about 10 years ago. Each song an instant classic. Love EJ and think I’ve seen him in concert more than any other musician (including his 60th birthday show at Madison Square Garden). This video made my day - thank you so much for this analysis!
During the 70s when young I enjoyed listening to Elton. Now when I listen I hear a great classic musician who will be enjoyed for years to come by young and old.
Five times I've seen Elton John, and his Farewell Yellow Brick Road was the first time I've ever heard Indian Sunset live.. Thank you for the great analysis! Legend, that he is..
I was 11 years old in 1971 . That's probably around the age I started buying Eltons records. Mostly singles from my parents giving me an allowance.. And it was just for his talent and voicd because it was rare if I even got to see him on tv at that age . Great Video And packed full of wonderful information . !! :0) It's Halloween night here as I'm watching this .So Happy Halloween !!
It was a long time within my life before I knew who Bernie Taupin was. Even later still that Burt Bacharach's lyricist was Hal David. It's amazing how over the years duo's like these have made such great music.
One of my favorite pianists is George Winston. He did one piece where he actually muted the strings on the piano. I had never seen anyone do this before. Elton is a great talent. His music is seared into my memory from my teenage years in the 70s.
In the 80's I picked up an album called Elton John 11*17*70. It was a recording in a small club and half the songs were covers. His voice was rough and immature and awesome. I became an instant fan! I see now it may have been an "unofficial" purchase.
What an incredible musical journey Sr. Elton John has had. superb analysis and breakdown on this performance. "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" among other I like of his.
This man truly provided the soundtrack of my teenage years.
Each song was a Christmas gift as each was unbelievably unique.
It is almost hard to imagine that one person wrote so many incredibly beautiful presents in the form of songs.
I'm convinced that Bernie and Elton's songs kept many of us alive and moving forward.
This host and this series is unbelievable! So many articles and videos only cover one type of instrument and one genre of music, but he covers instruments other than guitar (which he is very well educated in) and other types of music, such as country and early R&R. This channel is among the very best and he explains everything in a easy to understand way!
Thanks!
This is also why I am such a fan of this channel - being very busy and working full-time like everyone, I don’t have a lot of time to listen to a lot of channels. I only subscribe to a very few, but this is one that I get notices for and love to listen to. I love the positivity that Fil brings to these analyses. I have introduced him to others who have said the same thing. With so much on social media being so critical, it is refreshing to hear the positivity here. The only thing Fil ever criticizes is autotune LOL
dapinelli, he really is something special. What is most amazing is he does 100% of his research and production to such a high degree of professionalism.
This is the time period that Elton John did his best music. Brings back many memories. Thanks, Fil.
One of my favourite concerts was Elton. In the mid 90s I saw him play solo. Just Elton and his piano for 3 hours straight. Unforgettable!
I've been a guitarist for decades but I would never be able to do analysis like you do. Your explanations are so deep and clear, it's just amazing. Not sure how you were able to develop that skill but really appreciate it. Keep it up.
well said...i agree!! Fil is our superhero friend that keeps the real music relevant!
So glad you’re doing this review. I have been listening to Elton John these past 2 weeks, his complete discography. Love the way Bernie Taupin creates images with his lyrics. Been an Elton fan since the 70’s. The entire band is brilliant.
2008dbravo you are so right.
For myself,I never liked the narrating voice in first person that is-I - changes tribes first an Iroquois, then runs the 'gauntlet of the Sioux' then hears ' Geronimo (an Apache.America SW.) was dead' when laying down his weopens. This is not historically accurate. HOWEVER after hearing this live version I got a different perspective with the spacing Elton John gives the lyric. The room to be referring to more than one person is more evident. Point in the end of 2 new times listening I like this much more. Thanks letting me post. I like Levon, No sacrifice' 'Good Bye Yellow Brick Road' Is an All time favorite. Crocodile Rock was my intro to R and Roll.
This gentleman‘s knowledge is our joy and entertainment God bless Fil
I've always thought that Elton was an underrated singer. His voice sounds so beautiful here.
