Hey, I like your album. It has become an attractive version. Good job! I feel somewhat qualified to judge, because I have been a fan of Pink Floyd since childhood and know their entire oeuvre and because I also make music and upload it to RUclips. so I know the fiddling with sounds and notes. Moreover, I have no bias at all with AI: if you want and can use it, then do it. I hope you make more.
Thanks so much for your input! The fact is that no matter how resourceful I tools may be, one indeed needs to know a genre quite well to get "the sound and feel" of it. By default AI will either try to keep a continuity in melodies and chord progressions, which is not what you may want when working on something in the style of Pink Floyd. Thus some genres such as blues, country or R&B will benefit from it, but prog or psychedelic rock are more of a struggle. Once again I deeply appreciate your comment!
Thanks for the comment. Yes , despite the very « artificial » nature of the tool itself, I try to reflect a 500% human perspective in those songs, and « Faust » is indeed quite accurate when it comes to the vanity of so many of the things we all fall for!
Gracias vosotros hacéis que sean más grandes ,pero no quiero decir que lo hagáis mal es que son inrepetibles,no va a ser la última que os oiga , saludos y salud
Great album! Very Pink Floyd - like music. Can you tell us which parts were made with AI tools and which traditionally? Songwriting? Voices? Instruments? Mixing?... Thanks friend!
Thanks a lot! A second one is in the making. Basically the song lyrics are written by me, based on a synopsis I made as if it was for a short movie about a man facing a struggle that forces him to reevaluate his entire view of the worls and of his own microcosm. In the end he goes back to the vlues he learned as a child and acknowledge that it is the only way to happiness. It then evolved into songs, within the whole "concept album" paradigm. "The Mind Trap" is the result of that process. AI was used to render the songs. Even though you cannot really instruct it how you want the songs to sound "note by note", you can prompt it to get the proper feel and instrumentation for each song, and "refuse" all the propositions it comes up with until it offers something close enough to what you envisionned. Then you can control the melodic structure, the intensity, the "when and where" to put the harmonies, guitar break, sound effects etc. Thus a song like "The Fall" sounds very depressed and it serves the purpose of both the story and the lyrics. By opposition, "Redemption" gets a treatment where the mood is serene from the very start, with it's soft accoustic guitar intro, and its triumphal ending. Once I had the results I worked for, I imported everything in N-Track to create the album, inserting sound effects, masterig the songs and editing it when needed, with all the fadings between each titles. Hope it helps!
@@TheRetroBeatRepository I see. But the creative process is mainly yours. And is a very good work. I give you the credits not only for the composition, but the entire concept you created. Good work, keep on! Thaks!
@@TheRetroBeatRepository also somewhere towards the end of the album I heard Fish singing (ex Marillion). I have to listen again, it's a spectacular work! Thank you for sharing it!
@@TheRetroBeatRepository ovviamente il mio commento è basato su gusti personali....ci mancherebbe. la musica è universale in quanto ognuno può godere di ogni performance....ben vengano tutti i post e le varie innovazioni...però ribadisco il concetto che una macchina per quanto perfetta possa essere non arriverà mai al genio umano. buona musica a tutti
@@grambag7956 I don't even know why I bother answering you. Read the op and my post! Obviously you hate RW's Redux, and maybe my assumption is closer to the truth than yours. So, back to my opinion, AI doesn't kill music! People who use it wrongly, they do. It's not the case here.
In all honesty, I believe that grambag7956 is actually arguing with the person who said "AI kill music" and you might be on the same side of the fence on this one ;)
@@TheRetroBeatRepository If it's that so, then it's my bad and I apologize. The only danger of AI "assisted" music creation is overproduction. Too much of a good thing may turn into a bad thing and you have competitors too. So, careful on the "inflation" keep up the good work!
Absolutely brilliant. Love this, its so well done. Congratulations on an amazing project, beautifully done.
Thanks a lot!
Wow ... I really enjoyed this. From a lifelong Pink Floyd fan, I say congratulations and well done.
Hey, I like your album. It has become an attractive version. Good job! I feel somewhat qualified to judge, because I have been a fan of Pink Floyd since childhood and know their entire oeuvre and because I also make music and upload it to RUclips. so I know the fiddling with sounds and notes. Moreover, I have no bias at all with AI: if you want and can use it, then do it. I hope you make more.
Thanks so much for your input! The fact is that no matter how resourceful I tools may be, one indeed needs to know a genre quite well to get "the sound and feel" of it. By default AI will either try to keep a continuity in melodies and chord progressions, which is not what you may want when working on something in the style of Pink Floyd. Thus some genres such as blues, country or R&B will benefit from it, but prog or psychedelic rock are more of a struggle.
