Teenager is Shot by Police After Accurately Following Their Orders | Savannah Graziano Case Analysis
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 апр 2024
- This video answers the question: Can I analyze case of Savannah Graziano?
Support Dr. Grande on Patreon: / drgrande
Subscribe to the Bella Grande Media Podcast: / @bellagrandemedia
Dr. Grande’s book Harm Reduction:
www.amazon.com/Harm-Reduction...
Dr. Grande's book Psychology of Notorious Serial Killers: www.amazon.com/Psychology-Not...
Check out Dr. Grande’s merchandise at: teespring.com/stores/dr-grand...
![Shoreline Mafia - HEAT STICK (OHGEESY & FENIX FLEXIN) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xKEY6THtwuA/mqdefault.jpg)
Following police directions so you don't get shot.
Still get shot.
> still get shot
> police still get funded
Her Dad created that situation
@KingfishStevens-di9ji and the cops handled it in the worst way possible leading to the child's death.
Don't be a bootlicker and ignore the obvious procedural issues that led to an Innocent person's death.
Reminds me of that guy in the hotel who was offed by the cops after following their every order and begging for his life.
@@KingfishStevens-di9ji her dad didn't shoot her, and he clearly knew how to shoot people
Police investigated themselves and concluded, "Nothing to see here..."
And withheld footage from the public for 18 months.
Per usual…
Democrats said : after trump , election
you must need to take your meds dude. @@danielkim6092
What a surprise they’re usually so accountable 🫠
Partially to blame? They shot her dead. She was a 15 year old minor and she was following instructions. She was an innocent child. Its disgusting they are blaming her!
Do you wear combat fatigues on a daily basis? How bout the gunshot from the passenger car. Putting all this aside it's dad who brought on the shootout. At the very worst the cops had bad communication. Sometimes kids get damaged because their parents do something stupid. Happens.
@@bobbobertson7568 how do you know the father didn’t make her ? The fact of the matter they gave her instructions and then shot her
@@mr.denzelsausageton9719 This is a pretty silly argument. If someone is shooting at a cop I don't think who inspired said shooting, whether it's themselves, Dad, Jesus, etc. matters. They are trying to KILL the cops, they have every right to be on guard and defend themselves
@@bobbobertson7568when she was out of the vehicle was she shooting at a cop? No, she wasn’t. Did the cops who pulled the trigger follow their own engagement procedures? No. Did the cops that shot her act like a bunch of thugs with an uncoordinated response? Yes. Do we train our police on how to handle tense situations like this? Yes. Did any of these so called *professional* people act with any *professionalism*? No.
@@chrisl4999 The cops were positioned at various distances in the midst of a dangerous shoot out. Communication break down, mistakes happened in a very dangerous situation. You demand perfection from cops who put their life on the line every day, and you turn a blind eye to criminals who created the situation in the first place. You have a pretty demented way of viewing things.
While concealing this footage for two years, The sheriff gave a press conference and knowingly lied about the girl being an armed accomplice to her father during the gunfight with LE.
She was shooting at the cops
@@DemePoole Not at the time the piggies executed her.
At the time of the murder, she had surrendered and was following the piggies “lawful orders.”
@@DemePoole no she wasn’t….you can clearly hear in the body cam that she was unarmed and was following orders from police when she was killed. Why the hell are people still saying that lie even after the footage was released proving otherwise??
2 years. WTF.
@@DemePoole seems like your throat leaves those boots with an immaculate shine
Their mission was to save a kidnapped teen, but they gunned her down?!? I’ve never screamed nor been more infuriated as when I heard this story. We live in an age of utter incompetence and true IDIOCRACY!
🙄 They didn't "gun her down." It was a miscommunication. It's awful, but don't pretend like they were like, "HEY GUYS, LET'S KILL THIS KID, YEAH!!!"
It was a highly volatile situation, shots had been fired from both the passenger and driver, and a mistake was made. Cops are still people. No one wanted this outcome.
@@TigersandBearsOhMy Sorry, but she was the hostage and the priority and those inexperienced officers were trigger happy and driven by adrenaline and emotion and NOT FOCUSED on their priority, which was simultaneously putting bystanders lives at risk to save a kid. If she fired from the vehicle, she had to, he was putting her life at risk the entire time and had just murdered her mother. She was a hostage and a minor. They ABSOLUTELY needed constant communication and “Hostage is exiting passenger side. I’m having her come towards me. Hold fire towards passenger side.” Obviously! They needed way more training.
@@TigersandBearsOhMy officer safety first!