Sy Goldman he never considered himself a singer. He’s said he tried to find someone else to sing his songs but never could find anyone.
@@BeatlesCentricUniverse amen.
EJ is beloved for his unique voice and original style of singing.
Elton messed up his voice as he got older. His lifestyle, etc. His singing voice as a young man was great.
Brain Stormer He had nodules removed from his vocal chords, I think. Maybe back around the time of: Live with the Melbourne Symphony Orchestra?
You can always tell a confident performer: he/she is not scared to fluently use the full range of sounds as a palette for a song. From very soft piano keys through to the very energetic, Elton has the full range of expression on the piano. His passionate singing then gives the songs another extra edge.
I simply adore Elton...all his music makes me happy, even when he makes me cry. Empty Garden, Skyline Pigeon, My Father's Gun, Sacrifice, so many amazing songs.
A like for Trisha. My phone is being funky:(
Omgosh so many hours in my room listening to him and getting so caught up in the absolute magic!!
I appreciate the comments section on Fil's videos since I learn so much. Thanks for these songs that I want to discover.
What can i say, it's Elton John, 'NUFF SAID' Great Job on Elton's analysis, Filip!
Elton John, all class, all legend, all the time. A very powerful song from one of the masters of storytelling.. such a special time it was from 1965-1977 when the men, women and bands who could tell a real story with real emotions and real power. I wish music could still sound like this. Great analysis as always my brother. Keep it up!!
I don't care what people today say about Elton, but he, like you said was hit after hit after hit, much like Billy Joel, both extremely proficient at their learned musical instruments, but more than that, their feeling, their voices in vocal expression. Both John and Joel ultimate performers...besides tremendous recording artists. And for both, hard work to get there! I just HATE when people don't get the amount of hard work to become as good as they were/are.
Bernie and Reg, a match made in heaven, wonderful evocative lyrics set to beautiful music. Saw Elton 3 times in 1971, he was wonderful then as he is now. Respect to Sir Elton John and Bernie Taupin.
I saw him was by accident the first time. I went to see Leon Russell at the Swing Auditorium (a small venue in California) in 1970 and Elton was the opening act … such an amazing talent … he was fabulous.
Elton. My favorite artist since I first listened to the Goodbye Yellow Brick Road album. 💓💓💓
Elton hitting his prime. '70 to '76 was his peak creative period. Not forgetting the great Bernie Taupin.
Fil you are a GENIUS at bringing focus to what is great about particular musicians or performances. Well done. PS I don’t remember ever hearing this particular song before but it brought tears to my eyes. Well done Bernie, Elton
The album version is more powerful. Seek it out. And wait until you hear the rest of the Madman Across the Water album.
Great video, Fil. Elton is my all time favorite artist. This Sounds For Saturday concert is one of the finest sets I've ever heard done. Elton says his 11-17-70 live album was probably his best ever show, but I believe he might be forgetting this one!
I've heard Elton say that when he first reads Bernie's lyrics he can already hear the melody that fits them; it usually doesn't take even 20 minutes to get the music written.
I saw his "Don't Shoot Me" concert back in '73. F'ing AMAZING show! Literally almost brought down the reinforced concrete balcony of St.John's Arena at Ohio State - the University closed it to rock concerts after that.
Amazing! I saw him in '73 too when I was 11 years old. I thank my sister for dragging me along (reluctantly).
Elton John is an unbelievably talented singer, pianist, and entertainer. I'm dating myself again, but I saw him perform at Madison Square Garden too many years ago, when he was touring with Kiki Dee. Their duet, "Don't Go Breaking My Heart," was so well done and fun! He and Bernie Taupin made such magical music together.
Talk about a captivating performance! This was a joy to watch. Love the points you brought up - especially in bringing out emotion using dynamics even without vibrato. Once again, a great job with the analysis, Fil! It was very fitting that you played this one until the end...
He makes the sun shine and the rain bow and the heart beat fondly. I think he has a heart and sound that synchronized with a generation.
If you are going to deal with the piano and vocalist track...please engage with Aretha🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
For a few years during the 70's Elton John was the biggest thing on the radio, everywhere. Whenever a new single would come out people would go nuts. I remember bringing home Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy and playing it over and over and over......He was/is amazing.
