Lecture by Noam Chomsky at United Nations on prospects of resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 окт 2014
- The lecture by Prof. Noam Chomsky on the prospects for resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was organized at United Nations Headquarters in New York on 14 October 2014 by the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People, within the framework of the International Year of Solidarity with the Palestinian People. The lecture was followed by a Q&A session with Prof. Chomsky moderated by broadcast journalist Amy Goodman of Democracy Now!
Further information: www.un.org/unispal/document/a...
www.un.org/unispal/document/a...
Timestamps:
0:14 - Introduction by Amy Goodman
1:24 - Highlight on Chomsky's influence and contributions
2:38 - Chomsky’s critique on how the media covers the Israel-Palestine conflict and the portrayal of reality
4:14 - Chomsky on Intellectual Responsibility: Discussion on the responsibility of intellectuals, referencing his 1967 essay on U.S. involvement in Vietnam
7:52 - Chomsky begins his lecture on the complexities of the Israel-Palestine conflict
10:12 - Critique of U.S. foreign policy regarding Israel and its consequences on peace processes
Global Implications and Future Prospects
14:00 - Explanation of the real intentions behind publicized diplomatic moves, particularly the disengagement plans.
19:02 - Chomsky delves into historical legal settlements and the international community's stance on them, emphasizing the legality issues.
21:50 - Analysis of ceasefires in the region, their implementation, and frequent violations by Israel.
31:02 - Chomsky reflects on global responses to Israeli actions and discusses the broader implications for human rights.
37:31 - Chomsky discusses the broader implications of the conflict and potential pathways to peace
50:55 - Chomsky's closing remarks, encapsulating his thoughts on the pursuit of peace and justice in the region.
Follow the Committee activities on Social Media
/ un.palestinianrights
/ unispal
/ unispal
This was 8 years ago. Things have become worse and worse since then.
How so very nice to learn that NOAM CHOMSKY stood up with EAST TIMOR - I’m so Happy , so VERY Grateful ! My Parents never made it possible to return to the place they loved the most… Down to Fascist Governments as they can create too much pain.
I might now be able to take their remains back to where they belong: EAST TIMOR !
It's not antisemitism it's criticism of criminal actions of a state!
Of course its not antisemitism. There are 50mln refugees after the WW2, billions of victims of these processes. The overall internal death toll of the arabian world is hundreds of times higher than of all Israeli wars, half of the map if redrawn after the WW2. Right now millions of Afgans expelled from Pakistan. And we look at people who build cities, roads and gardens. And people who cut of babies from moms bellies and call their moms to share how cool it was. And the problem is in roads, of course..
HAMAS has climbed to the GAZA GOVERNMENT... and ISRAEL is a democracy DEFENDING THEMSELVES from this attack of October 7, 2023!!
Words chiseled in stone......... fast track December 2023. " The pattern right before our eyes"
To Amy Goodman, Our Gratitude And Admiration For Moderating This Noble Session. May God bless you. AMEEN
Amy is amazing lady may god blessed her for her 🙏 ❤️ ♥️ 💖 💕 💗 🙏 ❤️ ♥️ 💖 💕 💗 🙏 ❤️ ♥️ 💖 💕 💗 🙏 ❤️ ♥️ great work as a journalist .
I don't care who you are but I care what you are and this guy seems to be a good person and tells it like it is, thats what I think
💯!
He has such a great mind steering his thoughts , “democracy now “
Long live Amy and Noam
It is my first time to watch this youtube and I heard Ms. Amy Goodman talking as the moderator for this session. She is such a wonderful intellectual woman and moderator. She is as good as the main speaker.
She has not quite the stature, intellectual experience and long analysis time that Noam has but she is an excellent journalist and campaigner and I’m in love with her.
Democracy Now! is an incredible, highly confiable news source
This should have millions of views.
Very simple. Smart phones have brought humans to 2 digit IQ
Remarkable thing that, after one of his usual witty comments, Chomsky was applauded at the UNO Security Council.
I have to join 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼!
PEACE AND DEMOCRACY NOW
🙏🏻🕊
This video, despite being older, is so true after so many years. Nothing has changed. The world has changed, not in Ghaza, though!!
Ghaza will be free.
