It's like some people don't understand that Amy and Beyoncé don't want to express the same feeling, beyoncé is perfect for that version and of course Amy is perfect for her version
No, this is Amy's song she didn't do a "version" of her own song. This is her raw emotions and pain. You can feel it in her art which was through music. Beyoncé did her shitty version of this beautiful song, with a check in her hand for the songtrack to a shitty movie.
@@ashleyswartz2976 Music is art and all forms of art are left to be interpreted and expressed individually. It’s a different experience for each person.
I think it is a privilege that we live in a day and age where we can hear different renditions of a great song. The same piece of music can put us in different moods depending on how the music arrangement, vocals and vibe are. Enjoy both and more!
Beyonce's voice is better suited to this film and creates a sensual feel to the song. Amy Winehouse was amazing, but her voice has a different feel to the song itself. Beyonce has done this song justice!
Both artist sang the song with different emotions- Amy sang with pain, Beyonce sang with an aluring, lust emotion which is exactly what the movie is about. I think both version are great as the meaning kind of changes for me when the emotion is changed. Nevermind, the song is still dope.
Courteney Scandrett Amy's version has a different feel because she is actually trying to convey the meaning of the song while Beyonce was just trying to make a sexy cover which IDK if I like
I love the way this is done. It's so different from the original that it doesn't make you want to compare the two. But...it looks like people are still doing it smh
Beyoncé either loves 50 Shades or she is getting paid big time! Edit: I found out the same day I posted this comment that this was on The Great Gatsby. Just wasn't use to hearing it without Andre 3000.
keren, i agree with you beyonce's version is good but it's not something i would listen to on a regular basis - i didn't even replay it xD it serves the purpose tho amy's version i still to this day listen to it, in fact i'm going to go listen to it again now
I like the way Amy sung the original version, but I love that fact that while listening to this version, I want to pay attention to what lyrics actually say. It's the voice and emotion that grabs you in Amy's version.
"Amy's version was better! Amy's version was better!" We got it guys, you prefer Amy's! Preferences can't be criticize. It's not better, it's different. There's nothing to compare here. I actually didn't like Amy's voice but liked the song. Now I like both ;)
yo yo Lol, I'm serious there's are some song that it's sound good that actually better then actually cover. but doing an Amy Winehouse song it's just why'd...?
Dystany Shiaka I disagree. Even Amy's dad loves Beyonce's version and wishes she did not include Andre 3000 in the official version. I love Beyonce's version
To me, since they did such a different approach to the song, it feels incomparable to the original. I know it’s a cover, but style-wise it’s not one to put side by side with Amy’s. It feels like it’s own song. Both are so so great.
Amy's version was good enough for commercials , but not good enough for this forgettable movie .It's too bad , the sound track could have used her version to liven it up a little. She was kick ass singer!!!!
woahtini Actually, Amy's song would've fit better. If you read the books, which aren't great but better than the movies, Amy's pain fit exactly what Grey feels throughout the storyline.
I did read the books, but i feel like the whole point of beyoncé's cover is to fit to the movie, not the book, and with the same lyrics she gave it a more sensual beat that fits the movie more than the book bc as in the first movie i don't think Christian's inner pain will be much seen, except the whole childhood thing but the breakup won't be as painful as it's shown in the books *i guess*
I LOVE Amy but...that being said with this being a song Ive literelly cried to hearing her sing. This Beyonce version is awesome in a whole different way.
How dare she re-make this song. The song was written by someone who lived these words who felt that deep pain of what love can do to a person. That dark place it takes a person to once it's over. Beyoncé singing this song kills the emotional aspect of the song. She's only singing it because she's getting paid to sing it. Amy Winehouse Sang this song because of her heart break, love triangles, the life she had but didn't want, the hurt she felt deep in heart. You can hear the hurt and genuineness in Amy's version. They should have kept it with Amy singing it and maybe just edited and remastered it to sound fresh for the movie.
I couldn't care if Jesus done a cover to this song he wouldn't be able to sing it like Amy did, this song is about real life situations that Amy went through so no one can sing it the way Amy did, Because they can't tell the story and this proved it, as good as Beyoncés voice is it couldn't sing this song and with all these people failing to do cover proves how special Amy was and how special her music really. RIP Amy Winehouse. 👑❤❤
no offense but ofc pple will said that Amy is the best because she passed away but admit that FOR THE FILM and ONLY FOR IT Beyonce's voice suit better is not a crime !
