It's true though, what nicki said was true. Mariah's lower registers are sick. No one can touch Mariah's version. There's this so much emotions going on on that song that's just unparalleled. Classic!
She is a big fan of Mariah but I just wish that their fight and argument didn't happen at all.......they can be really cool friends with each other but who knows maybe in the future. Just wish both of them the best :)
Michael Marasigan - No she didn’t. Mariah went on idol to be praised and talk about herself. She gave no real criticism. She told everyone they did great and provided no actual advice of substance. Nicki Minaj gave better advice and very often Mariah would roll her eyes and make snide remarks while Nicki gave ACTUAL advice based on the contestants performances. That’s what they needed. Not someone who’s just showing up for the paycheck. But that wasn’t what I was referring to when I replied. The comment said “Mariah was so nice on Idol” and I said it was a lie because she was a very nasty person more times than one.
I think what some people forget is that you don’t have to be a singer to know if a version is good or not. What Nicki said is true because if anyone has heard Mariah’s version of the song, you would know that her version is the GOLD STANDARD of how to sing this song. Not only was Mariah’s high notes stellar (obviously) but also her low notes were unparalleled at the same time (which I think she doesn’t get enough credit for). You can just tell that Amber wasn’t fully confident in singing a song that needed so much vocal flexibility. She did good, but definitely not even close to what Mariah had done.
I just appreciate that mariah always tends to credit the people that helped her, like how the end she said, "Thank u herry neilson for writing such a great song"
@@thomsboys77 we're aware that badfinger was the original, they wrote it they made it first. BUT, mariah did not get inspiration from their version, she got inspiration from Harry Nilson's version and its obvious because her version sounds more like his than badfinger's
Nicki always acknowledges Mariah, she's a huge fan of her. Did you not see her interview when she said she was like the happiest little girl in the world when Mariah asked her to do "Up Out My Face" with her?!
Yas! Yas! Randy is right. It so hard to sing a Mariah song in front of MARIAH CAREY! Its just like killing yourself. Mariahs version its out of this world, the way she change the original version. Genius! And i love the way she mention Harry Neilsen and give credit for that song. I mean, thats how you appreciate a song. A REAL song!
Mariah puts so much emphasis on the importance of acknowledging songwriters (herself included). I can't believe she thought Harry Nilsson wrote this song!
Well its the version she hears and grew up with . It's like how most people assume just the way you are is Bruno Mars song originally cause he popularised it .
It shows you how fake she is. She made millions off of this song. She should at least know who wrote the song because I'm guessing a part of the money she makes off of it goes to the families of the writers, and not the person who made it a huge success back in the 70's. Really strange how she didn't know. Seems impossible not to know.
***** no . The way she did her cover is based off of Harry ' s version not badfinger's. Chances are that she really might not have known hey . Maybe Harry bought the rights to the song ? We don't know -
Grant Morgan Actually we do know. There's the internet, and the song is still credited to the two dead members of the band. I guarantee you if someone took a Mariah song and made it their own and someone else copied the new version - Mariah would be pissed if they gave the other person credit for writing the song. I understand that maybe when she first did the song years ago she may have been clueless, but once she made the recording and made money off of it - it's sort of surprising that so many years later she didn't know who the writer. On her album, it must give credit to the actual writers. Actually it does. It gives credit to both Peter and Tom of Badfinger.
She's a Soprano, of course those low notes are hard for her; her voice shines on the high notes. *Mariah* is also a Soprano but an extraordinary one! 👑
@@dejasimmons8759 Mariah said she's an alto so she's a fucking alto. I'm sure Mariah knows her voice better than you especially considering she was trained by an opera singer.
@@TheCallowayBride she has said herself that she doesn’t know what she truly is in multiple interviews and she has been known to not know technical terms she is a mezzo soprano which is between a altos range and a soprano also her mother the opera singer you are speaking of didn’t train her as much as you think she taught her the basics of the voice and Mariah grew with that
@@dejasimmons8759 Real Mariah fans believe her when she says she is an alto. She has said it bold and proud so go evaluate Taylor Swift's voice or something.
