Professional Potting Soil vs. DIY Mix // What's the Cost and quality difference?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 дек 2024

Комментарии • 87

  • @Growing-Our-Retirement
    @Growing-Our-Retirement Год назад +5

    Great advice to source locally. Pine bark, hardwood bark, humus, sand, can all be base components. Availability so much depends on where you live. Up north we wish we could buy pine bark economically but hardwood bark is easy and inexpensive to buy. We use a lot of readily available humus as well.
    Good advice to not let this hold you back. Hunt around, experiment, adjust and keep planting! Many mixes can be made inexpensively and will work just fine. Just add slow release fertilizer and water!
    Great video!

  • @CuriousMouse1988
    @CuriousMouse1988 6 месяцев назад +3

    Finally a potting mix video that is not 1/3 peat, 1/3 perlite 1/3 vermiculite. That’s a really expensive recipe over here. Some people recommend coco coir but my plants are always stunted because they tend to have top much sea salt. I tried to understand what nurseries use and turns out pine bark was the best ingredient - it’s cheap, simple, drains well and holds nutrients. The plant grows crazy in them. I use 2/3 pine bark and 1/3 sifted compost and works for most plants. If i need more drainage, i can tweak for more pine bark ratio.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  6 месяцев назад

      Exactly! Find a good mix and always be willing to tweak it as needed. Well done!!

  • @dreaminggreennursery
    @dreaminggreennursery Год назад +3

    Love watching your videos, always so full of information. I average between 25-26 cents in dirt for each plant as well, so we’re on the same page. Pots are the bigger expense for me, 12-15 cents “not bad” for 6” and 50-55 cents for trade gallons “ not horrible ” but that’s what it is. Thanks for sharing guys 👋🏻

  • @5rabbits807
    @5rabbits807 Год назад +2

    Thank you for inspiring me to keep looking for a potting soil source .I found one in my area.thank you for all the content you have given me some hope of growing my own nursery.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      You can do it - just can't be deterred when something is hard to find.

  • @oltrapper7984
    @oltrapper7984 Год назад +2

    Hey bud, you've been the main channel I watch on RUclips for the last few weeks. I have learned so much and I'm inspired. Thank you bud

  • @popandbob
    @popandbob 11 месяцев назад +1

    That's great you get such a good deal. I have to blend my own using ingredients that cost as much as your blended mix PLUS pay for delivery at $220/load. My overall cost is about $75/yard including delivery for the finished product. I have a load ban on my road too so I can't get a full truckload - the load ban says you can only load up to 70% of max weight.
    I use a few ingredients that some would say are big no-no's but it works for me and my climate. Pine/Spruce bark fine chips composted, topsoil, compost, peatmoss, sand, and sometimes some vermiculite/perlite gets mixed in if its included in the other ingredients. I do trees/shrubs and perennials in multiple sizes of pots (up to #10 for larger trees) and live in a very dry climate so the extra moisture retention is a huge necessity. Even with that water retention I still need to water 2x per day in the summer.

  • @nedhill1242
    @nedhill1242 Год назад +2

    Congratulations on your success and I love what you’re doing and the way you educate and share on RUclips.
    There is another family owned nursery on RUclips that I enjoy but unfortunately they heavily promote a brand of mulch and potting soil that they use and sell rather than making their own and educating people to create their own which would be just as good or better and save people a ton of money.
    They would actually save a ton of money if they made their own rather than using that stuff and pushing it as a product they sell.
    But pretty much everything they sell is either a product of proven winners or southern living.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      I'm a huge proponent of doing everything you can yourself. Sometimes that's not a good idea; sometimes it is. Every channel is its own business though, and businesses exist to make money. So... good for them!

  • @jkkelley7582
    @jkkelley7582 Год назад +1

    It is interesting to see what you can make the potting mix out of. Watching and reading comments! Thanks for doing a video on this!

  • @AFMR0420
    @AFMR0420 9 месяцев назад

    Got a ph tester and perlite today. Now I’m watching this and I agree, I’ve grown for years without ph testing.