I've NEVER UNDERSTOOD why people bother to come on someone else's page to throw shade at THEIR artistry. If you don't like THIS VERSION, PLEASE click away. Everybody knows you're not doing Beyonce a favor. And this comment is no shade to Amy either, everybody just chill.😒😳😒
I think Bey has honoured the original yet made it different. Amy's song is great but this is more sensual. I think I might be interested in the soundtrack too.... but not the movie.
I'm in tears, Amy was and is probably one of the best voices of ever, she had so much talent...the pain she was passing trough was always audible on her voice, unfortunately we couldn't save her and is no longer here for us, so the only thing we can do is remembering her great voice as she was alive
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
It's like some people don't understand that Amy and Beyoncé don't want to express the same feeling, beyoncé is perfect for that version and of course Amy is perfect for her version
Exactly, both are amazing.
Truly
Some people dont know what cover is lol
No, this is Amy's song she didn't do a "version" of her own song. This is her raw emotions and pain. You can feel it in her art which was through music. Beyoncé did her shitty version of this beautiful song, with a check in her hand for the songtrack to a shitty movie.
@@ashleyswartz2976 Music is art and all forms of art are left to be interpreted and expressed individually. It’s a different experience for each person.
Remember that Amy was also a huge fan of Beyoncé when she was alive, so trust that it’s pure love and respect. People cover songs ALL the time.
Until Beyonce killed Amy Winehouse 👹👹👹
Amy's version is raw, painful, gritty. Bey's is sensual. Both beautiful interpretations. Also, this song is from Gatsby....
beyonce sound like a scratchy violin me sounds like a beautiful angel
Beyonce did fucking horribly
You say she did horrible but watch it...... People these days
HOYAWNCÉ the Overrated Demon aren’t u a prude
Beyonce's 'pain' is a performance. Amy's pain is, as you said RAW because it is real.
Amy would absolutely lose her SHITTT knowing Beyonce covered one of her songs 😍😍😍 fans know she absolutely loved her ❤
Diddy
I think it is a privilege that we live in a day and age where we can hear different renditions of a great song. The same piece of music can put us in different moods depending on how the music arrangement, vocals and vibe are. Enjoy both and more!
I seriously love her haunting vibe to this song. I could just imagine something cool in the fantasy aspect.
Beyonce's voice is better suited to this film and creates a sensual feel to the song. Amy Winehouse was amazing, but her voice has a different feel to the song itself. Beyonce has done this song justice!
Courteney Scandrett I'd have to disagree. Amy sang with pain. Which is better suited for the characters internal struggle.
Courteney Scandrett how? Lmao. Her voice is so manly lol
Both artist sang the song with different emotions- Amy sang with pain, Beyonce sang with an aluring, lust emotion which is exactly what the movie is about. I think both version are great as the meaning kind of changes for me when the emotion is changed. Nevermind, the song is still dope.
Then in that sense, she has done the movie justice. Sensualness is not what the song is about.
Courteney Scandrett Amy's version has a different feel because she is actually trying to convey the meaning of the song while Beyonce was just trying to make a sexy cover which IDK if I like
this remake is not from Fifty Shades of Grey but from The Great Gatsby
Agreed!!!
The only difference between them are Andre 3000 who is featured in the Great Gatsby version
pofila1 there are two different versions
@@diana5537 andre is on the soundtrack version but not in the movie, its this song played in great gatsby.
Watching The Great Gatsby now 😂😂😂 I forgot she covered this! 🫶🏽
Love Beyonce... But this time I have to say that Amy's version is the best and hardly someone could do something better
apavon01 YESSS
Her version was the best in her style but that's it. I prefer this one . That's just preferences I guess :)
its just bcs it has to be kind of sexual since its for fifty shades darker
apavon01 yea
sad girl this is from the Great Gatsby soundtrack , not the new 50 shades movie
I love the way this is done. It's so different from the original that it doesn't make you want to compare the two. But...it looks like people are still doing it smh
No it’s just a piece of shit. Rihanna did it better than this with when 5 second clip
@@richb2821 Rihanna can barely hold a note chileeeeee.....
Sorry but this version just isn't it
Facts
Amy winehouse's version is still the best
zulficar salendab always but this is still good
why the fuck are you guys on here then?? RIP AMY💖💖
I love the amy version
middle fingers up
Eat Yoncé's shit. Amy more perfect than her
Beyoncé’s voice is just unreal!!! The sultry, the mysteriousness, the sensuality, the power! Ughhhhh!!!