@@comingoutspinster-rebellik1479 Yeah, well, their priorities might have changed somewhat when the kidnapping "victim" started shooting at police cars and innocent motorists.
Yes, it's complete incompetence. Someone needs to go to specsavers, and some officers need to get a different job. A trigger happy cop that can't listen to fellow officers has no place on the force. Outrageous is an understatement.
The police are absolutely accountable. The killed a 15 year old girl who was running to an officer for help
Its nothing but Murder...
The cop should be in jail...
No excuses....
She wasn’t running to them for help.
She surrendered and lay down on the ground. They TOLD HER TO GET UP and go towards them and then murdered her for doing it.
Running for help lol. She was just shooting at them.
@@user-qb9fv3bf2d police only say that shit to "justify" them murdering her, and trying to save their own skin.
@@user-qb9fv3bf2dshe wasn’t tho
Poor kid. Instead of protecting a child from her homicidal dad, the cops killed her themselves when she did exactly what they told her.
But muh police safety! A scared unarmed 15 year old girl was walking towards one of the cops so they had to take her out for his safety.
Don't be a know it all, she just as well was one of the shooters against the cops with her father. You must be sexist, if the kid was a guy you'd be more inclined to think he was a threat to the cops, just cuz it is a girl you think "she" is so innocent. No one had a clue if she had something to do with the mother being shot or not. Cops have the right to defend themselves. She was with her father of her own free will, knew he killed her mother, she went with the father and into a store and bought 2 sodas and her father let her go obviously trusting she wouldn't rat him out. Why would anyone assume she was purely innocent? Just because she is a girl? You don't even know if she was a gang member. What kind of girl goes with her father, I am sure he exhibited violent traits before he shot the wife!
@@commonsense2680 username doesn't check out
Pigs addresses all 7 of them are on reddit right now.. lol
@@commonsense2680They must be sexist because you said so? How do know their opinion would be different if it was a boy? As far as wether she was innocent or guilty is entirely irrelevant. She was following instructions and wasn't a threat. There's nothing commonsense about your comment.
The life this poor girl had to live, only to die so senselessly. Tragic.
Exactly..
That was my thought too 💔
Very sad
was she not also shooting ? he mentioned gun shots coming from the passenger side window.
@@Hypno_BPM So what?
That arrest was incompetent to the max. The cops on each side of the suspect's car put themselves in a crossfire situation. Not only did they shoot the kidnapped victim, but also at least four police bullets hit other police cars.
A complete "Taliban Wedding".
@@BIGxJIMxSLADE .You -= reported.
@@RullXovImagine logging onto the Internet to report others. I can tell you love your life and other people like you.
@@Votd66 You contradict yourself..🙄
Bounce, amateur troll.
@@RullXov Go take a Midol and change your tampon, princess.
If an officer gave an order and the victim got shot by another officer because she obeyed such order, the police is obviously to blame, whether there was intent or mere negligence. The officers up the embankement were there strictly for support against a possible escape attempt, they had absolutely no business interfering with the arrest perimeter. There’s simply no justification to such conduct, and if law enforcement be allowed such broad leeway of interpretation, no operation will ever be safe. To argue that the victim should’ve behaved otherwise is idle speculation, as she was just following orders - it should be stressed: ORDERS, NOT MERE INSTRUCTIONS.
This is beyond outrageous, the officers MURDERED this girl.
Cops are trained that anyone, of any age, can be armed. Makes them jumpy.
But at least she wasnt black so nobody will care 🤬
@@conscientiousobserver8772 anyone, of any age, CAN be armed and can kill you in a second.
@@conscientiousobserver8772 "I'm going home to my family, no matter what!" Officer safety is higher than the constitution.
Add to that ,for over the past decade ,and longer,tens of thousands of cops have been trained in Israel by the idf. They have totally been indoctrinated in the COMPLY OR DIE dictum. The main n facilitator of this aberration, has been the adl.
Cops: we investigated ourselves and found we are gods"
ACAB
Basically. The police in the USA are trigger happy psychopaths
You don't mind politicians using law to go after political opposition like trump right. Criminal justice reform lol you guys don't care how hypocrite you look
@@phillipmartinez9232 What? Using the law to go after law breakers is what the law is used for.
