The part that made me the most upset when BTU came out is the fact that we basically lost one of the most innovative versions of mc. Console brought so many amazing feature to the tables, some are still better than any other version like the custom superflat ui, the console minigames, the mash up pack releases even the end crystal cages in the dragon fight. So the fact that it got replaced with some weird ported over mobile game was really disappointing. Back then we were even promised things like mods that never came true. Like you said near the end, they should've told players long before they went full on with bedrock
Cross-play and simultaneous updates are such great features that I am extremely thankful for but man I could rant for hours and hours about how bad Bedrock Edition is...
I really wish they hadn't discontinued the console minigames. They had their own charm and polish to them, a great ost, and you didn't have to rely on certain servers because you could just queue up with anyone.
@@NaraSherko Bro just shut up. What are you even saying? Sure, it's called Minecraft but playing on my Switch with the crappy chunk loading, bugs from the Nether update still in the game, no 1.5 block tall crouching that's three years old, and obscene amounts of random bugs, it's just not fun. I have 600 hours on my Switch but it's just gotten worse over time. Here's a specific story. A week ago, I had stacks of coal ore blocks that I had gotten last time I played so I pillared up to fortune mine them. The first thirty blocks, I was taking nonstop damage when I placed a block. Absolutely nothing was hitting me. I got down to four hearts before I stopped placing blocks and healed up. I built the rest without any damage but as I started to mine it, I would randomly get teleported a block to the side and have to fly all the way up Landing on a single block. This kept happening so I wasted over 35 rockets just trying to mine some coal for like 15 minutes. It should've taken two. Just not fun
The thing about custom superflat on bedrock is that there is code for it. If you load up a custom superflat on console edition, and instantly port it to bedrock it will still generate past what loaded in on console, showing that bedrock has the capability to load superflat worlds
The fact that they just added 64 bit seeds in a random update with no precursor shows how much they're holding out. It would be SOOOOOO EASY for them to add good flat worlds and 1.5 block tall crouching but they just don't.
That’s because Bugrock devs are lazy overall they don’t even want to fix minor bugs not even mentioning world corruption and deletion like even Toycat has experienced
Out of all the differences between Bedrock and Java, I would love to see being able to hold anything in your off-hand in bedrock. It would make things so much better and make it feel a lot more similar.
It's really concerns about mobile gamers not being on the same competitive level as us. C'mon, when I was you g you had the console and controller for pretty colours on the TV, you don't need ten year olds to be competitive. It'd be better to hand off that responsibility to servers which might make minigames with mobile in mind. But not having the Java edition shortcuts is one of my biggest things against bedrock.
I feel parity in Mojang’s eyes is adding Java features to bedrock, which is good because the Java exclusives are far superior, but there are still some very good bedrock exclusives like vanilla armour stand arms and cauldrons and snow
hopefully some of the bedrock exclusive features like dyeing water, potions in cauldrons, making tipped arrows with cauldrons, armour stand options and placing blocks on air when bridging
to be honest, that problem with closing and reopening your world is so much worse for the nintendo switch... sometimes it won't even sign into my microsoft account and my skins won't load, my realms won't load, and the marketplace is broken. i've had to close and reopen the game like 3 times in a row before
Same man. My 2 year pocket edition survival world got corrupted and bugged out when I updated to 1.19 and I just have no motivation for survival anymore
That stinks! Start a new one. Make backups. I tried using Chunker to prune my world for 1.19, and EVERY attempt resulted in my world loading fine, everyone intact. Until I saved and quit… then it might have well been /kill @e. Every mob gone on reload. I am still playing on the original world, but the nearest new biome is 1000’s of blocks away. Make backups!
I would say it's overall better, but there is still way to many bugs, just from personal experience: End gates corrupted, endstone regenerating in the end, entities despawning, signs rollback to blank
As a PS4 player (now PS5) I disagree. I''ll watch the video to see toycats opinion, but in my opinion Playstation minecraft is almost unplayable in its current state (god of war has much much higher fps) , particularly on splitscreen.
@@tortoisewarrior4855 I've played it mainly on win10, I did try ps4 version a few years ago, which ended up crashing alot, sounds like it still isn't optimized well then
@@nakano8412 The PS4 edition was much better when it came to optimization (although it did have problems). On bedrock I'd you get between 30-40 FPS on PS4, while on splitcreen it would often freeze and and dip down to 10fps even after so many improvements. While on PS5 it has problems that aren't as bad it still lacks optimization, and still drops below 60 fps on singleplayer. Also they didn't even have realms for a year, it took them so long to add it.
@@nakano8412 none of the bedrock editions besides PE and maybe windows 10 is optimized. Its literally just an emulator with some bells and whistles that aren’t any good.
I personally think it was a good idea and a horrible idea... they could've added sooo much more to the legacy console edition that they just didn't add, like more mini games, they could've added servers, they could've expanded the world's further, they could've added cross play between android, ios, and pc, instead of all platforms, then they could've added cross play between xbox, switch, and playstation, that would've been super cool
What I don’t like, is that for us to get cross platform, more optimization and continuos updates, they sacrificed what console edition previously had, like host privileges, amplified, instant pop up and better understandable menus, world and biome sizes, and of course, THE MINIGAMES
Small correction, but C# is very dissimilar to C++. They only share a similar name because Microsoft thought it'd make it more popular. C# has a garbage collector to automatically manage memory, whereas C++ requires manual memory management. C# compiles to bytecode where it is then interpreted on user's computers, whereas C++ compiles directly into machine code. C# is also object-oriented, whereas C++ supports a variety of paradigms (with object-oriented being only one of many options). C# is actually much more similar to Java, another garbage collected, bytecode compiled and object-oriented language. As such C++ has far better performance compared to C#, at the cost of being more challenging to write code in.
-Dual Wielding -Hardcore -Superflat and more world options -Ability to build on Nether roof -Banners on shields -Sweeping Edge -Banner markers on maps These are some of the most wanted features for Minecraft Bedrock that I and probably other many millions of people have been waiting for for many many years and are still waiting to this day. I love to see parity don't get me wrong but I feel like Mojang should prioritize parity features which people actually really want and/or have been craving for for years on end. Instead it feels like they're completely ignoring all of these features so they can do more work on the Marketplace. I mean Dual Wielding I can understand even though they already fixed the touch screen problem by updating the controls and adding more buttons but I'll still give them a pass here. Features like Hardcore tho? How is something so simple not in the game yet? Superflat and more world options? They just updated the UI and moved things around so why couldn't they also just add more options on the way? Why is it so hard for them to give us the ability to build on the Nether roof like on Java? I don't know. Banners on Shields and banner markers on maps? These feel like easy features to add. Why do we not have them yet? Have I even mentioned RTX? Lol. That was a complete mess but people still crave and want RTX for current gen consoles AT LEAST to this day. Why do we not have RTX on Xbox Series X and PS5 yet? Why was it even announced and hyped up if it wasn't possible? No idea. We don't even have updated versions of the game for Xbox Series X and PS5. What's up with that? Why aren't they focusing on that? Every other game has a next/current gen version so why doesn't Minecraft? Because better optimization for the newer consoles would be too much to ask for I guess
I couldve sworn i saw a bedrock developer show a sneak peek of banners on shields back in like 2020 in an image. But then they didnt ever bring it up again since
i remember being so miffed about world options when i went to bedrock. i still am. i would say that i think bedrock is still a better future than remaining on specific versions. i wouldnt even be able to play with any of my friends without bedrock! i also feel that not allowing custom worlds and skins on console is kind of missing the point of WHY we would want them. i dont want to play as a random generic hero character, i want to play as this specific character that would be not legally allowed on the marketplace. i dont want to always play on another top notch survival spawn, i just want to play on a world my friend shared! or a test world! it would be cool if we could have these systems, and whilst i dont hate the marketplace, i feel it could be reworked.
Honestly I think the custom stuff has more to do with Sony and I guess to an extent Nintendo, years before mods were a thing on consoles, when fallout 4 came out it promised custom mods from the community in consoles (something never seen before) into the game (which honestly was one of the features I actually got the game) but the feature was delayed many times until finally Bethesda came out saying that mods weren't coming for PS4 and only Xbox. And if I remember correctly the reason why there wouldn't be mods on PS4 was because Sony feared it would be a way to make the console less secure and risk user's security. So I think the same is happening again with Minecraft where you can actually get mods on the Xbox version (in a very weird way but you can) and it's basically impossible on the PS4 and Switch. (Unless you play on a server).
The fact that code for custom superflat *EXISTED IN BEDROCK* and it used to work (with external apps, yea it generated new chunks with the custom modifiers like java) and they hadn't implemented it until 1.18 where they deleted it! and it was a legacy feature on consoles. Screw Mojang and Microsoft
14:16 Toycat - "Saying that you will do something and then not doing something because you only said you'd do it before you realized you would lose money, that is not a good tactic in my opinion." Mojang - "Saying that we will do something is not a commitment..."
