Are there Contradictions in the Quran? | Dr. Shabir Ally
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- Are there contradictions in the #Quran? This is a question emailed to us by a viewer. Dr. Shabir Ally responds with a clear answer: No! He explains that when people see contradictions, this is because they don’t understand or care to understand the Quran appropriately. He offers some examples of seeming #contradictions. He recommends that people look at commentaries of the Quran to understand how laws have been set in place gradually and how verses must be interpreted in relation to each other.
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks...
► SUBSCRIBE: www.youtube.co...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
Dear viewers, please subscribe to get all of our Ramadan updates at quranspeaks.com
Is itin thequran to pray 5 times... Or did Prophet Mohammed pray 5 times a day
Islam is really a Judeo-Christian breakaway sect. This is why Quran was written to attack the Jews and Christians and has contradictory stories of the bible. 😅
1)Subhan'Allah
2)Alhamdulillah
3)La ilaha illallah
4)Allahu Akbar
5)Astagfirullah wa atubu ilayhi
6)SubhanAllahi Wabi Hamdihi
SubhanAllahil adheem
Copy paste so that Insha'Allah u can receive the reward for the people who said the Zikir. ☺️
JazakAllah khair
WHERE MIND DOESN'T WORK EYES CAN'T SEE........ great effort by ever agile dr ally..to help one to see.. Allah swt give taufiq to those who r sincere in efforts....
Thank you shabir ally for your great video and explaintion. You are one of a reasonable apologetic in my eyes. Sadly some muslim scholars are calling you heretic without explaining any logical points. May Almighty Allah bless everyone.
Those against him are simpleton wahabbis who cant grasp advanced concepts
@@Hamza000h agree. Wahabi are nuisance everywhere around the world.
who calls him a heretic
@@JJ-io9ms 🤨
Surah 4:48 explains shirk is a unforgivable sin
Where as in surah 39:53 explains allah forgives all sins this got me thinking 1 of these verses can’t be right
alla cannot forgive sin because he is not god
@Nusrat Hussain alal is not god , and whether or not he forgive or not doesn’t count. Settled 😊
Shirk is an unforgivable sin if you die upon it but if you repent and ask Allah to forgive you about the shirk you have committed and mean it yes he will forgive
4:48
Shirk appointment of partnership in worshiping While you ar3 supposed yo worship Allah, so it won't be forgiven if you are asking for forgiveness without leaving that wrong act, remember all the people before accepting Islam have done shirk then cuez they never worshipped Allah and they got to know the truth and they did the right
In 1400 the circumstances have not changed. And no new Revelation is needed
It is amazing how much circumstances changed within 22 years requiring ever changing revelations. But now nothing has changed in 1400 years.
@@peterhwang3479 Exactly
True , that's why Islam is still a problem
There is a system for those changes but after the prophet died nobody is allowed to make changes in Quraan. But depending on the arival of new situation you can get guidance from Quraan
@@MuhammadHanif-ul3yy According to Dr Shabir Ally the common parroted response by Muslims that the Quran has been perfectly preserved. Word by word, letter by letter, dot by dot , Is not a scholarly response. Because the Islamic Scholars know very well that people have made changes to the Quran but the lay Muslim has been taught to think that the Quran is preserved, word by word, letter by letter and dot by dot
The first stage will remain applicable since new comers will enter Islam and then gradually go through the next stage befitting his/her situation.
It's ever so soothing to hear you speak Dr Shabir. May you be blessed in this world and beyond. In Shaa Allah.
In surah 75, "muslims would be looking toward Allah with beaming faces". Since looking involves light travelling from Allah in order for Him to be seen, does this therefore mean Allah enters His creation and hence a contradiction
@S A I know that verse in Quran... It is shld from Moha. out of hatred!
@@SixteenSpecial
A book of of interpretations written by power hungry men
@@noahwamalwa4385 Well, , opening a crossing way in sea, requires huge deal of gigantic heavy equipment, thousands of manpower, and work may go on for no less than 10 years! which is no way it's possible even in 2070!
How God claimed he did it all just at once to let children of Israel take there way across it?
Do you have any explanation?
@@noahwamalwa4385 It's called a metaphor. The Muslims would be at awe at seeing god that's what the Quran means with "Beaming faces"
I really respect you, Dr. Shabir Ally. You helped me a lot in the way to leave islam. Thank you ❤
Allah is pure Spirit and Will. And if you read the beginning of the Quran when Muhammad is in Mecca trying to convert the People in power Muhammad portrays Islam as something peaceful then when he is kicked out to Medina that’s when the other half of the Quran is written which is very war and anger driven. In the latter half Allah changes his Will. Can God Change if God is out of space and time????
As a MD i would say it makes perfectly sense cutting off alcohol in stages due to the effects on the body. And not cutting it off all at once to get a e.g. cold turkey
MashAllah Allah bless you!! Please Dr Ali join the Efdawa and dahaw wise team love to see on panel.
I AGREEEEEEE. I tried to ask but my comment just mixed in with the many
Hi everyone! I'm a muslim-born man and am still identified as a Muslim and have no desire to become something else ..BUT, I am, firstly, a forever seeker of truth before anything else and I had a question about the Quran, since we are talking about contradictions, , maybe someone could explain......so here it goes:
How can Allah be the most beneficent and the most merciful, but yet, still have the worst punishment for those who don't believe???
In my opinion this is the BIGGEST contradiction in the Quran.... almost in every beginning of the surahs, it says Allah is the most merciful but then it says over and over again, through out the whole Quran, that just because some are disbelievers, allah will punish them.... I dont get it ....Maybe someone can explain so I can be more connected to Islam.....because honestly, in my opinion, if only it said this instead: " Allah is the most beneficent and most merciful that even if you don't believe in him, he will forgive you, as you did not know better", then I surely wouldn't have had this question in me.
Because Christ is the only way brother✝️
If you have questions for me please ask me brother.
well Allah swt Is merciful but for those who dont seek forgiveness from Allah swt of their sins going to hell.
Im 11yo so maybe my explanation arent that clear and my pronounciation is bad so im going to apologize
for those disbelievers they can already convert to islam at any time because they can already decide which is good and which is bad but if they didn't believe in islam they get punishment.there are many stories in the holy quran stating that Allah swt Is merciful.
Again my apologize for bad pronounciation and explanation
After reading the quran couple of times again, I now, understand fully, why Allah (swt) will punish the disbelievers. It was only my assumption and not a contradiction, to think that Allah shouldn't punish them. Why wouldn't he? he can forgive anything, but only one sin which is (shirk) that he cannot and since disbelievers assosiate something or someone else to Allah or even worse, they just dont believe while there is signs everywhere in the quran and in the world for them to see. So I get it! Allah IS the most merciful and most importantly, the most fair and just. The judges of judges and the kings of kings and thats why he can and he should be fair with believers and disbelievers accordingly. Anyways, thanks for everyone who replied to my comment. I just had doubts which sometimes happens, but they're cleared off now. May allah bless us all!
What about the historical error where a part in the Quran says king David wore chain mail armour, but chain mail armour was invented 600 years AFTER king David!
Verses?
@@random-ed6kn Q34:11. The tafsirs:
al-Jalalayn: complete suits of armour which the person wearing it drags behind him along the ground ... In other words, make them so that the rings thereof are arranged properly. And act, O family of David, together with him, righteously. Indeed I am Seer of what you do, and will requite you for it accordingly.
This is how Allah taught His Prophet Dawud, peace be upon him, to make coats of mail... "Do not make the rivets too loose that the rings (of chain mail) will shake, or make them too tight that they will not be able to move at all, but make it just right.'' `Ali bin Abi Talhah reported that `Ibn `Abbas said, "Sard refers to a ring of iron.'' Some of them said, "Chain mail is called Masrud if it is held together with rivets.''
If the quran can be understood by itself, why does it need commentaries?
@Lily Puzzle
Why is Allah a kafirophobe ?
Define phobia whilst you're at it
A book written by heretics
@Lily Puzzle
Allah is a kafirophobic , bit of nutcase wouldn't you say
Most muslims can recite Quran but don't understand Arabic.
quran is a complex book you can get basic akida from it but there are very complex things for which you may need a teacher to whom you can ask questions
Some Muslim scholars argue it that way. However, the truth is that Koranic injunctions must be understood from a holistic perspective. For example, the holistic perspective about intoxicants is that they abominations of Satan, avoid them so that you may prosper. However, they do have some good in them, but bad is on the higher side. So, if you can not resist intoxicants, then make sure not to offer salah when you are intoxicated so that you can remember your words and sanctity of salah. This is how the glorious Koran warned people from a holistic perspective so that on the judgment day, individual circumstances are taken into consideration.
