Um, ending birthright citizenship would hurt Indian Americans whose parents were not born in the U.S. Meanwhile, both Vivek and Nikki have implied that African Americans who have been here for 400 years should be deported because we somehow aren't as patriotic. Why? Because we have fought and died in every single American War and dared criticize America for not living up to "All Men Are Created Equal?" That is appalling and insulting. My family fought/marched with Dr. King for people of color to enjoy the rights they now have. We welcome Indians, but we do not welcome their anti-blackness or the threat of casteism to everyone's very hard-won civil rights. Moreover, this country will always let anyone who is not white know they are not. Vivek thought he could keep his job with Trump after saying white Americans are lazy and dumb. He is going to find out that due to that statement he will not be appointed to fill Vance's Senate seat. He also will not be elected Governor of Ohio. Both "dumb" black and white Americans will unify to make sure he never even wins a school board election.
you won't believe this but It is happening in India since independence, there isn't Evan oath ceremony. political parties compete in this to strengthen vote bank. illegals even vote. But thanks to American political wings and media demonise Modi and his party. for wrong doing and brand him as authoritarian, dictator, whatever.
Irrespective of oil sanctions on Iran, India should buy some oil from Iran to save the shipping costs.. Because of US sanctions Indian govt is paying more shipping costs..its indirectly impacting our economy.. India should take the steps which are best for our nation..When US is doing what is best for it's country then India should do what's best for our country..
Yes, you are right, it should be the same in India. Illegal people or their children should not be allowed to live in any country. Whoever wants to come, come by the legal route
Most of the NRIs are demanding Hindu Rashtra in India. They should come back to India to fulfill their dream, especially Gujarati NRIs. Modi will be happy.😊
Most Indians become more desh bhakts after going abroad. Now is a good time for them to show their desh bhakti...Ideally they should not feel bad about this decision 😂😂😂😂
Well said. After leaving /abandoning India they come to US, start vehement propaganda against US, insulting their habits and trying to show they are superior and India is far far superior than US. If you have such a great openion on your motherland, why did you leave and ran to US keeping your tail between your legs? US is giving you better life, be grateful to America. Why spreading hatred about other religions in India from here?
Why would you BREAK the law to come into someone's country and expect your child to be a legal citizen? Do you want to be rewarded for breaking that law? What rights do you have in a country that is not yours?
And only the United States has such an absurd law. Trump makes a valid point. This law is incredibly stupid. Assume both foreigners are visiting the United States temporarily. If the female foreigner becomes pregnant and gives birth in the United States, her child will automatically become a US citizen. Nobody else in the world does this.
And this is exactly what the white man did, and the result seems to be white people have the right to pretend this is their land. All white people in America are a result of birthright, and many have come from a HISTORY of criminal mothers, fathers and so forth. So now what? The hypocrisy is interesting.
It doesn't. It affects a LOT of people to make any sense. Those people includes a large amount of workforce. Republicans and trumps shot themselves in the foot. It's going to impact their economy. You won't even need to wait for 2 years to see the impact.
As an Indian, Trump did the right thing. Why a country should give citizenship for the kids born in US for non American Citizens, Does India agree for this?
@@joshuaramirez3440 The problem is the statute is being abused willfully and intentionally. This will all seriously alter the demographics of a nation. I am not sure if there are many other Western democracies who sanction that privilege.
she said any baby born in the US is a citizen regardless of the ...STATUS OF THEIR PARENTS. That's not exactly what the constitution says. India doesn't have unconditional birthright citizenship. No country probably has. Why should the US have UNCONDITIONAL birth right to citizenship?
At present, the US does grant birthright citizenship. India is exceptionally exclusionary on this matter. The UK had it for many years, until Dame Thatcher changed it. Recall that C.R. Das saved Sri Aurobindo from possible execution by arguing that he was a British citizen by birth as he was born on a British ship.
Because USA is built on migrant people ! Do you think white people are from USA? They all migrated from Europe !! That's why their constitution is written like this !!
@@sdutta8 the constitution doesn't include the text "...REGARDLESS OF THE STATUS OF THEIR PARENTS..." or any such absolute stipulation. Just because the constitution was interpreted in a certain way since 1787 doesn't mean there can be no justification for unambiguous interpretation of birthright citizenship.
@@realnapster1522 ....hahaha... Remember NCR and CAA 😂😂 NRIs should return to India and enjoy the Amrit Kaal and hindu rashtra instead of chanting Modi Modi on American soil ...
As an Indian I am glad this law came into rule. Just because you have a kid coming your way doesn't mean that isn't illegal. What about all the students paying thousands of dollars just to stay legal in this country. Its you guys who take our opportunity.
They are jus coming from studies thats it. They are not there to reproduce and put their generation in the soil. Let em study and come back. Develop their own country.
One of the parent have to be a greencard(permanent resident)or American citizen then their children would be borned American citizen. Not all babies borned in a country get automatic citizenship.
that should first apply to chinese koreans japanese french italians spanish ,not just indians and arabs, trump hates a set of few races: mexicans (mexican wall) arabs due to being islamaphobic and indians ,so he focusing only these but never dare to pluck the hair of chinese due to xinping how dare! if he really eliminates all these ,america stops functioning. why cant those american chaps go to britain nor learn new language how long they going to yell same language, uneducated americans who just carry guns and never works hard now are standing behind trump asss
@@KingDTX Not really ...you can say that for majority of Indians. We have seen how most of the Americans pass racist comments on social media under the name of constructive criticism. The only thing that is left is geopolitics between Indians and Americans.
They have been interfering enough in Indian politics and dictating terms to us , so let them come back and live here , then they can rightly have a say
@@Adrinacolacoprakashsinha Absolutely. They should go back to India and serve India and save their heritage and cultural values, rather than establishing their culture in America. Some one raised a question what will happen to the children born for those who are on work permit, very simple go back to India for child delivery 😂. All these days they deliberately get pregnant to give birth to an American citizen 🙄.
People who are visiting on Business or Tourism visas are not NRIs. And this does not make any difference to NRIs who are in US with approved work visas.
WHY? ARE YOU LYING OR WORST YET IGNORENT LET ME CLARIFY THE AMENDMENT YOU SPEAK OF IS RACE AND CLASS SPECIFIC THAT WAS CREATED TO ALLOW ''' SLAVES ''' THAT WHERE BOUGHT INTO AMERICA WITHOUT THEIR CONCENT TO WORK AS BEING INDENTURED TO WORK IN FEILD OR IN HOMES ... THAT AMENDMENT WAS NOT A CART BLANCE ... YOU MISREPRESENT THESE FACTS IT WAS NEVER MENT TO ALLOW ANYONE OTHER THAN THOSE BLACK SLAVES AND THEIR DECENDENTS TO BECOME FULL U S AMERICAN CITIZENS IT WAS NOT FOR ANY OTHER PERSONS IN THE WORLD TO BECOME A CITIZEN BY BIRTH YOU ACTUALLY HAVE TO GO READ THE SPECIFICS IN OUR SUREAM COURT AS IT CLEARLY SITES WHICH PEOPLE BOUGHT HERE AS SLAVES AND THIS DOES NOT ADD ANY OTHER RACE OR PEOPLE!
