Is Taiwan a country or part of China answered once and for all.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
  • Excerpt from CGTN America
    • The Heat: Xi-Biden tal...
    The Heat : Xi-Biden talks and 9/11 : 20 years on

Комментарии • 196

  • @oxvendivil442
    @oxvendivil442 3 года назад +23

    It doesn't take an aerospace engineer or rocket scientist to understand that there is only inevitably one CHINA and that reunification will happen sooner or later; the earlier people come to terms with it, the better and easier the transition would be.

    • @xander2890
      @xander2890 3 года назад +4

      It's also true that even the dumbest person would recognise Taiwanese would not want to be enslaved by CCP dictatorship. They'd rather fight hard if they're invaded.

    • @francissantos7448
      @francissantos7448 3 года назад +2

      Hello Ox. It looks like later. Much later. Much Much later. And to the majority of Taiwanese, never. CCP China has the will, even with nuclear weapons, to forcibly reunite Taiwan to the mainland. I think the only way to militarily succeed is to turn the surface of Taiwan to nuclear rubble before sending its invasion army. Otherwise it is impossible to overwhelm Taiwan without the world reacting unfavorably to CCP China.

    • @onghockchwee2342
      @onghockchwee2342 2 года назад

      @@francissantos7448
      China Does Not Believe In Using Nuclear Weapons On Fellow Chinese. Both Countries Have Same Founding Father. Both Are like A Family. Bigger Brother Want To Unite As One Big Family. Foreigners With No More Family Values Left Will Never Understand What It Is To Be A Family.

    • @francissantos7448
      @francissantos7448 2 года назад

      @@onghockchwee2342 hello Ong. I hope you are right about use of nuclear weapons in the Taiwan issue, family or not family.

    • @ZHD1987E
      @ZHD1987E Год назад

      Ahem…
      Taiwan now wants to militarise itself. To repel any reunification.
      Heck, China once tried to reunify through non-violent tactics, it failed.

  • @88eclhome71
    @88eclhome71 3 года назад +19

    When the communist defeated the Kuomintang during the civil war in China, the Kuomintang fled to Taiwan taking a lot of the China treasures with them. The Communist party was stopped by the US navy at the time due to their lack of war ships. The Kuomintang had hope one day to reclaim back China. So the Kuomintang were from China, even now many of the people still have relatives in China.

    • @richarde.halliburton8022
      @richarde.halliburton8022 3 года назад +2

      All true but the majority of the population in Taiwan are descendants of the people who lived there for generations. Even a majority of the descendants of those who came here with the ROC government now define themselves as Taiwanese rather than Chinese.

    • @uggguuuuu
      @uggguuuuu 3 года назад +2

      @@richarde.halliburton8022ROC = Republic of CHINA
      The whole defining themselves as "Taiwanese" is a political statement now anyway - If you look at wikipedia, people who have always defined themselves as "Chinese-Americans" are now categorized as "Taiwanese-Americans" for some reason.

    • @xander2890
      @xander2890 3 года назад +1

      But KMT is just a diminishing opposition in Taiwan. Even a fool would understand KMT can't represent the Taiwan people.

    • @francissantos7448
      @francissantos7448 3 года назад +2

      @@richarde.halliburton8022 that's true. The generation born after the military hostilities have ended are now senior citizens. The soldiers who survived the war are fading away. The one China concept is going to get old and die and 2 Chinas will continue to exist.

    • @PolarTw
      @PolarTw 2 года назад +1

      Relatives means nothing. Same "people" go out and form new countries all the time. Australia, Canada, US all came from UK but are their own countries

  • @R4x0
    @R4x0 3 года назад +7

    The sneaky aspect of the US is in its wording, the term "acknowledge", it's merely denotes taking notice but neither accept not deny it. It sounds like a yes to some but not really.
    The proper diplomatic term to fully endorse a status is "recognise".

    • @scalarnai
      @scalarnai 3 года назад +1

      Biden has reaffirmed ie recognised that Taiwan is part of China....end of anymore confusion.

    • @R4x0
      @R4x0 3 года назад +1

      @@scalarnai From what VIctor is saying, Biden "reaffirms that the US acknowledges....." which is back to my point. I'd be very surprised if the US ever would "recognise" the situation.

    • @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052
      @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052 3 года назад +1

      @@R4x0 US already recognize Taiwan as territory of china under the japanese instrument of surrendered sign in 1945. No need for another recognition.

    • @francissantos7448
      @francissantos7448 3 года назад

      @@proudoverseachineseofsinga3052 That's true. And it is so with 195 or so countries in the world. The most important people to ask, though, are the Taiwanese people. I don't think they want to be another Hongkong.

    • @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052
      @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052 3 года назад

      @@francissantos7448 So I wonder when the intruders settle on your land, will you give them free land when they want your land? Maybe you would, but china won't.

  • @jeffreylee6388
    @jeffreylee6388 2 года назад +2

    Taiwan is like an organ, (formed from the blood and tears) of a part of China. Until today, that chord is still not detached. Building bridges from both sides is better than sending battle ships.

  • @MrGanbat84
    @MrGanbat84 2 года назад +6

    Love whole China from SKorea. We need to be strong together 👏👏🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷. I always studying about China history and culture that shows all aspect it is great nation and peaceful. I am so proud of China. I live in Busan city Republic of Korea but really like Sino culture. 👍🧧

    • @bigmedge
      @bigmedge 2 года назад

      Yep , peaceful enough to starve over 40 million of its own people to death during the great leap forward 🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️🤡🤡🤡🤡

  • @francissantos7448
    @francissantos7448 3 года назад +2

    The people to ask wether they are part of China or an independent entity are the Taiwanese from East Taiwan, not West Taiwan.

