*REAL TALK!* Our Jewish friend here makes the claim that the Torah was given to the Jewish people alone, and whatever the none Jews are worshiping they should continue in that practice. HOWEVER, the Torah clearly says that the Jews were chosen to be a light to the rest of the world (i.e. Their duty was to call the rest of humanity back to God. It was never meant to be a tribal message.) So, how the rabbi here can make the claim that the message of Judaism is for the Jewish people alone is beyond me. This attitude of their (pride) is precisely how the Quran describes them to be, but I'll digress.
i think the answer they have to this questions is such as: "Jews were chosen to be a light to the rest of the world" means that they should be an example for the rest of the world to follow the book given to each particular tribe. Meaning every other tribe should take the jews as a model in how they follow their book. And so each tribe should follow their own particular prophet who was sent to them the same way the jews follow Moses (PBUH) who they believe he was only sent to them.
First and foremost, it is indisputable that the Torah was given exclusively to the Jewish people. It serves as a guide for fulfilling the 613 mitzvot that bind us as Jews. The Torah and the commandments relevant to Jews alone and not meant for the entire world. Secondly, I would like to offer a different perspective on our role as the chosen people. Our duty as the people of Israel is to observe the Torah and its commandments, serving as a living example to those who strive to live in accordance with God's will. This is precisely why God dispersed the Jewish people throughout the world. Throughout history, the Jewish people have been present in every corner of the globe, always open to questions and inquiries about our identity and purpose. Anyone who sincerely sought answers could explore and join us on this spiritual journey. However, the responsibility to seek truth lies with each individual. If you expect someone else to hand you the truth, you will be mistaken. In Hebrew, the word for 'world' is derived from a root meaning 'to conceal.' The truth is hidden in this world, and it requires personal effort and search to discover it. And the nation of Israel was there always for the few people of truth who were searching for truth, and we're still here. It seems you're searching for something specific, expecting us to preach our faith, but no. The truth is found through personal inner exploration, a choice available to all. regardless of race, colour, gender or religion. We don't need to preach about God because our very existence proves it... our unwavering commitment to the one God of Israel, speaks volumes, the nation of Israel is living proof of the existence of God. And as such, it speaks for itself. you only needed to open your eyes and see. There is a comforting prophecy for the future of the Jewish people, as foretold by the Prophet Isaiah, that we will become 'a light unto the nations.' This signifies our universal destiny as teachers of spirituality and morality to the entire world. However, we have not yet reached that stage. It remains a prophecy of what is to come.
I'm just realizing how much philosophy their religion and ideology contains. They remind me of Ashari's and other Muslims that refuse to affirm what Allah ﷻ has affirmed for Himself. Subhan Allah
At the time of Moses,Israelites who accept Torah are true believers At the time of Jesus,Israelites who accept Injeel are true believers At the time of Mohammad,Israelites & Non Israelites who accept Quran are true believers. Peace be upon Moses,Jesus & Mohammad.
Why didn’t you just tell him that “regardless of what has happened in The Jewish history does not mean that they’re above criticism or ridicule just like everyone else is subjected to.
As Salaam Allaykum. Some of these same people argued against God within the same generation of being saved from the Pharoah. So, don't feel worried. Allah guides those whom He wills regardless of their background. Alhumdulillah, there are many Jewish reverts.
**--Ask a Jew--** "We believe that the commandments when followed has worldly benifits also why Jews don't want to share their commandments with gentiles? =>> Why is it OK for gentiles to have pork NOT OK for Jews? Noahide laws don't mention anything about pork. ==>> Why is it ok for jews to take interest/usury from gentiles but NOT ok to take usury from jews? ==>> Is an atheist Jew/Israelite also a 'choosen people' by God? ==>> If idolatry is hated by God why don't Jews stop idol worshippers or preach them not to do that? ==>> If Noahide laws donot mention anything about messiah , are gentiles obliged to follow Messiah when he comes. ..many more conceptual/ethical and moral issues ,
Ameen. But its not the dawah thats needs renewing, its the jews who need to get out their stubbornness, open their ears and listen for once. Deaf dumb and blind. They will not return except those who Allah wishes.
👉 *Chapter 50 Qaf سورة ق - Qaf: Verse 38* وَلَقَدْ خَلَقْنَا السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضَ وَمَا بَيْنَهُمَا فِي سِتَّةِ أَيَّامٍ وَمَا مَسَّنَا مِنْ لُغُوبٍ Indeed, We created the heavens and the earth and everything in between in six Days, and We were not ˹even˺ touched with fatigue. 👉 *Chapter 2 The Cow سورة البقرة - Al-Baqara: Verse 255* اللَّهُ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا هُوَ الْحَيُّ الْقَيُّومُ ۚ لَا تَأْخُذُهُ سِنَةٌ وَلَا نَوْمٌ ۚ لَهُ مَا فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَمَا فِي الْأَرْضِ ۗ مَنْ ذَا الَّذِي يَشْفَعُ عِنْدَهُ إِلَّا بِإِذْنِهِ ۚ يَعْلَمُ مَا بَيْنَ أَيْدِيهِمْ وَمَا خَلْفَهُمْ ۖ وَلَا يُحِيطُونَ بِشَيْءٍ مِنْ عِلْمِهِ إِلَّا بِمَا شَاءَ ۚ وَسِعَ كُرْسِيُّهُ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضَ ۖ وَلَا يَئُودُهُ حِفْظُهُمَا ۚ وَهُوَ الْعَلِيُّ الْعَظِيمُ Allah! There is no god but He,-the Living, the Self-subsisting, Eternal. No slumber can seize Him nor sleep. His are all things in the heavens and on earth. Who is there can intercede in His presence except as He permitteth? He knoweth what (appeareth to His creatures as) before or after or behind them. Nor shall they compass aught of His knowledge except as He willeth. His Throne doth extend over the heavens and the earth, and He feeleth no fatigue in guarding and preserving them for He is the Most High, the Supreme (in glory). 👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 67* وَمَا قَدَرُوا اللَّهَ حَقَّ قَدْرِهِ وَالْأَرْضُ جَمِيعًا قَبْضَتُهُ يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ وَالسَّمَاوَاتُ مَطْوِيَّاتٌ بِيَمِينِهِ ۚ سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ عَمَّا يُشْرِكُونَ They have not shown Allah His proper reverence-when on the Day of Judgment the ˹whole˺ earth will be in His Grip, and the heavens will be rolled up in His Right Hand. Glorified and Exalted is He above what they associate ˹with Him˺! 👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 68* وَنُفِخَ فِي الصُّورِ فَصَعِقَ مَنْ فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَمَنْ فِي الْأَرْضِ إِلَّا مَنْ شَاءَ اللَّهُ ۖ ثُمَّ نُفِخَ فِيهِ أُخْرَىٰ فَإِذَا هُمْ قِيَامٌ يَنْظُرُونَ The Trumpet will be blown and all those in the heavens and all those on the earth will fall dead, except those Allah wills ˹to spare˺. Then it will be blown again and they will rise up at once, looking on ˹in anticipation˺. 👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 69* وَأَشْرَقَتِ الْأَرْضُ بِنُورِ رَبِّهَا وَوُضِعَ الْكِتَابُ وَجِيءَ بِالنَّبِيِّينَ وَالشُّهَدَاءِ وَقُضِيَ بَيْنَهُمْ بِالْحَقِّ وَهُمْ لَا يُظْلَمُونَ The earth will shine with the light of its Lord, the record ˹of deeds˺ will be laid ˹open˺, the prophets and the witnesses will be brought forward-and judgment will be passed on all with fairness. None will be wronged. 👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 70* وَوُفِّيَتْ كُلُّ نَفْسٍ مَا عَمِلَتْ وَهُوَ أَعْلَمُ بِمَا يَفْعَلُونَ And to every soul will be paid in full (the fruit) of its Deeds; and (Allah) knoweth best all that they do.
