I know this isn't an official video, but it's for obvious reasons. Keep up the good work! This video in specific reminds me of the Adventist's version of the story of Lucifer's rebellion which is eerily similar to the Catholic creeds.
The still frames of statuary elicits a kind of awe-inspiring feeling, which is accentuated by the contrast of the extreme and hectic nature of the music. This is a beautiful video. Also, I'm a Christian, and fairly traditional at that. The lyrics do not offend me, because they describe a false "God", one that is conveniently used as an excuse for human evil. This is not the God of Christianity, and so, this is not blasphemous.
Sure, believe what you want. The lyrics of this song literally have a line that goes "He dreamed a god up and called it Christianity". Trent Reznor has been vocal about how he doesn't support religions like Christianity. He absolutely is talking about your made up god, and how it's believers choose to force their beliefs upon others, as he experienced with Christians.
@@gigachad2221-g4n To be honest, you're right, my reply was unnecessary. I had no reason to be so rude and condescending. It's your choice to believe in your religion. That's the value of free will. However, I'm not forcing any religion upon you. Personally I do not believe in the existence of any godly or higher power and do not practice any religion. The purpose of my comment was simply to address my belief that you misinterpreted the song and it's lyrics, but I'll admit, it was completely unwarranted. As with all art, music included, it is to be interpreted and appreciated by listener as they desire. Hence I'd like to apologise once again for my harsh comment. I had just had a hard day and took it out on someone online, which was foolish and rather immature or me.
He isnt trying to force any religion on to you . Keep believing in your evil god . The god of Christianity and Judaism . The same one who condones slavery that seems perfectly reasonable. Also why not throw in homophobia too , what a loving omnibenevelent megalomaniac . Also mass genocide , no biggie I’m god I can break my own rules if I want to . The mass slaughter of women and children by the isrealites . Perfectly acceptable in your gods eyes . Of course this song is talking about your god , “he dreamed a god up and called it Christianity “. I’m sorry to get so angry I’m not angry at you just your hateful religion .
Just added this one to Poker Night Alternative playlist. Indispensable. Along with STP, Smashing Pumpkins, Liz Phair, Veruca Salt, PJ Harvey, Ruby and SoundGarden. 🤷🏼♂️😜☄️💥
Cool 😎 video to one ☝️ of the most bad ass songs ever created. Well PHM came out back in 1989 so yea the 80’s but definitely not the 70’s. Mind you Trent Reznor is a very old and special soul who was probably unconsciously aware and subliminally creating the NIN Machine and all of it’s subsequent chapters In Utero. 😇
@ My apologies for generalizing, I was using red state as short hand for places associated with, but not limited to, practicing religious zealotry. I like to offend and this song I would imagine this song is pretty offensive to especially Christians. Didn’t mean to suggest only lefties listen to NIN
I find it funny that this song is all about "Screw you Christians! Who are you to tell me I shouldn't be promiscuous and *frick* anybody I want?!" and by the end of the album the main character is like "Maybe if I treated sex with some more respect I wouldn't be so miserable..."
Actually that take is funny given that the album begins with the idea that being sexually abusive will bring him closer to god, and this song is more rebellion of the idea of god.
I don't take this song as such. Because it is technically art. Anyone can see what they want aside the writers actual purpose of it. I think it's a warning. What he's saying is true. But that doesn't make it mocking. I'm a spiritual guy with issues. I'd do a music video that's pretty hard core for this. Doesn't mean I'm endorsing it because u are responsible for ur own integrity on what u do with the information handed u. Everything u experience and view can be taken in a positive or negative way. It's on u to choose, no one forces u.
Incorrect. Not over religious differences or supremacy of religious ideals at all, nor was it ever. As I said, the dispute is over two groups wanting to occupy several key regions of one territory.
Now this is music to have a good ol’ crucifixion to. People use to picnic while watching a crucifixion. People suffering unimaginable pain while others stuff their gobs with hummus. That sums up the human race perfectly. I’m still going to spread Love over Hate because I’ve always gone against the flow. Plus it really pisses off the people who want the ugliness to take over the beauty. They’ll never win because even with destruction is a form of creation or leaves a foundation for creation. There is no god. We are the product of incestuous apes banging who got tired of sitting their bare asses on uncomfortable tree branches and decided to come down.
This track is phat as phuck
It's so good. Honestly, all of Downward Spiral is amazing!!!!! I would listen to that and Pretty Hate Machine in my discman on the bus in high school.
Nine inch nails always has the scariest music videos. But they are awesome.
god this track is sooo fucking danceable its crazy I mean most of the album is but this one in particular always makes me want to
As per The Doom Generation.
@@philipmartin6924amazing flick
Yesss
I know this isn't an official video, but it's for obvious reasons. Keep up the good work! This video in specific reminds me of the Adventist's version of the story of Lucifer's rebellion which is eerily similar to the Catholic creeds.
Usaste mi video... muchas gracias... igual es algo viejo que hice experimentando en el cementerio de la recoleta
.
¿Recoleta es en Chile o Argentina?