    • @xander2890
      @xander2890 3 года назад

      台独=西台湾独立🤣🤣

  • @TAIWANPARTOFCHINA
    @TAIWANPARTOFCHINA 3 года назад +12

    ONE CHINA POLICY ☝️🇨🇳😎
    NO COUNTRY NAME TAIWAN ITS ONLY PROVINCE

    • @richarde.halliburton8022
      @richarde.halliburton8022 3 года назад +3

      I agree - Taiwan is a province of the Republic of China.

    • @francissantos7448
      @francissantos7448 3 года назад

      @@richarde.halliburton8022 I also agree. An independent province of China. Even CCP can exist with the permission of the Taiwanese people.

    • @ly8370
      @ly8370 2 года назад +1

      @@richarde.halliburton8022 in your dream forever. 🤣

    • @ly8370
      @ly8370 2 года назад

      @@francissantos7448 permission of the taiwan provincial people? You get your head checked?

    • @francissantos7448
      @francissantos7448 2 года назад

      @@ly8370 hello LY. My head is just fine. How about yours? How is it that CCP doesn't exist in Taiwan? Maybe because Taiwanese do not want it in Taiwan?

  • @asahiglass
    @asahiglass 3 года назад +5

    The day that what the USA can dictate and define what is a country or what should a country do are numbered

    • @milaapotinpsychimou1274
      @milaapotinpsychimou1274 2 года назад

      Yup, and CCP is so eager to take that place.

    • @asahiglass
      @asahiglass 2 года назад +2

      @@milaapotinpsychimou1274 said 2 weeks cia pennies paid account LOL

  • @gytan2221
    @gytan2221 2 года назад +2

    Stop pushing propaganda lol... it’s not your job

  • @tonbopro
    @tonbopro 3 года назад +3

    no need to patronise 1450s or Green bloods lah,thx for the clip bro

  • @RLDenham
    @RLDenham 3 года назад

    Lol Taiwan is China's version of Germany'sv Sudetenland

  • @milaapotinpsychimou1274
    @milaapotinpsychimou1274 2 года назад

    People who say they're answering a controversial topic "once and for all" are usually because they're afraid of any legit debate.

    • @NoelLee89
      @NoelLee89  2 года назад +2

      Or because the facts are so stark that any debate is senseless and stupid.

  • @wyodragon4325
    @wyodragon4325 3 года назад +2

    Free Hawaii. Kick the squatters out of Diego Garcia.

  • @sigillum_diaboli6668
    @sigillum_diaboli6668 3 года назад +3

    So it proves it only from a PRC viewpoint. My viewpoint is otherwise

    • @NoelLee89
      @NoelLee89  3 года назад +5

      Are you freaking kidding me Hayley?
      Your President Biden said it himself.
      Goodness freak'in gracious
      Such denial.
      Alright, just for your, Taiwan is country.

    • @tonbopro
      @tonbopro 3 года назад +3

      @@NoelLee89 no need to do this, bro you did your best

    • @richarde.halliburton8022
      @richarde.halliburton8022 3 года назад +1

      I agree with Hayley Rule - Taiwan is a country - the name of its government is the Republic of China, established in 1911. The fact that it’s not diplomatically recognized by most other governments doesn’t change this fact. You can’t make something that exists disappear just by insisting and declaring it so.
      Some might find it interesting that up until 1945, the Communist Party of China officially supported Taiwan independence. Check it out, it’s there in the annals of CCP history (of course it’s been purged from the PRC’s history books, but you can find it elsewhere).

    • @R4x0
      @R4x0 3 года назад

      @@richarde.halliburton8022 I would love to see this purged evidence. Even if it does exist in the way you portrayed it, it would be irrelevant. That was then, this is now.

    • @NoelLee89
      @NoelLee89  3 года назад +3

      @@richarde.halliburton8022 you can also type whatever you want doesn’t change the fact that Taiwan is a renegade province of China 🇨🇳 .

  • @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052
    @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052 3 года назад

    Someone from 🐸 island try to distort the facts and legal basis of the treaty with subjective claims like "Diewanese want to be independence blah,blah,blah" but now he got debunked with the actual statements. This prove his wisdom.🤣🤣🤣

    • @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052
      @proudoverseachineseofsinga3052 3 года назад

      @RichieChong Chong "I will protect diewan with my life but I don't want to get conscripted." So funny.🤣🤣🤣

    • @ly8370
      @ly8370 2 года назад

      @RichieChong Chong already some 1450 bots are here. 😁😁

  • @utopia6403
    @utopia6403 3 года назад +2

    Its a country but due to politics everybody pretends its not..

    • @NoelLee89
      @NoelLee89  3 года назад +2

      No it’s not a country, thanks

    • @R4x0
      @R4x0 3 года назад +1

      It is factually a "country" but not a sovereign state. "Country" is a very loose and ambiguous term, "sovereign state" however, is a clearly defined legal term, something Taiwan isn't.

    • @tonyho5827
      @tonyho5827 3 года назад +1

      Taiwan is one of provinces of China. It is not a country itself .

    • @richarde.halliburton8022
      @richarde.halliburton8022 3 года назад +3

      @@R4x0 The bottom line is, Taiwan is whatever the people of Taiwan, collectively, say it is. They have the sole right to determine their own future, not some outsiders. And they are willing and prepared to defend that right.

    • @R4x0
      @R4x0 3 года назад +1

      @@richarde.halliburton8022 wrong, if that is the case then there would be far more than 200 countries in the world.