Without you, Hero and We belong together are songs you don't sing in front of Mariah because you will always have her voice in your mind and to match a Mariah song is technically impossible.
Nicki was right though, there are things that Mariah can do vocally that literally no one else can do...that woman is a vocal BEAST! I can't imagine breathing in front of Thee Mariah Carey let alone singing one of her songs in front of her omg I'd FAINT
I like both Mariah and Nicki's comments, because it was true that her low beginning was a bit underwhelmed and not so emotional, but yeah, some very interesting choices as well
LOL at Ryan making fun of the rambling that the judges did. Four judges on a short time limit to say their opinions, what did they expect? lol I'd be rambling too probably.
I don't think Nicki has any idea of what she's going on about. Of course Mariah's version is better, she has 7 octaves on her side lol Amber done pretty good considering how many notes Mariah puts into her verson.
technically and vocally, she doesnt know anything about vocals... she just speak whats on her mind and what she think about their singing while mariah always speak about how someone can improve their vocal & technique and what part they are lacking ... i think we need both of that in competition like this...
She did'nt even know that her song was on top1 Billboard 100 when she won Billboard's Artist of Decade in 90s. So the fact that she didn't know who penned Without you is acceptable
Omg... Mariah saying how her mom used to sing this song to her as a baby is so sweet... she must have imparted a little of her interpretation when she did her own cover even though we know there's drama there....
Give her a break. You cannot compare Mariah to Amber! Mariah is the best we all know that but this young lady thid a great job! Concerning Nicki... come on, she even can't sing that song like Amber did.
No, they were definitely NOT cool. Nicki had to give props cuz she couldn't be untrue to them memories growing up listening to the Voice. She went out of her way to attempt to acknowledge Mariah WITHOUT complimenting her, and she FAILED. I seem to remember Mariah falling all over herself to correct the songwriting thing but I didn't quite understand why at the time. I mean I know it's important but unless it's like marjorly obvious I wouldn't criticize her for it. I mean when Rihanna sampled MJ for Please Don't Stop the Music she didn't even pay who he sampled, b/c she sampled a sample. They had to sue to get their money, otherwise no one would've been the wiser.
I wonder why they gave Whitney Houston the title of "The Voice". She was a talented singer. But, she primarily only applied two vocal techniques to her singing.......belts and Gospel-styled riffs. I am certain that the record company had a lot to do with this limited vocal styling. Although she is not popular in commercial music, Rachelle Ferrell should have the title of "The Voice". Ms. Ferrell is a TOTALLY free singer (all singers which to become).
She was talking about her version. What Mariah recorded was a collaboration with Harry Nilsson to fit her cover. Harry & Mariah made some changes so it won’t sound exactly as the Badfinger original.
cant believe mariah carey does not know harry nillson was NOT the writer of this song it was written by 2 members of the little known rock band called badfinger
I agree with Nicki, i love Mariah, but i am noticing that Mariah now is different with Mariah was before, i mean she is seems unfocus and you know right? Just check it during early career until even butterfly, she seems very mature and graceful, but now seems like lost and turned childish. this just my thought
Never forget the beauty that the original is. Harry Nillssen's raw vocals is what made that song so amazing. Mariah did a great cover but i'll always love Nillssen's more.
How was she rude? She just told her opinion in a very kind way, actually. She was a judge. That was her job. She wasn't there just to compliment everybody and said what they wanted to hear.
![Angie Miller - American Idol Season 12 - All Performances [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/uxJ44RJyVQc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Eminem - Tobey (feat. Big Sean & Babytron) [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/9xn0OHEZZ8Q/mqdefault.jpg)
Nicki doing the "Mariah hand flailing" hahaha. But what she said is true though. Mariah's version will forever be unbeatable.