Beyoncé either loves 50 Shades or she is getting paid big time!
Edit: I found out the same day I posted this comment that this was on The Great Gatsby. Just wasn't use to hearing it without Andre 3000.
Christian Ballard paid big time
Christian Ballard She said she loved the movie.
Christian Ballard her voice goes well with the trilogy
Boubakar D I figured that out when I listened to this a couple of more times. Thought it sounded familiar, but was missing the Andre 3000 part. xd
The one with Andree 3000 is much much better!!!
I like both versions Beyoncé isn’t trying to out do Amy this version was made for the great gatsby and fits perfectly for that movie
This version is good but Amy's version will always be the best for me
keren b no
keren, i agree with you
beyonce's version is good but it's not something i would listen to on a regular basis - i didn't even replay it xD it serves the purpose tho
amy's version i still to this day listen to it, in fact i'm going to go listen to it again now
keren b noting can't beat the original but don't hate on Beyoncé
+keren b is it because she's dead? 🙁
Daysha Anderson I don't hate on her! I just believe that Amy's version is better.
Jamail44 no :(
Don't know why there's so much hate for Beyonce's version.... I seem to like it very much :)
With a name like URS u would wouldn't u!
@@mimiesm365??
Mimies M no one named “Mimies” gets a say on anyone’s name lol
Crystal K lol true
Mimies M see how no one agrees with you 😂
covers aren't made to be "better" than the original so ..chill people xD
STFU "teresita"
@lílα wєllѕ that's your opinion though, just bcs you don't like something, doesn't make it bad for everyone, pls stfu
@lílα wєllѕ that's your opinion though, just bcs you don't like something, doesn't make it bad for everyone, pls stfu
@@mimiesm365 y'all are some fucking weirdos
Right!
I get chills listening to this version!
This fits perfect with 50 shades I hope they use this!!!
The musical arrangement on this is amazing. I could have never imagined this song with an 808 but with her voice and the mood it sets it's works well.
I like the way Amy sung the original version, but I love that fact that while listening to this version, I want to pay attention to what lyrics actually say. It's the voice and emotion that grabs you in Amy's version.
ugh it’s sooo good 😭😭😭♥️
Lana Del Rey should've been the one who covered this Amy Winehouse gold track
S.A. Morales that would have been too perfect
S.A. Morales I would have literally died 😮❤
S.A. Morales lana can't sing. oh auto tune gotcha
... lana cant sing? Are you good? Go watch her live performances. Shes amazing.
Safak Bulut I seen her live no thanks
I guess she wants my scalp too cause my edges still ain't grown back since lemonade
Bahhhhhhhh I can't stand that pushy ass bitch she's needs to be stopped 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
This has to be my favorite comment here LMFAOOOO
😭😭😭
"Amy's version was better! Amy's version was better!" We got it guys, you prefer Amy's! Preferences can't be criticize. It's not better, it's different. There's nothing to compare here. I actually didn't like Amy's voice but liked the song. Now I like both ;)
This is beautiful. R.I.P. Amy!
I'm having like 10 eargasms at the same time right now.
She can never be as original and great as amywinehouse.
why tf u here then go do smt w ur lifr
Amazing Beyoncé. Just simply Amazing. Well done!
Y ahora cuál es tu opinión de ella.. ??
I can't get enough of this version. Beyonce' did an OUTSTANDING job covering this song!
Beyoncé smoothend this track ❤️️ Love both Amy and Beys versions
Late, but if they went head to head which version do u think would triumph?
@@carolynhill8558 I don't have to answer that
Some people just should left Amy alone, this song should never be touch.
indeed
LOL
yo yo Lol, I'm serious there's are some song that it's sound good that actually better then actually cover. but doing an Amy Winehouse song it's just why'd...?
Dystany Shiaka I disagree. Even Amy's dad loves Beyonce's version and wishes she did not include Andre 3000 in the official version. I love Beyonce's version
JloveLamar omg.. of course Amy's dad loves Beyonce's version..
i'm in love with this song .. very good performance
Loooove this version. I just love the R&B/hiphop beat to it. My kind of music👌🏽
omg! it's amazing beyonce 😍😍😍
Amy would be honored by this ... it still holds the sadness and power in it .
Am I the only one who loves this version of the song too ?
I feel like amy version could have fit this movie.
Yes. Her version sounds better to me. No shade. I'm a Beyonce fan, but a music fan 1st.