@@Norma-Arte-y-VentasArgentina
Swietny film gratuluje talentu
Jodete😊
My favorite track on my favorite NIN album!? Ohhh jooooy!
I prefer Reptile; gritty, dark, crude, bleak and nihilistic beyond despair..er..repair !
@@serenechaosuk4682 that's a great track as well. that whole album is a treasure trove of amazing 90s industrial songs
El cemwnterio de la Recoleta, papa!!!. Que hermoso lugar de Buenos Aires, Argentina mi país. Un lugar magnífico para todo aquellos que quieran verlo.
One of my favorite tracks!
Grande trent, que tema. Gracias por la traducción.
12 añitos, este comentario tiene más edad que mi linda novia 😊😊
The still frames of statuary elicits a kind of awe-inspiring feeling, which is accentuated by the contrast of the extreme and hectic nature of the music. This is a beautiful video.
Also, I'm a Christian, and fairly traditional at that. The lyrics do not offend me, because they describe a false "God", one that is conveniently used as an excuse for human evil. This is not the God of Christianity, and so, this is not blasphemous.
Sure, believe what you want. The lyrics of this song literally have a line that goes "He dreamed a god up and called it Christianity". Trent Reznor has been vocal about how he doesn't support religions like Christianity. He absolutely is talking about your made up god, and how it's believers choose to force their beliefs upon others, as he experienced with Christians.
@@Music-qv8eq kind of like how you're trying to force your materialistic religion upon me right now?
@@gigachad2221-g4n To be honest, you're right, my reply was unnecessary. I had no reason to be so rude and condescending. It's your choice to believe in your religion. That's the value of free will. However, I'm not forcing any religion upon you. Personally I do not believe in the existence of any godly or higher power and do not practice any religion. The purpose of my comment was simply to address my belief that you misinterpreted the song and it's lyrics, but I'll admit, it was completely unwarranted. As with all art, music included, it is to be interpreted and appreciated by listener as they desire. Hence I'd like to apologise once again for my harsh comment. I had just had a hard day and took it out on someone online, which was foolish and rather immature or me.
@@Music-qv8eq Thank you for being a decent human being and apologizing.
He isnt trying to force any religion on to you . Keep believing in your evil god . The god of Christianity and Judaism . The same one who condones slavery that seems perfectly reasonable. Also why not throw in homophobia too , what a loving omnibenevelent megalomaniac . Also mass genocide , no biggie I’m god I can break my own rules if I want to . The mass slaughter of women and children by the isrealites . Perfectly acceptable in your gods eyes . Of course this song is talking about your god , “he dreamed a god up and called it Christianity “. I’m sorry to get so angry I’m not angry at you just your hateful religion .
His Royal Badness::: Continually out Classes this Centuries cake ass Clown Composers.
Digitally Immortalized
World Classic.
❤
This is awesome thank you for this awesome vid.
HELL YEAH
For the young ones: have a listen to 'We Believe' by MINISTRY from Twitch (1986) after this.
Not surprised! Trent used to be a Ministry roadie back in the day so no doubt some of their stuff would rub off on him...
Gracia por el video y la tradución!!
La letra impresionante loco
The perfect companion to Marilyn Manson's "Death Song"..this is genius..
jamie foyers I’d say it fits better with The Reflecting God, but yeah.
Who’s here in 2024?
This album is 30 today, 08 Mar 2024
Excelente video, y ke decir de la rola de lo mejor
me when tracey squuezes
IM ARRIVING
Muy bueno.
Vote against Project 2025!
And do what? Vote for the left? No thanks.
This song raised me out of hell
This is pretty sweet.
Oh yea!
????!!
A good song for Christmas caroling to the neighbors aint it?
🤪🤪🤪
Dalinar to Kadash be like: 1:56
Muy buena!¡ grazie
Happy Downward Spiral Day 3/8/24 this is my choice video to share away!!!...w/2 ppl on Facebook idgaf!
Si hay un infierno,nos vemos ahí.
🔥🔥🔥
is this an official video??
Drowninc in My own hipocrysy
Weird that America didn't get into this
Just added this one to Poker Night Alternative playlist. Indispensable. Along with STP, Smashing Pumpkins, Liz Phair, Veruca Salt, PJ Harvey, Ruby and SoundGarden. 🤷🏼♂️😜☄️💥
Deal me in!
Its so fuckin good song❤
yeah I live los angeles
I always listen rock music's the universe
I do drugs
Google RUclips Oh wait, so Google does drugs? That explains a lot, actually...
😍😘
I'm confused , My older Sister has a NIN Album back in the 70's or 80's ? Was there a different NIN before ?
Nope, you might just be high
Cool 😎 video to one ☝️ of the most bad ass songs ever created. Well PHM came out back in 1989 so yea the 80’s but definitely not the 70’s. Mind you Trent Reznor is a very old and special soul who was probably unconsciously aware and subliminally creating the NIN Machine and all of it’s subsequent chapters In Utero. 😇
Which album?
