Savarkar A Contested Legacy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- In this podcast, we discuss Vikram Sampath's latest book "Savarkar A Contested Legacy". This book covers Veer Savarkar's life from 1924-1966. What were Veer Savarkar's views on caste? What happened with the Hindu Mahasabha as a political outfit? Did Veer Savarkar have a role in Mahatma Gandhi's assassination?
Follow Vikram:
Twitter: @vikramsampath
Book Buying Link: www.amazon.in/...
#Savarkar #Hindutva #Gandhi
---------------------------------------------
Listen to the podcasts on:
SoundCloud: / kushal-mehra-99891819
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple...
Stitcher: www.stitcher.c...
------------------------------------------------------------
Support The Cārvāka Podcast:
Become a Member on RUclips: / the cārvāka podcast
Become a Member on Patreon: / carvaka
UPI: kushalmehra@icici
To buy The Carvaka Podcast Exclusive Merch please visit: kushalmehra.com...
------------------------------------------------------------
Follow Kushal:
Twitter: ku...
Facebook: / kushalmehraofficial
Instagram: www.instagram....
Koo: www.kooapp.com...
Inquiries: kushalmehra.com/
Feedback: kushalmehra81@gmail.com
It was lovely to hear someone sticking his neck out beyond just what is being told to us. I wish Vikram Sampath long life so that he leaves a great legacy of treasure of books that we and our next generations could devour and thrive upon. Carvaka poscast thanks for bringing this podcast on global platform.
Its a shame that sarvarkar and Ambedkar can't come to the same page .
If they formed an alliance we may have a strong hindu reformist movement and hindutva will be far more acceptable .
Well RSS has tried very hard to be associated with Ambedkar.
You are talking in present tense. They are both dead
@@Ganjalivesmatter iam from a Gujarati medium school madam English abhi college ke first year mein hee padni shru ki hai.
Savarkar was never allowed to go out of Ratnagiri till 1937. It was not possible to get political momemtum.
@@AjitJoshi686 Savarkar was a legend , RSS is just a Bramhin organization having many of its 48 permanent members as upper cast and mostly Bramhin. They made 5 Bramhan presidents and one Rajput. Where is equality and opportunity for others (SC , ST , OBC)
First time I'm seeing Vikram Sir since he was hospitalized. Thrilled to se you kicking!
I think we should introduce new curriculum in our country and call it" Relearn History". Amazing podcast !!!
1.09.00 The Konkanastha Brahmin got ghettoised. And stay in very few places, Bhalji Pendharkars studio is burned. Most of them were Congressmen. Like 1984 1948 ahimsa wadi Congressi were involved in mass killings.
Time stamps This podcast turned me from hindu to #iamhindutva .
0:30 - Beginning the podcast.
1:55 - Indian Political landscape during 1920s.
9:20 - What were Vikram's reaction on the movement of modern hindu samaj when he came to know about arya samaj and its connection with hindu mahasabha. (Itne saal kya hum jhak mara rahe tha jahan humko ek dayananda saraswati lag gayi hindu political thought ke modernisation begin karne me)
14:45 - Ambedkar-Savarkar relationship.
19:40 - Savarkar's 7 shackles of Hindu society.
25:45 - Savarkar's conceptual clarity in understanding hindu, hindutva and hinduism in 1920-40s. And we are still stuck in these questions.
30:00 - Kushal - Hum yaha apna narrative/propogonda chalate hai.
37:40 - Kushal don't understand what the hell was happening. The irony of the irony of the narratives. Chacha nehru zindabad.
43:00 - Savarkar on Ambedkar's Buddham Sharnam Gachhami. Vikram on ‘The clash of Civilisations’ and the response of our protagonists. Savarkar's obsession with arming and dearming hindus with the context of contemporary indian army proportions..
57:25 - Father of nation or the constant thron in the flesh of government Assasinated by making him a sitting duck.
1:09:00 - The massacre of Brahmins by the congressi gandhian ahinsavaadi after a murder, an important history lesson which remain unlearnt, repeated itself in 1984.
1:18:15 - Q and A.
1:43:00 - Why Kushal is grateful to Vikram, the ray of hope of meritocracy in the ocean of mediocrity. How students will get the taste of the truth which was never ever studied and analysed after 70 years. How vikram feels and next project.
1:49:35 - The most important quote of the podcast (jisko Savarkar ke bare me janna ho use chipka dena) with vikram closing remarks on podcast and kushal's content.