9:16 Console Edition has big salmon too. It is so sad, that Xbox One Edition and Nintendo Switch Edition were excluded from the aquatic update. 1:51 Console Edition was written in C#, what? Do you have a source? According to the minecraft wiki it was written in C++ just like bedrock. Console Edition is certanly still better than bedrock because it has a lot of nice features, that bedrock is still missing: 1. Furnace minecarts 2. The luck effect (with potions, splash potions, lingering potions and tipped arrows), 3. The shrub. 4. The tutorial world 5. Minigames 6. In game tips and descriptions for blocks and items 7. Smaller biomes 8. More common structures 9. Blazes dropping 0-2 Glowstone dust when killed by a player (drop rate is unaffected by the looting enchantment) 10. Nether warts generating outside of fortresses 11. Wither skeletons rarely spawning outside of fortresses 12. The ability to pause the game 13. Minecarts being twice as fast 14. Better looking 3d chest icon when the game is saving instead of a weird 2d icon 15. The crafting recipe for enchanted golden apples 16. Dog plays after cat in the music disc 17. Controller hints work better, the generally mostly only show up, when the action is possible unlike on bedrock, the hints are smaller and at the bottom left but still readable, which is better and the buttons for the controller hints look pressed if you press them in a menu. 18. You can scroll in the end text 19. Sneaking while gliding with an elytra and not holding an item in the mainhand makes your right arm face forward 20. Camera tilting when turning while gliding with an elytra (can be disabled in the setttings if you don’t like it) 21. The emerald above villagers and wandering traders when trading with them (for some reason this nice feature was removed from bedrock for parity even though it was really useful) 22. Better furnace (smoker and blast furnace too) GUIs (it shows the name of the ingredient and fuel slot) 23. You can hold down the attack key to continiously attack 24. Better held item tooltips, while bedrock only shows the name, the enchantments and potions effects of the item, Console Edition can show all information below the name when switching hotbar slots. You can see things like the flight duration for fireworks, attributes of the item etc. (Unlike bedrock, Console Edition also has a limit, where it only shows up to 3 rows below the name) 25. You can see the amount of armor points that an armor piece gives you when hovering over it and this can of course also be seen when switching the hotbar slow 26. The old longer XP level up sound (sounds better than the new one imo) 27. You can exit worlds without saving 28. The skin menu is better because the players in the menu wobble with their arms and legs, you have an option to add skins to your list of favourite skins and you can use the stick to turn (RS on Xbox) to rotate the player or make it sneak or move the arm 29. The player turns with the minecart when it goes around a corner 30. Sprinting is not cancelled when walking against a block 31. Phantoms have less health (10 instead of 20) 32. Vindicators deal less damage (6 on easy, 10 on normal and 15 on hard instead of 7 on easy, 13 on normal and 19 on hard) 33. On PS4 Edition, which has the village and pillage update you can see the item tooltip of items in villager trades, that you do not have unlocked yet, allowing you to see things like the enchantments before unlocking the trade. On bedrock you can only see the item but hovering over it doesn’t show the item tooltip. 34. Arrows get stuck inside the player 35. You can see the offhand slot on the left next to the hotbar to see the item! On bedrock it is so frustrating that I do not see it because it means I cannot see the amount, how often I have the item, the durability of the shield and the cooldown of the shield if it is disabled by an axe! 36. Spiders can spawn with an effect on hard difficulty 37. Creepers with an effect spawn an area effect cloud of their effects when exploding 38. Hearts moving in the correct direction (up) and not the wrong direction (down) when having the regeneration effect 39. You can right click mobs with its spawn egg to spawn the baby variant 40. Item frames are entities instead of blocks, making more decorations possible. All of these decorations break if you convert your world from Console Edition to bedrock. 41. More popular redstone mechanics, such as quasi-connectivity and sticky pistons not retracting the block, they pushed, when given a 1 tick pulse. This also means that a lot of your redstone contraptions from Console Edition stop working if you convert your world to bedrock. 42. Faster regeneration if you have saturation points (notable you regenerate a lot of hearts quickly if you eat items with high saturation like golden carrots or steaks) 43. Newer AI for skeletons and strays, where the move while drawing their bow 44. Heart particles when attacking an entity to show how much damage you dealt 45. Particles for the sharpness, smite and bane of athropods enchantment 46. Halloween easter eggs such as undead mobs spawning with pumpkins and jack o'lanterns and a special splash text for halloween and bats spawning at higher light levels (up to 6 instead of 3) from 20th October to 3rd November 47. Better blinking for effect icons on the HUD, they blink more and more the lower the duration is, while on bedrock they blink always the same during the last 10 seconds 48. Effect icons having two rows (top for positive effects and bottom for negative effects) as opposed to being on top of each other on bedrock 49. Smooth animation when mounting an entity, where the entity moves to it (can also be seen in multiple console edition update trailers) 50. Ability to enchant every item with every enchantment using an anvil in creative mode 51. Changes made to redstone dust hitboxes from Java Edition 1.9 (on bedrock it is still always a full block square hitbox) 52. Higher resolution for explosion particles 53. Max entity cramming, which deals 3 HP of damage every half second (on java edition there is also a gamerule to change the maximum amount, which is 24 by default added in java edition 1.11 and console edition TU54) 54. Updated durability bar, which is easier to see especially if the durability is low 55. Zombie sieges 56. Left handed mobs 57. Ability to see the amount of items and durability in the hotbar in creative mode without opening the inventory 58. Better void, meaning you take damage and die from it in creative mode, there is no barrier 40 blocks below the build limit and you take damage after being at least 64 blocks below the build limit instead of immediately when being outside of it. 59. Strongholds generating with iron doors 60. Not outdated boat physics (on bedrock boats still always swim up in water even when underwater just like the old boats did on Java before 1.9) It also has a lot of sounds, that bedrock hasn’t: 61. Newer sounds for using a fishing rod (both casting and reeling in), bedrock still uses the normal throwing sounds (Added in Console TU53 and Java 1.12) 62. The sound for a channeling trident spawning a lightning bolt (bedrock has the sound but it is unused) (Added in Console TU69 and Java 1.13) 63. Sound for placing lily pads (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9) 64. Sound for going with the eye level of the player underwater and out of the water (Added in Console TU69 and Java 1.13) 65. Shulkers using a different hurt sound, when closed (bedrock has the sound but it is unused) (Added in Console TU46 and Java 1.9) 66. Newer splashing sound for landing inside water 67. Unique sound for throwing eye of ender (bedrock uses the normal throw sound) 68. Sound for filling a glass bottle with water (bedrock only has the sound for filling it with dragon’s breath) (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9) 69. Newer sound for tilling farmland with a hoe and making grass path (dirt path in the newest version on java). On bedrock making dirt path just plays the sound for walking on grass, which makes no sense. (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9) 70. Newer sounds for activating wooden and weighted pressure plates (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9) 71. Sound for the thorns enchantment attacking the enemy back (on java edition it only plays for the player attacked by the enchantment while on console it plays for all players) (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9) 72. Sounds for paddling/rowing in boats (there are different sounds for rowing on land and rowing in water) (Added in Console TU54 and Java 1.12) 73. Sound for throwng eyes of ender breaking (Added in Java Edition 1.12 and Console Edition probably TU53) 74. Sound for making a critical hit (Added in Console TU46 and Java 1.9) 75. Newer door sounds, iron door sounds, trapdoor sounds, iron trapdoor sounds, fence gate sounds (Added in Console TU46 and Java 1.9) The actual list is way longer. I didn’t mention all of them. The list I posted in this comment is very incomplete. It is nice that the sound for enchanting an item in an enchanting table was added to bedrock in 1.19.30 though. This feature has existed on Console Edition for more than 5 years. Of course that’s not enough because all of the other missing sounds still need to be added.
Also we can’t forget that the “Worse Together” was just a downgrade to Minecraft they discontinued Minecraft Legacy Console Edition in favour of this bad version 😥 And we are still missing these LCE features and the ones that IBXToycat pointed out have still not been fixed on Bugrock on consoles. Also LCE got 1.12 earlier then by like half a month Java edition and Bugrock got it like a year later then java I think that LCE should have been updated and Bugrock discontinued even on mobile devices and replaced with a new better version.
@@Steve_Poland "Better version" Coding a completely new engine for the game exclusively for mobile to appease some complainers from the future sure sounds reasonable!
@@dumigamez397 Why would you like to have another mobile Minecraft version if we want one as the Minecraft community we should play LCE and Java and see how great those game are!
The way I play the game would never change after that update, yes I did make new friends but I didn't have the ones I used to. The only thing I really do like is that the device I went on there originally didn't get updated to bedrock
When i updated my ps4 creative world to bedrock my builds at the old border of the world got skewed downwards towards where the border used to be and all the blocks looked like they decided to become sand since roofs and platforms collapsed, I've never heard of this happening to other people though
did you wait until 1.18 to port the world? That’s mojang’s new chunk blending system in action. It’s supposed to make the transition between old chunks and new ones smoother but often ends up messing up builds like yours
They 100% should have refined Bedrock prior to going gungho and releasing it on the entire world. Minecraft on Switch is still the worst version to play on because of who knows why, corporate decisions or just the developers ignoring it. Other bugs have just been waved away on the Bug Tracker as "Will not fix" because why? There are some pretty serious issues and Bedrock's nickname being Bugrock isn't just a funny meme because it's moderately buggy. No you can basically just be playing casually and run into Bug after Bug constantly. I get that Bedrock's crossplay is great, but they just went through it too fast. Instead of optimizing it for everyone, mobile, consoles, and PC, they ended up just making a mess of a game that doesn't communicate with each other, and just ended up splitting the community into factions of Legacy Console, Bedrock, Java. Now no one is happy, and you have everything being a warzone and Mojang haven't really been helping the issue with ignoring certain issues being brought up.
I’ll say this again! To the people who say we should give Mojang a break! They’ve put themselves in this mess and they have to fix it themselves. They make enough money as is, so they shouldn’t have so many problems with efficiency and optimizing things for the people (if that’s bad it’s because of the dumb management.) Why shouldn’t they? Because they have money and I have data to back this up. Marketplace collabs are some of the proof of this, if those didn’t make money they wouldn’t license so many big mainstream things let alone build them. If they didn’t then they’d have more money from the marketplace and not worry about if things sold well or not. Not to mention taking ~30% of everything sold would fatten anyones pockets with the things being sold from .99 to ~15.99. When people say “be grateful the game is over 10 years old” I literally can’t believe it. Times have changed, getting updates for games are essential to keep a player base, whether it’s bugs or DLC; you’ll eventually have a need for more content for more buyers. That being said, saying the people shouldn’t expect to have amazing frequent updates when all they’ve done for the past 12 years is push out a banger one after another is BS. Notch, Jeb, Dinnerbone, all of the older team, effectively impacted the game more then a billion dollar company. They built the game so the company can use it and make it amazing, which granted, they’ve done wonders with a lot of updates however the max time they’ve taken for each one is at most, 7-8 months with the least being a month. We got 3 parts to the pillagers in under a 2/3 of year, two parts of Aquatic and that took less then 6 months. I don’t mind small updates, however they set our expectations way too high and never disappointed. They did this to themselves and not to mention if it’s money that’s the problem, then it’s Microsoft that’s at fault. Why? Because they’ve made 3.132e9 dollars or simply put 3123900000 dollars off of Minecraft in the past 10 years. With ~537 million being left out due to it being owned by Notch and not Microsoft. This means, they shouldn’t have problems like they have with staff. It’s poor management or spending or whatever, whatever it might be, it shouldn’t be happening. Frankly we shouldn’t have to be so loud about changes or horrible bugs. They should already know what is okay and not okay to add, we don’t have to hold their hand with ideas and additions with community votes or bad coding due to the piss take that is Bedrock. Ofc I’m not saying get rid of it, the communication is great but too much can be bad. We love bug reports but they have a weird system in place, don’t communicate what bugs they’re working on, nor keep “bugs” that literally are wonderful ideas and add so much to playing the game YOU want. This entire thing is absolutely unfair to both parties and it’s just tiring. All it takes is some optimization for bedrock and the freedom for the players to have most things at their disposal. Issues like PS or Switch not having custom skins, the power to enable beta (now preview, without realms or a second game bought on laptop or PE) shouldn’t be happening. They shouldn’t be gatekeeping so much from players, they shouldn’t have so many problems with the marketplace like Copyright or cheap cookie cutter “mods”. It should be noticed and taken care of within a reasonable amount of time, not within the next years when they run out of ideas, now, when they have the power and feedback from users. They’ve programmed lots into both versions and both should be accessible in a similar way. Education edition also has so many amazing features yet they don’t put them in the base game, it’s baffling, just so hard and annoying to understand or reason with. Everyone is at fault, but mostly Microsoft and Mojang are to blame for the bad rules and limitations set by newer and older devs.