  • @amsohn1
    @amsohn1 Год назад

    Oh how I feel your pain! When we got our putting soil sourced and 1st truckload delivered- went for the 2nd load- OUT! It's taken 4 months to find a 2nd source and they while we had enough for that current season, however we've not had anything to fill our new beds, or even refill our beds now...
    We've teamed up with a friend, and for me teaching him to Can food, he's helped source the potting mix- here we need to test for several things, and cannot find the pine bark... he also has a dump trailer and will be delivering it🙌🙌🙌
    Yes it's taken a good while to find and source our mix, however in the next 2 weeks we should have a truck load delivered. Woohoo!!
    It's not just us, there's been many here in East Texas who couldn't find or source pine bark or a potting mix...
    I appreciate you sharing.
    Blessings ❤

  • @jeromejaczynski8688
    @jeromejaczynski8688 Год назад

    Hope your soil co. Gets up and running soon 150 miles to go get soil is a stretch i have been through several soil co over the years finally found one that works.keep the videos coming. Us old back yard nursery folks enjoy them

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      I don't mind the drive since it's only once in a while... but I definitely wouldn't be interested in doing it often.

  • @bri0013
    @bri0013 Год назад

    The guys hauling that with the live bottom truck's will tell you where the other mills are in your region of Alabama. Chances are high your normal place is in "Outage/shutdown" phase. Sometimes it lasts for weeks. Drivers know where to find more. Most of them haul from multiple mills
    Hopefully they arent too far..

  • @msher479
    @msher479 4 дня назад

    Thank you for the valuable information

  • @Lynnhopeacres
    @Lynnhopeacres Год назад +3

    Hope the normal place gets things fixed fast! I’m sure they’re stressing everyday on losing business over all this!

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      Yeah... when I call them, they don't seem too concerned.

  • @glorialove7312
    @glorialove7312 9 месяцев назад

    Been there. One ended up draining slower and overwater happened. Might put a qt water in old soil and qt water in new one and see the difference. Percolating test. Just a thought.

  • @mhubertcfi
    @mhubertcfi Год назад +5

    As gardeners we just have to say no to peat. When you know better you just have to do better. It's so devastating to the areas that it's extracted from. I'm glad your home-made traditionally doesn't use it and hope your source gets figured out soon

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад +2

      You do you. I'll use what I have to while I have to. Thanks for the input.

  • @joshua511
    @joshua511 11 месяцев назад

    Wow, I've been looking and finally found a source for Double Ground hardwood mulch - $40/yd. Pine Bark soil conditioner is $70. This is in the midwest where the cost of living is very low! These prices sure seem high, though. :(

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  11 месяцев назад

      That seems a little high to me, but it’s not outrageous. If I were in your position, I’d be glad to have that available and be glad to use it… while I kept my eyes open for something cheaper. Potting soil is one of the key pieces of the pie so while you may have to pay a bit more than you want to, it’s a great find.

  • @danradtke1663
    @danradtke1663 Год назад

    Hope the additional expense will give you more water retention and quicker growth to speed up your sales for the additional cost. Water price savings,and quicker growth. Good luck.

  • @redwood1957
    @redwood1957 Год назад

    I would be interested in you doing a side by side. Yours the stuff what you just purchsed and your pine bark and peat and then your pine barke and sand. Thank you

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      I did a side by side in this video. thanks

    • @redwood1957
      @redwood1957 Год назад

      @@savvydirtfarmer after putting in the rooted cuttings. For drainage,water retention, the just to see how the cuttings grew. Thanks

    • @craigodem3815
      @craigodem3815 Год назад +1

      @@redwood1957 good idea!

  • @beth6085
    @beth6085 Год назад

    Have you ever tried Chip Drop? I got a huge dump truck load of hardwood chips from them about that size of that big truck in your video. I paid $40 for it. I got it this fall and I'm letting it compost to use in the spring.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      It is available here

    • @CuriousMouse1988
      @CuriousMouse1988 6 месяцев назад

      hardwood chips will lock out nitrogen. you want to use bark as they don’t decompose as fast.

  • @grizoswald210
    @grizoswald210 9 месяцев назад

    Very good video, really informative. I like the 'simple' soil mixes you use, like the pine and hardwood bark. I think you said you use that about 50/50 or so. I use a combination of pine bark, good quality potting soil, and some grit for drainage. Do you like the 'custom' mix you bought in this video? How does it compare to your original all-bark mix?

