Cancer - My Chemical Romance vs twenty one pilots (Comparison/Mashup)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 сен 2016
  • This one's completely for you guys - personally I'm not that big a fan of their cover. Please don't kill me :(
    Donate on Patreon: s.surveyplanet.com/VPRmEB9vX
    Check out the new playlist, Inanimate Radio: open.spotify.com/playlist/6fl...
    Twitter: / inanimash
    Facebook: / inanimatemashups
    Check out my original music: open.spotify.com/artist/4MDRM...
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 7 тыс.

  • @InanimateMashups
    @InanimateMashups  7 лет назад +884

    *Download link!!!*
    inanimatemashups.tumblr.com

    • @rebeccabaye2077
      @rebeccabaye2077 7 лет назад +1

      InanimateMashups It won't let me see the download?

    • @InanimateMashups
      @InanimateMashups  7 лет назад

      Should be under 'Pages' :) Rebecca Baye

    • @rebeccabaye2077
      @rebeccabaye2077 7 лет назад +2

      InanimateMashups Yea, it doesn't show up on mobile, thank you!

    • @diana-ni5gg
      @diana-ni5gg 7 лет назад +4

      You really need to put your work up on iTunes!

    • @InanimateMashups
      @InanimateMashups  7 лет назад +1

      FeelMySinsCrawl
      Copyright means I can't. :/

  • @Kittyrave64
    @Kittyrave64 7 лет назад +4800

    Gerard sings like he's fighting
    Tyler sings like he's losing
    I love their different perspectives on the song

    • @ginacoppola805
      @ginacoppola805 7 лет назад +77

      omg your comment made me so depressed and so inspired at the same time😢

    • @sjduda
      @sjduda 7 лет назад +20

      Raven Kwok oh my god you just made these songs too much better

    • @otousan69
      @otousan69 7 лет назад +16

      I now see everything so differently now.

    • @Melissa-zo7zu
      @Melissa-zo7zu 7 лет назад +12

      it's okay... I didn't need a heart😢😭😭

    • @toya1748
      @toya1748 7 лет назад +9

      why u gotta say that

  • @hayley4331
    @hayley4331 7 лет назад +1273

    This is what I imagine entering the gates of heaven sounds like

    • @justjello7599
      @justjello7599 7 лет назад +56

      heaven must be very edgy and emo then

    • @screenwalks7576
      @screenwalks7576 7 лет назад +3

      exactly

    • @stfutara1536
      @stfutara1536 7 лет назад +26

      too bad i'm going to hell

    • @rei8694
      @rei8694 7 лет назад +27

      CapturedMemes that's okay. Mama, we all go to hell .

    • @isabrockway7427
      @isabrockway7427 7 лет назад +9

      this comment is my everything

  • @abigailavenged8656
    @abigailavenged8656 6 лет назад +5136

    I think it’s so beautiful how two artists can give the same song different meanings. As several other people stated, Gerard sings like he’s trying so hard to hold on, while Tyler sings like he has accepted his fate.

    • @whyismimotaken9351
      @whyismimotaken9351 5 лет назад +69

      Oh my god

    • @lactosetolerant5078
      @lactosetolerant5078 5 лет назад +101

      This comment has been copied so many times jesus

    • @TheHorseOutside
      @TheHorseOutside 5 лет назад +107

      you can definitely see that in the lyrical changes Tyler made in his cover. Where Gerard sang "counting down the days to go, it just ain't living", Tyler sang "I'm counting down the days to go. This just ain't living"

    • @jadetrolland8095
      @jadetrolland8095 5 лет назад +3

      @@lactosetolerant5078 ikr? And I don't even really agree. But oh well, it's their opiniom

    • @coriquack1539
      @coriquack1539 4 года назад +26

      So maybe this one is about someone who’s trying to cling onto the hope that they’ll make it out alive, but deep down they know that hope won’t help them at all and that they’re already doomed

  • @stupidbitch3110
    @stupidbitch3110 6 лет назад +4551

    I'm just soggy from the emo

  • @Fleshwall
    @Fleshwall 7 лет назад +1584

    Play this at my funeral, I don't care if I get shot or have a heart attack I want this playing at my funeral

  • @highkingquill4616
    @highkingquill4616 7 лет назад +5261

    _ι dιd noт ѕιgn υp ғor тнιѕ paιn_
    _мy eмo ѕιde ιѕ ѕнowιng_

    • @adammcnarenape1759
      @adammcnarenape1759 7 лет назад +5

      MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

    • @kiittymashups2491
      @kiittymashups2491 7 лет назад +24

      tHIS IS NOT WHAT I HAD PLANNED
      THIS IS NOT WHAT I HAD PLANNED

    • @elskans
      @elskans 7 лет назад +5

      +KittyMashups gET OUT

    • @jamie8208
      @jamie8208 7 лет назад +19

      just don't leave the door open

    • @kiittymashups2491
      @kiittymashups2491 7 лет назад +21

      +Braniyah Sykes-uzumaki *doesn't close the goddamn door*

  • @nothanks3724
    @nothanks3724 6 лет назад +4917

    Hears the song: *sobs*
    Hears the cover: *cries*
    Hears this: *dies*

  • @libby1290
    @libby1290 4 года назад +516

    there is no better version.
    MCR is one of the first stages of finding out you have cancer and you don’t want to die because you have more to live for.
    TØP is when you know your death is inevitable and you decide to live the rest of your life peacefully instead of in turmoil with yourself.
    they are the same story, told at different times.