Honestly I think that Mojang is like this because of Microsoft and well Mojang currently being the developers of Minecraft. You have a nearly limitless budget and you don't have any reason to actually do something about the game because it's making money and even if it doesn't there's Microsoft who's willing to tank everything.
Facts, whole year has been one big self imposed mess and has definitely done great damage to themselves and our trust. I point to the glow squid, a hypnosis mob (rewatch the trailer, 3 times hypnosis was used, and if that wasn't a part of it then they shouldn't have teased it) that got a lazy as heck treatment that cannot be defended by a single dev as being of higher quality then an amateur modder. The very use can be replaced by glow stone dust and an ink sac.... boom I just made your high quality mob redundant. Whatever 1.20 is, we know now not to be excited till it's on our plates. 1.19 was literally like ordering a steak and getting a slice of rotten flesh with a sprinkle of suspicious stew as a seasoning sauce. Bleh..
I'll admit that I'm still really salty over the better together update, especially considering all of the features that Microsoft has yet to implement into bedrock.
I wish they would have made legacy cross-play and I wish they could make it compatible with java servers, added all the Java features, and kept updating it leaving bedrock as a mobile and windows only game.
1:48 C++ and C# are two very different languages. Very easy to not understand that though if you've never programmed in them before. C++ is built off of C and has support for object oriented programming (And a few other things). Meanwhile, C# is more similar to Java in terms of how code is structured. Both are Object Oriented languages, but the way code is structured is VERY different. tldr, They may both have C in the name, but that does not mean they're similar.
I think you pretty much described why I never switched to bedrock! I still played the legacy version of Minecraft Xbox one edition! It has features that bedrock will never have, and I still play it too thiiss daayy!
Its hard to believe that bedrock players have still not recieved amplified worlds and custom super flats (which have existed in java since 2014 and legacy console since 2016)
Imagine how awesome it'd have been if Mojang let 4J make the console editions all cross platform and up to date with java instead of what we have now 4J's minecraft was so good I could see it being cross platform with Java edition itself
Better Together is a bad "update." From a Switch User's point of view, there are way too many bugs, I keep having to reapply the classic texture pack and the "Servers" are a downgrade of Minigames. Because of this, I treat bedrock as a disappointment with the best thing coming out of it being the 3DS port. The New Nintendo 3DS Edition of Minecraft is better then the Switch Bedrock.
Legacy Edition looks better, feels better, runs better, has very good gui, has superflat, has amplified, has tutorial worlds, has minigames❤️ and no major bugs to name a few things
Imagine a timeline where Bedrock Edition never existed and we still had 4J working on Legacy Console. I'd give up every atom of my being in this reality to be warped to that one.
The changelog at 2:35 made me go WHAAATTT so many times as an xbox 360 enjoyer first for years until i bought Java. These things were almost always on console, im surprised PC didnt have them. At least in some capacity Also: custom skins: I found out something stupid. If you have java and a pc, you can make a custom skin and upload it to your character in java, then port it through the launcher to bedrock, then you can use it on console. But if you dont have a PC, you're SoL. Its the dumbest thing ever. And what makes it better I found out microsoft notified me my user experience was beingntracked for something. I shrugged it off like yeah whatever, and two days later you could buy my skin's head. I trawled the internet for a skin even remotely like the one i wanted on both the store and Java's third party files before finally settling down and working on mine, and yet they got a head exactly like mine to the pixel on the store for $1.29, right after they checked my account out. Idk about y'all but that sussed me out and was the final straw for me and bedrock's store. It may have been coincidence but i highly doubt it.
16:02 COULD be the same? I think that they would end up being released at the same time with no gap. PS4 got the village and Pillage only like 5 months after java and it had most of the features. I think that by the next major update the console editions would be fully caught up.
the only thing java needs is: the handsway animation from 🛏️ 🪨, its just make sense for the hand to sway in 1st person, leaves turning white when it snows, dyed water mid air faster bridge building without crouching and looking at the block
I will add something to the video, on Nintendo switch (I only play on Nintendo switch do I don't know if it on the rest of bedrock or not) if you use the down arrow on the d-pad, it instantly types your last chat message sent, and if you press it again, it instantly types the message before your last one that you sent, And it cycles until you reach the message you sent 20 messages ago. It is a good feature.
Hey I think an interesting idea for a video topic would be every blocks different colors and how many colors a blocks uses ranked from least to most? Intriguing question?
My problem is that it has taken away the individual attention given to each console and platform. Loading times can be up to 10 minutes long on Switch and they have done nothing about it. There is no per console optimization and thus doesn't take advantage of the Xbox Series and PS5 let alone the Xbox One X and PS4 Pro. They need to optimize their game.
Yes, we get to play with my friends on other consoles! Now I get to play with friends on my switch on someone’s pc or Xbox or PlayStation or someone’s phones or tablet!
It was worth it in the long run, but it could have gone better if they waited until like 2019 or 2020 to release the cross play update. Bedrock was so ridiculously buggy for console versions at launch and also didnt include ps4 or switch versions
All bedrock really has going for it over 4J Minecraft is infinite worlds and cross play. Mobile holds back bedrock edition on other devices so much and that’s only the start of the problems with bedrock
Personaly, I still find that the Legacy Console Editions are the best versions of Minecraft. Regardless of the disadvantages. In 2020, I started playing Bedrock Edition (got mad at the game every time I played it), in 2021, I moved to Java Edition (I no longer get mad at the game every time I play it), and I still play the PS3 Edition (legacy console edition) from time to time. I've played Pocket Edition, Nintendo Switch Edition and 3DS Edition, and have found that I liked the Legacy Console Editions better. Sorry for the paragragh...
One thing I had trouble transitioning from Legacy/Bedrock to Java was Ability to have Creative Flight in Survival (Bedrock had the MayFly from Education) And don't get me started on Redstone issues and the Give and Fill commands
Better together had actually made it significantly harder for me to play minecraft. There was so much lag that i could walk around and everything would get unloaded except for chests, spawners, etc so i basically had a vanilla xray glitch that occured when loading a chunk or when autosaving, which is almost always when playing in short sessions. I havent ever been easily able to host a game without buying a realm. 5 years later and i still cant host games. For the first 4 years it was almost always crashing and giving weird errors that deleted either all entities or only certain ones such as minecarts. I couldnt go in the nether without at least my minecarts getting deleted. I lost all of my farm animals, a half stack of iron from making minecarts, an armor stand with enchanted leather armor and an enchanted netherite sword, and a chunk even got reverted to a previous state somehow. My world is only 147mb and theres almost no entities. I shouldnt be having any of these problems and it shouldnt have taken mojang 4 years to even think about starting to fix them
I feel there is one flaw and that’s on consoles it usualy requires a subscription to either Xbox live gold or play station plus I could be wrong and this may have changed but its what I remember
I remember one time I spent awhile figuring out Geyser and Floodgate to put on my Java server so my friends on xbox can join the server and then it was super disappointing when I realized that there wasn't a join server button on bedrock for xbox but there is one for bedrock on PC.
Speaking as someone who has been programming for 35 years... The only relationship between C++ and C# is.. the name. In truth C# is closer to Java than it is to C++. Microsoft picked the name for marketing reasons, but the actual language has little to do with C or C++ beyond the vaguest of cosmetic similarities.
I really dislike how bedrock had a lot of stuff perfectly fine and identical to java (shadows, view bobbing, hand position, particles and block breaking... I can go on and on), but then messed it all up slowly. Remember when players moved smoothly at 60fps? When the menus were far more responsive and didnt lag? When the lighting was 100% identical to java? It sucks.
I still have never been able to get cross play to work and it seriously disappoints me. I have Minecraft on Switch, PS4, and Windows 10 and have tried to get them all to play together in every possible combination of the three and it has never been successful.
on the PS4 it actually was just an update that added the new version and a menu button to go back to the old one, there aren't 2 separate games. as for if it's worth it... idk. There's some huge improvements (command blocks, structure blocks, experimental features meaning more common updates, cross-play, infinite worlds, in game chat), but there's also some big downgrades (no custom superflat or amplified worlds, no world size select, a bunch of false promises about things they'd add, and some QOL downgrades, no furnace minecarts, no tutorial worlds or free DLC trials, no mini-games mode, bedrock redstone) there's also things that still really need changing on console (add a proper way to transfer worlds between platforms that doesn't rely on realms, add a way to download behaviour packs on console as currently you can't even do that from the marketplace since they don't sell behaviour packs that aren't connected to a world, and let console players connect to any server, not just the few "official" ones). It seems like the things that were big improvements with bedrock were things they weren't planning on doing on legacy console anyway, but it would have been nice to see the game as it is in 1.19 but on legacy console, it would have been fun making a deep dark superflat world, but mojang can't be bothered to just add it despite the fact they definitly could if they wanted to. It's the best selling game of all time, there's no way they wouldn't be able to add a feature that was added in TU25 on legacy console in 5 years. Switching over to bedrock was probably for the best and had to happen eventually, but they really didn't put enough effort into making sure that went well and felt like there weren't any major downsides.
