Their commitment, their expression, their feeling and their playing is just wonderful. I've watched this many times and am just in awe of their performance. Bravo. A tribute to the human race.
L'union est parfaite, et les intentions musicales admirablement partagées entre les deux jeunes interprètes. Toute leur sensibilité s'exprime dans les contrastes, très nuancés. Salim & Sivan nous offrent ici tous les bienfaits d'un réjouissant bain de jouvence, tonique et vivifiant !
Maybe the best performance I’ve heard of this march. They’ve got a good tempo and the right style. (Too many pianists play this like a breathless sprint.) A few small clinkers don’t ruin it, though it’s a shame the audience barges in at the wrong moment.
You are so correct, Tom Poore. Their tempo is perfect to provide a vigorous march rhythm as well as give a nice gentle "lilt" to the music (especially in the TRIO section). Yes, and too bad the dreadful audience didn't know the music and ruined it with the clapping in the middle.
@@VincentSPICER IMO the applause did not take away too much (if at all) from the rendition. It felt more like a scene applause. And then, the piece is neither well known nor particularly "serious" in the first place. Not much to ruin here... Correct me if I'm wrong.
I like the fact the audience applauded - not the wrong moment, more a false finish to the piece which might well have been intended to make the audience go ‘aaaaahh’ when the pianists unexpectedly start up again after they begin applauding. Maybe it is a teensy bit elitist to get precious about such matters? Spontaneity makes for a better experience! Although I would draw the line at audience giving enthusiastic whoops in the middle of the Moonlight Sonata… PS I played in a band a few years back where we did exactly that - a false finish, wait for the audience to start applauding, and then start up again. It always went down well!
Let's not chide the audience for their "inappropriate" applause. For instance, if you are unfamiliar with this work and it sounds like it's ending (which it actually is the end when the Da Capo is taken) then the audience will applaud. Call them rude if you wish but at least they appreciated the performance. Sometimes us "trained" musicians and listeners need to understand that not everyone is in our "world."
Did it matter at all? I don't think so. To me it feels like a, well, "fun piece" anyway. And the applause wasn't clearly attributed to an ending as well. Kind of snobbish to blame a general audience for expressing their feelings. (You didn't, others did.)
Hi 👋 hi can I come by today to pick it out and get the stuff for me to do and then I’ll come over to help out the whole day lol lol I’m not sure if you have to come home and do it in my car lol I just need a shower I don’t have a problem I don’t have a lot to go in the house I have a u the imposter and the other one is the best and the
Despite some adverse comments I enjoyed the performance, and they seem so passionate about what they are doing; a pity the audience didn't know what they were listening to !
Oh! so wonderful four hands Schubert is veryvery nice and graceful. Yeah! beautiful. I would feel that especially the middle part's 4 same notes might be so difficult.
This is just wonderful!! Why are people taking the piss about their movements and mannerisms?? When you are completely absorbed in, and engaged with, the music you don’t care what your body is doing!
Apparently in Singapore this is associated with some kind of listening comprehension exam. For me in the United States, at one time my sister tap-danced to this song in her recital!
And in Sweden it’s accociated with Christmas, since it’s used in ”santas workshop” that is played alongside many other Disney cartoons on Christmas Eve
This is in the middle of a concert, the rest of the orchestra would have played aswell that evening but it would take too long for whole orchestra to leave and come back for a single duet
Like many in the comments section, I was completely taken by the mesmerising beauty, mannerisms and performance of the female pianist and had to find out more about her. I think I've finally found her. I believe her name is Sivan Silver and the male pianists' name is Saleem Abboud Ashkar, though I could be wrong. So if anyone knows their correct identities please share!
Thank you Pulau for your research. You are correct on the guy's name: Saleem Abboud ASHKAR. I have not found the girl yet, so I will take your lead for now, Sivan SILVER ... I'll research and see what I come up with. I found the guy, now I want to find her. I want to find more recordings of both of them.
He has a beautiful face though (and so does she), get over it. Never mind the face or facial expressions or the hair - it's the MUSIC - their excellent "together" (synchrony), rhythmic, dynamics, an excellent performance.
二人の息ぴったりの連弾に、テンポの良い軍隊行進曲…。とても良かったです。素晴らしい！
これは大変貴重な動画だと思います。本当に有難う御座いました。
❤Exactement
Their commitment, their expression, their feeling and their playing is just wonderful. I've watched this many times and am just in awe of their performance. Bravo. A tribute to the human race.
Beautiful performance. Two very talented pianists.
Absolutely! This is one of my favourite performances of this work. I love both of these pianists.
@Antony Fragakis Salim Abboud ASHKAR, and the girl is Sivan SILVER with Garburg Duo.
Talented maybe but why so many mistakes?
@@ilovemydog6847 I caught some mistakes too but overall they're still talented to have pulled off this duet
@@ilovemydog6847
Spiegel kucken , da finden sie Fehler.