    • @JP-np8fj
      @JP-np8fj 3 года назад +5

      That's deep man

    • @aryanxavier5174
      @aryanxavier5174 3 года назад +6

      I like this explanation you gave. Its true.

    • @pickledfur
      @pickledfur Год назад

      ​@@JP-np8fjnot as deep as me in ur mom last night >:3

  • @saikinist
    @saikinist 7 лет назад +3039

    Gerard is singing like he's winning,
    Tyler is singing like he's losing.
    Gerard's voice has got more anger,
    Tyler's voice has got more sadness.
    Both songs have same melody and same lyrics,
    but each of them tells a different story.

    • @thomaswilliams2723
      @thomaswilliams2723 7 лет назад +118

      Phanic! At the Twenty Øne Septipliers EXACTLY! Thank you! Another person who gets it. Gerard is fighting to stay alive and Tyler is saying goodbye

    • @redassassin1347
      @redassassin1347 7 лет назад +1

      So true

    • @linkheroofspiritsakatrains4812
      @linkheroofspiritsakatrains4812 7 лет назад +20

      Phanic! At the Twenty Øne Septipliers you must be joking Tyler's voice has too much computers and electronic sounds in it it ruins the point

    • @nc23_87
      @nc23_87 7 лет назад +15

      Ted Brodhead shush

    • @annamullinger8671
      @annamullinger8671 7 лет назад +36

      Phanic! At the Twenty Øne Septipliers that is such a good analysis of the songs! I never thought about it that way. I like Gerard's voice so much *because* he sounds permanently angry

  • @aixa2807
    @aixa2807 7 лет назад +368

    _'I just became so emo I fell apart'_

  • @Kongstudios2
    @Kongstudios2 6 лет назад +804

    It's like both Gerard and Tyler play the same man, Gerard's bit is maybe a few months to a year after he finds out he's got cancer and is angry at himself and the world and is trying with all his might to stay but eventually over time it gets worse and he starts to accept the hand he was dealt leading into Tyler's bit where he's in the last stages of it before drifting away giving him just enough time to reflect on his situation and make peace with himself.

  • @moustachedomo767
    @moustachedomo767 6 лет назад +1788

    I don't think it's about "fighting back" (mcr) and "giving up" (top). Mostly because I hate the idea that cancer patients have "given up". I think these songs can be looked as the different states. Mcr shows regrets and anger. While top shown the acceptence of that you have to go now and wish to spend the last days in a loving, calm way.
    But it could also be seen in the view of relatives. When my grandpa wasn't around, I "was" the mcr version. Full of anger. But when I was with my grandpa I wanted to give him a calm, loving atmosphere, so I "was" the top version.
    Idk, I just like this explanation more than giving up and fighting back.

    • @enriqueantonio7868
      @enriqueantonio7868 5 лет назад +38

      I always preferred the term “letting go” rather than “giving up” or “lost the fight”

    • @Kiki_Kiwi_
      @Kiki_Kiwi_ 5 лет назад +4

      I was almost the same way with my grandfather but that all happened 3 years ago

    • @Ajlondon_
      @Ajlondon_ 5 лет назад

      I agree

    • @augustgarcia5756
      @augustgarcia5756 5 лет назад

      thank you

    • @lucien5884
      @lucien5884 5 лет назад

      i agree 100%

  • @kyriaanderson6564
    @kyriaanderson6564 7 лет назад +1718

    I didn't order a milkshake but I sure am shook

    • @andres_fernandez4512
      @andres_fernandez4512 7 лет назад +6

      Kyria Anderson that's great 😂

    • @soupiefr
      @soupiefr 7 лет назад +3

      Kyria Anderson XD

    • @koiwi4931
      @koiwi4931 7 лет назад +2

      Kyria Anderson I'm dead😂

    • @bruhmadisan9321
      @bruhmadisan9321 7 лет назад +2

      Idk how to react to this, me though

    • @anatchi
      @anatchi 7 лет назад +5

      Kyria Anderson I'm thinking of Shane now.anyone?

  • @ryanross2192
    @ryanross2192 6 лет назад +3461

    Tyler's soft tone puts a lot of sadness to it, and Gerard's raspy and long notes makes it even sadder
    HELP

  • @DylanPickleGaming
    @DylanPickleGaming 6 лет назад +678

    this isnt about which is "better"
    this is bringing us together

    • @teamrias7100
      @teamrias7100 4 года назад +12

      My chemical pilots? Or 21 chemical romances?

    • @squeeged
      @squeeged 4 года назад +10

      @@teamrias7100 My chemical pilots rolls of the tongue better

    • @teamrias7100
      @teamrias7100 4 года назад +6

      @@squeeged that i can agree✊

    • @vijaykrishnanchandramohan7603
      @vijaykrishnanchandramohan7603 4 года назад

      Mumblecrust Bucky yeah but 21 chemical romances makes more sense

    • @squeeged
      @squeeged 4 года назад

      @@vijaykrishnanchandramohan7603 I would disagree but to each his own

  • @bicuber8399
    @bicuber8399 5 лет назад +346

    Friend: Which is better, MCR's Cancer or TØP?
    Me: yes

  • @corn_inc.
    @corn_inc. 7 лет назад +2225

    Jesus christ- imagine how amazing it would be if Tyler and Gerard sang this together live.

