This is why I love books: everyone has their taste. No one *has* to like or dislike a book. This is also why I hate it when book lovers shame each other for liking certain books/genres.
Kristen Nowlin I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you somewhat, but when a story doesn’t make sense or is just riding on the coat tails of another book, it can be really frustrating when people call it brilliant or say that it’s the best book ever
@@graceglitters7371 I... I'm not the only one?!? I always thought everyone just loved it, apart from me. I mean, it's not bad, but not that great either
Certain books shouldn't be liked by anyone. Books that make toxic behaviour, racism etc quirky or cool and ok. Or Pedophilia (I'm looking at you...LOLITA.). For normal books I agree with you. But for literally dangerous books.. nahhh.
I read Thirteen Reasons Why when it first came out. I was in like 9th grade and I HATED it. Honestly it made suicide look like a petty, arbitrary choice a teenage girl might make just cuz she's in a bad mood that day. And then there's the whole "love could have saved her" thing. Like, I just thought it was kind of "meh" until I started working with a suicide hotline at which point I revisited it and decided I downright hated it.
Agreed. I didn't even really enjoy the storyline from and "entertainment" standpoint. I read it years ago when my best friend recommended it to me. She said it was "so good" and it was her favorite book by far. When I read it I was very underwhelmed. And I still haven't watched the series either.
see, i never saw it that way. i always looked at like, be careful of your actions, because you never know what someone is going through or how what you say might affect them. so like if someone is already REALLY depressed, one little insult might be that push that sends them over the edge, if they're that close to it already. i think 13 reasons showed how little trivial things can build and build, how they can add up until they become too much. i haven't watched the series yet, and i kind of don't want to, cuz i'm worried i won't care for the show. i can see why a lot of people think her reasons for committing suicide in the book were petty/trivial, but i think a lot of people also need to realize that the little things add up.
MewVenus it shows how your actions affect people and yes love can save people. Just be nice to people and think before you speak. But the blaming of other people from her tapes is so so wrong! Ppl who are depressed want to never make people want to feel bad because they know how it feels. Like maybe from experience but no person feeling like that will want ppl to feel the same way.
I read it before a year or so before the show came out and I think I only enjoyed it for the storytelling and the fast pace of it, but honestly looking back at it, it’s not the “healthiest” book to recommend to people.
"Smoke a lot of cigarettes, drink a lot of alcohol, and nothing really happens." Haha that describes the high school experience of a lot of American kids.
I’d take milk shots and here’s the funny story behind it: whenever I’m sad I drink a full glass of milk. Idk why I think I just love milk. So that way, when I get older I don’t get an alcohol problem, only a milk problem
The book thief is one of the most amazing books I have ever read it almost made me cry twice but I held it back because I was in school I finished it in like 5 days and then I saw the movie and was so mad there were so many things and characters that were left out u don't care if it was a 8 hour movie and they included everything I loved that book my family is now doing it as a read aloud and I love it even more now it is one of the most amazing books I have ever read I mean it is up there with To Kill a Mockingbird and I love that book so so much so if she disses on the book thief I will be so mad😡
I found Jude really likable, despite being morally grey, her manipulating them causes the book to be very character-driven and she was able to the manipulate them because she made herself valuable and managed to get herself invulnerable to their charms
yes! I didn't see Jude as unlikeable at all - I saw some points when she tried to be cunning in the way that faeries are, but never saw her as a bad person
Rose Van Hemmen I can relate in that as well. I was named after Emily Bronte, the most boring and uptight Bronte sister and I think that shapes the characters. However, you have one of the best Golden Girls at least.
Emily Rose Dreams That's true! Idk if you've seen Gilmore Girls but Emily Gilmore is one of my favourite characters, she's awesome :) I guess there are lots of good and bad characters for each name.
!SPOILERS! For me Looking for Alaska is more of a cause and effect book than anything. You’re supposed to know that Alaska is going to die, it gives you a certain perspective on the first half of the book. As for Miles, it was pretty clear to me from the beginning that he was more in love with the idea of Alaska than anything. It’s a sort of cautionary tale, he idealized her so much that he just ignored the issues that eventually led to her death. I see it as a sort of warning about idealizing both people and life. However, this is just my interpretation of the book :)
I don’t get why suicide is presented in this way, like it’s someone else’s fault. I’ve had moments where I seriously considered suicide, and even though in the moment, I’m like, life is just too much, it’s the depression’s fault, not yours for feeling that way, a normal person in the same situation doesn’t react the same, that’s why it’s a mental illness. I hurt for people who think they did something wrong after their friend commits suicide. Like no honey, you couldn’t have known. When I was in my bad places I isolated myself, I didn’t want to tell people how bad I felt, that’s why suicide is often so surprising, we put on a smiling face for our friends and family.
SheWhoWalksSilently thank you for this actually. I have friends who are really having a bad time with depression and I’m trying to help them. Whenever they start talking about suicide I really feel that I’m not doing them and I blame myself. Although one is doing much better. So thank you😊
I get what you mean but every suicide victim did not commit suicide due to depression. I was never depressed but I have had suicidal thoughts due to bullying. Being a friend is also not the same as a bully. Bullying is what have caused almost all of my mental illness today. I think there is a huge correlation between bullying and mental illness and also suicide that needs to be talked about. Bullying is like hurting a person on the inside which affects the person negative.
The way Alaska is described in that description is very delibrate on john green's part. That is the point of the book. Miles sees alaska as this otherworldly "thing", not a person. I feel like that is the point of most of Green's books. People think he is only writing about manic pixie dream girls; but they are not manic pixie dream girls. Thats the way the male protagonist sees her as, and he always turns out to be wrong. That was the message in both paper towns and Looking for Alaska. I'm not that articulate with this, but I saw a post on tumblr describing how his books are misconstrued, basically saying that his books are about whiny teenage boys realizing that they have been over idealizing women in their lives, seeing women as stories rather than complex, autonomous beings, and how wrong that is. But ofcourse, you can dislike the book still😅 Just pointing out my personal feeling about the issue you highlighted😅😄
Yeah if you watch his videos on RUclips you see this is a journey that he had to go through himself and therefore he writes about teenage boys who have to learn everything he had to learn. Is it something I see all the time and lots of books, don't be a character who isn't isn't an explicit antagonist that is intentionally unlikable and people will go oh I didn't like this book because I didn't like insert character, this is commonly done with the Great Gatsby, hint you aren't supposed to like Daisy Buchanan, and Gatsby's a romantic feelings for her are not supposed to be healthy.
Manmehak Kaur I totally agree with this! One of the main points of the story (at least that I felt) was that Miles was more in love with this idea of Alaska than who she actually was. That to me at least was pretty clear throughout the book
I like them because they prove that the reviewers are honest and aren't afraid to give their honest opinion. They're also super cathartic when you also hate the books
As someone who suffers depression and had suicide attempts, 13rw physically made me sick to read. I forced myself to watch the show after.. And it was even worse. 😣
I’m so torn on that book. I love the writing of the book, but some parts of the book could have been left on the cutting board IMO and it would have made the beautiful writing that much better.
Thank you Hannah!!! I detest 13 Reasons Why. There are so many other ways they could have dealt with the tough topics. Counselors are there to help you. It's ridiculous that there were no other lifelines.
Florentine Violet I listened to the audio book years ago and COULDN’T STAND IT. I was shocked that it became so popular and that Netflix made a series about it. The same thing happened with Twilight. I listened to the audio book while I was on a long drive with my Dad. At the end we just looked at each other like “WTF???”.
me too...my cousin liked it a lot and i couldn't really understand why....Hannah Baker just didn't really have an impact on me and i really didn't care about her......this book could have been much better but the message was conveyed really poorly
Yup, I also agree. I listened to the audio book because I saw the series and wanted to see if the book was better than the series (because I didn't like the series too much haha). And, yea, the book is better. I like the way it portrays Hannah more, but in the end it was still very meh.
Well, with Looking for Alaska the point isn't the plot. It's a character study and you see how Pudge is a bad person and you have to look past his narration and see her beyond that at her as a character. She is actually very complex and that's what the end is all about. He realizes how badly he imagined her and how selfish he was as a person to her. It's about the breakdown of toxic masculinity.
Thanks. I am currently reading Looking for alaska and I have not see it that way. I thought it was boring, still think it is, but you definitely show me a new way of looking at it.