Rocketman was enlightening. Mad respect for Elton for all he went through just trying to be himself.
I never fail to learn so much from your videos, Fil! Well done!
I saw Elton during his Yellow Brick Road tour. It was a hell of a show but I was too young to realize his genius. About 8 years ago I saw him again. It was wonderful but his piano playing was incredible. Levon is my favorite . I read an interview with him years ago and he was asked why he didn't have a piano in his house. He said he didn't like them around and all they're good for is standing on. Thanks Fil !!
Are we not lucky that this genius, virtuosio, all round nice guy is still with us and going strong...and ya, he's a wonderful daddy too:)
I have pondered the greatest popular music composers/creators of all, and am grateful that I was placed on the earth in the time period to have them. Even had I been born 20 or so years later, I would probably have completely missed it.
On the list I currently have the top 3 as Stevie Wonder, Paul McCartney and Quincy Jones. Elton I have as fourth. But that's absolutely still in god territory. I am stunned at his creations. And his piano skill is criminally underappreciated - he is a master. My head spins at his clear effortlessness with his playing.
@@Bill_Woo Someone (probably a good judge) was once pondering in print as to which bands would still be remembered 200 years from now. The view expressed was The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, Elvis, ABBA and Elton John. As for the greatest performers live, the list was Freddie Mercury, Prince and Michael Jackson.
@@tullfan7872 But if Stevie Wonder is omitted, something is wrong with civilization :)
@@tullfan7872 Have you ever seen the rehearsal/behind the scenes show of Michael Jackson's final [unperformed] performance? Itg's called This Is It. It gave me a great appreciation, even though I wasn't broadly crazy about him until that.
@@Bill_Woo No - but he was always said to have an amazing live performance back in the day.
The early Elton concerts were an EVENT not to be missed! The trio of Elton, Dee Murray on bass and Nigel 'so many drums he can't miss' Olsson were amazing.
Playing and singing like that is the equivalent of standing naked on stage. Pianos are particularly unforgiving and unless you approach them with the utmost in performance confidence they will betray every hesitancy and weakness. His playing is great while not the most adventurous, mostly block and broken chords but still he commands that instrument and it sings right along with him. His songs, along with this one, are some of the first rock and roll songs I learned on the piano. Great analysis and thanks for doing this one.
Beautiful. 🎼✒🎹🎤
Vocally and creatively speaking, my favorite time of both Sir Elton and Bernie's careers.
"Where To Now, St. Peter?" ... That's my favorite!!!
Thank you Fil. 🙂
You explained Eltons talent so eloquently.Elton is and was a master performer.Have seen him many times through the years.
My da loved classical music, but expanded outside of that to the Beatles and later John Lennon's plastic ono-band album. I still remember his reaction to me playing "Sorry seems to be the hardest word" on the stereo in the living room though. He stopped reading, put his book down, closed his eyes, moved a bit to the music. When it was over he asked if I could play it again and if I could do him a favour and just listen with him. We listened to it a couple of times and it always stayed his favourite song and "whatever gets you through the night" remained one of his favourite Lennon songs. I had a bootleg with Lennon's last live performance with Elton.
My God this is so good. I had never heard this before. Thanks, Fil.
Wow. So appreciative of you analyzing and reviewing this Elton John performance! What's cool about this song is how I happened upon it via a friend who had a significantly greater exposure to early Elton at the time. I was really just beginning to discover the depth of Elton's artistry when we used to listen to the Madman across the Water album exhaustively in the late 80's. That album is one of my favorite early Elton albums along with Tumbleweed Connection and Goodbye Yellow Brick Road. There is so much significantly fantastic, emotive music throughout all three of those albums. This song, remains especially significant, as there are times I find myself trying to belt out and sing this song (without a piano, as I can't play one) given how strongly I've connected with it, so many years ago.
Truly brilliant reflections and insight by you again! Thank you!
