It’s insane how 1 man's idea in a book becomes a whole different universe, that has so many people and events that us humans (knowing it’s all fantasy) still enamored by it. So cool
Handing out butterscotch fudge in a retirement home after taking and hiding all of the inhabitant’s false teeth is nothing but an outright rude thing to do and the fact that you are working there as a caretaker does not make it better at all.
I love the idea that aegon just meant "the king must have 3 dragons." And years and years of telephone has turned the profecy into "you gotta have extra marrital affairs."
I’ve found that most GOOD shows are entertaining until around the end of season 5/start of season 6 when the writers start getting a little wacky with the Storylines and arcs
@@TheMoose126heard that in some podcast, don't remember which one now. Basically the theory was that because of cast commitments, writers changing, people's tastes shifting etc. a series can't go on maintaining the same standard for longer than 5-6 seasons. For me the first 4 seasons of GoT where the best series ive ever watched. Then G.R.R. Martin left as creative advisor, they started veering away from source material.
It makes me think Elia knew what was going on. She knew about the prophecy, that she couldn’t have any more kids, so she gave her blessing. Especially after the tourney
@@NiKiMa023No woman in her right mind would give her 'blessing' to such a thing. Consider it was not so long ago that the Targaryens had to put down a threat from the Blackfyres. The Blackfyres are descended from Daemon Blackfyre who was a bastard son of King Aegon the 'Unworthy' who legitimized all of his bastards on his deathbed The results of this was decades of war against between the Targaryen true borns and the Blackfyres who claimed the Iron Throne was theirs. Against the backdrop of this history of bloodshed between House Targaryen and the bastard offshoot, _you think Elia Martell will give her 'blessing' for Rhaegar to father a bastard who could one day challenge her son Aegon's right to the Iron Throne like the Blackfyres did and still do?_ Where do you people come up with this stuff? Fanfiction?
So you’re saying that Lyanna didn’t want to be with Robert because he wouldn’t be faithful…so she chose to run off with Rhaegar….who was ALREADY MARRIED?! 🤷♀️
I need a Roberts Rebellion show. I want it to start out with Ned in Winterfell as a child. We meet young Lyanna & Benjen and Brandon. Then we follow Ned to the Eyrie when he wards for Jon Arryn and meets Robert. Have that be the first episode and then have it FF to when they are teens and the years before the Rebellion. Theyd be able to include the Mad Kings reign and young Rhaegar and his mother. So much lore they could make shows out of but I just reeeeally want to see this one done someday.
Ned is summoned to Robert's bedchamber where he finds Robert in his cups. A great deal of wine has been spilled on the floor and on Robert's tunic. "What is it Robert?" Ned asks. "Has someone in your family taken ill?""No!!" Robert cried, smashing his goblet on the floor. "Damned draginspawn!!" "The Mad King has slain your father and brother!!"
And then clowned itself by having the prophecy extensively brought up to Rhaenyra from Viserys, and focus on it, and Rhaenyra feeling her role is to ensure the prophecy by being queen, and Alicent believing Aegon is the prince who was promised as per Viseyrs words.Except as we all know the prophecy meant nothing as Arya of all people killed the night king, no targaryen sat on the throne at the time yet the white walkers only bothered the upper north of the North, the southern kingdoms felt nothing, and Dany only ended up murdering the entire city of kings landing, before being killed by Jon who became a pathetic shadow of himself in Season 8 and and refused the throne because he did not want it over and over, being the prince who was promised but not even fulfilling his destiny and ending up just wandering beyond the wall, with nothing accomplished.
@hubertdenise3100 well the biggest,best difference is with House of the Dragon (which truly is only one chapter of Fire and blood book Dance of the Dragons sadly is all they're going to show even having permission to take it to 10 season's maybe more) is that House of the Dragons has a show runner/writer Ryan Condell whom has read Fire and Blood a thousand times plus knows all of the story of Fire and Ice books so if he did all of Fire and Blood then picked up where the idiots left off and started being extremely lazy (as they were lazily writing all through the show) we might would have a great show that would probably have to be atleast 30 season's 20 episodes a season at minimum but why make all that money with some of the most epic story telling of our time.. not to mention the visual effects brought to life! If they were tired then hand it off to someone why destroy it not to mention do most of the characters any justice especially Yuron Greyjoy I mean WTF was that lol.. oh well a sign of the times I guess..
Horrid ending to some of the best storytelling of our time atleast the books anyway.. the two idiots royally messed up what could've been one of or the most epic TV show in history as they had a decent start to the show. But isn't Bran officially a Targaryn now being he is the three eyed raven? Bloodraven? Whom was a Targaryn.. they screwed it up so bad now GRRM can't release the last book in my opinion which he only writes sad endings anyway. There are no happy endings in the books!
It’s simply amazing just how there’s so many twists and turns throughout the history of The Thrones. All the plotting and trickery. It has me hooked! And millions of others
I think it will be told through bran in winds of winter or a dream of spring. At least it will be told if Rhaegar married Lyanna and I hope it will be told whats with Neds true love in dorne.
Ill give you a quick breakdown of what happened. Rhaegar, a sissy femboy went ran off with a real man's woman and got hammered into oblivion when he finally dared to face him in battle. The End.
Lyanna was a selfish cow; she ran off with a married man (with kids!) and let hundreds of thousands of people die when she could have just sent a raven to tell her family she was eloping.
I wouldn't say only selfish more like dumb and easily manipulated This is what happens when you spoil your daughters. We get Lyanna the idiot and Sansa the naive. At least Sansa is learning and I believe she will be a great power in the end, if George ever finishes the series that is.
@@lotusstormzyep, he was selfish too. But it's not just about the affair itself, she was the one who should have let her family know the truth before a war was started in her name.
