When the girl lost her innocent, promising life, the guilty criminal should have no right to life either. Besides, life imprisonment is a sham. He'll get out of prison in no time, as has happened so often. Remember the case of Aruna Shanbaug? She remained in a vegetative state for more than 40 years before dying in 2015 while the accused was released after a mere term of 7 years. He is still alive, married and has kids. What justice are we even talking about?
"Creating fear among criminals is better than, building fear among innocents"...and some judgements need to be made to let the severity be known of what's the rarest of rare!
I feel, the entire judicial system in India is very subjective and unfair when it comes to women, or minorities as well. There are hundreds examples for this. Its high time someone sits down and draw out laws to account for indecent exposure, eve teasing and more.
This was really enlightening. The same day RGKar rape case verdict came as life sentence, death sentence was awarded to a female in sharon murder case in Kerala. So now i understand that its the subjective difference between two judges bt doesnt this kind of imply tht a woman getting brutally raped and murdered is not so rare in our country tht nobody should be so shocked as to demand a death sentence?
What a balanced and informed view! Very insightful that less than 5% of death sentences from 2000-2015 were actually upheld. Also interesting to know that we have ~100 cases every year which are judged as rarest of rare and sentenced with death penalties!
as a 17 year old, with the limited knowledge that i have, i'd just say, death sentence or not should not be the question. the real problem is the fact that so many of these crimes happen and most of them aren't even reported. Out of the ones that are reported, only some of them reach the point where the criminal is actually found guilty. The problem is the judicial system, the police system, the problem is lack of cctv cameras, guards, street lights and what not. And for the judicial system, if we're able to streamline the process, and make sure that right decisions are taken (which is not as easy as it sounds), and the guilty is given proper punishment, people will think twice before committing such crimes.
Nowadays, young girls are engaging in Only-Fans and earning a significant amount of money. Many famous feminists also support this as a means of achieving financial independence for women. Although the production and distribution of pornography are illegal in India, many young girls employed in IT companies and residing in hostels or dormitories create Only-Fans videos part time and earn huge money. Some even get involved in escort services. Personally, I believe that by earning money in this manner, women themselves are responsible for deteriorating their image through these actions. Simultaneously, they force society to perceive other girls similarly, as it becomes challenging to differentiate between them. This is the reason why men on the street make inappropriate propositions. This the the other side of the coin and the root cause. Always blaming men for everything is pathetic.
Yes, in this case he had a well reasoned, thoughtful and fair assessment. However, in the ADM Jabalpur case, he stated that fundamental rights can be suspended under Emergency. Just goes to show that judges are not infallible, have their own biases and agendas. So in a way it also reiterates his point that if left to judges, death sentence would lead to unequal treatment of cases, violating right to equal justice. The justice system is indeed complex.
This is ridiculous. Court is saying death sentence is only awarded in the rarest of the rare cases. Now there is a 24 yr old girl in Kerala who has been awarded death sentence for poisoning her boyfriend. And here this gruesome rape & murder has not been awarded death sentence. What does this imply about Indian society? Does this even make any sense?!
Although I oppose capital punishment, I'm perplexed by the judge's decision that this crime didn't warrant the 'rarest of rare' designation, given the severe injuries revealed in the post-mortem report. These injuries clearly suggest multiple perpetrators were involved. Yet, only one person has been held accountable, and even he will be eligible for release after serving 14 years ( life imprisonment means 14 years I suppose. Correct me if I am wrong). Ideally, he should have received lifelong imprisonment in strict solitary confinement. However the greater tragedy lies in the fact that the influential perpetrators remain free, enjoying impunity. Many individuals have resigned themselves to cynicism, saying, "What did you expect?" Perhaps that's the most pragmatic approach - to abandon hope in societal justice.
Sisters Seema Mohan Gavit and Renuka Kiran Shinde injured the genitals of young boys before murdering them. The Supreme Court pardoned their execution and converted it life sentence.
Very True on the fact almost forgotten, what happened to other rap##sts n butchers. One lone man cannot do so much of physical torture.. But say anything against state or honorable judgment is a Sin
@Team Faye: please explore the option of CHAPTERS in your videos. Such videos are extremely good at informing people because they present current affairs with their historical context. Chapters will help in better recall and referring to the apt location in the video.
As a woman monsters like this being pardoned and being let back into society is a scary thought and looking how things get carried out people who are not awarded a death sentence have every likelihood to escape jail and that is an unsettling thought, so I believe in some cases death sentences should be awarded. Apart from this I think this case has been a miscarriage of justice, all parties involved have not been identified and punished.