What a great analysis. Very interesting points about piano I never thought about, as well as Elton's American "accent"! He does sound very natural in his pronunciation as you said. And he seems like just such a nice guy too. Rock on, Sir Elton!
Fil, you needn't ever apologize for the length of your videos. I can't imagine that anyone who is into music would leave part way through one of these masterpieces of education and entertainment. If one does, it's certainly their loss. I would be there to the end if it took an hour. So then, when it comes to songs by Elton John for analysis, the choices are almost endless. Whoever submitted this performance of 'Indian Sunset' is brilliant. As an EJ fan since the release of 'Your Song' when I was in 6th grade, I consider this submission extremely impressive and your breakdown of the song masterful, as usual. Kudos to you both.
Thanks!
This is a really sad song, a little known masterpiece whose lyrics along with the dramatic presentation on the album are one of the few songs I've ever heard that grab me, and leave me sad and empty. The line "peace to this young warrior" is - well, you'll feel it ... or not. All this on Elton's finest work, by far, IMO, Madman Across the Water. He had about five monstrously tremendous albums from 70 to 74 - so I realize that I'm making a strong statement about Madman.
Elton's young voice was smooth as silk any one of the songs he and Bernie wrote Elton had a way of putting the Melody just where it needed to go . And when asked Nigel Olson and Dee Murray to join
Ah Nigel Olsen that's the name I was looking for. Thanks What I read or heard that Nigel was very key for any harmonies. Especially live. Some people who saw him live at that time(With Nigel and a then later say the show suffered without him.) Just trying to acknowledge him.
Don’t forget Davey Johnstone! A great guitarist!
@@timmaxey148 yes I wouldn't forget Davey usually played a les Paul he joined a little after Dee and Nigel. On yellow brick road he layed down some fantastic licks on Saturday night s alright ,Bennie and the jets.
Scott Greer Funeral For a Friend!
@@Longhorn.Rock_Roll61 I'm looking for a Dolly to see Me right. I-sneak a little drink and shout out, "She's with me!"
Elton John..... Courage to overcome tremendous obstacles and become the man he was meant to be.....an extraordinary musical gift that will continue to give for generations to come.....✌❤🤘
This man was my 70's childhood right here. 🥰 Two of my favorite songs from '74 ("Goodbye Yellowbrick Road" and "Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me") were from Elton. 🙂 He and "Macca" ruled much of the 70's American airwaves, and helped to foster my love for British musicians. *Love* this man, and have several of his earlier albums. 😊♥️ Thank you, Fil! xx
Not my favorite Elton John song from the 70's,, but he was definitely at the height of his talent during this time. Thanks also to Bernie Taupin he and Elton created meaningful songs unlike the pop stuff he did in later years.
cannonball666 ‘Daniel, ‘ and, ‘Your Song,’ were my favorite songs in the 70’s. Bennie and the Jets, played non stop in New England, when released.
Thank you Fil, on this
Very full information,
On Elton, and his techniques. A lot of info on his vocals 🎤and piano 🎹😊
FIL, THANKS FOR THE GREAT VIDEO AND YOUR COMMENTS, I SAW HIM IN DETROIT IN 1970, I THINK IT WAS HIS FIRST AMERICAN TOUR, HE PLAYED THE ALBUM TUMBLEWEED CONNECTION, HE CAME OUT WEARING BIB OVERHAULS, NO FEATHERS YET AT THIS POINT, ELTON ACTUALLY DANCED ON THE KEYBOARD AND IT SOUNDED LIKE HE WAS PLAYING, I DO NOT KNOW HOW HE DID THAT, BUT IT SOUNDED GREAT!! IT WAS AN AWESOME SHOW, ROCK ON FIL, COUSIN FIGEL
The best ever and even as a hard rocker, Elton is my life's musical inspiration. Thank you Elton
My favorite Elton John album, and one that people who like this performance might enjoy, is 11/17/70 (US title) from a NYC live radio broadcast and featuring the stripped-down original 3 piece he started with before Davey Johnstone added his guitar. The main reason this album is so notable IMO is that it relies on those dynamics you talk about from all three of the musicians. As a guitarist/bassist who has alway admired great guitar-centered trio rock and blues groups, this Elton John album was an awakening, because I heard the power and excitement they could generate without necessarily getting loud or having the sustained instrumental voice that guitars are capable of, even in a trio. Thanks, as always, for sharing your insight on this great performance by one of THE great artists of my generation.
