Honestly, all this money on haircuts and eyewear, I'm beginning to think Andy has problem. I'm worried about the well-being of the children. Has anyone ever seen the wife?
The Mahavishnu is what brought me to this channel and I love to hear Andy extolling the virtues of this band. There would be no Close to the Edge without MO. I think Jerry Goodman and John playing in unison is such an unearthly sound, eerie and beautiful.
A fellow hard rocker introduced me to MO. I had no idea what rock/jazz fusion was. He died (at just 50) a few short years later. I think of him every time i listen to Birds of Fire. Miss you, Dave.
At 72 years old, Meeting of the Spirits still thrills and astounds as much as it did in 1971 or 1972. Interestingly, I was led to it for Billy Cobham. A discussion about rock drummers with an American exchange student ( thank you Mark L for this, and CTA) resulted in a listen at Rare Records, Manchester. A minute of MotS, and I was stunned and hooked!
Inner Worlds is a LITTLE bit unfocused? My god, it's embarrassingly horrible. It's McLaughlin's "Giant For a Day." On a side note, I was at the show where Nothingness was recorded -- press tickets , first row center. And to this day , it's the most incredible live performance I ever heard.
Saw the Birds of Fire show in Nov of 73 in St Petersburg Florida.I followed John Mc. since his time with Miles.The two girls we took to the show couldn't handle it and went out and sat in the car.The Orchestra totally brought the Fire! Billy Cobham is as advertised!
Hi Andy, I'm enjoying your channel since I discovered you about a couple of months ago. No sooner had I finished watching this ranking video on the Mahavishnu Orchestra that I went on eBay and immediately purchased what I hope is a good copy of 'Between Nothingness & Eternity' without ever having listened to it! That's the power of your passion for this music rubbing off on me. I've got the books '1001 Albums and 1001 Classical Albums You Must Listen To Before You Didn't and if there was an equivalent on both Prog music and Jazz, I'd snap them up straight away. Right now I can't think of anyone better than you to compile them. May your channel continue to grow.
I gave that Mahavishnu Orchestra another go due to you as you are always raving about them. I'm 50 now but prior to the last year my only exposure to them was finding them in my mate's dads record collection when I was about 15. I wasn't ready or able to listen properly or appreciate them then. I remember just thinking it was weird rubbish, ah the folly of youth. Thanks for reintroducing me to them as I can now hear the beauty and genius in them.
@@RobArmiter your comment reminds me of when my elder sisters boyfriend played me John Coltrane when I was about 14. Then, 1965, I was into Delta & Chicago blues R&B and folk. I thought it was just noise, rubbish. It wasn’t until my 20’s after being blown away by MO that I could hear what a genius Coltrane was. I mention this as he was a major influence on McLaughlin who wanted to sound like Train.
Hi Andy, thanks for the video. Just to let you know there is a Puerto Rican in your audience, and the album you placed at #4 was recorded in 1972 at the legendary Festival Mar y Sol in Vega Baja, Puerto Rico. It is probably the most famous musical event in the island's history, with highlights like the extraordinary performance of the Mahavishnu Orchestra, and an amazing set by Emerson, Lake and Palmer (festival's headliners). For many years the album you showed in the video was considered a collector's item, I know people in the island who own it (as well as peolple who were there). Don't know if the album was ever released on CD, but despite the chaotic organization of the festival, the recording is evidence of undeniable musical brilliance. And #4 is quite high on the list... Thanks.😎
Your top 3 mirrors mine. In my younger days, I had seen a glimpse of freedom in music from the Jimi Hendrix Experience as well as Zeppelin and was really into classic prog rock as well- Yes, Rush, Crimson, etc. This was ‘91, so I had my ears on 80’s metal of all types as well. I remember my musical compatriot bringing this in and putting on the cd player and it’s like a bomb went off in my musical world. For the first time I heard freedom over intense compositions. It served as my back door into the world of Jazz as well as Indian Classical and world music.
Great video Andy. I'm happy to be part of your viewing community. The new studio looks amazing. Can't wait for what you have planned for future videos. Cheers!
My own intro to John Mclaughlin was back when I was a 17 year-old high school student back in the '80s & just picking up the guitar - at my best friend's house with us admiringly listening to Van Halen when his older brother by 5 years (these guys were from a musical family - he played guitar, bass, keyboards and some drums) stolled in and quipped (and I remember his exact words) - "John McLaughlin can play twice as fast as Van Halen and ad lib while he's doing it". Really? I thought... I had to check it out... I bought soon after "Birds Of Fire" & was blown away - he was right. But as much as I loved "Birds Of Fire", when I first heard "Inner Mounting Flame" (part of my friend's older brother's LP collection) I was ABSOLUTELY blown away... I've (of course) listened to other Mahavishnu albums - especially in this age of Amazon Music, RUclips, etc. over the years, but none excite me more than "Inner Mounting Flame". On this album, you have 5 totally top-notch musicians going in with a musically completely novel concept, taking the ball, and really running with it as a unit in a way that'd been seldom heard before from music that could be considered "rock". It was totally fresh, spontanious, passionate, and played with incredibly executed - and improvised - musicical virtuosity... I'm listening to it as I write, and it still - after 40 years - absolutely knocks my f'n socks off. Great #1. It would be mine own Mahavishnu pick too, and would also be among my desert island albums. As a fellow Mahivishnu fan, I appreciated this video & congrats to your recent success - I sincerely hope it continues.
Never listened to these before and just sat charging my works EV and listened to your number 1 and2 and WOW will certainly be doing a deep dive into them WOW cheers Andy keep up the good work
Andy - what a wonderful video! Congratulations on your new charming venue. I'm also glad to hear of Jean-Luc Ponty' positive reaction to your content and look forward to your interviewing him. I was in high school when the Mahavisnhu Orchestra debuted and also instantly liked them. Thanks for continuing to share your insights on great music as well as various trends.
I've been deeply into Mahavishnu since 1974, starting with Inner Mounting Flame. I've heard all their albums, and there are so many great ones! But this one (I agree) is pure energy. The cut I've played the very most, in utter ecstasy, is "Dawn".
