The second movement of Brahms’ Second Symphony is such a fascinating movement full of ambiguity. Even from the upbeat of the first bar, you never really discover what key it’s supposed to be in. Is it B major or G# minor? This piece was my first introduction to orchestral music back in 1993 playing 2nd oboe at the ripe old age of 13. I can tell you, it was a bit of a revelation. Such a great choice for Mr Zander to choose to reveal the passion and torment of Brahms. And it ties in so well to the Cello Sonata in E minor. Thank you and well done!
@@petermarin BOOOOM! Ivan the necromancer is here to necro this thread to explain the comment. The title of the video originally said concerto not sonata, that's what caused all the confused comments. At some point later the mistake was corrected by the channel owners.
@Millefeuille: Hey, I am the cellist from the video. I'm always open to constructive criticism because I want to constantly get better and better in what I do. Could you please be more specific about what you didn't like about me? I'm happy to listen to you. So are other listeners. Thank you.
You're kidding surely...sight reading in front of an audience...working out the fingering alone in the time shows this guy's musicality. It was compelling to watch and very impressive.
Thank you everybody for listening to my cello playing! 🙏🏼
Thank you so much for playing for us. Loved your spirit coming through your music.
You really came to life and the improvement was remarkable.
Well played, both your videos 👏 best of wishes man, very nice to watch
you are a wonderful musician, humble and honest. Thumbs up!
It was an absolute pleasure sir. Thank you :)
Benjamin finds a sincere but very understanding and nice way to respond to an error. That's really part of the greatness of a teacher.
I watch Benjamin Zander every time I need enthusiasm and inspiration for my own work :) This is so contagious!
I see two people talking to each other with music. With passion and love
Beautiful playing, humble, full of emotion. A treat to hear.
Just found this amazing channel, thanks for uploading and thanks to Mr Benjamin Zander
The second movement of Brahms’ Second Symphony is such a fascinating movement full of ambiguity. Even from the upbeat of the first bar, you never really discover what key it’s supposed to be in. Is it B major or G# minor? This piece was my first introduction to orchestral music back in 1993 playing 2nd oboe at the ripe old age of 13. I can tell you, it was a bit of a revelation. Such a great choice for Mr Zander to choose to reveal the passion and torment of Brahms. And it ties in so well to the Cello Sonata in E minor. Thank you and well done!
The cellist is so Cool! Good rendition Lukasz :)
Dina is like Tinker Bell. She can magically find her way to any music.
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
6:50 I'm seating in my room and I felt the urge to get up and clap lol
If Master Benjamín Zander will be a RUclipsr, hel will be 'the bomb'
Will there ever be a piano solo masterclass?
He has a few if you search his name. Choosing your World talks have at least 1
Becky P thank you!
Love it when the glasses almost fall off from enthusiasm, e.g.15:55
Thank you so much this was amazing!!!
Awesome!! 😁
Cool stuff! When will we get to see a bass master class?
There was one
Forgot the title but there is
BOI send me the title when you find it.
For a brief moment I thought a somehow hidden Cello Concerto by Brahms had suddenly been discovered... then came the disappointment :(
What do you mean
@@petermarin BOOOOM! Ivan the necromancer is here to necro this thread to explain the comment. The title of the video originally said concerto not sonata, that's what caused all the confused comments. At some point later the mistake was corrected by the channel owners.
@@ivan_says_hi I'm laughing so hard with your introduction hahahahahhaha thank you
Beautiful emotion
"Who am I to think Brahms meant something else? I think he meant something else." lol
Video title states concerto rather than sonata, otherwise a wonderful masterclass thank you for uploading
Thank you!
Great video and very inspiring for me 👍🏼
16:44 I looked the same :DDDDDDDD
He is so cute and intelligent
I don't even like this piece & the guy is fundamentally beautifully talented
Why is the cellist so bad
Chill
@Millefeuille: Hey, I am the cellist from the video. I'm always open to constructive criticism because I want to constantly get better and better in what I do. Could you please be more specific about what you didn't like about me? I'm happy to listen to you. So are other listeners. Thank you.
Łukasz Pawlikowski Your intonation is too unstable for the fact that you’re in a masterclass with such a professional.
@@millefeuille2680 Zander would have said that in the masterclass if it were
You're kidding surely...sight reading in front of an audience...working out the fingering alone in the time shows this guy's musicality. It was compelling to watch and very impressive.