You have done a service to us
Thanks brother
Thank you sir
😇
Funny thing is that Savarkar's entire work is available on internet. On his memorial website. Yet most of so called hindutvavadis have never bothered to go through dt.
After reading Vikram's book they should go through dt website.
-1:35:00 great observation that nobody attacked cast system more than Savarkar
The Brahmin genocide in Maharashtra (1948) is the prequel of Bengal Genocide (2021)
What relation ??
@@indiancoder8301 whitewashed and state party sponsored
1:51:45 This piece reminds me of one speech of Late Sushma Swarajji where she said something like " We do not accept the definition of secularism where a Hindu has to be ashamed of himself" and when people compared Savarkar and Jinnah this is what I will show it to them.
A well balanced discussion.
A lot of people don’t know how Savarkar chose to end his life in his last days. This would put a lid to the controversy about mercy petitions. He voluntarily gave up food and water, a process called ‘Prayopveshan’, or self sacrifice.
Veer savarkar is one of greatest
Patriot bharamatha ever had
Vikram Sampath had done a seminal service by providing a fact based account of the remarkable man that Savarkar was. Shame on Congressmen for throwing mud on such a great patriot and champion of Hindus. Even Sri Aurobindo had a lot of respect for Savarkar, certainly much more than he had for Gandhi. This is evident from his evening talks recorded by AB Purani.
Always a pleasure to listen to Vikram Ji. We Indians owe you a lot. May the blessing of Saraswati Maa always be over you.
Vikram you are really a Ray of hope among the mediocrity.Thanks Kushal for coining this phrase
I am writing a book on Savarkarji for YUVA scheme. Such a great hero....hats off
What a man!!
What a life!!!
Thank you, Veer Savarkar 🙏🙏
Listening 3rd time this podcast, waiting for book to be delivered. This weekend will be reading this mostly. Actually re read the volume 1 last month.
Read the book. Phenomenal
Great podcast and what a great work by Vikram just like other great books he wrote earlier. He is a prolific writer and orator and such a young person producing such a high quality work. Kudos to you for reintroducing Veer Savarkar to our and next generations to come. Great great work. Keep it up.🙏🙏🙏
Looking forward for Tippu Sultan
I watched this interview after having watched Shekhar Gupta and Barkha Dutts interviews pertaining to the same book. Exactly as I had expected, and exactly as Vikram pointed out, this was indisputably a superior line of question than the typical trash the other two peddled. Well done, Kushal!
So true !
Thanks Kushal and Vikram for this well informed podcast.
Congratulations to Vikram for the much awaited second Volume on Veer Savarkar as the after reading first Volume on Veer Savarkar hunger to know more about him remain unquenched.
Once again thanks to Kushal and keep coming up with splendid well informed discussion.
Cheers!!
We need more n more such true stories on Bharat's history for youth n for future generations, which was hidden from us these many years.. 🙏
Lovely lovely podcast. As usual a great pleasure to listen to Vikram ji. Kushal you were an excellent host and can't wait to get both books in my collection. 🙏🙏🙏to both of you.
Before listening this audio, I bought the Kindle version and reading it now.The answer by Kushal about the book is really interesting
This discussion has certainly kindled my interest in knowing the real Veer Savarkar. So, will buy both the volumes and read. Am astonished at such young writers who do great work in bringing out the real history of our freedom fight. Blessings to Vikram for a healthy, long life.
We, the Bhartiyas, will remain great full to you when entire vision of veer savarkar prooves right & established in our Bharat Desh. I wish you grand early success to your marethon efforts.
जयो ss स्तुते !!
Thank you Kushal and thank you very much Vikram! 🙏
Very commendable discussion. Thanks a lot both of you brothers.
Kushal you need to hire somebody to manage your podcasts and add stuff like RUclips chapters
If you want him to hire you'll have to donate, because this is basically free content and then on top of that he will be out of pocket.
nice to know about savarkar the nationality
If Moderates are called loyalists and extremists are called nationalists then ….1.41.05
01:41:05
Well distributing janew to lower caste is not a original idea of Sarvarkar.
Guru ghasidas of satnami smapradya started to distribute janew to lower caste .
Still in Chattisgarh and Madhyapradesh the satnamis wear janew like Brahmins .