The rawness of the Lost Trident Sessions is so powerful! I absolutely love that album, buying it as soon as it came out; and I was not disappointed! And the groove in Sister Andrea is unbelievable along with McLaughlin’s huge, emotional descending solo. Incredible!!!
As an ignorant young college student I once stumbled Into in a rehearsal of the Boston Symphony Orchestra performing Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas. As he made his comments to the orchestra he would turn to the 5 or 6 students sitting in the audience to explain the piece and what he was doing with the orchestra. I was transfixed. Here was a teacher. Since then I became a fan of MTT. So when I saw his name on a Mahavishnu album I bought it. That’s how I discovered this great band! They only got better as I learned more.
I too discovered Birds of Fire - in 1973 (I was 24). I was obsessed with it, carried it around & played it wherever there was a turntable, & listened to nothing else for a month. My friend & sometimes bandmate Russ Tubbs found the first album ... And in 1975? Russ got the spot on sax on "Visions of the Emerald Beyond." Since then he's done solo stuff & a lit wit Carlos Santana etc. I saw him & the band in NYC supporting the Visions album & had dinner with him afterward - actually the last time insaw him (I moved away)
Yes, come on Jean-Luc! I loved that story about your mum buying 'Birds Of Fire' and leaving it out on the mantlepiece for you. I've just ordered a vinyl copy of 'Visions...' so can't wait to get that. The sound and everything was really good on this one, Andy, like you've made the studio your second home / den / shed / garage, what have you.
Great stuff. Head trip zone again for you, regarding talking to Ponty. I admire you for making those type of moves, as I’ve always got anxious at the idea of whether I’d want to mix the two worlds of the early childhood perception and memory of people and places,( with all their accompanying wonderment), with the cold reality of things as they actually are, through the prism of age/wisdom/understanding. Great vid.
Vital transformation is my favorourite track, starting of with blistering and rigid drums, Jan Hammer starring with Rhodes with ringmodulator parts. Full speed ahead!
Ahhh. Mahavishnu. Wonderful video. Well most anything related to McLaughlin is candy for me. You mention being too close to MO…I too am way too close. I see that VotEB has fallen but I agree with the pretext. And it too remains my all time favorite album. Love your setup in the corner. Saw your painting hanging in the new place but don’t see it here. Congratulations on your growing success Andy..well deserved!
Honourable mentions must also go to the two John McLaughlin albums, My Goal's Beyond from 1971 and his album with Carlos Santana, Love Devotion and Surrende from 1973. The acoustic music of My Goal's Beyond show the beginnings of John's fusion of Indian classical and Jazz, it also features Jerry Goodman. The Santana album is in the same musical vein as Mahavishnu Orchestra as well as featuring Billy Cobham on the drums.
The MO were a revelation to me from the 1st album...incredible playing and Billy playing like 2 drummers...I saw them twice live and they were awesome...It's tough listening for most...but the originalty and spirit of this great music/compositions has somehow prevailed...So thanks for highlighting this ground breaking band - Cheers
It's interesting mentioning the dying out of the music tutor as a role. I've been keeping it going for nearly 30 years now and as a self taught guitar player I find it difficult to justify myself and my chosen career path. Fortunately only two years away from retirement and I won't have to compete with the endless resources that are available now. It's great you've found something that helps you out but I must add it's something you are very good at. I'm a fan of the Mahavishnu Orchestra and I've learnt so much from this one video. If i were to pick a number one it would be the Trident Sessions. First time I heard it I was knocked out. Great job as always and I hope the new studio works out for you.
MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA-I followed John McLaughlin,Billy Cobham,Jan Hammer. And have great recordings of Rick Laird as well. Not to mention Narada Micheal Walden, who I followed as well! And Jean-Luc Ponty, I followed him, and love his music as well!!!They were one of the greatest groups ever! I also, followed Jeff Beck everywhere! And Stanley Clarke, and Marcus Miller, so I really love your channel,FUSION LIVES!!!
Thank you. This is one of those bands could never figure out a great entry point. I'm familiar with McLaughlin thanks to my favorite Miles Davis albums and box sets he's on.
You are a true fan of mahavishnu. Like me. I totally share your ranking and i am at 3 min of your video. I imagine it will be a reverse chronogical rank or almost. I think that there is cd before and after mahavishnu naming extrapolation, shakti or electric dreams. Let me know what you thing. Pierre from France 🙏
Birds Of Fire got me started on MO, John McLaughlin and jazz in 1979. For the longest time it was my favorite MO album. It’s since been replaced by Visions Of The Emerald Beyond. Visions brought heavy doses of the funk, fury and spirituality in a way the others do not. Oh, and thanks for the Tim Bowness interlude. I’m a major fan of his too.
Love the revised order (although I'd flip 3 and 4). Love the intermission. Love ALL the comments! The friend of Abercrombie was Jan Hammer. It's funny how over time i can overlook bad fidelity--i really had a hard time listening to early Tony Williams Lifetime in the mid 70's, now i love it. That rawness is why I've always preferred IMF to BOF (and as much as the moog solos on BOF are trail-blazing, i SO dig the ring-mod Rhoades of IMF) FIVE STAR REVIEW 🎉
There was a restaurant near me called Mahavishnu Orchestra. It was owned and run by a yellow robot with pink squirrels for chefs and staff. I remember banging a huge gong in there, using Paul McCartney as the mallet to strike it. They were dead against garden peas and sliced carrots.
I share your love of the MO. I was a freshman at Boston University in 1971. I soon met a fellow who had Devotion and My Goal's Beyond. I was hooked. We bought IMF upon its release. Hitch-hiked to URI for December concert of MO (with BOC and Byrds.) I thought I was ready for them, Hah! Absolutely earth-shattering! Saw them next in '72 at Symphony Hall Boston with Jerry Garcia. Disappointed because high volume turned the sound to mud. Saw them again in Boston late '73. Not sure if it was The Music Hall or Orpheum, but I am sure it was the best concert I've ever seen (including Bowie, Marley, Miles, etc.) They were positively telepathic and edifying; a unified musical entity w/Cobham as the bone structure. I'm 71 now, but I'm cool with it. I saw the incredible, original, MO.