@@icin4d except all the criminal on left literally Hillary on intent, lol and Biden not competent to stand trial weird same classified documents, the Georgia case is joke falling apart because super corrupt da if it was anyone else a black guy for instance which they were supporting trump in Atlanta talking how corrupt local da is look it up, the fake ny document case never been charged ever and on and on only someone with tds could say its all good so cops can't investigate themselves but your political enemies who hate more than hate itself could I love leftwing hypocrisy its so blatant hence so many leaving democrat party and you guys can't see had not for fake cases and they're are still losing most say lol imagine with out but me and alot I was democrat all my life by way but police state is police state going after someone you hate ut never ends there than its anyone who criticise them. And they already have been. Slippery slope, reason that never happened but in sure he was only president whi ever committed crime in telling you guys leave the bubble becaue un real world this and many other look bad it has converted people to trump not opposite and than more hypocrisy saying how great it is under Biden lol and how bad it was under trump lol that is clear sign of delusion or blatant lying to justify the means . Again im sure if same info came out like kn Georgia case for instance but it was anyone else but trump or anyone associated with him. Say a innocent black man I think we all know answer. Keep it up tho like Israel issue anyone who want Palestinian to keep suffering keep supporting iran and their puppets lol it has worked out great so far. I actually wanted them to be liberated for real not live under brutal radical dictatorship like taliban or isis, hamas, iran.
Cops consistently yell confusing and conflicting commands. One yeller at a scene guys.
They're all yeller.
But they are all on a power trip though
Who gets to decide which person gets to do the yelling in the heat of the moment? The smartest person?
Like the video of that poor guy (who was an exterminator) and staying in a hotel when some nosy MF called in that he had an assault rifle or something when it was a BB gun for shooting rodents. They allegedly saw him with it through the curtain partially when he was in his room and they were down at the pool, begging the question of how they deemed him a threat?
Then they have him in the hallway and he is clearly not armed but they were all screaming a deadly game of Simon Says. Kneeling, crawling, etc. and eventually killing him. For a BB gun glimpsed through a window at a distance.
@@marquisdelafayette1929
Daniel Shaver was drunk and pointing what looked like a rifle outside a hotel window. Calling the police for that is perfectly normal. Pointing firearms outside windows is not normal and incredibly irresponsible. Of course Swat will show up after we’ve already seen hotel window mass shooters like in Vegas. Then the dipshit kept reaching at his waistband after being warned not to. Why is it that the other guest wasn’t shot? Because she didn’t reach for her waistband.
The incompetence demonstrated by the cops in handling what was clearly a very high-stakes hostage situation rises to the level of CRIMINAL.
I dont think you have been trained in law. Crime requires intent. Incompetence is just that, an incapable actor. It doesnt become criminal because someone died from their lack of capacity.
@@rickjames5998 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_negligence
Victim wearing tactical gear and firing at LEO
@@twocents7495her father just unalived her mother, could she have been afraid her father would unalive her if she didn't go along?
@@rickjames5998 your statement is particularly ironic considering I'm a law graduate. But okay, you do you 😅 maybe I don't measure up to your standards, an honours degree and five years of studies be damned because some stranger on RUclips didn't agree with my opinion on a video.. a video about a case that neither of us have first-hand knowledge of.
Don't get me wrong, I respect differences of opinion, what I don't understand, however, is speculation about the credentials somebody holds (or lack thereof).
You'd be surprised how easy It is to refrain from being presumptive, while respectfully disagreeing with a stranger on the internet. I know this isn't reddit, and also that the age of forums and proper debate is long past, but maybe you can try it sometime in the RUclips comments section, too. Who knows, we can perhaps make this a more civilized platform someday?
This is unacceptable.. Rest in Peace Savanna 🌻
this sounds about as peaceful her life has ever been. when its over. sad story.
With the technology available today, it's negligent that they weren't ALL in communication. All it takes is one angry officer.
Incompetent
They all had radios, but no bodycams.
@@Naptosishow’s that even possible in the 2020s. At this point they all should have to wear them and leave them on at all times while on duty.
@@HeatherHoltresistance from police unions and chronic underfunding would be my two guesses
more like frightened
What an evil man. It’s weird she lived in a car with the dad rather than at home with her mom and brother, but for him to use her in his murder scheme is horrific.
Blood-boilingly monumental dereliction.
Rogan had this retired cop that talked about the lack of training they get.
No MMA training, and a couple of weeks of gun training, and you're off to the streets.
It's deeply disturbing.
Why would they get MMA training?😂
@@faythknowmore Really? Look at cops using jujitsu in order to take down a suspect.
Seems like MMA would be a bonus, not a requirement. The tasers and guns have a similar effect.
@@faythknowmoreYou honestly don't think learning grappling skills would be beneficial for cops?
Yes, and they don't get much if any training on what the public's civil rights are either! Which is why they routinely violate them.