Yeah true! Mariah is so humble!
Anastasia Romanov
It's true though, what nicki said was true. Mariah's lower registers are sick. No one can touch Mariah's version. There's this so much emotions going on on that song that's just unparalleled. Classic!
Very well said :)
She could just not be rude
Amanda Quaresma shes not rude she was just honest and theres a difference between those two
Baklang toh ahahaha
Leona Lewis version was good
Nicki stanning for Mariah! Yass
Mariah was being humble, if it wasn’t a song she sang she would have agreed with Nicki
1:30 Mariah like you better know it girl you better know it
PERIODT
Hhhhahahha
For the record, Mariah corrected herself on twitter right after this episode aired with the correct songwriter.
This is a hit over 35 countries!:)
Hmm.I agree with Nicki coz the version of "Without You" by Mariah is always in my mind even i hear anyone singing that song.
Don't sing Without You in front of Mariah. Crazy.
CyprusHot but Mariah is loving her version of the Song.
And what are you doing with your life? Lol
Singapore Pearl pmm Please dont send me RUclips notifications when I’m trying to sleep
Singapore Pearl again.... trying to sleep lol🤫
ikr! Don't even try dahling😂
1:28 Mariah Carey's face! Lol
Niki is right, even when beefing Mariah always deserves props for her talent. She’s second to none, NONE!
there was no beef. it was a script 😘
or at least i like to think 😅
1:28 that face Mariah made!!😘😁❤️
mariah looks like she wants to cry for amber when nicki said she didnt like her cover
AW! That was cute! Nicki is a fan of Mariah!
She is a big fan of Mariah but I just wish that their fight and argument didn't happen at all.......they can be really cool friends with each other but who knows maybe in the future. Just wish both of them the best :)
I'm confused as to how they even fell out.
@@ericvssl They were being secretly silent friends. 🤭
l love Mariah Carey.
First thing that Nicki said that was right lol ! Mariah is a legend !
Mariah was so nice on Idol
Agreed!
We clearly weren't watching the same show.
@@KingKenTM your interpretation is different then. She gives valid recommendations and criticisms as a great singer's perspective.
Michael Marasigan - No she didn’t. Mariah went on idol to be praised and talk about herself. She gave no real criticism. She told everyone they did great and provided no actual advice of substance. Nicki Minaj gave better advice and very often Mariah would roll her eyes and make snide remarks while Nicki gave ACTUAL advice based on the contestants performances. That’s what they needed. Not someone who’s just showing up for the paycheck. But that wasn’t what I was referring to when I replied. The comment said “Mariah was so nice on Idol” and I said it was a lie because she was a very nasty person more times than one.
@@KingKenTM Girl 2013 is over, get over it too
UGHH I LOVE THIS SOOO MUCH LOVE NICKI AND MIMI!!!
nicki praisinh Mariah ,okay am i dreaming
It's not the first time she has praised MC.
She’s one of her idols
Nicky is actually a great fan of Mariah and I do really feel that shes honest when she said that
Mariah's face at 1:29 is PRICELESS
they love each other
LMAO that Bitch was so happy to be praised by Nicki she was like "Guuuurl your sooo right Her version is not better than mine" hahaha
honest comments from Nicki :P
Nicki has a point but Salute to Mariah's Humbleness. She knows how hard the low notes are that is why she herself did not complain.
I think what some people forget is that you don’t have to be a singer to know if a version is good or not. What Nicki said is true because if anyone has heard Mariah’s version of the song, you would know that her version is the GOLD STANDARD of how to sing this song. Not only was Mariah’s high notes stellar (obviously) but also her low notes were unparalleled at the same time (which I think she doesn’t get enough credit for). You can just tell that Amber wasn’t fully confident in singing a song that needed so much vocal flexibility. She did good, but definitely not even close to what Mariah had done.