@@icydec3346 the downward piral
spiral
Ay muchos tipos de imen .. muchos tipos de agua .. muchos tipos de orín..
The map of the world is not reality...
He is afraid to see..
make it so!!!🤑🏳🏴☠️🏁🏴🏴🤑😜😝🤑😜😜🤑
❤️🔥💔🕳💢💥💯💤💭💯💣💥💢💔❤️🩹❤️🔥🖤🩶💕💞💓💗💖💖💖💖💫💫💫💫💜💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💫💥💫💫💫💫💫
Me encanta el tema, pero prefiero el video original
Haha, 999 likes, PERFECT
I love blasting this song while driving around in red states👹
What’s that got to do with it? I’m Republican. I freaking love Nine Inch Nails and Marilyn Manson.
@ My apologies for generalizing, I was using red state as short hand for places associated with, but not limited to, practicing religious zealotry. I like to offend and this song I would imagine this song is pretty offensive to especially Christians. Didn’t mean to suggest only lefties listen to NIN
Who else wants an egg and cheese on an English muffin?
the demiurgos can eat it
I find it funny that this song is all about "Screw you Christians! Who are you to tell me I shouldn't be promiscuous and *frick* anybody I want?!" and by the end of the album the main character is like "Maybe if I treated sex with some more respect I wouldn't be so miserable..."
This song is about the fact Christ is dead and no one cares
Duh
Actually that take is funny given that the album begins with the idea that being sexually abusive will bring him closer to god, and this song is more rebellion of the idea of god.
i dont know i think praying to a mythical fairy in the sky isn't exactly a more apt life choice
I don't take this song as such. Because it is technically art. Anyone can see what they want aside the writers actual purpose of it.
I think it's a warning. What he's saying is true. But that doesn't make it mocking.
I'm a spiritual guy with issues. I'd do a music video that's pretty hard core for this. Doesn't mean I'm endorsing it because u are responsible for ur own integrity on what u do with the information handed u. Everything u experience and view can be taken in a positive or negative way. It's on u to choose, no one forces u.
You all blasphemies against me.
You don't get it, do you?
Imagine NIN doing a live set in the GAZA Strip today , playing this track , with the fan video playing on big screen , what would the reaction be 🤔
Virus hey?
Christ was crucified ... 😦😳😨
Es muerte
I’m a nail mfs
Jesus is the way🙏🙏🙏
I have bad news…
@@SteveMillerFan then keep it too yourself my friend. May the lord bless you🙏🙏🙏
Sweet marathon. I love that game
@@PaleManSteve83 that music brought be comfort during the lowest points in my life
Jesus f you so long you pray like praying mantis.
FUCK!
Es matar al Fer ..
Jesus says suffer more there could be another soul. Father is in full control now. BIGGIE.
What is biggie?
@@SirRorschachJackbiggie smalls
I am has spoken today.
Es matar perros
Christ is feisty.
He was crucified.
Why do you think he'd feisty supposedly he is King and despite what atheist and satanics beleive wishes thee most best for us all even criminals
I think he has a sensitive soul and his fathers worry him to the point of insanity
Cu ri o si ty
I am the blue devil and angel of God called Baphomet and Allah in Greece God named me...One Coexisting Currency
Scorpion subzero an ....not mentioning are in agreance.
Israel and Palestinian people ALL over RELIGION
You Mama is dead, too
Actually it’s more of a territorial war. Difference of religion has very little to none to do with the dispute.
@@jojosmash69 🤣 A territorial dispute that's directly rooted in religious origins.
Incorrect. Not over religious differences or supremacy of religious ideals at all, nor was it ever. As I said, the dispute is over two groups wanting to occupy several key regions of one territory.
@@jojosmash69 And only one of them has the backing of the word of God in the Bible.
Es irte al pescuezo , con Crystal ya no era metal
God the father has the last word which is already done. Biggie.
Why’re you here commenting on this video lmao
Fundies gonna evangelize where they aren't needed or wanted. See also: fundies in Salem on Halloween
i don't think spreading your evangelism garbage here is gonna convince anyone of your make believe fairy tale
@@bondedwithpotatoes0076why are u an idiot
Ps Father son and whatever.
Anyone I challenge to prove in scripture that the holy spirit is not female. Your best scholars, preachers theologians. I might answ
The holy spirit is many things
Why? 😦
Some believe it is mary others believe it is chris jesus's ghost other believe it is God not in humanly form but in creation mode
Your god is dead and no one cares.
Jesus is King
The king of non-existence. Now shuffle along, little one.
Now this is music to have a good ol’ crucifixion to. People use to picnic while watching a crucifixion. People suffering unimaginable pain while others stuff their gobs with hummus. That sums up the human race perfectly.
I’m still going to spread Love over Hate because I’ve always gone against the flow. Plus it really pisses off the people who want the ugliness to take over the beauty. They’ll never win because even with destruction is a form of creation or leaves a foundation for creation.
There is no god. We are the product of incestuous apes banging who got tired of sitting their bare asses on uncomfortable tree branches and decided to come down.