What I understood as Jude's motive was that she was primarily bitter about being human. She kinda envied her older sister at the beginning for being a fairie, throughout the book she was constantly taunted for being weak and unable to defend herself against fairies, I assume this also stems from the fact that her father kidnapped her and killed her mother. While her twin sister accepts inferiority and behaves, Jude didn't want to be submissive she wanted power. I think the sisters themselves show how different a traumatic event can affect a person. For Jude it invoked something violent and vengeful but for Taryn (?) It was a message to stay down and obey people in power. Also the 2nd and 3rd book go in much deeper into Jude and Carden 😭 they're so good 👌
Call me by your name is like my favorite thing ever both book and movie so when you mentioned it I took a deep breath and basically turned into that Arthur meme with his fist but I respect your opinion and I’m okay 😂
I also understand hannah's opinion... this book hit me in a way i wasn't expecting to and I might never watch the movie but i did enjoy the book, it's one of my favorites books but i don't think i'm going read it again, i just can't :P
Broooooooo, noooooo. Not the cruel prince, not the cruel prince 😭😔💔 Just to add, where are all the cruel prince fans and comments? I'm out here by myself.. its lonely
Life gets hard when you’re an ace YA loving reader who just wants good YA books without a lot of romance in it. I don’t like a lot of popular books because why is there no adventures where people don’t suddenly fall in love?
If you like adventure books I would suggest the Nightrunner series by Lynn flewelling. It’s a fantasy adventure series. The main characters don’t fall in love until the second book. It’s one of my favorites!
EXACTLY! Apart from that fact the the MC paints as a living and there's insta-love, it sounds EXACTLY like acotar. The live interest is even called the Autumn Prince.....
LMAO I love that you talk about Enchantment of Ravens and say "It's extremely short, it's about 300 pages" I'm just dying, I totally relate but omg if someone who doesn't love books heard that
I believe she said that due to the fact that it's a fantasy book. In this genre the writter has to introduce this whole new world and explain everything from scrap so I would also say 300 pages is really short for a book of this type.
Regarding Jude. Her motives are clear in that she doesn’t want to adapt to this world by being a scared mortal like Taryn. She wants to be recognized as strong and par with faerie. She was able to lie - that was what was special about her. It’s sad that it didn’t click for you. :/ I don’t understand how that all went over your head.
I just started The Cruel Prince and it has me hook line and sinker. Hopefully it lives up to the hype; by how it started, I’m pretty sure it’s gonna be a great book.
An enchantment of ravens sounds almost exactly like a court of thorns and roses hmmmm let's see -painter feyre -human in a fae world feyre -falls in love with some powerful fae lets see..........................feyre
Thought so too. I even looked up the release dates and thorns and roses were release 2 years before an enchantment. So I'm thinking...did she plagiarized Sarah's work?
Talking about Call me by your name and the lack of development, I feel really connected to it because that's how all my summers were as a Spanish person. It's a really cultural thing that I feel it serves a nostalgia purpose. But you definitely got a point, I just loved it because it took me back to my own memories. Love your honest opinions and analysis!
Sorry, I'm not sure if it was understandable 😑 hahaha the lack of development is the feeling I get from my slow summers, the cities slow down so much, it always feels like nothing happens whilst you grow and change and think a lot, and spend a lot of the time in the house hiding from the sun and with friends during the nights....so that lack of development delivers that kind of emotion
No, I would completely agree with your statement. Call Me By Your Name was one of my favorite books partly because of the intense and very real feelings of first love and infatuation but also, partly because as someone who is French, it really highlights European culture and thinking. While we may not go on crazy, lavish planned dates like many Americans do, we have a way of doing nothing and meaning everything to the person we care about.
I personally love call me by your name, both the book and the movie but I definitely understand why it could be a bit too much for some people 😂 the peach scene is really something else
Oh, well. I didn`t read Looking for Alaska, but after your description, it is literally the same as paper towns. In both books there is the protagonist, who falls in love with a girl and sees her in a way everybody sees her, but not who she really is, the protagonist grows as a person and in the end, he is okay with leaving the girl behind, because now he is a better, more mature and sort of an understanding adult.
Lily Unruh i’m not sure after reading both paper towns and looking for alaska looking for alaska is definitely better paper towns was the most boring thing ever
exactly and now I hate that every john green's protagonist has to meet some person in order to grow up, i was fascinated by this trope when I was a teenager and I always thought being single is pathetic, i hated my life for this
I bought it before the major hype hit because "beauty and the beast retelling" and "really nice cover". I didn't read it until after the hype and I'm glad because I feel like I've grown as a reader and if I had read it when I first bought it I feel like I may have liked it because that was a period when I sort of just liked everything for some reason.
Agreed, I don't really like any of the series ( acomaf was honestly no better imo) but I love throne of glass and am worried it's becoming too much like the acotar series :/
I find it very funny that you hate Looking For Alaska and love Turtles all the way down, and I’m the opposite. LFA is one of my favourite books, and in my opinion TATWD has no plot to me. I just find that funny, but I’m glad to hear your opinion on it.
Same! Loved LFA, didn't really like TATWD. I felt it was a bit tonally confused, like it wanted to have a Paper Towns mystery but to also be TFIOS at the same time.
Alex why? The movie is actually so much better than the book and is nowhere near as sexual as the book was. Yes the peach scene is still in there, but it’s done in a way where it doesn’t seem as gross. Also Timothée Chalamet and Armie Hammer had insane chemistry and both were fantastic in their roles.
I vividly remember forgetting everything that happened in Looking for Alaska the moment I finished it. Like, honestly, I was forgetting it as I was reading it.
When I first read Queen of the Tearling I actually put it down after 50 pages but then decided to pick it up again about a year later and now its one of my favourite series, I can see why some people don't like it though, it took me ages to get into it!
The ending of Call Me By Your Name is the definition of nostalgia and it's so so good, and even if the rest of the book is a little slow (and gross) it was worth it
girl yassssss!!! you had me shook over looking for alaska though, it was my favorite book when i was in middle school so now i'm curious if i'll still love it now... you've inspired me to re-read it
oh as a gay guy i can confirm that call me by your name is trash. the age gap in the relationship is thing that seals its fate above all else for me, it makes me horribly uncomfortable and it plays into a lot of harmful and unfounded stereotypes that surround gay men. "it's just seven years why does it matter". dude, if you're 17 you're like, still in high school, whereas most 24 year olds are already out of college, if they went to college. if you're 17 you probably still live with your parents, if you're 24 you might even have a family of your own. if you're 17 you are still legally a CHILD and if you're 24 you're legally an adult. there's more i could say about that book, but i'd be wasting my breath. basically just trust my (gay) opinion when i say it sucks okay it belongs in the garbage.
the film take place in italy, and the age consent in there is 14. So basically elio is an adult. And if u watch the movie or read the book, elio is actually the one who is more dominant than oliver.
@@kawsarjune4894I really enjoyed it myself, especially Jude having her own agency thoughout the book despite being lost and confused at times, the family relationships were also really complex and nuanced thoughout the series. And then it gets even better from the end of Cruel Prince and into the next books, but I don't want to spoil why. If the faerie politics is boring to you, I can see why it's hard to push through.
I think the key to love call me by your name is to watch the movie first. Cause movie is better (in my opinion at least) and it makes you love the characters and understand emotions. Book is Elio's sick mind. I loved it and hated it but after finising it I watched movie again and omg, luca guadagnino is a f genius for all that scenes that was SO important and wasn't even in the book.
agat787 AGREED. A straight man writing about a mlm relationship is uncomfortable, tho I did read and like the book having a gay man like luca really bringing the book to life in the film adaptation is what really makes call me by your name touch your heart and pull at the heartstrings.
When she said she didn’t understand what was so special about Jude that she could climb the social ladder and do stuff other humans couldn’t I was legit like did u even read the book? Madoc is literally the general and she had special circumstances compared to the other humans that usually get taken to faerie. That rlly annoyed me ngl.
I disagree with your assessment of Looking for Alaska in terms of Miles not learning anything. He does fall in love with Alaska because she’s hot, and the book shows how we fall into idealization of a person it leads us to expect them to be more than they are. His whole final essay I think can be seen as the culmination of what Miles has learned: about how we deal with unfair things, unfair people and the way our lives change from them. Also you are supposed to know that Alaska is going to die and I think Iran interesting you viewed that negatively. John Green wrote in his anniversary edition of the book that Looking for Alaska is formatted in before and after because this is a book about grief and he was thinking a lot about 9/11 and how nothing was the same after. I keep finding that a lot of booktubers don’t like Green because of his lack of plot, and I find it really interesting because it seems to me that just because his books don’t have plot doesn’t mean there isn’t anything to take away from it. Just some thoughts :)
Jenna Woodcock I discovered John Green while I was taking a Lit course in high school, and I think that massively contributed to how much I love his books. They need to be approached more like literature than run-of-the-mill YA fiction. They're less about what happens, and more about what the characters experience. They're kind of like ruminations on certain facets of life.