Inner Mounting Flame changed my life for sure! As for The Lost Trident Sessions, I have a suggestion that may or may not bump it up a notch or two on your list: change the running order. After growing up listening to Between Nothingness and Eternity, starting TLTS with Dream made the rest seem anti-climatic. So I've ripped it into iTunes and my revised running order is Trilogy, I Wonder, Sister Andrea, Stepping Tones, John's Song #2, and Dream. Makes the whole album flow much better, imho... Thanks for another great vid AE!
I love this band and all of the incredible incarnations. For me I’ve always had more of an affinity for the second incarnation as it has some beautiful & melodic music. My favourite album by the MO and some of my favourite albums of all time. Apocalypse is sublime epicness with George Martin. Visions Of The Emerald Beyond is a very close second but Inner Worlds is my personal favourite record by this band. Pretty underrated as you said that this lineup of the band just couldn’t live up to what was the original lineup.
In 1971 I was 15 & at the crossroads of many of the GREATEST albums ever produced during such a powerful turning point in the life of a young man's consciousness. As an aspiring visual artist, my best friends at school were musicians in training and we were very open to anything groundbreaking! With the changes introduced by The BEATLES, HENDRIX, MILES/COLTRANE & ZAPPA we were ready for all the breakthroughs in the early 70's like KC, YES, OSIBISA, GAYE but MAHAVISHNU was another revelation! Then in 1974 while in NYC Central Park I saw LIVE the "BETWEEN NOTHINGNESS & ETERNITY" album's actual recorded concert. And by this point, I was a fan of Psychedelics so you can't imagine what it was like seeing this band performing that for the first time outdoors in that State of Being! INFRKNCREDIBLE!
I'm gonna have to track down the last 3....Inner to Radio, I've never heard these but I have the rest and love them as much as you. these records give me goosebumps every time I listen to them. I heard the lost sessions before the live album though and I love the Trident sessions! Enjoyed your ranking!
I don't think you'll read this, but while I knew about Mahavishnu Orchestra, I hadn't really listened to them until I heard you talk about them with such fervor. I'm a guitarist and was interested in Dixie Dregs back in the day, but there's really no comparison between them and Mahavishnu Orchestra, so thanks for letting me in on your thoughts! I'm having a great time listening and watching these videos.
I think the Dregs were highly influenced by MO. As a matter of fact I saw the Dregs a while back and Jerry Goodman was playing violin for them. It was a righteous experience!!
@@FelixUnger-q3kI think the King Crimson lineup that recorded Lark's Tongues in Aspic - with a violinist in the band - was also heavily influenced by Mahavishnu.
I was introduced to Mahavishnu Orchestra in the mid 70s by my guitar teacher, and since then, at the age of maybe14, I have played Birds of Fire all my life. It is my most played album, by far, in my lifetime. I was lucky, as if he had no more guitar lessons after mine on a Saturday morning, we'd spend the rest of the day playing his records. It was like having a Dad. I have to take issue though, with any band with the word Orchestra in it. It's just naff. Also, MO are interesting because I don't know where they stand with me geographically. John Mc is English, but it's definitely an American band because of his East Coast Jazz (Miles) connection, but it also - kinda isn't? Another idea for a video - where bands stand geographically: Did Nirvana only make sense in LA at that time on that college circuit, Grateful Dead didn't make sense outside the village of Haight, The Ramones only made sense in CBGBs, The Kinks only made sense if you lived all your life in north London? Oh, my word.. so much to discuss. One Word.. sorry. We haven't even begun on naff band names (Fairground Attraction) vs. great band names, or maybe you have and I wasn't here. Sorry, I'm over-excited already.
II really enjoyed this ranking clip. I need to expand my MO collection. My first, and still favorite, LP is "Birds of Fire". However, I'm up to explore more thanks to this.
My elder sibs brought home a majority of the records in the 60’s when Inner Mounting Flame came out i immediately switched the speed to 15 and started working out Dance of Maya… but- dude, Awakening is my go-to MO tune for a quick pick-me-up! Thanks Andy!
Eeee up luv your asking for trouble now. P s I haven’t watched your video yet. However, put simply, they are all brilliant. But so many thanks for the Noonward Race live version…..Its staggering.
J'ai écouté ça à 14 ans, moi qui n'écoutais que du rock. The Who, led zeppelin et Deep Purple. C'est la première ouverture que j'ai eu du jazz. Une révolution pour moi. J'en ai maintenant 65 Et j'écoute encore Mahavishnu Orchestra.
Your #3 is my #1 hands down, rarely has an orchestra and an electric band blended so well, yes the drumming is otherwordly, as everything else. Legendary album. And ,strangely, the only Mahavishnu Orchestra album I like.
I listened to that record obsessively along with Visions of the Emerald Beyond. Now my claim to fame: if any of you out there have the Roland VG-99 guitar processor I have created a "Miles Out" patch for those who want to do a cover of that tune. Polyphonic ring modulation to excess! I guarantee it will get you fired from your covers band but what a fun way to go out.
I remember the first time I heard Mahavishnu. It was Meeting of the Spirits while hotboxing a VW van with some mates while on break at a jam session…. there was some conversation but I just wanted everyone to SHUT UP as my mind was attempting to digest the absolute mind bending sounds that were coming from the speakers. My jaw had dropped and my musical brain had been altered forever. It was one of those Aha moments… I’ll never forget it.
Yay! MrE you've got it! How did the album of the music the likes of which no one had heard before, announce itself? That big crashing discordant chord: Bahm!! 'what the hell was that'? Bahm!! again and so on. It was a hell of a calling card
I have always loved the first two MO albums, but for some reason I have generally gravitated towards Inner Mounting Flame over Birds of Fire. Birds of Fire might be a more polished and better produced album but the fiery rawness and freshness of the first album was more captivating; and even more importantly to me the first album is more guitar centered which I preferred to the more democratic effort of the second.
I totally agree with the Mar Y Sol performance opinion. As great as they all are on that tune, it's Jan Hammer's piano solo that always stands out for me as the most melodic and memorable - stellar!