I just appreciate that mariah always tends to credit the people that helped her, like how the end she said, "Thank u herry neilson for writing such a great song"
She credited the wrong people. Badfinger’s Pete Ham and Tom Evans wrote “Without You”, not Nilsson
@@thomsboys77 we're aware that badfinger was the original, they wrote it they made it first. BUT, mariah did not get inspiration from their version, she got inspiration from Harry Nilson's version and its obvious because her version sounds more like his than badfinger's
@@jonathan_8100 Not the point. She should credit the correct songwriters regardless if she didn’t base her version on them
@@thomsboys77she corrected herself on twitter right after the show
first time i heard nicki acknowledge mariah at all...
Nicki always acknowledges Mariah, she's a huge fan of her. Did you not see her interview when she said she was like the happiest little girl in the world when Mariah asked her to do "Up Out My Face" with her?!
Ronnie Arellano calm down lol
For the first time I agree with Nicki
Yas! Yas! Randy is right. It so hard to sing a Mariah song in front of MARIAH CAREY! Its just like killing yourself.
Mariahs version its out of this world, the way she change the original version. Genius! And i love the way she mention Harry Neilsen and give credit for that song. I mean, thats how you appreciate a song. A REAL song!
i just Loved how nicki explained to Amber about what she wanted to hear.. i totally agreed with nicki!
MARIAH'S FACE WHEN NICKI WAS TALKING ABOUT HER LOOOOOOOOOOOL.
Mariah puts so much emphasis on the importance of acknowledging songwriters (herself included). I can't believe she thought Harry Nilsson wrote this song!
essa ñ é uma composição de Mariah Carey... dãaaaaaa
Well its the version she hears and grew up with . It's like how most people assume just the way you are is Bruno Mars song originally cause he popularised it .
It shows you how fake she is. She made millions off of this song. She should at least know who wrote the song because I'm guessing a part of the money she makes off of it goes to the families of the writers, and not the person who made it a huge success back in the 70's. Really strange how she didn't know. Seems impossible not to know.
***** no . The way she did her cover is based off of Harry ' s version not badfinger's. Chances are that she really might not have known hey . Maybe Harry bought the rights to the song ? We don't know -
Grant Morgan Actually we do know. There's the internet, and the song is still credited to the two dead members of the band. I guarantee you if someone took a Mariah song and made it their own and someone else copied the new version - Mariah would be pissed if they gave the other person credit for writing the song. I understand that maybe when she first did the song years ago she may have been clueless, but once she made the recording and made money off of it - it's sort of surprising that so many years later she didn't know who the writer. On her album, it must give credit to the actual writers. Actually it does. It gives credit to both Peter and Tom of Badfinger.
When Mariah sing the song, it becomes hers. It is so difficult to imitate it!
Looking at Randy and Mariah brings me back to the early 90's lol
She's a Soprano, of course those low notes are hard for her; her voice shines on the high notes. *Mariah* is also a Soprano but an extraordinary one! 👑
Mariah is an alto. Go watch her video where she says so.
@@TheCallowayBride she’s a mezzo soprano
@@dejasimmons8759 Mariah said she's an alto so she's a fucking alto. I'm sure Mariah knows her voice better than you especially considering she was trained by an opera singer.
@@TheCallowayBride she has said herself that she doesn’t know what she truly is in multiple interviews and she has been known to not know technical terms she is a mezzo soprano which is between a altos range and a soprano also her mother the opera singer you are speaking of didn’t train her as much as you think she taught her the basics of the voice and Mariah grew with that
@@dejasimmons8759 Real Mariah fans believe her when she says she is an alto. She has said it bold and proud so go evaluate Taylor Swift's voice or something.