@@cement_eater Dual-booting is really not a solution. You had to stop everything you're doing and reboot you're pc and when you're done with that reboot again
For me there's only 4 reasons Bedrock is good. 1. It's still updated. 2. Infinite Worlds. 3. Simultaneous Updates. 4. Crossplay. I'd much rather live in a world where all 3 Console Veraions were Crossplay using Console Edition. By now the Xbox Series, and PS5 could have Infinite Worlds(using the Console Edition), while the Switch might be limited to only playing on the Large Template from Console Edition(so Switch could play with Xbox, and/or PlayStation players if they are on those templates). In this world I guess Xbox One, and PS4 would also potentially be able to play with the others on the Large Template. A lot of my issues with Bedrock would probably be fixed if there was a next gen version of Minecraft, but that won't happen in order to not leave Xbox One, PS4, Switch, and Mobile behind.
I only play Minecraft Java now. I used to play pocket edition 5 years ago because i didnt have a PC that time, and I enjoyed it, the only problem was when I went into multiplayer like skywars and bedwars etc. i would get absolutely destroyed by the people playing on Windows 10 and controllers. It was absolutely impossible to counter because pc gaming is so dynamic. I bought a wireless controller of my own, a very good controller however minecraft didnt quite support it well. Finally I had to quit the game I loved so much because whenever i went into multiplayer the win10 sweats would call me a noob when I was playing on a touchscreen. When I did get a PC 2 years ago I downloaded bedrock again and went in and absolutely destroyed those same guys with barely any practice at all, and then quit Bedrock for once and for all after getting revenge, because I realised now I will be unfair for other touchscreen players playing mcpe because they cant afford a PC yet.
The fact that mojang called minecrafts "better together update" an update even though it was intire new version of the game should have been an indication that minecraft bedrock would turn into absolute dumpster fire of a game 🙄 What makes it worse is that developing bedrock edition was an absolute waste of time, they already had legacy console edition which was fully updated all the way to 1.13 yet they decided to scrap all of it and remake THE INTIRE GAME and miss several features in the process
I only got into minecraft playing on my phone, because my 8 year old got into it a few months ago on the ps4 so now I watch stuff so I can try to teach him new things and play together on wifi
I only have the console edition of Bedrock on Xbox. I've never bought a map on the market place and don't plan too in the foreseeable future. I use an app on the Xbox that lets me copy a world into Minecraft game folder. This is how I play multiple custom maps, especially Skyblock and Flatworlds. I still crave we get the custom flatworld options on console someday soon!
I lost a world I was SUPER proud of about a year after Bedrock’s launch. I have not been able to play Minecraft since. I just don’t have any motivation to
true 100% agree, and the only real way to make custom superflat worlds is to start a new world and then not accept multiplayer safety agreement, then open the world and edit the FlatWorldLayers json ""{ "biome_id": 9, "encoding_version": 4, "block_layers": [ { "block_name": "minecraft:black_concrete", "count": 64 }, { "block_name": "minecraft:air", "count": 0 }, { "block_name": "minecraft:air", "count": 0 } ] }""
Maybe to a certain level, but they forced us into a buggy unpolished version built for phones rammed by microtransactions, and took away legacy console edition versions slowly one by one
I think my main gripe with Bedrock edition is that it feels so unresponsive compared to the legacy console editions & Java. It felt optimized and the inventory management & crafting were superior imo. If Bedrock played like legacy console editions in it feels, I probably would've switched to Bedrock for my vanilla experience.
Honestly they should have kept the pocket edition a seperate version. If you really want to play with your pc friends, they could have made some sort of compatibility version exclusively for realms and servers.
I just hate that a game owned by Microsoft runs so poorly on their own console. Sometimes I just wanna play Minecraft, but I can't even go to the Nether in multiplayer because it lags so much that I can't eat food, or enemies just won't take damage sometimes.
Actually, you can access the keyboard with one of the d-pad arrows. At least, you can on Playstation. I didn't know for a long time, even though it says so every time you make a new world.
It just feels like bedrock devs don't really care about the users. I'm not talking about the marketplace or things out of their control, but we've had so many bugs that seem easy to fix and have lasted since the beginning of Bedrock edition. We've gotten to a point where bugs are more and worse like not being able to move to the right on mobile devices on 1.19.0 to the infamous pink glitch that was caused by renderdragon. All because they wanted to market the rtx which most of us will never use and the performance is worst than ever, and it brought so many bugs for no reason. That's the reason a lot of us changed to Java, but not everyone has that luxury
i dont have that luxury to go to java but also dont have the burden as said about bugrock, i encounter one reoccuring but harmless and uncommon bug but thats about it, had a pretty normal experience on bugrock despite its reputation, and its not all gloom and doom, as there is glimmers of hope as the devs dont entirely ignore these bugs, they often release bug fix and bug patch more than java, and even the infamous pink glitch from the render dragon, was fixed in a beta, though they took it back due to some other bug, not trying to defend bugrock and all, just saying it could be better, im an update behind to not experience the render dragon problem too
The update was terrible and ruined Minecraft for console gamers. We were forced onto this new version of the game which was literally a mobile port to console. To this day they still haven’t reached parity with console edition as they are still missing minigames, improved ui, console controls (not clunky mobile controls), exiting without saving, custom flat worlds, even some skin packs are still missing. They didn’t even try and if you experienced how incredibly smooth and well put together the console edition is then you don’t know what we lost. This is the reason I stopped playing Minecraft and I’m sure many others did the same. On top of that there were so many broken promises such as custom skins which never happened. I still consider bedrock to be inferior to console and would rather live in a reality where console edition continues to be updated.
I suppose this update was huge for bedrock. Extremely useful for multiplayer. And the fact that this was released during the dark era of minecraft attracted more player to play bedrock more than java. Maybe in the past, this wasn't so optimized, but now, they're slowly getting better.
think that minecraft shouldve had 3 versions Java for PC Bedrock for Consoles (n maybe pc) Pocket for Mobile This would allow many different teams work on their own schemes, optimizing for their platforms
Besides missing the console edition , sometimes I miss the old pocket edition as well 😕 I do agree that it was a good choice for the future of the game itself though , and I have faith in Mojang that eventually Bedrock will become a more stable and worthwhile version of the game . Even if that does take another 5-10 years
I only really hate it because it was the start of the shutdown of Xbox one edition, I absolutely hate this new version, I wish I can go back to the original mc xbox one edition.
There should be bedrock, java, and mobile. If mobile got separated, bedrock and java could even possibly merge. Touch controls parity causes a bunch of issues and is why the bundle doesnt truly exist anymore
What's funny is that Mojang one day decided that mobile (pocket edition) was so good that they decided to make it it's own grand version as Java's contender, aka Bedrock. Funny how the internal files in all Bedrock versions are basically still named "minecraftpe", where pe stands for pocket edition
while i can not speak about console minecraft that was shortly before started playing or watching the cat man but rarely find myself playing big salmon ver anymore due to bad post render dragon performance (dx12), bugs that have yet to be fixed some game breaking, lack of other game modes/worlds, and some poor gameplay design choices such as strongholds with no end frame wasnt till my 3rd bedrock world that i found working stronghold might have found one on 2nd world but one day it was just gone
Just because you can put Minecraft onto every device, doesn't mean that you should. Elytra's for example, are completely redundant on the Switch version due to slooooow updating of chunks in the world while flying.
I REALLY didn't like Bedrock coming to consoles and I still don't. This update changed everything, and it removed all the cool UI, multiplayer modes, 3rd party maps and skins, and the performance got worse. I miss the tutorial worlds. :(
The part that made me the most upset when BTU came out is the fact that we basically lost one of the most innovative versions of mc. Console brought so many amazing feature to the tables, some are still better than any other version like the custom superflat ui, the console minigames, the mash up pack releases even the end crystal cages in the dragon fight. So the fact that it got replaced with some weird ported over mobile game was really disappointing. Back then we were even promised things like mods that never came true. Like you said near the end, they should've told players long before they went full on with bedrock
Dude, minecraft is Minecraft
No matter which version, what device, Minecraft is Minecraft
And why get a console when you can play on anything
Like smartwatch
You should just play Roblox 😒
Cross-play and simultaneous updates are such great features that I am extremely thankful for but man I could rant for hours and hours about how bad Bedrock Edition is...
Yo first
What are you doing here I found this in 6 seconds
It's not bad, it's just optimised as well a at it could be
True
Bruh
I really wish they hadn't discontinued the console minigames. They had their own charm and polish to them, a great ost, and you didn't have to rely on certain servers because you could just queue up with anyone.
The console mini-games were the best. Just isn't the same with servers.
and the connection is still better today than bedrock’s servers lol
I wish legacy console edition was still available, it was so well optimized and it played fantastically, also the minigames like glide were really fun
Minecraft is minecraft
@@NaraSherko I firmly disagree, legacy was way better for consoles than Bedrock is
@@upstreamruben8011 No no no
@@NaraSherko Bro just shut up. What are you even saying? Sure, it's called Minecraft but playing on my Switch with the crappy chunk loading, bugs from the Nether update still in the game, no 1.5 block tall crouching that's three years old, and obscene amounts of random bugs, it's just not fun. I have 600 hours on my Switch but it's just gotten worse over time. Here's a specific story. A week ago, I had stacks of coal ore blocks that I had gotten last time I played so I pillared up to fortune mine them. The first thirty blocks, I was taking nonstop damage when I placed a block. Absolutely nothing was hitting me. I got down to four hearts before I stopped placing blocks and healed up. I built the rest without any damage but as I started to mine it, I would randomly get teleported a block to the side and have to fly all the way up Landing on a single block. This kept happening so I wasted over 35 rockets just trying to mine some coal for like 15 minutes. It should've taken two. Just not fun
@@narnianninja4964 Play any device you want
The thing about custom superflat on bedrock is that there is code for it. If you load up a custom superflat on console edition, and instantly port it to bedrock it will still generate past what loaded in on console, showing that bedrock has the capability to load superflat worlds
The fact that they just added 64 bit seeds in a random update with no precursor shows how much they're holding out. It would be SOOOOOO EASY for them to add good flat worlds and 1.5 block tall crouching but they just don't.
That’s because Bugrock devs are lazy overall they don’t even want to fix minor bugs not even mentioning world corruption and deletion like even Toycat has experienced
Out of all the differences between Bedrock and Java, I would love to see being able to hold anything in your off-hand in bedrock. It would make things so much better and make it feel a lot more similar.
It's really concerns about mobile gamers not being on the same competitive level as us.
C'mon, when I was you g you had the console and controller for pretty colours on the TV, you don't need ten year olds to be competitive. It'd be better to hand off that responsibility to servers which might make minigames with mobile in mind.