I am in favour of this decision of Trump. The big reason behind this is the way Indian families demanding boys to be American in order to get their daughters married to an American citizen
This was mainly intended for "Unauthorized workers", primarily the illegal immigrants from South American or other countries. And that is only fair. But The H1b just got hit as a result of collateral damage. It's sad because people (legal non-immigrants) plan a their life around this. Buying house, investments, choosing schools and colleges their kids will go to, tuition and so much more. Now they have to re-think all of that and take bigger steps that was not on the plan (perhaps moving back to their home country).
@@jules720 it’s outdated and was only every established because of slavery. It’s useless today and is a scapegoat for illegals who did crimes to enter our great country.
If the parents came here undocumented or a temporary status, they're offspring should not be given citizenship but it's not the fault of the children but the parents has to be held accountable. I think the supreme Court May side with Trump.
What if people are waiting lawfully for 15 years applied permanent resident and US not processing them? Kids born to them. How would anybody’s capacity know when US will process it.
@@MyTechnologyReviews-fx7mkwell that retrospective effect can take away everyone’s citizenship in US given you go back long enough, except native Americans
It is not the fault of the children or the parents. As long as the constitution allows, this will happen. If this is a loophole, then close it. Before the Asians and South Americans, the Europeans took advantage of the same much more.
Get pregnant in the US or vist the US while pregnant. Deliver baby in democrat state because hospitals can’t say deny hospitalization. Then you have American citizen baby you can anchor on. Easy pizzie. The cheapest And easiest CITIZENSHIP
Birthright should have ended long ago. Nothing in this world is granted, and it's now time for people to learn and accept this. Citizenship should be based on the value that an individual can provide to society, regardless of where they were born.
@ignorasmus I don't agree with birthright of foreigners, and if US citizens aren't productive to society and breaking laws and hurting people, they should also lose their citizenship. US citizenship is an opportunity, not a right. Opportunities are given to those who deserve them...
@@AlgorithmicApostasy LOL Do the babies born on the earth belong to the earth? Or should their residency status on the earth be revoked if they are "non-productive"? Maybe deport them to Mars?
He mentioned that babies of undocumented and illegal immigrants wont get citizenship rights - which makes all the sense. However who is legally here on an extended visa will get the citizenship. Also they are going to break down on the process where people would travel during pregnancy and deliver their baby in the US. That right will also be most likely be revoked as people misuse it.
nope, not what you think. If USA amend constitution then only kids born in USA, to people who came here on green card (and perhaps accepted refugees via some kind of program), would get citizenship not any other.
@@darrenclayton8246thats great. About time the illegals need to be stopped. This will definitely have a huge impact. Im sure there will be some modifications in this bill as Trump wants more H1B skilled workers.
@@darrenclayton8246 There is nothing like "temporary residency". you are basically on temporary visa for defined time frame to stay and work and not pathway to permanent resident status. There are very few possibilities to get a green card once you cross the border into the USA. Most green card applications are processed in country of applicant. Take everything thing that you hear from the family, friends and agents with a grain of salt.
Nita Ambani gave birth to Isha and Ananth in USA. May be to get a good ivf care. Even Isha Ambani gave birth in USA with ivf. It is not nice for those who paid taxes for decade or more. They must consider them as gc takes 20 years. The pregnant women who are on work visas couldn't stop worrying about it. Most of them studied and worked for over a decade here in US but due to country backlog the GC is still looking at 2012 filled applicaytions and now it would take 30-100 years to get GC. The kids will not have a proper identity if this starts and there is no meaning in the taxes paid and work done for decades for people with work visa. ALCU gave good explaination in law suit. You can make a video on it.
Comeback to India & produce children here, why run away to America? Afterall you are always secondary citizens outside India, evenif you get it from birthright...
This shows your ignorance. Taxes are paid to keep up the roads, fire and police personal to have a livable society. H1B abusers mostly indians should get out. ACLU is a criiminal organization hope Trump bans that like getting out of NATO etc.
UAE (Dubai...) does not allow birth right citizenships and lots of foreign workers and businessmen are working there. Yet everyone wants to be in Dubai.
I think this is long overdue. What other country allows people who come on vacation or as a temp worker to have a child and then get chain migration for an entire family? It is not just a Trump idea, people want to keep their country and only allow immigrants who will assimilate, learn our customs and speak English to be actual citizens.
I DO NOT BELIEVE THAT IF A TEMPORARY VISA WORK PERMIT HOLDER GOES TO ANY COUNTRY TO WORK THAT IF THEY HAVE A CHILD THAT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY SHOULD BE GIVEN A BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP. IF HOWEVER, A PERMANENT VISA HOLDER HAS A CHILD THEN THE OPPOSITE SHOULD BE ALLOWED.
Even if they are there legally their kids will not have citizenship thats what they are saying. If parents hold foreign passports then their kids are not eligible for citizenship. That is what it says.
@@user-uq6ic8pw8x not true. Go to the right source. If they have a lawful residence in this country which means being legal so yes they have that right. That’s is what the executive order says
There is a very strict limit on H1B visas and green card is severely restricted since India gets very less quota. So many H1B people as well as students have come back in the last 15-20 years. Developing the nation doesn't happen in a vacuum. It requires a corruption free administration, less bureaucracy, good administration, efficient legal system, protection of private property, and a strong judiciary.
It is applicable to visitors visa holders like B1B2 and illegal immigrants. Not applicable to F1,J1,H1. Currently diplomats children born in USA do not get citizenship. for eg Indian diplomat stationed in New York delivers a baby, the baby gets Indian citizenship not US.
It is applicable to all temporary (non-immigrant) visas such as F1, J1 etc., if neither the mother nor the father is not a US citizen. www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/protecting-the-meaning-and-value-of-american-citizenship/
@@DG-PaloAltoIt does because of the way the EO is written. It clearly says those who are in temporary status such as tourist, student and work visa.....
@bolnol Had the personal and immigration rules been properly formulated or expressed to foresee their exploitation, there would have been no overt abuse. Asylum seekers from different cultures and religions were granted citizenship without completing the required background checks or having the proper intention of their mass influx/invasion of arrivals, and no criminals, illegal immigrants, or refugees would have smuggled into the US or Europe if they or their children had not been granted citizenship. However, if their presence in a foreign country is deliberately planned, they or their children would never confront or kill residents on the street for the benefit of other countries, regardless of the political climate in their own country.
As an Indian living in US for the last 24 years and now an American citizen- I have felt that this is one of the greatest countries in the world if not the best. This country was built by immigrants and is great because of them and also because it has been accepting of them. That all will change if Trump succeeds in his efforts. It might be beneficial for India as there may be less brain drain in future…who knows. But it will be a difficult 4 or more years for anyone who has even a little bit of empathy for others. Please pray for us.
Age old strategy to abuse this right not only by Indians but by people from other countries mostly Indians. Let him do whatever he thinks is right for his country.
The phrase “subject to the jurisdiction” refers to being under the legal authority of the U.S. government, which generally applies to anyone physically present in the country, regardless of immigration status. This includes both documented and undocumented individuals, as well as U.S. citizens and lawful residents. If someone interprets this differently, it may be due to political agendas, a lack of understanding, or personal interests, but the legal meaning remains clear in its broad application to anyone within U.S. borders.
Once my neighbor who is single teenage pregnant girl entered my house, she was full term and gave birth inside my home. She claimed my husband and house as her own and made us pay for upbringing of her child. Not only she demanded everything for free, she wanted us to leave our home so she can have safe space. Would you be happy with this situation????