Amazing!
Even then He was already a star!
I so appreciate your analysis of EJ, he is an Absolutely gifted and one-of-a-kind performer and musician! I love how you break it down in such depth!
He and Bernie are such a unique team...
Gosh! I’m stunned...these two guys in a happy marriage making this amazing music together. Since my early youth, 12 yrs old in 1970, I have listened and loved and worshiped them two. The earlier material is to die for.
Fil, u are such a great person to listen to. What u don’t know when it comes to the musicworld...its not for us to know✌️
Rock on ⚡️🎸⚡️
Yet another fantastic analysis, Fil! I saw Elton in 1972 for $4 in a small venue. One of the finest concerts I've ever seen! And Bernie wrote those lyrics when he was 19 years old- AMAZING!!! Thanks, Fil!
I was very happy to see you do Elton. I think Davey Johnstone is one, if not, the most under-rated guitarist out there.
Thank you so very much for reacting to the video I requested. A truly fantastic, in depth analysis, there is no other channel like this. You cover every single point, in the way, I wish I could do without making people glaze over after 2 minutes! As a side note, I am actually the son of a jazz musician, who went on to be a trance music producer and DJ, so my outlook on music is very rounded. I love artists who perform solo, accomplished by themselves, something we just don't see enough of now. I guess my professional taste is somewhat contradictory of the music I request. I love electronic music that can provide layer upon layer of sound, that would be impossible to achieve in a live performance.
Hey Fil, very well done! Perhaps my fave video of yours. You always do your homework. Your passion as a musician came out in this one. Elton and Bernie are/were a match made in heaven. Bernie and Elton's early work is right up there with the Lennon & McCartney, Simon & Garfunkel, etc. Such great story tellers and talented performers.
Your getting close to 100 K followers Fil.
You deserve the huge following. You do a great job!
I love Elton. Thank you for this one.
I also enjoy reading the comment section.
So many people have interesting history wrapped around particular music.
Thanks!
I was lucky to see Elton in Vegas...OH MY GOD WHAT A SHOW!!! So well worth the money! He was WONDEFUL!!!
Oh that voice that took me away for so many hours! Elton is pure magic here!
Elton John is so talented. Great analysis Fil Thank you😊
Elton John inspired me to pick up the piano in my day. Elton John such a talented human being and a master on the piano. He's amazing but he wouldn't be amazing by himself, Bernie Taupin was a great song writer for Elton. The two had a chemistry that no one could replace. Elton provided the rhythm and Bernie would provide the lyrical content. Elton has a magical voice that catches your attention and his electrifying piano playing captivated his audience, easily. Thanks for a great analysis Fil. Cheers!!! I wonder how many sunglasses he has now. Lol.
Wow! Elton sure can captivate you! I had never heard this particular song. I'm glad I have now, with your analysis, Fil! Dynamic range so powerful!
I like how you smile so much while watching the videos yourself. It’s cool. I don’t know if you just really enjoy what you do or what it is. It really cool though to see someone seem to really appreciate the talent being displayed. Especially seeing how much talent you have yourself as demonstrated in your performance videos.
Thanks!
I agree. Watching someone who is obviously enjoying what they do makes it more enjoyable for me.
I also like that you treat the musicians that you review with respect. You’re not out to build yourself up by tearing them down. You are sharing with us what makes these artists great. That is really what made me subscribe.
Funny you mentioned his smile, since I wanted to make a comment that this was one where he wasn't smiling until the end. This is the kind of song that you don't smile to, it is too powerful a performance, . But you are spot on about the respect that Fil has.
Lawrence Taylor He smiles right at the beginning. That’s when I started the comment. He does it on all the videos he watches though so as soon as I saw him start smiling at the beginning I started the comment.
The kind of Musical Perfection thats so hard to find now a days.