Excellent Prof Chomsky....9 yrs ago you warned the world. And without affirmativative action we are back to Square One in 2023😓🙏
Forreal we can witness our human rights‘s last breath.
BUT... Mr.Chompsky DID NOT UNDERSTAND & ACCEPT the reality of this situation is: TERRORISTS have climbed to Gaza government /// Israelis DEFEND their DEMOCRACY... fighting AGAINST THE MILLIONS of dollars that HAMAS HAS BEEN RECEIVING from the USA and the UNITED NATION, monthly... for more than a DECADE!!! 😥😥😥
What really matters is freedom and dignity of people who struggle for recognition and acceptance as people of a particular territory.
Free Palestine
52:28 what a great answer from Noam! I've been doing that for over a decade now, it's opened my eyes.
Noam Chomsky is not only a person of honor, and integrity. He is what few men can become.
Here is one man who has become an institution.
And if you don't get vaxxed, you should be put in prison
Also: "safe and effective"
How does this not have 10 million views?
would you believe it's most likely part of controlling narrative. I am just a conspiracy theorists.
Because unfortunately when there’s been a decades long propaganda machine hard at play through western media and Hollywood through film etc, to paint Arabs and Muslims as barbaric terrorists, in order to dehumanize them and continue to get away with facts like the ones in this lecture.. people tend to really not care.. because Palestinians have been painted as the aggressor. But just as with everything.. things done in the dark eventually come to the light and the tide is shifting towards more awareness of the plight of the Palestinians
Simple answer, he's not in line with the war mongers in charge.
Long answer, he's too truthful and shows the hypocrisy that exists in the west.
#FreePalestine
spread the link
Cause .. you tube and facebook are monitoring for and by Zionism…+ the blindness of this generation!!!
The value and greatness of this human being are inconmensurable, not only as a thinker, but also and mainly as a person.
Ne perdez pas votre remps , le genocide sionnise isralien continu a Ghaza. Il faut arreter le maswacre.et les guide par la justice internationalle.. les juifs n'ont pas droit de parole avec leurs actes assassinat clllectif
36:42. He explained Israel’s policy perfectly and we might be seeing it coming to fruition now
My knowledge of the existence of Gideon Levy dates back to the 70s when I was still in high school. We obtained information about him at the time from certain specialist magazines and we could not even benefit from a photo of him to personalize him in the flesh. His articles were widely read and appreciated, and I myself keep graffiti in my memory several articles of him which helped me form a value judgment on the Israeli politics of the time. We were so impressed by his thinking and his courage, because he was the only Israeli capable of denouncing certain racist or criminal acts either by his government or by his fellow citizens. For this he enjoys an exceptional aura and unparalleled respect in both Moroccan intellectual and student circles. But since I had become a print journalist like him, I had begun to harbor certain doubts about his intellectual health; asking me a bunch of questions about its contradictory facets; because how is it possible for a talented journalist; who is at the same time a writer, to accept colonization? to live under the protection of an apartheid regime? to support the daily massacre of Palestinians? to never deny the lie maintained around the expulsion of the Jews from Palestine that another writer has denied with supporting evidence? And not to leave Palestine to save his reputation as required by professional ethics and the ethics of belonging to the family of writers ???
Amy Goodman 💚💚
Professor Noam Chomsky addresses UN council regarding Israel and Palestine.
His comments around 50:00 about how support for Palestine amongst young people in the US was slowly growing were evidently true, support for Palestine right now is higher than it’s ever been.
My left ear enjoyed this lecture.
I thought i was the only felt this way
that was intentional
This man and the moderator lady are beacon of truth in this world of propaganda. Love them from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Amy Goodman is a treasure for sure. Noam Chomsky is a legend, one of the most important people of the 20th and start of the 21st century. Peace to the man.
Well said
So helpful to know that the. Depth of languages..resistance and resilience ,SUMUD! so helpful to look at the strength of young people to stand up and be a part of society. As a jew from South Africa, listening on October 29th, it offers me a way forward.
How great would it be to see a stable and free Palestine it could be such a beautiful world without extremists longing for white superiority..
I think people tend to dogmatize his pronouncements on the more technical aspects of language,but aside from that 🤔, great man!