Even in the 90s, this misuse has been ongoing. I heard of two sisters (upper middle class) who travelled on to US on tourist visa in the sixth month of pregnancy and delivered here specifically for US passport.
Birthright citizenship was in the constitution to give citizenship to the children of freed slaves. Not so anybody can come over here and drop an anchor baby. No country does this. Close this constitutional loop hole.
Well, if you want to go on relate this law with children of freed slaves exclusively, then you would have to trace back every immigrant entered in USA till the day this law was ratified (which is to track back over centuries). So, be careful what you wish for. lol
Most of the children born to middle eastern legal workers are not provided citizenship especially the gulf countries. They need to take the citizenship of their parents?
For your information, only citizens vote. And this change will not affect them. People on visa should think before having property or kids in a foreign land when they are on visa. Every country tries to protect their people and the rights of their citizens. Why people sitting in India are acting like monkeys behind this change?
This is great .. birth right citizenship abolition is the right thing to do. It does not really affect legal immigrants . Legal immigrants will get their citizenship after getting green card . At that time their kids can get citizenship automatically. Illegals now can stand in line ..
@@rohitsai3983we don't need dollars we are happy with our rupees. Atleast we respect our culture, past struggles, freedom fighters, etc. and do not betray our own country unlike you. 😊
Yes he is right, who ever living without proper documents they must return to India. All indian diaspora must learn it and come back to India and work for India.
why India would take anyone that USA deport? India would only accept those deported who are positively and legally identified as Indian or former citizen of India, period.
Being indian, I support what Trump did. Indians are using this birth citizenship to get citizenship illegally. Wife will intentionally visit before pregnancy period travel ban starts.
Birthright citizenship doesn’t apply to children of diplomats or children of a hostile invasive force on US territory. They just need to declare the migrants as a hostile invasive force and then birthright citizenship would not apply!
@@Xoxososowi It should reinterpreted and amended to only and at least 1 parent of US Citizens and Lawful Permanent residents. Or otherwise the whole world will always come with babies and take advantage at the cost of longtime US TAXPAYERS!! Enough is Enough!
That is NOT the law. It's a bit more complex than that. ".... and the jurisdiction thereof..." Those words are key. The 14th Amendment does not give birthright citizenship to a child born of certain kinds of parents, such as foreign diplomats.
I migrated to Australia 12 years ago and have always understood and respected the policy regarding citizenship here. After acquiring my permanent residency, I then got citizenship. I do find the system in US and Canada regarding birthright citizenship a lot liberal than what we have here.
I know if you are a legal visitor to Canada and a baby is borned in canada then that child is automatic citizen but not sure if they overstayed or breached their visitor visa
You will be when the deportations start no ? Because Trumps clause in the executive order specifically includes children of people with temporary visas, which is the H1B. Your kids, will be stateless.
With regard to the bounds and limits of constitutional birthright citizenship, Seattle federal district judge John Coughenour has done all of us a favor because it is high time that the federal judiciary issued a contemporary opinion on the limits of birthright citizenship. The TRO just granted by John Coughenour is only a tiny first step in a legal process that, now started, seems likely to last for several years and ultimately result in a U.S. Supreme Court ruling. Naïve people seem to think that the executive order that starts this litigation is just an idol gesture. I believe that it was cunningly initiated with full knowledge that the order's long term consequence will be a fresh U.S. Supreme Court interpretation of the bounds and limits of U.S. constitutional birthright citizenship. - Americans have observed, for the past few decades, federal litigation that attempts to limit other constitutional rights, about which the political middle left is vehement. For example, it is a hallmark of current middle left American politics to claim that the right to keep and bear firearms "shall not be infringed" doesn't really mean what its plain text clearly says it means, and therefore seek restrictions and prohibitions on second amendment firearm rights. - Given the logic the political left applies to the second amendment, birthright citizenship should not be absolute or unlimited either. The current administration's new executive order seeks to limit birthright citizenship to newborn children with at least one U.S. citizen, or permanent legal resident non-citizen, parent. Stated another way, pursuant to this new executive order, newborn children of illegal border crossers, or with two non-citizen parents, would not be entitled to birthright citizenship. Although the new executive order likely has limited endurance, once the federal courts have issued rulings on this controversy, those federal court rulings will be the undeniable permanent law of the land. - It is my impression that once the matter of these limits on birthright citizenship make it to the U.S. Supreme Court in a few years, given the current makeup of the U.S. Supreme Court, the U.S. Supreme Court will uphold the limits on birthright citizenship expressed in this new federal executive order. If the U.S. Supreme Court issues such a ruling, the recent practice of birthright tourism, in which pregnant foreign mothers travel to the U.S on tourist visas in the 9th month of their pregnancy so that their baby can be born in the U.S., will instantly grind to a screeching halt.
Seattle judge is a traitor Birthright Citizenship = creating more traitors with US citizenship. Birthright Citizenship = creating more Anti-American American citizens.
It makes me feel betrayed. My one son is an American citizen and my other won't be?. I've followed the law, done what is asked of me. I pay my taxes. I work hard. Yet I am subject to green card discrimination. And now this. For all those who tell us to come back to India, you really have no right to tell me what to do. You can live your life as you please and as you deem necessary but what do you get out of shitting on people like me who have chosen to emigrate to United States.
@naraendrareddy273 I am not demanding anything. Simply expressing how I feel about such laws. I am not asking for handouts either. There is a contract (which is encoder in existing laws). And when that contract changes, I reserve the right to express my dissatisfaction. Why are you so attacking? What makes your tone so negative?
You don't have green card. You are just here, that does not mean you have immigrated. Paying taxes and abiding by law of the land where you are has nothing to do with your right to citizenship. It doesn't entitle to citizenship. There are millions of non-citizens who earn billions in USA and invest in property and market for which they must pay taxes, that don't entitle them to green card, citizenship, birth right. You may do whatever you want but there are consequences.
@@lokesh2608 what contract? Does it grant right to get green card leading to citizenship? Contract can be altered or cancelled both party has the right to do that. If it is no longer acceptable to either party that is it.
As jobless Indian once before 18 years, I used to look with awe , the serpentine queue outside American Embassy at Chennai. After Trump's Order, such queues would look like one gathered to receive Umemployment doles❤❤
As an Indian myself, it is really sad and also irritating to see what all tricks Indians use to try to enter USA and settle there for life. If only all these people put in these efforts in helping out India become better in various sectors... Alas, people all want easy money and an easy way out. Shame of them.
Monday’s order sets out the parameters by which a person can claim a birthright. It states that if one parent was “unlawfully present in the United States” and the other was not a citizen or a “lawful permanent resident at the time of said person’s birth”, the child cannot claim birthright.
What does Indian Constitution say about children born to Indian Citizens residing abroad. Are those children discriminated because they were born abroad and treated as secondary Indian Citizens?
@ that also not taught, that depends on how the person was raised by the parents. btw , I still didn’t get the ans, why to stop building BAPS temples in US ? I first time went to BAPS swaminarayan temple in Texas and it was really big and beautiful. I often goes to minakshi temple, hanuman temple and Sai baba temple in Houston, Dallas and austin area.
A US Constitutional amendment is not needed to eliminate birthright citizenship. A US Federal Circuit Court split should be created, then SCOTUS can rule. End of story.
Pls educate yourself. The courts will only arbitrate the constitutional validity of this order. Even if the SCOTUS agrees on the order, its will only be good for the term of that president only. For permanency, the congress and states have to ratify.