Lol looking for Alaska is one of my favourites and I think you completely misinterpreted the actual messages of the book about not idealising people and Alaska’s fractured life and personality
I love these videos so much! Also with Queen of the Tearling, I feel like the reason the world building isn’t really expanded upon in the first book is because of how important it is to the plot device and to the overall storyline. Because if you know everything up front then it’s a completely different story, you learn as the characters learn basically. But that’s just my take on it, and I totally understand why it can be hard to get through. Personally i love the pace
call me by your name is one of those books i never read, despite such good reviews, because i knew i would hate it so much lol. finally feel validated in my opinion. and i find it weird that no one mentions how creepy the age difference is tbh. as an (almost) 24 yo, i know how creepy it is when 20 yo are dating kids in high school
ik u commenter this 4 years ago so there's a chance you wont even see my reply but as someone who loved the book id advise you to try to read it, its truly wonderful but undertand if you wont, much love
It's odd how differently one can read a book. Because i read looking for alaska in the 8th grade and I still remember how miles strugged with his understanding of a person he thought he knew after a tragedy.
Thank you so much for making that point about 13 reasons why! It was also my main concern reading it because the way they execute the message of suicide and bullying is not good in my opinion. I didn't even bother watching the show no matter how much my friends love it. Glad I'm not the only one who didn't like it..
THANK YOU for not liking The Cruel Prince. I am so weirded out by all the positive ratings. I LOATHED it. It is one of the most toxic, horrible books I have read. Stockholme Syndrome glorified. Every character except for the sister were horrible, toxic, murderous people. Why would you want to stay in such a place?
L.A Zheng And the time I posted this comment I was reading it. I took basically a eight year hiatus from reading. The wicked King is better not great but better. Hopefully the queen of nothing is better
You're so right about 13 reasons.... Everyone I know, including myself, who has actual experience with serious depression hates the representation that depression gets in that book/TV show. The revenge story is terrible, and it doesn't properly represent depression. People who attempt suicide almost never do that to get back at someone or make them feel bad, it is ususally the opposite, that they feel removing themselves would be an improvement to other's lives.
I kind of agree about The Cruel Prince. I was expecting so much of that book, but nothing of that happened. It left me unmoved, I couldn't connect to any of the characters and in general it felt shallow and childish. I was guessing that maybe I'm not the target audience and it's more relevant for teenagers.
Nope, I didn’t love it either. I gave it three stars because it did an excellent job with the issues it presented, but I abhorred Monty’s personality and didn’t feel connected to the characters at all. I wanted to love Percy so much, but usually I felt really distant to it all.
Her: **pulls out call me by your name** Me: aw, i was planning on reading that, it looks good (I wanted to read it cause i love LGBT books- since I'm gay- but i didn't know much about it) Her: It's about a *seventeen year old boy* who falls in love with a *twenty four year old man* and it's also super sexual Me: well i guess i can put that on my "do not read" list
SillySatyr Productions I think you should give it a try. This book is much more than just those sexual things. It is about discovering who he really is, its about his family, art, books and much more stuff that make this book so lovely. I also find the way it is written very beautiful. And when you think about it their age difference is not that big. Just give it a try. I fell in love with this book.
I feel you with the Cruel Prince. That book was wayyyy too overhyped. There was no real human connection. I didn't feel anything for the characters. Nothing
My best friend committed suicide last year. Thirteen reasons why made me so angry, it made suicide seem so casual and can be caused just because someone is having a bad day. Since I have been through a situation like this, I was seriously offended. On the list of my least favorite books
I love the folk of air series however I have to agree about that the cruel prince isn’t the best book in the series the other books are much better especially the wicked king but I would still give it 4 stars because it sets up the story for the rest of the series
Agree.For me Cruel prince is just an overture for this series, it is like the pilot episode. I hardly even remembered the way Cardan acted in school once I started reading The wicked king.And even thoough I understand why she felt this way about the book, I fell quite the opposite. I adored Jude as a character. She is tough, brave, doesnt give up and is really smart.She fights for the things she wants and doesnt wait around to be saved. Also, its nice to have manipulative mc for once!! Cardan/Jude romance is not at its peak in the first book, but it didnt feel forced for me, especially by the end of the book. Also I usually never care about the politics in books, but I was hooked about this one
that peach scene scarred me too. i haven’t read the book or watched the movie but i came across a post on twitter about it and wish i would have kept scrolling lmaoo
I HATED The Cruel Prince!!! Everyone raves about it but I struggled SO much to get through it. Such a disappointment. Jude's attitude drove me nuts. Her character was so back and forth and nothing in the plot seemed to fit together. I really wanted to love it, but I can't.
I’m currently reading An Enchantment of Ravens right now aaaaaanddd I’m not sure how I feel about it - it’s sooo freaking slow! 🐢 UPDATE: I just finish it... aaaaaanddd it was garbage lmao.
13 Reasons Why is one of my favorite books; it resonated with me a lot. I didn't read her suicide as a revenge plot (at least not in the book -- I think the show definitely leans in the direction of revenge) -- the tapes seemed more about Hannah attempting to be understood by others on her own terms as opposed to the narrative about her that continued to spin out of control no matter what she did and, yes, making sure they knew what role their actions played in how difficult her life became and how she began to see herself. I definitely see your point though about how the novel is trying to accomplish a couple of different things at once and maybe should've taken time to develop both more fully.
I didn't appreciate Looking for Alaska until I re-read it after my father died very suddenly. I appreciated how John Green wrote about how lost and confused a person who goes through grief and loss could feel. Yes, Alaska does feel MPDG-like, but I guess that's one of the follies of youth? I think some teenagers or young adults idealize their crushes (and Miles was such a jerk for cheating on his girlfriend) and I hope the young people who read the book realize the pitfalls of not seeing someone for who they truly are. I also appreciate Call Me By Your Name because a story just like it happened to one of my dearest friends (a friend from childhood who is still my friend today). My friend is like Elio and his long-time boyfriend is like Oliver. I guess I read the book with understanding of Elio's heartbreak. I also saw the movie first before I read the book and I'm glad that the cinematography gave justice to Andre Aciman's writing. It actually is refreshing to hear another person's opinion. I love your voice and your content. Thanks for your hard work!
What you shared about 13 Reasons Why was very eloquent and expresses my own concerns. It makes it seem like suicide is a way up get revenge and it makes it sound like these people are responsible. And a few times Hannah put herself into bad situations and made some poor choices that lead to some of the situations. Young teens read it and they lack perspective and the ability to look at an entire situation. So it may send a wrong and dangerous message.
I totally agree with you a out the cruel prince. I loved the older sister wanting to go back to the human world (also points for it being the modern human world) and the subplot with the "cruel prince" actually being abused by his family and how he copes with it. But the main plot where Jude got hired as a spy even though at no point was that skill set or that she was capable of doing that implied happened I was confused and really only finished it to see if it made more sense later. Low key I like the prince more than Jude
I personally enjoyed Call Me By Your Name. But also kinda hated it. It wasn’t really the age gap, but the lack of detail in the reasoning for the infatuation between Elio and Oliver and overwhelming detail in the sexual romance between the two. I wish that there was more personal connection between them. But I fell in love with the writing style of the book. I honestly think that the movie was more put together than the book.
it's been nearly 4 years since this was uploaded, and although I still haven't read it, 'The Cruel Prince' shocked me cause it's still so popular and loved
I really didn't like call me by your name as a book either, the writing style wasn't for me, and i didn't care about the characters at all. I actually enjoyed the movie a lot though, probably the only time I've ever considered a movie better than the book lol.
I really didn't like the wringing style tbh, otherwise I'd probably actually enjoy the story itself. Haven't seen the movie yet but after reading a bunch of comments, I think I might get to it soon lol
Sarah Rivington Me too! Though I really liked the way the book delved deeper into Elio’s mindset, something about the way it was written made me uncomfortable. The movie though is hands down one of my favourite. It’s so well made.
Hello! Big fan of your channel! I know Cruel Prince was only a 2.5/maybe 3 for you, but I was wondering if you might do a video of book recs for people who like the cruel prince sometime? (Goodreads lumps in Cruel Prince with Sarah J Maas, Shatter Me, etc, books that I don't see as going together and would love to hear your opinions instead. Also as a sidenote if you ever do provide recs, I don't know that I or others would put this in the unlikeable narrators category) Thanks for being awesome, love all your book takes!
