Gla1ve had the structures and the GOAT coach to lean on. He hasn't proven anything since the legendary roster split up. Karrigan has proven several times that he is able to build a team from scratch and take it to the top. He's been playing at the highest level for over a decade and is able to adapt his calling to new metas
Gla1ve won 4 majors and created the most dominant team in CS history. Karrigan brought 3 different teams (4 if you count pre-gla1ve Astralis) to the top throughout his career so far, can consistently make the players under him shine, and shows no sign of stopping soon. Either way, it’s a great debate and the CS scene is better with them in it
I think gla1ve inherited a successful roster that was molded by karrigan and needed a bit more time or minor changes to become great. Now that gla1ve has had some changes he's struggled to find any form of success, if Karrigan was the IGL of this current iteration of Astralis that has dev1ce and blameF I have no doubt that they'd look a lot better than they do. Basically I don't rate gla1ve as highly because he didn't build the team from scratch, just came into a team that was already a perennial contender at the right time.
Im not taking everything from Karrigan, but Gla1ve didnt had "superstars" and big "aimers" but yeah u can keep talking about this for a long time :) Both are legends
I just wanna correct something, and I don't wanna come across as a douch. But gla1ve didn't create the most dominant team. He joined the most dominant core (device, Dupree, xyp9x)
@@jdiscount I think both are legends and both of them deserve respect but I feel like the huge factor about dominant astralis era was the fact that their IGL was literally top8 player in th world at that time. There is not much you can do vs a team that has 3 insane rifflers, top tier firepower IGL and a clutcher that wins unwinnable rounds so often. Obviously gla1ve calls were amazing, he was reading his enemies like a open book, I can literally remember games when his Tside was amazing, not going into a single stack, always attacking the right side of the map but his firepower was imho his stronger side
Karrigan vs Gla1ve is like Dev1ce vs S1mple one has all of the stats to be the GOAT whilst the other is widely considered to be the GOAT even without all of the accolades
Cos his team is underperforming hard lately. Not sure it's entirely his fault but like when Astralis is floundering, you don't really want to highlight them
Gla1ve has stagnated in his calling and hasn't achieved anything in the past 3 years now. Before he was the blueprint of what an ideal IGL is, but right now it hasn't been the case. If you're talking about past achievements, of course gla1ve takes the cake but right now i can't say the same.
Gla1ve is an IGL in a danish team and karrigan is IGLing an International team. I think its easier to IGL a team in you own language then in you second language.
@@xxivkraegen2124 why you salty I didn't even said anything about karrigan, just said video would've been more impactful if we heard more igls talking about karrigan being the goat igl, instead of keeping him in the same video. (Plus you yourself said he was leading a superteam so tell me how does that helps your argument )
Gla1ve won everything with the team that had karrigan as igl before him, Karrigan play csgo from begging and ten years later he won firsts big tournaments, and gla1ve was igl for the greatness team ever. Karrigan is great, but gla1ve is the best igl of all time
i cant decide, glaive is talking in his own language but karrigan speaks eng, glaive 4 majors but last year they are in shits and karr is consistent... i dont really know
Remember that Karrigan has won t1 trophies ever since the game came out. Gla1ve only did with the legendary astralis line-up. I'd say karrigan is the goat igl, but gla1ve has accomplished more as an igl if that makes any sense .
Why karrigan is better then gla1ve? Because he changed teams and all of these teams performed better then before karrigan...gla1ve had/have a chance now to show that he is best...but sadly Astralis is underperforming so far... More majors... It is not time yet to count majors... let's wait until they both finish their careers...then we can count majors:)
There is no way he is GOAT , If astralis were on thier previous form Nobody would have picked Karrigan . 4 Major championship + many top tier Victories Gla1ve is the real GOAT
Gla1ve had the structures and the GOAT coach to lean on. He hasn't proven anything since the legendary roster split up. Karrigan has proven several times that he is able to build a team from scratch and take it to the top. He's been playing at the highest level for over a decade and is able to adapt his calling to new metas
Niko caught strays from both Karrigan and Nexa!
I thought that was pretty funny hearing that
and Aleksib
Gla1ve won 4 majors and created the most dominant team in CS history. Karrigan brought 3 different teams (4 if you count pre-gla1ve Astralis) to the top throughout his career so far, can consistently make the players under him shine, and shows no sign of stopping soon. Either way, it’s a great debate and the CS scene is better with them in it
I think gla1ve inherited a successful roster that was molded by karrigan and needed a bit more time or minor changes to become great.
Now that gla1ve has had some changes he's struggled to find any form of success, if Karrigan was the IGL of this current iteration of Astralis that has dev1ce and blameF I have no doubt that they'd look a lot better than they do.
Basically I don't rate gla1ve as highly because he didn't build the team from scratch, just came into a team that was already a perennial contender at the right time.
