Every gesture is so clear yet so musical. And the musicality and sensitivity with which the group responds is incredible. Just brilliant all the way around. I hope everyone lucky enough to attend in person knew how special that was.
Yeah! Oh! my God Conducting, beautiful, wonderful, splendid and so much graceful through to the end, I would feel his left arm is God's Arm. By the way, I hear "Beethoven said Tempo is Music". especially he is veryvery good at changing tempo which is concerned with connection between various rhythm. Any way I was moved so much. and more orchestra played beautiful, energetic and graceful.(91yrs.Japanese) sorry strange English.
Unsurpassed. His complete control of all elements of the score, gestures to prepare them, and a physical technique that simply has never been seen, all of this is what made Kleiber Kleiber.
This is so perfect ....... I don't have any inclination to this specifical score, but each time, every time , when I see Carlos conducting it, I watch and listen till the end
@@enricomarconi1767 parla con Patrick Lang. Konrad von Abel. Raffaele Napoli. ...you know as well as i that Celi was THE KING without a crown...cuz he never wanted it. talk to those guys i told you about.
KARL KLEIBER , UNA MARAVILLA COMO DIRECTOR DE ORQUESTA !!! DE LO MEJOR QUE VI !!! MI RESPETO Y ADMIRACIÓN POR ÉL !!!! GRACIAS POR COMPARTIR EL VIDEO !!!
Для меня слушатьКАРЛОСА КЛАЙБЕРА, это не только слушать, но и видить, как Он дирижирует.Завораживает его пластика, как Он это делает. БРАВО, МАЭСТРО.❤🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🙏❤
Assolutamente straordinario e insuperabile, ogni sua esecuzione è una pietra miliare nella storia della musica, altro che "pregi e difetti." L'unico difetto, purtroppo per noi, è che non ha voluto dirigere più di tanto, e il repertorio che ci ha lasciato è ridotto rispetto ad altri "grandi" come Karajan o Bernstein che sono stati molto più voraci. Ma in quello che ha diretto non ha eguali. Un po' come Benedetti Michelangeli nel pianoforte.
i miss my beloved Brahms 3. with him, i am searching i found not ,it must be a bliss,-.i love him,he could be very angry with the orchestra but he was an very sensitive being .
He startet as correpetitor on Rhine Opera in Düsseldorf and there he also started directing. He directet very young anOthello in Düsseldorf with Hans Kaart as Othello. Unforgettable. Kaart died very young while a simple surgery on an ear. ❤
Mr. Kleiber totally feels this music. A joy to watch his "in the moment" involvement. The orchestra is absolutely fabulous. I would like to know what orchestra this was.
not even close to Celibidache's caliber! Celi...was not of this world, Kleber...too generic. too many "conductors" were , are....like kleiber. sorry man ...one day you'll realize no conductor was like Celi....EVER
Ha abbattuto completamente la distanza che c'è tra l'autore e l'esecuzione. Un'intelligenza musicale di enorme grandezza, ancor prima che un direttore dalla tecnica insuperabile. Nulla è meccanico, tutto sembra nascere nel momento della direzione.
Up in the conductor's room in Heaven, Lenny was heard, boldly declaring that " God said I AM His favourite conductor!!" Shortly after a quite grumble was heard from HvK ".... I did not." But in my view, HvK has more than proved that he has presented the most imaginative and highly polished performances of great music in the history of our current civilization. So many great conductors. Only one can fit at the top and that's HvK. And just so you know... BRRRRRRZZZ! There goes the buzzer, no further discussion will be admissible on this topic. I have spoken. Barney O'Hara
What a nonsense. Neither of them would have raised a question like that. They admired each other as their letters show. When the Berlin Philharmonic tried to play them against each other for the New Year's concert 1988, they failed. Kleiber wrote to Karajan: I have no ambition as a conductor. I prefer to listen to you ... I am one of those few people of really knowing what endless miracles of conducting you have achieved. I remain your unworthy pupil and if I may, your friend. In their exchange they called each other Kapellmeister (bandleader) an ancient German title emphasising the craft and not the art.
Quanta accademia ! Troppa saccenteria...come si fa a stilare classifiche tanto banali ? Ogni grande direttore ha avuto pregi e limiti...nessuno fu ed è grande sempre e ovunque...Celibidache fu certo un grande : peraltro stimatissimo da ABMichelangeli e ciò basterebbe, ma tanti altri lo furono : Franco Ferrara e Bruno Walter per esempio....buona musica a tutti...