So true my friend you see lots of pop singers covering these very songs
This is pure raw talent! No digital effects on voice or piano playing. Just the genious that is Elton and magical lyrics by Bernie
Great going Fil.... One of my two very favorite Elton John songs. This and Sixty Years On. Pure bliss.
Fil, one of my favorite songs, gonna ramble... when I was a little kid I lived close to an am radio station and I was their paperboy for years and it was a long hike through the transmission field with Minnesota snow and they would let me in to warm up and I got to watch the dj through the glass and music was always the topic and I was given 45s to take home, to me music was everything and so expressive and I like your channel because you have the mindset that was present in the 60s-70s where you sought out information on the band/ artist and followed all the connections, this channel brings me back home, a sense of peace and stability in the artistic expression of the truly great ones and your presentation is very good because you actually know what you’re talking about! Thanks again fil and I’ll stay tuned... jj
Omg. Love this song by Elton. Being Native American it is a great song for us. And the piano parts resemble drums and the flutes that the ancestors played. Elton has such a sway and makes me feel I am into the story much more than a song played on guitar. He just makes it come alive.
I had forgotten about this song until is started...had me in tears by the time he was finished. Dynamics...something a lot of performers forget about, but they're sooooo important to moving a piece, musically. Thank you, Fil, for reminding me of this wonderful song...heartbreaking as it is to hear and contemplate...
Elton John has ALWAYS been a fantastic musician and singer. I will never forget the first time I heard "Your Song." That's one of those songs that you always remember the exact moment you first heard it. I'm so glad he's still going strong. A TRUE virtuoso. . . . .
Thank you so much for featuring a pianist! I am such a fan of piano (I recently asked you during the super chat if you had any opinion on keyboards vs piano ☺️). Was not familiar with this particular song...such an emotional performance. I wish more current artists played piano! I’d like to make a request for an analysis of Billy Joel - not sure whether you need for us to cite a particular video, or just suggest an artist? I will look and see if I can find any versions of Billy singing New York State of Mind, which is such a great song. Will see if I can find any that might be copyright free. Thank you again for this wonderful analysis. One thing I wanted to mention was that to me the sign of any great performance of a more emotional song (rather than a rocking performance that gets people moving and singing) is how attentively the audience is listening. At first I wasn’t even sure if there was a live audience, given how quiet everyone was! You could hear a pin drop. Thank you again. Am proud to be one of your patrons - I can say honestly that you give great value!! Rock! 🤘
I love his wonderful voice and performance. What a genius. I also have to add when I found those old videos (there are quite a few of them form the 70s) after seeing his film Rocket Man and getting into his music again after years I cried. Grew up in the 1970s with his wonderful music.
That was such an interesting analyses comparing the piano & the guitar. Elton is a Legend! His shows today are just as great as the were back in the late 70s when I saw him for the first time. I always wondered why so many English singers lost their accent when they sang!
Extremely underrated song on the Madman album.
Yes. I just started playing the violin this month and I can tell how much I am actually thinking about each aspect of instruction. There is no expression in plucking, except maybe laughter. :) I couldn’t imagine being a master, perhaps one day. Thanks Fil!
Great video ! Love all you stuff ! Thanks Fil !
Thanks so much!! This is such a fantastic song...I'd love to hear you review some more early 70's Elton John songs.
One of the greatest performers of our times! I don’t think I could say much more about this man but a legend or musical genius! The amazing relationship he has with his piano is phenomenal and the result is pure magic! Excellent analysis Fil! Cheers Mario! 😀🤘🤘
While in the US Air Force stationed in Germany, they had a wreck room with a piano.
I would take my cassette player with some of my favorite music and learned how to play.
After I got out of the military I continued practicing.
After I accepted Jesus as my Savior, I began to play at church for Him.
Great analysis Fil, always liked Elton's music.
Phil, well done! So cool you covered EJ. Dude, you could guest lecture at Michigan, Harvard, Yale, Oxford. Such a great show.