I would love to see this story on screen, but true to the story and no extras unless it adds to it. Thanks for sharing! This was really educational. I tend to watch your videos when I get confused by the books
I've seen the GOT a few times, but watching this made me realize that Danny's brother would have married her if he didn't need Kal Drogo's army so bad 😆
i want to see an in depth roberts rebellion television adaption so bad. i saw rumors that HOTD might make it all the way to that point *fingers crossed*
Not the seasons of HoTD that are already planned, the Dance of the Dragons is like 100 years before the rebellion, they will probably do the life of Rhaegar which will culminate with the Battle of the Trident at the end of Robert’s Rebellion
@@Cloudy_Jones i think they will make it from the perspective of the Richardt Stark, Ned’s father. Then go onto young Ned and Rowling Reed near the end. Explore the family’s lores with children of the forest. Targareayans without dragons lack lustre. But the Stark family are so intriguing as a collective and highly influential. This is put into my favourites as office play because you know the white document montior is not sexy. 😂
Lyanna had to be one of the worst and stupid characters in GOT. We find out she wasn’t kidnapped so she chose to run away with him. Her action directly caused the deaths of her father and brother and millions of innocents. And all the deaths in GOTs are caused because of this choice
To be fair that's what the show writers wrote for the show. We don't know for sure if that actually happens in the books. The last book basically ended with Jon being stabbed by the nights watch. We don't even know if he will come back in the books because George R.R. Martin has the longest case of writers block known... he's been working on Winds of Winter since 2012! Then there is supposed to be A Dream of Spring for the last book.... 🙄 trust me the book series is amazing but not knowing what will happen drives me nuts...
Rhaegar was addicted ti prophecy. But prophecies had two layers. A legendary prophecy ignored by Rhaegar. When the hammer Smashes the Dragon a new king will be born. All believed they are destined. That was not a solution.
This vid does a good job of describing the reasons behind the rebellion but doesn't do a good job of describing the rebellion itself. It doesn't mention Robert leading three winning battles in a single day. Stannis' defense of Storms End. And the only mention of the battle of the Trident is how Robert defeated Reagar. Only a minute is devoted to Tywin Lannister turning on the Mad King...which was the key to fall of Kings Landing. This video leaves so much out.
Give an example within each scenario that you said he missed. So that it explains information pertinent to the story there's someone couldn't easily piece together with the information that's already given.
4:55 I'm so confused by this for some reason and have no clue what you mean??? Rhaegar is King Aerys 2nd of his name's heir by right of birth. Sounds like you don't even know they are father and son and baby rhaegar is trying to usurp his father(that comes later ;)) but maybe I heard it wrong
You forgot another, Ned went north to call his banners after his dad died. Robert was defeated by Randell Tarlly & he was trapped in a town hiding from Jon Cunnington the kings hand & Rahgars best friend. Robert was saved by Ned so the mad king exiled Jon & stripped of the position of Hand. Much more was left out but these are key factors you left out. Not to mention the mad king wanted the head of the mystery knight of the Harrenhall tournament.
Robert Baratheon Grandmother is Rhaelle Targaryen a Princess of Targaryen Dynasty She married Ormund Baratheon (Grandfather of Robert and Stannis Baratheon) They have a blood of Targaryen
Live action would be awesome but to me something even better would be an adult type animation series much like the spawn series on hbo in the 90s. They could do so much more that way due to budget (battle scenes for example) I just think it would be able to be so so much more detailed and stay truer to what source material there is on this most fascinating arc!!!
This video was released 4 months ago, but I am just watching it, what was cut on minute 34:32 when the narrator was saying that Ned learned from his father and then it seems that it was cut?
As soon as the Targuarians stopped riding dragons, their days were numbered. If I was a Berathion, Stark, or Lannister, I would've made my move as soon as I knew they didn't have dragons anymore.
So many little inaccuracies just drove me nuts. I couldn't get past 5 minutes in. I truly wonder if all the praise comments are bots. The pryomancers make Valyrian fire, and the prophecy says "born amidst salt and fire" now, I guess.
I thought I subbed to you a long time ago… I watched many of your videos and don’t regret it one bit. I made sure I hit the sub button. This was incredibly done. What an amazing video. Where did you get the pictures and the personification (if that’s the correct word) of all these famous Targaryens?!? They’re really beautiful and how I pictured them all these years
@@TheThreeEyedRavenreally cool stuff. If I paid you would you be willing to send me some so that I was able to get them printed out poster size? I’m doing a man cave in 3 parts. One side dedicated to Anakin/Vader, one a mix of the Witcher and LOTR and the biggest side ASOIAF/GOT. Posters of all these incredible pics you made would be an amazing and very welcome addition to it
While I usually despise computer read vid3os, this one wasn't so bad. The voice was so much better than most computer read vid3os. I actually made it to the end. I usually turn videos off right away when videos are read by computers.
Read somewhere that even though Ned was killed in s1 of the show, his name was mentioned at least once in every episode after…obviously the show holds no candle to the books, I just thought that was pretty cool 🤷🏻♀️ With that said, seasons 1-4 were truly HBO’s magnum opus, in my opinion. Which made it all the more heartbreaking when D&D butchered the last 3 seasons of the show. Season 5 was by no means “bad”, but I feel like it was the beginning of the end for the show bc they began abandoning plot points on creating plot holes.
About to start watching, but I feel automatically compelled to believe this is the entire objective account of what happened. You are The Three-Eyed Raven after all.
Always wondered what Lyanna's motivations were to dishonor her house. This gave a little more context with Robert's bastards. He couldn't have loved her that much. Rhaghar must've had mad rizz when he found her during the tourney at harrenhall. Hey baby, you knocked them suckas down! Let me tell you about this prophesy we're about to carry out 😂
@rektz2457 not only with her betrothal to Robert, but eloping and being second wife to Rhaegar. Why did it need to be a secret? Did she not have any sympathy for Elia? Pick me chick.