    • @snliz3272
      @snliz3272 7 лет назад +50

      I'm crying just thinking about it

    • @ajsteenrod100
      @ajsteenrod100 7 лет назад +10

      YES!!! 😭😭

    • @saturn3260
      @saturn3260 7 лет назад +39

      i will keep tweeting tyler and gerard until they respond with yes,

    • @jorgeoctaviomartineztovar8064
      @jorgeoctaviomartineztovar8064 7 лет назад +23

      dudes don´t ask that to tyler ask it to gerard he is the one that will mean it

    • @strcrsd
      @strcrsd 7 лет назад +8

      Oh my god yes :')

  • @yyxykive
    @yyxykive 7 лет назад +359

    I CAN IMAGINE TYLER AND GERARD SINGING TOGETHER OMFG

    • @comiccookie194
      @comiccookie194 7 лет назад +1

      Ruby Moss SAMME AHHHH

    • @mxmorrigans
      @mxmorrigans 7 лет назад +23

      Ruby Moss Tyler might cry

    • @champino3085
      @champino3085 7 лет назад +6

      Ruby Moss now you've said that I can see it too :'( I'm crying fuck it would be the highlight of my life to see them singing together

    • @owlgurl99
      @owlgurl99 7 лет назад +3

      Ruby Moss -single tear-

    • @sandraz205
      @sandraz205 7 лет назад +4

      Ruby Moss
      SAME I'M JUST CLOSING MY EYES AND I SEE THEM SINGING TOGETHER

  • @morgan7627
    @morgan7627 6 лет назад +255

    me: oh i love this part!
    fren: which part
    me: 00:00 through 2:53
    fren: thats the entire thing tho
    me: exactly.

  • @absolutelynoclue.3393
    @absolutelynoclue.3393 6 лет назад +160

    It seems like Tyler has accepted his fate, but Gerard still feels like there's hope and he's fighting. The contrast is so overwhelming.

    • @Chief_-yb3fx
      @Chief_-yb3fx 4 года назад +2

      Look at the older goner in no phun intended

    • @kitsune630
      @kitsune630 3 года назад

      Tyler hasnt accepted his fate, he knows that hes gonna die soon and accepted that he will live his last days in a peaceful loving a way.

    • @absolutelynoclue.3393
      @absolutelynoclue.3393 3 года назад

      @@kitsune630 i like your funny words, magic man.

  • @mint3465
    @mint3465 7 лет назад +1387

    The original by My Chemical Romance has a tone of fighting back and of regret, while Twenty-One Pilots' cover is of acceptance.

    • @spiderbvtch9143
      @spiderbvtch9143 7 лет назад +29

      I think Twenty One Pilot's is more weakness, though I can see what you mean by acceptance.

    • @giisellegaalvan1996
      @giisellegaalvan1996 7 лет назад +84

      MCR - Still fighting
      TØP - Giving up on life

    • @AntiiNea
      @AntiiNea 7 лет назад +43

      TOP makes it sound more like a love song somehow

    • @danny-bk8mz
      @danny-bk8mz 6 лет назад +4

      Clementine :p yES idk why

    • @cherryknots
      @cherryknots 6 лет назад +4

      Clementine :p I thought I was the only one who thought that

  • @krazykat3810
    @krazykat3810 7 лет назад +648

    1:07 I could just picture Tyler and Gerard singing together 😭

  • @mozzarellapizza5513
    @mozzarellapizza5513 5 лет назад +105

    One taught me sadness
    And
    One taught me anger

  • @chloed4482
    @chloed4482 6 лет назад +394

    the twenty one pilots version is actually how i got into mcr.
    (I didn't know who they were bc i was only like 5 or 6 when they split)

    • @bellesmith4431
      @bellesmith4431 5 лет назад +11

      Infinity On Chloe yeah that's how I got into them too

    • @gurobonnie
      @gurobonnie 5 лет назад +16

      chloe dieguez In that case, I believe we’re the same age 🤧 though you commented this a year ago it’s just nice finding fans of MCR who aren’t like, 16+

    • @user-iv2pu1er6p
      @user-iv2pu1er6p 5 лет назад +8

      I think I'm as old as you but I was 5 when I found out about them, and they were still together maybe some months before they broke up.

    • @alsolos3120
      @alsolos3120 4 года назад +8

      I was 7. I really needed to know that other young people liked them. Thank you

    • @jackwilliams8315
      @jackwilliams8315 4 года назад +5

      Same here, I was 8 when they broke up but I didn’t listen to music as a fan yet

  • @gabygaribaldi3866
    @gabygaribaldi3866 7 лет назад +1283

    THE VOCALS TOGETHER I ALMOST CRIED I SWEAR. i hope im not the only one....

    • @littletuna3073
      @littletuna3073 7 лет назад +2

      same, but I did cry...

    • @DrPants0
      @DrPants0 7 лет назад

      Omg same it's so good.