I edited my copy using protools. I seamlessly cut off all the bits I found annoying down to a 34 minute album. Now it's a mind blowing album. Yes, gotta be played loud!!
Adventures in Radioland has some great hooks in it, plus it was a daring and experimental record. Keeps with the spirit of Miles especially during the mclaughin period. Especially the often overlooked "On the Corner" record. I would even bet that Miles would say that it was the hippest thing John could've done at that time. On the opening track, the power and energy is that of later Jeff Beck records. Half-man Half cookie is forward thinking and stretches electronic drumming. I am deeply familiar the the entire catalog of John and Mahavishnu, and Adventures is one album I do not hesitate to play.
The 1984 album Mahavishnu is a very good album. You are correct Andy, Billy's playing is clean and tight on that album,. And what in blazes is that funk groove Billy breaks into on Radioactivity? That just takes the song into another realm and then the double bass on the out, jeez louise incredible playing.
I WILL TELL YOU ANDY. MICHAEL WALDEN WAS FANTASTIC DRUMMER. AND BILLY COBHAM WAS BRILLIANT. TWO DIFFERENT STYLES. I WOULD LOVE TO SEE THEM PLAY TOGETHER. LOVE THEM BOTH GREAT SKILL WHAT CAN I SAY. CHEERS
BTW - regarding "Wild Strings" - that is actually a soundboard recording that supposedly all of the band members signed off on it being released by CBS. Why it hasn't happened I can't be certain but it eventually is supposed to be put out officially because of the quality level.
Hi Andy. I'm interested to hear what you think of the Live Mahavishnu recording from his last American Tour with Jimmy Herring. Did you already review that. I guess I can search your site.
No I have not. I will at a certain point, as well as looking at JM's live at Ronnie Scott's where he returns to these compositions. I'm not too sure what JM's intent was with this at the moment
"The Inner Mounting Flame" is my fav, also "Between Nothingness and Eternity" was my first MO album. Love the first five albums. Hey, love the new studio, Andy!! (I'd never heard the phrase "Fusak" until now, lol!!)
George Martin was most proud of producing, outside of The Beatles, Jeff Beck’s “Blow By Blow”. Narada Michael Walden did one of the best drum intros on Jeff Beck’s song “Led Boot” off of “Wired”. Narada wrote 4 songs for the “Wired” album and played drums on most of the songs. I love all the Mahavishnu Orchestra albums. Still listen to them on a regular basis. Listen to Miles Davis’s “Jack Johnson”, “Bitches Brew”, and “In A Silent Way” as well; he is the one who invented the Fusion genre. But I listen to a phenomenal guitarist by far the most who you refuse to mention. The man brought fusion to the masses with a few Platinum selling albums that reached #4 and #16 on the Billboard Hot 200 Chart and one ascending into the top 10 on the Billboard Jazz Chart. And that would be Jeff Beck. You have exaggerated how well the MO albums sold in the US. Billy Cobham’s Spectrum sold better than any MO record. Light~Live Long< Life…
Weird timing, I was taking my trash out this morning, and there was a vinyl copy of visions of the emerald beyond in front of the trash can. Can't wait to clean it up and listen to it for the first time.
Please do a vid on Miroslav, Alfonso and Victor Bailey. Also on the Dave Holland Drummers : Steve Ellington, Marvin Smitty Smith, Steve Kilson, Nate Smith, Eric Harland and Obed Calvaire
Passport was another fusion band that inspired me so much. A dive into them would be epic. Klaus is a genius and Curt Cress is one of my biggest influences. Plus their album covers are awesome!
1976 was not that early for guitar synthesizers. Indeed, Palo Tofani was using guitar synths back in 1973 with AREA on 'Arbeit Macht Frei' as well as his solo album 'Electric Frankenstein'. Palo's guitar synth work is very impressive, even by today's standards. (Of course, this is Italian progressive-fusion.)
I still want a Andy Hair Styles RANKED.This is the best channel on youtube !
Great idea, lol!
I'm transfixed by it. Is that a beaufànt hairstyle? And a neckerchief to complement it. Is this for the jazz audience?
@@tangfastic7075 Mmmmm, nice!
After that, let's keep it going with the eyeglasses.
Honestly, all this money on haircuts and eyewear, I'm beginning to think Andy has problem. I'm worried about the well-being of the children. Has anyone ever seen the wife?
The Mahavishnu is what brought me to this channel and I love to hear Andy extolling the virtues of this band. There would be no Close to the Edge without MO. I think Jerry Goodman and John playing in unison is such an unearthly sound, eerie and beautiful.
A fellow hard rocker introduced me to MO. I had no idea what rock/jazz fusion was. He died (at just 50) a few short years later. I think of him every time i listen to Birds of Fire. Miss you, Dave.
At 72 years old, Meeting of the Spirits still thrills and astounds as much as it did in 1971 or 1972. Interestingly, I was led to it for Billy Cobham. A discussion about rock drummers with an American exchange student ( thank you Mark L for this, and CTA) resulted in a listen at Rare Records, Manchester. A minute of MotS, and I was stunned and hooked!
Inner Worlds is a LITTLE bit unfocused? My god, it's embarrassingly horrible. It's McLaughlin's "Giant For a Day." On a side note, I was at the show where Nothingness was recorded -- press tickets , first row center. And to this day , it's the most incredible live performance I ever heard.
My new favorite channel on RUclips! I love your presentation. Thank you!
Your best ranking video ever! Educational and inspiring. You have turned the page to a new chapter. The sky is the limit.
Saw the Birds of Fire show in Nov of 73 in St Petersburg Florida.I followed John Mc. since his time with Miles.The two girls we took to the show couldn't handle it and went out and sat in the car.The Orchestra totally brought the Fire! Billy Cobham is as advertised!