@NM-iy6dd for sure. He didn't even know her. I wonder if he only paid attention to her when Rhaegar gave her the crown of Winter Roses. Robert was competitive
It astounds me that they're seemingly not even considering the Rebellion for a prequel series... I think the vast majority of us would be ecstatic to see it portrayed on screen
a lot of things could have prevented this starting from rheagal and lyanna and ending with arys who was mad and even the stark father and brother who went to challange the mad king lol then there was varys and little finger and even tywin all plotting on the sidelines it's a combination of many f'ups
I know this might be an unpopular opinion but I think Robert and Lyanna would had gotten along fine if they knew each other better. Everyone keep pointing out Robert faults but we never gave him a benefit of the doubt. Let’s be honest Rhaegar and Lyanna has no business being together one my main problem of the tv show calling it a lie when mad king was still a threat and their so called love led to thousands men to there death all because of prophecy and love ridiculous.
Lyanna didn't love Robert though and she knew that he'd be unfaithful to her. Also, you've highlighted one of the reasons for Roberts Rebellion. Keep in mind, the whole war could have been completely avoided only if Arys handled the love quarrel between Robert, Rhaegar and Lyanna diplomatically, instead of killing Lyanna's father, older brother and the Northern lords and their sons who went to kings Landing with Brandon and Rickard and ordering the executions of Ned and Robert. Your opinion isn't unpopular though and you definitely made some great points, but these are just my opinions on the matter in response. Have a nice day, friend!
Also, I do agree with your thoughts about the TV show calling Robert's Rebellion a war "built on a lie". That was ridiculous. I think Bran Stark said that at the end of season 7 and he was completely wrong like you stated. I mean, Robert had no earthly idea that Lyanna WILLINGLY ran off with Rhaegar to get married. So the fact that he didn't know that and thought that she was abducted means that he didn't start the war on the basis of a lie but rather a misconception...and as I stated before, the war also came to fruition because of several very terrible decisions of King Aerys II Targaryen.
John Arryan had started the war when King had demanded him to bring his protegee’s for execution. This was tyranny. After Ned’s father and older brother was brutally murdered when they wanted to have legal representation as was their rights as lords. Robert lead the pact. But he was just a young lord he needed credible backing and nobility on his side and John Arrayn gave it to him. Lyanna and Bobby B was extra element to the story to give foundations that Bobby B even though he had won he still lost. Martin wrote this in the mindset that fairytales dont exist similar to allegory to greek mythology hereos can still lose and suffer consequences.
I 100% agree with you. Robert and Lyanna are both cut from the same cloth. They both love hunting, riding and fighting and they bought try to escape the feudal obligations placed upon them i.e Lyanna to marry and Robert to be a Lord She never gave him a chance, and you know what I'm not sure he deserved that chance. For someone supposed to be _so in love_ he didn't spend much time wooing her or getting to know her but instead spent his time getting drunk and laid Perhaps it is because they are so very alike that it would never have worked out between them. Weird as it is to say Robert needed a wife like Catelyn to remind him of his duties and Lyanna needed a husband like Ned to keep her on the straight and narrow. Seriously though, I don't think Rhaegar and Lyanna had a single thing in common and Rhaegar only saw Lyanna as a pawn in a cosmic war.
All this doesn’t matter because we still don’t know what happened. We don’t get raegar or lyannas side of the story. Only what other people say about them.
@ 5:34 you mean before the Rebellion not the Conquest. Or is Roberts Rebellion considered a conquest as well? If so there needs to be specifics in place to separate the two.
Based on the artwork. If we ever get a Robert's Rebellion series... Manu Bennett would look exactly like the artwork. Also Henry Cavill would be a great Rhaegar
This content dun ripped my heart ❤️ out! Ayrs must have been Jamie and Cercys pops...and Tyrion was Tywin's! If that don't beat all and make it make sense! #Dag ...that's why The Mad King had Jamie at his side...that was his #babyboy
I always thought, how can Jaime have these beautiful children, knowing obviously that their his, and just fade into the background....hidden....because he grew up that way...hidden. 😔
It's based off the book series A song of ice and fire. Which will more than likely never be completed. The books came out way before the HBO show did, however the writer still has at least 2 more books for the series. HBO writers from season 6 to 8 basically had to write their own material since the book series is not done. There are also lots of side books off the ice and fire history.
I wish this would’ve stuck to just the books. You added a lot of speculation to this as if it was facts. You did do a fantastic job on the video editing though.
@storeylocs2750 This is based off the HBO show A Game of Thrones based off the book series A song of ice and fire. However, the book series is not completed. The HBO show basically from seasons 6 to 8 had to write their own material due to the books not be completed.. that said, we don't know for sure if Jon Snow truly is a Taragaryen because the last book ended with him being stabbed by the nights watch. So I believe he used materials from the books and TV show.
@@storeylocs2750I will say the show does follow the book series pretty well they did cut out a lot of material ( the books are huge). It wasn't till I'd say season 7 through 8 it really went downhill for the show. Remember books aren't done so we really don't know what happens in the end
@@GrimJRS Why can’t it be a spin-off? Besides you having this arbitrary demand that only Sean Bean can be Ned, even though the original show also had another actor who played young Ned.
@@GrimJRS Plenty of people have played Superman besides Henry Caville, who barely gets to actually act as Superman, he just looks good in the costume. Someone else could absolutely play Gandalf and be just as good as Ian McKellan. Also, you are aware that young Ned and Robert are very different people from their older selves, right? Like, people change over the course of decades.