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  9 месяцев назад +1

      Through the endless days of late winter and early Spring potting, it's all gotten mixed together. Custom mix, pine bark, hardwood bark, all piled together in various amounts. It's just really not that important that you have a "perfect" mix. For what I do, it all works well.

  • @JustJamesDean
    @JustJamesDean Год назад

    We used peat and washed course sand (and slow release fertiliser) with good result. Could try mixing the pine bark with course sand.
    Driving 150 miles is pretty crazy, ha ha

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      Yeah... the drive. It's not too bad doing it once in a while. If I had to do it every week, I'd have to figure something else out.

    • @HoaGarden902
      @HoaGarden902 11 месяцев назад

      What ratio did you use for sand and peat? I have lots of access to both here.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  11 месяцев назад +1

      I really don't know; I don't use much sand in my potting soil at all... usually none. In my propagation mix, it's 100% sand, or maybe down to 70% sand just to make it less heavy.@@HoaGarden902

    • @JustJamesDean
      @JustJamesDean 11 месяцев назад

      @@HoaGarden902 for our climate, half and half. Adjust to your needs

  • @bjornhoffmann6008
    @bjornhoffmann6008 Год назад

    This has always been the biggest expense for me, a good quality soil medium. Based down in South Africa and pickings are slim. Found that most potting soils have too much bulky wood chip and not enough finer material for the roots just to "bite". Any info I can get to do my own is much appreciated ❤ so thank you

    • @bri0013
      @bri0013 11 месяцев назад +1

      I came across your comment. If you're having trouble coming up with bulk medium to pot with, I have a tip. I read about in Africa actually, about "Keyhole" gardens.
      I cant remember where I seen it but it's a good way to produce a great deal of high quality compost.
      Hope that helps.

  • @richdc27
    @richdc27 5 месяцев назад

    Thanks, I appreciate the video. Anything wrong with using just plain sawdust as a potting mix? I know it varies a lot. The stuff I have is fine but not a superfine powdery dust. It drains quickly when I do a drainage test (in a few seconds) and holds moisture. Of all the videos on youtube about potting mix, nobody seems to use sawdust. I wonder why? It's cheap and readily available. Am I missing something?

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  5 месяцев назад

      If I had it readily available, I'd try it. Likely problem is lack of nitrogen - sawdust would be high in carbon. Is the sawdust from dry, older wood, or green wood? That would likely make a huge difference, as green wood would not work, I wouldn't think. Sawdust mixed with pine bark, maybe??? Experiment with it and see.

    • @richdc27
      @richdc27 5 месяцев назад

      @@savvydirtfarmer Yes I'm going to try it.I'd be using a mix of sawdust and wood shavings from logs at a local sawmill to get the best water retention and drainage properties. I'm not sure how dry the logs are when cut. So many sites say uncomposted sawdust will steal nitrogen because it's high carbon. But so are the other popular soil less potting mix ingredients like peat moss, coir, hardwood bark, pine bark, rice hulls, etc. I wonder why makes them any better than plain old sawdust?

  • @williamcarter746
    @williamcarter746 3 месяца назад

    What would you use if you could only get soil conditioner (pine fines) and cannot get hardwood fines. I’m out west and hardwood fines are pretty scarce.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  3 месяца назад +1

      Peat, compost, vermiculite, mushroom compost..., anything that holds some moisture. Quality of any product will vary place to place, so just try some different things and see what results you get.

    • @williamcarter746
      @williamcarter746 3 месяца назад

      @@savvydirtfarmer I can get community compost for $15 a yard. I’ll give that a shot.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  3 месяца назад +1

      @@williamcarter746 try it mixed with pine about 50/50... You'll probably want a higher percent pine than that, but it's a good starting point

    • @williamcarter746
      @williamcarter746 3 месяца назад

      @@savvydirtfarmer thanks a bunch. Love your videos!

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  3 месяца назад

      @@williamcarter746 much appreciated

  • @nel6211
    @nel6211 Год назад

    I would separate the plants that have the new soil from the old mix just to see how they respond. The new mix may hold more water so that can be an issue you haven't had before. Not a bad idea diluting the new mix with what you have to keep your costs down.