I wonder why is something forbidden in this life whereas the same thing will served in abundance in the next life.
Take it this way. This life is an exam meaning that you have to pass the "subjects" in order to get to Paradise. Before you pass the exam, you cant get a job which requires a certificate because you dont have one. Assuming u get 100% in literally all the subjects without cheating then you could get pretty much any job (this is a hypothetical scenario). In this world we are in the "exam phase" and once we get our certificate and we pass, we will be able to do anything we want to. The better your grades, the higher the level in Paradise you'll get.
Sorry if this explanation is confusing. If you have further question pls ask 😊
And in the case of wine, in heaven it's not intoxicating like it is here, sure wine is wine, but the difference between the wine in heaven and the wine here is that, the wine in heaven hasn't been influenced by satan
in the quran one verse said that the allah made the earth after that the haven. but in the other verse said that allah made the haven after that the earth. how to explain this so that it not become contradict each other.
No religious apologist can agree publicly that there is error or contradiction in his holy book and religion even when they know there are errors and contradictions. We understand this very well
Who was the first muslim according to the Koran? Some Muslims says Adam was the first muslim.
Other muslims says Abraham was the first muslim.
Other muslims say jesus was also a muslim.
Surah 6:163 - says Mohamad was the 1st muslim.
Thanks for bringing as the most educated program all the time, may Almighty Allah bless you for your good work.
ameen amigo!
I pray YAWEH opens your eyes Joshua loves you brothers
Turn to Islam before it’s too late. If you worship Jesus you’re being a polytheist which is the biggest sin.
We are muslims bro, we are on the straight path, And I'll ask Allah to help you and to guide you, you are lost bro.
What is the email address? How can we ask questions to you?
Go to their Instagram, they always answer me in less than a week...or write here, they always read the comments
@@deliranteotaku oh really?
@@phenomenal17playz yeah...well...sometimes they do take about a week to answer 🤷♂️😊
@@deliranteotaku what’s there Instagram
"I WANT those historical and scientific errors and those contradictions in there not to exist, so there are none. It is only the others don't seeing what I see".
Not only is the Quran full of contradictions it is historically inaccurate. I took a small dive into the Quran the first time I read it and it has glaring errors and historical inconsistences all through out the book.
My question is , if the word is literal then it can't be interpreted . That means it's trying to guess what your god is saying so in essence the verses are metaphorical and not literal . So what's the truth ?
This is figurative wording which changes to an unrelated meaning . To say the Quran is the literal word of God is impossible if you translate it to something else to suit a narrative .
It's contradictory.... period
WTH 😂😂😂
@@belalfawzi6786
Bet you can't give a rebuttal can you
@@Curiouzzz750 no one can give a rebuttal to nonsense 😂😂
‘The Man (Mohammad), The Book (Qu’ran) and The Place (Mecca); huge holes in all 3. 3 clear examples are: (1) Sura 2:29 states that the Earth was created first; whereas Sura 79:27-30 says that the Heavens were created first. (2) Did the Creation take 6 or 8 days to complete? Sura 7:54 says it took 6 days; while Sura 41:9-12 states that it took 8 (4+2+2). (3) Of what substance was mankind created? Huge discrepancies between Sura 3:59 (‘from dust’); Sura 15:26 (‘from clay and mud’); Sura 16:4 (from a small seed’); Sura 19:67 (‘created out of nothing’); Sura 21:30 (‘from water’) and Sura 96:2 (‘from a mere clot of congealed blood’). Seems that the author of the Qu’ran had a rather poor memory 😳🥴😣. BTW, Jesus stated that HE WAS THE SON OF GOD in the gospel of John chapter 10 verse 36.......so where does THAT leave Mohammad’s ‘revelation’.
Or to put it another way, why did Gabriel give a totally different revelation to Miryam in the gospel of Luke chapter 1 verse 35, than he apparently did nearly 600 years later to Mohammad? Had he changed his mind over that time, or was Mohammad deceived🤔☹️
Did you watch the video?
And david calls god his father in Psalm 89:26-28
@@mohammedafthab1503 If you carefully read the Psalm from verse 20 to the end, you will realise in the context that the ‘David’ being referred to is not the Biblical King David of Israel, but actually Jesus Christ himself. The last few stanzas actually refer to the things that happened to Jesus, the son of God, during his trial, torture and crucifixion. The terms used to describe the everlasting, world-altering dominion of ‘David’ simply cannot refer to the earthly king, who only reigned until the age of 70.
As with many Biblical figures, Joseph (under Pharaoh), Moses, Boaz, David, Daniel, etc, they are all types of Jesus himself. In this Psalm, David is clearly one such type.
To answer your other question, No, I didn’t watch the whole video. I have a low tolerance for Islamist Dawah boys trying to convince me that chalk is actually tasty cheese. The whole foundations of Islam, resting as they do on ‘The Man’, ‘The Book’ and ‘The Place’, have been so thoroughly undermined as to be utterly useless as spiritual guidance.
I have readt the koran and find it fascinating. It speaks a lot of truth about the laws, torah and gospel. I have a few concerns, hoping you can give me an answer. Why does the koran say I must go and read the old and new testament if some muslims say the bible is corrupted? Especially solomons story. The koran doesnt mention that solomon worshipped other other gods which is clearly stated in the book of kings. I hope to find out the truth about this. Because sometimes we can look at things wrong
So when a book has no contradictions meaning its from God? My Chemistry book has no contradictions meaning its from God?
The Quaran says its a clear explanation of everything... Same Quaran says that there are some clear verses which only Allah knows the meaning. Finally which is which?
Kindly explain this
A man came to the Prophet and said: I have found a woman of rank and beauty, but she does not give birth to children. Should I marry her? He said: No. He came again to him, but he prohibited him. He came to him third time, and he (the Prophet) said: Marry women who are loving and very prolific (in child bearing), for I shall outnumber the peoples by you.
Thanks
We've got a whole hadith series on this subject: ruclips.net/p/PLFgZuRzI2wM7lUU7yIyD7p6uPHt_KUYzz
😂 allah is always like that, every times you drill more on the same issue he will tell you different thing 😂😂😂 ‘a man’ always keep asking alla question because he didn’t get the answer 😂😂😂
The Qur'an says in two verses, (22:47 and 32:5), that the measure of one day in the sight of Allah is equal to 1,000 years of our reckoning.
In another verse (70:4) it says that the measure of one day in the sight of Allah is equal to 50,000 years of our reckoning.
SCIENCE QUESTION IF QURAN IS NOT FALSE: What is the speed of earth's rotation in MPH on human time if 1000 years is equal to 1 day of Allah? (1 day is 24 hours, circumference of earth 24,901 Miles).
Any Muslim, Christian and Atheists out there to answer this calculations? (how about the verse 1 day equal to 50,000 years.)
It sounds to me like that most parsimonious explanation is that there are indeed contradictions in the Qur'an.
😢😢😢 it's been 14 hundred years
2 million people memorize it you think thier is controdiction
so which is it don't drink too much or don't drink before prayer or don't drink at all, and issue here is not the point that it comes in sequences but, why would he (allah) need to change his mind?
The mental gymnastics you have to do to refute these contradictions is impressive considering you'll gladly point out contradictions of other religions but yet when they explain and refute the contradictions in their book all of the the same way you do, you don't hold your book to the same standard. Your reasoning is backwards. You think because God inspired the Quran it's perfect and infallible so there must be explanations for the contradictions in the Quran instead of letting the Quran stand on its own showing that it's objectively infallible. Which clearly isn't the case when you take an unbiased view. What a coincidence that you happen to be born in the middle east but yet are Muslim. If you were born in India chances are you would belive in their religions or if you were born in the states you would most likely be Christian. What a coincidence that the God everyone was brought up to believe, you all happen to believe you believe in the "one true god".
🤔 You have a very good point
It's easy to say when you have to translate the most eloquent language, that was at it's most eloquent state (being 1400 years ago) into English *and then have to counter their ridiculous mental gymnastics strawman argument, using objective, factual and extremely detailed explanations.* If you're struggling to understand or are frankly unable think objectively, textual criticism is not for you.
Yeah, we must understand that there's no contradiction between verses in the Quran, because in Surah Al Baqarah verse number 2 or 1 it says "that book which there's no doubt, a guidance for the pious", this means that there are no doubts in the Quran and no problems and no contradictions, this is just a misunderstanding of people who say that there are contradictions in the Quran.
lol
You are mostly going round and round without answering the question. Please answer it so that we Muslims can educate those who believe otherwise. You have to be factual rather than just invoking the faith or references to Muslim scholars.
how can god change his law like a man who change his mind 🤔
By the way if we see comparison,
Quran : can drink wine > cannot drink wine
Bible: 10 commandments never change
@@heloisaheng3189 agree, the GOD couldn’t have send different messages at different times and based on circumstances or people’s sentiments. These are all selective interpretations of GOD’s messages.