@@GrimJRS Spider-Man, one of the most iconic characters in fiction, has had three different actors in the last 20 years that have all been well received.
If you wish to purchase the books about this story or the official shirts of this channel, please follow this link: linktr.ee/3eyedraven
Great content 3-Eyed Raven! I really hope HBO producers make a movie about Robert's Rebellion 🔥⚔🔥
Why do you use the computer narrator? It’s really clunky.
😮😮😮😮😊😮😮😮😊😊😊😊😮😊😊😮😮😮😮😊@@SSGoatanks
😊😊😊😊
Faxts lol
It’s insane how 1 man's idea in a book becomes a whole different universe, that has so many people and events that us humans (knowing it’s all fantasy) still enamored by it. So cool
You’re insane if you think this is all just fantasy. 🙄🙄
@@TheBerkeleyBeautyNo you're insane
@@TheBerkeleyBeautywot?
Handing
out
butterscotch
fudge
in
a
retirement
home
after
taking
and
hiding
all
of
the
inhabitant’s
false
teeth
is
nothing
but
an
outright
rude
thing
to
do
and
the
fact
that
you
are
working
there
as
a
caretaker
does
not
make
it
better
at
all.
what @@hensolo3262
Do you really think I'm going to watch an hour of Robert's Rebellion? You know I am 😂! Love these stories!
I’m so glad you love them! Enjoy watching!
I could watch 100 of hours of Bobby's afventures
Literally The Greatest Story Ever Told, no doubt in my mind about that one either
You could pass for a Targaryen
Should actually make a spin series about Roberts Rebellion
who else watching this like it’s real history
What do you mean “like it’s real”?
@@NiKiMa023 loll you right.
ITS NOT?
It’s indistinguishable from something you’d see on the history channel by how well it’s put together.
it's not copied from England;
No, that would be wrong
I love the idea that aegon just meant "the king must have 3 dragons." And years and years of telephone has turned the profecy into "you gotta have extra marrital affairs."
I really hope we get Robert’s rebellion series or movie or something… such an epic story it deserves to be told on the screen
They’d manage to ruin it somehow
I’ve found that most GOOD shows are entertaining until around the end of season 5/start of season 6 when the writers start getting a little wacky with the Storylines and arcs
@@TheMoose126heard that in some podcast, don't remember which one now. Basically the theory was that because of cast commitments, writers changing, people's tastes shifting etc. a series can't go on maintaining the same standard for longer than 5-6 seasons. For me the first 4 seasons of GoT where the best series ive ever watched. Then G.R.R. Martin left as creative advisor, they started veering away from source material.
@@TheMoose126 just what I was thinking, They would make her super manly and unlikeable
@@konstantywilczynski8650 well it could go longer, the standard has to increase, but the standard went down because hbo writers had to make stuff up
Bobby B in his Prime was an absolute animal
Uncle Bobby b baby. Uncle Bobby b
Bobby B was George Martin’s version of Henry the 8th. Except he wasn’t a warrior-poet. Just a warrior
His was the king stag
And Bobby B well after his prime was killed by an animal lol
Mark addy was a great Robert
Kind of seems like a double slap to the face. Not only leaving her for another woman, but taking the new woman to the ex's home for their wedding
I thought the same thing. Disrespect at the highest level.
It makes me think Elia knew what was going on. She knew about the prophecy, that she couldn’t have any more kids, so she gave her blessing. Especially after the tourney
@@NiKiMa023No woman in her right mind would give her 'blessing' to such a thing.
Consider it was not so long ago that the Targaryens had to put down a threat from the Blackfyres.
The Blackfyres are descended from Daemon Blackfyre who was a bastard son of King Aegon the 'Unworthy' who legitimized all of his bastards on his deathbed
The results of this was decades of war against between the Targaryen true borns and the Blackfyres who claimed the Iron Throne was theirs.
Against the backdrop of this history of bloodshed between House Targaryen and the bastard offshoot, _you think Elia Martell will give her 'blessing' for Rhaegar to father a bastard who could one day challenge her son Aegon's right to the Iron Throne like the Blackfyres did and still do?_
Where do you people come up with this stuff? Fanfiction?
@@NiKiMa023she didn’t since the knowledge of the prophecy died with rhenyera until aerys I came along
So you’re saying that Lyanna didn’t want to be with Robert because he wouldn’t be faithful…so she chose to run off with Rhaegar….who was ALREADY MARRIED?! 🤷♀️
That's probably what she told people around her, but we know why she chose Rhaegar lol.
@@oRnch199 - 😉
Teenagers can be hypocrites, who knew
Rhaeger had a bigger penis
☕️☕️☕️
Small correction. It was Benjen Stark who received a face full of wine from Lyanna’s cup at the tourney.
Because he laughed at her
I barely know about American History but for Game of Thrones I can give you accurate dates 😂
I need a Roberts Rebellion show. I want it to start out with Ned in Winterfell as a child. We meet young Lyanna & Benjen and Brandon. Then we follow Ned to the Eyrie when he wards for Jon Arryn and meets Robert. Have that be the first episode and then have it FF to when they are teens and the years before the Rebellion. Theyd be able to include the Mad Kings reign and young Rhaegar and his mother. So much lore they could make shows out of but I just reeeeally want to see this one done someday.
Ned is summoned to Robert's bedchamber where he finds Robert in his cups. A great deal of wine has been spilled on the floor and on Robert's tunic. "What is it Robert?" Ned asks. "Has someone in your family taken ill?""No!!" Robert cried, smashing his goblet on the floor. "Damned draginspawn!!" "The Mad King has slain your father and brother!!"
I'd love to see Robert's rebellion either at the end of HotD or as a separate show if only to see the Demon of the Trident squash that femboy Rhaegar.