The last time I read something other than Fanfiction I was twelve/thirteen... whenever The Heroes Of Olympus series ended was the last time I read a real book...
Ahh, i felt the EXACT same way about 13RW but so many people praised it as this "wonderful insight" into someone who was suicidal that I just kept my mouth shut lol
I think if you go into a book believing you're going to dislike it, you will constantly be looking for reasons to sustain that belief and to not like it because you've already made up your mind from the start...
Call me by your name has many life philosophies in it and it is really raw, the author doesn't try to mask anything. I guess you missed it. It is one of my favourite books. Also i love your videos.
No, it was just an extremely problematic book with awful cliches and misconceptions about gay men. Just bc she didn't like doesn't mean she "missed something"
I liked the cruel prince, but I feel like a major issue I had with it was how little the characters were fleshed out. (Spoilers ahead) I read it in like 4 days so I might be off about some things, but overall it just seemed like Holly gave basic amounts of characterization to everyone. With Cardan, for example, it seemed like she tried to make us pity him for having a bad home life (which she didn't give enough detail to), and then tried to make him likable because now he's captured and admits he likes Jude. He treated Jude really, really bad, but it seems like that's all forgiven because Jude and him are forced to work together. That whole Locke and Taryn thing made...no sense, honestly. Taryn and Jude are supposed to be super close, so why would Taryn agree to Locke's plan, especially given they had no prior relationship before? I know she just wants to fit in with the Faerie but all of that could have been executed better. Those are just two examples but there are plenty of things I either didn't understand or thought was too rushed or just didn't work well. I'll definitely read the next book, but I worry that the series might be tropey. I hope Holly doesn't gloss over a lot of the stuff that she did in TCP and make it like "Cardan was really awful to Jude but she gets with him anyway". If Jude and Cardan are going to be a thing I hope that Cardan's behavior is actually addressed and that he truly tries to make amends with everyone, and not just because he wants Jude to like him, because I honestly love redeemed characters and enemies-to-lovers when they're done right. Maybe the first book was just meant to be an opener and the other two will be much better, but we'll see!
you should do the opposite video to this concept!! like “unpopular books that you love”!
Cassie Williams I really want to! I’m planning it soon ☺️
A Clockwork Reader yay!! looking forward to it!!
A Clockwork Reader, Woohoo!! I can’t wait.
Maze runner
A Clockwork Reader did you to this ????
this video is fun until she pulls out one of your fav books 😂😂
farah accurate 😂😂😂
So true 😂😂mine was the cruel prince
I felt personally attacked when she brought up the Tearling series lmao
I was offended when she said 'call me by your name'😅😅😅
alexandra xx dont watch the video if you get offended by a respectable reader’s unpopular opinions
This is why I love books: everyone has their taste. No one *has* to like or dislike a book. This is also why I hate it when book lovers shame each other for liking certain books/genres.
Kristen Nowlin I understand what you’re saying and I agree with you somewhat, but when a story doesn’t make sense or is just riding on the coat tails of another book, it can be really frustrating when people call it brilliant or say that it’s the best book ever
Kristen Nowlin Yes, I personally don't like Harry Potter and I actually lost a friend because of it. Stupid.
@@graceglitters7371 I... I'm not the only one?!? I always thought everyone just loved it, apart from me. I mean, it's not bad, but not that great either
It's just sad that people judge others based on what they like. I just want to be friends with people, not murder or fight them. 😒😥
Certain books shouldn't be liked by anyone. Books that make toxic behaviour, racism etc quirky or cool and ok. Or Pedophilia (I'm looking at you...LOLITA.). For normal books I agree with you. But for literally dangerous books.. nahhh.
I read Thirteen Reasons Why when it first came out. I was in like 9th grade and I HATED it. Honestly it made suicide look like a petty, arbitrary choice a teenage girl might make just cuz she's in a bad mood that day. And then there's the whole "love could have saved her" thing.
Like, I just thought it was kind of "meh" until I started working with a suicide hotline at which point I revisited it and decided I downright hated it.
Agreed. I didn't even really enjoy the storyline from and "entertainment" standpoint. I read it years ago when my best friend recommended it to me. She said it was "so good" and it was her favorite book by far. When I read it I was very underwhelmed. And I still haven't watched the series either.
see, i never saw it that way. i always looked at like, be careful of your actions, because you never know what someone is going through or how what you say might affect them. so like if someone is already REALLY depressed, one little insult might be that push that sends them over the edge, if they're that close to it already. i think 13 reasons showed how little trivial things can build and build, how they can add up until they become too much. i haven't watched the series yet, and i kind of don't want to, cuz i'm worried i won't care for the show. i can see why a lot of people think her reasons for committing suicide in the book were petty/trivial, but i think a lot of people also need to realize that the little things add up.
MewVenus it shows how your actions affect people and yes love can save people. Just be nice to people and think before you speak. But the blaming of other people from her tapes is so so wrong! Ppl who are depressed want to never make people want to feel bad because they know how it feels. Like maybe from experience but no person feeling like that will want ppl to feel the same way.
I read it before a year or so before the show came out and I think I only enjoyed it for the storytelling and the fast pace of it, but honestly looking back at it, it’s not the “healthiest” book to recommend to people.
I absolutely despise 13 Reasons Why and its popularity makes me genuinely sad and worried especially considering how young a lot of the audience is.
"Smoke a lot of cigarettes, drink a lot of alcohol, and nothing really happens." Haha that describes the high school experience of a lot of American kids.
😂😂
The fuck are you from
We stumbled onto a murder scene, complete with the (later) convicted murderer on the phone with the cops.
Wild times.
James Cotter I read it before that happened 😅 so maybe that’s why I liked it.
Maybe that's why I didn't enjoy it. Either that or the edgyness on it.
23 minutes of Hannah and her opinions? Sign me UP
I took a shot (of water) whenever I guessed which book you were gonna show.....let’s just say I’m hydrated AF
Alison Fabi HAHAHA
I’d take milk shots and here’s the funny story behind it: whenever I’m sad I drink a full glass of milk. Idk why I think I just love milk. So that way, when I get older I don’t get an alcohol problem, only a milk problem
Over hydration is a big problem too
Steph K uh milk isn’t healthy and is cruel so nothing to brag about lol
Maria C milk is cruel? What has milk ever done to you?
Me the whole time:
Please don't say the book thief
Please don't say the book thief
Please don't say the book thief
OH MY GOD I LOVE THAT BOOK SO MUCH
My faaaave.
The book thief is one of the most amazing books I have ever read it almost made me cry twice but I held it back because I was in school I finished it in like 5 days and then I saw the movie and was so mad there were so many things and characters that were left out u don't care if it was a 8 hour movie and they included everything I loved that book my family is now doing it as a read aloud and I love it even more now it is one of the most amazing books I have ever read I mean it is up there with To Kill a Mockingbird and I love that book so so much so if she disses on the book thief I will be so mad😡
This book changed my life
@@sophieg7021 Saaaame.
I found Jude really likable, despite being morally grey, her manipulating them causes the book to be very character-driven and she was able to the manipulate them because she made herself valuable and managed to get herself invulnerable to their charms
yes! I didn't see Jude as unlikeable at all - I saw some points when she tried to be cunning in the way that faeries are, but never saw her as a bad person
Jude was supposed to be an unlikeable character?!! I liked her.
She was awesome
Jude is a damn queen.
I LOVED her
she’s real badass so
I was shocked hearing this :)) didn´t seem like an unlikeable character at all
Hannah ranting about books is my favorite thing, I’M SO READY FOR THIS ❤️
Do you ever feel weird reading a book with a main character with the same name? Usually Emily characters die; so, that just might be me.
13 reasons why is the only book ive ever read with a main character that has the same name as me, so yeah, it was pretty weird lolll
Almost every book character with my name have either been a total b***h or super boring and it sucks 😂😂
Rose Van Hemmen I can relate in that as well. I was named after Emily Bronte, the most boring and uptight Bronte sister and I think that shapes the characters. However, you have one of the best Golden Girls at least.
Emily Rose Dreams That's true! Idk if you've seen Gilmore Girls but Emily Gilmore is one of my favourite characters, she's awesome :) I guess there are lots of good and bad characters for each name.
can’t relate hahahah
when you're afraid she's gonna say the pjo series but then you spot them all on the background
the typewriter huge mood omg
Yessssss
the typewriter True
me
me: * immediately scans the shelf *
!SPOILERS!