The poor boy lost both his parents and his sister... so sad
This is so disturbing. They took her down like a dog in the street. They should be held accountable but… we know they won’t!!! They even said she was a criminal - a child - get real! It’s infuriating.
I think there’s a federal investigation on it though ?
They "protected and served" her alright. Thank god for the Amber Alert system. Her father could have seriously harmed her. Thank god the cops showed in time to "protect and serve" her.
😮
So, cops.. wearing tactical gear, see someone else wearing tactical gear, and think it's a sign of aggression? And they still wonder why people think they're aggressive thugs.
Well that's part of the cops job. To protect and serve. Was Savannah a cop at large or something? Otherwise why was SHE wearing that attire?
@@bobbobertson7568protect themselves and serve the government first, corporations second, and people third.
@@jackdanson2 You planning to get in a gun fight with cops with your kids in the passenger seat? No? Then you have nothing to worry about.
@@jackdanson2 How do you figure that?
@@bobbobertson7568
All legally owned attire.
A Cops job is to Catch NOT Kill......Unless Cop means Assassin
I've seldom seen such dimwitted policing. This is what happens when you hire your family members because they're unemployed.
Completely inept. No plan, no training.
This is heartbreaking. I can't stop thinking about savannahs brother who's lost everyone.
This is terrible, that poor girl.
Heartbreaking enough, watching them gun down Savannah, but the attempts to cover it up are horrifying !😪
Criminals are everywhere. I have no friends and barely leave the house.
@@verbalkint1770don’t live in fear friend. Good people are still out there and are plentiful… a healthy fear of people is good, just don’t let it rule you!
youre not safe there either theyre in the walls !@@verbalkint1770
She wasn't "gunned down". She was participating in a crime and incompetent law enforcement officers accidentally killed her.
@@verbalkint1770 It's awful, but your chances of being victimised by a criminal or the police are still low. 🤍
Hopefully this will help end the "if the officer perceives danger" arguments. Just because you think a little girl is an armed 45 year old man that doesnt mean it was justified
"Officer safety" is Officer cowardice.
@@nuclearmedicineman6270 Which was the massacre that police waited outside a school to let a murderer execute as many kids and teachers as he could, and stopped parents from trying to save their children?
There are so many in the USA, I forget.
@@Naptosisuvdale - what another complete clusterfk of 🐱🐱🐱🐱 cops!!
"She's coming right for us!!!!"
@@nuclearmedicineman6270what's especially egregious is they can't even claim officer safety with that crossfire they set themselves up with.
The policeman who directed the girl was negligent for having much faith in the competence of the other cops. Police need to receive training that includes being educated on how incompetent their brothers-in-blue can often be.
police receiving proper training AND using it? don't make me laugh
You don’t get it do you?
Nobody wants to be a cop when they know just how stupid and poorly trained the other cops around them are.
You mean more training than the 2hrs of annual mandatory firearms training. And the qualification doesn’t go beyond 15yd line. Only a 50rd course where 80 is passing. 😂😂😂
If recorded video is not released same day , you know cops did something wrong.. If they did everything correct that video is released that same day.
What police footage are you getting same day that the rest of don't?
What a tragedy for a young girl💔
The tragedy started with a lack of condoms
FL Cop: hears an acorn fall and thinks he's being shot at, executes two combat rolls & promptly unloads his clip into his own vehicle (luckily nobody was hurt, how that's possible IDK)
CA Cop: girl is obeying orders so they shoot and kill her
Kind of paints "from sea to shining sea" in a new and terrible light.
Cops out here acting like Is real ees "from sea to shining sea, America will not be free" this place is turning into a lawless (or maybe too many laws, for the proletariat anyway while the elite and authority figures wearing their jackboots obey zero laws) hellscape.
How tragic. The police and fathers should be the ones protecting young girls.
Sadly we can’t ever depend on anyone to protect anyone else ever 💔
Too many police officers are only interested in protecting themselves and their positions of power. Children come after that unfortunately...
Men like to claim they're protectors of women and children, but all they continue to prove is that we're statistically safer staying away from them.
It is the job of a parent to protect their children. It is the job of police officers to protect and serve. They are in positions of power. I’m glad that Dr. Grande holds people accountable.
@@elizabethhamm5320 He didn’t hold them accountable.
He might’ve subjected them to some light mockery, but at the end of the day he soft-pedaled them.
Nothin says “hey I make great decisions” like a poorly done neck tattoo.
As someone without tattoos: can we please stop equating tattoos to intelligence, criminality or morality? Lots of people get bad tattoos without it meaning shit, even neck tattoos . They’re more common now. It’s just part of modern culture
This guy is disgusting full-stop tho, not defending the father
@@NickolaiPetrovitchdon't call human beings monsters! Especially damaged ones! Aint you lucky!