Allah says in the Quran he is a ahad and samad. There is none like unto him. No man, no animal no jinn. And there is no doubt in the Quran. No contradiction, no ambiguity, no riddles, incoherence. Allah challenged the Arabs to compile a book like it. 1400 years have passed and they couldn't do it. An illiterate man in the desert and how did he know about the water cycle, about the development of a baby, about space and the cosmos, about disease prevention,about the separation of the oceans,about history,about gog and Magog about metal and iron and the way the mountains maintain balance. How was an illiterate unread man able to gain companions who were romans, Persians, turks African when he did not know their language? How could he and his companions memorize an entire book and 1400 years later its still being memorized.
Does their persecution give them amnesty? The truth is the truth, and responding to the topic of "has the Torah been reliably transmitted?" by saying "We have been persecuted! How can you ask us this!" is not appropriate. Interestingly, Br. Abbas and Br. Hashim had a conversation with Josh on Sam Dawah (i believe) where they discuss the accuracy/historicity of the Torah. That tells you all you need to know. I encourage everyone to look it up.
It is always offensive that you Muslims say that we Jews supposedly changed the Torah, while our history is filled with the blood of Jews who gave their lives for it and its integrity. And that is what the Jew (Ahron) was trying to say. We kept the Torah with our lives, we were murdered for it and for its preservation! There are continuous unbroken Torah transmission chains from Moses to us from various Jewish communities... so that kinda prove it..
@hanna319 Actually your own Torah says the jews changed it. Eg Jeramiah. If you feel offendend by the insinuations, then vent it towards your torah. Its a rational and evidenced claim that it is corrupted whereas yours is an emotional unevidenced assertion. Being persercuted doesnt preclude that one died for a false book/doctrine.
You still gotta admit that Jews have been respected in the majority of Muslim ruled lands compared to Christian as Jews were still allowed to practice their religion compared to Christian land that banned their religion and persecuted or exiled them@@joshualeonpearl3724
Discussing with a Jew searching for the truth is easy..Why..because he grew up on knowledge and facts and discussing matters..But the problem is with the Jew, the Muslim, and the Christian who follow their desires, lusts, and the interests of the world and do not think about the consequences of that in the afterlife..I wish this rabbi to reach the truth as the Jews reached it. Many were honest with themselves
How do u know u r good ?? good is not a subjective term that is for us to determine. Allah is then one who chooses what is good and bad and u follow accordingly
5:12 the calim that the Torah we have today is written in the exact same way is unsubstantiated. The way the words are written in the Torah have fundamentally *CHANGED* from archaic to using modern letters. So not the same.
Well it's clear the jews resorted to heavy apologetics to explain that God "rested". It's a sign of corruption, the way the christians have to apologise their trinity.
Bro, no "apologetics" here. Just a lack of understanding. No one says that God rests. And maybe if you watch again and honestly try to understand the Jewish position, you will see it for yourself.
@@hanna319 no man the text is clearly being explained away just as the christians have to fit three in one. Your understanding might be right but the text clearly isn't.
@@frabber321 Brother, first of all, the nature of a text in general is that it is a subject to interpretation. Each person interprets differently. As a Jew, a native Hebrew speaker, I am closest to understanding the Old Testament simply because I read it in the original language - Hebrew. Just as a person who speaks Arabic will be the closest to understanding the Qur'an than a person who does not speak Arabic. I hope you will agree with me that Christians who rely too much on the literal writing of the translated Bible, may get lost in the translation (especially in light of the fact that the translation is wrong) and when the context is ignored and you come from the beginning with a certain bias, you may get everything wrong.
It really does not matter what Muslims or any other people who believe and follow other religions out there because according to Judaism what really counts is the soul. Jewish soul vs non Jewish soul
The Jew who is defending his Torah seems not aware of his scripture (The Lamentation 2:9) saying that the Israelites lamented for losing the Torah when the Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar destroyed the temple of Jerusalem.
The regular Jewish brothers at Speakers Corner (e.g. David, Josh etc) are polite, educated and communicate clearly. The arguments typically used to dismantle Christianity don't apply to these Jews. They are already closer to Islam because they are monotheists and believe in 1 God only. They already accept Tawheed. Their Rambam is comparable to Surah Al-Ikhlas. The Torah is more well preserved than the teachings of Eesa / Jesus / Yeshua, which was totally corrupted by Paul / Saul and the Romans. It's better to highlight what we share in common first with Jews, especially Tawheed, then show what added value Islam brings. It doesn't make sense to keep questioning if they truly are upon Tawheed because they are. They worship the same God worshipped by Abraham and Moses. We need to help them know who was Muhammad SAW, and help them see how his teachings confirm Tawheed.
Don’t be so stupid’ there is nothing wrong in respecting another person beliefs Did Hamza say he BELIEVES in what they believes in ? no he did not That is the whole point of him giving Dawah to them in the first place so they can embrace Islam Rather than behaving like an Armchair computer critic why don’t you come down to speakers corner and show us how it’s done
Here we go again. Brother Hamza has not taken on their belief, he is giving dawah with the best of manners to build rapport and bring people from other religions to the truth.
@@TheSlaveOfAllah1992Stop behaving and asking STUPID Questions The Example you are giving is Extreme the issue is not about respecting Gay Right beliefs Hamza is calling them back to the religion of the one True God Islam Why are you so Stupid not to see this ? Please Whoever sees this message do not respond to this fool All you re doing is looking for Fitna on purpose
This is a stupid argument. I am an American Unitarian Christian. Just because God “ rested” from His creative works, doesn’t mean He went and took a nap. It just means that He completed His project of creation. God declared His creation “good”. After that, there is no way to improve it. He completed His project of creation. He is STILL maintaining the universe.
As nice as your explanation sounds but the reality is it doesn’t say what you are saying at all It says God RESTED it means what it means you then interpret it the way you think it is but it does not say what you are saying 😅
@@hamzaTVNetwork It most certainly does. Do you really think God takes a nap and let's the world spin out of control? What YOU need to worry about is WHY the Quran embraces the false dogma of Eternal Torment which comes from the Roman Catholic church and the Egyptian Book of the Dead. The Quran cannot possibly be from God.
What a nice calm discussion, Raihan is very respectful but his evidence for the Torah being corrupt, against all historical evidence to the contrary, is because the Quran overrides it, what kind of logic is that? Does the Quran say the Torah is corrupt, if so why does he say he respects the Torah,
@@j86485 You must be confused, are you saying you're ignorant of the authors of the Torah and Tenach? Are you also asserting Mohammad refered to a book in the Quran that has no validity?