@@rafiqul991 actually it can, when Muhammad early preaching God told him to do secretly and when he had solid follower God told him to preaching openly in public.
Because Qur'an came verse by verse with certain event, the commentary really helpful to understand why and when the verse came. If any of you confuse with it, seek to Imam and expert.
And on early time, muslim pray facing Al-Aqsa after that God told us to face Masjidil Haram in Mecca.
@@cotesia7931 Imams are the last persons who should be consulted if you have any questions or confusion. 99% of the so called Imams don’t know or understand what they are talking about. They interpret Quran in absolute terms to suit their own interest. They are all scared just like the churches around 15th century to loose their absolute powers of interpreting the religion. They are scared that people themselves will find out the facts and their influence and power would wane. Imams must come up with explanations that suits modern times. They must research more and turn away from dogmatic interpretations of the Quran and Sunnah. You can not ask women to stay inside, produce babies , and don’t look at any man other than her husband or brothers. I believe Quran is the source of infinite wisdom and takes care of all issues past, present, and the future. It’s only the Imams who refuse to research, find broader meanings.
Universe creation sequence:
If you spent a little bit more of thought into this, you’ll see the answer:
So, since Quran 79:27-31 says that first the sky is built, THEN the earth is spread, that means that in Quran 49:9-12 it forces that last 'thumma' to mean moreover (thumma is also commonly used as just “moreover”, and this avoids the contradiction), so the order is: smoke everything > heavens into 7 > earth 'spreading' & earth nourishment. (Also fyi, the verse specifically says the 4 days of 'earth nourishment/creation' are equal, but the other 2 for the heavens are not mentioned as such, aka, different time lengths.) Also, it can't be the other way around, 79:27-31 show the sky was built first, and THEN earth is spread out, meanwhile in the other sequence, it starts off with the earth is created, then sustenance, and 'THEN' the sky is still smoke and needs to be ordered into 7 and decorated, complete opposite, which shows that thumma here, is 'moreover' rather than 'next' sequence. This would also make it fit in perfectly with the 'heavens and earth were one piece' verse 21:30, as when everything was 'smokey' or prior to that or it could even just mean the earth was generally part of the heavens as a preexisting formless state(part of the gassy nebulae), and then 'split off', aka, a chunk was taken from the heavens to form the Earth. Also notice Quran 79:27-31 mentions 'building/proportioning' things, not 'creating' from scratch. Sky proportioned. Earth then proportioned. This solves the problem of 'then He spread out the Earth', as some think that implies the Earth pre-existed the heavens. It's just 'sky was proportioned' then 'earth was proportioned'.
But that's exactly what Muslims do when they condemn the Bible and claim it is corrupted. When a Christian tries to explain the context of a verse or a doctrinal belief, the Muslim will say that's wrong, you are twisting the literal written text. I have seen it so many times. Also a good example is about the Holy Spirit, where Muslims claim Jesus was referring to their prophet Muhammed, but when you read the full chapter, you will see it cannot be referring to Muhammed
I’ve heard there are several contradictions in the quran but what gets me the most is that is gets the Holy Blessed Trinity wrong in that the quran thinks that it is 3 Gods and that the gods are the Father, Jesus and Mary. It makes no attempt to try and disprove the actual Trinity. It states that allah is the greatest of ALL deceivers, yet in the Bible the greatest deceiver is satan/devil while God of the Bible is the TRUTH. I pray you seek after the true Jesus and see your need for the Savior in whom the Father has sent to us for our salvation so that all may honor the Son “Jesus Christ” just as we honor the Father! Glory to God Almighty!
can you use your brain please?
If God isn’t the greatest of something, then he isn’t god.
If I’m a better deceiver than God; that means (in this case) I am better than god.
God is the best at all things.
So muslims can understand other religion and its text and claim that it is incomplete but anyone,no matter how intelligent and accomplished ,who challenges Quaran hasn't understood it??
Lol..no wonder I call it religion of convenience.
Some intelligent Non-Muslim study the Qur'an in one read then form their conclusions immediately. That isn't how it works. No matter how intelligent and accomplished you are, if you don't know how to approach a text, you won't understand it. Intellectuals read the Qur'an as if it's just another academic text which is completely wrong, thus lead to misconstructions. If they truly wish to study it objectively, they should understand how it should be approached (i.e., words of God with ingenious literary techniques). They don't have to believe that it's the word of God, all they have to do is PRETEND that it's the word of God so that it can act as an incentive for them to discover its gems.
The Qur'an is like a mine. Digging in for days is tiresome, but once you find the gems, you'll believe that it was all worth it.
The problem is that Non-Muslim intellectuals has this bias they don't recognize when they approach the Qur'an. They think that studying it for a week or month is enough for them to form conclusions. We could see the Qur'an as a field beyond any fields of science. Ask yourself, do you think you can master Geology in one or two months? No, you can't, then you must not form conclusions yet. Same with the Qur'an. Even after 1400 years of tafseers, we still have not understood wholly the Qur'an, and it cannot be understood completely, but it can be understood "enough".
Just accept islam and reconcile with God
I was watching for few days CP arguments ... Could you please one by one explane those subjects? Thanks 🙏... my Sala is under pressure of doubts ...🙄
I suggest you check out farid responds. He completely exposed that man
Do not ever watch cp or videos similar to his because first of all these videos are known to be deceptive and fake and have been exposed by several individuals who have knowledge about Islam like for example Farid responds is a great channel to look into. He has exposed and debunked many of cp ‘s videos and misleading videos of other deceptive youtubers
Lord Jesus Christ said that the last prophet was John the Baptist. (Mathew 11:11-14). And The Lord also said that after him (Jesus Christ) many false prophets will come, (Mathew 7:15) and Mohammad is one of them. And the Lord said that from their fruit you will get to know, and the fruit of Islam the whole world sees clearly. Jai Hind
😂jonh the baptist is one of our prophet..who mentioned in quran...
His name is yahya prophet
Though he is gentle, such an explanation is nothing but clutching at straws. Any religion is the same...
Why is this book so complicated. Why do you need to be so analytical isn’t god organized/not confusing/straight forward. He is finite he doesn’t change his mind
Is the language of Arabic. If you study Classical Arabic, you would understand how complex the language is and why Allah chose that language to be in the Quran.
@@vbandz2645
You mean the heretical Christians who wrote it
Just accept islam and reconcile with God
To understand the Quran one has to learn Arabic language and recite it with understanding from beginning to end. Also Quran is for guidance for mankind when reading a verse one must look for guidance it gives out. If one reads carefully one will find guidance in every verse. Plus whole of Quran must be kept in mind before trying to explain a verse. Jazakallah khairan.
@Brother asked a very good question Brother the word 'Yaum' is used which also means in verse concerned 'period, epoch or era'. So Allah Almighty in His Word the Holy Qur'an means six different stages. In science people are still discovering things and will do until end of times. Complete knowledge is with Allah All-Knowing Who is the Creator and maintainor of all Universes.
@Brother asked a very good question In Arabic language the word for day is 'nahaar' and for night is 'lail' the word used is 'yaum' meaning already mentioned. Two billion years is guess work and doesn't refute the concept of a Creator and the created. The other theory is of evolution which is not proven people believe in it because they don't want to believe in their Creator. Denying does not change the reality, closing eyes does not make the sun disappear. The truth is in the last testament the Word of our Lord and Creator the Holy Qur'an it is up to believe in it or leave it.
@Brother asked a very good question As I said 'yaum' also means period, era or epoch. It is entirely up to you to believe or not. Majority of people believe in God their Creator when calamity befalls them they automatically say O' God help us'.
@Brother asked a very good question Allah is not need of oxygen he created it.
Guidance for mankind ? I think not
which was made 1st heaven or earth please
They were created simultaneously
@@athousandwaystojannah really, best you be reading the quran again and then get back to me
ther is no contradictions if you ask me, i take care of any detailles, i didnt find any error, know that if you read the quran in english or any other laungage then arabic, it means you didnt read it really, the quran is pure in it own laungage, "the arabic" and each word have many meanings, and you take them by understanding each word, that why they didnt understand the quran, and they say : ooh i find contradictions, it is normaly acceptable cause they didnt understand, wish it totaly normal in my openion they are humains after all, people some time make mistakes, they just need to carfuly undestand befor the critique, as i said, ther is 0 errors in quran, and it even predicted prophecys that are 100 % real with out any contraction, even the prophet muhammad in the hadith etc he did let us know what coming, and everything start mutching, that is a miracle of prophecy of ower propher muhammad pbuh
Are Allah’s decrees changed or not?