A great conductor, to be sure, and the discussion of where he "ranks" belittles that greatness. It must be said, though, that his greatness is revealed in a very small part of the repertory and that all of us are disappointed that for whatever reasons he was able to bring himself to conduct, say, only the 4th, 5th, 6th, and 7th symphonies of Beethoven and only the 2nd and 4th of Brahms and, say, only 5 or 6 operas. I doubt that had he come along earlier in the century, his career would have survived, so let's be grateful that he came when he did and gave us the enormous little he was able to. How this "ranks" vs Szell's or Abbado's omnicompetence and a great deal more in a much larger repertory is not for any of us to say as musicians are not thoroughbread horses and we are not handicappers. . 2:45
I was lucky enough to see him 4 times at the Met - Otello, Boheme, Traviata and Rosenkavalier. The Met musicians adored him. THE master!
Gosh! You were very lucky to see Carlos at the Met so many times.
What memories and an experience. I love his performances.
Every gesture is so clear yet so musical. And the musicality and sensitivity with which the group responds is incredible. Just brilliant all the way around. I hope everyone lucky enough to attend in person knew how special that was.
Yeah! Oh! my God Conducting, beautiful, wonderful, splendid and so much graceful through to the end, I would feel his left arm is God's Arm. By the way, I hear "Beethoven said Tempo is Music". especially he is veryvery good at changing tempo which is concerned with connection between various rhythm. Any way I was moved so much. and more orchestra played beautiful, energetic and graceful.(91yrs.Japanese) sorry strange English.
Unsurpassed. His complete control of all elements of the score, gestures to prepare them, and a physical technique that simply has never been seen, all of this is what made Kleiber Kleiber.
This is so perfect ....... I don't have any inclination to this specifical score, but each time, every time , when I see Carlos conducting it, I watch and listen till the end
His total with both the music and the musicians is the magic.
Ich habe schon viele Versionen der Fledermaus mit Kleiber gehört. Diese ist die Beste!
Dankeschön!❤️
Un angelo che è venuto tra noi ad insegnare ai direttori d'orchestra come si dirige e ai musicisti come si fa musica veramente.
quel angelo sia chiamato Celibidache. ❤👍
@@ionutzamfir5794 ma per favore! Era un bravo direttore ma nessuno è arrivato ai livelli di Kleiber. Neppure suo padre.
@@enricomarconi1767 parla con Patrick Lang. Konrad von Abel. Raffaele Napoli. ...you know as well as i that Celi was THE KING without a crown...cuz he never wanted it. talk to those guys i told you about.
KARL KLEIBER , UNA MARAVILLA COMO DIRECTOR DE ORQUESTA !!!
DE LO MEJOR QUE VI !!! MI RESPETO Y ADMIRACIÓN POR ÉL !!!! GRACIAS POR COMPARTIR EL VIDEO !!!
Nothing compares to this
Elegancia, precisión y gracia. Un deleite verlo dirigir al maestro Carlos Kleiber. Irrepetible y único.
Totally agree
Для меня слушатьКАРЛОСА КЛАЙБЕРА, это не только слушать, но и видить, как Он дирижирует.Завораживает его пластика, как Он это делает.
БРАВО, МАЭСТРО.❤🙏🌹🌹🌹🌹🙏❤
Though not being a conductor, I ADORE him! His bodylanguage couldn´t be more illustrative!
Fantastic. Agogic. Hands. Super.
Assolutamente straordinario e insuperabile, ogni sua esecuzione è una pietra miliare nella storia della musica, altro che "pregi e difetti." L'unico difetto, purtroppo per noi, è che non ha voluto dirigere più di tanto, e il repertorio che ci ha lasciato è ridotto rispetto ad altri "grandi" come Karajan o Bernstein che sono stati molto più voraci.
Ma in quello che ha diretto non ha eguali.
Un po' come Benedetti Michelangeli nel pianoforte.
Grandissimo Kleiber.