In any case, language evolves, just as we, and our society evolve. Hopefully, we will come out of this frenzy of societal change with an emphasis on Loving-kindness and compassionate understanding 🙏 💖
Pulled my left earbud out to test the right (but seriously, thanks for sharing this).
It's a shame that even microphones are not listening to Chomsky, he has so much to say.
He could have found a solution to this mess in the region, too bad he's being ignored for decades from the mainstream media, all by design. People could start to think, nobody in power wants that to ever happen.
I thought it was only me
When a country is established based on a religion or ethnicity, the manner in which it behaves….its government’s foreign and domestic policies and actions will, per force, rightly or wrongly, reflect upon that entire religion or ethnicity.
People are irrational.
They don’t distinguish between what a nation’s government does and the citizens of that nation.
For whatever reasons, the leaders of both Israel and the Palestinians have failed to find justice
They want justice for themselves but don’t seem to care enough about the rights of the other.
They can’t get beyond their tribal identities to see others as equally worthy .
There are tremendous pressures to remain intractable on both sides.
And the people…the inhabitants are caught in the middle.
Like people everywhere, they just want peace, security, a measure of prosperity and a chance to live their lives and raise their families in safety.
People become irrational. when they are targets of propaganda.
Easily fired up.
Quick to join mass movements.
Quick to fall into an “us and them” mentality.
I’m dismayed but not surprised to see a rise in anti-semitism after what has happened.
When excited, people discard nuances.
Zionism,like colonialism, and imperialism have consequences.
Not all Americans supported our deeds in Viet Nam.
Not all Arabs or Muslims supported the attack on 9/11.
But Arab Looking Americans were beaten or killed for it.
Not all east Asians are Chinese.
But they were blamed for covid and attacked on the street and their businesses were vandalized and shunned .
Not all Jews support the policies of the Israeli government.
But even they can be targets of pro-Palestinian anger.
People are irrational.
This is the best comment I’ve ever read. Bless you 🙏🏼
Prof Noam Chomsky, Our sincerest thanks and gratitude to you. May God bless you. AMEEN.
thank you very much . 🙏
What a wonderful lecture! We send our thoughts to the people of Palestine and will work towards educating for the future of people to work out diplomatic solutions to their future problems. Thanks very much.
Thank god (if there is one outside of ourselves), for U, Amy Goodman. U are the light bearer in this dark age.
(I pray for u, (just in case), often.😢
This man is like a Prophet , he tells of things in the present and those to come. Fast forward to 2023 - Mowing the grass to another level.
And dear Amy Goodman!
Way ahead of his time
"Lacrou" como dizemos no Brasil ❤
Amazing human being he never gives up standing 🧍♂️ ❤️ 💙 ♥️ 💖 💛 🧍♂️ ❤️ 💙 ♥️ 💖 💛 🧍♀️ ❤️ 💙 ♥️ 💖 💛 🧍♂️ ❤️ 💙 ♥️ for justice may god blessed this man 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢
Let's share this lectures so we can edecate ourselves from reliable information.
So sad, so little justice, and so much injustice, towards the Palestinians.
The UN 🇺🇳 is an American NGO headquartered in the USA 🇺🇸 as a speakers platform, that has no power over the decisions global governments take except to promote business interests internationally to keep the peace, support progress and prosperity for all nations. It’s important to listen to the speakers since many share interesting solutions to global problems. Ideas can promote improvements in global business interests for all citizens.
please like it...
Warm regards to you sir. We praise you again and again!
This Jews Palestinian conflicts were resolved in 1947 by UN approved a 2 states solutions. The Jews took it by hearts and declared a new state Israel . The whole world is still waiting an independent Palestine 🇵🇸 state 😢
The land grab started then, no wonder the Palestinians were not good with the idea, they only could lose.
All led by the UK well before 1947. After WWI it started. Arthur James Balfour helped the zionists, he entertained the idea for many years, after the holocaust the world felt they had to do some good. Look what good that has brought?
They could have gone anywhere else, but hey, their old book of lies said it's their land, what an excuse, why doesn't the world quit believing in such books of lies?
Being asked why people give to beggars but not to philosophers, he said, "Because they think they may one day be lame or blind, but never expect that they will turn to philosophy."