Hey Shiv ❤❤❤
@@NickolaiPetrovitch Tattoos are ugly, disgusting and demonic. Never trust anyone who has a tattoo.
@@raspberrykitten6676 what ? And you have no idea about my life lol
I think we are on the same side, chill
Lesson : If you are being held hostage, do not walk / run toward the Police, no matter what you are told.
I mean to be fair when your attacker is right there the last thing you want to do is be next to him or even remotely close. Especially if he could shoot you, it's pathetic that this happened to her
Who fired the shot? Their silence is deafening
The coverup is worst than the crime
Does it matter? She was told to walk toward them. If you don't do as they say, they shoot you. If you do as they say, they shoot you. So why does it matter if she was walking toward them or not? She would get shot anyway.
It's like if you're on a ship that's sinking, get up on deck with a life jacket no matter what the crew tell you to do. Their default response to an emergency is to tell you to go sit in your cabin and wait. That's where the body recovery divers will find you if you obey.
NOBODY had Savanah's best interests at heart. Neither her parents or the police
American cops seem to shout before they think.
While this may be true, it’s not really fair compare this to other countries since there are so many guns there. In my country I haven’t seen a private citizen gun in 30 years. You can’t advocate for gun freedom and expect the cops to behave like they’re from Switzerland or Australia. It’s unreasonable. If everyone may potentially have a gun then of course it’s a different playing field for cops. US cops do a lot of stupid shit for sure but why is the gun debate always non existent when it comes to police-side misbehavior. It’s all part of a broader and very broken system.
@@pablosskates7067Australia used to have as many private guns as America but never had the killings. We got rid of most guns (well at least the broader gun ownership as there is still a lot of guns) after a particular massacre performed by a literal madman. US gun culture is a bit mad. Gun safety is the least of it.
@@pablosskates7067 That's a nice circular excuse, but it's not even true. Gun ownership per capita is also high in e.g. Canada, over a quarter that of the United States, but this tyoe of cop behaviour is still rare there.
Furthermore, gun ownership in your own example of Switzerland is almost a quarter that of the United States, and things like this are virtually unheard of.
Guna are bad, but Americans are really bad.
@@icturner23 ok fair enough. I’ve never lived in a country where anyone had guns so gun culture and all its implications is new to me.
@@pablosskates7067 There is no excuse. There needs to be federal standards for rules of engagement for the police, and there isn't. It's state by state. For instance, in Tennessee, where I live, there is no mandatory training at all, all you need to be a cop here is to have graduated from high school, or have a GED, and have maintained a job for a year. Any job. We actually have cops shoot the victims all the time, and often, if you call a cop, they will arrest you, because you're the closest and easiest one to get a hold of, and they can say they're done.
Those Police aren't cut out to be Law Enforcement. And the father was trash..
There always seems to be a big rush with many of these incidents.
Cops need to be trained to take their time and calm down.
And don’t lie and cover up abuse. I think they desperately need people to dumb down the fact that this is why some people don’t trust them. And if they want to change the public perception, they need to shape up and stop being so narcissistic/entitled.
They are there for the adrenaline rush and the power trip
Cops dont have the IQ level required to learn anything above 4th grade level IMO
Their “qualified immunity” will guarantee that none of her killers will spend a day in jail.
It's evident that they want to sweep this under the rug, now we need to start the ball rolling by contacting the DA's office in San Bernardino.
cry
@@hyznbrg66 Wow, you're so smart!
BEHIND BELIEF, THEY KILL AN INNOCENT GIRL THAT WAS FALLOWED THE POLICE DIRECTION. A BLATANT DEPLORABLE COVER UP. THY ARE ALL GUILTY SHAME ON YOU.
@@hyznbrg66 thats exactly what a bad-cop would say...
All those cops and no body cam footage of them killing the child...this is so suspect
the bodycam footage shows the cops did nothing wrong, that's why they don't need to release it
@@allancouceiro9255 They killed a kid
I guess you're okay with that
@@Simonisms I was being sarcastic.
Cluster****. Lousy communication. Poor planning. And probably a bit of panic.
The over-obsession with their own safety of some law enforcement officers makes them a potentially unreasonable danger to those they supposedly serve.
Uvalde?
So, the officers aren't able to hear each other? I certainly hope this has been resolved for ALL departments.
yeah right
Not all 50 cops were able to hear all the other 50 cops. 50 times 50 is 2,500 different lines of communication that have the potential to get missed or not heard during an active gunfight.