If they’re smart, this will probably be season 5 of house of dragon.
The Clone wars of Game of Throne it would be insane
You wish shall be granted.
What is ridiculous is that the TV show KNEW of the prophecy and STILL didn’t put a Targaryen on the Iron Throne.
And then clowned itself by having the prophecy extensively brought up to Rhaenyra from Viserys, and focus on it, and Rhaenyra feeling her role is to ensure the prophecy by being queen, and Alicent believing Aegon is the prince who was promised as per Viseyrs words.Except as we all know the prophecy meant nothing as Arya of all people killed the night king, no targaryen sat on the throne at the time yet the white walkers only bothered the upper north of the North, the southern kingdoms felt nothing, and Dany only ended up murdering the entire city of kings landing, before being killed by Jon who became a pathetic shadow of himself in Season 8 and and refused the throne because he did not want it over and over, being the prince who was promised but not even fulfilling his destiny and ending up just wandering beyond the wall, with nothing accomplished.
Well to be honest that family are terrible rulers there few exceptions.
D&D were complete idiots
@hubertdenise3100 well the biggest,best difference is with House of the Dragon (which truly is only one chapter of Fire and blood book Dance of the Dragons sadly is all they're going to show even having permission to take it to 10 season's maybe more) is that House of the Dragons has a show runner/writer Ryan Condell whom has read Fire and Blood a thousand times plus knows all of the story of Fire and Ice books so if he did all of Fire and Blood then picked up where the idiots left off and started being extremely lazy (as they were lazily writing all through the show) we might would have a great show that would probably have to be atleast 30 season's 20 episodes a season at minimum but why make all that money with some of the most epic story telling of our time.. not to mention the visual effects brought to life! If they were tired then hand it off to someone why destroy it not to mention do most of the characters any justice especially Yuron Greyjoy I mean WTF was that lol.. oh well a sign of the times I guess..
Horrid ending to some of the best storytelling of our time atleast the books anyway.. the two idiots royally messed up what could've been one of or the most epic TV show in history as they had a decent start to the show. But isn't Bran officially a Targaryn now being he is the three eyed raven? Bloodraven? Whom was a Targaryn.. they screwed it up so bad now GRRM can't release the last book in my opinion which he only writes sad endings anyway. There are no happy endings in the books!
I would love a miniseries about Robert's Rebellion.
6 two hour episodes
Or a 3-hour movie would be enough.
It’s simply amazing just how there’s so many twists and turns throughout the history of The Thrones. All the plotting and trickery. It has me hooked! And millions of others
I wish we had a series on rhaegar and what truly happened
I think it will be told through bran in winds of winter or a dream of spring. At least it will be told if Rhaegar married Lyanna and I hope it will be told whats with Neds true love in dorne.
Ill give you a quick breakdown of what happened.
Rhaegar, a sissy femboy went ran off with a real man's woman and got hammered into oblivion when he finally dared to face him in battle.
The End.
@@gerardjagroo ROTFL!!!!!!
@@NeurosenkavalierEmilSinclairthem books ain’t getting finished dude
@@BostonsF1nest I know but hope is humans biggest curse
Thanks
Roberts rebellion needs it's own mini series.
Lyanna was a selfish cow; she ran off with a married man (with kids!) and let hundreds of thousands of people die when she could have just sent a raven to tell her family she was eloping.
I wouldn't say only selfish more like dumb and easily manipulated
This is what happens when you spoil your daughters. We get Lyanna the idiot and Sansa the naive.
At least Sansa is learning and I believe she will be a great power in the end, if George ever finishes the series that is.
So the married man with the wife, kids, and duty to the kingdom isn't the selfish cow but the woman HE pursued was? Wild.
@@lotusstormz In this world men do what they can.
It is up to the women to be sensible and strong enough to not to fall for anything.
@@lotusstormzyep, he was selfish too. But it's not just about the affair itself, she was the one who should have let her family know the truth before a war was started in her name.
@@lotusstormzexactly. A girl having to be responsible for the actions, thoughts and deeds of the married man. Wild indeed!
I would love to see this story on screen, but true to the story and no extras unless it adds to it.
Thanks for sharing! This was really educational. I tend to watch your videos when I get confused by the books
Glad you enjoyed it!
i mean this alone is too short for a series, a film or two at most
they would have to add lots of extras to make it a series
This was really well done.. thank you for your hard work in making this video
34:17 "With a more subtle, and equally WALKERS" 🤣🤣 if that was intentional, well then that was masterful editing my friend!
WALKERS
Holy, wow. Thank you so much for this upload and other GOT ones. I love the in-depth explanation.
You're very welcome!
is this story from the same book that brought us GOT@@TheThreeEyedRaven
Absolutely amazing video. You have done a great job summing up this critical backstory
Love your channel!!
man I had no idea there was this much to it. changed my perception of the show completely as i rewatch it!
I know 99%of the details in this video..and yet it's still a great watch ...thanks..great job
Hi, im just watching Game of Thrones for the hundred time 😊😂
Me too lol. Just finished HotD and now I’m on ep 3 season 1. So excited even after watching it many many times.
You’re just like me
Just a hundredth??? Catch up friend 😂
Same 😂
I've seen the GOT a few times, but watching this made me realize that Danny's brother would have married her if he didn't need Kal Drogo's army so bad 😆
i want to see an in depth roberts rebellion television adaption so bad. i saw rumors that HOTD might make it all the way to that point *fingers crossed*
A series would be dope. I’d be stoked with a trilogy film series too
Not the seasons of HoTD that are already planned, the Dance of the Dragons is like 100 years before the rebellion, they will probably do the life of Rhaegar which will culminate with the Battle of the Trident at the end of Robert’s Rebellion
I would love to see a series from the very beginning when the Targaryen's were still in Valeria and made their way over to westeros
@@Cloudy_Jones i think they will make it from the perspective of the Richardt Stark, Ned’s father. Then go onto young Ned and Rowling Reed near the end. Explore the family’s lores with children of the forest. Targareayans without dragons lack lustre. But the Stark family are so intriguing as a collective and highly influential. This is put into my favourites as office play because you know the white document montior is not sexy. 😂
@@idiotaboard5909I'm just trying the help:
The names you're looking for are Rickard Stark and Howland Reed.