The last 6 words in the 1st sentence of 14th Amendment requires a parent to be a resident of a State in the United States. "of the State wherein they reside" 14th Amendment Section 1 All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.
Good for America. India does not allow birthright citizenship to people from other countries. It’s only FAIR that America does the same.
It doesn't matter; if india do or not. this is not going to be for Indians only.
@ most countries do not
@@Wog68 "Rules for thee not for mee" ass reply.
Um, ending birthright citizenship would hurt Indian Americans whose parents were not born in the U.S. Meanwhile, both Vivek and Nikki have implied that African Americans who have been here for 400 years should be deported because we somehow aren't as patriotic. Why? Because we have fought and died in every single American War and dared criticize America for not living up to "All Men Are Created Equal?" That is appalling and insulting. My family fought/marched with Dr. King for people of color to enjoy the rights they now have. We welcome Indians, but we do not welcome their anti-blackness or the threat of casteism to everyone's very hard-won civil rights. Moreover, this country will always let anyone who is not white know they are not. Vivek thought he could keep his job with Trump after saying white Americans are lazy and dumb. He is going to find out that due to that statement he will not be appointed to fill Vance's Senate seat. He also will not be elected Governor of Ohio. Both "dumb" black and white Americans will unify to make sure he never even wins a school board election.
Do you know that Make America Great Again means Make America White Again? All white.
If you are illegal then the child cannot be a citizen. No other country does this. It should have ended long time back.
you won't believe this but It is happening in India since independence, there isn't Evan oath ceremony. political parties compete in this to strengthen vote bank. illegals even vote. But thanks to American political wings and media demonise Modi and his party. for wrong doing and brand him as authoritarian, dictator, whatever.
You need to go back to your civics and understand the US Constitution. Being an ignoramus does not care about you racism.
Correct...our guys know how to utilise loop holes . We will have a lot of talent in it.
I concur with you.
Hey dumbwit its not about only about illegal immigrants,it applies to even legal visa holders and working people. Their children are no citizens now.
What he he has done is correct, because I have seen so many pregnant women in their 7 to 8th month pregnancy travelling to USA just for citizenship.
Right
So cheap of them agree with you 😂😂
I agree 👍
I am indian but i dont know why indians are crying for this decision ....trump is doing best thing for his country
Yeah he is.. no more loud bhajans and Curry smell in a quite and beautiful Suburbs on the countryside.
Irrespective of oil sanctions on Iran, India should buy some oil from Iran to save the shipping costs.. Because of US sanctions Indian govt is paying more shipping costs..its indirectly impacting our economy.. India should take the steps which are best for our nation..When US is doing what is best for it's country then India should do what's best for our country..
@@Rexorazorcomes a Puslim Baas . Tard to run fake propaganda.
Yes, you are right, it should be the same in India. Illegal people or their children should not be allowed to live in any country. Whoever wants to come, come by the legal route
Don't forget no matter how much you show your support they still don't like you.
Most of the NRIs are demanding Hindu Rashtra in India. They should come back to India to fulfill their dream, especially Gujarati NRIs. Modi will be happy.😊
😂 exactly and let trump make america a catholic country
@idk-ll6yv that's why he didn't have a bible during swearing in
Honesty NRIs should have zero say In Indian politics
The Randi rona of all the guys sitting in India who can't make money and cry over the rich NRIs is funny to watch 😂
@@Xoxososowi Exactly
Most Indians become more desh bhakts after going abroad. Now is a good time for them to show their desh bhakti...Ideally they should not feel bad about this decision 😂😂😂😂
Not impacting Indians. Only illegals impacted
😂😂😂
It's habit of gujuratis and jains . They do it everywhere they go .
Well said. After leaving /abandoning India they come to US, start vehement propaganda against US, insulting their habits and trying to show they are superior and India is far far superior than US.
If you have such a great openion on your motherland, why did you leave and ran to US keeping your tail between your legs?
US is giving you better life, be grateful to America.
Why spreading hatred about other religions in India from here?
@@Theackermans121 you seem to be from Kanglu land. Jealous of Gujju successs!
Why would you BREAK the law to come into someone's country and expect your child to be a legal citizen? Do you want to be rewarded for breaking that law? What rights do you have in a country that is not yours?
And only the United States has such an absurd law. Trump makes a valid point. This law is incredibly stupid. Assume both foreigners are visiting the United States temporarily. If the female foreigner becomes pregnant and gives birth in the United States, her child will automatically become a US citizen. Nobody else in the world does this.
Very True ❤
And this is exactly what the white man did, and the result seems to be white people have the right to pretend this is their land. All white people in America are a result of birthright, and many have come from a HISTORY of criminal mothers, fathers and so forth. So now what? The hypocrisy is interesting.
Because it’s the law that anyone born in this country is an American citizen…. So it’s an expectation specifically because it’s in the constitution.
... and now the law is about to change... and if new law will take effect... That Will Be The Law.
I think if u think from American point of view it makes sense to abolish it
Exactly
Correct
It doesn't. It affects a LOT of people to make any sense. Those people includes a large amount of workforce. Republicans and trumps shot themselves in the foot. It's going to impact their economy. You won't even need to wait for 2 years to see the impact.
Yeah but NRIs supporting him are going to cry wolf 😂
Absolutely.
As an Indian, Trump did the right thing. Why a country should give citizenship for the kids born in US for non American Citizens, Does India agree for this?
Citizenship is given where the person is born, you dum dum. This is protected under 14th amendment. And most likely this law will not be passed😂😂
Why Indian agreement is required? What the hell India has to do with this?
@ India has nothing to do with this, My intention is does India allow citizenship by birth? India has the most illegal immigrants
@@anita2053-r1f India is NOT PEANUT sized compared to US.!!!! india is the 7th largest Country !!
@@joshuaramirez3440 The problem is the statute is being abused willfully and intentionally. This will all seriously alter the demographics of a nation. I am not sure if there are many other Western democracies who sanction that privilege.
she said any baby born in the US is a citizen regardless of the ...STATUS OF THEIR PARENTS. That's not exactly what the constitution says. India doesn't have unconditional birthright citizenship. No country probably has. Why should the US have UNCONDITIONAL birth right to citizenship?
This rule was made to attract foreigners to come and settle in the US
Now they have enough people so talk of finish the rule
read the constitution of USA and ask Americans. doh
At present, the US does grant birthright citizenship. India is exceptionally exclusionary on this matter. The UK had it for many years, until Dame Thatcher changed it. Recall that C.R. Das saved Sri Aurobindo from possible execution by arguing that he was a British citizen by birth as he was born on a British ship.
Because USA is built on migrant people ! Do you think white people are from USA? They all migrated from Europe !! That's why their constitution is written like this !!
@@sdutta8 the constitution doesn't include the text "...REGARDLESS OF THE STATUS OF THEIR PARENTS..." or any such absolute stipulation. Just because the constitution was interpreted in a certain way since 1787 doesn't mean there can be no justification for unambiguous interpretation of birthright citizenship.
A country is changing its Laws so why are the foreigners bothered?
Because they are residents in U.S. that's why. And pay taxes there.
Obviously, some want to stay.
@@realnapster1522 ....hahaha... Remember NCR and CAA 😂😂 NRIs should return to India and enjoy the Amrit Kaal and hindu rashtra instead of chanting Modi Modi on American soil ...
@@realnapster1522 , how is this change in the Law affecting their residency? Please, do elaborate.