Fuck it then, screw communications... Just close your eyes & unload since there's just too much talking... Literally how these idiots think.
they heard they chose not to listen
@@rwid71663 actually the problem was that so many cops were yelling out orders at one time. They need to train the officers to take turns speaking during a gunfight. When one officer is done speaking then another officer can take a turn telling everyone what to do. They also need to begin each command by using the names of the people they are speaking to. So instead of saying " Get on the ground, hold your fire", They should say "Suspect in the vehicle, stop shooting". "Young lady, get on the ground ". "Officer Davis, Officer Watanabe, Officer Guggenheim, and Officer with the fake boobs, hold your fire"!
So a driver cannot lean over and fire out of the passenger side window? What a load of crock.
That’s what I was thinking. And she didn’t have much of a choice if he directed at her to shoot.
Sideways but not behind or forward.
You'd have thought they'd have done a gunshot residue test to ascertain if she had fired. But it's irrelevant to this scenario as she wasn't armed and was following police orders at the point she was shot.
The witness said that the guy was leaning out of the passenger side window at first, then he changed the story a minute later.
Exactly!!
Entire family dead. Unbelievable 😔
Poor younger brother is alive!
@@JavaT6437 There’s a brother? Damn
Yes @@joshuatealeaves
Worse than that. A young boy now has to go through life knowing that his dad killed his mum and got himself and his sister killed.
@@joshuatealeaves Did you not even listen to the video?
Also I find it suspicious L.E. denied shooting her at first and didn't want to release the video until now about a year and half later..
So he was on the driver's seat actively shooting on them, yet someone thought the other person who left the car was also him, because a man, they've never seen in person, was only a bit taller than his daughter? That alone doesn't make much sense.
In a situation of a recent domestic murder, husband driving away and shooting at police with his daughter in the car, this was not going to end well. There is literally no safe place in this scenario for the daughter. The father put everyone's life in danger and cared about no-one. If she would survived this mess, that would have been wonderful. Thank you for the detailed retelling. Many facts were omitted on the news.
I agree, but she was actually pretty close to getting to safety before she got the firing squad treatment from the nice police department
ACAB
@@SmoothLikeSilk I'm surprised the police don't charge the remaining family for the bullets the poor lass bled all over.
Unfortunately it just what happens when your parents don't care about you, because no one in the world cares about you. Sad life for the unlucky girl
@@SmoothLikeSilkright. She was like 20 feet from the cops. Begging for help. Hands in the air. Ugh.
Oh this is heartbreaking 😢
This case is very troubling and sad. An innocent girl needlessly lost her life. This is a case of trigger happy officers who shoot first and ask questions later. 💔
He never said there was proof she was shooting. Just a witness saying it came from the passenger side. That’s not good.
Lol cops were being shot at, and from officer and bystander accounts it was from the driver and passenger side. How were they trigger happy? 🤦🏼♀️
If she was shooting at people, she wasn't innocent. Less culpable than her father? Sure, but not innocent.
"Innocent" is debatable. Do you wear tactical gear when going to visit your mother? #1 blame goes with Dad, he brought on the shootout with his crime spree, and there's a good chance Savannah was an active participant. Cops deal with dangerous people on a daily basis. Next time they hesitate it could mean their death.
@@scottandrews947 A jury should decide that. She was no danger to the cops on the ground and unarmed.
Poor girl she probably would hsve suffered the same fate should she have stayed in the vehicle, her father clearly had no regard for her safety.
Did you see his picture?? No you are correct I doubt he cared about anyone at all
If the officer told her to put her hands up maybe things would have been different
You know it wouldn't have been
Those deputies should be in jail.
Unacceptable
Any benefit of the doubt that I could have given this situation evaporated when the department sat on the video and refused to release it for TWO YEARS until a media organization successfully filed a FOIA request and forced their hand. At that point it stops being a forgivable accident and becomes a situation where the department tried to cover up the killing of a 15 year old girl.
Dad failed his daughter. Disgraceful!
I mean, he had already killed her mother, so I'm sure this wasn't to big a deal to him
And the cops failed the child!
The police failed her too!
The criminal is obviously always at fault. But the police failed the victim as well
@@RoastPostthe father is guilty of kidnapping. The police are guilty of killing a child due to incompetence.
The boy lost everybody in one day -- Mom, Dad, & Sis.
You’re off base on this one Doc. The actions of the deputies - particularly the one(s) who shot her - are criminal. Remember that conduct need not be intentional in order to be criminal. Recklessness, or even negligence, can be criminal and that’s the case here.
