Why Students Hate Caste Reservation? | College Admission 2024
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 авг 2024
- Unlock the untold stories of Indian students grappling with the complexities of reservation policies in higher education! In this eye-opening video, I sat down with students from Delhi University to delve deep into the challenges posed by both reservation and 2nd generation reservation in the college admission process.
Hear firsthand from these students as they share their views and concerns about how reservation impacts their chances of securing spots in reputed colleges. We explore the nuanced ways in which reservation systems affect not only admission opportunities but also the academic landscape for aspiring scholars.
Additionally, we shine a light on a growing concern-how tier 1 students, armed with better resources, might be leveraging the system to their advantage, widening the gap between those who have access to privileges and those who don't.
Join the conversation as we discuss the ripple effects on general category students, with the decreasing availability of spots based on merit. This candid exploration aims to foster awareness, understanding, and perhaps even solutions to address the complexities surrounding reservation policies in Indian higher education.
Chapters
0:00 Intro
0:36 What if there was no Reservation in India ?
1:45 What are your thoughts on 2nd Gen Reservation ?
3:54 Do you think Reservation hurting Merit Students ?
5:23 Can tier 3 backward Students compete with tier 1 city backward class students ?
7:13 Conclusion
Share your thoughts in the comments below and let's work towards a fair and equitable educational landscape for all! #reservation #mrhemantshow #ReservationInEducation #StudentVoices #DelhiUniversity #2ndGenReservation #CollegeAdmissions #EducationInIndia #delhi #delhiuniversity #students #interview #streetinterview #interviews
@dhruvrathee @NitishRajput 
Развлечения
Congrats as you are brave enough for bringing up topics like this hats off
Trying to bring new perspective to already existing topic .👍🏼😍
@@mrhemantshow Yes bro ik how it feels I'm also general
the red person with spectacles is actually good educated person . he is giving very relevant answers which are
very satisfactory
Yeah he had some good opinion but I think everybody shared something good and personal.
yes the educated person who doesn't know that there are no seats reserved for general students. the point of quota system which he brought up was wrong. there is no 50% seats for general students. that 50% comes under unreserved. which means anyone on merit basis can get those seats. people like you suffer from selective hearing and hear what you want to hear. just give me one good reason for 2nd generation reservation without being biased. i am all in for 1st generation reservations but to give the entire bloodline the benefit of reservation is straight up stupidity. i can cry the same my great great great great grandfather was discriminated by Mughals i need reservation too, sound stupid right? these caste based reservations will sound the same in a few years. people who never saw their grandparents getting discriminated and are children of government officers are getting benefits of reservation. do you think a Son of an IAS officer sc/st category deserves reservation to hide their incompetence. In my school children from all categories used to study together, eat together and sit together and the only time i got to know about their caste was at the time of college admissions. i know now you will cry that still discrimination exits. yes caste based discrimination is a crime and should be punished like any other crime- prison sentence, fine etc. reservations will never solve a problem like discrimination. if given a choice to a reserved category person to either punish the single individual that discriminated against you are punish a entire strata of smart students they wil always chose the latter. the truth is they don't want justice they want reservations that give them access to top institutes of the country even though they don't deserve it.
@@user-sv2jl3sr5qru chamar?
imo, govt giving reservation tells us a lot about in 75+ years of independence how they have managed basic education. As if you are giving good quality education in govt schools then the child not need reservation in the first place. If he lacks the economic potential then we can solve that through scholarships.
Every party has some political agenda they hardly gonna touch this
4:54 bro is completely non sense there is no reserved seat for general 50 percent seats are open for all categories
reservation ki vajhe se logo ka future kharab hua hai ,some at lower marks with greater family background stil getting reservation but for poor who does not have resourse doesnt get seat because he is from general catagory
That’s a solid point
Cinema me bhi same hai
Jo already director ya actor k bacche hai
Unko movies k liye bhatakna nahi padhta they already..get movies easily and flopn(nowadays)
..jisse Indian cinema ka budget bhi khrb aur aage nahi badh paa raha Bollywood
Wahi ek accha actor usko 10-10 saal bad success milte hai (no guarantee)
Scientist like nambi Narayan also caught in fake allegation..which make India backwards atleast 25yrs ...in space field
Aur reservation ki wajah se career khrab hua hai to
70s 60s me ..