@@josephking1947 Lol we have scholars, historians and archaeologists that have verified that Muhammad's companions during his life compiled the Quran by putting in writing, which proves its validity. That is something you cannot say the same for Torah and Tanakh which scholars, historians and archaeologists have said as it is just guesswork on who wrote it. Who compiled and put the Torah in writing? It's just unknown authors from different centuries of different Jewish communities that then became canon. How can we know if they're trustworthy if we don't know who they are and their names? Many of the original Jewish text has been destroyed. The oldest surviving manuscript you can find is Dead Sea Scrolls carbon dated from the third century BCE to the first century CE. That only shows parts of the Jewish books. The oldest surviving manuscript of the Quran is the Birmingham manuscript which is carbon dated either around Muhammad's life or shortly after his death.That is exactly the same text as the Qur'an we have now
@@josephking1947 The original Jewish text is not the same we have now, that's my point. We have no evidence to prove the current Jewish text is the same as it was first revealed from a historical point of view and archaeological point of view. The original Jewish original texts have been destroyed due to Jewish persecution, exile, relocations, etc over the centuries which Jewish scholars have even admitted. This is something that's widely known around the world and educated Jews would know this too if you learnt about the history of Judaism
@@j86485 What Torah is Mohammad referring to in the Quran, when the Prophet says the Torah is from Allah, he must of had or of seen a schroll to verify its authenticity, or if Allah is simply telling Mohammed the Torah is from above, your comments would wholly contradict this, are you then saying the Quran is incorrect?
These Jew our cousins, believe that "you scratch m❤y back and I will your's" just stick to what we believe. The❤y will not agree even provided with the evidence Unfortunately !!!
Ask jews Why do they deny 2 noble messengers Eesa a.s and muhammad s.a.w Eesa a.s was a jew like them Muhammad s.a.w was an arab If they say muhammad s.a.w was not from among them Then what about eesa a.s Eesa a.s was a jew
They will say, Jesus proclaim to be God. They got the affirmation from Christian that also proclaim Jesus is God. That is the problem. The truth is, nowhere does Jesus was proclaim he is God in the gospels. 2nd is, they believe Jesus was dead on the cross and messiah should not died before he ascend to the throne of 3rd temple. 3rd is, Jesus was born without father, therefor Jesus born without lineage, while the messiah and future king of the jews would be from David lineage. This is where Islam came to straighten the truth about Jesus : - he never proclaim divinity or as God - he still live, escape from the cross and save and lift up to heaven and will come down back - indeed Jesus is messiah and king of Bani Israel but Quran doesnt specified the criteria, maybe there is but i never hear it from my local scholars
@sadaalmady In Genesis watcher angels had intercourse with human girls and that lead to Giants or Nephils and they used to eat even humans ( Enoch 1,2 and 3). So if it was an angel then Jesus should be a giant or Nephile.
Disbelief of itself does not mean that the disbeliever's belief is true-otherwise Allah shouldn't exist because an atheist is not a Muslim. Islamic 'logic' is very peculiar. shouldn't
I didn’t hear anything career ending? Just that the Jewish fella got emotional at the start and went in to victim mode. Point which I’d like to know is why does the present Judaism ascribe deficiencies to The Almighty, when The Almighty is free from any deficiencies and is perfect in all attributes and works. Why the current version of Judaism if claimed to be true doesn’t propagate the truth to non Jews?, this point for me alone is suspect as the message of truth should be brought to all mankind!
The muslim guy can say whatever he wants but do never forget what happened on the sinai mountain, no religion can claim that entire nation was evident to god speaking to them. Its not 1 or 2 people, entire nation. This could not pass from father to son until this day if it didnt happen...all other prophets beside moses dont have any evidence that they really got god words from god. The story of the jewish people is uncomparable to any other nation. It doesnt make them better, it just means that they have a big responsibily to take care of. The ones that tries to invent new religions just cant accept the fact that god gave the instruction to this world to the jews
Well, as dodgy as it may sound, it doesn't matter what you think bro, no offense The fact is that God gave the Torah to the people of Israel only.... If he wanted it to be the role of the world, he would have given it to the whole world.
Because we respect that there are other belief systems and other ways of life, other ways of finding truth. We dont force our way on anyone. But for anyone who wants to follow the Torah and become a Jew, they are all welcome.
@@ahmedadam8851 brother im neither Christian or muslim im still debating in my own head but this right here proved alot to ME about it all. I am trying to find how Islam is related to the Abraham's faith and I can't see it. And no Paul isn't who is followed if u understand the whole Bible. What the Jews said here confirms everything about Christianity and the plural of God head. Jews were the first Christians.
@flat earth realm the irony of saying to me if I understood the bible hahahahhah with all due respect you sound absolutely clueless. You've just listened to a Muslim and jew debating but some how got from it the plural god head hahahhahaha Neither jew or Muslim believe in such a pagan idea nor does either the torah or quran scripture promote such belief. The idea of the trinity was concocted hundreds of years after jesus. To say you don't see how Islam connects to Abraham but somehow Christianity does is laughable. What did every prophet including jesus preach???? One god, but then you have Christians hundreds of years later talking about a trinity which jesus never spoke about nor mentioned. You said jews were the first Christians, meaning what exactly??? The first Christian Jews believed god was 1, upheld the torah commandments, didn't believe jesus was god and kept all the dietary laws and were circumcised!!!! Non of which Christians do today!!! All of which jesus and the first Christians upheld!!!! Christians on the other don't do any of that! Christians follow paul that's a fact and I'll provide evidence!! Jews and Muslims believe you should be circumcised, jesus and his followers were all circumcised!! Christians don't circumcise cause Paul taught them its the circumcision of the heart that matters 😂😂😂😂 Muslims and Jews slaughter in the same way and Drain blood from the animal which makes it kosher/halaal. Muslims and Jews also don't eat pork. Christians don't do you either cause Paul told them all foods are clean 😂😂😂😂😂 Muslims and Jews believe upholding the law that was given to them and all thou some laws are abrogated the core is the same and that's why Jews themselves believe Muslims will be saved because according to them we are gentiles who follow and uphold the noahide laws!!! Christians don't follow or uphold the laws, Paul taught them they'll be saved because of jesus death and resurrection even though jesus didn't preach such a thing. Jesus fasted, Muslim fast. Jesus prayed to 1 god, Muslims pray to 1 God. Jesus upheld the law, Muslims uphold the law. Jesus eat kosher/halaal and didn't eat pork, Muslim eat kosher/halaal and don't eat pork. Christians follow paul like I said!!! Jesus would absolutely not recognise Christianity which is religion that was made up after him. Even his mother Mary covered her hair in modesty which Christian women don't 😂😂😂😂😂 Here's more evidence if you need that paul was teaching something completely different to the apostles and what jesus believed!! Read Galatians 2:11-14. Paul was reprimanded by James the brother of jesus for teaching people false teachings!!!! What more evidence do you need.