But not having the Java edition shortcuts is one of my biggest things against bedrock.
I miss the tutorial worlds. Someone should take it upon them selves to release a tutorial world on the market place every major update.
4J actually has released marketplace maps, so it bothers me that they haven’t re-released all their old ones there
I feel parity in Mojang’s eyes is adding Java features to bedrock, which is good because the Java exclusives are far superior, but there are still some very good bedrock exclusives like vanilla armour stand arms and cauldrons and snow
hopefully some of the bedrock exclusive features like dyeing water, potions in cauldrons, making tipped arrows with cauldrons, armour stand options and placing blocks on air when bridging
Yes though i would be excited for shields with banners
I'm still waiting to get bedrock bridging on java. Like why not, it's so handy!
And being able to swap between your chestplate and elytra without entering the inventory
I want the revamped wither fight on java edition and easier block placing too, that would be very sweet
to be honest, that problem with closing and reopening your world is so much worse for the nintendo switch... sometimes it won't even sign into my microsoft account and my skins won't load, my realms won't load, and the marketplace is broken. i've had to close and reopen the game like 3 times in a row before
I've lost my will to continue playing Bedrock ever since an update despawned all of my mobs
Same man. My 2 year pocket edition survival world got corrupted and bugged out when I updated to 1.19 and I just have no motivation for survival anymore
Relatable
happened to me worse still playing mcpe
Damn that must sting, setting up a lot of the mobs is a pain.
That stinks! Start a new one. Make backups.
I tried using Chunker to prune my world for 1.19, and EVERY attempt resulted in my world loading fine, everyone intact. Until I saved and quit… then it might have well been /kill @e.
Every mob gone on reload.
I am still playing on the original world, but the nearest new biome is 1000’s of blocks away. Make backups!
This was the first version of Minecraft I played I can’t believe it’s been 5 years!
I would say it's overall better, but there is still way to many bugs, just from personal experience: End gates corrupted, endstone regenerating in the end, entities despawning, signs rollback to blank
As a PS4 player (now PS5) I disagree. I''ll watch the video to see toycats opinion, but in my opinion Playstation minecraft is almost unplayable in its current state (god of war has much much higher fps) , particularly on splitscreen.
@@tortoisewarrior4855 I've played it mainly on win10, I did try ps4 version a few years ago, which ended up crashing alot, sounds like it still isn't optimized well then
@@nakano8412 I’ve never had any issues with ps5 bedrock strangely
@@nakano8412 The PS4 edition was much better when it came to optimization (although it did have problems). On bedrock I'd you get between 30-40 FPS on PS4, while on splitcreen it would often freeze and and dip down to 10fps even after so many improvements. While on PS5 it has problems that aren't as bad it still lacks optimization, and still drops below 60 fps on singleplayer. Also they didn't even have realms for a year, it took them so long to add it.
@@nakano8412 none of the bedrock editions besides PE and maybe windows 10 is optimized. Its literally just an emulator with some bells and whistles that aren’t any good.
I personally think it was a good idea and a horrible idea... they could've added sooo much more to the legacy console edition that they just didn't add, like more mini games, they could've added servers, they could've expanded the world's further, they could've added cross play between android, ios, and pc, instead of all platforms, then they could've added cross play between xbox, switch, and playstation, that would've been super cool
Why would they separate the cross play that’s a terrible idea
Yeah, I agree with you on this
I agree completely with this
i think about the furnace minecart every day, it still haunts me
The update actually corrupted almost all my legacy worlds, I personally hate it for that reason.
What I don’t like, is that for us to get cross platform, more optimization and continuos updates, they sacrificed what console edition previously had, like host privileges, amplified, instant pop up and better understandable menus, world and biome sizes, and of course, THE MINIGAMES
Small correction, but C# is very dissimilar to C++. They only share a similar name because Microsoft thought it'd make it more popular. C# has a garbage collector to automatically manage memory, whereas C++ requires manual memory management. C# compiles to bytecode where it is then interpreted on user's computers, whereas C++ compiles directly into machine code. C# is also object-oriented, whereas C++ supports a variety of paradigms (with object-oriented being only one of many options). C# is actually much more similar to Java, another garbage collected, bytecode compiled and object-oriented language. As such C++ has far better performance compared to C#, at the cost of being more challenging to write code in.
-Dual Wielding
-Hardcore
-Superflat and more world options
-Ability to build on Nether roof
-Banners on shields
-Sweeping Edge
-Banner markers on maps
These are some of the most wanted features for Minecraft Bedrock that I and probably other many millions of people have been waiting for for many many years and are still waiting to this day.
I love to see parity don't get me wrong but I feel like Mojang should prioritize parity features which people actually really want and/or have been craving for for years on end. Instead it feels like they're completely ignoring all of these features so they can do more work on the Marketplace.
I mean Dual Wielding I can understand even though they already fixed the touch screen problem by updating the controls and adding more buttons but I'll still give them a pass here.
Features like Hardcore tho? How is something so simple not in the game yet?
Superflat and more world options? They just updated the UI and moved things around so why couldn't they also just add more options on the way?
Why is it so hard for them to give us the ability to build on the Nether roof like on Java? I don't know.
Banners on Shields and banner markers on maps? These feel like easy features to add. Why do we not have them yet?
Have I even mentioned RTX? Lol. That was a complete mess but people still crave and want RTX for current gen consoles AT LEAST to this day. Why do we not have RTX on Xbox Series X and PS5 yet? Why was it even announced and hyped up if it wasn't possible? No idea. We don't even have updated versions of the game for Xbox Series X and PS5. What's up with that? Why aren't they focusing on that? Every other game has a next/current gen version so why doesn't Minecraft? Because better optimization for the newer consoles would be too much to ask for I guess
Hardcore mode can't be added be cause pillaring up can kill you if you do it in a lag spike lol
Sweeping is too OP without combat cooldowns
I couldve sworn i saw a bedrock developer show a sneak peek of banners on shields back in like 2020 in an image. But then they didnt ever bring it up again since
We have banners on shields now. I guess you can cross it off your list now. :P
@@flawyerlawyertv7454 Lol yeah. I'm actually very happy about that
@@laurwolfxd_3830 Same! I could finally put my country's flag onto my shield. 🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳
i remember being so miffed about world options when i went to bedrock. i still am. i would say that i think bedrock is still a better future than remaining on specific versions. i wouldnt even be able to play with any of my friends without bedrock! i also feel that not allowing custom worlds and skins on console is kind of missing the point of WHY we would want them. i dont want to play as a random generic hero character, i want to play as this specific character that would be not legally allowed on the marketplace. i dont want to always play on another top notch survival spawn, i just want to play on a world my friend shared! or a test world! it would be cool if we could have these systems, and whilst i dont hate the marketplace, i feel it could be reworked.
Honestly I think the custom stuff has more to do with Sony and I guess to an extent Nintendo, years before mods were a thing on consoles, when fallout 4 came out it promised custom mods from the community in consoles (something never seen before) into the game (which honestly was one of the features I actually got the game) but the feature was delayed many times until finally Bethesda came out saying that mods weren't coming for PS4 and only Xbox. And if I remember correctly the reason why there wouldn't be mods on PS4 was because Sony feared it would be a way to make the console less secure and risk user's security.
So I think the same is happening again with Minecraft where you can actually get mods on the Xbox version (in a very weird way but you can) and it's basically impossible on the PS4 and Switch. (Unless you play on a server).
They removed the old world choice
The fact that code for custom superflat *EXISTED IN BEDROCK* and it used to work (with external apps, yea it generated new chunks with the custom modifiers like java) and they hadn't implemented it until 1.18 where they deleted it! and it was a legacy feature on consoles. Screw Mojang and Microsoft
@@Enriquelorn how does adding custom superflats do that?
that was on the ps4 edition
14:16
Toycat - "Saying that you will do something and then not doing something because you only said you'd do it before you realized you would lose money, that is not a good tactic in my opinion."
Mojang - "Saying that we will do something is not a commitment..."
Mojang was never a good dev team change my mind
9:16 Console Edition has big salmon too. It is so sad, that Xbox One Edition and Nintendo Switch Edition were excluded from the aquatic update.
1:51 Console Edition was written in C#, what? Do you have a source? According to the minecraft wiki it was written in C++ just like bedrock.
Console Edition is certanly still better than bedrock because it has a lot of nice features, that bedrock is still missing:
1. Furnace minecarts
2. The luck effect (with potions, splash potions, lingering potions and tipped arrows),
3. The shrub.
4. The tutorial world
5. Minigames
6. In game tips and descriptions for blocks and items
7. Smaller biomes
8. More common structures
9. Blazes dropping 0-2 Glowstone dust when killed by a player (drop rate is unaffected by the looting enchantment)
10. Nether warts generating outside of fortresses
11. Wither skeletons rarely spawning outside of fortresses
12. The ability to pause the game
13. Minecarts being twice as fast
14. Better looking 3d chest icon when the game is saving instead of a weird 2d icon
15. The crafting recipe for enchanted golden apples
16. Dog plays after cat in the music disc
17. Controller hints work better, the generally mostly only show up, when the action is possible unlike on bedrock, the hints are smaller and at the bottom left but still readable, which is better and the buttons for the controller hints look pressed if you press them in a menu.
18. You can scroll in the end text
19. Sneaking while gliding with an elytra and not holding an item in the mainhand makes your right arm face forward
20. Camera tilting when turning while gliding with an elytra (can be disabled in the setttings if you don’t like it)
21. The emerald above villagers and wandering traders when trading with them (for some reason this nice feature was removed from bedrock for parity even though it was really useful)
22. Better furnace (smoker and blast furnace too) GUIs (it shows the name of the ingredient and fuel slot)
23. You can hold down the attack key to continiously attack
24. Better held item tooltips, while bedrock only shows the name, the enchantments and potions effects of the item, Console Edition can show all information below the name when switching hotbar slots. You can see things like the flight duration for fireworks, attributes of the item etc. (Unlike bedrock, Console Edition also has a limit, where it only shows up to 3 rows below the name)
25. You can see the amount of armor points that an armor piece gives you when hovering over it and this can of course also be seen when switching the hotbar slow
26. The old longer XP level up sound (sounds better than the new one imo)
27. You can exit worlds without saving
28. The skin menu is better because the players in the menu wobble with their arms and legs, you have an option to add skins to your list of favourite skins and you can use the stick to turn (RS on Xbox) to rotate the player or make it sneak or move the arm
29. The player turns with the minecart when it goes around a corner
30. Sprinting is not cancelled when walking against a block
31. Phantoms have less health (10 instead of 20)
32. Vindicators deal less damage (6 on easy, 10 on normal and 15 on hard instead of 7 on easy, 13 on normal and 19 on hard)
33. On PS4 Edition, which has the village and pillage update you can see the item tooltip of items in villager trades, that you do not have unlocked yet, allowing you to see things like the enchantments before unlocking the trade. On bedrock you can only see the item but hovering over it doesn’t show the item tooltip.