Lower caste ka bhi career khrb hua tha...
Bcz upper caste Dont allow lower caste for studies n business things
So support for caste fee INDIA 🇮🇳👳
@@k.1024 tab ki baat alag hai tab situation apki control mai nhi tha tab reservation hi ek tarika tha par ab caste based rakhke koi fayda nahi economically evaluate karna chiye
Are bhyiii casteism kitna h ab bhiii shi h bhai reservation 🎉
*Why gen Category people are not living their caste they are only 15% population of this country if they start doing inter caste marriages they will also start getting reservation and eventually their will no reservation and no caste but the reality is that people want caste but not reservation that is not possible bro we 85% obc sc sts of these country will not allow that to happen
👍🏼👍🏼
This video is not about reservation per se, it is about how reservation is making student feel.
Intercaste marriage is always a option. Don't impose it
@@CRYMOOre removing reservation is also a option don't impose it
@@rahulece-0197 intercaste will not affect anyone but reservation is deteriorating the merit and causing reverse casteism. Hope u have brain to understand
cast based discrimination hai to caste base reservation bhi ho
tu bhi 43 percent me addmission lene wala h kya 😅😅
abe pahle apne aap ko dekh phir meri brabri karna@@Synchronic_beasttt
kya discrimination, reservation wale toh majority hai toh unku khilaf kese discrimination ho raha
bahut discrimination hai bhai you general girl cannot marry sc/st/obc boy
also we are restricted to higher post like ias/ips restricted in the sense they to try put general in candidate in good posts
@@user-lo3uo2rg6n
@@Synchronic_beasttt😂😂.
Good attempt to understand social issues……. Appreciable
I appreciate your Feedback .
BHAI GENERAL WALE KAFI MAJE LE CHUE H AB SC WALON KO BHI LENA RESERVATION IS GOOD MERE OR AAAPKE KEHNE SE KUX NHI HOTA I AM ALSO FROM GENERAL CASTE @@mrhemantshow
What an informative video!! with great editing
Glad you liked it!
Can anyone tell me can obc or other category can use reserved seat of UR
Yes they can but conditionally
👍🏼
*Bro reservation is not economic welfare program its about representation of all section of society* as a responsible person before making you could have studied it and made video on increasing seats instead of reservation they didn't got good colleges bcoz seats are very limited for this much population.
Fact
This video is not about if reservation is a economic welfare program this is about why UR category dislike it. If you want to know why reservation is important and why it is in india there are many videos on RUclips.
Bro it's not about representation of category people why ur people dislike it is becoz they work very hard and still don't get their desired colleges while the people with low marks they get it easily with category if u want to show their representation then they should also fight among their category and get at high level cut off like ur .Also their competition is with their own people among same category then their cut off should also be high.
@@prishasanyal4210 bro u should first study about it nd thn make conclusions whether it is about representation or not....they only get admission in the college through reservation in college they have to pass semester exams as well....aur rahii baat ki unko khud k cat m compete krna chahiye to iss logic se hm 85% reservation lengeee fir compete krenge
@@shubhamdeopa7991 this video is about reservation nd mostly people dislike it becoz they think it is economic welfare program ....without knowing the facts you can't blame reservation for your failure
College me Marks se jada Category matter krti haii
Lo bhai aap to keh rhe the ki mene pucha he ki merit student jyada safar karte h but dusre channel se comment kar rhe ho ki category matter karti h
@@mcqseries1716bro mera venki college ke review ke time ek ladke ne ye baat boli thi mujhe maine bs repeat kiya h
Why not you talk about that time when sc st are not allowed to enter in school ?? Then there is 100 % reservation at that time ? Is this little time enough to heal that ?
Great Work!!
Thanks a lot!