    • @jilbrockman747
      @jilbrockman747 7 лет назад +13

      Same
      It actually brought tears to my eyes

    • @katepage9040
      @katepage9040 7 лет назад

      I ALMOST HAD A STROKE THOU SAAAAMEEE

    • @sjduda
      @sjduda 7 лет назад

      Gaby garibaldi same

  • @ellabieling803
    @ellabieling803 6 лет назад +2313

    Dont imagine going to a tøp concert and the lights are out and then when the lights turn on the stage is completly empty and tyler and gerard both drag chairs in and set them up back to back and start singing this together :)

    • @elenamark6941
      @elenamark6941 5 лет назад +30

      Ella Bieling thanks 😭

    • @choccmilk
      @choccmilk 5 лет назад +57

      don't imagine? no i would very much like to imagine that

    • @Liamochii
      @Liamochii 5 лет назад +20

      I wish

    • @epic8223
      @epic8223 5 лет назад +32

      I would
      Not
      Live

    • @I_GET_NO_SL33P
      @I_GET_NO_SL33P 5 лет назад +3

      I just did 😭😭😭

  • @emilydaniels2693
    @emilydaniels2693 6 лет назад +176

    My brother: look up the top and mcr mashup of cancer
    Me: ok!
    (watches this video)
    Me: (awkward silence) wow...
    (I go in my room)
    (Start crying)
    This is the best thing I’ve ever heard. Great job!

  • @annaliamcdowall3582
    @annaliamcdowall3582 6 лет назад +62

    Tyler is singing like he's given up and is sad about it whereas Gerard sounds like he's in pain and angry yet still fighting...
    I love both so much, though I think I prefer the original as it's less techy and more raw and natural

  • @emmagraceeb
    @emmagraceeb 7 лет назад +379

    the biggest difference I see is Gerard sings in a way like he's still fighting, as Tyler seems he's given up.

    • @emmagraceeb
      @emmagraceeb 7 лет назад +5

      I saw this on Instagram but it's true. ❤️

    • @mevaleunpepino
      @mevaleunpepino 7 лет назад +6

      since when instagram has stolen part of TUMBLR?

    • @minivloggers_ytreal5475
      @minivloggers_ytreal5475 7 лет назад

      Emma Grace ii

    • @impishizzy2590
      @impishizzy2590 7 лет назад +9

      Yeah it's like the two different sides of cancer just when you start to give up you come back and fight harder

    • @k8_cringe
      @k8_cringe 7 лет назад +3

      Omg I never thought about it like that but now I realize that's so true

  • @kyliegustin9658
    @kyliegustin9658 7 лет назад +760

    It's official. I'm depressed

  • @summershepard4615
    @summershepard4615 6 лет назад +122

    MCR Cancer will always be the best to me Gerard’s voice just had more emotion behind it and really makes is amazing

    • @chloeprall9944
      @chloeprall9944 3 года назад +14

      Right! He’s the one who actually wrote the song! So it has so much more raw meaning to it. Tyler and joshes version was very good and it makes me rlly happy to know that they like My Chemical Romace and look up to them enough to cover a song and feel a connection to it. But this song came from G’s hearts so of course it’s better and more heartfelt. ❤️

  • @cap4264
    @cap4264 4 года назад +26

    I used to believe that perfection wasn’t possible
    AND THEN I HEARD THIS

  • @gracie3060
    @gracie3060 6 лет назад +1369

    Roses are red
    Gerard is bae
    MCR broke up
    Im not okay.

    • @nicholaswolff2181
      @nicholaswolff2181 5 лет назад +38

      Do you promise?

    • @thatsroughbuddy1040
      @thatsroughbuddy1040 5 лет назад +17

      I do. I promise.

    • @kristygrosso8648
      @kristygrosso8648 5 лет назад +4

      Oof

    • @void3381
      @void3381 5 лет назад +7

      Ann Smith You're officially in the cult!

    • @Aly-cv4mp
      @Aly-cv4mp 5 лет назад +19

      I'm not okay. I pormise.
      When me and my ex gf dated after every time we said "i'm not okay" we would look at each other and say i promise at the same time and everyone was so confused

  • @giakms9852
    @giakms9852 7 лет назад +702

    This makes me feel a certain type of way

  • @hpsauce8152
    @hpsauce8152 5 лет назад +20

    When Tyler and Gerard had that part together I started bawling my eyes out. Two black smudges down my face. It was beautiful 😢😢

  • @sh7dowmustdie
    @sh7dowmustdie 6 лет назад +77

    2nd part sounds like MCR feat.TØP

  • @resurrectthenight
    @resurrectthenight 7 лет назад +2393

    THIS IS WHAT I ACTUALLY WANTED IM DEAD

  • @nehathejedi4962
    @nehathejedi4962 7 лет назад +1683

    When I first heard the original song I thought it was extremely sad because he's still got a little fight in him. But Tyler sings it like he's given up completely and that makes it even sadder!
    Great mashup btw.

  • @sarah-yi4hb
    @sarah-yi4hb 5 лет назад +15

    Gerard Ways voice and Josh Duns drums is something I never thought I would hear at the same time

  • @giannaf874
    @giannaf874 5 лет назад +39

    Person: Why are you crying?
    Me: *CAUSE THE HARDEST PART OF THIS IS LEAVING YOU!*
    Person: Um what..?

