Staccato 2011 XC Review - Can an advantage be bought?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 апр 2024
- As a competition shooter, it has been great to see rules relax to where manufactures are going these days. As a result, the XC, Staccato’s flagship model… has increased in popularity and I had to get my hands on one. But this begs the question… can it be so Good that it provides an advantage? In this video, I review the Staccato XC.
Checkout the Shootout between this Gun against the Nighthawk TRS Comp, Sand Viper, and the Masterpiece Arms DS9 (Ported):
• Staccato XC vs Sand Vi...
#staccato2011 #staccato #staccatoXC #2011
The action of the XC has to be experienced to be believed. So slick and smooth.
Buy once, cry once. Pass it down generationally.
I have this gun and I love it
Excited for the Nighthawk TRS (Sandhawk) comparison follow up! Great content as always. The grip kinemantic with the middle finger body mechanics is such an amazing tip.
Ready nice-looking gun and made in the USA by veterans. Worth the money!
I saw you let David review the MPA. Good stuff
I can't wait for the next episode
I enjoy your content good stuff
excellent overview as usual, much appreciated. my friend purchased one.. it is a cheat code. I suppose the old saying, "its the Indian, not the arrow" doesnt hold up when the arrow is over 4k. :P
I didn’t mention this in the video as I didn’t have time… but I’m surprised how many LEOs in my local municipality carry these. It’s also a great conversation starter with them. But these gentlemen are making proactive choices to buy them at their own expense just because they love how these shoot.
That’s what I love about the Staccato and the mags is that they engineered the mag extensions exactly the length it needs so there is no chance of over insertion anymore like other 1911 double stacks. Great review and XC! Thanks!
2 different XC’s and they both have experienced over-insertion with 20-rd mags. Locked the whole pistol up whenever that happens.
More great content, Paul. DP “Bro”… 😂😂😂
What. A great gun
Are y’all long lost brothers?
@@Yellow_Flannel That'd be impossible Paul is half avocado.
Good stuff Paul. As with all guns I think that the "advantage" this gun provides covers up the "sin" of bad technique especially in A/B class shooters (Like EX/Low level MAs in IDPA). When it comes to things like for duty use I am all for that. Most LEOs don't train as much with their gun so I want the tool to make the job easier. I think in competition it gives people a false sense of ability. As you discovered on your transitions drills. It's similar to when red dots started getting popular on carry guns. Over time, the skill level will rise to meet the equipment. I think the same is true here. I look forward to where the shooting sports will be in the next 10 years.
Also "epitome" pronounced: Eh-PIT-oh-mee not epy-TOME.
Oh you know I agree as you and I have experience in other things to validate that.
To answer…YES!
Spoiler alert, the XC beats the TRS Comp/MPA/Sand or Pit Viper and it's the best bang for your buck.
MPA makes a comped gun? It makes perfect sense that a quasi-open gun is going to beat a limited gun.
I’m curious, I’m relatively new to 2011’s, what makes the XC “beat” any of the pistols you listed? Now I’ve heard several people commend the XC but I’m wondering what makes it better than another 2011 because I haven’t heard that ? Legit question, trying to learn or at least decide if the info makes sense. Thanks in advance
@michaeltaylor1517 the XC is the cheaper of the ones mentioned in the video. Out of thr comped guns, its the only one with a one piece barrel/comp combo, some say it shoots better than the TRS Comp with a better trigger for about $2k depending on the features you get from NH that come stock on the XC. Pit/Sand Viper are way overpriced due to the whole John Wick movie. Check out RDR gear where he compares the XC, TRS Comp and Sand Viper.
Thanks for the info, I would assume the XC is cheaper due to the polymer grip vs the steel/aluminum ones on the others tho no, although I think the taran ones are polymer as well? Idk man, I just bought an atlas to replace my shadow 2 for competition and within the same week I bought the nighthawk trs commander but I haven’t shot that and neither are comp’d. I think if staccato went with a metal grip like the E2 by cheely they would be closer in price to some of the others and I watched a video dogging polymer triggers in 2011’s but idk how true that is due to lack of experience with them. I will watch that video you suggested tho, thanks for the info , I really do appreciate it!!
@michaeltaylor1517 the Atlas is a very good choice, some prefer the Athena over the XC due to the tight tolerances, better trigger, better/metal grips and ergos. I'm just saying that for a production gun, Staccato XC is a very good gun for the money.
The quality is obvious. I'm just not sure how that translates into an advantage. It just looks like a fully optimized 2011.
You mentioned it ran flawlessly. However with the comp are there any ammunition considerations or will it run reliably on most production ammunition?
So I ran Blazer 115 A, Sig 124 +P, Fed124, as well as AS 124 JHP. All fed and ran. I wouldn’t run subsonic ammo through this for performance reasons (lack of gas to work the comp)… but I can certainly do it as a follow up item on the shootout video
Would love to have one of these, although they seem less practical for uspsa since it pushes you into open.
