I love how you explain everything detail but not mentioned how mina was messy online and keep blaming jimin every other day thats how mina lost her credibility
At the end, Mina was sensitive and couldn't understand basic things that an idol should do. Jimin was harsh, because ChoA couldn't do anything about Mina plus ChoA had her own issues personally. Mina went on a tyrant of post about Jimin. Saying she brought men to the dorm, on how her father got a delax room in his death (even though Jimin came from a very rich family and her father was very influencal). Dispatch released a 180 minute text sheet about on how Mina actually accepted Jimin apology and many more things of that. Jimin was harsh because Mina didn't do the things that Aoa needed. Like taking 2 vocal practices in her 10 year career. On how mina took a hair transplant over a dance practice of Aoa. Yes Mina has mental health issues, but Jimin had to be harsh (yea she didnt do it in a good way) just because Mins refused to listen. Someone described Mina as a person who has "cotton in their ears" Plus when a photographer worked with them, Mina only got bad words about them but the rest of the Aoa got good things said about them. Mina had try to use Sulli passing as a way to help her. That's why Luna unfollowed her, and many people unfollowed Mina but not Jimin and that could've tell that Mina was in the wrong.
True, mina online activities and constantly changing the stories, make her look less credible, and she couldn't stop blaming jimin every other day and public got tired of it also
I really didn’t understand before , jimin was bully but not really bully also , she was harsh with mina because she was lazy but mina took it too personal, mina brought man in dorm and fck so jimin was right to be harsh
@Serena-Vanderwoodsen dispatch released text message but it didn't help anything because jimin was harsh but jimin was leader and had very big responsibility so she has right to be harsh when your member bring man in dorm and not come to dance practice
There are a few things missing from your video. The issue between Jimin and Mina was complex with one being too harsh and one being, ahem, too sensitive, which can happen when coming from a messed up childhood. Disbatch showed Jimin's attempts to owing up to her mistakes and attempting to repair things with Mina. When Jimin left the public spotlight, Mina went unhinged and posted constantly on Instagram for Jimin to talk to her. Mina was not easy to work with and Jimin lacked the experience and the deft hand to deal with her. And although taking Mina's sensitivity into account was important to keep the group together, it is also Mina's responsibility to manage it. My opinion is that the problem is the public's rush to label good guys and bad guys. When most of the time they're just a bunch of children trying to navigate a stressful environment.
This is really glossing over all the parts which show Mina and all the other issues she was a part of. Like in the dispatch article, there is a quote from Mina which is basically her admitting to lying. There is also the numerous other thing's she randomly alleged happened with wild inconstancy, such as claiming she was Sexually Assaulted by a famous person. hinting it was an idol, but then when she was further pushed about this she backs down and says that people wouldn't know him, which directly contradicted her first story. Then there was the time she went on a show and cried about the violent abuse she encountered by her father, which if you remember was the foundation of Jimin's bullying, that she was insensitive about Mina's Dad's death. I get abusive relationships are complex, but either Mina is lying or taking advantage of the satiation as she see's fit to get more attention. Then there is all the evidence that she was selfish and would avoid working whenever she felt like it, making unreasonable demands and so on, all of which Jimin as the leader was having to reprimand her, which is why there are insensitive text messages, but also why Jimin say's she understands that she may have hurt Mina. There is so much more and Mina definitely ins't mentally well, but these are important to mention when discussing the topic. You do a lot of alluding to Jimin's side of the story but refuse to tell it, and I personally think that is equivalent to misinformation. Most people would come away from this video assuming that Jimin really was the terrible person you even claim she isn't and that Mina is just a victim, when it's actually far more complex adn both girls are victims but also have flaws which caused the drama. Which is pretty obviously Mina's fault
When i first learned about AOA, Mina was my bias but a little while after (a month or two) I learned about the Mina and Jimin situation, I wanted to know more... when I did... I automatically stopped Mina from being my bias. Jimin is innocent!!!
You missed some parts. Mina accused Jimin Jimin first responded with a post saying fiction Then mina came back n started posting more stuff Mina mentioned Jimin apologized to her at jimin's father's funeral before. she felt it wasn't genuine and Jimin had to only feel the same pain to finally understand. Jimin eventually came back n apologized and said she's retiring Mina kept posting against Jimin n mentioned some things about seolhyun That's when I think seolhyun stans started getting mad. Mina started posting mutilation pictures multiple times and ppl got scared but also them n seolhyun stans tried to use that to say mina is crazy and hallucinated or exaggerated everything she said which I think is bigotry. So there was a whole side that wanted mina to be debunked for stupid parasocial reasons.. Mina got into a cheating scandal and that was their aha Dispatch did a report. Ppl who didn't do any research just say mina lied bc of dispatch. Dispatch showed mina and Jimin didn't see eye to eye, that I agree
@lemonaidebey6190 because i think a lot of things happened maybe i missed some parts 🥹🥹🥹but thank you for posting this so people who don't know full story will get the point
I think mina saying Jimin shamed her for trying to see her dad in his last days was damning. That's not being sensitive at all!!! Jimin apologizing and crying to mina at her dad's funeral is also evidence that mina was right on at least some gripes. If mina wants to hold a grudge, that's her business. I hate ppl belittling mina's grievances. Even Jimin felt bad herself. I do wish healing for both
This is a wildly incomplete account of what happened. If you didn't know about this situation beforehand, then you'd never understand how Jimin was able to attempt a comeback in the first place. And the recounting of the Dispatch release is wildly off: that release helped Jimin much more than Mina, but your summarizing made it seem as if it buried Jimin under a bridge.