Nicki was 100% right
charmedgleek not
This was the best panel of judges on Idol
Mariah was so sweet on American Idol I wonder if she's this lenient with her kids. She was the nicest judge ever
Without you, Hero and We belong together are songs you don't sing in front of Mariah because you will always have her voice in your mind and to match a Mariah song is technically impossible.
tHANKS!! I WAS LOOKING FOR IT. Ryan Seacrest is why I watch this show too. Just like the way he always add his bit to the show.
nicki i agree with you
Randy will never stop name dropping!
NICKI EXPLAINED IT PERFECTLY !!!!!
Agree with Nicki
Mariah were like "I know Iam"
Nicki was right though, there are things that Mariah can do vocally that literally no one else can do...that woman is a vocal BEAST! I can't imagine breathing in front of Thee Mariah Carey let alone singing one of her songs in front of her omg I'd FAINT
1:29 Mariah's face! LOL! Made my day 😂
1:48 Mariah Carey face--she felt bad for the girl when Nicki said "It wasn't good" --so much empathy
Yes Mariah- you are a Legend
But a little bit haughty
preach nicki!
When Mariah thanked the songwriter. #RESPECT
Songwriter to songwriter.
She thanked the wrong songwriter. Pete Ham and Tom Evans from the band Badfinger wrote Without You, not Harry Nilsson
@@thomsboys77 i think I told you this in another thread but she didnt get inspiration from theirs she got inspo from harry's, end of story.
Back when American Idol was about vocalists
I like both Mariah and Nicki's comments, because it was true that her low beginning was a bit underwhelmed and not so emotional, but yeah, some very interesting choices as well
The way Nicki's hand moved makes it look like she's sketching her next red carpet costumes.
Nobody:
Keith Urban: *"Woooh, we got an Amber Alert going on!😁🙋"* 0:15
LMAO
she have to have guts to sing that song in front of mariah carey. congratz amber!
Mariah Carey was like ayyy gurlll
Freaking love Nicki’s Extraness
Nicki is a Mariah fan. They respect eachother but media and AI put them against eachother. There's no actual feud it's entertainment stuff.
If nicki and mariah can get along, they were great as judge
That was encouraging from MC I mean.
LOL at Ryan making fun of the rambling that the judges did. Four judges on a short time limit to say their opinions, what did they expect? lol I'd be rambling too probably.
Ryan 😂 i laughed so hard
I❤and love you and how the job was and how
mariah carey the best
I agree with nicki with wat all she said... wen Mariah cover a song u forget d original, bcoz dats how gud she is. And a humble superstar
1:28 that diva stare.
aff!! pq a Nick sempre tem q alfinetar Mariah, qanta inveja
I think she did great ,the song is haaard especially with them low notes
Pete Ham & Tom Evans from The band Badfinger wrote the song "Without You"
Mariah carey is the Queen no1 can compare to her but Amber did an amazing job.... Talent I support Talent. Nicki lacks that lol
Stupid bitter gourd
So classy that Mariah acknowledges Harry Neilson as the writer. Most people would have want to have people believe their the writer.
Nilsson didn’t even write the song. Badfinger’s Pete Ham and Tom Evans wrote the song...
When it comes to country music, Keith is very keen. But when it comes to other music, he is ... kinda .. too nice.
Nicki is just only truthful critic
Randy deixou Nick por baixo,bem feito.
Leona Lewis' version on XFactor 2006 is still the best cover! Props to Amber, love your version too.
I definitely agree with nicki I didn’t think this performance was all thar
bachata
I don't think Nicki has any idea of what she's going on about. Of course Mariah's version is better, she has 7 octaves on her side lol Amber done pretty good considering how many notes Mariah puts into her verson.
She does know what she's talking about
KEITH URBAN DEFINITELY SCREWED UP BY SAYING "AMBER ALERT"😳
is nicki perfect for a judge?
technically and vocally, she doesnt know anything about vocals... she just speak whats on her mind and what she think about their singing while mariah always speak about how someone can improve their vocal & technique and what part they are lacking ... i think we need both of that in competition like this...