34. Arrows get stuck inside the player
35. You can see the offhand slot on the left next to the hotbar to see the item! On bedrock it is so frustrating that I do not see it because it means I cannot see the amount, how often I have the item, the durability of the shield and the cooldown of the shield if it is disabled by an axe!
36. Spiders can spawn with an effect on hard difficulty
37. Creepers with an effect spawn an area effect cloud of their effects when exploding
38. Hearts moving in the correct direction (up) and not the wrong direction (down) when having the regeneration effect
39. You can right click mobs with its spawn egg to spawn the baby variant
40. Item frames are entities instead of blocks, making more decorations possible. All of these decorations break if you convert your world from Console Edition to bedrock.
41. More popular redstone mechanics, such as quasi-connectivity and sticky pistons not retracting the block, they pushed, when given a 1 tick pulse. This also means that a lot of your redstone contraptions from Console Edition stop working if you convert your world to bedrock.
42. Faster regeneration if you have saturation points (notable you regenerate a lot of hearts quickly if you eat items with high saturation like golden carrots or steaks)
43. Newer AI for skeletons and strays, where the move while drawing their bow
44. Heart particles when attacking an entity to show how much damage you dealt
45. Particles for the sharpness, smite and bane of athropods enchantment
46. Halloween easter eggs such as undead mobs spawning with pumpkins and jack o'lanterns and a special splash text for halloween and bats spawning at higher light levels (up to 6 instead of 3) from 20th October to 3rd November
47. Better blinking for effect icons on the HUD, they blink more and more the lower the duration is, while on bedrock they blink always the same during the last 10 seconds
48. Effect icons having two rows (top for positive effects and bottom for negative effects) as opposed to being on top of each other on bedrock
49. Smooth animation when mounting an entity, where the entity moves to it (can also be seen in multiple console edition update trailers)
50. Ability to enchant every item with every enchantment using an anvil in creative mode
51. Changes made to redstone dust hitboxes from Java Edition 1.9 (on bedrock it is still always a full block square hitbox)
52. Higher resolution for explosion particles
53. Max entity cramming, which deals 3 HP of damage every half second (on java edition there is also a gamerule to change the maximum amount, which is 24 by default added in java edition 1.11 and console edition TU54)
54. Updated durability bar, which is easier to see especially if the durability is low
55. Zombie sieges
56. Left handed mobs
57. Ability to see the amount of items and durability in the hotbar in creative mode without opening the inventory
58. Better void, meaning you take damage and die from it in creative mode, there is no barrier 40 blocks below the build limit and you take damage after being at least 64 blocks below the build limit instead of immediately when being outside of it.
59. Strongholds generating with iron doors
60. Not outdated boat physics (on bedrock boats still always swim up in water even when underwater just like the old boats did on Java before 1.9)
It also has a lot of sounds, that bedrock hasn’t:
61. Newer sounds for using a fishing rod (both casting and reeling in), bedrock still uses the normal throwing sounds (Added in Console TU53 and Java 1.12)
62. The sound for a channeling trident spawning a lightning bolt (bedrock has the sound but it is unused) (Added in Console TU69 and Java 1.13)
63. Sound for placing lily pads (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9)
64. Sound for going with the eye level of the player underwater and out of the water (Added in Console TU69 and Java 1.13)
65. Shulkers using a different hurt sound, when closed (bedrock has the sound but it is unused) (Added in Console TU46 and Java 1.9)
66. Newer splashing sound for landing inside water
67. Unique sound for throwing eye of ender (bedrock uses the normal throw sound)
68. Sound for filling a glass bottle with water (bedrock only has the sound for filling it with dragon’s breath) (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9)
69. Newer sound for tilling farmland with a hoe and making grass path (dirt path in the newest version on java). On bedrock making dirt path just plays the sound for walking on grass, which makes no sense. (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9)
70. Newer sounds for activating wooden and weighted pressure plates (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9)
71. Sound for the thorns enchantment attacking the enemy back (on java edition it only plays for the player attacked by the enchantment while on console it plays for all players) (Added in Console TU43/TU46 and Java 1.9)
72. Sounds for paddling/rowing in boats (there are different sounds for rowing on land and rowing in water) (Added in Console TU54 and Java 1.12)
73. Sound for throwng eyes of ender breaking (Added in Java Edition 1.12 and Console Edition probably TU53)
74. Sound for making a critical hit (Added in Console TU46 and Java 1.9)
75. Newer door sounds, iron door sounds, trapdoor sounds, iron trapdoor sounds, fence gate sounds (Added in Console TU46 and Java 1.9)
The actual list is way longer. I didn’t mention all of them. The list I posted in this comment is very incomplete. It is nice that the sound for enchanting an item in an enchanting table was added to bedrock in 1.19.30 though. This feature has existed on Console Edition for more than 5 years. Of course that’s not enough because all of the other missing sounds still need to be added.
Also we can’t forget that the “Worse Together” was just a downgrade to Minecraft they discontinued Minecraft Legacy Console Edition in favour of this bad version 😥 And we are still missing these LCE features and the ones that IBXToycat pointed out have still not been fixed on Bugrock on consoles. Also LCE got 1.12 earlier then by like half a month Java edition and Bugrock got it like a year later then java I think that LCE should have been updated and Bugrock discontinued even on mobile devices and replaced with a new better version.
@@Steve_Poland "Better version" Coding a completely new engine for the game exclusively for mobile to appease some complainers from the future sure sounds reasonable!
@@dumigamez397 Why would you like to have another mobile Minecraft version if we want one as the Minecraft community we should play LCE and Java and see how great those game are!
@@Steve_Poland ?
@@dumigamez397 ?
The way I play the game would never change after that update, yes I did make new friends but I didn't have the ones I used to. The only thing I really do like is that the device I went on there originally didn't get updated to bedrock
I remember playing Minecraft on Xbox until Better Together, that was when I quit Minecraft
If you gave me the choice to have each update take twice as long but we still had the console editions I’d gladly revert
When i updated my ps4 creative world to bedrock my builds at the old border of the world got skewed downwards towards where the border used to be and all the blocks looked like they decided to become sand since roofs and platforms collapsed, I've never heard of this happening to other people though
did you wait until 1.18 to port the world? That’s mojang’s new chunk blending system in action. It’s supposed to make the transition between old chunks and new ones smoother but often ends up messing up builds like yours
@@cement_eater nope, transferred it immediately after the change to bedrock, and the biome blending wasn't added yet
They 100% should have refined Bedrock prior to going gungho and releasing it on the entire world. Minecraft on Switch is still the worst version to play on because of who knows why, corporate decisions or just the developers ignoring it. Other bugs have just been waved away on the Bug Tracker as "Will not fix" because why? There are some pretty serious issues and Bedrock's nickname being Bugrock isn't just a funny meme because it's moderately buggy. No you can basically just be playing casually and run into Bug after Bug constantly. I get that Bedrock's crossplay is great, but they just went through it too fast. Instead of optimizing it for everyone, mobile, consoles, and PC, they ended up just making a mess of a game that doesn't communicate with each other, and just ended up splitting the community into factions of Legacy Console, Bedrock, Java. Now no one is happy, and you have everything being a warzone and Mojang haven't really been helping the issue with ignoring certain issues being brought up.
I’ll say this again! To the people who say we should give Mojang a break! They’ve put themselves in this mess and they have to fix it themselves. They make enough money as is, so they shouldn’t have so many problems with efficiency and optimizing things for the people (if that’s bad it’s because of the dumb management.) Why shouldn’t they? Because they have money and I have data to back this up. Marketplace collabs are some of the proof of this, if those didn’t make money they wouldn’t license so many big mainstream things let alone build them. If they didn’t then they’d have more money from the marketplace and not worry about if things sold well or not. Not to mention taking ~30% of everything sold would fatten anyones pockets with the things being sold from .99 to ~15.99.
When people say “be grateful the game is over 10 years old” I literally can’t believe it. Times have changed, getting updates for games are essential to keep a player base, whether it’s bugs or DLC; you’ll eventually have a need for more content for more buyers. That being said, saying the people shouldn’t expect to have amazing frequent updates when all they’ve done for the past 12 years is push out a banger one after another is BS. Notch, Jeb, Dinnerbone, all of the older team, effectively impacted the game more then a billion dollar company. They built the game so the company can use it and make it amazing, which granted, they’ve done wonders with a lot of updates however the max time they’ve taken for each one is at most, 7-8 months with the least being a month. We got 3 parts to the pillagers in under a 2/3 of year, two parts of Aquatic and that took less then 6 months. I don’t mind small updates, however they set our expectations way too high and never disappointed. They did this to themselves and not to mention if it’s money that’s the problem, then it’s Microsoft that’s at fault. Why? Because they’ve made 3.132e9 dollars or simply put 3123900000 dollars off of Minecraft in the past 10 years. With ~537 million being left out due to it being owned by Notch and not Microsoft.
This means, they shouldn’t have problems like they have with staff. It’s poor management or spending or whatever, whatever it might be, it shouldn’t be happening. Frankly we shouldn’t have to be so loud about changes or horrible bugs. They should already know what is okay and not okay to add, we don’t have to hold their hand with ideas and additions with community votes or bad coding due to the piss take that is Bedrock. Ofc I’m not saying get rid of it, the communication is great but too much can be bad. We love bug reports but they have a weird system in place, don’t communicate what bugs they’re working on, nor keep “bugs” that literally are wonderful ideas and add so much to playing the game YOU want.