@flat earth realm the irony of saying to me if I understood the bible hahahahhah with all due respect you sound absolutely clueless. You've just listened to a Muslim and jew debating but some how got from it the plural god head hahahhahaha Neither jew or Muslim believe in such a pagan idea nor does either the torah or quran scripture promote such belief. The idea of the trinity was concocted hundreds of years after jesus. To say you don't see how Islam connects to Abraham but somehow Christianity does is laughable. What did every prophet including jesus preach???? One god, but then you have Christians hundreds of years later talking about a trinity which jesus never spoke about nor mentioned. You said jews were the first Christians, meaning what exactly??? The first Christian Jews believed god was 1, upheld the torah commandments, didn't believe jesus was god and kept all the dietary laws and were circumcised!!!! Non of which Christians do today!!! All of which jesus and the first Christians upheld!!!! Christians on the other don't do any of that! Christians follow paul that's a fact and I'll provide evidence!! Jews and Muslims believe you should be circumcised, jesus and his followers were all circumcised!! Christians don't circumcise cause Paul taught them its the circumcision of the heart that matters 😂😂😂😂 Muslims and Jews slaughter in the same way and Drain blood from the animal which makes it kosher/halaal. Muslims and Jews also don't eat pork. Christians don't do you either cause Paul told them all foods are clean 😂😂😂😂😂 Muslims and Jews believe upholding the law that was given to them and all thou some laws are abrogated the core is the same and that's why Jews themselves believe Muslims will be saved because according to them we are gentiles who follow and uphold the noahide laws!!! Christians don't follow or uphold the laws, Paul taught them they'll be saved because of jesus death and resurrection even though jesus didn't preach such a thing. Jesus fasted, Muslim fast. Jesus prayed to 1 god, Muslims pray to 1 God. Jesus upheld the law, Muslims uphold the law. Jesus eat kosher/halaal and didn't eat pork, Muslim eat kosher/halaal and don't eat pork. Christians follow paul like I said!!! Jesus would absolutely not recognise Christianity which is religion that was made up after him. Even his mother Mary covered her hair in modesty which Christian women don't 😂😂😂😂😂 Here's more evidence if you need that paul was teaching something completely different to the apostles and what jesus believed!! Read Galatians 2:11-14. Paul was reprimanded by James the brother of jesus for teaching people false teachings!!!! What more evidence do you need.
29:50 he well known, remember he get bit trigger in the middle, in simple text "dont mind our book" and the he describe muslim, who's believe on muhammad pbuh, they are jews, they have their religion, book and so on. We are muslim could not be muslim if we dont believe of the existenz of the whole 25 prophet. we tough not to make distinction between them. we love and respect them All as messanger of Allah. You could imagine if you said "falsely" something bad about my brother. you gonna fill my oshoes 🤭 We are muslim love them all more than our mother. and you make story about them? 🤣🤣🤣 Alhamdulillah we are not allowed to use our shoes, lips insya Allah ok, in a good way 🤭
Sorry but this discussion was worthless, shamsi dismantled this guy in a couple of minutes. These brothers should stop being so apologetic and call this man to tawheed.
Is not truth, yemen jeweish speaks the real Hebrew, the modern Hebrew that he speaking they change it because they don't want Arabs to understand them, while yemen jeweish speaks the real Hebrew, and Yemeni the can understand it.
Nonsense bro, as a descendant of Yemenite Jews from my mother side, the Hebrew pronunciation of Yemenite Jews is the most accurate. And it was not mostly used for speaking Hebrew, which hardly existed then, but mainly for liturgical needs and during Torah study. Among themselves they spoke Yemenite-Jewish which is a dialect of Jewish Arabic spoken by Yemenite Jews. My grandparents from Yemen speak this language by the way. Modern Hebrew (which we all speak) is largely based on biblical Hebrew, with many similarities in grammar, syntax, and vocabulary. The core structure and essence of the language have been preserved throughout history. While there are new words introduced to accommodate modern concepts and advancements in technology, the fundamental understanding of the Torah written in biblical Hebrew remains intact. I can literally understand the Torah (biblical Hebrew) 100% The Yemenite language has nothing to do with Hebrew. stop making things up
Straight & simple. If you are human then UNDERSTAND AS HUMAN . This jew is trying to mystify & reach where he cannot by saying ' But we don't know whts happening up there ' ?! If course you CANNOT KNOW ! But as God wants us to understand .... understand that much ! Angry means angry. Rest means rest ! Period. Infact it is this trait among most jews......trying to get into God's head that led them to rebellion & stupidity for which they were repeatedly punished .
If Torah, Gods word has changed, it means God is changeable and thus not ALL POWERFUL. PERIOD!! Because Torah was ETERNAL word of God, and if God's words can be changed, it means God can be changed lol. Btw Uthman burned hundreds of qurans lol.
![Gunna - HIM ALL ALONG [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HiCxoDeo0hc/mqdefault.jpg)
brother raihan hamza is a well Educated individual with a very calm manner god bless u my brother
Yes education from the devil
According to the Bible god rests, forgets and regrets, orders a genocide i am sorry no insults but it is too much
*REAL TALK!*
Our Jewish friend here makes the claim that the Torah was given to the Jewish people alone, and whatever the none Jews are worshiping they should continue in that practice. HOWEVER, the Torah clearly says that the Jews were chosen to be a light to the rest of the world (i.e. Their duty was to call the rest of humanity back to God. It was never meant to be a tribal message.) So, how the rabbi here can make the claim that the message of Judaism is for the Jewish people alone is beyond me. This attitude of their (pride) is precisely how the Quran describes them to be, but I'll digress.
Thank you for that I was thinking the same exact thing it is amazing how wrong he was .
i think the answer they have to this questions is such as:
"Jews were chosen to be a light to the rest of the world" means that they should be an example for the rest of the world to follow the book given to each particular tribe. Meaning every other tribe should take the jews as a model in how they follow their book. And so each tribe should follow their own particular prophet who was sent to them the same way the jews follow Moses (PBUH) who they believe he was only sent to them.
First and foremost, it is indisputable that the Torah was given exclusively to the Jewish people. It serves as a guide for fulfilling the 613 mitzvot that bind us as Jews. The Torah and the commandments relevant to Jews alone and not meant for the entire world.
Secondly, I would like to offer a different perspective on our role as the chosen people. Our duty as the people of Israel is to observe the Torah and its commandments, serving as a living example to those who strive to live in accordance with God's will. This is precisely why God dispersed the Jewish people throughout the world.
Throughout history, the Jewish people have been present in every corner of the globe, always open to questions and inquiries about our identity and purpose. Anyone who sincerely sought answers could explore and join us on this spiritual journey. However, the responsibility to seek truth lies with each individual. If you expect someone else to hand you the truth, you will be mistaken. In Hebrew, the word for 'world' is derived from a root meaning 'to conceal.' The truth is hidden in this world, and it requires personal effort and search to discover it.
And the nation of Israel was there always for the few people of truth who were searching for truth, and we're still here.
It seems you're searching for something specific, expecting us to preach our faith, but no. The truth is found through personal inner exploration, a choice available to all. regardless of race, colour, gender or religion.
We don't need to preach about God because our very existence proves it... our unwavering commitment to the one God of Israel, speaks volumes, the nation of Israel is living proof of the existence of God. And as such, it speaks for itself. you only needed to open your eyes and see.
There is a comforting prophecy for the future of the Jewish people, as foretold by the Prophet Isaiah, that we will become 'a light unto the nations.' This signifies our universal destiny as teachers of spirituality and morality to the entire world. However, we have not yet reached that stage. It remains a prophecy of what is to come.
@@hanna319 No-one sees Israel as a proof of the existence of god. Ask 100 people only one might agree with you.
@@hoshszn4736 I see it. and if you look deeper, you'll see it too
MashAllah this brother is so eloquent. May Allah all mighty bless him with more and more eloquent in his speech amman.
Really love those discussions with the Jews may Allah guide them
Ameen
Jew-WISH that they were the real Israelite people
i guides us for more than 4000 years
Jews follow the Torah and don't need Islamic guide. Jews don't follow Allah they follow the G-d of Avraham
May Allah Guide them to Islam the True religion of God
Ameen
Judaism and the Torah are the true book.