Harry Nelson didn't write that song, Badfinger did. Just sayin'
yeah, she tweet about that and corrected herself
@@antoncutie where
@@jonathan_8100 there's screenshot of the tweet floating around twitter, find it yourself but its true that she corrected herself in a very humble way
Mariah
Omg mariah credited harry nilson and not badfinger for writing the song. How does she not know harry covered it too 😂
She did'nt even know that her song was on top1 Billboard 100 when she won Billboard's Artist of Decade in 90s. So the fact that she didn't know who penned Without you is acceptable
Duy Lê heartbreaker or tgify? And how do you know she didnt know that? Lol
She corrected herself on Twitter after the show~
Seth Kitamura oh I didn't remember that
Omg... Mariah saying how her mom used to sing this song to her as a baby is so sweet... she must have imparted a little of her interpretation when she did her own cover even though we know there's drama there....
Mariah's face lmao
Never. EVER. SING. MARIAH's Song in music Competition. Period.
Especially in front of her lol
It’s not her song anyway
for the very 1st time i'm agree with Nicki. lol
Give her a break. You cannot compare Mariah to Amber! Mariah is the best we all know that but this young lady thid a great job! Concerning Nicki... come on, she even can't sing that song like Amber did.
what the heeeeeeeel is Nicki minaj talking about!!!!!!!! like hell she can sing the first sentence of that song!!!!PLIIIIIIZ
Mariah did not write it Ryan
No, they were definitely NOT cool. Nicki had to give props cuz she couldn't be untrue to them memories growing up listening to the Voice. She went out of her way to attempt to acknowledge Mariah WITHOUT complimenting her, and she FAILED. I seem to remember Mariah falling all over herself to correct the songwriting thing but I didn't quite understand why at the time. I mean I know it's important but unless it's like marjorly obvious I wouldn't criticize her for it. I mean when Rihanna sampled MJ for Please Don't Stop the Music she didn't even pay who he sampled, b/c she sampled a sample. They had to sue to get their money, otherwise no one would've been the wiser.
Mariah is "songbird supreme "
I wonder why they gave Whitney Houston the title of "The Voice". She was a talented singer. But, she primarily only applied two vocal
techniques to her singing.......belts and Gospel-styled riffs. I
am certain that the record company had a lot to do with this limited
vocal styling. Although she is not popular in commercial music, Rachelle Ferrell should have the title of "The Voice". Ms. Ferrell is a TOTALLY free singer (all singers which to become).
Harry Nilson for writing a great song? Lmao that was a Badfinger song!!
She was talking about her version. What Mariah recorded was a collaboration with Harry Nilsson to fit her cover. Harry & Mariah made some changes so it won’t sound exactly as the Badfinger original.
Shes talking about the version she was inspired from
Well did anyone notice nicki is throwing shade lol?
+Tone Deaf where
In yo face :D
Tone Deaf I didn't see any shade, only praise.
No~~~
OMG what was Nicki saying? Lol
cant believe mariah carey does not know harry nillson was NOT the writer of this song it was written by 2 members of the little known rock band called badfinger
I agree with Nicki, i love Mariah, but i am noticing that Mariah now is different with Mariah was before, i mean she is seems unfocus and you know right? Just check it during early career until even butterfly, she seems very mature and graceful, but now seems like lost and turned childish. this just my thought
Never forget the beauty that the original is. Harry Nillssen's raw vocals is what made that song so amazing. Mariah did a great cover but i'll always love Nillssen's more.
yeah nicki was right
Am i the only one who hates her expression while she was paying attention to the judges?? It kinda said "ohh shut up bitches!! I did great already!"
Noo standing o from nicki
It's such a difficult song ans she did a decent job! Nicki was so rude! And then Mariah is the "diva" 🙄
How was she rude? She just told her opinion in a very kind way, actually. She was a judge. That was her job. She wasn't there just to compliment everybody and said what they wanted to hear.
@@yasminfalcao5583 WORD