Please help Men.. there is genocide on Men going on in India in every house 😢😢 criminal if women are not arrested and becoming serial criminals 😢 help Men 😢😢
I don't understand why still after so many years the laws in india are not made strict . 😢 Since ages we have heard india is a developing country ...still not developed then when ?
Your analysis of the actual ground problem is totally correct. Our government must identify the core minute problems which lead to such heinous crimes in our country. Our judiciary must concentrate on eradicating these problems at a lower level
..........chances still are that it won't be carried out and it will take years and years if at all it is executed......the process in law is such........so many death sentences by lower courts are overturned or even converted to life sentences
His life will be a living hell in prison. Most convicts live by a seemingly twisted moral code. They might be serving time for murder, theft, assault, and other heinous crimes but they all look down on child molesters and rapists…who are considered the absolute bottom of the heap. Some convicts will try to earn brownie points by coming down heavily on a rapist or child molester. Violent beatings are common, and the occasional fatal assault is often covered up or put down as an accident. Remember Ram Singh, the convicted rapist in the Nirbhaya case? He was found mysteriously hanging in his cell. You can guess what happened to him. Plus, jail officials tend to look the other way in such cases. So Sanjay Roy may get some harsh justice handed to him in prison.
You are absolutely right Faye! it’s definitely odd, & especially the way the compensation was decided. Everything is odd about this case and what is sad is no one cares about atrocities caused to women in our country and that these can be compensated with money! Sad indeed. Death sentence is cruel ?! as per the Judge. Seriously? Then, what is rape with broken bones, injury marks, suffocating to death ??? or surviving to live that situation each day dying. Pathetic judiciary system. This country seems hopeless by all means. Not flawed it’s SICK system.
So glad you covered this because it just seemed like no one is talking about it anymore and then justice isn’t getting served. Hope her soul rests in peace 🕊️
That's why in India crime rates are more. The judicial system is supportive to the accused than victim. With all this whatever happened in Hyderabad rape and murder case was best. In countries like the middle East murder is itself is considered as death penalty
Ma'am capital punishment is rare in India. Even if he was sentenced to death he would always hv the right to approach the higher courts..this is what's happening since decades...
This balanced view exposes the gaps in our judicial system where awarding the death sentence is left to the final discretion of the judge. What qualifies as "rarest of the rare " should be clearly outlined and articulated so that justice is served for such cases.
Today's paper had two court verdicts for two heinous crimes causing death of tge victim. One was a male who raped and killed a woman doctor at Kolkata. The other was a young girl poisoning her male friend and killing him. The male accused got a life sentence while the female accused got a death sentence ! How fair is that ? Even in crimes and in court verdicts women are treated unfairly ?
Please don't raise the gender card on everything. Both crimes are brutal. As for Sharon's case, he suffered a most horrible death after being in the hospital for over 11 days. His internal organs were damaged and he was bleeding continuously. He had to undergo dialysis and part of his tongue had come off because of the poison greeshma had given. The poor guy could not even drink water. Even on his deathbed, he tried to protect her until he couldn't. As for greeshma, she didn't seem to have an ounce of remorse about the crime she committed. She had said that she is 24 now and that she will come out by 38 after serving her life sentence. What sets this case apart is that it is not a random murder, but a first degree premeditated senseless murder done for personal gains. Please study the case before arriving at conclusions.
@@elzamathew3846ofcourse after studying still I would say abhaya is not served justice. That man suffered while being taken care but what about the other case? Also there many involved.
The crime rate is increasing because the judiciary is ineffective. The judiciary is ineffective because the number of cases it is handling is high. The number of cases the judiciary is handling is high, because our Police is ineffective. Our Police are ineffective because, the Police positions are held by criminals. The Police positions are held by criminals because our recruitment system is faulty as only those candidates willing to pay a bribe for the job(crime) are recruited. Our recruitment system is faulty because it is designed by our politicians. Our Politicians design a faulty recruitment system, as they are criminals. Our Politicians are criminals, because the majority of the people elect them. The majority of the people elect criminals as their representatives, as they themselves lack morals.
U missed something ! Our police to civilians ratio contributes to the crimes, the police in major cities are overworked and that often leads to inefficiency.
This is really a very sad assessment of India as a functional democracy! I believe this is needlessly harsh. Elections are being routinely engineered hence outcomes are not really indicative of the people's will.
The lawyer has actually disgraced the case by calling it not a rarest of the rarest case... We must not trust our law anymore.. We must not send our daughtets to any government institution.. Teach our
Justice is denied because both state and central government tried to save someone/some people that are somehow linked and connected to both governments. The same reason the criminal could avoid death sentence. Criminals are more valued than an army of doctors in our new India.