For me Looking for Alaska is more of a cause and effect book than anything. You’re supposed to know that Alaska is going to die, it gives you a certain perspective on the first half of the book. As for Miles, it was pretty clear to me from the beginning that he was more in love with the idea of Alaska than anything. It’s a sort of cautionary tale, he idealized her so much that he just ignored the issues that eventually led to her death. I see it as a sort of warning about idealizing both people and life. However, this is just my interpretation of the book :)
starry _ eyed _ scorpio I totally agree
omg i’m literally reading this book and i scrolled through the comments and you spoiled it for me :((
Regina Phalange why would you read the comments if you’ve not read the books yet
Just put a spoiler warning please?
thanks for the spoiler warning
I don’t get why suicide is presented in this way, like it’s someone else’s fault. I’ve had moments where I seriously considered suicide, and even though in the moment, I’m like, life is just too much, it’s the depression’s fault, not yours for feeling that way, a normal person in the same situation doesn’t react the same, that’s why it’s a mental illness. I hurt for people who think they did something wrong after their friend commits suicide. Like no honey, you couldn’t have known. When I was in my bad places I isolated myself, I didn’t want to tell people how bad I felt, that’s why suicide is often so surprising, we put on a smiling face for our friends and family.
SheWhoWalksSilently thank you for this actually. I have friends who are really having a bad time with depression and I’m trying to help them. Whenever they start talking about suicide I really feel that I’m not doing them and I blame myself. Although one is doing much better.
So thank you😊
Well for me my parents mentally and physically abused me which caused my depression so..
It's kind of their fault lol
@@Lia-tn5nr Ya, that’s rude. Hope you have new people in your life that treat you right 😅
I get what you mean but every suicide victim did not commit suicide due to depression. I was never depressed but I have had suicidal thoughts due to bullying. Being a friend is also not the same as a bully. Bullying is what have caused almost all of my mental illness today. I think there is a huge correlation between bullying and mental illness and also suicide that needs to be talked about. Bullying is like hurting a person on the inside which affects the person negative.
Depression is more Spiritual than Mental. But to those who aren't spiritual, your prozac won't save you.
The way Alaska is described in that description is very delibrate on john green's part. That is the point of the book. Miles sees alaska as this otherworldly "thing", not a person. I feel like that is the point of most of Green's books. People think he is only writing about manic pixie dream girls; but they are not manic pixie dream girls. Thats the way the male protagonist sees her as, and he always turns out to be wrong. That was the message in both paper towns and Looking for Alaska. I'm not that articulate with this, but I saw a post on tumblr describing how his books are misconstrued, basically saying that his books are about whiny teenage boys realizing that they have been over idealizing women in their lives, seeing women as stories rather than complex, autonomous beings, and how wrong that is. But ofcourse, you can dislike the book still😅 Just pointing out my personal feeling about the issue you highlighted😅😄
Manmehak Kaur exactly this. how do people not see this wtf
Yeah if you watch his videos on RUclips you see this is a journey that he had to go through himself and therefore he writes about teenage boys who have to learn everything he had to learn. Is it something I see all the time and lots of books, don't be a character who isn't isn't an explicit antagonist that is intentionally unlikable and people will go oh I didn't like this book because I didn't like insert character, this is commonly done with the Great Gatsby, hint you aren't supposed to like Daisy Buchanan, and Gatsby's a romantic feelings for her are not supposed to be healthy.
i totally agree. personally its my favourite john green book
Manmehak Kaur I totally agree with this! One of the main points of the story (at least that I felt) was that Miles was more in love with this idea of Alaska than who she actually was. That to me at least was pretty clear throughout the book
Looking for Alaska is forever in my top 10 favs. Because of that. 💜
I am so trash for these videos
Same girl, same
Same. I thrive off negativity. Lol
I like them because they prove that the reviewers are honest and aren't afraid to give their honest opinion. They're also super cathartic when you also hate the books
Same! I enjoy these videos so much!!
Me too. They also make me feel less crappy for disliking popular books.
you’re actually one of not many people who doesn’t like 13RW and thank you for speaking about it, a lot of people don’t see this
As someone who suffers depression and had suicide attempts, 13rw physically made me sick to read. I forced myself to watch the show after.. And it was even worse. 😣
Yea i personally didn’t really like it either
me: she’s gonna say call me by your name. it’s something she wouldn’t usually read.
*mentions call me by your name*
disappointed but not surprised.
I mean Call me by your name sucks
I’m so torn on that book. I love the writing of the book, but some parts of the book could have been left on the cutting board IMO and it would have made the beautiful writing that much better.
Tbh I just read the book and it also disappointed me
India Anna I kinda feel that fr
i'm reluctant to read the book bc of the minor x adult relationship,,, also the author is a white cishet male.
Thank you Hannah!!! I detest 13 Reasons Why. There are so many other ways they could have dealt with the tough topics. Counselors are there to help you. It's ridiculous that there were no other lifelines.
1. Enchantment of Ravens
2. The Cruel Prince
3. 13 Reasons Why
4. Looking for Alaska
5. Call me by your name
6. The Queen of the Tearling
Rachel Z thank you ❤️❤️❤️
Rachel Z Call me by your name was a great film though✌🏽❤️
I’ve only read Looking For Alaska and I gave it 3/5
why do you list the books but don't say if you loved/hated them?
@@bookwormlife1278 I think you missed the title of the entire video
I definitely agree with you about Thirteen Reasons Why. I read it a few years ago and I really didn't like it.
Florentine Violet I listened to the audio book years ago and COULDN’T STAND IT. I was shocked that it became so popular and that Netflix made a series about it. The same thing happened with Twilight. I listened to the audio book while I was on a long drive with my Dad. At the end we just looked at each other like “WTF???”.
me too...my cousin liked it a lot and i couldn't really understand why....Hannah Baker just didn't really have an impact on me and i really didn't care about her......this book could have been much better but the message was conveyed really poorly
Yup, I also agree. I listened to the audio book because I saw the series and wanted to see if the book was better than the series (because I didn't like the series too much haha).
And, yea, the book is better. I like the way it portrays Hannah more, but in the end it was still very meh.
Well, with Looking for Alaska the point isn't the plot. It's a character study and you see how Pudge is a bad person and you have to look past his narration and see her beyond that at her as a character. She is actually very complex and that's what the end is all about. He realizes how badly he imagined her and how selfish he was as a person to her. It's about the breakdown of toxic masculinity.
mustardsfire22
Thanks. I am currently reading Looking for alaska and I have not see it that way. I thought it was boring, still think it is, but you definitely show me a new way of looking at it.
Whaaattt?!? No omg I just finished reading it and I loved that book!?!
I think you could „trash talk“ my favourite book and I wouldn’t care, because you do it so politely and gently!
What I understood as Jude's motive was that she was primarily bitter about being human. She kinda envied her older sister at the beginning for being a fairie, throughout the book she was constantly taunted for being weak and unable to defend herself against fairies, I assume this also stems from the fact that her father kidnapped her and killed her mother. While her twin sister accepts inferiority and behaves, Jude didn't want to be submissive she wanted power. I think the sisters themselves show how different a traumatic event can affect a person. For Jude it invoked something violent and vengeful but for Taryn (?) It was a message to stay down and obey people in power.
Also the 2nd and 3rd book go in much deeper into Jude and Carden 😭 they're so good 👌
It's really subtle but I always really love your eye makeup
Thank you
Emma D Same here!
The peach scene has scarred us all - my friend split peach tea on herself and I got serious flashbacks
Nokutenda Zhou what happened with the peach??? Don't really plan to read that book, but now I'm so curious. Please tell me!!
How to put this delicately ? He (can't remember which character) ejaculates into the peach and the other guy eats the peach.
D:< omg
Omg
true. i can't forget that scene...
Call me by your name is like my favorite thing ever both book and movie so when you mentioned it I took a deep breath and basically turned into that Arthur meme with his fist but I respect your opinion and I’m okay 😂
I respect yours too! I'm glad you loved them both!
Lmaooo not the Arthur meme
I also understand hannah's opinion... this book hit me in a way i wasn't expecting to and I might never watch the movie but i did enjoy the book, it's one of my favorites books but i don't think i'm going read it again, i just can't :P
I usually agree with a lot of Hannah's opinions on bad books, but I'm still so intrigued by this one. And so curious now about the peach scene...
Gabby Wray same lol
I love the cruel prince and I'm waiting to read the queen of nothing
Broooooooo, noooooo. Not the cruel prince, not the cruel prince 😭😔💔
Just to add, where are all the cruel prince fans and comments? I'm out here by myself.. its lonely
🙌🙌 I love the cruel prince. I finished all 3 books the day I bought them lol
Meee!! Waiting for the how the king of elfhame learned to hate stories💖💖
I didnt really love the cruel prince it was good I liked it, but the wicked king is just 😍😍😍 I loved it
The cruel prince is alright, i read it and it wasn't the worst.
the cruel prince is good, but it's hard to keep up with what's going on there's so many details you have to remember
Life gets hard when you’re an ace YA loving reader who just wants good YA books without a lot of romance in it. I don’t like a lot of popular books because why is there no adventures where people don’t suddenly fall in love?