I say this as a lawyer with decades of practice in criminal law.
I enjoy your show and will defer to you on mental and psychological issues. But not on the definition of a crime or what constitutes criminal behavior.
True the DA probably won’t bring a criminal case. The deputies are his colleagues; they work together frequently. But that doesn’t mean that a crime wasn’t committed here.
I'm betting on the gender.
❤
@@KingfishStevens-di9ji Could you clarify what you mean?
You’re not a lawyer. A real lawyer wouldn’t even try to make that comment because they’d know nobody would take it seriously. Take it with a boulder of salt.
@@Naptosis And get banned? No thanks.
I knew something bad was going to happen as soon as he said Barstow.
😢
How did the minds of these deputies work? "Oh hey, the other deputies who are close by, have a better view at the scene, give orders to the girl and don't seem to view her as a threat surely must be threatened and paralized by fear, let us fix this"? 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Easy analysis to make with the benefit of a video that explains ahead of time what is about to happen to the girl. The video you viewed was stitched together from multiple angles including a helicopter all while you were comfortably sitting in a chair somewhere. The decisions become a little more tricky when you don't know ahead of time who the next person to die is going to be. When real bullets are flying and real people have been killed.
It’s been a bad week for Victorville, about a week ago, Victorville police shot and killed a mentally challenged kid, he had a gardening tool…couple days ago, this story, then either yesterday or today shot and killed another kid during a bathroom scuffle…
I think these officers need to be retrained. 😮
The police are literal serial killers of children at this point...
And they're legally allowed to do it 😢
Obviously there is blood lust among the law enforcement officers in that town.
@@katc2040legal like the Nazis legally gassed the Jews. Same type of legal.
Such a tragic end for young Savanah
This could be your child.
This could only be my child if I become a violent criminal and my child is an idiot.
:(
How so? I'm not a murderous, armed to the teeth Dad on the run from the law.
@@moreygloss9248your wife might be tho, we don’t know
Ummmm, no it could not. And it is scary that you can write that in a serious manner
One of the channels I support just got hacked by scammers. Just a reminder to Dr Grande not to click on attachments from people who say they want to advertise on your channel. I would hate for you to lose your youtube channel. All the best.
Yes, never click on email attachments or links in emails unless you know what you're doing, and how to identify attachments/links that are safe.
Joe Blogs got hacked.
Absolutely tragic. What became of Savannah’s brother? He’s the only one left…
Something needs to be changed in training or protocols. I understand that it's a volatile situation but there should never be a situation where one officer's directions are determined as an imminent threat on life by another.
We need to demand longer training for police and maybe don’t teach them to be super paranoid seeing as a paranoid person with a gun and qualified immunity is a deadly combination.
Oh and more training on dealing with disabled people especially deaf/hoh communities.
I think this was negligent to a criminal level. The police didn't need to keep shooting once the truck was disabled and could have waited a fucking minute for the girl they knew was in there to be clear. Once the helicopter was on the truck they didn't even need to continue the pursuit like they did.
So once the truck was disabled the murderer will decide to stop shooting or do his guns also stop working? Who makes the decision whether or not the truck is disabled? If there is a helicopter in the air the guy who just killed a woman isn't going to harm the child or other members of the public? It appeared that gunfire was coming from the truck even with the helicopter in the air.
We've investigated ourselves and found we did nothing wrong. The police showed a level of incompetence that is frightening. Like time and time again, we see insufficient training. I understand that being a police officer can be a stressful, dangerous job.
There's nothing incriminating on our body cam footage, so we don't need to make it public.
@@allancouceiro9255 That’s why we never turn our body cameras on.
Modern problems require modern solutions!
Thank you for tackling a difficult subject in a very compassionate but objective way.
They attended the Uvalde Texas School of Tactical Police Response.
Which third world country did this take place in?
California. The worst third world country in the world.
Very Disturbing, RIP Savanna 🇮🇪
Always interesting
Thank you❤
Thank you Dr Grande for this thoughtful and insightful analysis of this disturbing situation
You neglected to describe the hail of gunfire directed at the vehicle before it came to rest. The appearance of many clouds of dust from the impact of the bullets is shocking.
Im curious whether LE tested Savannahs hands for GSR? Im assuming her father dressed her in the tactical gear and helmet - he knew what was coming and may have actually cared about her (but not enough, clearly).
Precisely what I was thinking 🤔
You must be kidding. If he cared, she wouldn't be in that car at all.