  • @hhgreggfan
    @hhgreggfan 7 лет назад +2081

    thnks fr mkng m cry

  • @itinera207
    @itinera207 7 лет назад +193

    I just love how mcr influenced tøp

  • @jUaN-cw2bz
    @jUaN-cw2bz 4 года назад +19

    Emo kids in 2016: 21 PILOTS
    Emo kids in 2007: MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE

  • @allisonschumann6691
    @allisonschumann6691 5 лет назад +36

    Omg it sounds 😊 good when they sing together! It’s almost like echoey!

    • @jadetrolland8095
      @jadetrolland8095 5 лет назад +1

      Right? When both voices are singing at the same time it's the actual best

  • @sikeziato2133
    @sikeziato2133 6 лет назад +200

    I will not die if this isn't played at my funeral

  • @CrazyMaddie24
    @CrazyMaddie24 7 лет назад +772

    wat this sounds like a completely different song i love it tho

  • @finnbush361
    @finnbush361 4 года назад +17

    This is my favorite song ever for a couple reasons:
    1. My grandma recently passed away due to cancer
    2. It’s from my birth year
    3. It’s one of the only songs that has ever made me cry

  • @aliciab988
    @aliciab988 4 года назад +25

    no one:
    Literally nobody:
    me in middle school: *Screaming the lyrics through hitched breaths while eyeliner streams down my face*

  • @hannahmiller1115
    @hannahmiller1115 7 лет назад +573

    *sharply inhales breath when Gerard starts singing* God, this cover is beautiful with Tyler and Gerard's vocals together.

    • @gcozzoli
      @gcozzoli 7 лет назад +23

      I know I started crying

    • @yaboiskinnypenisxxx4003
      @yaboiskinnypenisxxx4003 7 лет назад

      +Gianna Cozzoli me too...

    • @raybarreno2900
      @raybarreno2900 7 лет назад +4

      play this at my funaral

    • @loganphetteplace6532
      @loganphetteplace6532 7 лет назад +4

      I don't like the Twenty One Pilots version. The MCR version is just better.

    • @tyler_bt3326
      @tyler_bt3326 7 лет назад +1

      logan phetteplace I don't like it either. Of all the MCR songs to cover, they covered one of their best songs (imo). They should've just left MCR alone

  • @ZacharyOsterman
    @ZacharyOsterman 7 лет назад +944

    The contrast in this is Beautiful, like they both deal with grief in different ways

    • @yeetjuice8085
      @yeetjuice8085 7 лет назад +24

      Well said! That's exactly what's i was thinking!

    • @ahmedelosta9551
      @ahmedelosta9551 6 лет назад +5

      Zeke The Geek we are all counting down the days to go

    • @This_Guy55
      @This_Guy55 6 лет назад +15

      Zach Osterman yeah! With MCR, he sounds like he still has a little bit of hope left. Tøp sings it like they’ve given up completely.

  • @tcavendano
    @tcavendano 3 года назад +19

    They way they sing it is so beautiful but tragic, and makes the song sadder in different ways:
    1. Tyler's gentle, soothing voice seems to be saying softly that he knows what is to come is inevitable while
    2. Gerard's raspy, desparte voice seems to be screaming that he wants to hold on, when he knows it's hopeless
    Now excuse me while I cry for another hour :D

  • @gr4ydmai
    @gr4ydmai 6 лет назад +13

    this seriously made me cry when my two favorite bands sang together. in memory of mcr and working through the hiatus. this music helps me get through a lot

  • @madiburgsfx7194
    @madiburgsfx7194 7 лет назад +1142

    When you promised you left your emo phase but then you hear this and smudge your black eyeliner to match your blacked ripped skinny jeans.

  • @IcedJameson
    @IcedJameson 7 лет назад +353

    Whoever had the idea to mash these songs together... Hats off to you. you are the real MVP

  • @twentysixdegrees
    @twentysixdegrees 5 лет назад +17

    someone: which version of Cancer do you like?
    me: yes

  • @quinnperez184
    @quinnperez184 6 лет назад +48

    I've always liked the MCR version more but liked the mood of the TOP version and ive been wanting to listen to something in between, and this is it!! Omg beautiful?! I'm gonna be blasting this for a good while!!!! Great job!!!! 👏👏👏

  • @erinwalker7015
    @erinwalker7015 7 лет назад +88

    I can sort of see them both performing on the same stage to this song and it's making me cry for multiple reasons

  • @littleconch
    @littleconch 7 лет назад +354

    Everyone always claims that the MCR version sounds like he is still fighting, but to me it sounds like a really painful acceptance, like he is angry because he just wants to distance himself to avoid anyone being hurt. That's why I like MCR's version better because it sounds like he is on the verge of crying and trying to protect loved ones while twenty one pilots makes me think of the weakness of someone's last moments in life dealing with cancer and something that'd be played after someone's death.

    • @user-iv2sw6vg1c
      @user-iv2sw6vg1c 7 лет назад +12

      idkwhattonamemychannellol
      The mcr version sounds like if Gerad is angry at himself for making people sad and the fact that he cant do anything to stop it from happening.
      The twenty one pilots version sounds like if Tyler is accepting everything that is happening and he knows that being angry or sad is not going to help
      Well thats how I see it! 😅

    • @littleconch
      @littleconch 7 лет назад +5

      Lawless Sempai Well said :) I just don't see how people think Gerad sounds like he's fighting because like you said it sounds more like he's angry that he's making people sad and it sounds kind of painful

    • @E_N_B
      @E_N_B 7 лет назад +5

      idkwhattonamemychannellol I'd like to think that the mashup of both songs are an acceptance that the cancer has impacted them and their family permanently, and are just trying to move on.

