The cinematic potential of the Parshendi language... Ominous, huge sounds, thunderous voices. Starting small, growing louder, the rumbling, shaking of the theater during the creation of the first everstorm. Think of it.
I can't see the language being completely musically sung. Brando did say that non singers can't really pick up on the meaning. Which means it's kinda subtle. Which means it's most likely minute tonal shifts in their voice and intonation.
@@mikemigasproduction you could pull a tolkein and say "your human ears just can't pick it up" lol. If you were watching this and you were a singer youd understand. In all honesty I would personally have them talk and add a subtle humming sound anytime they talk. The hum will be in different key depending on their rhythm. Like C major for victory, Eb Major for reprimand, A major for joy, etc. these are emotional connections we already associate to musical keys
@@ninnusridhar No, I'm pretty sure it's just rhythm and not intonation and tonal shifts. The part where Brandon said that humans can't pick up on the meaning is where he also said "they can pick up a Rhythm even if there's not enough of it" and "if it's only a couple words being said." To me, that clearly implies that 1. the different Rhythms are kinda long, at least 10 notes or so that repeat 2. if you only say a few words in a particular Rhythm, it could sound exactly the same as the same words in a different Rhythm, because you're only using a couple notes of it 3. Singers can pick up on the difference even if they sound the same, because they have a magical connection to the Rhythms of the planet, and other Singers can magically sense the intent of another Singer through a shared Connection of their Investiture. So humans _could_ learn to hear the difference if Singers said entire sentences in a row in the same Rhythm, but not if it's just a few words, because, as Brandon said "there is not enough information there" in that case. And you don't have the magical connection to the Rhythms to help you distinguish them. I'm also pretty sure that if you recorded just a few words, the Singers also couldn't distinguish the exact Rhythm anymore if you play it back to them, because the recorder doesn't have the magical Connection necessary for that. (And you'd probably also be replaying the recording out of sync with the current Rhythm of the planet)
how the evil Russian stereotype started:
ruclips.net/video/YJOKoOCYhoY/видео.html
The cinematic potential of the Parshendi language... Ominous, huge sounds, thunderous voices. Starting small, growing louder, the rumbling, shaking of the theater during the creation of the first everstorm. Think of it.
when will we get the adaptation? i'd really like sth in style of Arcane
@hearthemovies I've got the cast picked out in my head. Javier Bardem as Dalinar, Michael Shannon as Torol Sadeas.
I can't see the language being completely musically sung. Brando did say that non singers can't really pick up on the meaning. Which means it's kinda subtle.
Which means it's most likely minute tonal shifts in their voice and intonation.
Yeah unless the director would want otherwise lol but no, I think the same but it would have to be maybe a bit more obvious for the viewer too
@@mikemigasproduction you could pull a tolkein and say "your human ears just can't pick it up" lol. If you were watching this and you were a singer youd understand.
In all honesty I would personally have them talk and add a subtle humming sound anytime they talk. The hum will be in different key depending on their rhythm.
Like C major for victory, Eb Major for reprimand, A major for joy, etc. these are emotional connections we already associate to musical keys
@@ninnusridhar No, I'm pretty sure it's just rhythm and not intonation and tonal shifts.
The part where Brandon said that humans can't pick up on the meaning is where he also said "they can pick up a Rhythm even if there's not enough of it" and "if it's only a couple words being said." To me, that clearly implies that
1. the different Rhythms are kinda long, at least 10 notes or so that repeat
2. if you only say a few words in a particular Rhythm, it could sound exactly the same as the same words in a different Rhythm, because you're only using a couple notes of it
3. Singers can pick up on the difference even if they sound the same, because they have a magical connection to the Rhythms of the planet, and other Singers can magically sense the intent of another Singer through a shared Connection of their Investiture.
So humans _could_ learn to hear the difference if Singers said entire sentences in a row in the same Rhythm, but not if it's just a few words, because, as Brandon said "there is not enough information there" in that case. And you don't have the magical connection to the Rhythms to help you distinguish them.
I'm also pretty sure that if you recorded just a few words, the Singers also couldn't distinguish the exact Rhythm anymore if you play it back to them, because the recorder doesn't have the magical Connection necessary for that. (And you'd probably also be replaying the recording out of sync with the current Rhythm of the planet)
I’m pretty sure that when they speak alethi, it’s just like they intone certain syllables and stuff to make it fitt the rytms
I think you are in a good track, these are concepts that i think could make into a movie. I liked the video a lot!!!
Thanks, I wonder when we get to see the adaptations
Think hindtva polyryhtms, work/marching songs.
Zoey Saldana Venli Zoey Saldana Venli