@Inuus crazy people do still care in their own messed way and what seems like obviously disturbing behavior to the rest of us it's totally normal in their brain dude obviously had an arsenal so yeah I think in some crazy way I think he thought he could protect her or he perceived the world was taking his family and he wasn't about to let that happen. Still just imagine being a teenager your dad guns down your mom and takes you makes you wear body armor your in a high speed police chase and hes shooting his gun maybe he started yelling at her saying she needed to help him or these people were going to take him away from her there's so many different possibilities that it just seems heartless to try and justify why she had to die even if she wanted to be there!! You should be able to trust your parents
I'm sure Savanah dressed herself in the tactical gear. She was a thug in the making shooting out the passenger side of the car. Poor child - my ass. Girls do many violent crimes today. Gender means nothing.
@@InuusExactly. I'm wondering IF she were a he, if people would still express sympathy and excuses? A teen boy shot and killed by police following him shooting at them would NOT go go down the same way. Most of these comments would hail police, claiming HE deserved it.
This is absolutely heartbreaking and infuriating at the same time.
This is such a terrible tragedy. There is one that is even worse, where this cop with an assault rifle just unloaded on this unarmed innocent guy who was just following his simon-says orders.
She surrendered. I’m pro police but not here. Not at all. 😢
They MURDERED that poor girl instead of Rescuing her! May she rest in peace. 💔🙏🕊️💐🕊️
No difference between Soldier and Police.
Both claim to be trained in Firearms........Both are Government employees
@@christinebuckingham8369 yes they did and why is that deputy not being held accountable?
@@statementleaver8095 Soldiers are better trained, and far less likely to be this incompetent.
@@NaptosisIDF enters the conversation.
Another one protected and served! Of course the dad and the killer cops are the parties who get off unharmed.
Hopefully she is with her mother now. Can't even imagine how the little brother feels, he lost his whole family in one day.
💔
I really like Dr. Grande's videos because he doesn't do the dramatics and sensationalism that so many other outlets and RUclipsrs do. I feel like the information is given in a thorough and ethical way and with so much ridiculousness out there, it's hard to find information I feel I can trust.
is there anything we can do to get the coos to serve time? this is outrageous. the people who are supposed to help are doing nothing but harming the community. lifelong chicagoan and its just as bad here
They'll get paid leave and shuffled to another department at worst.
I don't understand how they can be protected by Qualified Immunity, when they are clearly less qualified than a janitor. Janitors at least greatly benefit their community.
@@Naptosisright. It’s like the Catholic priest pdfiles that get shuffled to other churches instead of held accountable for their actions
The courts have already written into law that collateral damage lies at the feet of the perpetrator.
There was one case where cops shot at and wounded bystanders who were standing at a food truck. Eventually, it was decided the truck was at fault.
At the very least,this was a total breakdown in communications between the involved officers-but there seems to have been an attempt at covering up the facts
There always is. "We investigated ourselves and found we did nothing wrong", it's the statement every police department makes after they gun down an innocent citizen.
Poor baby girl never had a chance
Very even-handed analysis. Thanks.
I think it's more likely that the dad was shooting out of both sides of his truck. It's possible that the girl was indeed by the window so "witnesses" might have thought she was firing a weapon, when it was actually her dad.
Omg this makes me sick to my stomach. Im sorry Savanah! 💔💔💔💔😢
GSR on the kids hands?
I watch every case, every day. This one is beyond tragic
Ugh, this is so heartbreaking! 💔
Liked camping = homeless
This was a tough one
Officers really need better training
Well, we, the people need to call San Bernardino County Sheriffs and respectfully air our grievances. This is the first time hearing this, how terrible. The police just keep getting worse and worse, shameful.
The news video will break your heart.
@@Hollylivengood Was this in 2023?
@@notozknows2022 i thought
Yes everyone needs to call them and speak their mind. Look up San Bernardino sheriff’s office and get their number and make yourself known
@@Fractal_blip Yes, the police suppressed the video for almost 2 years.
This is one of the best in terms of not knowing Dr.’s opinion… really didn’t see it coming. The outcome it was just a mess and the dad was IMHO hundred percent responsible. Cops have some liability but the situation was just tough to handle
Let me guess, the police will investigate themselves and find no wrong doing.
Lack of communication between police does not justify taking a life.
Thank you Dr. Grande. The cops always cover each other for their fatal errors.
How long does it take to be investigated and police to be prosecuted?? Why haven't they released who killed her yet?
A HUGE DEPLORABLE COVER UP. LIKE USUAL
Some cities have created statutes that not only give cops anonymity, but also a length of time before footage will be released to the public. It can range anywhere from 1 to 4 years, if released at all.
I saw this video yesterday. So sad.