Well analysed. The case can definitely be moved to the higher courts unless the prosecutors and/or defendants do not file an appeal. Has there been a move for an appeal, especially when there is such a public outcry? Another reason to keep the convicted alive is to appear as witness increminating any others who are also party to the crime. Sadly, none of the others remanded have been so far charged for even abetment or any other offence!
Absolutely correct assessment Fayed 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽🙌🏼🙌🏼. I was afraid that your video will go down the route of asking for capital punshment in this case. Honestly, if we take a step back and look properly at all the factors responsible for horrible crimes like this one happening, there would be consequences for many more in society, including the government and hospital authorities. We also really need to be educated, as a public, on ethical problems and concerns that arise from the ‘call for blood’. It’s incredible to me that a democratic country like India, still hasn’t abolished the death penalty altogether. As a parent, as a woman, as a working woman, I won’t be satisfied until change happens at the societal level including reduction in mysogyny, equality in workplaces, a government committed to and responsible for safe public spaces and effective policing.
@chandrashekharpadala8242 How ? Nirbhaya's rapists were hanged after 8 years, mind you that was the fastest justice, after multiple hearings from lower to high to supreme court, review petition, mercy petitions.
Even if he got the death sentence what will change, the parents have lost their daughter and there is going to be no change in society after this incident hundreds of girls are raped every day and no one can do anything even while watching this vedio is some part of India and girls is being harresed as we speak 😢
Justice never changes.Judge alone changed justice from state to state for the same crime committed. In Kerala State justice is offered as death sentence. In West Bengal state, justice is delivered as life imprisonment. But the crimes committed are one and the same. People lost faith in court.
Thanks a lot for this important video. Our judicial system and the police need to work out very systematically without the political influence at all. We need to encourage everyone to approach the police station without fear but unfortunately sometimes they are the main cause as well. Really don't know how long it will take to punish the right person. Sometimes innocent people are just lingering behind the big walls. 😢😢😢
Rare-est of rare has a flip side consequence If you don't treat the first "rare-est of rare" case adequately, it has the consequence of normalization And that's something we would never want in the society, and rightly as you said, if we cannot bring peace through justice? It's flawed from the core
Not for the death penalty. Have read about so many people being acquitted because they were found innocent later especially due to advancements in forensic science. In this case, still not convinced he was the only perpetrator.
Capital punishment is hardly a deterrent to rape. Look around you!And then there's the political class. Just last year the rapists/killers of the utterly gruesome Kamduni case were SET FREE by Kolkata high court even after being given death penalty by the lower court. Mamta's police made sure that there were not enough evidence for the death penalty to hold. Here too, Mamta shrieking "fansi chai" is the biggest joke since it was her government police and health dept that destroyed all evidence and are still sheltering the culprits. Sanjoy ray was just a very convenient pawn in the whole scheme of things. Won't be shocked if he walks free after moving to the higher courts.
Yup that's what this guy isn't the only culprit..... definitely not the main one.....the investigation on this case shouldn't be done with..... otherwise the actual culprits would be allowed to live freely without facing any consequences for such a heinous crime.
You have hit the nail on the head. I agree the judiciary and the police along with the politicians need to be more transparent and show some will on cleaning our (obviously) not good enough system. If the system is good and transparent, I am sure judiciary will never be giving death sentence since they have full information and no doubt is there in a judges mind when he is giving out the verdict. The reason that politicians are screaming for death penalty is to shut the case down..any case, after which everyone is stoic and silenced with lingering doubt that was this true?!!. Our system is always in search of a scape goat and not the truth. A temporary fix. That's exactly the reason the death penalty acts as a double edged knife. We all know our country may never be good enough for the removal of death penalty.
The Judge of Sealdah Court was very prudent in sentencing Sanjay Rai with life imprisonment and not with capital punishment, knowing fully well that he may not be the real culprit. So that if ever the real criminals are found,there is some scope of redress. The CFSL and DNA reports indicate more are involved, with no comments from CBI.. Trial had been started without the visera report for unknown reasons. CBI has been vocal and proactive ,demanding capital punishment to Sanjay, but did not show such proactiveness in the investigation process and has failed to identify and book the real culprits and the mastermind, for whatever reasons. The lower court also pointed out to the lapses of the premier investigating agency. CBI is yet to disclose the status reports submitted by them at SC, reading which ex CJI and another Judge had commented it is very disturbing and that he has not seen such lapses on the part of kolkata police in 30 years of practice.
Has he been convicted without a shadow of a doubt even then there are many speculations about this particular incident about more people involved in this case?