Alhamdulillah, may Allah SWT guide them to the straight path and give them hidayah.
Challenging Torah and believes . It is sacrosanct .
On 7th day, it is celebrated on 7th heaven . It is not like slumber.
I'm just realizing how much philosophy their religion and ideology contains. They remind me of Ashari's and other Muslims that refuse to affirm what Allah ﷻ has affirmed for Himself. Subhan Allah
May Allah guide jews Christian and all World non muslim🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻... ⚔️⚔️⚔️⚔️⚔️⚔️⚔️⚔️Allah hu akbar💚💚💚💚💚💚💚💚
Ameen
At the time of Moses,Israelites who accept Torah are true believers
At the time of Jesus,Israelites who accept Injeel are true believers
At the time of Mohammad,Israelites & Non Israelites who accept Quran are true believers.
Peace be upon Moses,Jesus & Mohammad.
Peace be upon them all.
That Jacobite waffles too much. Why does anybody bother talking to him?
Why didn’t you just tell him that “regardless of what has happened in The Jewish history does not mean that they’re above criticism or ridicule just like everyone else is subjected to.
Exactly 💯
Subhanallah Alhamdulillah Allah-u-akbar.
I think there has to be a more effective form of Dawah to Jews that we have yet to discover... May Allah guide us all
As Salaam Allaykum. Some of these same people argued against God within the same generation of being saved from the Pharoah. So, don't feel worried. Allah guides those whom He wills regardless of their background. Alhumdulillah, there are many Jewish reverts.
**--Ask a Jew--**
"We believe that the commandments when followed has worldly benifits also why Jews don't want to share their commandments with gentiles?
=>> Why is it OK for gentiles to have pork NOT OK for Jews? Noahide laws don't mention anything about pork.
==>> Why is it ok for jews to take interest/usury from gentiles but NOT ok to take usury from jews?
==>> Is an atheist Jew/Israelite also a 'choosen people' by God?
==>> If idolatry is hated by God why don't Jews stop idol worshippers or preach them not to do that?
==>> If Noahide laws donot mention anything about messiah , are gentiles obliged to follow Messiah when he comes.
..many more conceptual/ethical and moral issues ,
Ameen. But its not the dawah thats needs renewing, its the jews who need to get out their stubbornness, open their ears and listen for once. Deaf dumb and blind. They will not return except those who Allah wishes.
@@sunUK20 Rather than discussing historical evidences of Torah's correctness, we can expose them on moral and ethical grounds as I mentioned above .
they will close their ears and refuse to listen until the day of yawm al qiyamah
Beautiful dawah ma shaa Allah tabarak'Allah
Thank you Dan
👉 *Chapter 50 Qaf سورة ق - Qaf: Verse 38*
وَلَقَدْ خَلَقْنَا السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضَ وَمَا بَيْنَهُمَا فِي سِتَّةِ أَيَّامٍ وَمَا مَسَّنَا مِنْ لُغُوبٍ
Indeed, We created the heavens and the earth and everything in between in six Days, and We were not ˹even˺ touched with fatigue.
👉 *Chapter 2 The Cow سورة البقرة - Al-Baqara: Verse 255*
اللَّهُ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا هُوَ الْحَيُّ الْقَيُّومُ ۚ لَا تَأْخُذُهُ سِنَةٌ وَلَا نَوْمٌ ۚ لَهُ مَا فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَمَا فِي الْأَرْضِ ۗ مَنْ ذَا الَّذِي يَشْفَعُ عِنْدَهُ إِلَّا بِإِذْنِهِ ۚ يَعْلَمُ مَا بَيْنَ أَيْدِيهِمْ وَمَا خَلْفَهُمْ ۖ وَلَا يُحِيطُونَ بِشَيْءٍ مِنْ عِلْمِهِ إِلَّا بِمَا شَاءَ ۚ وَسِعَ كُرْسِيُّهُ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضَ ۖ وَلَا يَئُودُهُ حِفْظُهُمَا ۚ وَهُوَ الْعَلِيُّ الْعَظِيمُ
Allah! There is no god but He,-the Living, the Self-subsisting, Eternal. No slumber can seize Him nor sleep. His are all things in the heavens and on earth. Who is there can intercede in His presence except as He permitteth? He knoweth what (appeareth to His creatures as) before or after or behind them. Nor shall they compass aught of His knowledge except as He willeth. His Throne doth extend over the heavens and the earth, and He feeleth no fatigue in guarding and preserving them for He is the Most High, the Supreme (in glory).
👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 67*
وَمَا قَدَرُوا اللَّهَ حَقَّ قَدْرِهِ وَالْأَرْضُ جَمِيعًا قَبْضَتُهُ يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ وَالسَّمَاوَاتُ مَطْوِيَّاتٌ بِيَمِينِهِ ۚ سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ عَمَّا يُشْرِكُونَ
They have not shown Allah His proper reverence-when on the Day of Judgment the ˹whole˺ earth will be in His Grip, and the heavens will be rolled up in His Right Hand. Glorified and Exalted is He above what they associate ˹with Him˺!
👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 68*
وَنُفِخَ فِي الصُّورِ فَصَعِقَ مَنْ فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَمَنْ فِي الْأَرْضِ إِلَّا مَنْ شَاءَ اللَّهُ ۖ ثُمَّ نُفِخَ فِيهِ أُخْرَىٰ فَإِذَا هُمْ قِيَامٌ يَنْظُرُونَ
The Trumpet will be blown and all those in the heavens and all those on the earth will fall dead, except those Allah wills ˹to spare˺. Then it will be blown again and they will rise up at once, looking on ˹in anticipation˺.
👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 69*
وَأَشْرَقَتِ الْأَرْضُ بِنُورِ رَبِّهَا وَوُضِعَ الْكِتَابُ وَجِيءَ بِالنَّبِيِّينَ وَالشُّهَدَاءِ وَقُضِيَ بَيْنَهُمْ بِالْحَقِّ وَهُمْ لَا يُظْلَمُونَ
The earth will shine with the light of its Lord, the record ˹of deeds˺ will be laid ˹open˺, the prophets and the witnesses will be brought forward-and judgment will be passed on all with fairness. None will be wronged.
👉 *Chapter 39 The Troops سورة الزمر - Az-Zumar: Verse 70*
وَوُفِّيَتْ كُلُّ نَفْسٍ مَا عَمِلَتْ وَهُوَ أَعْلَمُ بِمَا يَفْعَلُونَ
And to every soul will be paid in full (the fruit) of its Deeds; and (Allah) knoweth best all that they do.
Allah says in the Quran he is a ahad and samad. There is none like unto him. No man, no animal no jinn. And there is no doubt in the Quran. No contradiction, no ambiguity, no riddles, incoherence. Allah challenged the Arabs to compile a book like it. 1400 years have passed and they couldn't do it. An illiterate man in the desert and how did he know about the water cycle, about the development of a baby, about space and the cosmos, about disease prevention,about the separation of the oceans,about history,about gog and Magog about metal and iron and the way the mountains maintain balance. How was an illiterate unread man able to gain companions who were romans, Persians, turks African when he did not know their language? How could he and his companions memorize an entire book and 1400 years later its still being memorized.