This entire thing is absolutely unfair to both parties and it’s just tiring. All it takes is some optimization for bedrock and the freedom for the players to have most things at their disposal. Issues like PS or Switch not having custom skins, the power to enable beta (now preview, without realms or a second game bought on laptop or PE) shouldn’t be happening. They shouldn’t be gatekeeping so much from players, they shouldn’t have so many problems with the marketplace like Copyright or cheap cookie cutter “mods”. It should be noticed and taken care of within a reasonable amount of time, not within the next years when they run out of ideas, now, when they have the power and feedback from users. They’ve programmed lots into both versions and both should be accessible in a similar way. Education edition also has so many amazing features yet they don’t put them in the base game, it’s baffling, just so hard and annoying to understand or reason with. Everyone is at fault, but mostly Microsoft and Mojang are to blame for the bad rules and limitations set by newer and older devs.
For real tho man
Honestly I think that Mojang is like this because of Microsoft and well Mojang currently being the developers of Minecraft. You have a nearly limitless budget and you don't have any reason to actually do something about the game because it's making money and even if it doesn't there's Microsoft who's willing to tank everything.
@@Enriquelorn Yeah true, Microsoft did make them do it since it is their game, and they do make a ton of money of the marketplace
Couldn't have said it better myself. It really is a mess
Facts, whole year has been one big self imposed mess and has definitely done great damage to themselves and our trust. I point to the glow squid, a hypnosis mob (rewatch the trailer, 3 times hypnosis was used, and if that wasn't a part of it then they shouldn't have teased it) that got a lazy as heck treatment that cannot be defended by a single dev as being of higher quality then an amateur modder. The very use can be replaced by glow stone dust and an ink sac.... boom I just made your high quality mob redundant. Whatever 1.20 is, we know now not to be excited till it's on our plates. 1.19 was literally like ordering a steak and getting a slice of rotten flesh with a sprinkle of suspicious stew as a seasoning sauce. Bleh..
I’ll say bedrock would be better if they’d add the missing features. Like custom superflat worlds and amplified worlds.
They took away old type worlds
@@ashethedestroyer5114 They never even did old type worlds right. I should have been able to use “nyan” or “0.4.0” and get the classic seeds.
@@tankmchavocproductions6907 old world type was never disgnined for that, it was the legacy console world type
@@dudeofdudovia Oh I’m talking about bedrock edition.
Ibxtoycat; “in Java you wouldn’t be able to achieve RTX with all the performance and all like in bedrock.” Me with sodium and iris
As much as I agree with you we still have to use mods to get that far, where as they have the ability built in!
bedrock is still superior in performance and rtx
@@themicsterend095 bedrock used to have shaders built in!
before the stupid rtx update
@@thesss4835 the menus still take too long for me to say that the performance is better, it does have rtx built in so it's better in that department
I'll admit that I'm still really salty over the better together update, especially considering all of the features that Microsoft has yet to implement into bedrock.
I wish they would have made legacy cross-play and I wish they could make it compatible with java servers, added all the Java features, and kept updating it leaving bedrock as a mobile and windows only game.
In truth, the better together update made me quit Minecraft, and it broke up my friend group. so no, I don't look at the change with fondness
Ouch
1:48 C++ and C# are two very different languages. Very easy to not understand that though if you've never programmed in them before. C++ is built off of C and has support for object oriented programming (And a few other things). Meanwhile, C# is more similar to Java in terms of how code is structured. Both are Object Oriented languages, but the way code is structured is VERY different.
tldr, They may both have C in the name, but that does not mean they're similar.
I think you pretty much described why I never switched to bedrock! I still played the legacy version of Minecraft Xbox one edition! It has features that bedrock will never have, and I still play it too thiiss daayy!
Yes
Its hard to believe that bedrock players have still not recieved amplified worlds and custom super flats (which have existed in java since 2014 and legacy console since 2016)
Imagine how awesome it'd have been if Mojang let 4J make the console editions all cross platform and up to date with java instead of what we have now
4J's minecraft was so good I could see it being cross platform with Java edition itself
4J's Minecraft is objectively superior to Bedrock in every way.
Better Together is a bad "update." From a Switch User's point of view, there are way too many bugs, I keep having to reapply the classic texture pack and the "Servers" are a downgrade of Minigames. Because of this, I treat bedrock as a disappointment with the best thing coming out of it being the 3DS port. The New Nintendo 3DS Edition of Minecraft is better then the Switch Bedrock.
And they still have not given us amplified worlds back :(
Legacy Edition looks better, feels better, runs better, has very good gui, has superflat, has amplified, has tutorial worlds, has minigames❤️ and no major bugs to name a few things
But Minecraft is Minecraft
Yes, but better is better
@@NaraSherko No Legacy Console edition is minecraft, Bedrock is a shameless low effort, low quality cash grab.
@@megaman37456 Bruh dude you can choose what device you can play on
@@NaraSherko Yeah, and? That doesn't stop Bedrock Edition from being a flaming heap of trash.
Imagine the timeline where better together was made by 4j it would be beautiful
I agree
Imagine a timeline where Bedrock Edition never existed and we still had 4J working on Legacy Console. I'd give up every atom of my being in this reality to be warped to that one.
What is the song that plays at 3:10?
You: Talking about The Better Together Update
Me: *What's he building?*
The changelog at 2:35 made me go WHAAATTT so many times as an xbox 360 enjoyer first for years until i bought Java.
These things were almost always on console, im surprised PC didnt have them. At least in some capacity
Also: custom skins:
I found out something stupid.
If you have java and a pc, you can make a custom skin and upload it to your character in java, then port it through the launcher to bedrock, then you can use it on console.
But if you dont have a PC, you're SoL. Its the dumbest thing ever. And what makes it better I found out microsoft notified me my user experience was beingntracked for something. I shrugged it off like yeah whatever, and two days later you could buy my skin's head.
I trawled the internet for a skin even remotely like the one i wanted on both the store and Java's third party files before finally settling down and working on mine, and yet they got a head exactly like mine to the pixel on the store for $1.29, right after they checked my account out.
Idk about y'all but that sussed me out and was the final straw for me and bedrock's store. It may have been coincidence but i highly doubt it.
16:02 COULD be the same? I think that they would end up being released at the same time with no gap. PS4 got the village and Pillage only like 5 months after java and it had most of the features. I think that by the next major update the console editions would be fully caught up.
the only thing java needs is:
the handsway animation from 🛏️ 🪨, its just make sense for the hand to sway in 1st person,
leaves turning white when it snows,
dyed water
mid air faster bridge building without crouching
and looking at the block
I will add something to the video, on Nintendo switch (I only play on Nintendo switch do I don't know if it on the rest of bedrock or not) if you use the down arrow on the d-pad, it instantly types your last chat message sent, and if you press it again, it instantly types the message before your last one that you sent, And it cycles until you reach the message you sent 20 messages ago. It is a good feature.
Hey I think an interesting idea for a video topic would be every blocks different colors and how many colors a blocks uses ranked from least to most? Intriguing question?
No lie, I un-ironicly want furnace minecarts back I was super sad to find they were removed when I got back into the game
My problem is that it has taken away the individual attention given to each console and platform. Loading times can be up to 10 minutes long on Switch and they have done nothing about it.
There is no per console optimization and thus doesn't take advantage of the Xbox Series and PS5 let alone the Xbox One X and PS4 Pro. They need to optimize their game.
Og game play of you covering up the sheep prison that doesn't exist
Yes, we get to play with my friends on other consoles! Now I get to play with friends on my switch on someone’s pc or Xbox or PlayStation or someone’s phones or tablet!
It was worth it in the long run, but it could have gone better if they waited until like 2019 or 2020 to release the cross play update. Bedrock was so ridiculously buggy for console versions at launch and also didnt include ps4 or switch versions
All bedrock really has going for it over 4J Minecraft is infinite worlds and cross play. Mobile holds back bedrock edition on other devices so much and that’s only the start of the problems with bedrock
I just hope one day they start doing Console edition parity for Bedrock
Mojang should’ve just gotten 4J to develop bedrock edition. Things would’ve been SO much better that way.. We’d probably still have tutorial worlds!!
5 years already... It feels like yesterday we were all still playing on the console editions..
Worst day in Minecraft history, so no minecart furnace & exit without saving.
has it really been 5 years? damn.
Personaly, I still find that the Legacy Console Editions are the best versions of Minecraft. Regardless of the disadvantages. In 2020, I started playing Bedrock Edition (got mad at the game every time I played it), in 2021, I moved to Java Edition (I no longer get mad at the game every time I play it), and I still play the PS3 Edition (legacy console edition) from time to time. I've played Pocket Edition, Nintendo Switch Edition and 3DS Edition, and have found that I liked the Legacy Console Editions better. Sorry for the paragragh...
Is this what led to the dumb red stone changes I still don’t know why they did that so much for parity
One thing I had trouble transitioning from Legacy/Bedrock to Java was Ability to have Creative Flight in Survival (Bedrock had the MayFly from Education)
And don't get me started on Redstone issues and the Give and Fill commands
Better together had actually made it significantly harder for me to play minecraft. There was so much lag that i could walk around and everything would get unloaded except for chests, spawners, etc so i basically had a vanilla xray glitch that occured when loading a chunk or when autosaving, which is almost always when playing in short sessions. I havent ever been easily able to host a game without buying a realm. 5 years later and i still cant host games. For the first 4 years it was almost always crashing and giving weird errors that deleted either all entities or only certain ones such as minecarts. I couldnt go in the nether without at least my minecarts getting deleted. I lost all of my farm animals, a half stack of iron from making minecarts, an armor stand with enchanted leather armor and an enchanted netherite sword, and a chunk even got reverted to a previous state somehow. My world is only 147mb and theres almost no entities. I shouldnt be having any of these problems and it shouldnt have taken mojang 4 years to even think about starting to fix them
I feel there is one flaw and that’s on consoles it usualy requires a subscription to either Xbox live gold or play station plus I could be wrong and this may have changed but its what I remember
I remember one time I spent awhile figuring out Geyser and Floodgate to put on my Java server so my friends on xbox can join the server and then it was super disappointing when I realized that there wasn't a join server button on bedrock for xbox but there is one for bedrock on PC.
I have yet to fully forgive them until they add amplified and custom super flat to bedrock
Speaking as someone who has been programming for 35 years... The only relationship between C++ and C# is.. the name. In truth C# is closer to Java than it is to C++. Microsoft picked the name for marketing reasons, but the actual language has little to do with C or C++ beyond the vaguest of cosmetic similarities.
I really dislike how bedrock had a lot of stuff perfectly fine and identical to java (shadows, view bobbing, hand position, particles and block breaking... I can go on and on), but then messed it all up slowly. Remember when players moved smoothly at 60fps? When the menus were far more responsive and didnt lag? When the lighting was 100% identical to java?