    • @elle3975
      @elle3975 7 лет назад +5

      idkwhattonamemychannellol I like that and I think this is why I like the TØP version better. It think that one shows fear and the original shows what you said

    • @geenote4524
      @geenote4524 7 лет назад +5

      I agree because the MCR one has more emotion.

  • @chilllil5225
    @chilllil5225 6 лет назад +10

    I love how Tyler’s voice sounds with the piano from the MCR version! It’s so beautiful. And when they come together I almost cried. Amazing job!

  • @oliveoddle
    @oliveoddle 6 лет назад +280

    a girl dressed up as a girl from the black parade (i was blurryface) we were arguing over which was better. she said mcr i said both were great but i felt so attacked she was so scary

    • @alsolos3120
      @alsolos3120 4 года назад +11

      Well, I mean, obviously.

    • @egoapple5421
      @egoapple5421 4 года назад +19

      MCR is better so like ye edgy girl is right

    • @koemiseina4495
      @koemiseina4495 4 года назад +17

      I can totally imagine it going like:
      You: hey, it's okay, I care what you think...
      She: YOU'LLNEVERMAKEMEBECAUSETHEWORLDWILLNEVERTAKEMYHEARTTTTT

    • @nash.3939
      @nash.3939 4 года назад +1

      Out of Context, but nice kirishima picture tho.

  • @emrysbee9393
    @emrysbee9393 7 лет назад +769

    I think tøp's cover had more of the sadness in it but the original had more of the anger of it. I love them both

    • @mayab8888
      @mayab8888 7 лет назад +27

      Emily SOMEONE FINALLY PUT IT INTO WORDS

    • @moriahmars1462
      @moriahmars1462 7 лет назад +13

      +Emily I wouldn't say anger but I guess it's a person fighting cancer, The top version was like letting cancer kill him

    • @breehurricane6361
      @breehurricane6361 7 лет назад +23

      Emily Gerard's song feels like he is fighting
      And Tyler sang it like he is losing the fight

    • @indothekd1397
      @indothekd1397 7 лет назад +40

      Emily i think Gerard from mcr is more of a fighting cancer patient and in the tøp cover tyler makes it sound like he's a losing one

    • @kettyforest9101
      @kettyforest9101 7 лет назад +2

      I thought exact the same thing

  • @wokeypsyche
    @wokeypsyche 6 лет назад +2251

    Friend: Which Cancer song do you like? The one by MCR, or the one by TOP?
    Me: ... Um. *Shows vid*
    Friend: Oh

    • @jaidynlarios1589
      @jaidynlarios1589 6 лет назад +18

      Coffee Aroma "top" dude seriously?

    • @darrenmendez7262
      @darrenmendez7262 6 лет назад +11

      Friend: what cancer song do you like? The one by mcr or the one by top?
      Me: Justin Bieber song

    • @royalblu1100
      @royalblu1100 6 лет назад +33

      Flappy shet why r u even here

    • @versatilesamuel1607
      @versatilesamuel1607 6 лет назад +8

      Coffee Aroma Your friends like MCR ?!

    • @stuff5684
      @stuff5684 6 лет назад +1

      same

  • @lovelyava3626
    @lovelyava3626 6 лет назад +100

    The moment I say I’m not emo I look on RUclips “tøp vs mcr” 😂😂

  • @_figgle_diggle_4636
    @_figgle_diggle_4636 6 лет назад +18

    IM ACTUALLY CRYING ITS SO BEAUTIFUL

  • @emilyannelincicome2921
    @emilyannelincicome2921 7 лет назад +141

    *wipes tear* this is the most beautiful thing I've ever heard

  • @caroline-gw1zq
    @caroline-gw1zq 7 лет назад +167

    the difference between them is that it sounds like gerard is fighting. tyler has already given up.

    • @caroline-gw1zq
      @caroline-gw1zq 7 лет назад +13

      i didnt make that up but

    • @naurarri
      @naurarri 7 лет назад

      true tho

    • @tristian2598
      @tristian2598 6 лет назад +1

      Well the entire Album of welcome to the blackparade is about fighting against and then accepting death

  • @cosmicloafi9704
    @cosmicloafi9704 5 лет назад +26

    Like many believe, I don’t think the original sounds like the patient is still fighting and the cover has accepted it. I think that the original is just at the point when the patient is angry and full of regrets and things he wishes he could have done, overall the patient thinks his way of living now is not a true life and that there is just a slither of hope he must cling to.
    And the cover is a different point when he’s lost hope and is barely holding on to anything anymore. Not that he’s accepted it, but that he’s too weak to fight anymore, or the point where he’s about to die/ dying

    • @jadetrolland8095
      @jadetrolland8095 5 лет назад +3

      Thank you! This is exactly what I think.
      I just can't see the original as fighting back, as to me he has given up. So this explanation is perfect

  • @liannegroenendijk2096
    @liannegroenendijk2096 5 лет назад +13

    I love both.
    When I heard that my grandmother would probably die the next day (due to the effects of cancer) I was inconsolable. I went to bed and I absolutely could not sleep. There are 165 songs in my playlist on spotify. I clicked on shuffle and exactly this song played first (the Twenty Øne Piløts version). I don't believe in god, spirits or angels, but this could not be a coincidence. It helped me that night. The next day I went to her. She died an hour after I arrived.