As a long time keyboard guy I must give you kudos for your great analysis of forming emotions with the piano♪♫♪
Always thought if I could play the piano that I would want to master it as well as Elton, the emotions of his songs came through the piano. No autotune needed for legends like him, original great voice and talent. Great review, :)
Playing both guitar & piano l found many of my most emotional songs l wrote l composed on piano and often transfered them onto guitar for use in the band while some had to remain piano songs with me behind the piano to keep the emotional impact in tact. What an iconic pairing in music history..Elton and Bernie. Such stunning incredible lyrics and Elton John's music and vocals! Elton John a true icon in Every sense of the word..larger than life. What a career and well deserved success! One of the few artists l never saw live and wish l had. Great Review as usual Fil! Thanks!😎🎼🎶🎵🇨🇦
I remember my Metal head friend teasing my horribly for listening to Elton but I would fight over it .
The part I find most fascinating is, artists usually write songs from their own emotions, experiences & how they see life, but in his case, Elton had Bernie write the songs yet sang them as if it was from his own words.
Elton John one of the greatest musicians to come out of the 70s!
I am musically smitten with him, but I have him as fourth. Before you fret, hear who are the other three - Wonder, McCartney, and Quincy Jones. I know, Quincy Jones? Yeah. But 4th place considering those 3 is definitely god territory.
I grew up in the 70's. Elton and Macca were a big part of my childhood musical landscape (and Barry Manilow..lol).
You didn't Fil you just made my day
Great review Fil. Ok, now that you've opened the piano door--Bill Joel. Endless material there for you going back to the early 70's with plenty of juicy guitar riffs!
Elton John another singer that you can tell is unique voice in 3 seconds ! What a tremendously talented artist for so many decades 😎🎹 Sweet video , analysis and back story... Thank-you Fil ! ✌😎
Request: Dr.John playing "Such A Night" w/ The Band from the Last Waltz concert 😎🎹 Another very unique voice.......
I know "Right Place,Wrong Time was his big hit but I really love the "Such A Night" tune......,thanx Fil !
HAPPY HALLOWEEN 🎃
Fil & viewers ✌😎
I used to have a CD of EJ’s Tokyo 1971 concert (recorded from a radio broadcast) that I received about 10 years ago. Each song an instant classic. Love EJ and think I’ve seen him in concert more than any other musician (including his 60th birthday show at Madison Square Garden). This video made my day - thank you so much for this analysis!
During the 70s when young I enjoyed listening to Elton. Now when I listen I hear a great classic musician who will be enjoyed for years to come by young and old.
No auto tune here. Pure and raw emotion.
Five times I've seen Elton John, and his Farewell Yellow Brick Road was the first time I've ever heard Indian Sunset live.. Thank you for the great analysis! Legend, that he is..
He is so mesmerizingly brilliant, thanks for this!
BRILLIANT analysis, Fil ! :-)
I was 11 years old in 1971 . That's probably around the age I started buying Eltons records. Mostly singles from my parents giving me an allowance.. And it was just for his talent and voicd because it was rare if I even got to see him on tv at that age . Great Video And packed full of wonderful information . !! :0) It's Halloween night here as I'm watching this .So Happy Halloween !!
Tiny Dancer one of my faves. Saw him in California a long time ago. Fil, I love your analysis. Never thought of piano like that.
Thanks for bringing this to us, it is so powerful
Love Elton's music, this song was new to me. Very intense. Thank you for posting it.
It was a long time within my life before I knew who Bernie Taupin was. Even later still that Burt Bacharach's lyricist was Hal David. It's amazing how over the years duo's like these have made such great music.
One of my favorite pianists is George Winston. He did one piece where he actually muted the strings on the piano. I had never seen anyone do this before.
Elton is a great talent. His music is seared into my memory from my teenage years in the 70s.
In the 80's I picked up an album called Elton John 11*17*70. It was a recording in a small club and half the songs were covers. His voice was rough and immature and awesome. I became an instant fan! I see now it may have been an "unofficial" purchase.
What an incredible musical journey Sr. Elton John has had. superb analysis and breakdown on this performance. "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" among other I like of his.
Thanks fil I find your Analysis’s 🤔 really great!