Lotta Niemi have you read this savage song
Ciara White I haven’t actually because I haven’t gotten my hands on it yet but I heard good things!
If you like adventure books I would suggest the Nightrunner series by Lynn flewelling. It’s a fantasy adventure series. The main characters don’t fall in love until the second book. It’s one of my favorites!
01yhesi Thanks for the suggestion! I’ll look into it.
the gentleman's guide to vice and virtue. a lot of adventures and low pace romance..
I was curious about the peach scene so I looked it up and now I want to launch myself into the sun
Daniella Roque
eXPLAIN
I don't wanna be responsible for scarring you for life but here www.vulture.com/2017/11/armie-hammer-peach-scene-in-call-me-by-your-name.html
@@daniellaroque8672Wow. I'm scarred for life. Don't know why I had to read that. ._.
What the actual fuck. This is some fan fiction shit.
@@_x_sxs_x_7181 @DragonGirl_14 I warned y'all
An Enchantment of Ravens sounds suspiciously similar to the A Court of Thorns and Roses series..
I searched for this comment!
EXACTLY! Apart from that fact the the MC paints as a living and there's insta-love, it sounds EXACTLY like acotar. The live interest is even called the Autumn Prince.....
LMAO I love that you talk about Enchantment of Ravens and say "It's extremely short, it's about 300 pages" I'm just dying, I totally relate but omg if someone who doesn't love books heard that
I believe she said that due to the fact that it's a fantasy book. In this genre the writter has to introduce this whole new world and explain everything from scrap so I would also say 300 pages is really short for a book of this type.
Regarding Jude. Her motives are clear in that she doesn’t want to adapt to this world by being a scared mortal like Taryn. She wants to be recognized as strong and par with faerie.
She was able to lie - that was what was special about her.
It’s sad that it didn’t click for you. :/ I don’t understand how that all went over your head.
It really sucks when you’re hyped for a book and it totally disappoints
Giannah Golden yes Jm Ariel last one utter rubbish compared to the others didn’t finish it.
OVERHYPED BOOKS THE TITLE FOR MY NEW VIDEO
you should try to read Will Grayson, Will Grayson! it's co-written by David Levithan and i really enjoyed the characters
obiyaa i’m glad someone like it too! it’s my favourite john green book! :)
obiyaa I DNFed that book. I just couldn’t get into. But I do LOVE some of John Greens other books.
obiyaa i HATED that book. it may be contributed to the fact i read it when i was pretty young, but i remember being extremely bored
obiyaa
I LOVED THE SECOND WILL GRAYSON BUT THE STEREOTYPES WITH THE GUY HE ENDED UP WITH UGHHHH
I really enjoyed that book!
I just started The Cruel Prince and it has me hook line and sinker. Hopefully it lives up to the hype; by how it started, I’m pretty sure it’s gonna be a great book.
lol the peach scene in call me by your name was iconic
An enchantment of ravens sounds almost exactly like a court of thorns and roses hmmmm let's see
-painter feyre
-human in a fae world feyre
-falls in love with some powerful fae lets see..........................feyre
YES I IMMEDIATELY THOUGHT OF FEYRE WHEN SHE TALKED ABOUT THAT BOOK
The book reminded me of the lost girl the show
And how the fae love interest is ruler of a SEASON WORLD!!! Such a rip-off.
Thought so too. I even looked up the release dates and thorns and roses were release 2 years before an enchantment. So I'm thinking...did she plagiarized Sarah's work?
Don't forget the fact that there's courts of Fae.
Talking about Call me by your name and the lack of development, I feel really connected to it because that's how all my summers were as a Spanish person. It's a really cultural thing that I feel it serves a nostalgia purpose. But you definitely got a point, I just loved it because it took me back to my own memories. Love your honest opinions and analysis!
Sorry, I'm not sure if it was understandable 😑 hahaha the lack of development is the feeling I get from my slow summers, the cities slow down so much, it always feels like nothing happens whilst you grow and change and think a lot, and spend a lot of the time in the house hiding from the sun and with friends during the nights....so that lack of development delivers that kind of emotion
No, I would completely agree with your statement. Call Me By Your Name was one of my favorite books partly because of the intense and very real feelings of first love and infatuation but also, partly because as someone who is French, it really highlights European culture and thinking. While we may not go on crazy, lavish planned dates like many Americans do, we have a way of doing nothing and meaning everything to the person we care about.
I definitely agree with u...
I personally love call me by your name, both the book and the movie but I definitely understand why it could be a bit too much for some people 😂 the peach scene is really something else
Oh, well. I didn`t read Looking for Alaska, but after your description, it is literally the same as paper towns. In both books there is the protagonist, who falls in love with a girl and sees her in a way everybody sees her, but not who she really is, the protagonist grows as a person and in the end, he is okay with leaving the girl behind, because now he is a better, more mature and sort of an understanding adult.
True!
Lily Unruh i’m not sure after reading both paper towns and looking for alaska
looking for alaska is definitely better paper towns was the most boring thing ever
actually no it's about idealizing people but what happens in the book like the whole plot and everything is totally different
After rereading both novels, I can confirm that the plot lines are quite similar.
exactly and now I hate that every john green's protagonist has to meet some person in order to grow up, i was fascinated by this trope when I was a teenager and I always thought being single is pathetic, i hated my life for this
So true about the cruel prince, DNF’d because when I say I was BORED
I really didn't care for ACOTAR. *RUNS AND HIDES FROM THE MOBS*
I have no intention of ever reading it so I don't blame you :D
I bought it before the major hype hit because "beauty and the beast retelling" and "really nice cover". I didn't read it until after the hype and I'm glad because I feel like I've grown as a reader and if I had read it when I first bought it I feel like I may have liked it because that was a period when I sort of just liked everything for some reason.
the first one is crap but it definitely gets better but you do have to struggle through the abusive first book
I’ve read it and although I enjoyed it, I was still disappointing due to the overhype with it!
Agreed, I don't really like any of the series ( acomaf was honestly no better imo) but I love throne of glass and am worried it's becoming too much like the acotar series :/
I find it very funny that you hate Looking For Alaska and love Turtles all the way down, and I’m the opposite. LFA is one of my favourite books, and in my opinion TATWD has no plot to me. I just find that funny, but I’m glad to hear your opinion on it.
FrenchyIsAwesome I love both books, but I agree that TATWD lacks a plot. LFA definitely has more of a plot.
I disagree,TATWD had a lot of plot.
Same! Loved LFA, didn't really like TATWD. I felt it was a bit tonally confused, like it wanted to have a Paper Towns mystery but to also be TFIOS at the same time.
same
Same, I love looking for Alaska and I hated turtles all the way down
LETS WATCH CALL ME BY YOUR NAME NOW HANNAH 😂😂
WHY DO YOU WANT TO TORTURE ME
I love u Brandon
the movie is incredibly beautiful id recommend it even if the peach scene made you squeamish. its done very well in the movie
It's actually really beautiful 😂
Alex why? The movie is actually so much better than the book and is nowhere near as sexual as the book was. Yes the peach scene is still in there, but it’s done in a way where it doesn’t seem as gross. Also Timothée Chalamet and Armie Hammer had insane chemistry and both were fantastic in their roles.
I vividly remember forgetting everything that happened in Looking for Alaska the moment I finished it. Like, honestly, I was forgetting it as I was reading it.
I litterly just finished looking for Alaska and I’m so in love with it. I cried the whole freakin’ book. Does that make me an emotional person??
When I first read Queen of the Tearling I actually put it down after 50 pages but then decided to pick it up again about a year later and now its one of my favourite series, I can see why some people don't like it though, it took me ages to get into it!
The ending of Call Me By Your Name is the definition of nostalgia and it's so so good, and even if the rest of the book is a little slow (and gross) it was worth it
girl yassssss!!! you had me shook over looking for alaska though, it was my favorite book when i was in middle school so now i'm curious if i'll still love it now... you've inspired me to re-read it
oh as a gay guy i can confirm that call me by your name is trash. the age gap in the relationship is thing that seals its fate above all else for me, it makes me horribly uncomfortable and it plays into a lot of harmful and unfounded stereotypes that surround gay men.