@@Wog68 , you mean like climbing the ladder using their children’s backs. What a bunch of BASTARDS.
As an Indian I am glad this law came into rule. Just because you have a kid coming your way doesn't mean that isn't illegal. What about all the students paying thousands of dollars just to stay legal in this country. Its you guys who take our opportunity.
They are jus coming from studies thats it. They are not there to reproduce and put their generation in the soil. Let em study and come back. Develop their own country.
Don't understand what's all the hype for.If both parents are not us citizens how would the children be granted citizenship.
USA made the law like that. Anyone is born in soil of USA become citizen. Now they want to change it, so be it, it is there country.
One of the parent have to be a greencard(permanent resident)or American citizen then their children would be borned American citizen. Not all babies borned in a country get automatic citizenship.
Exactly. And this is in the context of illegal immigrants. What's wrong with that?
that should first apply to chinese koreans japanese french italians spanish ,not just indians and arabs, trump hates a set of few races: mexicans (mexican wall) arabs due to being islamaphobic and indians ,so he focusing only these but never dare to pluck the hair of chinese due to xinping how dare! if he really eliminates all these ,america stops functioning. why cant those american chaps go to britain nor learn new language how long they going to yell same language, uneducated americans who just carry guns and never works hard now are standing behind trump asss
The 14th Amendment is very clear and was written in response to newly freed enslaved people after the American Civil War.
Thank you Indians. I am glad most of you understand why birthright citizenship needs to come to an end. We can still be friends.
Indians will whine for a century but still wish to be white and American by magic. hahahahahahah
We are geopolitical partners....not friends whatsoever
@ Everyone except this guy.
@@KingDTX Not really ...you can say that for majority of Indians. We have seen how most of the Americans pass racist comments on social media under the name of constructive criticism. The only thing that is left is geopolitics between Indians and Americans.
@@sreenathjimmy245 don't generalize . There are many commoners in america who are kind and appreciative .
Good for America. I am an Indian. Take that!
😂😂leech
Mera desh mahan!
We don't need dirty India!!😂
I agree.. This is an outdated law that needs to change
Why you peope always say i am indian, i am proud to be indian... do you guys feel inferior and low in front of others?
Indians are gonna get the first hand experience of what "Changing the Constitution" looks like.
How wonderful 😊
Modi Bhakts take notes.
All NRI should return to Modi call, instead demanding their rights in America
They have been interfering enough in Indian politics and dictating terms to us , so let them come back and live here , then they can rightly have a say
Yes please.
@@Adrinacolacoprakashsinha Absolutely. They should go back to India and serve India and save their heritage and cultural values, rather than establishing their culture in America.
Some one raised a question what will happen to the children born for those who are on work permit, very simple go back to India for child delivery 😂.
All these days they deliberately get pregnant to give birth to an American citizen 🙄.
Even though we won't get citizenship or in future child, noone is willing to go back to india.
Ofcourse, rahul baba ko thodi karenge 😂
As an Indian I support Trump's decision
doest matter, who cares/
He dont need your support
Leave amirca
NRIs crying like Oh no now our kids will be our country citizens.
People who are visiting on Business or Tourism visas are not NRIs. And this does not make any difference to NRIs who are in US with approved work visas.
@@AguiarMelwyn Only those with green card will not have any issues. H1B holders are impacted as well with this EO.
People in India start celebrating at least the one good news they get in their entire life 😂.
WHY? ARE YOU LYING OR WORST YET IGNORENT LET ME CLARIFY THE AMENDMENT YOU SPEAK OF IS RACE AND CLASS SPECIFIC THAT WAS CREATED TO ALLOW
''' SLAVES ''' THAT WHERE BOUGHT INTO AMERICA WITHOUT THEIR CONCENT TO WORK AS BEING INDENTURED TO WORK IN FEILD OR IN HOMES ... THAT AMENDMENT WAS NOT A CART BLANCE ... YOU MISREPRESENT THESE FACTS IT WAS NEVER MENT TO ALLOW ANYONE OTHER THAN THOSE BLACK SLAVES AND THEIR DECENDENTS TO BECOME FULL U S AMERICAN CITIZENS IT WAS NOT FOR ANY OTHER PERSONS IN THE WORLD TO BECOME A CITIZEN BY BIRTH YOU ACTUALLY HAVE TO GO READ THE SPECIFICS IN OUR SUREAM COURT AS IT CLEARLY SITES WHICH PEOPLE BOUGHT HERE AS SLAVES AND THIS DOES NOT ADD ANY OTHER RACE OR PEOPLE!
@@LikeDeep-q6wno only undocumented illegals are impacted
I am in favour of this decision of Trump. The big reason behind this is the way Indian families demanding boys to be American in order to get their daughters married to an American citizen
This was mainly intended for "Unauthorized workers", primarily the illegal immigrants from South American or other countries. And that is only fair. But The H1b just got hit as a result of collateral damage. It's sad because people (legal non-immigrants) plan a their life around this. Buying house, investments, choosing schools and colleges their kids will go to, tuition and so much more. Now they have to re-think all of that and take bigger steps that was not on the plan (perhaps moving back to their home country).
So sad come back modi is making hindu rashtra. He will take are of you
Yea challenge is they are planning it all on basis of temp work visa 😢
@@Viswamsa you do realize when Indians go back, the jobs go back with them ? Indians can single handedly crash the US economy. Wanna try ?
IT'S NOT IF IT WILL HAPPEN , BUT WHEN IT WILL HAPPEN . THE LAW HAS NOT BEEN SET IN STONE . WAIT AND FIND OUT .
@@vijshan9289 nonsense. what part of temporary you did not understand. why you expect citizenship on temporary visa?
When India self doesn’t allow citizenship by birth if none of the parents are Indian, then How Indian should expect such privilege in USA?
We are not the same country. In the United States if you are born on the soil you are a citizen by right. That is what the Constitution says.
So you want to implement all Indian laws in USA 😂😂😂
Very true
@@jules720 it’s outdated and was only every established because of slavery. It’s useless today and is a scapegoat for illegals who did crimes to enter our great country.
In india anyone born between 1952-1987 are birth right citizens .
If the parents came here undocumented or a temporary status, they're offspring should not be given citizenship but it's not the fault of the children but the parents has to be held accountable. I think the supreme Court May side with Trump.
depends on who appointed those SC Judge. In the USA, judiciary is an extension of political parties and SC judges usually follow party line.
What if people are waiting lawfully for 15 years applied permanent resident and US not processing them? Kids born to them. How would anybody’s capacity know when US will process it.
Trump should give it a retrospective effect
@@MyTechnologyReviews-fx7mkwell that retrospective effect can take away everyone’s citizenship in US given you go back long enough, except native Americans
It is not the fault of the children or the parents. As long as the constitution allows, this will happen. If this is a loophole, then close it. Before the Asians and South Americans, the Europeans took advantage of the same much more.
This is the best of all the bills he signed. People from third world countries were abusing this privilege to extreme practices.🎉🎉🎉🎉
yes and to the tune of 💲Billions💥..No More Mexico😂‼️💁🏿♀️
It's not a bill. It's an executive order. They are different.
I guess this includes Elon Musk and Vivek as abusing privileges since they are people from so called third world countries
Scamming the system for decades and it was designed for my enslaved ancestors in 🇺🇸
@@sambakos4183 These goobers don't know the difference.