Once again I deeply appreciate your comment!
David, Richard and Roger need to hear this masterwork.
Thanks so much! I so much wish they would
where are Richard and Roger
😊😊😊😊😊😊@@TheRetroBeatRepository
Hello from France, ok for these 3 remaining guys but I'm afraid Syd can't do this ...
Got to say I;m quite surprised by the quality of this project. Got that 70's Floyd vibe. Thank you.
Thanks a whole lot for your good words. It's worth the world to me!
This wonderful wow💜💜💜
🎸🎸🎸🎹🎹🎹
Thanks a lot!
The end of "The Fall" has a very "genesis" sound to it :)
Indeed!
Hello from France, do you mean "Selling England by the Pound" ?
Holy crap I needed to hear Faust when I did.
It saved me heartache.
Thanks for the comment. Yes , despite the very « artificial » nature of the tool itself, I try to reflect a 500% human perspective in those songs, and « Faust » is indeed quite accurate when it comes to the vanity of so many of the things we all fall for!
By the way, I like synthesizers very much ...
excellent ..!! thanx
Thanks to you for listening and commenting!
@@TheRetroBeatRepository my pleasure!
Best AI/human Floyd... definitely wonderful
Красиво! 😊
Спасибо!
❣️
Gracias vosotros hacéis que sean más grandes ,pero no quiero decir que lo hagáis mal es que son inrepetibles,no va a ser la última que os oiga , saludos y salud
Great album! Very Pink Floyd - like music. Can you tell us which parts were made with AI tools and which traditionally? Songwriting? Voices? Instruments? Mixing?... Thanks friend!
Thanks a lot! A second one is in the making.
Basically the song lyrics are written by me, based on a synopsis I made as if it was for a short movie about a man facing a struggle that forces him to reevaluate his entire view of the worls and of his own microcosm. In the end he goes back to the vlues he learned as a child and acknowledge that it is the only way to happiness. It then evolved into songs, within the whole "concept album" paradigm. "The Mind Trap" is the result of that process.
AI was used to render the songs. Even though you cannot really instruct it how you want the songs to sound "note by note", you can prompt it to get the proper feel and instrumentation for each song, and "refuse" all the propositions it comes up with until it offers something close enough to what you envisionned. Then you can control the melodic structure, the intensity, the "when and where" to put the harmonies, guitar break, sound effects etc.
Thus a song like "The Fall" sounds very depressed and it serves the purpose of both the story and the lyrics. By opposition, "Redemption" gets a treatment where the mood is serene from the very start, with it's soft accoustic guitar intro, and its triumphal ending. Once I had the results I worked for, I imported everything in N-Track to create the album, inserting sound effects, masterig the songs and editing it when needed, with all the fadings between each titles.
Hope it helps!
@@TheRetroBeatRepository I see. But the creative process is mainly yours. And is a very good work. I give you the credits not only for the composition, but the entire concept you created. Good work, keep on! Thaks!
@@enriquejuarez3409 Thanks so much for your good words
Light is Syd
It is more « mystical » in tone than the other songs on the album so you are most probably right.
@@TheRetroBeatRepository also somewhere towards the end of the album I heard Fish singing (ex Marillion). I have to listen again, it's a spectacular work! Thank you for sharing it!
A.I. ......meglio ascoltare uno dei miei vinili consumati.....nessuna macchina potrà mai avvicinare le emozioni che un vero artista può dare!!!!!
A ciascuno il suo
@@TheRetroBeatRepository ovviamente il mio commento è basato su gusti personali....ci mancherebbe. la musica è universale in quanto ognuno può godere di ogni performance....ben vengano tutti i post e le varie innovazioni...però ribadisco il concetto che una macchina per quanto perfetta possa essere non arriverà mai al genio umano. buona musica a tutti
Похоже на elo😊
Who is singing?
AI rendering of my lyric, and "rendering" bending to a maximum, until I get the melody/intonations/emotions I had envisionned.
AI kills music
As you can hear, it does not!
Obviously you don't know pink Floyd and or didn't listen to it.
@@grambag7956 I don't even know why I bother answering you. Read the op and my post! Obviously you hate RW's Redux, and maybe my assumption is closer to the truth than yours. So, back to my opinion, AI doesn't kill music! People who use it wrongly, they do. It's not the case here.
In all honesty, I believe that grambag7956 is actually arguing with the person who said "AI kill music" and you might be on the same side of the fence on this one ;)
@@TheRetroBeatRepository If it's that so, then it's my bad and I apologize. The only danger of AI "assisted" music creation is overproduction. Too much of a good thing may turn into a bad thing and you have competitors too. So, careful on the "inflation" keep up the good work!
Mah...