“Rejected were the messengers before thee: with patience and constancy they bore their rejection and their wrongs until Our aid did reach them: there is none that can alter the words (and decrees) of Allah. Already hast thou received some account of those messengers,” (6:34).
“The word of thy Lord doth find its fulfillment in truth and in justice: None can change His words: for He is the one who heareth and knoweth all, (6:115).
None of Our revelations do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten, but We substitute something better or similar: Knowest thou not that Allah Hath power over all things?” (2:106).
When We substitute one revelation for another,- and Allah knows best what He reveals (in stages),- they say, “Thou art but a forger”: but most of them understand not,” (16:101).
How can the eternal speech of God go from, "decide what YOU want to decide about alcohol" to, "don't come to the prayer drunk" to " don't even touch alcohol"
these are serious changes for someone who had this word in eternity even before the prophet was born. it looks like this god didn't actually know what he was saying or doing. he was just " testing the waters"
The 2 verses were "They ask thee concerning wine and gambling. Say: "In them is great sin, and some profit, for men; but the sin is greater than the profit" and "O ye who believe! Approach not prayers with a mind befogged, until ye can understand all that ye say" then the forbid verse came later. I don't think these verses are contradicting each other, and nowhere was mentioned that you decide what you want about alcohol. The two verses discourage people from alcohol, yet no forbid was mentioned until later in the 3rd verse, which I don't think to be a contradiction. Regarding that god has the words in eternity, yes it was, yet was revieled over the span of 23 years according to each circumstances and occasion, then in the end became a whole program together, which not something that decreases its value. Hopefully that gives enough explanation.
@@qosaiomar8924 if alcohol was wrong to drink from eternity, then why were muslims drinking it and only forbidden to do it later. In the hadiths there are stories of muslims going to war drunk and going to prayer drunk hence the surahs. Muslim wanted a straight answer and were told ..."not much profit" that's in essence saying "it's not worth it" it's not being forbidden. The later it is forbidden. How is that not a contradiction? Either way, contradiction is not really my argument here, although there are many in Islam, my issue here is that allahs eternal speech seems to always change and adapt according to the situation or circumstances that mohammed would face. Same thing with the woman covering themselves, that only came after Umar kept advising Mohammed to tell his wife's they should cover, thereafter the revelation was revealed. Again, we see here that muslim women were not always covering, and yet this is allas eternal speech?
@@qosaiomar8924 if it takes 23 years to reveal a complete revelation how is that a real revelation from God? He didn't know what to tell the prophet immediately? It took 23 years to finalize the rules?
@@RamoLasiaf the problem with reading too much into any religious book is when you get busted ...today after years of burning Qurans and cutting edges etc you still have 30+ Qurans officially...so which of what fits into what of which 😂...
I always tell people who talk about hidden science in religious books why if the inventor or author knew in this case Allah not mention what we are reading into his words
exactly. very wierd.
The Qur'an contradicts itself in many passages, for example how unbelievers should be treated. In Qur'an 25:63 it says that they should be treated kindly but in 9:29 it says that they should fight unbelievers. This is just one of hundreds of examples where the Qur'an contradicts itself and also people misinterpret it. Qur'an describes Mekkah as a vibrant city with trade, olive trees and water but archeologists have never found any evidence that there used to be a city at times the prophet was living there. There weren't any old structures from the 7th century, there have never been olive trees or water and no mention anywhere on maps of this period. Mekkah was not in Saudi Arabia, otherwise the Qur'an would be wrong.
Quran says earth is flat , miracle of muham mad😮
Thanks for explanation
Jazakallah dear sheikh
Arabic people intentionally try to make it seem that Quran has lots of meaning is to confuse you till they can translate it into something that might work in their favour. The quran is pretty much black and white
Asking a Muslim if the Quran has problem areas is silly . You need a non bais person to ask and research
so Allah didn't know what was going to happen ?
what the hell are you talking about
Who did Muhammad say he saw in the Hira Cave? He said he had seen the devil or Satan and he came trembling and shivering back home. Confession is the master of evidence. Muhammad confessed that he saw a Devil or was touched by a Demon. Khadijah convinced him that what he saw was the Angel. Thirdly: Khadijah's testimony is rejected because she saw nothing to testify about. It is a fact: You testify to what is seen.The truth is clarified in the books of the Prophet's biography and the books of Islamic heritage, beloved Muslims, but truth is in their heritage books. The fact that the creature that appeared to him in the cave in various manifestations, is that he: is a follower from the Jinn, in other words it is the Devil, and a third more comprehensive expression is that he feared for himself from this time. In the book (Al-Sirah Al-Halabiyah, 1/380) "From Umaru bin Sharhabil that the Messenger of Allah said to Khadija.. I am afraid that the one who calls me is a follower of the Jinn (Demon)." "I am afraid that the madness in me is touched from the Jinn (Demon)." Again Khadijah’s witness is not accepted under Muslim law: As it is a witness of a woman, and woman in Islam lack in intellect and religion. This comes from the statement of Muhammad in (Sahih Bukhari 2/531, Hadith 1393) Khadijah’s testimony is illegal: you do not accept a testimony unless it is from two men, or one man and two women. (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:282- And bring to witness two witnesses from among your men. And if there are not two men,then a man and two women from those whom you accept as witnesses - so that if one of the women errs, then the other can remind her.} And here is Khadijah who is giving a testimony alone, and it is wrong as described in the Quran. So it is a testimony not by Shariah. The whole Quran contradicts itself and destroys the testimony of Khadijah that what Muhammad saw was the Angel Jibreel. Accept the confession of Muhammad and the conclusion is that the whole Muslim religion is founded by Satan: THE CONTRADICTIONS IN THE QURAN HAVE BEEN ABROGATED AND THE VERSES REWRITTEN TO CORRECT THEM UNDER THE THEORY CALLED NASKH
What does it even mean to say the world was created in a number of days? The notion of a day presupposes and earth and a sun fully formed with that earth rotating about its axis or in some way going through a cycle of light to dark and back to light again (in the presence of the Sun)
Plenty contradictions. This is just a small part the list can go on and on.
*What was man created from: blood, clay, dust, or nothing?
“Created man, out of a (mere) clot of congealed blood,” (96:2).
“We created man from sounding clay, from mud moulded into shape, (15:26).
“The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam; He created him from dust, then said to him: “Be”. And he was,” (3:59).
“But does not man call to mind that We created him before out of nothing?” (19:67, Yusuf Ali). Also, 52:35).
“He has created man from a sperm-drop; and behold this same (man) becomes an open disputer! (16:4).
*Is there or is there not compulsion in religion according to the Qur’an?
“Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah hath grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold, that never breaks. And Allah heareth and knoweth all things,” (2:256).
“And an announcement from Allah and His Messenger, to the people (assembled) on the day of the Great Pilgrimage, - that Allah and His Messenger dissolve (treaty) obligations with the Pagans. If then, ye repent, it were best for you; but if ye turn away, know ye that ye cannot frustrate Allah. And proclaim a grievous penalty to those who reject Faith,” (9:3).
“But when the forbidden months are past, then fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, and seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war); but if they repent, and establish regular prayers and practice regular charity, then open the way for them: for Allah is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful,” (9:5).
Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued,” (9:29).
*The first Muslim was Muhammad? Abraham? Jacob? Moses?
“And I [Muhammad] am commanded to be the first of those who bow to Allah in Islam,” (39:12).
“When Moses came to the place appointed by Us, and his Lord addressed him, He said: “O my Lord! show (Thyself) to me, that I may look upon thee.” Allah said: “By no means canst thou see Me (direct); But look upon the mount; if it abide in its place, then shalt thou see Me.” When his Lord manifested His glory on the Mount, He made it as dust. And Moses fell down in a swoon. When he recovered his senses he said: “Glory be to Thee! to Thee I turn in repentance, and I am the first to believe.” (7:143).And this was the legacy that Abraham left to his sons, and so did Jacob; “Oh my sons! Allah hath chosen the Faith for you; then die not except in the Faith of Islam,” (2:132).
*Does Allah forgive or not forgive those who worship false gods?
Allah forgiveth not that partners should be set up with Him; but He forgiveth anything else, to whom He pleaseth; to set up partners with Allah is to devise a sin Most heinous indeed,” (4:48). Also 4:116
The people of the Book ask thee to cause a book to descend to them from heaven: Indeed they asked Moses for an even greater (miracle), for they said: “Show us Allah in public,” but they were dazed for their presumption, with thunder and lightning. Yet they worshipped the calf even after clear signs had come to them; even so we forgave them; and gave Moses manifest proofs of authority,” (4:153).