It sucks.
Play roblox
The hand position in first person on Bedrock just pisses me off. It's been there since the 1.13 betas
@@NaraSherko Eww no 🤢
Minecraft bedrock edition was a pure mistake as it took all that 4J studios made and threw it in the bin
Should have just updated bedrock to the 4j version tbh
I still have never been able to get cross play to work and it seriously disappoints me. I have Minecraft on Switch, PS4, and Windows 10 and have tried to get them all to play together in every possible combination of the three and it has never been successful.
on the PS4 it actually was just an update that added the new version and a menu button to go back to the old one, there aren't 2 separate games.
as for if it's worth it... idk. There's some huge improvements (command blocks, structure blocks, experimental features meaning more common updates, cross-play, infinite worlds, in game chat), but there's also some big downgrades (no custom superflat or amplified worlds, no world size select, a bunch of false promises about things they'd add, and some QOL downgrades, no furnace minecarts, no tutorial worlds or free DLC trials, no mini-games mode, bedrock redstone)
there's also things that still really need changing on console (add a proper way to transfer worlds between platforms that doesn't rely on realms, add a way to download behaviour packs on console as currently you can't even do that from the marketplace since they don't sell behaviour packs that aren't connected to a world, and let console players connect to any server, not just the few "official" ones). It seems like the things that were big improvements with bedrock were things they weren't planning on doing on legacy console anyway, but it would have been nice to see the game as it is in 1.19 but on legacy console, it would have been fun making a deep dark superflat world, but mojang can't be bothered to just add it despite the fact they definitly could if they wanted to. It's the best selling game of all time, there's no way they wouldn't be able to add a feature that was added in TU25 on legacy console in 5 years.
Switching over to bedrock was probably for the best and had to happen eventually, but they really didn't put enough effort into making sure that went well and felt like there weren't any major downsides.
I find it ironic that the version that emphasizes multiplayer has multiplayer that never works.
I really hope Minecraft Bedrock comes to Linux or MacOS one day so it could be the true crossplay Minecraft
kid named bootcamp/whatever you want to use on linux:
@@cement_eater Dual-booting is really not a solution. You had to stop everything you're doing and reboot you're pc and when you're done with that reboot again
@@Atius yeah that’s fair
For me there's only 4 reasons Bedrock is good.
1. It's still updated.
2. Infinite Worlds.
3. Simultaneous Updates.
4. Crossplay.
I'd much rather live in a world where all 3 Console Veraions were Crossplay using Console Edition.
By now the Xbox Series, and PS5 could have Infinite Worlds(using the Console Edition), while the Switch might be limited to only playing on the Large Template from Console Edition(so Switch could play with Xbox, and/or PlayStation players if they are on those templates).
In this world I guess Xbox One, and PS4 would also potentially be able to play with the others on the Large Template.
A lot of my issues with Bedrock would probably be fixed if there was a next gen version of Minecraft, but that won't happen in order to not leave Xbox One, PS4, Switch, and Mobile behind.
I only play Minecraft Java now. I used to play pocket edition 5 years ago because i didnt have a PC that time, and I enjoyed it, the only problem was when I went into multiplayer like skywars and bedwars etc. i would get absolutely destroyed by the people playing on Windows 10 and controllers. It was absolutely impossible to counter because pc gaming is so dynamic. I bought a wireless controller of my own, a very good controller however minecraft didnt quite support it well. Finally I had to quit the game I loved so much because whenever i went into multiplayer the win10 sweats would call me a noob when I was playing on a touchscreen.
When I did get a PC 2 years ago I downloaded bedrock again and went in and absolutely destroyed those same guys with barely any practice at all, and then quit Bedrock for once and for all after getting revenge, because I realised now I will be unfair for other touchscreen players playing mcpe because they cant afford a PC yet.
The fact that mojang called minecrafts "better together update" an update even though it was intire new version of the game should have been an indication that minecraft bedrock would turn into absolute dumpster fire of a game 🙄
What makes it worse is that developing bedrock edition was an absolute waste of time, they already had legacy console edition which was fully updated all the way to 1.13 yet they decided to scrap all of it and remake THE INTIRE GAME and miss several features in the process
they didn't remake the game, they ported mobile to every platform
Minecraft is Minecraft
Please stop using version numbers to refer to feature updates.
I only got into minecraft playing on my phone, because my 8 year old got into it a few months ago on the ps4 so now I watch stuff so I can try to teach him new things and play together on wifi
I only have the console edition of Bedrock on Xbox. I've never bought a map on the market place and don't plan too in the foreseeable future. I use an app on the Xbox that lets me copy a world into Minecraft game folder. This is how I play multiple custom maps, especially Skyblock and Flatworlds. I still crave we get the custom flatworld options on console someday soon!
Speaking of the outro joke, stationary and stationery are different things, and I just learned recently about the difference in spelling.
This update is extremely nostalgic to me no matter how good or bad it was.
I lost a world I was SUPER proud of about a year after Bedrock’s launch. I have not been able to play Minecraft since. I just don’t have any motivation to
I miss mine carts with furnaces, wish they would add it back
I wish they found a way to port the 4J version to mobile and pc instead...
true 100% agree, and the only real way to make custom superflat worlds is to start a new world and then not accept multiplayer safety agreement, then open the world and edit the FlatWorldLayers json ""{
"biome_id": 9,
"encoding_version": 4,
"block_layers": [
{
"block_name": "minecraft:black_concrete",
"count": 64
},
{
"block_name": "minecraft:air",
"count": 0
},
{
"block_name": "minecraft:air",
"count": 0
}
]
}""
Maybe to a certain level, but they forced us into a buggy unpolished version built for phones rammed by microtransactions, and took away legacy console edition versions slowly one by one
I think my main gripe with Bedrock edition is that it feels so unresponsive compared to the legacy console editions & Java. It felt optimized and the inventory management & crafting were superior imo. If Bedrock played like legacy console editions in it feels, I probably would've switched to Bedrock for my vanilla experience.
Honestly they should have kept the pocket edition a seperate version. If you really want to play with your pc friends, they could have made some sort of compatibility version exclusively for realms and servers.
Why would they create such an unreasonable mess?
I just hate that a game owned by Microsoft runs so poorly on their own console. Sometimes I just wanna play Minecraft, but I can't even go to the Nether in multiplayer because it lags so much that I can't eat food, or enemies just won't take damage sometimes.
Actually, you can access the keyboard with one of the d-pad arrows. At least, you can on Playstation.
I didn't know for a long time, even though it says so every time you make a new world.
It just feels like bedrock devs don't really care about the users.
I'm not talking about the marketplace or things out of their control, but we've had so many bugs that seem easy to fix and have lasted since the beginning of Bedrock edition.
We've gotten to a point where bugs are more and worse like not being able to move to the right on mobile devices on 1.19.0 to the infamous pink glitch that was caused by renderdragon.
All because they wanted to market the rtx which most of us will never use and the performance is worst than ever, and it brought so many bugs for no reason.
That's the reason a lot of us changed to Java, but not everyone has that luxury
i dont have that luxury to go to java but also dont have the burden as said about bugrock, i encounter one reoccuring but harmless and uncommon bug but thats about it, had a pretty normal experience on bugrock despite its reputation, and its not all gloom and doom, as there is glimmers of hope as the devs dont entirely ignore these bugs, they often release bug fix and bug patch more than java, and even the infamous pink glitch from the render dragon, was fixed in a beta, though they took it back due to some other bug, not trying to defend bugrock and all, just saying it could be better, im an update behind to not experience the render dragon problem too
I refuse to believe the better together update was more then 2 years ago
The update was terrible and ruined Minecraft for console gamers. We were forced onto this new version of the game which was literally a mobile port to console. To this day they still haven’t reached parity with console edition as they are still missing minigames, improved ui, console controls (not clunky mobile controls), exiting without saving, custom flat worlds, even some skin packs are still missing. They didn’t even try and if you experienced how incredibly smooth and well put together the console edition is then you don’t know what we lost. This is the reason I stopped playing Minecraft and I’m sure many others did the same. On top of that there were so many broken promises such as custom skins which never happened. I still consider bedrock to be inferior to console and would rather live in a reality where console edition continues to be updated.
I suppose this update was huge for bedrock. Extremely useful for multiplayer. And the fact that this was released during the dark era of minecraft attracted more player to play bedrock more than java. Maybe in the past, this wasn't so optimized, but now, they're slowly getting better.
think that minecraft shouldve had 3 versions
Java for PC
Bedrock for Consoles (n maybe pc)
Pocket for Mobile
This would allow many different teams work on their own schemes, optimizing for their platforms
Besides missing the console edition , sometimes I miss the old pocket edition as well 😕
I do agree that it was a good choice for the future of the game itself though , and I have faith in Mojang that eventually Bedrock will become a more stable and worthwhile version of the game . Even if that does take another 5-10 years
2 years after the better together update i switched to windows 10 for custom skins and skin packs
I only really hate it because it was the start of the shutdown of Xbox one edition, I absolutely hate this new version, I wish I can go back to the original mc xbox one edition.
Heck yeah it was! Cross play was the best idea!
There should be bedrock, java, and mobile. If mobile got separated, bedrock and java could even possibly merge. Touch controls parity causes a bunch of issues and is why the bundle doesnt truly exist anymore
What's funny is that Mojang one day decided that mobile (pocket edition) was so good that they decided to make it it's own grand version as Java's contender, aka Bedrock. Funny how the internal files in all Bedrock versions are basically still named "minecraftpe", where pe stands for pocket edition
I love legacy more its very relaxing
And the minigames are amazing
while i can not speak about console minecraft that was shortly before started playing or watching the cat man but rarely find myself playing big salmon ver anymore due to bad post render dragon performance (dx12), bugs that have yet to be fixed some game breaking, lack of other game modes/worlds, and some poor gameplay design choices such as strongholds with no end frame wasnt till my 3rd bedrock world that i found working stronghold might have found one on 2nd world but one day it was just gone
Just because you can put Minecraft onto every device, doesn't mean that you should. Elytra's for example, are completely redundant on the Switch version due to slooooow updating of chunks in the world while flying.
I REALLY didn't like Bedrock coming to consoles and I still don't. This update changed everything, and it removed all the cool UI, multiplayer modes, 3rd party maps and skins, and the performance got worse. I miss the tutorial worlds. :(