Court cannot demarcate the rarest of rare case in a watertight compartment. Cases depend on the facts. Also, a judge should not get swayed by the media and hand out a death sentence. Such cases often have a scapegoat victim because the media coverage led to public outcry and the police had to put the blame on someone. This is how the police works in India. (I am not saying he is not the rapist, just that you can never be sure w the indian police)
In my opinion, remove the death sentence and shift to life sentences because the justice system can be biased in reality. Streamline grass roots notifying and addressing abuse of any form where the process of filing complaints are digitised and followed up by a competent support team. Have strong awareness programs in our education system and counsellors established in schools that can detect and guide individuals. The govt. also can subsidise equipment’s related to security that can further reduce inaccuracies and process cases faster at the lower level. Define some guidelines in terms of a warning and fine for people sitting in positions of responsibility and visibility who mobilises the masses for a negative intent.
There is no such thing as a perfect system - every system is fallible. The reversal argument is bogus. For example, if someone commits a crime that gives him two years imprisonment, and only after the completion of his sentence he is able prove his innocence, then also the punishment cannot be reversed. Should we try to build a system that gives better protection to people and also the innocent accused ? Yes. Can we afford it? that is not so certain. Justice and policing is expensive and the country needs to balance this need with other things that it has to do. On the other hand, no nation in the world is immune to large scale corruption by politicians, we just have to live with it. It is the job of the public to ask for the things they care about during elections - the public gets what they prioritise in a democracy. Would your vote change based on how the punishment is given in certain types of cases? If not, it will never be on the radar of any politician.
India needs Islamic law for rape, murder and corruption...which have become a menace for the country... Andh bhakts and Islamic haters might be triggered with my comment😂😂😂
Women often talk about men having all the power, money, and control, oppressing women. However, it is important to note that this perception confuses a small percentage of wealthy men with the majority of men who struggle. Most men have no money, no power, no sex from their wife, and face difficulties in court battles, even losing their homes and the chance to see their children. Their lives are challenging. The truth is - ~When a man earns he takes the responsibilities of family. When an women earns she becomes independent. ~When a man earns he may pick a no-earning women and makes her life-partner. When a woman earns she reject a men. ~A strong man can pick broken women and make her life strong. Strong women don’t look after broken men. While men share money, properties on divorce....but women share nothing...this is our well educated law makers we believe in.
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
It’s shocking how intentional rap* and planned m*rder are too common to fall under rarest of rare cases in India
Our legal system does not care about victims life, the person is dead and they are worried about well being of the of convict! What a shame!
this is wretched land of india
When the girl lost her innocent, promising life, the guilty criminal should have no right to life either. Besides, life imprisonment is a sham. He'll get out of prison in no time, as has happened so often. Remember the case of Aruna Shanbaug? She remained in a vegetative state for more than 40 years before dying in 2015 while the accused was released after a mere term of 7 years. He is still alive, married and has kids. What justice are we even talking about?
Very true unfortunately 😢😢😢
It is unlikely a guy like him is gonna reform, and it is a waste of taxpayers’ money to feed and shelter him for life.
So many men have lost their lives
Idiots
"Creating fear among criminals is better than, building fear among innocents"...and some judgements need to be made to let the severity be known of what's the rarest of rare!
That's what we all believed after the Nirbaya case
I feel, the entire judicial system in India is very subjective and unfair when it comes to women, or minorities as well. There are hundreds examples for this. Its high time someone sits down and draw out laws to account for indecent exposure, eve teasing and more.
@@bhavxyz i think they do acknowledge it . They just don't care
True
This was really enlightening.
The same day RGKar rape case verdict came as life sentence, death sentence was awarded to a female in sharon murder case in Kerala. So now i understand that its the subjective difference between two judges bt doesnt this kind of imply tht a woman getting brutally raped and murdered is not so rare in our country tht nobody should be so shocked as to demand a death sentence?
What a balanced and informed view! Very insightful that less than 5% of death sentences from 2000-2015 were actually upheld. Also interesting to know that we have ~100 cases every year which are judged as rarest of rare and sentenced with death penalties!
you're right Faye, very odd to have compensation for the victim's family rather than a detailed investigation. Thank you for sharing a balanced view
Ma'am, you have so well articulated. No shouting no screaming as with others
as a 17 year old, with the limited knowledge that i have, i'd just say, death sentence or not should not be the question. the real problem is the fact that so many of these crimes happen and most of them aren't even reported. Out of the ones that are reported, only some of them reach the point where the criminal is actually found guilty. The problem is the judicial system, the police system, the problem is lack of cctv cameras, guards, street lights and what not. And for the judicial system, if we're able to streamline the process, and make sure that right decisions are taken (which is not as easy as it sounds), and the guilty is given proper punishment, people will think twice before committing such crimes.