*Are Allah’s decrees changed or not?
“Rejected were the messengers before thee: with patience and constancy they bore their rejection and their wrongs until Our aid did reach them: there is none that can alter the words (and decrees) of Allah. Already hast thou received some account of those messengers,” (6:34).
“The word of thy Lord doth find its fulfillment in truth and in justice: None can change His words: for He is the one who heareth and knoweth all, (6:115).
None of Our revelations do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten, but We substitute something better or similar: Knowest thou not that Allah Hath power over all things?” (2:106).
When We substitute one revelation for another,- and Allah knows best what He reveals (in stages),- they say, “Thou art but a forger”: but most of them understand not,” (16:101).
*Was Pharaoh killed or not killed by drowning?
“We took the Children of Israel across the sea: Pharaoh and his hosts followed them in insolence and spite. At length, when overwhelmed with the flood, he said: “I believe that there is no god except Him Whom the Children of Israel believe in: I am of those who submit (to Allah in Islam). (It was said to him): “Ah now!- But a little while before, wast thou in rebellion!- and thou didst mischief (and violence)! This day shall We save thee in the body, that thou mayest be a sign to those who come after thee! but verily, many among mankind are heedless of Our Signs!” (10:90-92).
Moses said, “Thou knowest well that these things have been sent down by none but the Lord of the heavens and the earth as eye-opening evidence: and I consider thee indeed, O Pharaoh, to be one doomed to destruction!” So he resolved to remove them from the face of the earth: but We did drown him and all who were with him,” (17:102-103).
*Is wine consumption good or bad?
O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,-of Satan’s handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye may prosper,” (5:90).
(Here is) a Parable of the Garden which the righteous are promised: in it are rivers of water incorruptible; rivers of milk of which the taste never changes; rivers of wine, a joy to those who drink; and rivers of honey pure and clear. In it there are for them all kinds of fruits; and Grace from their Lord. (Can those in such Bliss) be compared to such as shall dwell forever in the Fire, and be given, to drink, boiling water, so that it cuts up their bowels (to pieces)?” (47:15).
Truly the Righteous will be in Bliss: On Thrones (of Dignity) will they command a sight (of all things): Thou wilt recognize in their faces the beaming brightness of Bliss. Their thirst will be slaked with Pure Wine sealed,” (83:22-25).
*How many days did it take to create Heavens and Earth ?
Quran 7: 54 Your gurdian-Lord is Allah who created the heavens and earth in Six Days
Quran 10: 3 Verily your Lord is Allah, who created the heavens and earth in Six Days
Quran 11:7 He it is Who created the heavens and earth in Six Days
Quran-25:29: He Who created the heavens and earth and all that is between, in Six Days
*The above verses clearly state that God created the heaven and Allah created the heaven and the Earth in 6 days. But the verses below stated-
Quran 41: 9 Is it that ye deny Him who created the earth in Two Days ?
Quran 41: 10 He set on the (earth) Mountains standing firm high above it, and bestowed blessing on the earth, and measured therein all things to give them nourishment in due proportion, in FOUR DAYS…
Quran 41: 12 So He completed them (heavens) as seven firmaments in Two days and …
Now do the math: 2(for earth) + 4(for nourishment) + 2 (for heavens) = 8 days; and not 6 days
All of these has already been debunked. They aren't contradictions. They're simply a literary technique.
*What was man created from: blood, clay, dust, or nothing?
“Created man, out of a (mere) clot of congealed blood,” (96:2).
“We created man from sounding clay, from mud moulded into shape, (15:26).
“The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam; He created him from dust, then said to him: “Be”. And he was,” (3:59).
“But does not man call to mind that We created him before out of nothing?” (19:67, Yusuf Ali). Also, 52:35).
“He has created man from a sperm-drop; and behold this same (man) becomes an open disputer! (16:4).*
This isn't contradictory at all. These just describes the different ways we were created. God didn't say "Oh, I created you from DUST and only DUST, and nothing else in between or beyond".
Allah described himself as the Almighty in one passage and the Most Wise in another. Is that a contradiction? Nah, it isn't. Similar to this example.
Don't read the Qur'an as if its just another poem or academic text. The Qur'an isn't any of our literary forms. Then why approach it that way? If the Qur'an is unique then the approach must be unique also.
What you're doing here is akin to STUDYING A POEM AS IF IT'S AN ACADEMIC TEXT. lol
Not only that, the passages of the Qur'an was revealed orally during the time of the Prophet. Thus, we should understand the context to which a verse was revealed.
Watch the first 25 seconds of the video.
"Part of the Qur'an will interpret another part". - Shabir Ally
The Qur'an isn't some academic textbook wherein every single fact about the fundamentals of a subject is presented in one paragraph.
It seems to me that you went to this video, pause the video, comment this, not watch the video and leave.
Simple answer , yes. There are a lot of contradictions but apologists like dr Shabir practice a lot of language acrobats to save the image of a god that cannot speak clearly.
These are not the eyes that are blind but heart
@@Bahaduralikhan1990 your eyes and heart are both blind, you can't even understand what the Quran even says. It's so dumb that it approves of the bible IN THE TIME OF MUHAMMAD yet completely contradicts the bible. And there's no evidence whatsoever that the Bible changed after that because there were so many copies already.
Unlike the Quran, the bible was written and not memorized then written after about 40 years. The worst is that it uses hadiths 300 years later to fix up the mistakes that the Quran made, because Allah isn't smart enough to give context.
Keep crying 😂
Actually no you brain dead zombie only what you Christians made up. The Quran explains things in different verses. You love 8 days creation it’s still 6 days because the word thumma is used. That has got 3 meanings simultaneously, moreover and then.
Go on give us one contradiction? There are 0 there’s non Muslims who became Muslim and they found 0 contradictions. You have got mixed up with the bible which is full of scientific errors, contradictions, historical errors and mathematical errors.
The doctor wants to say that the first (2) is counted in (4), not the last (2), small error.
The similtitude of someone criticizing the Quran based on a translation is like someone who reads Shakespeare's Macbeth in Gujarati language and then says it doesn't make sense.
In order to dive deeper into any text, not just religious text, one must understand its original language.
Unfortunately this is impossible with today's American Media influenced minds that are stuck in one language and cannot appreciate the nuances, subtleties and idiomatic references of other languages.
Technically all religious texts have contradictions
Not really tbh. The ones in the Quran have been refuted unlike the Bible. However, the Bible has less contradictions than people think.
God’s creation took 6 days according to a prophet born 1500 years after the Hebrew scriptures (Genesis) which first said the same thing. Putting aside the complete inconsistency with what we now know from cosmology, this seems like borrowing rather than revelation. Also, if the all knowing creator wanted to reveal himself clearly and unambiguously to his children, he would have chosen to do so in Mandarin Chinese or English (and to a literate population) which are understood by far more of his creation than ancient Arabic. It seems quite a coincidence that the one who revealed the creator’s words to humanity just happened to only speak Arabic and when anyone today raises contradictions they are told the true meaning can only be understood through a scholar’s level understanding of Arabic. Hmmm.
*Arabic Revelation*
Honestly, how can you be this dumb, It was revealed in Arabic because the prophet and the people spoke Arabic. If the prophet spoke English it would have been revealed in English.
Had We revealed it as a non-Arabic Quran, they would have certainly argued, “If only its verses were made clear ˹in our language˺. What! A non-Arabic revelation for an Arab audience!” Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “It is a guide and a healing to the believers. As for those who disbelieve, there is deafness in their ears and blindness to it ˹in their hearts˺. It is as if they are being called from a faraway place.”
(Fussilat 41:44)
"God’s creation took 6 days according to a prophet born 1500 years after the Hebrew scriptures (Genesis) which first said the same thing"
If you're saying that Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) Copied the scriptures then you're a fool. Prophet Muhammed (PBUH) was illiterate he could neither read nor write forget Hebrew he could neither read nor write Arabic. So pretty dumb to say that he copied from Hebrew scriptures.
"which are understood by far more of his creation than ancient Arabic"
Are 446 Million Arabic speakers very few to you?
And just so you know the Bible was never in English too. It was ofc revealed in Aramaic because as agreed by most of the Christian scholars the Jesus and his disciples spoke Aramaic. But the earliest manuscripts of the bible are in Hebrew, So the Aramaic manuscripts are lost. So you don't even know if the Aramaic-Hebrew translators were right, they would've made many mistakes or even added their own stuff removed what they like and you would never know( And some figures even admitted to do that). It is now that they are translated into English.