  • @IMShKdiS-ox6lp
    @IMShKdiS-ox6lp 7 лет назад +414

    If they ever play this at my funeral I would arise from the dead at walk into the bathroom and start balling tears then I would walk back into my coffin.
    Sorry,I'm WAY to SH00K 4 dis

    • @Emily-wh2lz
      @Emily-wh2lz 7 лет назад +6

      IM2Sh00K4diS :0 imagine you just do like a Helena thing where when the best drops your like NOPEEEE SCUSE ME

    • @daniellebuchanan5357
      @daniellebuchanan5357 7 лет назад

      Same tho

    • @kenma-_-4335
      @kenma-_-4335 6 лет назад

      Me tooooo

  • @okaythen3045
    @okaythen3045 7 лет назад +527

    My only request is that my loved ones play this mashup at my funeral.

  • @lalrinchhanaralte8936
    @lalrinchhanaralte8936 6 лет назад +23

    i will not kiss you...cuz da hardest part of this is leaving you😭😭😭

    • @milliedaniels8355
      @milliedaniels8355 6 лет назад

      Lalrinchhana Ralte I read this as soon as he said it.. and it made me cry! 😭😭

  • @kriswhitley5876
    @kriswhitley5876 4 года назад +8

    "Emo is short for emotional and music without emotion is just another jingle,so call us emo but we are still better than your ass"-
    Frank Iero

  • @playofthegame9545
    @playofthegame9545 7 лет назад +526

    i didn't cry am i not emo enough?
    *puts on an intense amount of black eyeliner and dyes hair black*
    IM READY

    • @lizzielbbh8043
      @lizzielbbh8043 7 лет назад

      Play Of The Game 😂😂

    • @me-ik1hr
      @me-ik1hr 7 лет назад +7

      +Kawaii_chan Games Its time to stop

    • @killjysmakesmenise3977
      @killjysmakesmenise3977 7 лет назад +5

      Play Of The Game luckily I don't need to dye my hair black..cuz my hair is already born black

    • @bluebell560
      @bluebell560 7 лет назад +10

      +Killjøys make søme nøise! Make it darker. It's not black enough until you become the void.

    • @yaaxis
      @yaaxis 7 лет назад

      same here its so black that people think i dye it ;P

  • @ryanngan7385
    @ryanngan7385 7 лет назад +342

    What I've noticed so far is Tyler's voice sounds like he's given up while Gerard's sounds like he's fighting

  • @cv4061
    @cv4061 5 лет назад +9

    I can imagine them doing a concert together and sounding just like this

  • @isthatjojivlogs7551
    @isthatjojivlogs7551 3 года назад +4

    I love the comment comparing tøp’s to giving up and mcr’s to fighting. But, i see it more as;
    Mcr’s: Anger, learning you have cancer, and holding that anger for months.
    Tøp’s: the acceptance, and the sadness you feel, but not giving up.

  • @zadraking
    @zadraking 7 лет назад +516

    Through out this video, my nails painted themselves black and chipped, while black rubber band bracelets slowly made there way to my wrists in the same fashion Iron Man's suit attaches. #ForeverEmo

  • @cassandravanmeter304
    @cassandravanmeter304 7 лет назад +361

    Im not crying my neighbors just like cutting onions at 3am

  • @celeswilliams3047
    @celeswilliams3047 5 лет назад +9

    Nothing makes me cry that often but some how you did it. I'm not ok, I promise.

  • @the.creature._
    @the.creature._ 3 года назад +3

    the two different voices make an illusion of a group people singing together. I really like that.

  • @uncannyalex6905
    @uncannyalex6905 7 лет назад +386

    this mashup should be considered a third version of cancer honestly this is so good

    • @greylark2759
      @greylark2759 7 лет назад

      Uncanny-Alex ikr its no its so good

    • @marsh896
      @marsh896 7 лет назад +6

      Uncanny-Alex that can be interpreted in so many different ways

    • @mevaleunpepino
      @mevaleunpepino 7 лет назад +2

      who left this onions beside me?

  • @avreythequeen2910
    @avreythequeen2910 7 лет назад +139

    that was the most beautiful sound i ever heard

  • @arthuranderson844
    @arthuranderson844 2 года назад +3

    I still refuse to listen to any of the separate pieces, because pieced together makes this a master piece

  • @spacedout3218
    @spacedout3218 4 года назад +6

    MCR sounds like he’s fighting, and has hope, but Tyler sounds like he’s already given up

  • @chlorinelive6573
    @chlorinelive6573 7 лет назад +336

    *People:* How long are you going to listen to this song?
    *Me:* Until I hate it.
    *1 hour later*
    *People:* Are you done yet???
    *Me:* No.