Tiauna Pratt exactly
This Isnt Even The Right Movie
Yeah No sorry😭😭😭
No it wouldn’t have. there was a twist with the whole soundtrack for the movie. did you watch the actual movie
Vous êtes où les français? 😍😍
Sarah Presca 😍😍😍
dtc
là
Bourbia Nasro 😉😉😉😉
To me, since they did such a different approach to the song, it feels incomparable to the original. I know it’s a cover, but style-wise it’s not one to put side by side with Amy’s. It feels like it’s own song. Both are so so great.
I'm actually obsessed, Bey definitely did Amy justice 👌🔥
this is something else.... this excites my internals..... omg Beyoncé's voice is wonder....
Amy's version was good enough for commercials , but not good enough for this forgettable movie .It's too bad , the sound track could have used her version to liven it up a little. She was kick ass singer!!!!
it has nohing to do with being good enough or not. beyoncé's cover gives the song another beat that fits better with the plot
+woahtini of course it fits, they raped this song!
woahtini Actually, Amy's song would've fit better. If you read the books, which aren't great but better than the movies, Amy's pain fit exactly what Grey feels throughout the storyline.
I did read the books, but i feel like the whole point of beyoncé's cover is to fit to the movie, not the book, and with the same lyrics she gave it a more sensual beat that fits the movie more than the book bc as in the first movie i don't think Christian's inner pain will be much seen, except the whole childhood thing but the breakup won't be as painful as it's shown in the books *i guess*
Okay, I give you that. I do agree with you there.
Beyoncé arrasa !! 👏
both versions are distinct and unique.
You can like both it's not one or the other. People are stupid
MrsShakur1996 but this just sucks, tho. I think thats wht being said
@@dmitri7641 it's absolute amazing. You have zero taste, sad.
Wack
Totally agreed.. amy sung beautifully but beyonce has also done just great.. perfect for this movie..
No
Beyonce versión is not that good
The original is leyend
Is a fact sorry
Don't let that the fanatism make you blind
from "sung by a dead singer" song to MASSIVE HIT thank Queen Bey!
If only Amy was around to see it. Can you imagine the collab that could have happened....I think Amy would be very honored to hear this.
I love both Amy's and Bey's versions. I think Bey made it sexier and suitable for the movie 😻❤❤
Danielle Kim Sad revelation, it's not even included in the movie. Someone just said that it was.
@@paulveitch5870 it was on the soundtrack idiot
eyediosmio try checking it again or send a link if you can find it
paul veitch m.imdb.com/title/tt1343092/soundtrack it’s literally listed on google if you search the great gatsby album track list
eyediosmio You stupid bitch. The title says it’s for the Fifty Shades Darker soundtrack.
Beautiful and gorgeous version song infact very romantic always take my breath away. I love you forever
R.I.P. Amy Winehouse. You should have gone to rehab.
She did go to rehab. Multiple times.
Gallium Mercury, I heard they tried to make her go, but she said no no no.
Sarita -.- 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
She said " no...no...no..." RIP Amy
Gallium Mercury y'all play too much
I LOVE Amy but...that being said with this being a song Ive literelly cried to hearing her sing. This Beyonce version is awesome in a whole different way.
simply amazing
Omg love this version as well as original wow.. man.. thanks 4 sharing x
La hizo suya, y por ello es una buena canción.
Sin olvidar que la original es una JOYA.
Beyonce sounds PHENOMENAL on this song!
How dare she re-make this song. The song was written by someone who lived these words who felt that deep pain of what love can do to a person. That dark place it takes a person to once it's over. Beyoncé singing this song kills the emotional aspect of the song. She's only singing it because she's getting paid to sing it. Amy Winehouse Sang this song because of her heart break, love triangles, the life she had but didn't want, the hurt she felt deep in heart. You can hear the hurt and genuineness in Amy's version. They should have kept it with Amy singing it and maybe just edited and remastered it to sound fresh for the movie.
Bey atribuiu a Essa canção sua personalidade enquanto intérprete. É um trabalho fantástico
Meanings can be interpretted differently with different tones and beats
Keyandria Miller exactly
This was meant to sound seductive mysterious i like both versions
Keyandria Miller But this version was unappealing to most of us.. Somehow the seductive tone doesn't work for this song..
I like both versions thb they both convey a deep meaning to them.