Good content 👍🏼
Glad you enjoyed
resrrvatuion ke hatne se genral walo ko koi farak nahi padega reservation mai bohot kam seete hi hai genral walo ko sirf iss baat se problem hai ki sc st ka kam par ho gaya or ye baat unke parents hi unke dimag mai daalte hai
mujhe batao reservation kyu hai comment mai batao
👍🏼👍🏼
Bohot kam seat hai ?? Kya padhai krta hai tu ??? Already 65% reserved haii 50 %for obc sc st 10 % ews 5% pwd this sums up 65% and left with 35% that too is open any body can come in those 35 percent …. Its is not about caste or anybody its about that more aspiring and more effort putting people are not getting seats this is doing brain drain
@@mayanksharma6758 population persentage se compare kar ke dekh 15 %genral ke pass 10 % reservation hai or 50 persent obc ke pass 27 persent reservation hatana hai to cast hata do thik hai
@@mayanksharma6758 or tune mare question ka answer hi nahi Diya reservation kyu hai
@@thanosgodzilla6003 bhut km seat h ?? aadhe se jyda seat reserved h murkh
Finally bhaiya 2 month baad video ❤
Yeah I apologise for this
acha be mtlb 3000 years tak tumne education ko dominate kiya.... lower cast tak education pohochne nahi di aur ab jab sirf 70 years se lower casts ko reservation mila hai to tumhari jal rhi hai
kahan 3000 years kahan 70...
The video is not about abolishing reservation in India it is about how the hate of reservation is dividing our country in whole we all need to be on same page to avoid further hatred. You can call me a optimistic if you want.
@@mrhemantshow bro maine ye comment aapke liye nahi jo log hatred faila rhe hai unke liye Kiya tha 🙂🙂
Abey chutiyaa kisne khh diya tujhe ??? Ye sb 3000 saal ,,,, 4 varna vertical nahi the horizontal thee ,,,,, or vedic history padh sb education lete thee ,,, every one was educated ( indian education not british) ,,,all this happemd after britishers
kon sa tin hajar sal be, sale kuch bhi fekte ho murkh.
Ha tu bhi 3000 sal tak ved padh le full reservation dunga tujhe . 3000 saal pehle sirf ved padhe jaate the 😎
100% reservation declare kr do, Pass an Act that Generals are not allowed in IIT, Government Jobs because lower caste faced discrimination for 100000000 years.
This debate will be over for ever, no confusion nothing.
Bahut ache bhai lge rho...
Thanks For The love bhaiya
5:00 isko WhatsApp University sa knowledge mila ha
General ka seat sab la sakta ha
Yeah I got to know that recently myself.
@@mrhemantshow nice video 👍
if you remove reservation then also remove intercaste marriage give all right to sc /st /obc as general get equality to all categories
Brooo It is a social problem but why are innocent gets punished who does not practise reservation?
that's not a problem bro this is done because before constitution you also know how caste system affected the life of sc/st/obc
@@offcial_O
I know in past the treatment of backward caste in unforgivable but the way we are handling reservation right know the hate between communities are growing day by day and we also see the political agendas.
you are right sometimes i also feel sometimes@@mrhemantshow
Bhai ye vaise puchne ki bat hi nhi …..100%% reservation ne studetns ki brbadi ki hai….neet m toh 400 no walo ka bhi ho jata h orr gen ka 620 pe…orr mostly sare amir log hote h ..meaine apni akho se dekha h fam income more than50 lakhs pe orr student ki rank itni piche or ab india ki no 1 IIT m khud dekhlo…yaha pe jee mei 5 hzar rank p bhi koi achi IIT nhi milti
Yeah 2nd generation is affecting everything.
Aab sale sc st walo ki keda uthega sahi hai yrr unke bacho ko kyu de reservation jab unke family background aacha hai baap ips beta ko tab bhi quota chaye
❤
Bhai ham Brahmin me to bhot jyada dikat hain en obc sc st k vjeh se ham Brahmin bhot pareshan hain.
All you Need is to do hardwork brother
bhai sirf brahmin hi nahi me kshatriya hun general 🥲
😭😭@@user-lo3uo2rg6n
Reservation should only be given in top schools so they can get good education and compete on merit basis starting from UG courses
4:54 he is saying that people don't know about reservation while he himself doesn't know about it. i mean what bs is he even talking about? 50 percent quota for general? he must be really high.
Its my opinion so no one have right yo judge it ok... So listen i am from the Northeast side of india and we have different view about reservation.. First of all as everyone may know the history of how the Northeast part of india become a part of india.... So they gave us special right.. That is reservation because at that time before we became a part of india .. We all were economically wealer secton.. So they wanted us to have equal right as indian
Just a video by "manuwadi" read your holy book "manusmriti".