In my hometown a lot of so called "lower caste" wore janeu in Aryakanya Gurukul....all of them girls
Actually anyone getting education should wear a Janau. It is like identity card for school students
@@AjitJoshi686 to be fair dude the history and social reality is quite diffrent.
Reformers like Basavaanna a brahmin himself told his follower to throw their janew as a symbol of opression.
On the other hand Ghasidas who wad from a lower caste encourage everyone to wear janew as a symbol of resistance against oppression.
The texts may have diffrent meaning for janew but in social reality janew was worn by upper caste only.
@@smoky3302 that’s correct. One should not judge past in today’s context
@@AjitJoshi686 I don't care about past that much.
If people are willing to give up jati varna and jati related endogamy iam cool with them.
I only had issues with trads who argue for birth based jati .
I respect reformist hindutva movement and people like Sarvarkar.
Thanks for the interview. It reveals lots truth behind several myths of the past. A glimpse of how beneath a dirty and chaotic socio-politocal disastrous decades, there lies true intellect and wisdom with potential to lift the country back from abyss.
God forbid violence against innocence people. The original varna approach looks better, each trying to achive a higher level from sudra . First time hearing about it, and feels a better approach. Any way feels good, spending time on this study.
A great conversation,
We want Hindi translations of both these Volumes for facilitating wider readership in large part of Bharat.
When can we have Hindi Volumes ?
I have Volume I with me with the Signature of Shri Sampat ji. I want Volume II also now. I to go about it ?
Loved this conversation!
I had many misconceptions about Savarkar. I still have my doubts but if what Vikram Sampath is saying about Savarkar is true (or close to the truth) then I think I am in agreement with Savarkar and his way of thinking.
Hats off to Vikram sir's knowledge
36:40 - 37:44 hmmm mother of all the ironies...
SarvarkAr is a hero
understated hero
Thanks
Do one podcast with Anuj Dhar also on gumnami baba please
Jai Savarkar
Kushal's podcast is THE place to know Savarkar. Savarkar and Kushal seem to have very similar thought process.
Not many people know that when Nehru wrote the names and portfolios of the first Cabinet on a piece of paper and gave it to Mountbatten, Patel’s name was not on it.
Great discussion, known some unknown truth . . Thnq sir 🙏🇮🇳
Savarkar within the CONFINEMENT.
vikram is so gentle, in bure communisto ke aage kaaise khade ho paayenge.God bless him
Jai Shri Ram 🙏🚩
Really enjoyed!...G8 interview!
Maharashtra the land of visionaries
1.53.05 I have read volume 1 and waiting for hard copy of 2 reaching on Friday
Only consolation for me getting low views is that Kushal da gets such ridiculously low views on all his mind blowing videos, interviews.
Even you are like Sham Sharma. No Paytm option to join. Learn something from OpIndia you guys. You keep using GPay only. Not good. Even Sanjay Dixit is on Paytm. You guys are missing out and then complain
Very good work by vikram sir
Read caste history & regional histories before assuming & pondering about caste. False projections only further complicate the matter & there is way more nuanced work which has come out in last few years which goes beyond how people conceived identities {religion as well as caste} before colonial period.
Eg.s of such work would like to read
Caste or jati varna is a BS system to begin with .
And it was opposed by bhakti saints of all regions .
The work of some extreme hindutva wadis suggest that caste was a british creation which is just absolute complete nonsense !
I mean if the hindutva people will rely on such totally false claims, obviously the leftists will snatch the narrative from them!
Many OBC castes were actually the ruling classes and are now claiming backwardness which has complicated this caste issue. But let's face it, dalits or the so called untouchables did not have any social mobility in at least the last 1500 years.
@@RD-pp9ds well neobuddhist are already doing that they are capatalizing on historic caste injustices.
We must learn from sarvarkar and accept that jati varna is a horrible system we came up with but now it's time to move forward .
But trad hindus and some hindutvavadi who belive everything bad is British creation are doing a great disservice to reformist hindutva.
@@smoky3302 We can and should get rid of the current understanding of caste (which is absolutely pathetic), but how would you get rid of Varna? Do you aspire the communist utopia (or dystopia as I understand it) of classless society? We can stop using the term 'varna' for it, but classes will exist. This is where I disagree with Kushal's stance that you can understand Bharatiya shastras without basic Sanskrit knowledge, the whole bogus understanding and clubbing together of Jati and Varna stems from this. The word Varna in Sanskrit LITERALLY means 'some classification you choose and accept'. The word Varna and Varan have the same root (For example, the sentence "Maine iss dhanush ka varan kiya" means I chose and accepted to use this bow). Brahman, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Shudra are VARNAS AND NOT JAATIS. The word Jaati literally means 'an identity by birth' and we can have prajatis as well (sub-jatis, for example prajati of a dog). The whole BS started when we mixed jati and varna, to which the britishers also mixed family occupations during their census and thus the BS of 'Caste' emerged.