"it's just seven years why does it matter". dude, if you're 17 you're like, still in high school, whereas most 24 year olds are already out of college, if they went to college. if you're 17 you probably still live with your parents, if you're 24 you might even have a family of your own. if you're 17 you are still legally a CHILD and if you're 24 you're legally an adult.
there's more i could say about that book, but i'd be wasting my breath. basically just trust my (gay) opinion when i say it sucks okay it belongs in the garbage.
goth boyfriend EXACTLY. It really isnt a good representation of lgbt people and enforces a lot of harmful stereotypes about gay men.
the film take place in italy, and the age consent in there is 14. So basically elio is an adult. And if u watch the movie or read the book, elio is actually the one who is more dominant than oliver.
call me by your name (the movie) is a poetic masterpiece, you can't change my mind.
@@tgandreaa just because the age of consent is 14 doesn't mean he's an adult. Those are different things.
"its only 7 years apart" lmao try saying the same thing when one guy is 17 and the other 10. It gets a whole lot creepier yikeeeees
I didn’t really like the cruel prince but pushed through and the wicked king is honestly one of the best books I’ve ever read 🤷🏻♀️
I'm really struggling to push through the first book and came to RUclips to look for inspiration so that I can finish it 😭
@@kawsarjune4894I really enjoyed it myself, especially Jude having her own agency thoughout the book despite being lost and confused at times, the family relationships were also really complex and nuanced thoughout the series. And then it gets even better from the end of Cruel Prince and into the next books, but I don't want to spoil why. If the faerie politics is boring to you, I can see why it's hard to push through.
I think the key to love call me by your name is to watch the movie first. Cause movie is better (in my opinion at least) and it makes you love the characters and understand emotions. Book is Elio's sick mind. I loved it and hated it but after finising it I watched movie again and omg, luca guadagnino is a f genius for all that scenes that was SO important and wasn't even in the book.
agat787 AGREED. A straight man writing about a mlm relationship is uncomfortable, tho I did read and like the book having a gay man like luca really bringing the book to life in the film adaptation is what really makes call me by your name touch your heart and pull at the heartstrings.
I read the book then watched the movie and well I loved both! The book and movie are beautiful in their own ways
when you talked about The Cruel Prince
me: *clenches fist*
(;^;)
When she said she didn’t understand what was so special about Jude that she could climb the social ladder and do stuff other humans couldn’t I was legit like did u even read the book? Madoc is literally the general and she had special circumstances compared to the other humans that usually get taken to faerie. That rlly annoyed me ngl.
I felt attacked tbh
I disagree with your assessment of Looking for Alaska in terms of Miles not learning anything. He does fall in love with Alaska because she’s hot, and the book shows how we fall into idealization of a person it leads us to expect them to be more than they are. His whole final essay I think can be seen as the culmination of what Miles has learned: about how we deal with unfair things, unfair people and the way our lives change from them. Also you are supposed to know that Alaska is going to die and I think Iran interesting you viewed that negatively. John Green wrote in his anniversary edition of the book that Looking for Alaska is formatted in before and after because this is a book about grief and he was thinking a lot about 9/11 and how nothing was the same after. I keep finding that a lot of booktubers don’t like Green because of his lack of plot, and I find it really interesting because it seems to me that just because his books don’t have plot doesn’t mean there isn’t anything to take away from it. Just some thoughts :)
Jenna Woodcock I discovered John Green while I was taking a Lit course in high school, and I think that massively contributed to how much I love his books. They need to be approached more like literature than run-of-the-mill YA fiction. They're less about what happens, and more about what the characters experience. They're kind of like ruminations on certain facets of life.
Lol looking for Alaska is one of my favourites and I think you completely misinterpreted the actual messages of the book about not idealising people and Alaska’s fractured life and personality
YES. I actually loved Looking for Alaska and disliked Turtles All The Way Down (TFIOS was also a big meh for me).
You're right!
Exactly.
Not everyone has the same taste. It's her choice if she liked it or didn't.
I love these videos so much!
Also with Queen of the Tearling, I feel like the reason the world building isn’t really expanded upon in the first book is because of how important it is to the plot device and to the overall storyline. Because if you know everything up front then it’s a completely different story, you learn as the characters learn basically. But that’s just my take on it, and I totally understand why it can be hard to get through. Personally i love the pace
call me by your name is one of those books i never read, despite such good reviews, because i knew i would hate it so much lol. finally feel validated in my opinion. and i find it weird that no one mentions how creepy the age difference is tbh. as an (almost) 24 yo, i know how creepy it is when 20 yo are dating kids in high school
when i read the book i didnt know the age difference and imagened he was only 2 or 3 years older, by the book alone you cant really tell
ik u commenter this 4 years ago so there's a chance you wont even see my reply but as someone who loved the book id advise you to try to read it, its truly wonderful but undertand if you wont, much love
It's odd how differently one can read a book. Because i read looking for alaska in the 8th grade and I still remember how miles strugged with his understanding of a person he thought he knew after a tragedy.
Thank you so much for making that point about 13 reasons why! It was also my main concern reading it because the way they execute the message of suicide and bullying is not good in my opinion. I didn't even bother watching the show no matter how much my friends love it. Glad I'm not the only one who didn't like it..
Heshuah my mom works with a suicide hotline and she told me she hated it
THANK YOU for not liking The Cruel Prince. I am so weirded out by all the positive ratings. I LOATHED it. It is one of the most toxic, horrible books I have read. Stockholme Syndrome glorified. Every character except for the sister were horrible, toxic, murderous people. Why would you want to stay in such a place?
Ohmigod it's so relieving to hear someone DIDN'T like The Cruel Prince, bless up.
Lauren Crowley I didn’t either am hoping wicked king is better
Wheels of Glitter you haven't read wicked king yet? It was better, at least, in my opinion.
L.A Zheng And the time I posted this comment I was reading it. I took basically a eight year hiatus from reading. The wicked King is better not great but better. Hopefully the queen of nothing is better
Haha me2! I thought I was just missing something. The wicked king was slightly better nut still not a 4 or 5 stars
You're so right about 13 reasons.... Everyone I know, including myself, who has actual experience with serious depression hates the representation that depression gets in that book/TV show. The revenge story is terrible, and it doesn't properly represent depression. People who attempt suicide almost never do that to get back at someone or make them feel bad, it is ususally the opposite, that they feel removing themselves would be an improvement to other's lives.
I can’t believe she said looking for Alaska
Same issues with looking for Alaska I was still didn't understand why it was so popular everywhere
I kind of agree about The Cruel Prince. I was expecting so much of that book, but nothing of that happened. It left me unmoved, I couldn't connect to any of the characters and in general it felt shallow and childish. I was guessing that maybe I'm not the target audience and it's more relevant for teenagers.
I really really did not like The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue but I feel like I'm the only one. So disappointing
Nope, I didn’t love it either. I gave it three stars because it did an excellent job with the issues it presented, but I abhorred Monty’s personality and didn’t feel connected to the characters at all. I wanted to love Percy so much, but usually I felt really distant to it all.
Her: **pulls out call me by your name**
Me: aw, i was planning on reading that, it looks good (I wanted to read it cause i love LGBT books- since I'm gay- but i didn't know much about it)
Her: It's about a *seventeen year old boy* who falls in love with a *twenty four year old man* and it's also super sexual
Me: well i guess i can put that on my "do not read" list
SillySatyr Productions Sammee. I’m Bi personally and it’s something I hate about stories so nope!
SillySatyr Productions I think you should give it a try. This book is much more than just those sexual things. It is about discovering who he really is, its about his family, art, books and much more stuff that make this book so lovely. I also find the way it is written very beautiful. And when you think about it their age difference is not that big. Just give it a try. I fell in love with this book.
Yeah, the books is actually pretty meh but try to watch the movie! It's a pretty dope movie
I, to this day cry when i think of call me by your name. Please give it a try- its a very beautiful book.
It is my favorite book. Its so well written. I love it. Please give it a try.
I didn't like 13 reasons why either, luckily I got my copy for free so I didn't spend money on it
I feel you with the Cruel Prince. That book was wayyyy too overhyped. There was no real human connection. I didn't feel anything for the characters. Nothing
My best friend committed suicide last year. Thirteen reasons why made me so angry, it made suicide seem so casual and can be caused just because someone is having a bad day. Since I have been through a situation like this, I was seriously offended. On the list of my least favorite books
“NOTHING ELSE REALLY HAPPENS SIS” ALASKA DIED SO MUCH HAPPENED
Lol you just spoiled the book for so many people
OH MY GOD I HATE YOU.
YOU JUST SPOILED EVERYTHING. I CAN'T BELIEVE
YOU JUST DID THIS.