Check out him conducting Richard Strauss Der Rosenkavalier opening. Wow! His urging of the horn 'whoops' is amazing to watch. 📯📯📯📯
Grandísimo!!!!
i miss my beloved Brahms 3. with him, i am searching i found not ,it must be a bliss,-.i love him,he could be very angry with the orchestra but he was an very sensitive being .
He startet as correpetitor on Rhine Opera in Düsseldorf and there he also started directing. He directet very young anOthello in Düsseldorf with Hans Kaart as Othello. Unforgettable. Kaart died very young while a simple surgery on an ear. ❤
Mr. Kleiber totally feels this music. A joy to watch his "in the moment" involvement. The orchestra is absolutely fabulous. I would like to know what orchestra this was.
He was the greatest conductor of the 20th century！He was the best out of the best！
not even close to Celibidache's caliber! Celi...was not of this world, Kleber...too generic. too many "conductors" were , are....like kleiber. sorry man ...one day you'll realize no conductor was like Celi....EVER
celibidache was! another league! kleiber, karajan,Nernstein, Bohm and so forth....monor league...like in.baseball😂😂😂😂
The one person who would certainly agree with you is Celibidache himself.
read the bible bro
Strange comment
Ha abbattuto completamente la distanza che c'è tra l'autore e l'esecuzione. Un'intelligenza musicale di enorme grandezza, ancor prima che un direttore dalla tecnica insuperabile. Nulla è meccanico, tutto sembra nascere nel momento della direzione.
Un fuera de serie
Für wahr, ein Gott.
父親ゆずりのシュトラウス演奏。堂に入ったもので、ウィーン情緒も溢れて愉しい！長生きして欲しかった大指揮者の一人。
круто
My god too !
Il Dio dei direttori d'orchestra
you meant Celibidache , right?😂😂😂
Quello è Karajan
ESSE ERA DIFERENCIADO
Mine too!
Up in the conductor's room in Heaven, Lenny was heard, boldly declaring that
" God said I AM His favourite conductor!!"
Shortly after a quite grumble was heard from HvK ".... I did not."
But in my view, HvK has more than proved that he has presented the most imaginative and highly polished performances of great music in the history of our current civilization. So many great conductors. Only one can fit at the top and that's HvK.
And just so you know... BRRRRRRZZZ! There goes the buzzer, no further discussion will be admissible on this topic.
I have spoken.
Barney O'Hara
What a nonsense. Neither of them would have raised a question like that. They admired each other as their letters show. When the Berlin Philharmonic tried to play them against each other for the New Year's concert 1988, they failed. Kleiber wrote to Karajan: I have no ambition as a conductor. I prefer to listen to you ... I am one of those few people of really knowing what endless miracles of conducting you have achieved. I remain your unworthy pupil and if I may, your friend.
In their exchange they called each other Kapellmeister (bandleader) an ancient German title emphasising the craft and not the art.
Quanta accademia ! Troppa saccenteria...come si fa a stilare classifiche tanto banali ? Ogni grande direttore ha avuto pregi e limiti...nessuno fu ed è grande sempre e ovunque...Celibidache fu certo un grande : peraltro stimatissimo da ABMichelangeli e ciò basterebbe, ma tanti altri lo furono : Franco Ferrara e Bruno Walter per esempio....buona musica a tutti...
A great conductor, to be sure, and the discussion of where he "ranks" belittles that greatness. It must be said, though, that his greatness is revealed in a very small part of the repertory and that all of us are disappointed that for whatever reasons he was able to bring himself to conduct, say, only the 4th, 5th, 6th, and 7th symphonies of Beethoven and only the 2nd and 4th of Brahms and, say, only 5 or 6 operas. I doubt that had he come along earlier in the century, his career would have survived, so let's be grateful that he came when he did and gave us the enormous little he was able to. How this "ranks" vs Szell's or Abbado's omnicompetence and a great deal more in a much larger repertory is not for any of us to say as musicians are not thoroughbread horses and we are not handicappers. . 2:45
El conductor perfecto sería: el brazeo y agilidad de Kleiber junto a al tempi y espiritualidad de Chelidache.
celibidache E il padrino dei tutti diretori d'orchestra EVER
Which orchestra is this?
L 'Orchestra Filarmonica di Tokyo
Just don't try that with a regular provincial orchestra, it might not work, unless you have his charisma and his pedigree 😏
He was for shure not the best!
Mannerism.
you go wash your mouth.