Love the beat to B's take on Amy's classic
Beautiful homage to a unique talent gone far too soon 😔
I couldn't care if Jesus done a cover to this song he wouldn't be able to sing it like Amy did, this song is about real life situations that Amy went through so no one can sing it the way Amy did, Because they can't tell the story and this proved it, as good as Beyoncés voice is it couldn't sing this song and with all these people failing to do cover proves how special Amy was and how special her music really. RIP Amy Winehouse. 👑❤❤
One of the best covers I’ve ever heard!!!
I adore her 👏🏼👏🏼❤️ OMG THAT SONG İS AMAZİNG WİTH BEY💋🔥
just stop the amy shit. Beyonce is not trying to sing it better than amy did.But she did a great job
Jessej Thanks for saying it.. This beat is hideous and Beyonce's seductive tone isn't working for this song at all..
lol she didn't
AGREED BOTH WOMEN ARE AMAZING ARTIST
RIP AMY WINEHOUSE
Shut up amy's version is the best forever
@@personunknown9008 good on you bij
THIS IS SO GOOD🔥🔥🔥🔥😍
wow. Amy would be freaking out. wow. wow. wow. I'm not a huge fan of Beyonce, but she DID THIS and she did it well.
no one can sing Amy's songs better than her even in their dreams #A.W❤#
As a big fan of Bey I just have to say that no one can sing that like Amy did. I love amy
I love Beyoncé...but this song should be left alone, I love the original. R.I.P Amy 😢
Te amo, Beyoncé, mas Back To Black nunca deveria ser regravada desta maneira. É um hino que só respeito no ritmo e voz de Amy Winehouse
no offense but ofc pple will said that Amy is the best because she passed away but admit that FOR THE FILM and ONLY FOR IT Beyonce's voice suit better is not a crime !
NO, not because she passed away we say this, just go compare the 2 ffs
KinectWars or maybe because the original is already perfect and Amy was a great singer
Noooooooooo
TOTALLY AGREE
i was thinking the same thing. But of course they’ll deny that. They’re literally in the comments saying it’s horrible lmao
I love this song.
Amy can't be duplicated she was in a league of her own
Beyonce didn't try to duplicate her. You're stupid AF.
Adele sounds just like her
Did you come here just to hate on Beyoncé?
I've NEVER UNDERSTOOD why people bother to come on someone else's page to throw shade at THEIR artistry. If you don't like THIS VERSION, PLEASE click away. Everybody knows you're not doing Beyonce a favor. And this comment is no shade to Amy either, everybody just chill.😒😳😒
People called Beyonce queen B...but what about Amy though?
Crazywebshowgirl09 Queen of Soul.
True I guess but she's still like my queen of everything :")
That title belongs to Aretha Franklin
She's....a queen.
ForCommentingMusic&Etc. :D♥ I miss her so much 💔
i love beyonce but amy will always sings this iconic song the best and no one will change that. not even queen bey
This is from the great gatsby
Both Versions Rock!!😍👊❤
Bruh the weeknd need to make a song to this movie like last time 😍😍😍😍
yeeeesssss
Best version out , especially with andre 3k on the remix. Fiiire
yass Queen!!!!
She killed it, that song should never be touched by anybody. Just tragic.
Chris Dimi it’s just a cover, stfu idiot
I don't like Beyonce's voice with this song, it does not fit. Amy's version had real emotion and a story.
Ola Talks I’m curious to see what Lana Del Rey’s voice would do for back to black
@@bloodshotgoth it's gonna sounds completely shit
Ola Talks its for fifty shades lmao you’re stupid
I love love love amy winehouse and I love love love Beyonce ❤
I think Bey has honoured the original yet made it different. Amy's song is great but this is more sensual. I think I might be interested in the soundtrack too.... but not the movie.
I love how people are calling Fifty Shades a "Forgettable" movie, yet it will be one of the most remembered.
Beyoncé is the best
what a perfect voice omg..... 😍😍😍😍😭
Oh. My. God.
Her Voice
I love her💪🏻💛
Beautiful queen well done
I like the version with Andrè 3000, shit go hard...
THIS MOVIE DONT DESERVE THIS SOUNDTRACK😫😖😩
RIP Amy 💜 that was my fave song.
I have to say that Amy's version is the best and hardly someone could do something better
I'm in tears, Amy was and is probably one of the best voices of ever, she had so much talent...the pain she was passing trough was always audible on her voice, unfortunately we couldn't save her and is no longer here for us, so the only thing we can do is remembering her great voice as she was alive
Love this, Bey'voice 💕💖💋
Sensual sexy sad loving. Not a beyonce fan yet I'm feeling this song in my soul💜💜💋💋💔💔