Kidding! I don't hate you.
But maybe a little bit....^^
Different opinions. Stop attacking her like that.
@@madhatter4129 Girl I was joking first of all and not you coming on here attacking a comment I made a year ago-
@@ashleyberry8288 You should put spoiler alart. I was thinking of reading the book but now I already found out the ending before even starting 😭
I love the folk of air series however I have to agree about that the cruel prince isn’t the best book in the series the other books are much better especially the wicked king but I would still give it 4 stars because it sets up the story for the rest of the series
Agree.For me Cruel prince is just an overture for this series, it is like the pilot episode. I hardly even remembered the way Cardan acted in school once I started reading The wicked king.And even thoough I understand why she felt this way about the book, I fell quite the opposite. I adored Jude as a character. She is tough, brave, doesnt give up and is really smart.She fights for the things she wants and doesnt wait around to be saved. Also, its nice to have manipulative mc for once!! Cardan/Jude romance is not at its peak in the first book, but it didnt feel forced for me, especially by the end of the book. Also I usually never care about the politics in books, but I was hooked about this one
that peach scene scarred me too. i haven’t read the book or watched the movie but i came across a post on twitter about it and wish i would have kept scrolling lmaoo
Ariana lol grow up
I HATED The Cruel Prince!!! Everyone raves about it but I struggled SO much to get through it. Such a disappointment. Jude's attitude drove me nuts. Her character was so back and forth and nothing in the plot seemed to fit together. I really wanted to love it, but I can't.
I feel you on Looking For Alaska. I didn't really get all the hype with that one at the time.
Are there any Fairy/Fae court books you do recommend?
I’m currently reading An Enchantment of Ravens right now aaaaaanddd I’m not sure how I feel about it - it’s sooo freaking slow! 🐢
UPDATE: I just finish it... aaaaaanddd it was garbage lmao.
13 Reasons Why is one of my favorite books; it resonated with me a lot. I didn't read her suicide as a revenge plot (at least not in the book -- I think the show definitely leans in the direction of revenge) -- the tapes seemed more about Hannah attempting to be understood by others on her own terms as opposed to the narrative about her that continued to spin out of control no matter what she did and, yes, making sure they knew what role their actions played in how difficult her life became and how she began to see herself. I definitely see your point though about how the novel is trying to accomplish a couple of different things at once and maybe should've taken time to develop both more fully.
I didn't appreciate Looking for Alaska until I re-read it after my father died very suddenly. I appreciated how John Green wrote about how lost and confused a person who goes through grief and loss could feel. Yes, Alaska does feel MPDG-like, but I guess that's one of the follies of youth? I think some teenagers or young adults idealize their crushes (and Miles was such a jerk for cheating on his girlfriend) and I hope the young people who read the book realize the pitfalls of not seeing someone for who they truly are.
I also appreciate Call Me By Your Name because a story just like it happened to one of my dearest friends (a friend from childhood who is still my friend today). My friend is like Elio and his long-time boyfriend is like Oliver. I guess I read the book with understanding of Elio's heartbreak. I also saw the movie first before I read the book and I'm glad that the cinematography gave justice to Andre Aciman's writing.
It actually is refreshing to hear another person's opinion. I love your voice and your content. Thanks for your hard work!
Omg I hated the Cruel Prince so much... There was absolutely no plot and nothing about it made sense. It was the worst thing I've ever read...😭😭
What you shared about 13 Reasons Why was very eloquent and expresses my own concerns. It makes it seem like suicide is a way up get revenge and it makes it sound like these people are responsible. And a few times Hannah put herself into bad situations and made some poor choices that lead to some of the situations.
Young teens read it and they lack perspective and the ability to look at an entire situation. So it may send a wrong and dangerous message.
I totally agree with you a out the cruel prince. I loved the older sister wanting to go back to the human world (also points for it being the modern human world) and the subplot with the "cruel prince" actually being abused by his family and how he copes with it. But the main plot where Jude got hired as a spy even though at no point was that skill set or that she was capable of doing that implied happened I was confused and really only finished it to see if it made more sense later. Low key I like the prince more than Jude
She was hired as a spy bc she is a human thus she can lie while faries cant
I still giggle every time I remember 'apricock'.
I personally enjoyed Call Me By Your Name. But also kinda hated it. It wasn’t really the age gap, but the lack of detail in the reasoning for the infatuation between Elio and Oliver and overwhelming detail in the sexual romance between the two. I wish that there was more personal connection between them. But I fell in love with the writing style of the book. I honestly think that the movie was more put together than the book.
And the movie looked beautiful, that's what makes me angry! I want to hate it but it's really hard to
I am so glad to hear you didnt like looking for Alaska and paper towns either!! I hate the magic pixie girl trope
it's been nearly 4 years since this was uploaded, and although I still haven't read it, 'The Cruel Prince' shocked me cause it's still so popular and loved
I really didn't like call me by your name as a book either, the writing style wasn't for me, and i didn't care about the characters at all. I actually enjoyed the movie a lot though, probably the only time I've ever considered a movie better than the book lol.
I really didn't like the wringing style tbh, otherwise I'd probably actually enjoy the story itself. Haven't seen the movie yet but after reading a bunch of comments, I think I might get to it soon lol
Sarah Rivington Me too! Though I really liked the way the book delved deeper into Elio’s mindset, something about the way it was written made me uncomfortable. The movie though is hands down one of my favourite. It’s so well made.
When you said Call Me By Your Name, I really wanted to stop watching but I love your videos way too much
Thank you I appreciate you
Lol same
Thirteen reasons why I felt the same thing...Agree so muchhhhhhh
Hello! Big fan of your channel! I know Cruel Prince was only a 2.5/maybe 3 for you, but I was wondering if you might do a video of book recs for people who like the cruel prince sometime? (Goodreads lumps in Cruel Prince with Sarah J Maas, Shatter Me, etc, books that I don't see as going together and would love to hear your opinions instead. Also as a sidenote if you ever do provide recs, I don't know that I or others would put this in the unlikeable narrators category) Thanks for being awesome, love all your book takes!
I'm so happy I'm not the only person in the world who just HATED Looking for Alaska. Saddest part is I had really high expectations for it.
same 😩
The last time I read something other than Fanfiction I was twelve/thirteen... whenever The Heroes Of Olympus series ended was the last time I read a real book...
Omgomg "Heroes of Olympus" yasssssssssss😂💜
Ahh, i felt the EXACT same way about 13RW but so many people praised it as this "wonderful insight" into someone who was suicidal that I just kept my mouth shut lol
I think if you go into a book believing you're going to dislike it, you will constantly be looking for reasons to sustain that belief and to not like it because you've already made up your mind from the start...
caroliinalopes i think if you keep your expectations low you can be blown away more easily so yeah
i know she said she didnt like it.. but i have to read call me by your name now. like i need to know what the peach scene is its morbid curiosity
Call me by your name has many life philosophies in it and it is really raw, the author doesn't try to mask anything. I guess you missed it. It is one of my favourite books. Also i love your videos.
No, it was just an extremely problematic book with awful cliches and misconceptions about gay men. Just bc she didn't like doesn't mean she "missed something"
@@susanam10 i feel like it’s meant to be problematic, it’s just truthful that’s personally why i love it
I liked the cruel prince, but I feel like a major issue I had with it was how little the characters were fleshed out. (Spoilers ahead) I read it in like 4 days so I might be off about some things, but overall it just seemed like Holly gave basic amounts of characterization to everyone. With Cardan, for example, it seemed like she tried to make us pity him for having a bad home life (which she didn't give enough detail to), and then tried to make him likable because now he's captured and admits he likes Jude. He treated Jude really, really bad, but it seems like that's all forgiven because Jude and him are forced to work together. That whole Locke and Taryn thing made...no sense, honestly. Taryn and Jude are supposed to be super close, so why would Taryn agree to Locke's plan, especially given they had no prior relationship before? I know she just wants to fit in with the Faerie but all of that could have been executed better. Those are just two examples but there are plenty of things I either didn't understand or thought was too rushed or just didn't work well.
I'll definitely read the next book, but I worry that the series might be tropey. I hope Holly doesn't gloss over a lot of the stuff that she did in TCP and make it like "Cardan was really awful to Jude but she gets with him anyway". If Jude and Cardan are going to be a thing I hope that Cardan's behavior is actually addressed and that he truly tries to make amends with everyone, and not just because he wants Jude to like him, because I honestly love redeemed characters and enemies-to-lovers when they're done right. Maybe the first book was just meant to be an opener and the other two will be much better, but we'll see!