L'union est parfaite, et les intentions musicales admirablement partagées entre les deux jeunes interprètes. Toute leur sensibilité s'exprime dans les contrastes, très nuancés.
Salim & Sivan nous offrent ici tous les bienfaits d'un réjouissant bain de jouvence, tonique et vivifiant !
Très bien dit! C'est tout à fait juste!
Maybe the best performance I’ve heard of this march. They’ve got a good tempo and the right style. (Too many pianists play this like a breathless sprint.) A few small clinkers don’t ruin it, though it’s a shame the audience barges in at the wrong moment.
You are so correct, Tom Poore. Their tempo is perfect to provide a vigorous march rhythm as well as give a nice gentle "lilt" to the music (especially in the TRIO section). Yes, and too bad the dreadful audience didn't know the music and ruined it with the clapping in the middle.
@@VincentSPICER IMO the applause did not take away too much (if at all) from the rendition. It felt more like a scene applause. And then, the piece is neither well known nor particularly "serious" in the first place. Not much to ruin here... Correct me if I'm wrong.
I like the fact the audience applauded - not the wrong moment, more a false finish to the piece which might well have been intended to make the audience go ‘aaaaahh’ when the pianists unexpectedly start up again after they begin applauding. Maybe it is a teensy bit elitist to get precious about such matters? Spontaneity makes for a better experience! Although I would draw the line at audience giving enthusiastic whoops in the middle of the Moonlight Sonata…
PS I played in a band a few years back where we did exactly that - a false finish, wait for the audience to start applauding, and then start up again. It always went down well!
Very nicely done! Great duet on a wonderful piece of music. Thank-you.
This music is exciting and reminds me of why I first fell in love with the piano
Let's not chide the audience for their "inappropriate" applause. For instance, if you are unfamiliar with this work and it sounds like it's ending (which it actually is the end when the Da Capo is taken) then the audience will applaud. Call them rude if you wish but at least they appreciated the performance. Sometimes us "trained" musicians and listeners need to understand that not everyone is in our "world."
Did it matter at all? I don't think so. To me it feels like a, well, "fun piece" anyway. And the applause wasn't clearly attributed to an ending as well. Kind of snobbish to blame a general audience for expressing their feelings. (You didn't, others did.)
We not "us". But agree, of course.
Hi 👋 hi can I come by today to pick it out and get the stuff for me to do and then I’ll come over to help out the whole day lol lol I’m not sure if you have to come home and do it in my car lol I just need a shower I don’t have a problem I don’t have a lot to go in the house I have a u the imposter and the other one is the best and the
@@mayaru1171 what the fuck
@@mayaru1171 sssure..
Absolutely beautiful, Light and shade. Brilliant!
Tempo exacto y coordinación perfecta. Magnífico!
Exquisite phrasing! With clarity over such a broad dynamic range that it sounds orchestral.
I learned this many many years ago. Played the primo part. Fun piece. These two are definitely expressive.
Awesome! Especially once they adjusted the bench.
I agree 🤗 with the bench issue
This could very well be thee greatest piano masterpiece ever!! And four hands.. 🤩😍🤓☝️
Passionate playing by the young man. I enjoyed his performance and the young lady who in truth was making me swerve to the music as well.
"What the hell are they doing?"
Well kids they actually have passion for music unlike other musicians and can feel the music
Nearly flawless technique with a modern flair and 19th century joie de vivre. My thanks for an admirable posting!
Lovely duet,perfect.😍
Despite some adverse comments I enjoyed the performance, and they seem so passionate about what they are doing; a pity the audience didn't know what they were listening to !
Agree with you!
Totally agree they are very talented
Not everyone is an expert in classical music, but everyone starts somewhere.
that bobbing of his hair is so cute
Nice to see a NICE comment, yes he is cute here - because he is natural, feeling the music.
BRAVO! that was a brilliant performance, love this piece
Incredible performance!! One of thee best masterpieces ever!! 🤠🤓💥☝️
I love there talent!!! they play beautifully!!!!
Their
audience got tricked by schubert
Miriam Rabidly thnx, I came up with it all by myself! :)
yes they did
Great performance by this duet. Well harmonized.
Perfect timing! Amazing.
I couldn't help but stare at his face and hair flipping haha
exactly XD
EPIC!!!!!!!! Thanks for sharing......
their timing is fucking perfect
TRUE.
No need to emphasize you views with vulgar language.
Always good to hear an educated person............
@@roystewart663 bro 😂 he can say what he wants
I FUCKING KNOW RIGHT
If only now, that land could ever be this harmonious……. (A Jew and an Arab playing the piano together harmonious)
Wonderful performance.
Quand j'entends : "celui-là il ne sait rien faire de ses dix doigts !", en voilà deux qui savent les occuper leurs dix doigts. Bravo et merci.