Well said brother
Brother Hamza machallah is great to listen to him... Very humble and knowledgeable
Does their persecution give them amnesty? The truth is the truth, and responding to the topic of "has the Torah been reliably transmitted?" by saying "We have been persecuted! How can you ask us this!" is not appropriate.
Interestingly, Br. Abbas and Br. Hashim had a conversation with Josh on Sam Dawah (i believe) where they discuss the accuracy/historicity of the Torah. That tells you all you need to know. I encourage everyone to look it up.
It is always offensive that you Muslims say that we Jews supposedly changed the Torah, while our history is filled with the blood of Jews who gave their lives for it and its integrity. And that is what the Jew (Ahron) was trying to say. We kept the Torah with our lives, we were murdered for it and for its preservation!
There are continuous unbroken Torah transmission chains from Moses to us from various Jewish communities... so that kinda prove it..
You don't even know the authors of the Jewish books nor can reliably get a chain of narration from these authors@@hanna319
@hanna319 Actually your own Torah says the jews changed it. Eg Jeramiah.
If you feel offendend by the insinuations, then vent it towards your torah. Its a rational and evidenced claim that it is corrupted whereas yours is an emotional unevidenced assertion. Being persercuted doesnt preclude that one died for a false book/doctrine.
Living a place or certain location millions years doesn't mean what u believe is correct
أَفَتَطْمَعُونَ أَن يُؤْمِنُوا لَكُمْ وَقَدْ كَانَ فَرِيقٌ مِّنْهُمْ يَسْمَعُونَ كَلَامَ اللَّهِ ثُمَّ يُحَرِّفُونَهُ مِن بَعْدِ مَا عَقَلُوهُ وَهُمْ يَعْلَمُونَ
May Allah Guide this Jews this life is only 130 at most so May Allah guide the sincere
At 6:20...so, talk about the ERRORS & CONTRADICTIONS in the TORAH
Except Iraq there has been no atrocities done by Muslims to Jews. They flourished on Arab lands and Morish Spain. Period.
Ever heard of the Farhud? Ever hear of Dawud Pasha?
lol is that a joke?
You still gotta admit that Jews have been respected in the majority of Muslim ruled lands compared to Christian as Jews were still allowed to practice their religion compared to Christian land that banned their religion and persecuted or exiled them@@joshualeonpearl3724
Discussing with a Jew searching for the truth is easy..Why..because he grew up on knowledge and facts and discussing matters..But the problem is with the Jew, the Muslim, and the Christian who follow their desires, lusts, and the interests of the world and do not think about the consequences of that in the afterlife..I wish this rabbi to reach the truth as the Jews reached it. Many were honest with themselves
All Humans & Angels created By God 's willing ..
All we have to be a good Human.
This is the purpose of life .
How do u know u r good ??
good is not a subjective term that is for us to determine. Allah is then one who chooses what is good and bad and u follow accordingly
@@gsxii1292 Did I Said in my Comment " i m a good person " ?????????????
Are y mad ?
I love to see a smart Jew actually educate these Muslims, Muslims cant letcure us on Judaism sorry to break it to you guys
They slipped away as per usual
Who ever is in charge of the camera needs to be sacked, terrible angle, all you can see is heads
What more do you want to see 💀
5:12 the calim that the Torah we have today is written in the exact same way is unsubstantiated. The way the words are written in the Torah have fundamentally *CHANGED* from archaic to using modern letters. So not the same.
Well it's clear the jews resorted to heavy apologetics to explain that God "rested". It's a sign of corruption, the way the christians have to apologise their trinity.
Bro, no "apologetics" here. Just a lack of understanding.
No one says that God rests. And maybe if you watch again and honestly try to understand the Jewish position, you will see it for yourself.
@@hanna319 no man the text is clearly being explained away just as the christians have to fit three in one. Your understanding might be right but the text clearly isn't.
@@frabber321 Brother, first of all, the nature of a text in general is that it is a subject to interpretation. Each person interprets differently.
As a Jew, a native Hebrew speaker, I am closest to understanding the Old Testament simply because I read it in the original language - Hebrew. Just as a person who speaks Arabic will be the closest to understanding the Qur'an than a person who does not speak Arabic.
I hope you will agree with me that Christians who rely too much on the literal writing of the translated Bible, may get lost in the translation (especially in light of the fact that the translation is wrong) and when the context is ignored and you come from the beginning with a certain bias, you may get everything wrong.
They’re not the Israelites of the Bible 🙄
Neither are those west Africans who are from nigeria Ghana or even Jamaica lol
@@squidguard1 The trans Atlantic slaves fit the curse. Tell me who else fits it?
@@squidguard1 Literally lmao.
@@She_iswise Kochba Revolt. You were kangz though.
@@She_iswise The Jews
It really does not matter what Muslims or any other people who believe and follow other religions out there because according to Judaism what really counts is the soul. Jewish soul vs non Jewish soul
The Jew who is defending his Torah seems not aware of his scripture (The Lamentation 2:9) saying that the Israelites lamented for losing the Torah when the Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar destroyed the temple of Jerusalem.
Torah comes from the word to teach, in CONTEXT it means there is no TEACHER to teach..
27:22 he should change his shampoo
Zo moet het met elkaar in gesprek.
Damn these Khazarian yehudi 🤨
What makes you think that they are a Turkic people?
The regular Jewish brothers at Speakers Corner (e.g. David, Josh etc) are polite, educated and communicate clearly. The arguments typically used to dismantle Christianity don't apply to these Jews. They are already closer to Islam because they are monotheists and believe in 1 God only. They already accept Tawheed. Their Rambam is comparable to Surah Al-Ikhlas. The Torah is more well preserved than the teachings of Eesa / Jesus / Yeshua, which was totally corrupted by Paul / Saul and the Romans. It's better to highlight what we share in common first with Jews, especially Tawheed, then show what added value Islam brings. It doesn't make sense to keep questioning if they truly are upon Tawheed because they are. They worship the same God worshipped by Abraham and Moses. We need to help them know who was Muhammad SAW, and help them see how his teachings confirm Tawheed.
Stop using insulting titles to jews and trinitarians..
Be humble when you beat them in debate...
Form your own channel and take your advice
Christians, 3 is actually 1.
Jews, 1 is not 1.
Bonkers
Jews: 1 is not a number
Why do they always play the victim card?
This brother needs da'wah himself. We don't respect their beliefs. We don't disrespect either.
Don’t be so stupid’ there is nothing wrong in respecting another person beliefs
Did Hamza say he BELIEVES in what they believes in ? no he did not
That is the whole point of him giving Dawah to them in the first place so they can embrace Islam
Rather than behaving like an Armchair computer critic why don’t you come down to speakers corner and show us how it’s done
Here we go again. Brother Hamza has not taken on their belief, he is giving dawah with the best of manners to build rapport and bring people from other religions to the truth.
Brother hamza does not need dawah, he has been giving dawah since 2006, and is very well respected in the park
@@jama-jay8154 Would you respect a gay couple's belief, they believe that Allah gave them the wrong body? Yes or no.
@@TheSlaveOfAllah1992Stop behaving and asking STUPID Questions
The Example you are giving is Extreme the issue is not about respecting Gay Right beliefs
Hamza is calling them back to the religion of the one True God Islam
Why are you so Stupid not to see this ? Please Whoever sees this message do not respond to this fool
All you re doing is looking for Fitna on purpose
This is a stupid argument. I am an American Unitarian Christian. Just because God “ rested” from His creative works, doesn’t mean He went and took a nap. It just means that He completed His project of creation. God declared His creation “good”. After that, there is no way to improve it. He completed His project of creation. He is STILL maintaining the universe.