Hi Andy, I'm enjoying your channel since I discovered you about a couple of months ago. No sooner had I finished watching this ranking video on the Mahavishnu Orchestra that I went on eBay and immediately purchased what I hope is a good copy of 'Between Nothingness & Eternity' without ever having listened to it! That's the power of your passion for this music rubbing off on me. I've got the books '1001 Albums and 1001 Classical Albums You Must Listen To Before You Didn't and if there was an equivalent on both Prog music and Jazz, I'd snap them up straight away. Right now I can't think of anyone better than you to compile them. May your channel continue to grow.
That should read... Before You Die' The first book of course refers to Albums of all genres.
I found a copy of it for AU$6 at a vinyl fair about 5 years ago and it's signed by Billy Cobham.
One of my prized possessions and best vinyl finds.
@@howardmccann7246 There actually is an equivalent on jazz; the MusicHound series includes a jazz album guide. I recommend it.
Thanks Andy, that was great, keep up the good work.
Birds of Fire really great album, thank you Andy.
I gave that Mahavishnu Orchestra another go due to you as you are always raving about them. I'm 50 now but prior to the last year my only exposure to them was finding them in my mate's dads record collection when I was about 15. I wasn't ready or able to listen properly or appreciate them then. I remember just thinking it was weird rubbish, ah the folly of youth. Thanks for reintroducing me to them as I can now hear the beauty and genius in them.
@@RobArmiter your comment reminds me of when my elder sisters boyfriend played me John Coltrane when I was about 14.
Then, 1965, I was into Delta & Chicago blues R&B and folk. I thought it was just noise, rubbish. It wasn’t until my 20’s after being blown away by MO that I could hear what a genius Coltrane was. I mention this as he was a major influence on McLaughlin who wanted to sound like Train.
What an amazing lighting and sound! Very very professional!
Hi Andy, thanks for the video. Just to let you know there is a Puerto Rican in your audience, and the album you placed at #4 was recorded in 1972 at the legendary Festival Mar y Sol in Vega Baja, Puerto Rico. It is probably the most famous musical event in the island's history, with highlights like the extraordinary performance of the Mahavishnu Orchestra, and an amazing set by Emerson, Lake and Palmer (festival's headliners). For many years the album you showed in the video was considered a collector's item, I know people in the island who own it (as well as peolple who were there). Don't know if the album was ever released on CD, but despite the chaotic organization of the festival, the recording is evidence of undeniable musical brilliance. And #4 is quite high on the list... Thanks.😎
I agree...if you know anyone who was there, I would love to interview them
Your top 3 mirrors mine. In my younger days, I had seen a glimpse of freedom in music from the Jimi Hendrix Experience as well as Zeppelin and was really into classic prog rock as well- Yes, Rush, Crimson, etc. This was ‘91, so I had my ears on 80’s metal of all types as well. I remember my musical compatriot bringing this in and putting on the cd player and it’s like a bomb went off in my musical world. For the first time I heard freedom over intense compositions. It served as my back door into the world of Jazz as well as Indian Classical and world music.
I love when Andy gives the two top albums a little kiss.
Great video Andy. I'm happy to be part of your viewing community. The new studio looks amazing. Can't wait for what you have planned for future videos. Cheers!
My own intro to John Mclaughlin was back when I was a 17 year-old high school student back in the '80s & just picking up the guitar - at my best friend's house with us admiringly listening to Van Halen when his older brother by 5 years (these guys were from a musical family - he played guitar, bass, keyboards and some drums) stolled in and quipped (and I remember his exact words) - "John McLaughlin can play twice as fast as Van Halen and ad lib while he's doing it". Really? I thought... I had to check it out...
I bought soon after "Birds Of Fire" & was blown away - he was right. But as much as I loved "Birds Of Fire", when I first heard "Inner Mounting Flame" (part of my friend's older brother's LP collection) I was ABSOLUTELY blown away...
I've (of course) listened to other Mahavishnu albums - especially in this age of Amazon Music, RUclips, etc. over the years, but none excite me more than "Inner Mounting Flame". On this album, you have 5 totally top-notch musicians going in with a musically completely novel concept, taking the ball, and really running with it as a unit in a way that'd been seldom heard before from music that could be considered "rock".
It was totally fresh, spontanious, passionate, and played with incredibly executed - and improvised - musicical virtuosity...
I'm listening to it as I write, and it still - after 40 years - absolutely knocks my f'n socks off.
Great #1. It would be mine own Mahavishnu pick too, and would also be among my desert island albums.
As a fellow Mahivishnu fan, I appreciated this video & congrats to your recent success - I sincerely hope it continues.
Never listened to these before and just sat charging my works EV and listened to your number 1 and2 and WOW will certainly be doing a deep dive into them WOW cheers Andy keep up the good work
Looking sharp Andy!
The joy with which you talk about this band is moving. Keep it up, Andy!peace!
Andy - what a wonderful video! Congratulations on your new charming venue. I'm also glad to hear of Jean-Luc Ponty' positive reaction to your content and look forward to your interviewing him. I was in high school when the Mahavisnhu Orchestra debuted and also instantly liked them. Thanks for continuing to share your insights on great music as well as various trends.
another milestone by andy lovely lively presentation like our favourite band MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA mucho gracias! 👽🥷🕉
A really useful list would be the best Mahavishnu live shows out there. There are just so many.
I've been deeply into Mahavishnu since 1974, starting with Inner Mounting Flame. I've heard all their albums, and there are so many great ones! But this one (I agree) is pure energy. The cut I've played the very most, in utter ecstasy, is "Dawn".
The rawness of the Lost Trident Sessions is so powerful! I absolutely love that album, buying it as soon as it came out; and I was not disappointed! And the groove in Sister Andrea is unbelievable along with McLaughlin’s huge, emotional descending solo. Incredible!!!
As an ignorant young college student I once stumbled
Into in a rehearsal of the Boston Symphony Orchestra performing Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique conducted by Michael Tilson Thomas. As he made his comments to the orchestra he would turn to the 5 or 6 students sitting in the audience to explain the piece and what he was doing with the orchestra. I was transfixed. Here was a teacher. Since then I became a fan of MTT. So when I saw his name on a Mahavishnu album I bought it. That’s how I discovered this great band! They only got better as I learned more.
The guitarist with the Sonic Youth T shirt is incredible. Love it.