Hindi me kiya karo for wider reach 🙏
😊🚩🙏
VIKRAM SIR🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡
Whats the idea behind a 30 sec intro?
1:51:45 Best part
Wonderful
Good video.
Please ask him where's a book with Marathi translation?!!! I haven't yet found the first book part1 with marathi translation :/
👍👍👍👍👍👍
Ambedkar said.I born in Hindu not die a Hindu
👍
🙏
Please share a link to the 100 pages draft constitution mentioned in the discussion.
11:15
50:00
🕉️🚩
💯
25:02💯
39:30
“Manusmriti is that scripture which is most worshipable after Vedas for our Hindu Nation and which from ancient times has become the basis of our culture-customs, thought and practice. This book for centuries has codified the spiritual and divine march of our nation. Even today the rules which are followed by crores of Hindus in their lives and practice are based on Manusmriti. Today Manusmriti is Hindu Law.”
(Savarkar, V. D., ‘Women in Manusmriti’ in Savarkar Samagar, Vol. 4 (Collection of Savarkar’s Writings in Hindi) New Delhi: Prabhat, p. 416.)
Quote him completely. Not pick and choose
Trolling Shekhar
Kushal you must speak in English or Hindi. Don't mix it together.
Hum jante hein Congress ne apne sidhanton ke karan 1925 mein RSS ki taraf se apni ankhen band kar li thee.
Yahan tak Gandhi ki hatya ke baad bhi Nehru nahi chete.
Congress chunavan mein ulaj ke reh gai par RSS lagatar takatwar hoti rahi aur Hindu Rastra ka sapna junta mein pahunchati rahi apana cadre badati rahi.
Bajpei aur Modi ke aane baad usse laga ki time aa gaya hei hindudtav ki rajneeti karne ka.
Problem RSS ke saat ye hei ki woh desh ko nahi samaj pai na hi junta ko.
Uske sare chintak jo agle 50 ya 100 se aage ki sochte hein unki sari ideology ek ret ke Mahal par bani hui hei.
Bharat ki junta itni vibhintaon ke saat RSS ko nahi janti na jan na chahti hei.
BJP ko bahot asani se haraya ja sakta hei aur rajneeti ke hashiye par duakela ja sakta hei par RSS ko nahi kyun ki woh chunav hi nahi ladti.
Haan ye bhi satya hei ki jese Modi ne desh ko 20 saal peeche dhakel diya hei usi tarah RSS ko bhi 1925 ke mukam par pahuncha diya jayega.
Desh aur videshon mein RSS ek grahna pattar sanghthan mana jayega.
Kya ye samvidhan badal sakte hein?
Toh 20th century bhari padi hei jab dictators ne samvidhan badal kar shasan kiya. Akhiri mein woh sab junta ke virodh ke karan dharashahi ho gaye.
Han jab tak RSS khatam nahi hoti bhot se log maare jayenge
Jai Hind.
39:35 This pact is the reason Hindus cannot rise up against the 2 Neighboring muslim nations otherwise the Indian army will go after those Hindus.
Is there a single video where Kushal doesn't mention that He "does not like the caste system" ? What is your obsession with mention this in every single youtube video or podcast?
I think it is waste of efforts to talk about a nonce of history.
No history, No future.
The author is opportunists, earlier he aligned with Congress & got favours, now he wants favours from the present ruling party, do all this drama.
When did he align earlier? Can you clarify the point
Nimma T sikka patte urita irabeku. Swalpa kobbari enne hacchikolli T ge, sari hogabahudu
Sarvarkar was not a hero he was a British stooge he was one of the main culprit behind partition of India.he sow the seed of hatred amoung hindus and Muslims.
We must denounce him his legacy is only of hatred.
Maybe you should watch the previous episode
please read 'thoughts on linguistic states'
Care to read Ambedkar !?
This is how illiterate sounds.. first listen the episode man
Dont be a stupid librandu. Listen to the podcast. And read. Dont just go to your social echochamber and eat up everything that people vomit.