The situation helped Jimin to some extent, but not completely. Dispatch released text messages that highlighted the complex relationship between the two individuals. While these messages lifted Jimin’s image slightly, they also cast her in a negative light. Some of the texts revealed that Jimin could be harsh at times, but Mina’s perspective was presented more favorably overall. Even now, Jimin hasn’t been fully exonerated, as life doesn’t always offer the perfect resolution we see in fairy tales. Jimin was doing her job, while Mina seemed overly sensitive, often taking things too personally. Looking at the bigger picture, it becomes clear that every side holds its own truth. Jimin may not have intended to bully Mina, but from Mina’s perspective, she suffered mentally due to Jimin’s lack of understanding and sensitivity toward her situation. This shows that in such cases, there can be two truths and two wrongs at the same time.
@@Xiwang希望 The Dispatch releases completely turned the tide towards Jimin's side, coupled with Mina's self-sabotage. Jimin wouldn't be allowed to attempt a comeback if not for a turn in public opinion, especially when it comes to a bullying scandal, which is why she went from going into hiding to competing in shows again. There is nothing for Jimin to be exonerated from because Mina has been shown to be unreliable in her statements not only in regards to Jimin but also toward third parties, and she has consistently shown a propensity to casting blame on others when it doesn't seem to make sense. This tanked Mina's reliability as well as the already present inconsistency in her claims. I think you're understating a bit the negative effects of Mina's own statements in conjunction the Dispatch release. I'm looking at comments when the Dispatch article dropped from various sites, and they strongly favor Jimin over Mina. Even the most sympathetic comments blame the K-pop system rather than bolstering Mina's claims because the Dispatch release contradicts many of her claims.
I love how you explain everything detail but not mentioned how mina was messy online and keep blaming jimin every other day thats how mina lost her credibility
At the end, Mina was sensitive and couldn't understand basic things that an idol should do. Jimin was harsh, because ChoA couldn't do anything about Mina plus ChoA had her own issues personally.
Mina went on a tyrant of post about Jimin. Saying she brought men to the dorm, on how her father got a delax room in his death (even though Jimin came from a very rich family and her father was very influencal).
Dispatch released a 180 minute text sheet about on how Mina actually accepted Jimin apology and many more things of that.
Jimin was harsh because Mina didn't do the things that Aoa needed. Like taking 2 vocal practices in her 10 year career. On how mina took a hair transplant over a dance practice of Aoa.
Yes Mina has mental health issues, but Jimin had to be harsh (yea she didnt do it in a good way) just because Mins refused to listen. Someone described Mina as a person who has "cotton in their ears"
Plus when a photographer worked with them, Mina only got bad words about them but the rest of the Aoa got good things said about them.
Mina had try to use Sulli passing as a way to help her. That's why Luna unfollowed her, and many people unfollowed Mina but not Jimin and that could've tell that Mina was in the wrong.
True, mina online activities and constantly changing the stories, make her look less credible, and she couldn't stop blaming jimin every other day and public got tired of it also
I really didn’t understand before , jimin was bully but not really bully also , she was harsh with mina because she was lazy but mina took it too personal, mina brought man in dorm and fck so jimin was right to be harsh
I agree.
However, Mina is an attention seeker it seems. Imo anyway. I wonder what the truth is with Jimin though.
@Serena-Vanderwoodsen dispatch released text message but it didn't help anything because jimin was harsh but jimin was leader and had very big responsibility so she has right to be harsh when your member bring man in dorm and not come to dance practice
There are a few things missing from your video. The issue between Jimin and Mina was complex with one being too harsh and one being, ahem, too sensitive, which can happen when coming from a messed up childhood. Disbatch showed Jimin's attempts to owing up to her mistakes and attempting to repair things with Mina. When Jimin left the public spotlight, Mina went unhinged and posted constantly on Instagram for Jimin to talk to her. Mina was not easy to work with and Jimin lacked the experience and the deft hand to deal with her. And although taking Mina's sensitivity into account was important to keep the group together, it is also Mina's responsibility to manage it. My opinion is that the problem is the public's rush to label good guys and bad guys. When most of the time they're just a bunch of children trying to navigate a stressful environment.
Still, K-pop fans don't learn from the T- ara,S#arp, Aoa, and many other situations. They still like jumping to conclusions.