Wow! I loved 🥰 this video! All of yr videos are so well done & narration is spot on! ❤😎
Thank you so much! Glad you enjoy them!
Lyanna had to be one of the worst and stupid characters in GOT. We find out she wasn’t kidnapped so she chose to run away with him. Her action directly caused the deaths of her father and brother and millions of innocents. And all the deaths in GOTs are caused because of this choice
To be fair that's what the show writers wrote for the show. We don't know for sure if that actually happens in the books. The last book basically ended with Jon being stabbed by the nights watch. We don't even know if he will come back in the books because George R.R. Martin has the longest case of writers block known... he's been working on Winds of Winter since 2012! Then there is supposed to be A Dream of Spring for the last book.... 🙄 trust me the book series is amazing but not knowing what will happen drives me nuts...
The same way rob lead himself and his mother to death because of his “stupidity”
Kind of like Rob choosing love over duty, Cersei and Jamie and their strange love, etc…. Seems to be a theme
Fu k george rr martin, as a book reader it pissez me off to know he will never finish the books...makes my soul sad
“the things we do for love” - Jamie L.
Rhaegar was addicted ti prophecy. But prophecies had two layers. A legendary prophecy ignored by Rhaegar. When the hammer Smashes the Dragon a new king will be born. All believed they are destined. That was not a solution.
Just look what happened to hard Hugh
This vid does a good job of describing the reasons behind the rebellion but doesn't do a good job of describing the rebellion itself. It doesn't mention Robert leading three winning battles in a single day. Stannis' defense of Storms End. And the only mention of the battle of the Trident is how Robert defeated Reagar. Only a minute is devoted to Tywin Lannister turning on the Mad King...which was the key to fall of Kings Landing. This video leaves so much out.
Give an example within each scenario that you said he missed. So that it explains information pertinent to the story there's someone couldn't easily piece together with the information that's already given.
4:55 I'm so confused by this for some reason and have no clue what you mean??? Rhaegar is King Aerys 2nd of his name's heir by right of birth. Sounds like you don't even know they are father and son and baby rhaegar is trying to usurp his father(that comes later ;)) but maybe I heard it wrong
You forgot another, Ned went north to call his banners after his dad died. Robert was defeated by Randell Tarlly & he was trapped in a town hiding from Jon Cunnington the kings hand & Rahgars best friend. Robert was saved by Ned so the mad king exiled Jon & stripped of the position of Hand. Much more was left out but these are key factors you left out. Not to mention the mad king wanted the head of the mystery knight of the Harrenhall tournament.
Robert Baratheon Grandmother is Rhaelle Targaryen a Princess of Targaryen Dynasty She married Ormund Baratheon (Grandfather of Robert and Stannis Baratheon) They have a blood of Targaryen
And their house is descended from Orys Baratheon bastard brother of Aegon the Conquerer.
hell yea
I really hope we get a live action adaptation of Robert’s Rebellion.
Live action would be awesome but to me something even better would be an adult type animation series much like the spawn series on hbo in the 90s. They could do so much more that way due to budget (battle scenes for example) I just think it would be able to be so so much more detailed and stay truer to what source material there is on this most fascinating arc!!!
@@chrisfarber451 that would be great too!
This video was released 4 months ago, but I am just watching it, what was cut on minute 34:32 when the narrator was saying that Ned learned from his father and then it seems that it was cut?
Awesome video. Its a little all over the place and a bit repetitive but overall very cool
34:51
Why are there random cuts in between....
As soon as the Targuarians stopped riding dragons, their days were numbered. If I was a Berathion, Stark, or Lannister, I would've made my move as soon as I knew they didn't have dragons anymore.
Their was no dire reason to start a war and risk you're titles until the mad king gave all of them a reason.
Rickard didn’t go to kings landing with Brendon he was summoned after Brendon went to the red keep and “come out and die
Sansa said to Jon Snow that the last Stark that was summoned to Kings Landing was roasted, so you are correct.
Brandon did not go with his father to Kings Landing his father was summoned after he was captured and jailed
So many little inaccuracies just drove me nuts. I couldn't get past 5 minutes in. I truly wonder if all the praise comments are bots. The pryomancers make Valyrian fire, and the prophecy says "born amidst salt and fire" now, I guess.
@@wingy200why don't you make your own video instead of whining
@@forcecaptainoverlordsuprem2964 No. Pound sand.
i'm obsessed with these videos. the history feels so real!!
Neds dream about the tower of Joy, after his tussle in kings landing is one of my favorite bits of foreshadowing in literature.
Show I want and need to see on tv ASAP
Is this a bunch of shorter videos put into one? There is a constant repeating of what was said 5 mins prior
FASCINATING ~~!!! Hooked for the entire story. Thank you for sublime information and presentations.
Glad you enjoyed it!