Super cool 😎 and it’s a great piece
Hi 👋
Lovely playing
Firstly they form a sweet couple
Secondly they play admirably well
I thought they were brother and sister lol
@@EriPages Still... (ha.)
@planetrob555 You liked your own comment.
But that's alright. I've now liked your comment too.
A superb performance.
This is amazing!
I loved this.
군대행진곡 연주중 최고
환상적인 듀엣❤
Oh! so wonderful four hands Schubert is veryvery nice and graceful. Yeah! beautiful.
I would feel that especially the middle part's 4 same notes might be so difficult.
We enjoyed this, thanks for posting ❤
!!!!! Bravissimo!!!
They make me smile
Para mí, es la mejor versión. Es estupenda!!!!!!
very articulate playing!..awesome :-)
I love listening to it. Nearly in every recording you can find small mistakes. Even in Lang Langs recording there was a mistake :D
Beautiful duets, bravo 👏👏👏👏💐💐
Wonderful❤
I'm happy to meet this music video.
my favorite schubert duet
Maravilloso! y las expresiones de él suman mucho al espectáculo.
Most charming march ever!
Son Mágicos!!!!!!
¡fantástico!
just watching the guy's facial expressions was more entertaining than the music.
Exactly!!!
Lol
Hey! you're rude!!hahahahaha!!his mouth works very well🤣
ahahahahahahahahaah !!!!!
Sin la menor duda, eres muy SORDO.
It's so good
This is just wonderful!! Why are people taking the piss about their movements and mannerisms?? When you are completely absorbed in, and engaged with, the music you don’t care what your body is doing!
Magnificent talent
]
THE STACCATTO IS JUST 🤯🤯🤯🤯
Bravo!!!!
Exquisite!
Bravo!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Love 💗 so much melody
Duet of the key blade masters is the best duet I've heard.
wonderfull
Bravo bravissimo. Congratulation. Szívből gratulálok az előadó művészeknek. Bravó
ma version préférée félicitation aux 2 pianistes
Wonderful! Wow! Are there any other performances by these two?
Passionate 👍👍👍
Awesome
this is a very good performance. it has a sense of march. well done!!!!!!!!
Apparently in Singapore this is associated with some kind of listening comprehension exam. For me in the United States, at one time my sister tap-danced to this song in her recital!
Just tap dancing to this is impressive. Even though it's named "Military March" you simply can't march to it.
And in Sweden it’s accociated with Christmas, since it’s used in ”santas workshop” that is played alongside many other Disney cartoons on Christmas Eve
I wanted to download this to listen to it but the clapping in the middle...
+Yami Bakura My same dilemma!
The applause is brief. I downloaded it and love it!
I know, eh? An inexperienced audience (they are unfamiliar with this work).
Easy to remove.
@@stanmaes1648 how?
Good job 👍
Why isn't anyone mentioning the musicians at the back? They are all staring at them like: what the hell are they doing?!
Naturally musical playing.
This is in the middle of a concert, the rest of the orchestra would have played aswell that evening but it would take too long for whole orchestra to leave and come back for a single duet
THiS iS SooO PerFeCT..
Astonishing
Magnifique😘
Молодцы!!!
Casa jfjdjjdjsjs
I ship them
Exactly, this is instant-ship!
d
Brilliant!!!
Glorioso
I’m in love with Sivan 😍😍😍
Same
Molto bravi e decisi
Nice❤️
love it!
Perfect tempo..
Well done.
How much time they change therir sitting position
Jiji
I love 😍😍😍😍 adjusting 😍😍😍 the bench 🤪🤪🤪🤪
I love both of these pianists; I want to hear (see) some of their solo performances. What are their full names?
Salim and Sivan
Sivan Silver I dont know his full name.
Geweldig!
Nodame e chiakiii ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
0:45 Start
0:52 Primary Starts
1:07 First Section Repeat
1:30 2nd Section Begins
Like many in the comments section, I was completely taken by the mesmerising beauty, mannerisms and performance of the female pianist and had to find out more about her. I think I've finally found her. I believe her name is Sivan Silver and the male pianists' name is Saleem Abboud Ashkar, though I could be wrong. So if anyone knows their correct identities please share!
Thank you Pulau for your research. You are correct on the guy's name: Saleem Abboud ASHKAR. I have not found the girl yet, so I will take your lead for now, Sivan SILVER ... I'll research and see what I come up with. I found the guy, now I want to find her. I want to find more recordings of both of them.
My face is like the guy's facial expression now, and I know there're something words never can tell. just feel the music
His face though! XD
lol
He has a beautiful face though (and so does she), get over it. Never mind the face or facial expressions or the hair - it's the MUSIC - their excellent "together" (synchrony), rhythmic, dynamics, an excellent performance.
Spasibo very match!
Je suis tombé amoureux de leur déconcertante expressivité
super 😘😘😘😘
excelente