I too discovered Birds of Fire - in 1973 (I was 24). I was obsessed with it, carried it around & played it wherever there was a turntable, & listened to nothing else for a month. My friend & sometimes bandmate Russ Tubbs found the first album ... And in 1975? Russ got the spot on sax on "Visions of the Emerald Beyond." Since then he's done solo stuff & a lit wit Carlos Santana etc.
I saw him & the band in NYC supporting the Visions album & had dinner with him afterward - actually the last time insaw him (I moved away)
Excellent reviews as expected, and the intermission cooked!
Yes, come on Jean-Luc! I loved that story about your mum buying 'Birds Of Fire' and leaving it out on the mantlepiece for you. I've just ordered a vinyl copy of 'Visions...' so can't wait to get that. The sound and everything was really good on this one, Andy, like you've made the studio your second home / den / shed / garage, what have you.
Really good commentary and insights.
Love your videos Andy. Keep it coming 😊
Great stuff. Head trip zone again for you, regarding talking to Ponty. I admire you for making those type of moves, as I’ve always got anxious at the idea of whether I’d want to mix the two worlds of the early childhood perception and memory of people and places,( with all their accompanying wonderment), with the cold reality of things as they actually are, through the prism of age/wisdom/understanding.
Great vid.
Vital transformation is my favorourite track, starting of with blistering and rigid drums, Jan Hammer starring with Rhodes with ringmodulator parts. Full speed ahead!
Ahhh. Mahavishnu. Wonderful video. Well most anything related to McLaughlin is candy for me. You mention being too close to MO…I too am way too close. I see that VotEB has fallen but I agree with the pretext. And it too remains my all time favorite album.
Love your setup in the corner. Saw your painting hanging in the new place but don’t see it here. Congratulations on your growing success Andy..well deserved!
VISIONS OF THE EDWARDS BEYOND
Honourable mentions must also go to the two John McLaughlin albums, My Goal's Beyond from 1971 and his album with Carlos Santana, Love Devotion and Surrende from 1973.
The acoustic music of My Goal's Beyond show the beginnings of John's fusion of Indian classical and Jazz, it also features Jerry Goodman. The Santana album is in the same musical vein as Mahavishnu Orchestra as well as featuring Billy Cobham on the drums.
The MO were a revelation to me from the 1st album...incredible playing and Billy playing like 2 drummers...I saw them twice live and they were awesome...It's tough listening for most...but the originalty and spirit of this great music/compositions has somehow prevailed...So thanks for highlighting this ground breaking band - Cheers
It's interesting mentioning the dying out of the music tutor as a role. I've been keeping it going for nearly 30 years now and as a self taught guitar player I find it difficult to justify myself and my chosen career path. Fortunately only two years away from retirement and I won't have to compete with the endless resources that are available now. It's great you've found something that helps you out but I must add it's something you are very good at. I'm a fan of the Mahavishnu Orchestra and I've learnt so much from this one video. If i were to pick a number one it would be the Trident Sessions. First time I heard it I was knocked out. Great job as always and I hope the new studio works out for you.
Love your show.
MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA-I followed John McLaughlin,Billy Cobham,Jan Hammer. And have great recordings of Rick Laird as well. Not to mention Narada Micheal Walden, who I followed as well! And Jean-Luc Ponty, I followed him, and love his music as well!!!They were one of the greatest groups ever! I also, followed Jeff Beck everywhere! And Stanley Clarke, and Marcus Miller, so I really love your channel,FUSION LIVES!!!
Thank you. This is one of those bands could never figure out a great entry point. I'm familiar with McLaughlin thanks to my favorite Miles Davis albums and box sets he's on.
You are a true fan of mahavishnu. Like me. I totally share your ranking and i am at 3 min of your video. I imagine it will be a reverse chronogical rank or almost. I think that there is cd before and after mahavishnu naming extrapolation, shakti or electric dreams. Let me know what you thing. Pierre from France 🙏
Birds Of Fire got me started on MO, John McLaughlin and jazz in 1979. For the longest time it was my favorite MO album. It’s since been replaced by Visions Of The Emerald Beyond. Visions brought heavy doses of the funk, fury and spirituality in a way the others do not. Oh, and thanks for the Tim Bowness interlude. I’m a major fan of his too.
Love the musical interlude, more of this please.
"Visions Of the Emerald Beyond" my prefered one too . This is the third album I bought ( a long time ago : 1976 !)
We enjoy your videos so carry on. Saw Jean-Luc Ponty live 6 years and he was amazing.
My Top 5:
1. Birds
2. Flame
3. Visions
4. Trident
5. Apocalypse
I saw MO on the Visions of the Emerald Beyond tour, and NM Waldon absolutely blew me away.
Love the revised order (although I'd flip 3 and 4). Love the intermission. Love ALL the comments!
The friend of Abercrombie was Jan Hammer.
It's funny how over time i can overlook bad fidelity--i really had a hard time listening to early Tony Williams Lifetime in the mid 70's, now i love it. That rawness is why I've always preferred IMF to BOF (and as much as the moog solos on BOF are trail-blazing, i SO dig the ring-mod Rhoades of IMF)
FIVE STAR REVIEW 🎉
There was a restaurant near me called Mahavishnu Orchestra. It was owned and run by a yellow robot with pink squirrels for chefs and staff. I remember banging a huge gong in there, using Paul McCartney as the mallet to strike it. They were dead against garden peas and sliced carrots.
I share your love of the MO. I was a freshman at Boston University in 1971. I soon met a fellow who had Devotion and My Goal's Beyond. I was hooked. We bought IMF upon its release. Hitch-hiked to URI for December concert of MO (with BOC and Byrds.) I thought I was ready for them, Hah! Absolutely earth-shattering!
Saw them next in '72 at Symphony Hall Boston with Jerry Garcia. Disappointed because high volume turned the sound to mud. Saw them again in Boston late '73. Not sure if it was The Music Hall or Orpheum, but I am sure it was the best concert I've ever seen (including Bowie, Marley, Miles, etc.) They were positively telepathic and edifying; a unified musical entity w/Cobham as the bone structure. I'm 71 now, but I'm cool with it. I saw the incredible, original, MO.