Don't try to criticize the Quran when you don't even know the history of your bible. History is proof that the Quran is wayyyyy better preserved than the bible.
*Relating to the 6 days Creation*
Yes, it's true the Quran says that the universe was created in 6 days. now the word used is 'Ayyam' which could either mean a day or a long period of time. Because the way we perceive a day is 24 hrs which is not how God perceives it or even how it actually is, So scientifically scientists say that there is no objection in saying that the Universe was made in a long period. There are some Christians that say that like the Quran even the bible means a long period. It does not !! If you read the bible it says evening and morning clearly stating 24 hrs but even if I agree with you that the Bible means the same thing, then congrats you have solved 1 paradox you got 5 more Contradictions to go. So while presenting the criteria of the development of the Universe the bible makes a lot of Scientific Mistakes and the Quran doesn't.
Then God said, “Let there be light”; and there was light. (1:3)
Then God made two great lights: the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night. He made the stars also.
-So light was created on the 1st day and Sun and Stars on the 4th day.
How can Light be created before the source of light (Sun, Stars) completely illogical.
Then God said, “Let the waters under the heavens be gathered together into one place, and let the dry land appear”; and it was so. And God called the dry land Earth, and the gathering together of the waters He called Seas. And God saw that it was good. Then God said, “Let the earth bring forth grass, the herb that yields seed, and the fruit tree that yields fruit according to its kind, whose seed is in itself, on the earth”; and it was so. And the earth brought forth grass, the herb that yields seed according to its kind, and the tree that yields fruit, whose seed is in itself according to its kind. And God saw that it was good. So the evening and the morning were the third day. (1:9-13)
Then God said, “Let there be light”; and there was light. And God saw the light, that it was good; and God divided the light from the darkness. God called the light Day, and the darkness He called Night. So the evening and the morning were the first day.(1:3-5)
-So Earth was created on the 3rd day. And Day and Night were created on the 1st day.
How can you have a Night and Day without the Earth? Night and day depends on the rotation of the Earth. If there is no Earth there is no concept of Night And Day.
-So Earth was created on the 3rd day and the Sun and Moon were created on the 4th.
According to established science Earth is part of the parent body Sun. Earth cannot come into existence before the sun.
-So all the Vegetation(Herbs, grass,tree,fruit) was on the 3rd day and the Sun was created on the 4th day.
How can there be vegetation without sunlight, and how can they even survive without sunlight?
Then God made two great lights: the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night. He made the stars also. And God set *them* in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth. (1:16-17)
-It says God made two lights the Sun and The Moon, But the Moon has no light according to Established Science, The light of the Moon is reflected light of the Sun and not its own light.
God set them in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon earth, indicating that the Moon has its own light which again contradicts established Science. And even the Hebrew word used for light is 'hammaowr' which means a lamp or a chandelier something having its own light.
*But in the Quran (25:61) The word used to describe the light of the sun is 'Siraajan' literally meaning Lamp, Something which produces it's own light. And the Arabic word used to describe the light of the Moon is 'Moonera' Meaning a borrowed light or reflected light. Which 100% goes with the Established Science that the Moon has it a borrowed light and the sun has it's own light*
Blessed is He who has placed in the sky great stars and placed therein a [burning] lamp and luminous moon. (Furqan 25:61)
The Quran does not have Contradictions in the concept of the creation of the universe unlike the bible which has many contradictions. I mean Isn't it dumb that A illiterate person who didn't even know to read and write 1400 yrs ago copied the 6 days concept with eliminating all mistakes and contradictions again *1400 yrs ago* . Forget about the 6 days criteria he wrote the whole book without any mistakes and contradictions.
It is not possible, this type of knowledge is only with the creator himself, the Quran has been revealed from the creator himself.
Then do they not reflect upon the Qur’ān? If it had been from anyone other than Allah, they would have found within it much contradiction. (An Nisa 4:82)
@@JuiceJukeBox First, the books that make up the old testament were written in ancient Hebrew. The books that make up the New Testament were written in Greek, not Aramaic. Clearly, the Quran borrows heavily from the stories first recited in the Old and New Testaments, at some points the words in the Quran mirror the Bible word for word. Elsewhere the Quran seeks to explain certain beliefs that were held by Jews and Christians and gets those beliefs completely wrong. Muhammad lived in a region where the stories of the Torah and New Testament were being circulated by adherents of the Jewish and Christian faiths and so there are some parallels to these texts in the Quran. He didn’t need to read and write Hebrew or Greek to have some basic idea (albeit sometimes inaccurate) of what these texts contained or what their adherents believed.
The six day creation story in the Quran is borrowed from Genesis and both, if read literally, are completely contrary to what we know about cosmology. Neither understood the billions of years that separate the age of the Universe and the Earth, and in both texts the authors repeatedly and incorrectly thought the moon generates its own light. The authors clearly didn’t understand the basic fact that the earth revolves around the Sun, the Sun is a star and is 100 times larger than the earth, that Billions of Galaxies exist, that there are trillions of stars many light years distant from the earth with their own planets revolving around them. You would think the vessels communicating the divine revelations of an omniscient creator would have gotten these facts straight.
As to the Quran’s Arabic antecedents being “obvious” because Mohammad only spoke Arabic, you’re missing the point. And it it’s you who could not be dumber for using circular reasoning. An all knowing creator who wanted to get the message out to as many people as possible would have chosen another so called prophet who was literate and communicated in a language understood by the majority of people or he would have endowed Muhammad with miraculous multi-lingual powers. After all, given all the “miracles” of the Quran, this would have been a minor feat by comparison.
@@DPM917 Mr.DPM are you even a Christian? or Athiest?
@@JuiceJukeBox Why is that relevant? Facts are facts.
@@DPM917 Mr.DPM Because that's how my answers will depend, According to what you believe.
100s of contradictions
Lolol there are DOZENS of contradictions
Yes Quran is full of contradictions and mistakes
2:256 There is no compulsion in religion.
Clearly, there is.
We are compelled by a coercive Allah into his religion under pain of eternal suffering.
How about the scientific errors? Please talk about those
There are no scientific errors. I suggest you check out “Abuzar Responds” with subtitles and he refuted all these “scientific errors.”
@@endlessnutella8612 fresh and salt waters do mix. i've read the tafsir ,the verse is supposed to be taken literally which means that the quran made an error.
There's actually scientific errors and historical errors and yes contradictions. The Quran says the sun sets in a muddy spring and it also says the Sun goes under the throne of Allah at night (which is above us according to Quran) but if Allah and his throne is above us than how can the Sun set in a muddy spring which would be below us which would also mean Allah is under ground
1. When it talks about the muddy spring it says, as if the sun layed in a muddy spring to the good people (meaning they had nice, clear weather) and the sun was so hot and scorching to the bad people. Read the verses correctly.
2. This is common sense. The verse says the sun is under Allahs throne at night. We know his throne is above us. If the sun is below us, then the throne is still above it.
@@random-ed6kn the Sun isn't above us lol
@@bryanbradley6871 exactly
@@random-ed6kn No, that is not what the Quran says at all in the arabic version and there is nothing in it that would point to it.
This has only recently became a reinterpretation to try to cover up the horrifying lack of scientific knowledge of the supposedly divine book.
@@baldwinthefourth4098 are you talking about the muddy spring
Takbeer!!!
The simple answer is yes
All due respect, why would Allah keep contradictory/ old laws included in the Qur'an? I can understand that things can change, but with a lot of confusion, and not everyone is a commentator/ scholar. Who could get it right? A lot of muslims do not understand arabic and for the Imams they follow, a lot of people have different perspectives.
I guess I just want to know why it has to be this confusing.
Average Muslim here, nothing is confusing except why people try to learn it from non Muslims that gives them wrong ideas about Muslims and Islam.
@@user-sc6uu5iq2b Many of the best Islamic scholars disagree on which verses have been abrogated. Most scholars for example argue that the verse on "no compulsion" has been abrogated (else the Quran contradicts itself with verses in surah 9), yet a few want to argue that is is not abrogated. The Quran is not clear and it most certainly does not say which verse abrogates which.
Also, abrogation makes little sense. Why use in within a short (23 year period) in a book that existed for all time (trillions and trillions of year) and which is supposed to be valid for all time into the future? It's amusing that the all-knowing god who "knows best" needs to change a few silly rules initially only for a few people in a 7th century desert.
@@theastronomer5800 can you give me the scholars name, if you don't mind?