I mean… Nils won Limited Nats shooting Minor 😂
But I’m with you on that. Generally speaking… once we start to look at competition guns in this price range… the qualification becomes broader as well as the justified use.
@@TheGentlemanGunnerBob Vogel also won open major shooting a stock g35 with his irons.
@@chrisharris6834 Chris Harris also won Pineywoods shooting with his hands only 😎
@@TheGentlemanGunner😂😂😂😂these are facts I seent it meself
Since you have a P, would you trade it for an XC? Or find any reason to keep it if you have an XC?
Good video thanks! Do you miss an aluminum or steel grip or metal trigger? The XC always looks amazing but 4300 gets you plenty of all metal double stack options.
Good question, I prefer those things… but the XC’s selling point isn’t parts. It’s what is the best shooting gun they can make and shooting it makes you forget those nice to have items. But without spending time on it, it can dilute the perceived value as to why are there polymer in places where it’d be nice have aluminum/steel. Best illustration I can come up with is how the Corvette’s body panels have been fiberglass/composite rather than metal… three reasons… general weight savings, having the ability to increase chassis stiffnesses as well as weight distribution… part of what makes the Corvette a “Corvette”. Having the polymer grip, helps with weight, recoil absorption, and improved ergonomics (easier to mold polymer).
@@TheGentlemanGunner Kinda wish someone would do a Turk High power clone review with a Cylinder and Slide 2# trigger kit. Be nice for the poors to have some sao options under $1000 that ran on cheap reliable mags to casually compete with.
Mpa is suppose to be coming out with a comped gun soon. If it is priced anything near the staccato it will be market disruptive.
Yes, we probably have 4-5 shooters consistently using them now.
For IDPA? Or for USPSA?
@@coltontaylor4572 IDPA - Carry Optic; You can shoot USPSA with this, but it scored as Open Minor (vs Major)
Which do you prefer for idpa carry optics the XC or the DS9 now that you shot both?
Why do you ask such hard questions?!?! 🤣🤣🤣… I’m going to do another round of testing and reserve that for the shoot off video!
@@TheGentlemanGunner 😂😂😂 to be honest now that I am watching your video again. I think I will just wait to see what mpa comes out with. Mpa will probably have a better sub 2lb trigger out the box and no grip safety to monkey around with. I just bought an atlas Athena as a do all gun to hold me over till figure out dedicated guns for limited optics and idpa carry optics. Been shooting an sp01 for years but my grip caused my hand to bleed after ever match. Not a problem with the Athena so far. Going to order an mpa loc based on your video alone.
@@TheDuppyman have you seen David’s review of comped vs Ported? That’ll support what you’re thinking 😎
ruclips.net/video/UPgeHAAUfbQ/видео.htmlsi=35YlEPuZyplUv93Z
What about the width? You didn’t slide anything across the top. Some say the ambi safety is too wide and it won’t pass the equipment check at major matches. Can you confirm?
It slides over
I think you said epitome wrong. 10:37
Nah (I am joking)
Would you recommend their 2.5 or 4 pound trigger for edc?
I’d say 4 is sufficient
How is it against the MPA DS9!?!?!? I ask because i own one
..
Im working on the shootout video with this and between the Ported DS9, TRS Comp and Sand Viper... stay tuned!
Can’t wait! Just wish there was an Erebus as well.
@@TheGentlemanGunner can't wait as well! I have the ported DS9 too
How much shit comes out the top of that chunk port watch out yeah right lol😅😅
Can it handle 9mm major?
I wouldn’t recommend it. There’s a question of can it handle a round of it… possibly (assuming it can chamber it)… but whether it can do it more than once is another question. The guns that can truly handle 9 major have thicker barrels, links, etc…
Per Staccatos website
"What ammo pressure levels can I run through my Staccato 2011®?
Standard pressure level and +P rated ammunition.
**Do NOT use +P+ rated ammunition"
Classic Firearms intro music to your video?..
I don’t know and don’t watch that channel as well as what song you’re talking about (there’s a total of 4)… this is all royalty-free music from Storyblocks.com that thousands of people have access to. So you’re probably correct, but that means that there are probably thousands of other channels that likely have this too.
I’m surprised you don’t get more clicks. The thumbnails are always so tight. Maybe the doom scroller looks for more punchy (ugly in my opinion) pictures.
How would a fiber optic sight be useful at night? It needs light… gun geeks
You’re right and I have to own this one lol. So I ran a low-light stage sometime ago and at the time, I had a green fiber and was thinking… how it made it easier to differentiate… but keyword is in low light is LIGHT. Good catch 😂
Why do u say delta point bro
you can say 2011 to describe any double stack 1911 that has a slide frame and grip. Trademarks only apply to other companies not what we say. Same way you call tissue paper Kleenex.
I physically cringed at the "deltapoint bro"