This is really glossing over all the parts which show Mina and all the other issues she was a part of. Like in the dispatch article, there is a quote from Mina which is basically her admitting to lying. There is also the numerous other thing's she randomly alleged happened with wild inconstancy, such as claiming she was Sexually Assaulted by a famous person. hinting it was an idol, but then when she was further pushed about this she backs down and says that people wouldn't know him, which directly contradicted her first story. Then there was the time she went on a show and cried about the violent abuse she encountered by her father, which if you remember was the foundation of Jimin's bullying, that she was insensitive about Mina's Dad's death. I get abusive relationships are complex, but either Mina is lying or taking advantage of the satiation as she see's fit to get more attention. Then there is all the evidence that she was selfish and would avoid working whenever she felt like it, making unreasonable demands and so on, all of which Jimin as the leader was having to reprimand her, which is why there are insensitive text messages, but also why Jimin say's she understands that she may have hurt Mina. There is so much more and Mina definitely ins't mentally well, but these are important to mention when discussing the topic. You do a lot of alluding to Jimin's side of the story but refuse to tell it, and I personally think that is equivalent to misinformation. Most people would come away from this video assuming that Jimin really was the terrible person you even claim she isn't and that Mina is just a victim, when it's actually far more complex adn both girls are victims but also have flaws which caused the drama. Which is pretty obviously Mina's fault
When i first learned about AOA, Mina was my bias but a little while after (a month or two) I learned about the Mina and Jimin situation, I wanted to know more... when I did... I automatically stopped Mina from being my bias.
Jimin is innocent!!!
You missed some parts. Mina accused Jimin
Jimin first responded with a post saying fiction
Then mina came back n started posting more stuff
Mina mentioned Jimin apologized to her at jimin's father's funeral before. she felt it wasn't genuine and Jimin had to only feel the same pain to finally understand.
Jimin eventually came back n apologized and said she's retiring
Mina kept posting against Jimin n mentioned some things about seolhyun
That's when I think seolhyun stans started getting mad. Mina started posting mutilation pictures multiple times and ppl got scared but also them n seolhyun stans tried to use that to say mina is crazy and hallucinated or exaggerated everything she said which I think is bigotry.
So there was a whole side that wanted mina to be debunked for stupid parasocial reasons..
Mina got into a cheating scandal and that was their aha
Dispatch did a report. Ppl who didn't do any research just say mina lied bc of dispatch. Dispatch showed mina and Jimin didn't see eye to eye, that I agree
@lemonaidebey6190 because i think a lot of things happened maybe i missed some parts 🥹🥹🥹but thank you for posting this so people who don't know full story will get the point
No problem!
I think mina saying Jimin shamed her for trying to see her dad in his last days was damning. That's not being sensitive at all!!! Jimin apologizing and crying to mina at her dad's funeral is also evidence that mina was right on at least some gripes. If mina wants to hold a grudge, that's her business. I hate ppl belittling mina's grievances. Even Jimin felt bad herself. I do wish healing for both
❤❤❤
This is a wildly incomplete account of what happened. If you didn't know about this situation beforehand, then you'd never understand how Jimin was able to attempt a comeback in the first place. And the recounting of the Dispatch release is wildly off: that release helped Jimin much more than Mina, but your summarizing made it seem as if it buried Jimin under a bridge.
The situation helped Jimin to some extent, but not completely. Dispatch released text messages that highlighted the complex relationship between the two individuals. While these messages lifted Jimin’s image slightly, they also cast her in a negative light. Some of the texts revealed that Jimin could be harsh at times, but Mina’s perspective was presented more favorably overall.
Even now, Jimin hasn’t been fully exonerated, as life doesn’t always offer the perfect resolution we see in fairy tales. Jimin was doing her job, while Mina seemed overly sensitive, often taking things too personally. Looking at the bigger picture, it becomes clear that every side holds its own truth.
Jimin may not have intended to bully Mina, but from Mina’s perspective, she suffered mentally due to Jimin’s lack of understanding and sensitivity toward her situation. This shows that in such cases, there can be two truths and two wrongs at the same time.
@@Xiwang希望 The Dispatch releases completely turned the tide towards Jimin's side, coupled with Mina's self-sabotage. Jimin wouldn't be allowed to attempt a comeback if not for a turn in public opinion, especially when it comes to a bullying scandal, which is why she went from going into hiding to competing in shows again.
There is nothing for Jimin to be exonerated from because Mina has been shown to be unreliable in her statements not only in regards to Jimin but also toward third parties, and she has consistently shown a propensity to casting blame on others when it doesn't seem to make sense. This tanked Mina's reliability as well as the already present inconsistency in her claims.
I think you're understating a bit the negative effects of Mina's own statements in conjunction the Dispatch release. I'm looking at comments when the Dispatch article dropped from various sites, and they strongly favor Jimin over Mina. Even the most sympathetic comments blame the K-pop system rather than bolstering Mina's claims because the Dispatch release contradicts many of her claims.
I wish stupid fans would not harass idols. It's so disgusting