Im not taking everything from Karrigan, but Gla1ve didnt had "superstars" and big "aimers" but yeah u can keep talking about this for a long time :) Both are legends
@@jdiscount I give it to karrigan
like try to compare if we never had karrigan vs gla1ve
I just wanna correct something, and I don't wanna come across as a douch. But gla1ve didn't create the most dominant team. He joined the most dominant core (device, Dupree, xyp9x)
@@jdiscount I think both are legends and both of them deserve respect but I feel like the huge factor about dominant astralis era was the fact that their IGL was literally top8 player in th world at that time. There is not much you can do vs a team that has 3 insane rifflers, top tier firepower IGL and a clutcher that wins unwinnable rounds so often.
Obviously gla1ve calls were amazing, he was reading his enemies like a open book, I can literally remember games when his Tside was amazing, not going into a single stack, always attacking the right side of the map but his firepower was imho his stronger side
Karrigan vs Gla1ve is like Dev1ce vs S1mple
one has all of the stats to be the GOAT whilst the other is widely considered to be the GOAT even without all of the accolades
karrigan best support player. ropz most valuable player - pair of two unbeatable players to date
I like how nobody talks about gla1ve who changed the meta and who created one of the most dominant eras ever
Cos his team is underperforming hard lately. Not sure it's entirely his fault but like when Astralis is floundering, you don't really want to highlight them
Nitr0 did talk about gla1ve but still decided on karrigan as the best
Gla1ve has stagnated in his calling and hasn't achieved anything in the past 3 years now. Before he was the blueprint of what an ideal IGL is, but right now it hasn't been the case. If you're talking about past achievements, of course gla1ve takes the cake but right now i can't say the same.
Not their fault they forgot about gla1ve, he's like the 5th best IGL in Denmark.
@@garuda1221 Of course they are talking about past achievements, they were asked who the greatest IGL of all time was....
Gla1ve is an IGL in a danish team and karrigan is IGLing an International team. I think its easier to IGL a team in you own language then in you second language.
Karrigan IS THE BEST
I think it would've been more powerful if someone other than karrigan was interviewed with the other two.
You tripping karrigan was leading the faze superteam even before 2021. They won a lot and it only went downhill after they lost the boston major
@@xxivkraegen2124 why you salty I didn't even said anything about karrigan, just said video would've been more impactful if we heard more igls talking about karrigan being the goat igl, instead of keeping him in the same video. (Plus you yourself said he was leading a superteam so tell me how does that helps your argument )
@@lavincex6521 I was reading your comment the wrong way before I saw the explanation 😅😅
Nitro really likes the word like
Amazing vid! Like always! Just didnt like the title, its so reductive of the whole amazing convo.
he clearly is AND he not done yet.
ik im late asl but how long do you think this whole faze team stays together? and how long he will play? bro is 33
Karrigan, for me you are the best and nobdy can change my mind.
great content but the aspect ratio is just pretentious
fun fact: nitr0 is the only one of these not to play with NiKo in a major grand final.
Gla1ve won everything with the team that had karrigan as igl before him, Karrigan play csgo from begging and ten years later he won firsts big tournaments, and gla1ve was igl for the greatness team ever. Karrigan is great, but gla1ve is the best igl of all time
i cant decide, glaive is talking in his own language but karrigan speaks eng, glaive 4 majors but last year they are in shits and karr is consistent... i dont really know
Remember that Karrigan has won t1 trophies ever since the game came out. Gla1ve only did with the legendary astralis line-up.
I'd say karrigan is the goat igl, but gla1ve has accomplished more as an igl if that makes any sense .
Where is my boy Zeus blea?
Hooxi is my master
J'sais même pas qui était le meilleur en 2022 : Simple ou Karigan
Karrigan
nexa talkign about people not trusting him, so did karrigan.... who did they have in common? lmao
Why karrigan is better then gla1ve? Because he changed teams and all of these teams performed better then before karrigan...gla1ve had/have a chance now to show that he is best...but sadly Astralis is underperforming so far... More majors... It is not time yet to count majors... let's wait until they both finish their careers...then we can count majors:)
Faze performed better because they got ropz and twitzz...faze always had the better player but still choke very often
How could he ever be the goat compared to the one and only gigachad hooxi
short answer - no, he is not
Jame?
who
wins one major = goat
Your pfp checks out
@@stormy9144 And you're playing cs irl i see
@@ronniescottie3634 And who ?
@@martinkrejci6842 asked u?
But who?
gla1ve is the goat 🐐
Prime gla1ve >
😀
Gla1ve easy. They dominated for 2 years and won 3 Majors in a row with countless other trophies.
HOOXI > ALL OF IGL
gla1ve is all time best IGL
cadiaN*
first
Major respect to karrigan but Gla1ve is better.
There is no way he is GOAT , If astralis were on thier previous form Nobody would have picked Karrigan . 4 Major championship + many top tier Victories Gla1ve is the real GOAT
Karrigod
Gla1ve still better.
Just not on the server