Get pregnant in the US or vist the US while pregnant. Deliver baby in democrat state because hospitals can’t say deny hospitalization. Then you have American citizen baby you can anchor on. Easy pizzie. The cheapest And easiest CITIZENSHIP
If you can afford a hospital in the US... even in Democrat ruled states 😂!
@@KaushikAdhikariTaxpayers citizens pay for pregnant illegals who refuse to pay for hospital.
@@KaushikAdhikari They don't charge those who can't pay, they legally can't.
It's f*cked up
ignorance is a bliss, lol.
This will help restore self respect of all countries, since no person should be regarded as a begger of US citizenship
actually real beggars of citizenship are corporate and those who buy green card on investment scheme.
Birthright should have ended long ago. Nothing in this world is granted, and it's now time for people to learn and accept this. Citizenship should be based on the value that an individual can provide to society, regardless of where they were born.
Birthright is part of their 14th amendment.
@MrSamtola Not any longer. Amendments are not permanent. We have taken back our country.
Should you have been granted the citizenship of your country?
Why?
@ignorasmus I don't agree with birthright of foreigners, and if US citizens aren't productive to society and breaking laws and hurting people, they should also lose their citizenship. US citizenship is an opportunity, not a right. Opportunities are given to those who deserve them...
@@AlgorithmicApostasy LOL Do the babies born on the earth belong to the earth? Or should their residency status on the earth be revoked if they are "non-productive"? Maybe deport them to Mars?
He mentioned that babies of undocumented and illegal immigrants wont get citizenship rights - which makes all the sense.
However who is legally here on an extended visa will get the citizenship. Also they are going to break down on the process where people would travel during pregnancy and deliver their baby in the US. That right will also be most likely be revoked as people misuse it.
nope, not what you think. If USA amend constitution then only kids born in USA, to people who came here on green card (and perhaps accepted refugees via some kind of program), would get citizenship not any other.
The order says that Only if the father has a permanent residence or citizenship the child will receive citizenship that excludes temporary residency
@@darrenclayton8246thats great. About time the illegals need to be stopped. This will definitely have a huge impact.
Im sure there will be some modifications in this bill as Trump wants more H1B skilled workers.
@@darrenclayton8246 There is nothing like "temporary residency". you are basically on temporary visa for defined time frame to stay and work and not pathway to permanent resident status. There are very few possibilities to get a green card once you cross the border into the USA. Most green card applications are processed in country of applicant. Take everything thing that you hear from the family, friends and agents with a grain of salt.
Come back home. Live a life of dignity and respect. It's not all that bad here 😊
Nita Ambani gave birth to Isha and Ananth in USA. May be to get a good ivf care. Even Isha Ambani gave birth in USA with ivf. It is not nice for those who paid taxes for decade or more. They must consider them as gc takes 20 years. The pregnant women who are on work visas couldn't stop worrying about it. Most of them studied and worked for over a decade here in US but due to country backlog the GC is still looking at 2012 filled applicaytions and now it would take 30-100 years to get GC. The kids will not have a proper identity if this starts and there is no meaning in the taxes paid and work done for decades for people with work visa. ALCU gave good explaination in law suit. You can make a video on it.
❤💯
Comeback to India & produce children here, why run away to America? Afterall you are always secondary citizens outside India, evenif you get it from birthright...
Foreigners have taken advantage of this stupid law.
@@bhujangabhushan4578 Really well put man. I am in this same boat and increasingly feeling isolated, helpless and left out.
This shows your ignorance. Taxes are paid to keep up the roads, fire and police personal to have a livable society. H1B abusers mostly indians should get out. ACLU is a criiminal organization hope Trump bans that like getting out of NATO etc.
This shud hav been done long ago, it's the rite step to take not too late even now
Lot of comments by friends who could not get work permits to USA. They are truly delighted . God bless them
Someone spoke my mind
Jealous souls.
Lol, south indians 😂😂😂
lol. here jealousy is in plenty.
😂😂😂
Nothing like this can happen overnight and amending a constitution is something close to impossible because of soooooo many legalities
Same I was thinking. The reporter here has not done her homework
Not so read the 14th amendment when it gets to supreme Court Democrats are done
Damn!! FINALLY!!
Ignorant..it takes more than an executive order to change the US Constitution..
Im going to US in August so we were planning to have a baby in 2026 once my wife was in US
UAE (Dubai...) does not allow birth right citizenships and lots of foreign workers and businessmen are working there. Yet everyone wants to be in Dubai.
greed
I think this is long overdue. What other country allows people who come on vacation or as a temp worker to have a child and then get chain migration for an entire family? It is not just a Trump idea, people want to keep their country and only allow immigrants who will assimilate, learn our customs and speak English to be actual citizens.
I DO NOT BELIEVE THAT IF A TEMPORARY VISA WORK PERMIT HOLDER GOES TO ANY COUNTRY TO WORK THAT IF THEY HAVE A CHILD THAT DOES NOT MEAN THAT THEY SHOULD BE GIVEN A BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP. IF HOWEVER, A PERMANENT VISA HOLDER HAS A CHILD THEN THE OPPOSITE SHOULD BE ALLOWED.
Well that would not be birthright citizenship then
It’s irrelevant what you want. The 14th amendment is quite clear, including what jurisdiction means.
@@Zenoithegreek Amendments are always subject to change.
Caps are for lames
@@aswini4222 what’s the point in having them? If that’s the case
If you are here illegally why in the world would you have that privilege? If you come legally so nothing to be scared about
I agree with you but why USA enacted that law? Now, If USA want to change it, change it fast without fanfare and it would stop.
No. Even legal immigrants and their kids are affected.
Even if they are there legally their kids will not have citizenship thats what they are saying. If parents hold foreign passports then their kids are not eligible for citizenship. That is what it says.
@@Wog68 did you see what president trumps just did?
@@user-uq6ic8pw8x not true. Go to the right source. If they have a lawful residence in this country which means being legal so yes they have that right. That’s is what the executive order says
Important step. Also there should be limits on H1B visa.
Indians should be back to India after studies and develop India.
They left for USA as India offers a raw deal to them
There is already a limit on H1b.
There is a very strict limit on H1B visas and green card is severely restricted since India gets very less quota. So many H1B people as well as students have come back in the last 15-20 years. Developing the nation doesn't happen in a vacuum. It requires a corruption free administration, less bureaucracy, good administration, efficient legal system, protection of private property, and a strong judiciary.
Remove reservation in India, then I will find opportunities and come back to work.
@indianboy8129 there is no reservation in the private sector.
A step in the right direction. As an Indian in America
It is applicable to visitors visa holders like B1B2 and illegal immigrants. Not applicable to F1,J1,H1.
Currently diplomats children born in USA do not get citizenship. for eg Indian diplomat stationed in New York delivers a baby, the baby gets Indian citizenship not US.
It's applicable for H1B. Because it's a non-immigrant visa
@@prateeknarendra1637 Not true.
It is applicable to all temporary (non-immigrant) visas such as F1, J1 etc., if neither the mother nor the father is not a US citizen.
www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/protecting-the-meaning-and-value-of-american-citizenship/
@@DG-PaloAltoIt does because of the way the EO is written. It clearly says those who are in temporary status such as tourist, student and work visa.....
I think... Its applicable only to children going to be born... 30 days from 21st January 2025 day of EO signed..
Not for those born earlier,..😮
It is a good step...we should do same in all countries...lot of illegal immigrants get aadhar card , pan ,voter card etc 😊
it is your problem.