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      May do that just to see if there's any difference

    • @kusterflattail
      @kusterflattail 3 месяца назад

      Opportunities to experiment should never be passed up. It's how we learn the unknown and create better decisions in the future. It is the bedrock of propagation.

  • @robertgross9066
    @robertgross9066 Год назад

    Nice looking chips. What thickness of landscape material do I use thanks.

  • @beth6085
    @beth6085 Год назад

    I have a question. Since you are working on your home property do you have to have additional insurance over above your home owners insurance? How does all that work since you have people coming onto your home property?

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад

      I have a business insurance policy that covers us.

    • @beth6085
      @beth6085 Год назад

      @@savvydirtfarmer
      Thank you! I will have to check on that.

  • @lenny1038
    @lenny1038 Год назад +1

    The white balls are perlite, not vermiculite.

  • @billybass6419
    @billybass6419 Год назад

    What is a tray galloon nursery pot? How much do they hold?

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад +1

      "Trade" gallon; approx 2/3 gal.

    • @garyhidalgo5460
      @garyhidalgo5460 11 месяцев назад

      Trade gallon. Usually smaller means saving money.

  • @cjminor6429
    @cjminor6429 Год назад

    I hope that your supplier of your soil-less medium gets back up and running again soon!

  • @traciethomas1544
    @traciethomas1544 Год назад

    Hey Craig. This might be a silly question but is double shred the same thing as fine shred?

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад +1

      Probably... of course, terminology varies place to place, I'm sure.

  • @melodyscamman244
    @melodyscamman244 Год назад

    Thank you

  • @pamelamercado6902
    @pamelamercado6902 Год назад

    So sad I hope their able to get up and running sooner than later When it comes to overhead every penny counts. .

  • @danowen9142
    @danowen9142 Год назад

    Is that Bermuda Grass encrouching on you pile of pine bark? We don't have too much of that here in Utah but when we do it's nasty!

  • @erbauungstutztaufgnade1875
    @erbauungstutztaufgnade1875 7 месяцев назад

    👍🏼

  • @lilyrosedaisyvioletsweetpe1207
    @lilyrosedaisyvioletsweetpe1207 11 месяцев назад

    💚💚

  • @johanconradie2120
    @johanconradie2120 11 месяцев назад +1

    the perfect planting medium for all plants is,
    One measure each,
    sand, compost, ground, manure
    NO ARGUMENT

    • @TheJunkFarm
      @TheJunkFarm 7 месяцев назад

      Yeah I'm honestly a little bit shocked they can grow anything at all in just bark. That would drain out immediately and give zero nutrients to anything where I am in the high desert.
      I'm thinking he must have really good water, and a lot of it to o grow all those beautiful plants.
      I add dirt to home made compost (woodchips/green waste and sometimes manure)
      But I will argue a bit I'm that I'm totally off manures that could possibly have weed killer in them, just too hard to know their provenance) so for me anyway it needs to be chicken or something you know FIR SURE doesn't have persistent weedkiller in it.

  • @TheRainHarvester
    @TheRainHarvester Год назад

    I use leaves to make soil. No cost and no storage space in my pathways. On my channel.

  • @Andrew-sanders
    @Andrew-sanders Год назад

    Your potting soil is a num one no no in the garden. That stuff need to go in the hen house for a couple to 6 months. All that bark equals nitrogen deficiency to the plant. Makes my life easy when everyone uses that junk. Pot them plants in the best compost you can get and they will sell themselves

    • @savvydirtfarmer
      @savvydirtfarmer  Год назад +1

      Take a look at some of my other videos that have my plants in them, and show me where you see Nitrogen deficiency. I'd like to know.

    • @Andrew-sanders
      @Andrew-sanders Год назад

      @@savvydirtfarmer you probably don't have at your place but when people take home and don't post the chemicals on it shows up fast. Take one of mine home fo nothing but water for 6 months and it stays green and growing. Garden starts are non GMO and beyond organic don't need anything if you get ones in 6 inch pots for its lifetime