As nice as your explanation sounds but the reality is it doesn’t say what you are saying at all
It says God RESTED it means what it means you then interpret it the way you think it is but it does not say what you are saying 😅
@@hamzaTVNetwork It most certainly does. Do you really think God takes a nap and let's the world spin out of control? What YOU need to worry about is WHY the Quran embraces the false dogma of Eternal Torment which comes from the Roman Catholic church and the Egyptian Book of the Dead. The Quran cannot possibly be from God.
@@stevendubberly8106Eternal Torment ? So a man who Rapes a woman or kills a child is going straight to heaven or hell ?
What a nice calm discussion, Raihan is very respectful but his evidence for the Torah being corrupt, against all historical evidence to the contrary, is because the Quran overrides it, what kind of logic is that? Does the Quran say the Torah is corrupt, if so why does he say he respects the Torah,
You don't even know the authors of the Jewish books nor can reliably get a chain of narration from these authors
@@j86485 You must be confused, are you saying you're ignorant of the authors of the Torah and Tenach? Are you also asserting Mohammad refered to a book in the Quran that has no validity?
@@josephking1947 Lol we have scholars, historians and archaeologists that have verified that Muhammad's companions during his life compiled the Quran by putting in writing, which proves its validity. That is something you cannot say the same for Torah and Tanakh which scholars, historians and archaeologists have said as it is just guesswork on who wrote it. Who compiled and put the Torah in writing? It's just unknown authors from different centuries of different Jewish communities that then became canon. How can we know if they're trustworthy if we don't know who they are and their names?
Many of the original Jewish text has been destroyed. The oldest surviving manuscript you can find is Dead Sea Scrolls carbon dated from the third century BCE to the first century CE. That only shows parts of the Jewish books. The oldest surviving manuscript of the Quran is the Birmingham manuscript which is carbon dated either around Muhammad's life or shortly after his death.That is exactly the same text as the Qur'an we have now
@@josephking1947 The original Jewish text is not the same we have now, that's my point. We have no evidence to prove the current Jewish text is the same as it was first revealed from a historical point of view and archaeological point of view. The original Jewish original texts have been destroyed due to Jewish persecution, exile, relocations, etc over the centuries which Jewish scholars have even admitted. This is something that's widely known around the world and educated Jews would know this too if you learnt about the history of Judaism
@@j86485 What Torah is Mohammad referring to in the Quran, when the Prophet says the Torah is from Allah, he must of had or of seen a schroll to verify its authenticity, or if Allah is simply telling Mohammed the Torah is from above, your comments would wholly contradict this, are you then saying the Quran is incorrect?
These Jew our cousins, believe that "you scratch m❤y back and I will your's" just stick to what we believe. The❤y will not agree even provided with the evidence Unfortunately !!!
how did the Jewish boy's hat not fall off?
the kippa.....i think its secured with bobby clips.....
Well done brothers Mashallah, very respectful conversation, may Allah guide the rabbi
The Rabbi walks away with a cig, on the side cool Rabbi
Playing the victim card, cliche.
lol so funny
Where is the Torah of Mosse, that is the question.
what about the quran of Muhammad
They both said they are students. How does a student have a career?
Click bait Sam.
We are student until we die because we learn sth new everyday.Student doesn't mean we hv to go to a university.
Ya lost me at all the one shit lol
but it was and they didn't do it ???
as they cannot pronounce the tetragram its all lies from them
Jews need help.
We're good tnx
Ask jews
Why do they deny 2 noble messengers
Eesa a.s and muhammad s.a.w
Eesa a.s was a jew like them
Muhammad s.a.w was an arab
If they say muhammad s.a.w was not from among them
Then what about eesa a.s
Eesa a.s was a jew
They will say, Jesus proclaim to be God. They got the affirmation from Christian that also proclaim Jesus is God. That is the problem. The truth is, nowhere does Jesus was proclaim he is God in the gospels. 2nd is, they believe Jesus was dead on the cross and messiah should not died before he ascend to the throne of 3rd temple. 3rd is, Jesus was born without father, therefor Jesus born without lineage, while the messiah and future king of the jews would be from David lineage.
This is where Islam came to straighten the truth about Jesus :
- he never proclaim divinity or as God
- he still live, escape from the cross and save and lift up to heaven and will come down back
- indeed Jesus is messiah and king of Bani Israel but Quran doesnt specified the criteria, maybe there is but i never hear it from my local scholars
@@sadaalmady4688 muhammad s.a.w was arab
In this sense i said
Eesa a.s is a jew
But again I retetriate, Torah is there as it was.
@sadaalmady In Genesis watcher angels had intercourse with human girls and that lead to Giants or Nephils and they used to eat even humans ( Enoch 1,2 and 3). So if it was an angel then Jesus should be a giant or Nephile.
@sadaalmady No Ishamaelites are a brotherly nation. All NOHIDES will have some part in kingdom of G-d provided they follow NOHIDE laws , at least
Disbelief of itself does not mean that the disbeliever's belief is true-otherwise Allah shouldn't exist because an atheist is not a Muslim. Islamic 'logic' is very peculiar. shouldn't
I didn’t hear anything career ending? Just that the Jewish fella got emotional at the start and went in to victim mode. Point which I’d like to know is why does the present Judaism ascribe deficiencies to The Almighty, when The Almighty is free from any deficiencies and is perfect in all attributes and works. Why the current version of Judaism if claimed to be true doesn’t propagate the truth to non Jews?, this point for me alone is suspect as the message of truth should be brought to all mankind!
Victim mode is their default mode
The muslim guy can say whatever he wants but do never forget what happened on the sinai mountain, no religion can claim that entire nation was evident to god speaking to them. Its not 1 or 2 people, entire nation. This could not pass from father to son until this day if it didnt happen...all other prophets beside moses dont have any evidence that they really got god words from god.
The story of the jewish people is uncomparable to any other nation. It doesnt make them better, it just means that they have a big responsibily to take care of. The ones that tries to invent new religions just cant accept the fact that god gave the instruction to this world to the jews
It’s Palestine under the Roman Empire not Israel
Are you aware of the fact that the Romans conquered the Kingdom of Judah and changed the name of the area to Syria-Palestine?
Lol their religion is only for them, not for everyone?? That sounds well dodgy to me sorry. Not being anti semitic. Just being honest
Well, as dodgy as it may sound, it doesn't matter what you think bro, no offense
The fact is that God gave the Torah to the people of Israel only.... If he wanted it to be the role of the world, he would have given it to the whole world.
Because we respect that there are other belief systems and other ways of life, other ways of finding truth. We dont force our way on anyone. But for anyone who wants to follow the Torah and become a Jew, they are all welcome.
Career ending for who? This just checked alot for christianity thats all I'm saying
Jesus wouldnt even recognise Christianity, you follow paul.
@@ahmedadam8851 brother im neither Christian or muslim im still debating in my own head but this right here proved alot to ME about it all. I am trying to find how Islam is related to the Abraham's faith and I can't see it. And no Paul isn't who is followed if u understand the whole Bible. What the Jews said here confirms everything about Christianity and the plural of God head. Jews were the first Christians.
@flat earth realm the irony of saying to me if I understood the bible hahahahhah with all due respect you sound absolutely clueless.