Nowadays, young girls are engaging in Only-Fans and earning a significant amount of money. Many famous feminists also support this as a means of achieving financial independence for women. Although the production and distribution of pornography are illegal in India, many young girls employed in IT companies and residing in hostels or dormitories create Only-Fans videos part time and earn huge money. Some even get involved in escort services. Personally, I believe that by earning money in this manner, women themselves are responsible for deteriorating their image through these actions. Simultaneously, they force society to perceive other girls similarly, as it becomes challenging to differentiate between them. This is the reason why men on the street make inappropriate propositions. This the the other side of the coin and the root cause. Always blaming men for everything is pathetic.
Kudos to that one judge who took their time to deconstruct capital punishment.
Yes, in this case he had a well reasoned, thoughtful and fair assessment. However, in the ADM Jabalpur case, he stated that fundamental rights can be suspended under Emergency. Just goes to show that judges are not infallible, have their own biases and agendas. So in a way it also reiterates his point that if left to judges, death sentence would lead to unequal treatment of cases, violating right to equal justice. The justice system is indeed complex.
This is ridiculous. Court is saying death sentence is only awarded in the rarest of the rare cases. Now there is a 24 yr old girl in Kerala who has been awarded death sentence for poisoning her boyfriend. And here this gruesome rape & murder has not been awarded death sentence. What does this imply about Indian society? Does this even make any sense?!
Although I oppose capital punishment, I'm perplexed by the judge's decision that this crime didn't warrant the 'rarest of rare' designation, given the severe injuries revealed in the post-mortem report. These injuries clearly suggest multiple perpetrators were involved. Yet, only one person has been held accountable, and even he will be eligible for release after serving 14 years ( life imprisonment means 14 years I suppose. Correct me if I am wrong). Ideally, he should have received lifelong imprisonment in strict solitary confinement.
However the greater tragedy lies in the fact that the influential perpetrators remain free, enjoying impunity. Many individuals have resigned themselves to cynicism, saying, "What did you expect?" Perhaps that's the most pragmatic approach - to abandon hope in societal justice.
He was given life imprisonment not for 14 years . He will be imprisoned for life.
Sisters Seema Mohan Gavit and Renuka Kiran Shinde injured the genitals of young boys before murdering them. The Supreme Court pardoned their execution and converted it life sentence.
Very True on the fact almost forgotten, what happened to other rap##sts n butchers. One lone man cannot do so much of physical torture.. But say anything against state or honorable judgment is a Sin
Very well analysed.
First view... always on time when u bring any video. More Power!!
@Team Faye: please explore the option of CHAPTERS in your videos. Such videos are extremely good at informing people because they present current affairs with their historical context. Chapters will help in better recall and referring to the apt location in the video.
As a woman monsters like this being pardoned and being let back into society is a scary thought and looking how things get carried out people who are not awarded a death sentence have every likelihood to escape jail and that is an unsettling thought, so I believe in some cases death sentences should be awarded. Apart from this I think this case has been a miscarriage of justice, all parties involved have not been identified and punished.
@@preyranamishra5265 moreover when a culprit like Sanjay has no remorse for his crime
Please help Men.. there is genocide on Men going on in India in every house 😢😢 criminal if women are not arrested and becoming serial criminals 😢 help Men 😢😢
I feel this guy is a scapegoat.
Are you crazy? Overacting.@@jungleking9
I don't understand why still after so many years the laws in india are not made strict . 😢 Since ages we have heard india is a developing country ...still not developed then when ?
Your analysis of the actual ground problem is totally correct. Our government must identify the core minute problems which lead to such heinous crimes in our country. Our judiciary must concentrate on eradicating these problems at a lower level
What an amazing opinion completely agree! Again my fav journalist ❤
A woman was given death sentence in Kerala today for poisoning and killing her boyfriend
..........chances still are that it won't be carried out and it will take years and years if at all it is executed......the process in law is such........so many death sentences by lower courts are overturned or even converted to life sentences
Very analytical Faye
His life will be a living hell in prison. Most convicts live by a seemingly twisted moral code. They might be serving time for murder, theft, assault, and other heinous crimes but they all look down on child molesters and rapists…who are considered the absolute bottom of the heap. Some convicts will try to earn brownie points by coming down heavily on a rapist or child molester. Violent beatings are common, and the occasional fatal assault is often covered up or put down as an accident. Remember Ram Singh, the convicted rapist in the Nirbhaya case? He was found mysteriously hanging in his cell. You can guess what happened to him. Plus, jail officials tend to look the other way in such cases. So Sanjay Roy may get some harsh justice handed to him in prison.