That was fantastic! I honestly didn’t think I could be so riveted. Many thanks.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I thought I subbed to you a long time ago… I watched many of your videos and don’t regret it one bit. I made sure I hit the sub button. This was incredibly done. What an amazing video. Where did you get the pictures and the personification (if that’s the correct word) of all these famous Targaryens?!? They’re really beautiful and how I pictured them all these years
Thanks for subbing! We created the images using AI and Photoshop ☺️
@@TheThreeEyedRavenreally cool stuff. If I paid you would you be willing to send me some so that I was able to get them printed out poster size? I’m doing a man cave in 3 parts. One side dedicated to Anakin/Vader, one a mix of the Witcher and LOTR and the biggest side ASOIAF/GOT. Posters of all these incredible pics you made would be an amazing and very welcome addition to it
@@MichaelMedici61W2nerd heaven!
@@SklLLLYchill man!
@@rccrforeverfrrdfortuneshav9823 nah u chill lol
According to the Mad King his grandkids smelled dornish. So Tyrion would just give Young Griff a good sniff he could clear up his legitimacy.
Personally I think he’s legit. Orrrr a blackfyre. 3 dragons 3 targaryens.
Miscommunication over a woman, ain’t gonna lie, these people back then fell in love very easy and quickly!
Love the video!
The visuals are amazing 👍👍they go hand in hand with the storytelling
Seriously how have we not gotten a stag’s rebellion: a game of thrones prequel?
The people who makes the art should make an animated show. With book proportions.
While I usually despise computer read vid3os, this one wasn't so bad. The voice was so much better than most computer read vid3os. I actually made it to the end. I usually turn videos off right away when videos are read by computers.
Read somewhere that even though Ned was killed in s1 of the show, his name was mentioned at least once in every episode after…obviously the show holds no candle to the books, I just thought that was pretty cool 🤷🏻♀️
With that said, seasons 1-4 were truly HBO’s magnum opus, in my opinion. Which made it all the more heartbreaking when D&D butchered the last 3 seasons of the show. Season 5 was by no means “bad”, but I feel like it was the beginning of the end for the show bc they began abandoning plot points on creating plot holes.
Absolutely fasinating! Discovering this vid by accident and NOW I know thw BAck Story.
What happened at 34:17 and 34:34 ? So much skipped.
You use a automated narrator and IA images? What a content
Fr
So impressed. Definitely helped me tie loose ends together. Thank you.
Great to hear!
About to start watching, but I feel automatically compelled to believe this is the entire objective account of what happened. You are The Three-Eyed Raven after all.
At 49:32 you say that Robert’s banner sigil is a “majestic black crow” on a field of gold. Isn’t it a crowned stag? I’m confused.
A game and a movie must be made for this
Loved it, they MUST do Robert's Rebellion into a show but doesn't look like it will be made any time soon
I love all these AI pictures y’all make for these videos. That’s how u make the pictures of Aegon and stuff correct ?
Also how did u make that video of the tournament at harrenhall? Is that from the shows?
I think it's from House of the Dragon, episode one.@@sirwhodison
@@matro2 ahh ok thanks man
Always wondered what Lyanna's motivations were to dishonor her house. This gave a little more context with Robert's bastards. He couldn't have loved her that much. Rhaghar must've had mad rizz when he found her during the tourney at harrenhall. Hey baby, you knocked them suckas down! Let me tell you about this prophesy we're about to carry out 😂
Lyanna was a disgrace to her house
@rektz2457 not only with her betrothal to Robert, but eloping and being second wife to Rhaegar. Why did it need to be a secret? Did she not have any sympathy for Elia? Pick me chick.
It was always obvious by the way Robert spoke about her, that he was way more into her than she him
@NM-iy6dd for sure. He didn't even know her. I wonder if he only paid attention to her when Rhaegar gave her the crown of Winter Roses. Robert was competitive
from which book Robert rebellion are tell?
Baratheons are just build for wars. What a beast Bobby B was.
It astounds me that they're seemingly not even considering the Rebellion for a prequel series... I think the vast majority of us would be ecstatic to see it portrayed on screen
Where do you get all the footage and pictures for this?
So basically all this death and suffering could have been avoided if Lianna stark was not a home wrecker
a lot of things could have prevented this
starting from rheagal and lyanna and ending with arys who was mad and even the stark father and brother who went to challange the mad king lol
then there was varys and little finger and even tywin all plotting on the sidelines
it's a combination of many f'ups
What is with that editing around 34:30?
Just noticed that and came to the comments
I always thought it odd that they chose to go to Dorne..I mean, were his wife's relatives not there and angry? Did I miss something, lol?
What's with the snap jump mid sentence @34:18?
I wanted to like this video but the repeating the same things over and over again to add time is frustrating and the AI voice over is terrible
I only watched the first 30 minutes cuz this dude repeats the same thing over and over.
I know this might be an unpopular opinion but I think Robert and Lyanna would had gotten along fine if they knew each other better. Everyone keep pointing out Robert faults but we never gave him a benefit of the doubt. Let’s be honest Rhaegar and Lyanna has no business being together one my main problem of the tv show calling it a lie when mad king was still a threat and their so called love led to thousands men to there death all because of prophecy and love ridiculous.
Lyanna didn't love Robert though and she knew that he'd be unfaithful to her.
Also, you've highlighted one of the reasons for Roberts Rebellion. Keep in mind, the whole war could have been completely avoided only if Arys handled the love quarrel between Robert, Rhaegar and Lyanna diplomatically, instead of killing Lyanna's father, older brother and the Northern lords and their sons who went to kings Landing with Brandon and Rickard and ordering the executions of Ned and Robert.
Your opinion isn't unpopular though and you definitely made some great points, but these are just my opinions on the matter in response. Have a nice day, friend!
Also, I do agree with your thoughts about the TV show calling Robert's Rebellion a war "built on a lie". That was ridiculous. I think Bran Stark said that at the end of season 7 and he was completely wrong like you stated.