    • @the2muskateers687
      @the2muskateers687 7 лет назад +11

      Mickeymouse1987 *1 years*
      People: you done yet
      Me: NO NEVER

    • @momosworld1489
      @momosworld1489 7 лет назад +5

      * 30 years later *
      People - ya done?
      Me - * hasn't showered eaten and is living off this song* NOOO

    • @Cloud5472
      @Cloud5472 6 лет назад

      bl|rryf|c| i remember back when i was on hour 1

    • @0xeyeDaisy
      @0xeyeDaisy 6 лет назад +2

      *10 years*
      Friends: are you okay
      Me: *NNOoOo*

    • @gerardpanickingatthediscow3670
      @gerardpanickingatthediscow3670 6 лет назад +4

      *47375738285 years layer*
      me: *in an old raspy voice* “Just one. More. Time!

  • @adowbeflashplayer
    @adowbeflashplayer 7 лет назад +1078

    why am I torturing myself by listening to this.... help. :'( im alrdy crying

    • @DXDDY.SKETCHY
      @DXDDY.SKETCHY 6 лет назад +5

      Mayley same

    • @angelvillica2268
      @angelvillica2268 6 лет назад +9

      Mayley omg I can't stop listening to the part where they both sing

    • @psycho.galaxy
      @psycho.galaxy 6 лет назад

      My thoughts exactly.

    • @smoothcriminal6622
      @smoothcriminal6622 6 лет назад

      Morganimations same
      Stay alive fren

    • @jazzy2347
      @jazzy2347 6 лет назад +3

      Omg i found someone who likes bts and depressing music ......yay

  • @frnksfrthmmrs2508
    @frnksfrthmmrs2508 5 лет назад +4

    i’m not crying i just have some March 22 in my eye

  • @infrogswetrust420
    @infrogswetrust420 4 года назад +6

    At 1:22 you can test wich one you stan more by looking at how you sing the line.

  • @Jay-ub6nk
    @Jay-ub6nk 7 лет назад +924

    Tyler has given up Gerard is fighting back

  • @leonathompson9898
    @leonathompson9898 7 лет назад +470

    I think this song brings TOP fans and MCR fans together to show how amazing they both really are. It's an amazing song that mcr made and they played it so well and TOP killed it on the cover. Both bands are amazingly awesome and this mashup is like the heavens

    • @natashaviolettt
      @natashaviolettt 6 лет назад +3

      Leona Thompson I hate top..

    • @vedikapandey8855
      @vedikapandey8855 6 лет назад +10

      wait wait, we love gee, but we don't like that youtube account

    • @NinaWTF
      @NinaWTF 6 лет назад +6

      True, I love both of them.

    • @bellamyclark926
      @bellamyclark926 6 лет назад +8

      Leona Thompson damn right.please donate some of your common sense to triggered fans.

    • @morgan7627
      @morgan7627 6 лет назад +2

      um thanks this is so true

  • @Perrified
    @Perrified 6 лет назад +18

    I'm crafting frantically I have already made about 700 paper snowflakes send help

  • @luckymoonjoy1278
    @luckymoonjoy1278 3 года назад +2

    I haven’t heard either of these songs and I can say, I was listening to this in the background while doing other stuff, and I thought to myself “Huh? I thought this was supposed to be a mashup of two different songs?” And I had to come and check.

  • @esetaviejo
    @esetaviejo 7 лет назад +141

    tHE MIDDLE BIT WHERE THEY SING TOGETHER IS MORE PAINFUL THAN DYING I STG

  • @abbimohrman5184
    @abbimohrman5184 7 лет назад +286

    The Twentyonepilots version to me sounds more sad and makes me depressed while the MCR version makes me not want to give up and keep fighting.

  • @tcavendano
    @tcavendano 4 года назад +4

    Their voices together made my heart melt

  • @nopoop630
    @nopoop630 3 года назад +8

    This version made me cry harder than both versions lol

  • @liaguianen5247
    @liaguianen5247 7 лет назад +164

    ok guys.....stop fighting....both versions are outstanding..........yes MCR did make this song and tøp did the cover. But that doesn't mean Tyler didn't do good....his voice fits the song greatly.
    Gerard's voice is more rough, and it sounds likes he is fighting.
    Tyler's is soft and worn down and sounds like he has given up.
    both fit the song, just in different ways.

    • @savannahray2044
      @savannahray2044 7 лет назад +3

      F.O.B lover wow, that is great.

    • @ThisOneCassie
      @ThisOneCassie 6 лет назад +4

      I wouldn't say given up more likes somber acceptance

  • @aykangaming
    @aykangaming 7 лет назад +437

    1:07 if this happened in concert (gerard walks on stage and starts singing with tyler), the whole crowd would fucking explode

    • @teodora7400
      @teodora7400 7 лет назад +6

      sign me up

    • @archerrz24
      @archerrz24 7 лет назад +9

      AykanGaming I would have yelled "OI, I WANT MCR BACK" and faint

    • @panicatmychemicalphandoml4492
      @panicatmychemicalphandoml4492 7 лет назад +5

      AykanGaming i rhink my overies would explode

    • @pretzel_bun
      @pretzel_bun 7 лет назад +1

      AykanGaming I would screech as loud as I possibly could while crying oml

    • @perceptiondeceptiondeletio4342
      @perceptiondeceptiondeletio4342 7 лет назад +7

      AykanGaming imagine my chem showing up in a tøp concert be like : "hey guys whaddup we're back!Let's sing now.....I WILL NOT KUSSSS UUUUU"

  • @madisonlindenmuth2030
    @madisonlindenmuth2030 3 года назад +3

    im not gonna lie, when tyler started singing...........chills man......chills