Thanks for organizing the lecture!
thanks to Amy Goodman and Democracy Now!
I work with all.
No matter how smart someone is, Talks won’t make changes in the world or anything else. Actions do!
What Hamas did on October 7th might backfire but at least they took action. Israel was slowly removing the Palestinians as Chomsky described. Hamas’ actions were borne of desperation
The best recourse is for other states to do the same recognition and for UN to implement the established boundaries of the 2 independent states...
How is it that your program never discusses, nor takes up the issue of the persecution of the Igbos in South Eastern Nigeria? What will it take to get "Democracy Now Program" to report to the world what is happening to the Igbos in Nigeria?
@12:05 to roughly @13:08, in October of 2014,NOAM CHOMSKY, simply based upon a ‘preponderance’ of observed behaviors from 1942 to Present Day, told us exactly what would occur in. The ‘run up to October 7, 2023. The USA and its allies within the UNITED NATIONS HAD eight years to broker peace.😱😕🤑🫠
The most lucid mind of his times since the 1960s... One of the few true Homo SAPIENS I've ever read and listened to.
And the world has done nothing for peace. It's all about colonialism, capitalism and geo political acts for the current empire. The old UK one handed the world over to the current one, the USA.
But as the US is falling apart from within (look at the failed house speaker, version 2 happening), who will jump into the void? It's a mess, most of the world have blindly ignored the huge cesspool that is the Zionists takeover of Palestinian lands and their human rights.
There's one change urgently needed in the UN Security Council.
Any permanent member involved in any international conflict, either directly or indirectly, must transfer all the United Nation Security Council resolutions to the UN General assembly.
For instance, not only is America involved in the Israeli war but the British Empire, with his out-posts of Australia and Canada are also involved, making Britain's vote at the Security Council blocked the same as America.
However, everyone gets an equal vote in the General Assembly, making the final UN decision not unfairly stacked against one country in favour of another.
9 yrs ago ! I was thinking what a great job his Barber had done !
Ill be closing now.enjoy your afternoon, ladies xn gentlemen, good night again
❤💓UN
Khaybar khaybar ya yahoud, jaisyu Muhammad saufa ya'ud ☪️☪️☪️
United Nations Palestinian Rights Committee should fix the audio on this!
7:50 Chomsky speech starts
We do have State Media in the US
23:32 "He [Obama] was talking about a lot of other things but not this" - genius underplay from Noam.
Noam Chomsky is great righteous and logical thinker for human beings’ benefits because he stays on the right side of injustices. We wish him a long life from Allah.
9 years later, and everything is EXACTLY the same today as it was then. Sickening
sorry! the resolution of two states for 67 instead of 76.
Allaahummaftahleeabwaabarahmatika
*Muslims don't fear death; they know of a better place in life*
Israel's crime in Gaza and the insane occupation of Palestine for 70 years have put human conscience and honor to the test. So much right and wrong are standing in this disaster. There is no rational or customary reason and argument in choosing the false line, in which all the evil people of the world are present. The false choice is nothing but contempt for human beings, honor, pride and dignity of humanity. Undoubtedly, Gaza is Karbala and the field is the field of choice between dignity or humiliation. Honor or meanness and finally angel or devil Regarding the issue of Gaza, I realized that the choice is not difficult because of the clarity of the truth, but very simple. Undoubtedly, I take the side of the truth and avoid everything that threatens my humanity.
This woman’s voice is so jarring - why does she always shout - shouting shuts down the listener.
Im with you...
or better, this is what I believe
This almost 10 years agoin is in 2014 and still nothing changed in the Palestinian situation!
✅✅👍👍
Regan did a lot of good in international relations. I, and most Australians, were ashamed of Keeting for his recognition of Indonesian I East Timor. Israel SHOULD be dragged into the UN and be FORCED to Answer for their Crimes, including International crimes in Palestine!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ THE AWAKENING...
They never respect Law and order.
*Do Water and Oil interact🤔*
Next US election may hinge upon who stands against the overly generous support of Israel by the US.