Inner Mounting Flame changed my life for sure! As for The Lost Trident Sessions, I have a suggestion that may or may not bump it up a notch or two on your list: change the running order. After growing up listening to Between Nothingness and Eternity, starting TLTS with Dream made the rest seem anti-climatic. So I've ripped it into iTunes and my revised running order is Trilogy, I Wonder, Sister Andrea, Stepping Tones, John's Song #2, and Dream. Makes the whole album flow much better, imho... Thanks for another great vid AE!
That interlude was brilliant
PHD level analysis. Phenomenal work Andrew. I would have made Birds of Fire number one myself, but I respect your choice.
Great band. Great Video.
BoF was my introduction to MO in 1973. My all time favorite still today.
I love this band and all of the incredible incarnations. For me I’ve always had more of an affinity for the second incarnation as it has some beautiful & melodic music. My favourite album by the MO and some of my favourite albums of all time. Apocalypse is sublime epicness with George Martin. Visions Of The Emerald Beyond is a very close second but Inner Worlds is my personal favourite record by this band. Pretty underrated as you said that this lineup of the band just couldn’t live up to what was the original lineup.
Great ranking, here’s mine:
1) The Innner Mounting Flame (1971)
2) Birds Of Fire (1973)
3) Visions Of The Emerald Beyond (1975)
4) Apocalypse (1974)
5) Between Nothingness & Eternity (1973)
6) Inner Worlds (1976)
7) Mahavishnu (1984)
8) Adventures In Radioland (1987)
In 1971 I was 15 & at the crossroads of many of the GREATEST albums ever produced during such a powerful turning point in the life of a young man's consciousness. As an aspiring visual artist, my best friends at school were musicians in training and we were very open to anything groundbreaking! With the changes introduced by The BEATLES, HENDRIX, MILES/COLTRANE & ZAPPA we were ready for all the breakthroughs in the early 70's like KC, YES, OSIBISA, GAYE but MAHAVISHNU was another revelation! Then in 1974 while in NYC Central Park I saw LIVE the "BETWEEN NOTHINGNESS & ETERNITY" album's actual recorded concert. And by this point, I was a fan of Psychedelics so you can't imagine what it was like seeing this band performing that for the first time outdoors in that State of Being! INFRKNCREDIBLE!
I'm gonna have to track down the last 3....Inner to Radio, I've never heard these but I have the rest and love them as much as you. these records give me goosebumps every time I listen to them. I heard the lost sessions before the live album though and I love the Trident sessions! Enjoyed your ranking!
Any rankings list must be qualified as Subjective or Objective. Well done my Friend.
I don't think you'll read this, but while I knew about Mahavishnu Orchestra, I hadn't really listened to them until I heard you talk about them with such fervor. I'm a guitarist and was interested in Dixie Dregs back in the day, but there's really no comparison between them and Mahavishnu Orchestra, so thanks for letting me in on your thoughts! I'm having a great time listening and watching these videos.
I think the Dregs were highly influenced by MO. As a matter of fact I saw the Dregs a while back and Jerry Goodman was playing violin for them. It was a righteous experience!!
@@FelixUnger-q3kI think the King Crimson lineup that recorded Lark's Tongues in Aspic - with a violinist in the band - was also heavily influenced by Mahavishnu.
I was introduced to Mahavishnu Orchestra in the mid 70s by my guitar teacher, and since then, at the age of maybe14, I have played Birds of Fire all my life. It is my most played album, by far, in my lifetime. I was lucky, as if he had no more guitar lessons after mine on a Saturday morning, we'd spend the rest of the day playing his records. It was like having a Dad. I have to take issue though, with any band with the word Orchestra in it. It's just naff. Also, MO are interesting because I don't know where they stand with me geographically. John Mc is English, but it's definitely an American band because of his East Coast Jazz (Miles) connection, but it also - kinda isn't? Another idea for a video - where bands stand geographically: Did Nirvana only make sense in LA at that time on that college circuit, Grateful Dead didn't make sense outside the village of Haight, The Ramones only made sense in CBGBs, The Kinks only made sense if you lived all your life in north London? Oh, my word.. so much to discuss. One Word.. sorry. We haven't even begun on naff band names (Fairground Attraction) vs. great band names, or maybe you have and I wasn't here. Sorry, I'm over-excited already.
They were based mainly in america, but John is English and composed most of the material. I see them as an international collective
Looking forrward to this walk through mushrooms and fancy flowers… which can be great fun and insights
II really enjoyed this ranking clip. I need to expand my MO collection. My first, and still favorite, LP is "Birds of Fire". However, I'm up to explore more thanks to this.
Glad you enjoyed!
My elder sibs brought home a majority of the records in the 60’s when Inner Mounting Flame came out i immediately switched the speed to 15 and started working out Dance of Maya… but- dude, Awakening is my go-to MO tune for a quick pick-me-up! Thanks Andy!
Eeee up luv your asking for trouble now.
P s I haven’t watched your video yet.
However, put simply, they are all brilliant.
But so many thanks for the Noonward Race live version…..Its staggering.
Yep, best stuff. Saw them live in 1972. Loud and clear.
I really loved the interlude! No hiding behind computers, this is the real thing.
J'ai écouté ça à 14 ans, moi qui n'écoutais que du rock. The Who, led zeppelin et Deep Purple. C'est la première ouverture que j'ai eu du jazz. Une révolution pour moi. J'en ai maintenant 65 Et j'écoute encore Mahavishnu Orchestra.
Your #3 is my #1 hands down, rarely has an orchestra and an electric band blended so well, yes the drumming is otherwordly, as everything else. Legendary album. And ,strangely, the only Mahavishnu Orchestra album I like.
"Inner Worlds" is my fave ❤ Makes me happy. Spiritually backward and funny
I listened to that record obsessively along with Visions of the Emerald Beyond.
Now my claim to fame: if any of you out there have the Roland VG-99 guitar processor I have created a "Miles Out" patch for those who want to do a cover of that tune. Polyphonic ring modulation to excess! I guarantee it will get you fired from your covers band but what a fun way to go out.