@@Wog68That's why NRC should be implemented.
The best of all. How come become a citizen just by borning in the country in the first place if not legal!?
you are ignorant
because nothing says progress like taking a step back into the 1800s. Brilliant idea, really.
Desh bhakti dikhao india aao ab 😂😂😂 hippocracy of nris…. Trump had done best for America
देशभक्त इंडियन जो बाहर रहते है ने
NRI उनको वापस आना चाहिए इंडिया में ओर इंडिया को आगे बढ़ाना चाहिए 😊😊
Their 'patriotism' only exists when they are abroad
actually many does come back.
Love this… Trump should also ban H1 and H2. Already enough here.
The Trump has done in the interest of his country regarding child birth citizenship.
Honestly you explained better than other lawyers here on RUclips ❤you really made it easy to understand thank you
Abuse of the laws is completely conceivable in all respects if they are not properly defined or described.
They are properly defined and described, if you read the legal dicta and the law there is NO WIGGLE ROOM it is exact
@bolnol Had the personal and immigration rules been properly formulated or expressed to foresee their exploitation, there would have been no overt abuse. Asylum seekers from different cultures and religions were granted citizenship without completing the required background checks or having the proper intention of their mass influx/invasion of arrivals, and no criminals, illegal immigrants, or refugees would have smuggled into the US or Europe if they or their children had not been granted citizenship. However, if their presence in a foreign country is deliberately planned, they or their children would never confront or kill residents on the street for the benefit of other countries, regardless of the political climate in their own country.
As an Indian living in US for the last 24 years and now an American citizen- I have felt that this is one of the greatest countries in the world if not the best. This country was built by immigrants and is great because of them and also because it has been accepting of them. That all will change if Trump succeeds in his efforts. It might be beneficial for India as there may be less brain drain in future…who knows. But it will be a difficult 4 or more years for anyone who has even a little bit of empathy for others. Please pray for us.
Age old strategy to abuse this right not only by Indians but by people from other countries mostly Indians. Let him do whatever he thinks is right for his country.
The phrase “subject to the jurisdiction” refers to being under the legal authority of the U.S. government, which generally applies to anyone physically present in the country, regardless of immigration status. This includes both documented and undocumented individuals, as well as U.S. citizens and lawful residents. If someone interprets this differently, it may be due to political agendas, a lack of understanding, or personal interests, but the legal meaning remains clear in its broad application to anyone within U.S. borders.
That’s a wise move, it should be implemented in Canada also.
Who are the Indians entering illegally thru Mexico... Gujjus?! 😂😂
Hope creates pressure on indians to hold govt accountable n not just runaway. Our country can also be good
Exactly fix your country..
Same to Africans stay there fix ur continent @@NB-nh2sf
@NB-nh2sf you sound dumb and ignorant. First, read up on immigration before you mouth off. This has nothing to do with India.
@NB-nh2sf America is not perfect. Keep ur negativity to urself
@@NB-nh2sf We know how to fix our own, nobody asked your opinion. You should first fix the mess America is in
Once my neighbor who is single teenage pregnant girl entered my house, she was full term and gave birth inside my home. She claimed my husband and house as her own and made us pay for upbringing of her child. Not only she demanded everything for free, she wanted us to leave our home so she can have safe space. Would you be happy with this situation????
In 2024, 90000 illegal Indian immigrants entered US but the total number is 700000 by adding all previous years.
Well deport them. It is right of USA to deport anyone that want.
Even in the 90s, this misuse has been ongoing. I heard of two sisters (upper middle class) who travelled on to US on tourist visa in the sixth month of pregnancy and delivered here specifically for US passport.
Birthright citizenship was in the constitution to give citizenship to the children of freed slaves. Not so anybody can come over here and drop an anchor baby. No country does this. Close this constitutional loop hole.
No country if false. Canada does this as well
Well, if you want to go on relate this law with children of freed slaves exclusively, then you would have to trace back every immigrant entered in USA till the day this law was ratified (which is to track back over centuries). So, be careful what you wish for. lol
For someone who preaches about Jesus you seem the opposite of what he represents, your honestly a disgrace
Most of the children born to middle eastern legal workers are not provided citizenship especially the gulf countries. They need to take the citizenship of their parents?
Trump government should give this end of birthright citizenship a retrospective effect , to help American citizens
bro it will impact Indians big time
I agree and I wish this so much!
@@deepa8305 why?
They actually did it in the past but then changed mind.
@@rationalhuman3290 does American citizens are not impacted?
All the NRI Sanghis who mostly voted or supported Trump should come back to India and "Make India Great Again".
For your information, only citizens vote. And this change will not affect them. People on visa should think before having property or kids in a foreign land when they are on visa. Every country tries to protect their people and the rights of their citizens. Why people sitting in India are acting like monkeys behind this change?
@livelikeamonk3161 one NRI sanghi spotted :-)
This is great .. birth right citizenship abolition is the right thing to do. It does not really affect legal immigrants . Legal immigrants will get their citizenship after getting green card . At that time their kids can get citizenship automatically. Illegals now can stand in line ..
@@livelikeamonk3161😢So sad, Come back bro. We want india to make hindu rashtra.
@@shaikhabdulaziz759 Its not a law yet, similar case went to court and failed long ago. jeeh@di dancing for no reason.
Makes total sense, good job President Trump 👍
Great explanation! Thanks. You're good.
Thanks
You elected him for it and he is delivering. No one has the right to cry now.
Patriotic Indians in US are sad and I don't understand why? Desh ki mitti ki yaad aati thi na tumko 😂
Bank account details de.. Will send you some dollars to wipe your tears 😂
@@rohitsai3983we don't need dollars we are happy with our rupees. Atleast we respect our culture, past struggles, freedom fighters, etc. and do not betray our own country unlike you. 😊
@rohitsai3983 im earning euros lil bro 😂
@@rohitsai3983dollar yuk over new super power the peoples republic of china
@@rohitsai3983aur tumsa amir log ha Jo tum jasa 10 kutto ko asani sa karide saktha ha sapana details da tare Pura family ko ma kharid Lunga
Enjoyed listening to your commentary Faye. Keep it up.
7:55 Barely any non-European country follows through with the climate change policies. So it's not a biggie
Go Trump!
Yes he is right, who ever living without proper documents they must return to India. All indian diaspora must learn it and come back to India and work for India.
why India would take anyone that USA deport? India would only accept those deported who are positively and legally identified as Indian or former citizen of India, period.
Being indian, I support what Trump did. Indians are using this birth citizenship to get citizenship illegally. Wife will intentionally visit before pregnancy period travel ban starts.
Citizenship is a privilege Not a Right. Very much like our iwn country. 🇮🇳
So people draw arbitrary borders on land and decide who can stay in which land. Humans are ridiculous.
Really?
exactly
Now those BJP guys who fed cakes to Trump's photo will need to do an enema on the same photo as a response.😂😂😂😂
Ask RAGA he love to go to USA and UK to badmouth about India.
Thanks for 360 degreer. Sent to our people in America.
Your smart man
Birthright citizenship doesn’t apply to children of diplomats or children of a hostile invasive force on US territory. They just need to declare the migrants as a hostile invasive force and then birthright citizenship would not apply!