Bismillaahiwassalaatu
Don't play dirty politics on innocent civilians of Palestine
1:43:00 a question of anti Semitic relations upon the conflict , defuses it entirely with its own devices
It's a supremacy of Humanitarians honor to hear this kind of freethinkerslike Professor Chomsky ! When i see him,i remember Our Brother Edward D Saïd and so many others like Mahmoud Darwiche Samih AlKacem who were,teenagers Standing in Palestine occupayed and slaped by those who came from their european countries to practice thé same kind of atrocities on Our Palestinian People : Christians,Muslims and Palestinian Arab Jewich communities !?I remember one of m'y professors who told us about Mr Pablo Picasso who was orinting Guernica,this spanish village wich was devastzted by Franco's milichias allied with hitlerian nazis in thé civil War !One of the germans officers told him that his peinting was very interesting ? Picasso replayed to him:"It's yours Idea !?"or something liké this !?Nowadays,thé Ghetto Ghazza looks like Guernica in Big dimensions,but thé same Drama and Violence commited to the nazism ideology !!?
The UN MUST SEND TROOPS TO SUPORT PALISTINE .OR DECLARE IYSSELF REDUNDANT
Why not charge in court of justice those violating or responsible in such violation of said US law...
🙏🙏🤲🤲🤲🤲🤝🤝
انا إنسان عربي لست مثقفا بكلمة المعرفة عالمية غير أن الاستاد نعوم هو آدمي ويتمتع بروح سليمة.اصوت على مبايعته رئيسا للامم المتحدة وما بقي له إلا أن يعين حكومته...ارفع قبعتي لامثاله انه فخر الإنسانية...! هده فطرة الإنسان...والدين....والإيمان . أسرار الكون وخفايا الروح وعلومه سيرة الرسول و اصحابه....حيث ان بيث المقدس له مخرج روايته لقومية فضلها الله تعالى منهم من غضب الله عز وجل عليهم من أفكارهم وأعمالهم وإن اكثرهم لفاسقون ومنهم خير أمة أخرجت للناس تأمن بالله وملائكته ورسالته عبر الأنبياء والرسل واليوم الآخر وتامر بالمعروف وتنهى عن المنكر... الذين أنعم الله تعالى عليهم في الدنيا والآخرة...!!!!وهم غرباء فطوبى للغرباء...!
Watch
Watch this in x2 speed. The man talks so slow that in 2x speed it sounds normal 😂 turn this 2hr video to about 40mins 😂
Your welcome
He is 94 years old 🥴 what do you expect
doing that now
And shortens her 7 1/2 minute introduction
@@donnamattingly5857 your welcome 🤣
Teachers who have long thought and prepared their lessons know they must speak slowly for the comprehension of all
2.5 thousand views only
11K now
@@martinjanecek4950 still, it should be in the millions to be fair, but people are too busy with their lives in the current hell hole the planet is going through.
That has done a serious JUMP after 7.oktober...
52k views interesting how very few cared until recently
Reparations are owed to Palestinians.
*And whaa' is the political social structure on/in the controversial land of Judistric Isreal and it's power structure?🙄* since an amplitude amount of our money is/has been ship dear.*
Being paid by tax deduction is paid partially by the patrons
Wake up world people innocents are butchared and massacred, where is the people of the world.
Why no sound?!!!
یشه ترجمه اش رو بگذارید
Very smart but hard to hear what he says
He denied the bosnian genocide
The major has too, to doo , permission when you are on a job.all your life, what happens when you are debutted, equities personalities are troubled yes " keeping up.updating costs peoples sanity has to do with children, the banks ondly when at work has to do but esp also has there sweet, dealing with the crockles, prople do cook, to creat an impass
7
Allaahummarabbahaathihiddawatittaammatiwaasalaatilqaaimatiaatimuhammadanilwaseelatawalfadheelatawaseelata
I have two questions for philosoph ,hi must to know.
Palestinin its in istorical terytory of Israel (kindom of Israel)? for all of us to know who's agresor.
You talking just of conflict ,this will not have a end.
Who's attached first that its wrong.
Its one more of this situation between Moldova and Russian made a Transnistria autonomie were Moldova has been put face to face with Transnistria but Rusia and there's allys left in background and supart this region this its a international low.,you like isn't?
Like this its a Palestine ,Gaza vs.Israel. Has been made a autonomie in istorical teritory to keep Israel, region in tension for anexation of historical teritory of another country like Israel