👍🏼
2nd generation reservation new and better concept maybe
👍🏼 Thanks for the feedback
5:05 o bhai kaha kaha se aate hai ye log 50% general ki reserve bata hai kaun si bhaang khayi hai isne 50% sc st obc ki reserved hai aur baaki jo 50% bacha usme bhi to sc st obc general kashmiri migrant cw quota aur bht saare hai holi ki bhaang abhi bhi nahi utari bhai ki
Oh bai m aa hi gya video m😂
Nice bro
Education system 📉
1st of all general caste ko bhi reservation milta h wo bhi 10% but they are only 15% in the country and obc ko 27% milta h aur obc 50% h country m to discrimination kiske saat hua ? Bas hawa bna rakhi j ki general caste reservation nhi leti but in actually general caste sabse jyada reservation leta h.
EWS 10% right we talked about that as well in video
@@mrhemantshow then why are you asking that ki general caste sabse jyada safar karti h reservation se?
Brother I said do you think merit student suffer because of reservation
@@mrhemantshow bhai pheli baat to ye ki aap ne apne dusre channel hi comment kar rakha h ki marks se jyada category matter karti h
@@mcqseries1716EWS cutoff phir bhi obc cutoff and SC St cutoff se zyada high kyu hota hai? Kya app mange ho kam hone ke bawajud general log smart hote hai? Thank you mujhe jawab mil gaya!
Ab thode bheem k ladu aate hi honge😂 3000 salo se ham pdhe nnhi ye nnhi vo nhi …abey ja na ma-ch-r kahi ke……resservation is the major cause abtk india kuch nhi krpaya..koi ek single company dikhado jiska ceo laddu ho..sare general k hote h….studetns k abroad jane ka reason bhi yahi hi hai….jo gye h unse pucho..kyuki canada m ye sab nhni mahnat chlti h
There will be no quotas..in education
General walo ko koi reservation nahi hai 40% is open for all
👍🏼
Pandey ko bolo banan bnd kre😂🤣 paise leke
Ok bhaii
Gargi ka bhi kro plzz
👍🏼👍🏼
Reservation should be based on income
me bhi obc se hu
👍🏼👍🏼
reservation is the cause
Caste system is THE ROOT
fight for caste free INDIA
4:50 he defines correctely
Yeah 👍🏼👍🏼
toh yeh quoata discrimination nahi ho mtlb woh divide kar rahe ki gen wal sirf gen walo ke saath hi compete karega
plus discrimination kya teir 1 cities me bhi ho raha hai kya?
me mumbai se hu mre kitne frnds obc/st/sc se hai jo mujhe 12th ka form bharne tak malum bhi nahi tha kya uska mtlb yeh hai ki 12th ka gov form reason hai ki mujhe uski caste pata chali (jo pata chalne pr bhi koi farak nahi padta) pr woh tih mere saath hi padh raha uske ghar ke condition mere se same hi hai toh unne reservation q? dena hi hai tih gaav walo ko dona.
Lanth Ho aise country paa
Brother etni bhi buri nhi h country yr
@@mrhemantshow ambedkhar maderchod ruined our lives
@@mrhemantshowTo aadhe se zyada general category vale log kyu bhag jate hain desh chodke ?
"While America is taking the deserved ,India is keeping the reserved ".
Tax bhi bhare hum(with absolutely ZERO benifits )...reservation bhi hum hi jhele ...lanat hai ese desh par ....sirf gareebo ko rakha jaye fir to desh me tab khush hongi hamari sarkar .....Mai to nikal hi jau ga 100% pg ke liye bahar ....bhaade jaye merit ,india ko bas reservation chahiye ....1 Kodi ki growth nhi hogi is desh ki zindagi me
Reservation only economic base pr hona chahiye na ki caste base prr
It’s not only about economic status it’s about do we see them as equal and treat them equal in society.
caste base discrimination h to fir reservation bhi caste base prr hoga
Remove reservation
We Support 2nd Gen Reservation 🔥
👍🏼
Bhai reservation shi h ek dum.. tum casteism wapas leke dkho bhai phle phr reservation ki baat hogi
We support 2nd generation reservation ❤@hemant_showw
👍🏼👍🏼