You've just listened to a Muslim and jew debating but some how got from it the plural god head hahahhahaha
Neither jew or Muslim believe in such a pagan idea nor does either the torah or quran scripture promote such belief.
The idea of the trinity was concocted hundreds of years after jesus.
To say you don't see how Islam connects to Abraham but somehow Christianity does is laughable.
What did every prophet including jesus preach???? One god, but then you have Christians hundreds of years later talking about a trinity which jesus never spoke about nor mentioned.
You said jews were the first Christians, meaning what exactly???
The first Christian Jews believed god was 1, upheld the torah commandments, didn't believe jesus was god and kept all the dietary laws and were circumcised!!!!
Non of which Christians do today!!! All of which jesus and the first Christians upheld!!!!
Christians on the other don't do any of that!
Christians follow paul that's a fact and I'll provide evidence!!
Jews and Muslims believe you should be circumcised, jesus and his followers were all circumcised!!
Christians don't circumcise cause Paul taught them its the circumcision of the heart that matters 😂😂😂😂
Muslims and Jews slaughter in the same way and Drain blood from the animal which makes it kosher/halaal.
Muslims and Jews also don't eat pork.
Christians don't do you either cause Paul told them all foods are clean 😂😂😂😂😂
Muslims and Jews believe upholding the law that was given to them and all thou some laws are abrogated the core is the same and that's why Jews themselves believe Muslims will be saved because according to them we are gentiles who follow and uphold the noahide laws!!!
Christians don't follow or uphold the laws, Paul taught them they'll be saved because of jesus death and resurrection even though jesus didn't preach such a thing.
Jesus fasted, Muslim fast.
Jesus prayed to 1 god, Muslims pray to 1 God.
Jesus upheld the law, Muslims uphold the law.
Jesus eat kosher/halaal and didn't eat pork, Muslim eat kosher/halaal and don't eat pork.
Christians follow paul like I said!!! Jesus would absolutely not recognise Christianity which is religion that was made up after him. Even his mother Mary covered her hair in modesty which Christian women don't 😂😂😂😂😂
Here's more evidence if you need that paul was teaching something completely different to the apostles and what jesus believed!! Read Galatians 2:11-14.
Paul was reprimanded by James the brother of jesus for teaching people false teachings!!!!
What more evidence do you need.
@flat earth realm the irony of saying to me if I understood the bible hahahahhah with all due respect you sound absolutely clueless.
You've just listened to a Muslim and jew debating but some how got from it the plural god head hahahhahaha
Neither jew or Muslim believe in such a pagan idea nor does either the torah or quran scripture promote such belief.
The idea of the trinity was concocted hundreds of years after jesus.
To say you don't see how Islam connects to Abraham but somehow Christianity does is laughable.
What did every prophet including jesus preach???? One god, but then you have Christians hundreds of years later talking about a trinity which jesus never spoke about nor mentioned.
You said jews were the first Christians, meaning what exactly???
The first Christian Jews believed god was 1, upheld the torah commandments, didn't believe jesus was god and kept all the dietary laws and were circumcised!!!!
Non of which Christians do today!!! All of which jesus and the first Christians upheld!!!!
Christians on the other don't do any of that!
Christians follow paul that's a fact and I'll provide evidence!!
Jews and Muslims believe you should be circumcised, jesus and his followers were all circumcised!!
Christians don't circumcise cause Paul taught them its the circumcision of the heart that matters 😂😂😂😂
Muslims and Jews slaughter in the same way and Drain blood from the animal which makes it kosher/halaal.
Muslims and Jews also don't eat pork.
Christians don't do you either cause Paul told them all foods are clean 😂😂😂😂😂
Muslims and Jews believe upholding the law that was given to them and all thou some laws are abrogated the core is the same and that's why Jews themselves believe Muslims will be saved because according to them we are gentiles who follow and uphold the noahide laws!!!
Christians don't follow or uphold the laws, Paul taught them they'll be saved because of jesus death and resurrection even though jesus didn't preach such a thing.
Jesus fasted, Muslim fast.
Jesus prayed to 1 god, Muslims pray to 1 God.
Jesus upheld the law, Muslims uphold the law.
Jesus eat kosher/halaal and didn't eat pork, Muslim eat kosher/halaal and don't eat pork.
Christians follow paul like I said!!! Jesus would absolutely not recognise Christianity which is religion that was made up after him. Even his mother Mary covered her hair in modesty which Christian women don't 😂😂😂😂😂
Here's more evidence if you need that paul was teaching something completely different to the apostles and what jesus believed!! Read Galatians 2:11-14.
Paul was reprimanded by James the brother of jesus for teaching people false teachings!!!!
What more evidence do you need.
29:50 he well known, remember he get bit trigger in the middle, in simple text "dont mind our book" and the he describe muslim, who's believe on muhammad pbuh, they are jews, they have their religion, book and so on.
We are muslim could not be muslim if we dont believe of the existenz of the whole 25 prophet. we tough not to make distinction between them. we love and respect them All as messanger of Allah.
You could imagine if you said "falsely" something bad about my brother. you gonna fill my oshoes 🤭
We are muslim love them all more than our mother. and you make story about them? 🤣🤣🤣
Alhamdulillah we are not allowed to use our shoes, lips insya Allah ok, in a good way 🤭
Sorry but this discussion was worthless, shamsi dismantled this guy in a couple of minutes. These brothers should stop being so apologetic and call this man to tawheed.
Is not truth, yemen jeweish speaks the real Hebrew, the modern Hebrew that he speaking they change it because they don't want Arabs to understand them, while yemen jeweish speaks the real Hebrew, and Yemeni the can understand it.
Nonsense bro, as a descendant of Yemenite Jews from my mother side, the Hebrew pronunciation of Yemenite Jews is the most accurate. And it was not mostly used for speaking Hebrew, which hardly existed then, but mainly for liturgical needs and during Torah study.
Among themselves they spoke Yemenite-Jewish which is a dialect of Jewish Arabic spoken by Yemenite Jews. My grandparents from Yemen speak this language by the way.
Modern Hebrew (which we all speak) is largely based on biblical Hebrew, with many similarities in grammar, syntax, and vocabulary. The core structure and essence of the language have been preserved throughout history. While there are new words introduced to accommodate modern concepts and advancements in technology, the fundamental understanding of the Torah written in biblical Hebrew remains intact. I can literally understand the Torah (biblical Hebrew) 100%
The Yemenite language has nothing to do with Hebrew. stop making things up
@@hanna319 from where in yemen is you grandparents?
@@mazim9111 My mother's family is from Yemen. My grandfather is from Amran, my grandmother is from Sana'a.
@@hanna319 are yemeni or what?
I don't know if you know the historie where was the first jeweish state?
Straight & simple. If you are human then UNDERSTAND AS HUMAN . This jew is trying to mystify & reach where he cannot by saying ' But we don't know whts happening up there ' ?! If course you CANNOT KNOW ! But as God wants us to understand .... understand that much ! Angry means angry. Rest means rest ! Period. Infact it is this trait among most jews......trying to get into God's head that led them to rebellion & stupidity for which they were repeatedly punished .
If Torah, Gods word has changed, it means God is changeable and thus not ALL POWERFUL. PERIOD!! Because Torah was ETERNAL word of God, and if God's words can be changed, it means God can be changed lol. Btw Uthman burned hundreds of qurans lol.