@@user-sc6uu5iq2b he cant give you a name because there aren't! these people hears about islam from islamophobes like david wood and tomy robinson and they believe everything theyve heard
@@aliahmed2650 possibly, it's been 1 day already
i confirm: (2//2)+4=6
الله اکبر
Masha Allah, perfect answer!
Muslims cannot marry polytheist women (2:221), Christians are polytheists (5:116), Muslims can marry Christian women (5:5)
The Quran is a clear book (4:174, 5:15, 26:2, 28:2) The Quran is unclear in some verses (3:7)
@Nusrat Hussain alla is so tricky that he doesn’t want you to know the meaning of his word. Quran is not a book from God thats why you need to find and keep find interpretations, and than create another interpretation to cover previous interpretation and then find another big interpretation to reinterpret the holes in all previous interpretation.
@@heloisaheng3189
don't misunderstand...
Allah is wise and he made the Qur'an with no mistakes or contradictions.
why do you hate Islam?? its a religion of peace and true guides.
why don't you do some research and you'll find that the Qur'an is the truth unlike the Bible which has alot of contradictions.
just do the research and be honest with yourself and you'll find the truth.
peace.
@@abdullahalbadra8328 I used to be ok with Islam until my uncle marry second & third wife and broke the heart of my beloved Aunty.
@Nusrat Hussain I saw bad condition with my Muslim relatives. Anyway I dont like how Muhammad take kid as wife and have so many wife, love women and perfume, too much nonsense with this guy.
@@heloisaheng3189
So true lol
So you agree that one aspect is in one place and another aspect in another , which shows that the book is wildly disorganised and thus cannot be divine but only human.
@Asad Ahmad lol. Couldn't care less about hinduism.
You want to talk scientific errors? Then try 71:19 And Allah has made the earth for you as a carpet (spread out)
Spread out doesn't imply a globe and a carpet is always set on a flat surface.
@Asad Ahmad exactly , spread the earth as a carpet , and a carpet is flat.. what are you not getting.
@Asad Ahmad okay...I am not getting this part of wrapping day and night , what's this about , where does it say that ?
@@shashankphansikar7094 if u put a carpet over a sphere it becomes a sphere... the carpet represents that he has made the ground flat and sturdy to walk on... there’s a verse where it says earth is round so yh
@@blakeemel3819 the part of "putting carpet over a sphere" that you are saying ,
Can you confirm it with any verse ? Because all Qur'an says that , we have made the earth for you as a carpet.
Plain and simple.
And we always lay a carpet on a flat surface only.
so yes then
It can be answered in another way. The word used in the so called 8 day verse is summa. The word can mean moreover, then and at the same time . Some translations use then when it should be at the same time.
You mean Allah intentionally confusing people.
Read the verses carefully, here summa means then.
@@mansurhallaj8568 No he isn’t. You clearly are confused. The word summa means at the same time, moreover and then. Some Quran translations use then. It’s at the same time.
@@Truth_Seeker1 so, which one is right? Both meaning can't be correct. My question who knows the correct answer?
@@mansurhallaj8568 Dude im sorry but can you read? like he @Truth Seeker literally said at the same time/moreover is the meaning?? yo?
I am very disappointed after that video, I was always worm supporter of Ally , but now I see he is afraid of radicals fanatics, and he is not as honest as we would except, I’m very sorry to say that, fear can change people…
He is extremely honest. The man is telling the truth about Islam as far as he understands, he has no fear of radicals or fanatics
@@DBUification
Islam is radical , there's no levels of high or low , Islam is Islam
@@Curiouzzz750 Islam is not radical in any way, shape, or form. People have taken Islamic texts and scripture and attempted to use it to justify their own radical behaviors, but anyone with common sense and knowledge knows they’re radical and Islam is not.
True
Why is the creation narrative different from that in the Bible? It's totally illogical! 🤔
Oh dear no is a ridiculous answer, always 'youre not reading it correctly, your not translating it correctly' absolute spin and baseless propaganda
So there was some changes in the quran from its original teaching …? why change a preserved holy book?
what are you taking about? these changes were from god not humans
@@aliahmed2650 So are muslims allowed to drink or no?? and if no? why were they allowed before??
@@heavensapprentice777 muslims are not allowed to drink. back then the arabs pegans used to drink alcohol like water and it wouldve been nearly impossible for them to stop drinking immediately. thats why allah banned alcohol in three phases and they are mentioned in the quran.The reason alcohol was tolerated for some time is that you cannot ban something as addictive and as integral to many cultures like alcohol except gradually. Allah made sure the early Muslims would be able to bear it being forbidden before He completely forbade it.
There are contradictions....that can't be explained away and the same with the bible...
Most of these contradictions are misinterpretations and when I see atheists point them out Muslim apologists refute them. Same with the Bible although it really has some contradictions but only about 101 not 1000 like people say
Patricia Crone just didn't understand? Er, not likely.
Shabirs intepretation is sadly wrong. Acc. Sura41 its clear that first the earth was made in 2 days. Second its clear, that in 4 days Al-lah made plants mountains etc. Thats a total of 6. But in verse 11 capter 41 its clear that ther stands "THEN" (thereafter) he made the sky in 2 days. Whats the meaning of "THEN"? Is then refered to: "Then before when he made the Earth" acc. Shabir..where is that fact from his expanation? "Then" means just therafter, (correct me if im wrong) so you have to add 2 days and end up with 8 days. Isnt it mentioned the Quran is very clearly? So clear written that nobody can bring a verse in the same beauty? Why THEN we end up with such debates while reading it, because its clear?...But more sad is the fact that Al-lah is no more know what he made first, heaven (sky where Al-lah is physical lives in and goes there every night) or the Earth...can you expain this? Inshal- LAH, Al hamdu Li`l-LAH, Al-LAH, Abdul-LAH or have Abullah only one "L"? ALCOLHOL YES OR NO? Acc. Islam Al-LAH made a scripture from the Quran before he even start making the Earth or anything else. Shabir says that rules can change from: you can drink alcohol to only dont be drunken when you go pray to alcohol is forbidden. Hmm..Why was Al-Lah not clear with that when he got made a scripture before? Belive it or not, Al-Lah changed his mindset...
Not exactly, it was for people at that time to adapt to the new rules. If someone comes to you and forbid you from something you love would u be happy with it. But if they come to you and did this gradually you will be able to accept it better.
One must question why there are so many abrogations to excuse the numerous contradictions in the Quran. If the Quran is Allahs eternal book, perfectly preserved and the final revelation from the time it was recited to Mohammad, WHY didn't Allah get it right the first time???? Why does Allah have to create a "better" verse to overrule older verses??? Why does the Quran contradict the Jews Torah and Christian bibles which predate it by hundreds and thousands of years, Please do not try to claim these bibles were corrupted because not only are there THOUSANDS of historical manuscripts to confirm accuracy, the Quran itself claims the authenticity of the Jew and Christian Bibles.
Would you mind providing me with the belief system you subscribe too? It matters as your questions involves the old and new testament and it will make my response a little easier.
@@Guyanababoo217 Regardless of one’s beliefs, when you read and compare all three books, Quran, Bible and Torah, only the Bible and Torah are consistent with each other and make sense. The tone and manner in which theTorah and Bible are written are fluid , logical, spiritual, and inspiring. The tone and manner in which the Quran is written is the exact opposite. The Quran seems to be obsessed with polemics against Jews and Christians and fulfilling the carnal needs of its claimed prophet Mohammad. One does not need a belief system to objectively understand the writings of these book.
@@byip2415 No problem. I don't know why you're ashamed of your beliefs, but it's not a biggy.
You said a bit about abrogation then went on to ask "WHY didn't Allah get it right the first time???? Why does Allah have to create a "better" verse to overrule older verses???", you then went on to say that the Torah and Bible are logical.
Before digging into any specifics, I would like to question your logic. Let's apply the logic you're applying to the Quran, to the Bible, shall we?
"Jesus 🙂" created Adam and Eve and they sinned, causing him to come to earth and sacrifice himself, so that he could forgive their descendants. Why didn't he get it right the first time?
"Jesus 🙂" restricted the Jews from having pork, then allowed the Christians to eat whatever they want. Why didn't he get it right the first time?
"Jesus 🙂" forgave the Jews for their unintentional sins previously before ultimately sacrificing himself for their sins. Why didn't he get it right the first time?
Seems to me like you have a serious case of the double standard syndrome. I don't think Jesus would like that vary much :). Funny enough, out of the three book/ collection of books you've mentioned, all of them have abrogation, but only the one you're attacking, justifies it.
Deal with your lack of logic before I move on to your, oh so weak argument of manuscripts and what the Quran confirms or not.