You can't do that to peaceful law abiding H1B holder
Chinese plane filled with pregnant women is one thing that needs to stop
@@Xoxososowi It should reinterpreted and amended to only and at least 1 parent of US Citizens and Lawful Permanent residents. Or otherwise the whole world will always come with babies and take advantage at the cost of longtime US TAXPAYERS!! Enough is Enough!
That is NOT the law. It's a bit more complex than that. ".... and the jurisdiction thereof..." Those words are key. The 14th Amendment does not give birthright citizenship to a child born of certain kinds of parents, such as foreign diplomats.
Thanks Faye. Very Helpful❤
I migrated to Australia 12 years ago and have always understood and respected the policy regarding citizenship here. After acquiring my permanent residency, I then got citizenship. I do find the system in US and Canada regarding birthright citizenship a lot liberal than what we have here.
I know if you are a legal visitor to Canada and a baby is borned in canada then that child is automatic citizen but not sure if they overstayed or breached their visitor visa
@@VishnuRamdin-xe7yd that’s correct and that is same as US.
In Australia though, thankfully, we don’t have this system.
Why it is a problem for you? You live in Australia.
@@Wog68 who said I have a problem?
I have no say in what happens in US and their laws. And yes you are right - I am glad I live in Australia
@@himanshu.dhamankar Good for you.
Thank you Faye, so lucidly explained.
Much appreciated. Please see if you can improve audio clarity
I am on work visa in the US. I think it is fine either way for me. American citizenship or not, we aren’t too worried for future kids.
Good for you.
You will be when the deportations start no ? Because Trumps clause in the executive order specifically includes children of people with temporary visas, which is the H1B. Your kids, will be stateless.
With regard to the bounds and limits of constitutional birthright citizenship, Seattle federal district judge John Coughenour has done all of us a favor because it is high time that the federal judiciary issued a contemporary opinion on the limits of birthright citizenship. The TRO just granted by John Coughenour is only a tiny first step in a legal process that, now started, seems likely to last for several years and ultimately result in a U.S. Supreme Court ruling. Naïve people seem to think that the executive order that starts this litigation is just an idol gesture. I believe that it was cunningly initiated with full knowledge that the order's long term consequence will be a fresh U.S. Supreme Court interpretation of the bounds and limits of U.S. constitutional birthright citizenship.
-
Americans have observed, for the past few decades, federal litigation that attempts to limit other constitutional rights, about which the political middle left is vehement. For example, it is a hallmark of current middle left American politics to claim that the right to keep and bear firearms "shall not be infringed" doesn't really mean what its plain text clearly says it means, and therefore seek restrictions and prohibitions on second amendment firearm rights.
-
Given the logic the political left applies to the second amendment, birthright citizenship should not be absolute or unlimited either. The current administration's new executive order seeks to limit birthright citizenship to newborn children with at least one U.S. citizen, or permanent legal resident non-citizen, parent. Stated another way, pursuant to this new executive order, newborn children of illegal border crossers, or with two non-citizen parents, would not be entitled to birthright citizenship. Although the new executive order likely has limited endurance, once the federal courts have issued rulings on this controversy, those federal court rulings will be the undeniable permanent law of the land.
-
It is my impression that once the matter of these limits on birthright citizenship make it to the U.S. Supreme Court in a few years, given the current makeup of the U.S. Supreme Court, the U.S. Supreme Court will uphold the limits on birthright citizenship expressed in this new federal executive order. If the U.S. Supreme Court issues such a ruling, the recent practice of birthright tourism, in which pregnant foreign mothers travel to the U.S on tourist visas in the 9th month of their pregnancy so that their baby can be born in the U.S., will instantly grind to a screeching halt.
Seattle judge is a traitor
Birthright Citizenship = creating more traitors with US citizenship.
Birthright Citizenship = creating more Anti-American American citizens.
It makes me feel betrayed. My one son is an American citizen and my other won't be?. I've followed the law, done what is asked of me. I pay my taxes. I work hard. Yet I am subject to green card discrimination. And now this. For all those who tell us to come back to India, you really have no right to tell me what to do. You can live your life as you please and as you deem necessary but what do you get out of shitting on people like me who have chosen to emigrate to United States.
Go back to jeets land. Take back all your jeetz with you
Executive order cant change the existing constitutional amendment
@naraendrareddy273 I am not demanding anything. Simply expressing how I feel about such laws. I am not asking for handouts either. There is a contract (which is encoder in existing laws). And when that contract changes, I reserve the right to express my dissatisfaction. Why are you so attacking? What makes your tone so negative?
You don't have green card. You are just here, that does not mean you have immigrated. Paying taxes and abiding by law of the land where you are has nothing to do with your right to citizenship. It doesn't entitle to citizenship. There are millions of non-citizens who earn billions in USA and invest in property and market for which they must pay taxes, that don't entitle them to green card, citizenship, birth right. You may do whatever you want but there are consequences.
@@lokesh2608 what contract? Does it grant right to get green card leading to citizenship? Contract can be altered or cancelled both party has the right to do that. If it is no longer acceptable to either party that is it.
please keep this coming. your discussions are very helpful as i am preparing for b school gdpi
That law has been changed in Australia and New Zealand many years ago and it does make sense.
How can u change it with executive order... Its a constitutional amendment...
As jobless Indian once before 18 years, I used to look with awe , the serpentine queue outside American Embassy at Chennai. After Trump's Order, such queues would look like one gathered to receive Umemployment doles❤❤
As an Indian myself, it is really sad and also irritating to see what all tricks Indians use to try to enter USA and settle there for life. If only all these people put in these efforts in helping out India become better in various sectors... Alas, people all want easy money and an easy way out. Shame of them.
Monday’s order sets out the parameters by which a person can claim a birthright.
It states that if one parent was “unlawfully present in the United States” and the other was not a citizen or a “lawful permanent resident at the time of said person’s birth”, the child cannot claim birthright.
Maam please continue bringing in these news and your personal insights. Really loving it❤
What does Indian Constitution say about children born to Indian Citizens residing abroad. Are those children discriminated because they were born abroad and treated as secondary Indian Citizens?
I agree with Trump decision
As an Indian this is the best thing made by Trump😂
Excellent idea
It will good thing if these folks come back and pay taxes in India
Stop building BAPS temples in the US.
why ?
@Tigriyabadshah when you are breaking churches?
@ why would I break the church?
My hindu dharma didn’t teach me to harm any religion
😂😂😂 but it taught you to protect cows and not women
@ that also not taught, that depends on how the person was raised by the parents.
btw , I still didn’t get the ans, why to stop building BAPS temples in US ?
I first time went to BAPS swaminarayan temple in Texas and it was really big and beautiful.
I often goes to minakshi temple, hanuman temple and Sai baba temple in Houston, Dallas and austin area.
Ouuuccchhh, Corporate Modi Supporters and Gujjus will be the unhappiest
A US Constitutional amendment is not needed to eliminate birthright citizenship. A US Federal Circuit Court split should be created, then SCOTUS can rule. End of story.
Pls explain to 5 year old😭 too complex
Pls educate yourself. The courts will only arbitrate the constitutional validity of this order. Even if the SCOTUS agrees on the order, its will only be good for the term of that president only. For permanency, the congress and states have to ratify.
Yeah why have checks and balances?
@@Xoxososowi The criminal parent who caused the problem should explain it. Not my problem.
Change all the constitution then. Democrats will next , watch
The last 6 words in the 1st sentence of 14th Amendment requires a parent to be a resident of a State in the United States. "of the State wherein they reside"
14th Amendment
Section 1
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.