Yes. This is what came to my mind when I heard of his imprisonment for life.
basically telling the convicts and accused to step up their game.
atul subhash will not get justice...
rg kar victim will not get justice...
but law will protect nikita AND PEOPLE like sanjay
🤡🤡🤡indiAn judiciary laws
You are absolutely right Faye!
it’s definitely odd, & especially the way the compensation was decided.
Everything is odd about this case and what is sad is no one cares about atrocities caused to women in our country and that these can be compensated with money! Sad indeed.
Death sentence is cruel ?! as per the Judge. Seriously?
Then, what is rape with broken bones, injury marks, suffocating to death ??? or surviving to live that situation each day dying.
Pathetic judiciary system.
This country seems hopeless by all means.
Not flawed it’s SICK system.
Great report mam thank you
So glad you covered this because it just seemed like no one is talking about it anymore and then justice isn’t getting served.
Hope her soul rests in peace 🕊️
That's why in India crime rates are more. The judicial system is supportive to the accused than victim.
With all this whatever happened in Hyderabad rape and murder case was best.
In countries like the middle East murder is itself is considered as death penalty
Ma'am capital punishment is rare in India. Even if he was sentenced to death he would always hv the right to approach the higher courts..this is what's happening since decades...
This balanced view exposes the gaps in our judicial system where awarding the death sentence is left to the final discretion of the judge. What qualifies as "rarest of the rare " should be clearly outlined and articulated so that justice is served for such cases.
Today's paper had two court verdicts for two heinous crimes causing death of tge victim. One was a male who raped and killed a woman doctor at Kolkata. The other was a young girl poisoning her male friend and killing him. The male accused got a life sentence while the female accused got a death sentence ! How fair is that ? Even in crimes and in court verdicts women are treated unfairly ?
Dont add unnecessary dimensions. It's not male vs female. There are other factors
Don’t make false equivalence.
Please don't raise the gender card on everything. Both crimes are brutal. As for Sharon's case, he suffered a most horrible death after being in the hospital for over 11 days. His internal organs were damaged and he was bleeding continuously. He had to undergo dialysis and part of his tongue had come off because of the poison greeshma had given. The poor guy could not even drink water. Even on his deathbed, he tried to protect her until he couldn't. As for greeshma, she didn't seem to have an ounce of remorse about the crime she committed. She had said that she is 24 now and that she will come out by 38 after serving her life sentence. What sets this case apart is that it is not a random murder, but a first degree premeditated senseless murder done for personal gains. Please study the case before arriving at conclusions.
@@elzamathew3846ofcourse after studying still I would say abhaya is not served justice. That man suffered while being taken care but what about the other case? Also there many involved.
Capital Punishment is Revenge & Not justice. Capital Punishment has Not Stopped Heinous Crime. Capital Punishment Must be Abolished.
We need more educated people to vote for educated and honest ministers who can make and implement better policies!
The crime rate is increasing because the judiciary is ineffective. The judiciary is ineffective because the number of cases it is handling is high. The number of cases the judiciary is handling is high, because our Police is ineffective. Our Police are ineffective because, the Police positions are held by criminals. The Police positions are held by criminals because our recruitment system is faulty as only those candidates willing to pay a bribe for the job(crime) are recruited. Our recruitment system is faulty because it is designed by our politicians. Our Politicians design a faulty recruitment system, as they are criminals. Our Politicians are criminals, because the majority of the people elect them. The majority of the people elect criminals as their representatives, as they themselves lack morals.
@@sydneygracias44 Fantastic! Ha ha ha ha 😂 😆 😄 🤣
U missed something ! Our police to civilians ratio contributes to the crimes, the police in major cities are overworked and that often leads to inefficiency.
This is really a very sad assessment of India as a functional democracy! I believe this is needlessly harsh. Elections are being routinely engineered hence outcomes are not really indicative of the people's will.
The lawyer has actually disgraced the case by calling it not a rarest of the rarest case...
We must not trust our law anymore.. We must not send our daughtets to any government institution.. Teach our
Justice is denied because both state and central government tried to save someone/some people that are somehow linked and connected to both governments. The same reason the criminal could avoid death sentence. Criminals are more valued than an army of doctors in our new India.
Well analysed. The case can definitely be moved to the higher courts unless the prosecutors and/or defendants do not file an appeal. Has there been a move for an appeal, especially when there is such a public outcry? Another reason to keep the convicted alive is to appear as witness increminating any others who are also party to the crime. Sadly, none of the others remanded have been so far charged for even abetment or any other offence!
Great. A journalist i truly respect
Very informative
Thanks Faye
Very nicely explained and well structured video. Thankyou!