@@Guyanababoo217 Please do not resort to ad hominems and make false accusations or assumptions about ones beliefs or unbeliefs. Please also do not try to pivot or attempt to distract from answering my questions. Thank you.
@@byip2415 I'm sorry for doing that, but i'm not pivoting. All I did was question your logic, by applying the same standard you've applied to the Quran, to the Bible. By doing this, i've demonstrated that your questions about abrogation are irrelevant based on your own standards.
I would like for you to accept the refutation by retracting your stance on abrogation or propose a rebuttal to the points i've raised, before moving forward.
Gradually means eternal,lol
Does allah permit drinking alcohol? It seems that he could not make up his mind. You may drink alcohol at least in wine (83:25), and allah organises rivers of delicious wine in paradise (47:15) and is good for people who reason (16:67). Drinking is not allowed during prayers (4:43), except if you still know what you are saying. On the other hand, consuming alcohol (from satan ) should be avoided (5:90, not forbidden!) and is a great sin (2:219), although alcohol has benefit for people.
83:22-26: Indeed, the righteous will be in pleasure. On adorned couches, observing. You will recognize in their faces the radiance of pleasure. They will be given to drink wine, sealed. The last of it is musk.
47:15 : Is the description of paradise, which the righteous are promised, wherein are rivers of water unaltered, rivers of milk the taste of which never changes, rivers of wine delicious to those who drink, and rivers of purified honey, in which they will have from all fruits and forgiveness from their lord, like those who abide eternally in the fire and are given to drink scalding water that will sever their intestines?
16:67: And from the fruits of the palm trees and grapevines you take intoxicant and good provision. Indeed in that is a sign for a people who reason.
4:43: O you who have believed, do not approach prayer while you are intoxicated until you know what you are saying or in a state of janabah , except those passing through, until you have washed. And if you are ill or on a journey or one of you comes from the place of relieving himself or you have contacted women and find no water, then seek clean earth and wipe over your faces and your hands.
5:90: O you who have believed, indeed, intoxicants, gambling, stone alters, and divining arrows are but defilement from the work of satan, so avoid it that you may be successful.
83:25 says "They will be given to drink a sealed wine" please fact check
@@po334 What you get in paradise is wine, sealed. Ok. But it should not be named wine, but grapejuice, etc. Anyway, there is still a contradiction left in the quran.
I think when they’re not sure they just choose not to drink, Shabir said we need to judge based on the situation. thats the problem when allah dont give clear answer, but together we can decide by ourselves.
wine in paradise isn’t intoxicating, wine on earth is intoxicating, that’s why we can drink wine in paradise
@@junudallah6406 "Drinking is not allowed during prayers, except if you still know what you are saying". Thus, it is allowed on other occasions and if you still know what you are saying.
Dr. Shabir, by maintaining objectivity and rejecting bigotry and religious biases i.e using one standard for all,
Only two outcomes make sense:
1. No contradictions in Quran and bible
2. Contractions in both quran and bible.
The third outcome (contradictions in one but not both) is definitely false.
I go with the second outcome.
Sadly your opinion doesn't matter.
The Bible and the Quran are totally different. The Quran was preserved and the Bible was changed.
@@hyrunnisa997
Change meaning having fake content?,
Quran by content is just the Hebrew Bible- the torah- translated into old Arabic and spread around the world. It is based on that supposedly fake biblical content.
@@geeljirejahil9570 lol. If you utter these things before even biblical theologians, they will call you mad. New testament is based on old testament as well but they are nearly hundreds of years gap. They are all from abrahamic faith and from same origins . At least the books claim that. No one is gonna buy your words until you establish that. Even the first Arabic bible is found to be hundred of years after the last prophet of Islam. You are trying to interpolate things and making up things that fits your preconceived mind set. You are historically wrong.
@@One-rr8um
It was not a translated copy of the bible.
The prophet got these biblical ideas from his immidiate environment and composed the arabic quran using these biblical ideas.
Assalamualaikum put subtitle Indonesia jazakallah
I drink alcohol tho I'm a Muslim just not on Ramadan. You aren't perfect Allah loves the sinners aswell. Someone who preys religiously and does everything could go to a hell. No one is guaranteed paradise by works lest anyone should boast right? I'm not promoting sin it's just that we are sinners regardless of religious economic status.
According to islam, every single muslim will eventually get to heaven. They may go to hell but only temporarily, so hell is more a purgatory for them.
Meanwhile we, the unbelievers, enter it forever. And every one of us will enter it.
@@baldwinthefourth4098 I'm waiting for a Christian to say Muslims will enter forever and I guess the catholic rumor of purgatory is real.
In Islam no one is guaranteed paradise. Fear Allah!
@@BeautifulMuslim99 Muslims are sooner or later all gonna enter paradise according to islamic sources.
THE BELOW MENTIONED VERSE OF THE QURAN PROVES THAT QURAN IS WORD OF GOD ALMIGHTY AND THAT ISLAM IS THE TRUE RELIGION,ITS SURAH AS-SAFF 61:6:
And ˹remember˺ when Jesus, son of Mary, said, “O children of Israel! I am truly Allah’s messenger to you, confirming the Torah which came before me, and giving good news of a messenger after me whose name will be Aḥmad.
HAD IT BEEN THAT MUHAMMED A.S. WAS A FALSE PROPHET HE WOULD NOT HAVE MENTIONED HIS NAME IN THE QURAN IN THE ABOVEMENTIONED VERSE AS AHMED,BECAUSE ALL IDOLATERS OF MECCA HAD KNOWN HIM FROM HIS BIRTH THAT HIS NAME WAS MUHAMMED, AND HE WOULDNT HAVE CONVINCED THEM TO BELIEVE HIS "FALSE MESSAGE" BECAUSE OF THAT NAME.BUT,ALLAH ALMIGHTY HAS USED HIS SECOND NAME AHMED AS ISA A.S. HAD MENTIONED HIM,THUS,ALLAH ALMIGHTY HAS TESTIFIED,CITED THE WORD OF ISA A.S. IN HIS ORIGINAL PREACHING SPEECH.
SO, IN OTHER WORDS MUHAMMED A.S. IF HE WASNT A PROPHET IT WOULD BE A EXTREME RISKY AND CERTAINLY GAMBLING FOR HIM TO WRITE HIS NAME AS AHMED IN THE QURAN.A NAME THAT QURAYSH HADNT KNOWN IT TO BE A NAME OF OUR BELOVED PROPHET.
What are you going on about ?
The only proof you got is that Islam is a Christian heresy
I think its com from js like this (2+2)=4+2 =6 Subhnallah Nothing contradiction about this❤️✊
Why are you lieing? There are many contradictions in Quran.
Days of playing with numbers are gone.
Summa means then....not otherway. Why Allah should confuse people?
Evidence?
@@user-sc6uu5iq2b you read, and you will get clrar evidences.
@@mansurhallaj8568 I've read the Quran many times, have not found any contradictions. Provide Evidence
@@arkstorm73 you read told get some Swab, you didn’t understand it.
@@mansurhallaj8568 what did you even say. Plas Engliss
Just say the Quran is a book 📖 of contradictions
If there are no contradictions in the Qur'an why do Muslims try to convert non-Muslims when Allah has already decreed who will go to paradise and who will go hell?(Qur'an 16: 93 et passim)
We have free will but God has the ultimate knowledge about who will end up where. But it's not because God did it himself but the abuse of freewill by the people.
@@sandan8787 good job, now adress his question
1 that’s false no Muslim can convert anyone....Who ever meant to be Muslim will be....
2. Your question made no sense and if you actually read Surah 16:93 it answers your own question smh
@@MansaMusa-v5q
whats does this sound to you?
Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.
@@ivonikolov2916 1. You should read the verse before that which was talking about the polytheism ppl....and when it’s speaking about fighting it’s referring to defending one self....letting one know u have the right to defend yourself
2. You should read 2:190
3. And since you’re pulling that from 9:29 you should also read 9:31 which talk about how ppl worship their prophets & how they worship Jesus....it states that none should be worship other then Allah (God)
2+4+2 =6 according to the muslim scholar here. Yet they mock we Christians with their 1+1+1=1God in falsely describing the Trinity. Which the koran explains as allah, Jesus and Mary.
Not to mention abrigation is a euphemism for correcting errors or editing.
Koran has been written by 6th century pagan men. Theres no one another than a muslim who could read quran and think that the author of the Bible wrote it. The character of the Bibles author and the korans author are diametrically opposed.
Yeshua (Jesus) says, "He is the beginning and the last Revelation 22:13, that disqualifies Mohammed from being a prophet."
yeah yeah we misunderstood that life created from sperm which is produced in the backbone . we were wrong that sperm is produced in testis