@aliensporebomb 😂😅
Thanks very much. This is great. So pleased. I discovered them in 1984.
I remember the first time I heard Mahavishnu. It was Meeting of the Spirits while hotboxing a VW van with some mates while on break at a jam session…. there was some conversation but I just wanted everyone to SHUT UP as my mind was attempting to digest the absolute mind bending sounds that were coming from the speakers. My jaw had dropped and my musical brain had been altered forever. It was one of those Aha moments… I’ll never forget it.
Yay! MrE you've got it! How did the album of the music the likes of which no one had heard before, announce itself?
That big crashing discordant chord: Bahm!! 'what the hell was that'? Bahm!! again and so on. It was a hell of a calling card
I have always loved the first two MO albums, but for some reason I have generally gravitated towards Inner Mounting Flame over Birds of Fire. Birds of Fire might be a more polished and better produced album but the fiery rawness and freshness of the first album was more captivating; and even more importantly to me the first album is more guitar centered which I preferred to the more democratic effort of the second.
I totally agree with the Mar Y Sol performance opinion. As great as they all are on that tune, it's Jan Hammer's piano solo that always stands out for me as the most melodic and memorable - stellar!
The Eleventh House, just caught that Andy, will check them out
I listened to 'Noonward Race' last night - jaw-dropping! Shame it's not available on a stand-alone CD of 'The Inner Mounting Flame.'
Birds of Fire - BAM!
Play Adventures VERY loud! You won't be disappointed.Drums are stunning.
I edited my copy using protools. I seamlessly cut off all the bits I found annoying down to a 34 minute album. Now it's a mind blowing album. Yes, gotta be played loud!!
Ken Scott also engineered a bunch of Beatles stuff, mainly on Magical Mystery Tour and The White Album. Visions is so crisp and punchy❤
Adventures in Radioland has some great hooks in it, plus it was a daring and experimental record. Keeps with the spirit of Miles especially during the mclaughin period. Especially the often overlooked "On the Corner" record. I would even bet that Miles would say that it was the hippest thing John could've done at that time. On the opening track, the power and energy is that of later Jeff Beck records. Half-man Half cookie is forward thinking and stretches electronic drumming. I am deeply familiar the the entire catalog of John and Mahavishnu, and Adventures is one album I do not hesitate to play.
yo *the noonward race* at mar y sol kicks ass and there was nothing like it for decades later on
The 1984 album Mahavishnu is a very good album. You are correct Andy, Billy's playing is clean and tight on that album,. And what in blazes is that funk groove Billy breaks into on Radioactivity? That just takes the song into another realm and then the double bass on the out, jeez louise incredible playing.
Radioactivity is fantastic
👏👏👏👏👏
I WILL TELL YOU ANDY. MICHAEL
WALDEN WAS FANTASTIC DRUMMER. AND BILLY COBHAM
WAS BRILLIANT. TWO DIFFERENT STYLES. I WOULD
LOVE TO SEE THEM PLAY TOGETHER. LOVE THEM BOTH
GREAT SKILL WHAT CAN I SAY.
CHEERS
What you said about Rick Laird is also why I love Benny Rietveld: he always sounds like a bass player.
BTW - regarding "Wild Strings" - that is actually a soundboard recording that supposedly all of the band members signed off on it being released by CBS. Why it hasn't happened I can't be certain but it eventually is supposed to be put out officially because of the quality level.
Hi Andy. I'm interested to hear what you think of the Live Mahavishnu recording from his last American Tour with Jimmy Herring. Did you already review that. I guess I can search your site.
No I have not. I will at a certain point, as well as looking at JM's live at Ronnie Scott's where he returns to these compositions. I'm not too sure what JM's intent was with this at the moment
"The Inner Mounting Flame" is my fav, also "Between Nothingness and Eternity" was my first MO album. Love the first five albums. Hey, love the new studio, Andy!! (I'd never heard the phrase "Fusak" until now, lol!!)
George Martin was most proud of producing, outside of The Beatles, Jeff Beck’s “Blow By Blow”. Narada Michael Walden did one of the best drum intros on Jeff Beck’s song “Led Boot” off of “Wired”. Narada wrote 4 songs for the “Wired” album and played drums on most of the songs. I love all the Mahavishnu Orchestra albums. Still listen to them on a regular basis. Listen to Miles Davis’s “Jack Johnson”, “Bitches Brew”, and “In A Silent Way” as well; he is the one who invented the Fusion genre. But I listen to a phenomenal guitarist by far the most who you refuse to mention. The man brought fusion to the masses with a few Platinum selling albums that reached #4 and #16 on the Billboard Hot 200 Chart and one ascending into the top 10 on the Billboard Jazz Chart. And that would be Jeff Beck. You have exaggerated how well the MO albums sold in the US. Billy Cobham’s Spectrum sold better than any MO record. Light~Live Long< Life…
Weird timing, I was taking my trash out this morning, and there was a vinyl copy of visions of the emerald beyond in front of the trash can. Can't wait to clean it up and listen to it for the first time.
Saw 2 back to back shows in 1973...WOW!!!
Love this discussion ! Who you calling sophisticated ?!? 😄🤪
Please do a vid on Miroslav, Alfonso and Victor Bailey.
Also on the Dave Holland Drummers : Steve Ellington, Marvin Smitty Smith, Steve Kilson, Nate Smith, Eric Harland and Obed Calvaire
Passport was another fusion band that inspired me so much. A dive into them would be epic. Klaus is a genius and Curt Cress is one of my biggest influences. Plus their album covers are awesome!
Remember Isotope with Gary Boyle?
@@roberts6053 I dont but I will check them out. I do remember Camel with Andy Latimer though! He is amazing.
19:49 🙏🙏❤❤
1976 was not that early for guitar synthesizers. Indeed, Palo Tofani was using guitar synths back in 1973 with AREA on 'Arbeit Macht Frei' as well as his solo album 'Electric Frankenstein'. Palo's guitar synth work is very impressive, even by today's standards. (Of course, this is Italian progressive-fusion.)