It is unlikely a guy like him is gonna reform, and it is a waste of taxpayers’ money to feed and shelter him for life.
Absolutely correct assessment Fayed 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽🙌🏼🙌🏼. I was afraid that your video will go down the route of asking for capital punshment in this case. Honestly, if we take a step back and look properly at all the factors responsible for horrible crimes like this one happening, there would be consequences for many more in society, including the government and hospital authorities. We also really need to be educated, as a public, on ethical problems and concerns that arise from the ‘call for blood’. It’s incredible to me that a democratic country like India, still hasn’t abolished the death penalty altogether. As a parent, as a woman, as a working woman, I won’t be satisfied until change happens at the societal level including reduction in mysogyny, equality in workplaces, a government committed to and responsible for safe public spaces and effective policing.
The fact that the case does not seem RARE according to the judge is just disgusting and sad
Justice denied ??? 💯💯💯
The only true form of Justice is Eye for an Eye.
Sometimes it could be somebody else's eye.......
@chandrashekharpadala8242 How ? Nirbhaya's rapists were hanged after 8 years, mind you that was the fastest justice, after multiple hearings from lower to high to supreme court, review petition, mercy petitions.
*"City of Psychos"*
There is much more to this, scam cover up is successfully done with the facade of heinous crime
This does not categorised under wise judgement what court chosen to do so.
Brilliantly explained Faye! Love the way you speak. So very opposite to Arnab Goswami's obnoxious style
Did the Kolkata court have doubts that he was not the real culprit?
The behaviour of the state government was questionable in the whole episode.
Faye De Souza your topic is of no use to women safety, a better title would be "Where are the other KILLLERS ? " lets get them behind bars.
Death sentence is too lenient. Life sentence is harsh.
Lol what is a rarest of rare crime then... the sentence is a joke
Edit: "Sentence" is the punishment from the court, not the other sentence.
Watch the entire video before commenting
@Madhusree1293 i did... if this isn't a rare crime, what is.... the court should clarify this. Which is why the sentencing is a joke.
Even if he got the death sentence what will change, the parents have lost their daughter and there is going to be no change in society after this incident hundreds of girls are raped every day and no one can do anything even while watching this vedio is some part of India and girls is being harresed as we speak 😢
There are many cases where death penalties have been reversed. Ref DARA SINGH
Justice never changes.Judge alone changed justice from state to state for the same crime committed.
In Kerala State justice is offered as death sentence.
In West Bengal state, justice is delivered as life imprisonment.
But the crimes committed are one and the same.
People lost faith in court.
Thanks a lot for this important video.
Our judicial system and the police need to work out very systematically without the political influence at all.
We need to encourage everyone to approach the police station without fear but unfortunately sometimes they are the main cause as well. Really don't know how long it will take to punish the right person. Sometimes innocent people are just lingering behind the big walls. 😢😢😢
Then WHAT IS RAREST OF RARE?
Watch the entire video before commenting
Rare-est of rare has a flip side consequence
If you don't treat the first "rare-est of rare" case adequately, it has the consequence of normalization
And that's something we would never want in the society, and rightly as you said, if we cannot bring peace through justice? It's flawed from the core
Theatrics is the only thing all political parties in our country is good at and absolutely nothing else
Not for the death penalty. Have read about so many people being acquitted because they were found innocent later especially due to advancements in forensic science. In this case, still not convinced he was the only perpetrator.
Capital punishment is hardly a deterrent to rape. Look around you!And then there's the political class. Just last year the rapists/killers of the utterly gruesome Kamduni case were SET FREE by Kolkata high court even after being given death penalty by the lower court. Mamta's police made sure that there were not enough evidence for the death penalty to hold. Here too, Mamta shrieking "fansi chai" is the biggest joke since it was her government police and health dept that destroyed all evidence and are still sheltering the culprits. Sanjoy ray was just a very convenient pawn in the whole scheme of things. Won't be shocked if he walks free after moving to the higher courts.
Yup that's what this guy isn't the only culprit..... definitely not the main one.....the investigation on this case shouldn't be done with..... otherwise the actual culprits would be allowed to live freely without facing any consequences for such a heinous crime.
Please add captions to the video
You have hit the nail on the head. I agree the judiciary and the police along with the politicians need to be more transparent and show some will on cleaning our (obviously) not good enough system. If the system is good and transparent, I am sure judiciary will never be giving death sentence since they have full information and no doubt is there in a judges mind when he is giving out the verdict. The reason that politicians are screaming for death penalty is to shut the case down..any case, after which everyone is stoic and silenced with lingering doubt that was this true?!!. Our system is always in search of a scape goat and not the truth. A temporary fix. That's exactly the reason the death penalty acts as a double edged knife. We all know our country may never be good enough for the removal of death penalty.