I mean, Robert had no earthly idea that Lyanna WILLINGLY ran off with Rhaegar to get married. So the fact that he didn't know that and thought that she was abducted means that he didn't start the war on the basis of a lie but rather a misconception...and as I stated before, the war also came to fruition because of several very terrible decisions of King Aerys II Targaryen.
John Arryan had started the war when King had demanded him to bring his protegee’s for execution. This was tyranny. After Ned’s father and older brother was brutally murdered when they wanted to have legal representation as was their rights as lords.
Robert lead the pact. But he was just a young lord he needed credible backing and nobility on his side and John Arrayn gave it to him.
Lyanna and Bobby B was extra element to the story to give foundations that Bobby B even though he had won he still lost. Martin wrote this in the mindset that fairytales dont exist similar to allegory to greek mythology hereos can still lose and suffer consequences.
I 100% agree with you. Robert and Lyanna are both cut from the same cloth.
They both love hunting, riding and fighting and they bought try to escape the feudal obligations placed upon them i.e Lyanna to marry and Robert to be a Lord
She never gave him a chance, and you know what I'm not sure he deserved that chance.
For someone supposed to be _so in love_ he didn't spend much time wooing her or getting to know her but instead spent his time getting drunk and laid
Perhaps it is because they are so very alike that it would never have worked out between them.
Weird as it is to say Robert needed a wife like Catelyn to remind him of his duties and Lyanna needed a husband like Ned to keep her on the straight and narrow.
Seriously though, I don't think Rhaegar and Lyanna had a single thing in common and Rhaegar only saw Lyanna as a pawn in a cosmic war.
All this doesn’t matter because we still don’t know what happened. We don’t get raegar or lyannas side of the story. Only what other people say about them.
simply fantastically made!
Glad you think so!
Weird cuts around the 34 min mark.
Excellent video I really enjoyed it as G OT entertainment.
Glad you enjoyed it
Love A Song of Ice and Fire....I hope we get to read the ending to this masterpiece
This was awesome video thanks
Glad you enjoyed it
Eventually we all know this story will come to HBO, hopefully they are smart enough to tell Rhagar's story in season one.
Crazy how extensive George's fictional historic timeline is. He had to write most of these events before even starting ASOIAF
King Robert was also “Eggs” great grandson too
@ 5:34 you mean before the Rebellion not the Conquest. Or is Roberts Rebellion considered a conquest as well? If so there needs to be specifics in place to separate the two.
Based on the artwork. If we ever get a Robert's Rebellion series... Manu Bennett would look exactly like the artwork. Also Henry Cavill would be a great Rhaegar
Where do all these live images of the Targaryen’s come from? Was there a short film?
Really enjoyed this video ❤
Want to see this as a series
Like the content. The stories are awesome 🎉
Brandon did not go to KL with his father though. Nice video BTW.
Good video thank you
Glad you enjoyed it
Another great depiction.
This content dun ripped my heart ❤️ out! Ayrs must have been Jamie and Cercys pops...and Tyrion was Tywin's! If that don't beat all and make it make sense! #Dag ...that's why The Mad King had Jamie at his side...that was his #babyboy
I always thought, how can Jaime have these beautiful children, knowing obviously that their his, and just fade into the background....hidden....because he grew up that way...hidden. 😔
If this theory is true, the twincest sorta makes sense. Sort of
Where does the info from this come from? A specific book? Also the images and video? I’d love to know
It's based off the book series A song of ice and fire. Which will more than likely never be completed. The books came out way before the HBO show did, however the writer still has at least 2 more books for the series. HBO writers from season 6 to 8 basically had to write their own material since the book series is not done. There are also lots of side books off the ice and fire history.
@@ericabouchard8786 I’ve actually read all the Tues books 2x and they never talk to deeply about this at all
I wish this would’ve stuck to just the books. You added a lot of speculation to this as if it was facts. You did do a fantastic job on the video editing though.
This guy speculates like crazy as if its his job and acts as if its proven incontrovertible fact.
He reminds me of the Order of the Green Hand
Where do you ger all the pictures and illustrations? They're fantastic. Do these stories exist or have you made them up? Im fascinated, thank you.
I make them my self! And I get the stories from the books...
In which book is this information in? I’ve never read a more detailed explanation in the books. I feel like I’m missing some books lol.
@storeylocs2750 This is based off the HBO show A Game of Thrones based off the book series A song of ice and fire. However, the book series is not completed. The HBO show basically from seasons 6 to 8 had to write their own material due to the books not be completed.. that said, we don't know for sure if Jon Snow truly is a Taragaryen because the last book ended with him being stabbed by the nights watch. So I believe he used materials from the books and TV show.
@@storeylocs2750I will say the show does follow the book series pretty well they did cut out a lot of material ( the books are huge). It wasn't till I'd say season 7 through 8 it really went downhill for the show. Remember books aren't done so we really don't know what happens in the end
Apparently they're making a spinoff show about this, but without the original cast it will be bad.
No one else can be those characters.
Why would they bring back the original cast? Sean Bean and Mark Addy are 64 and 59 years old. Ned and Robert are both teenagers during the rebellion.
@@GrimJRS Why can’t it be a spin-off? Besides you having this arbitrary demand that only Sean Bean can be Ned, even though the original show also had another actor who played young Ned.
@@GrimJRS Plenty of people have played Superman besides Henry Caville, who barely gets to actually act as Superman, he just looks good in the costume.
Someone else could absolutely play Gandalf and be just as good as Ian McKellan.
Also, you are aware that young Ned and Robert are very different people from their older selves, right? Like, people change over the course of decades.
@@GrimJRS Why do you keep insisting that different = bad? It’s absurd.
@@GrimJRS Spider-Man, one of the most iconic characters in fiction, has had three different actors in the last 20 years that have all been well received.
Great catch up for me - thanks !