The Judge of Sealdah Court was very prudent in sentencing Sanjay Rai with life imprisonment and not with capital punishment, knowing fully well that he may not be the real culprit.
So that if ever the real criminals are found,there is some scope of redress. The CFSL and DNA reports indicate more are involved, with no comments from CBI.. Trial had been started without the visera report for unknown reasons. CBI has been vocal and proactive ,demanding capital punishment to Sanjay, but did not show such proactiveness in the investigation process and has failed to identify and book the real culprits and the mastermind, for whatever reasons.
The lower court also pointed out to the lapses of the premier investigating agency. CBI is yet to disclose the status reports submitted by them at SC, reading which ex CJI and another Judge had commented it is very disturbing and that he has not seen such lapses on the part of kolkata police in 30 years of practice.
Men ☕
Wasn't this case already at SC?
Has he been convicted without a shadow of a doubt even then there are many speculations about this particular incident about more people involved in this case?
It's not Roy!! It's Rai!! Not expected from u at all.
Mam please speak up for Athl Subhash.. this is a much bigger problem as lakhs of Men are getting abused daily in every house 😢😢 please save Men 😢
Court cannot demarcate the rarest of rare case in a watertight compartment. Cases depend on the facts. Also, a judge should not get swayed by the media and hand out a death sentence. Such cases often have a scapegoat victim because the media coverage led to public outcry and the police had to put the blame on someone. This is how the police works in India. (I am not saying he is not the rapist, just that you can never be sure w the indian police)
In my opinion, remove the death sentence and shift to life sentences because the justice system can be biased in reality.
Streamline grass roots notifying and addressing abuse of any form where the process of filing complaints are digitised and followed up by a competent support team.
Have strong awareness programs in our education system and counsellors established in schools that can detect and guide individuals.
The govt. also can subsidise equipment’s related to security that can further reduce inaccuracies and process cases faster at the lower level.
Define some guidelines in terms of a warning and fine for people sitting in positions of responsibility and visibility who mobilises the masses for a negative intent.
No death sentence
There is no such thing as a perfect system - every system is fallible. The reversal argument is bogus. For example, if someone commits a crime that gives him two years imprisonment, and only after the completion of his sentence he is able prove his innocence, then also the punishment cannot be reversed. Should we try to build a system that gives better protection to people and also the innocent accused ? Yes. Can we afford it? that is not so certain. Justice and policing is expensive and the country needs to balance this need with other things that it has to do. On the other hand, no nation in the world is immune to large scale corruption by politicians, we just have to live with it. It is the job of the public to ask for the things they care about during elections - the public gets what they prioritise in a democracy. Would your vote change based on how the punishment is given in certain types of cases? If not, it will never be on the radar of any politician.
PUBLIC SHOULD REPEAT ITS ACTIVITY. WHAT NONSENSE IS THIS? RAPING AT WORK PLACE IS NOT RAREST OF RARE?
Remember Atul Subhash
😂😂😂
Faye mam did you follow the Nagpur case, muder of Girlfriend because of no return on debt of 4.5 lakh.
I salute the judge
Of course its not fair..mamta ji is right..
Well becoz sum IPS is involved..how can justice be dun?😢😢😢😢😢
All a setup between CBI and centeral govt
India needs Islamic law for rape, murder and corruption...which have become a menace for the country...
Andh bhakts and Islamic haters might be triggered with my comment😂😂😂
𝕋𝕙𝕒𝕟𝕜 𝕪𝕠𝕦 🙏
Stupid case.
❤very handsome look.
Women often talk about men having all the power, money, and control, oppressing women. However, it is important to note that this perception confuses a small percentage of wealthy men with the majority of men who struggle. Most men have no money, no power, no sex from their wife, and face difficulties in court battles, even losing their homes and the chance to see their children. Their lives are challenging.
The truth is -
~When a man earns he takes the responsibilities of family. When an women earns she becomes independent.
~When a man earns he may pick a no-earning women and makes her life-partner. When a woman earns she reject a men.
~A strong man can pick broken women and make her life strong. Strong women don’t look after broken men.
While men share money, properties on divorce....but women share nothing...this is our well educated law makers we believe in.
And how is your (dumb) comment relevant to the RG Kar case ?
Kaise aurat hai yarr , Mamta. Chee
Death penalty is not the answer. justice diesnot mean revenge. dont forgot Dhanjay chettrjii death sentence in fake rape case.
are u suggesting that this is a fake rape case? Since this case is proven not to be false why not death penality?