Electric vs CNG vs Petrol With Tata Tigor: Running Cost, Purchase Cost And Performance Compared
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 авг 2024
- Rising fuel prices are forcing buyers to look at alternate fuel options, and the two most suitable alternatives are CNG and Electric. While it's widely known that both of these options reduce running cost as compared to petrol, there is also a premium you pay to buy them in the first place. In this video, we find out if the lower running cost can justify the purchase premium? And is there a compromise in the space and practicality if you choose these alternative fuel options. To keep this video as fair as possible, we will use the Tata Tigor, the only car in the country to have offered all fuel types - petrol, diesel, CNG and electric. Today, we have the CNG and EV with us.
Useful Links
Tata Tigor EV On Road Price: www.cardekho.c...
Tata Tigor CNG On Road Price: www.cardekho.c...
Tata Tigor Full Battery Drain Test: • Tata Tigor EV Range Te...
Tigor EV vs CNG handling Test ZigWheels: • Tata Tigor i-CNG vs EV...
#EVvsCNG #TigorEV #TigorCNG #EVCNGRunningCost
Video Crew
Host: Nabeel Khan (@IndiaCarGuide)
DOP: Kamesh Chauhan | Neeraj Panwar | Nikhill Rege
Video Editor:
Graphic Artist: Shreelesh Shirke
I have the Tigor XZ+ iCNG. really happy with the performance. CNG is the most sensible option for now.
Sir meri car Tata tigor icng engine oil consume Karti hai 5000 km k baad 300ml kya aapki car b engine oil consume karti hai
It has become the first and the most unique car of India because it is available in Petrol, CNG and EV. No other cars are available in all three types of options. Well done Tata
EV has range anxiety
Petrol/Diesel are costly
CNG is not available everywhere
That's why need affordable full scale Hybrids...
I have found the most valid comment here. I am also in favor of Hybrids. We need budget hybrids in the below 4 meters category.
@@ashishsharma1117 Yeah... But only problem is that hybrids have too many taxes... Still Honda took a bold step by launching the City Hybrid... But that too costs about 25 lakh which exceeds VFM quotient... Still, response is good...
EV Rs. 2.5 per km
CNG Rs. 2.6 per km
Petrol Rs. 6.5 per km
In 7 yrs I drove 65000 km
EV would have cost 1, 65, 000
CNG Rs.1,69,000
Diesel Rs. 3,25,000
Petrol Rs. 4,16,000
Exactly, when i chose CNG my biggest fear was Boot space compromise beside company assuring CNG saftey also. but i realised I hardldy ever use Boot space because im buying for Home and work purpose and not some kinda transporting purpose. But God please reduce Priceses .
Its a good comparo video but there is one most important practical bit that was missed to discuss. We don't get automatic transmissions in CNG vehicles. Driving manual in Cities is a curse. So for automatic transmission, we need to go for petrol, diesel or EVs.
No automatics in CNG as of now because they were being targeted towards the taxi buyers. I am hoping this will change with more mainstream CNG cars/
Good one
Yes you are right Nabeel sir that cng are best alternative of petrol but factory feated cng is not available with automatic transmission. what is you opinion Nabeel sir? Excellent work by Nabeel & Cardekho team.
Shukriya. As of now, no automatics in CNG because they were being targeted towards the taxi buyers. I am hoping this will change with more mainstream CNG cars/
EV s mein engine oil ka tension nahi. That is also expensive. Also breakdown bhi kaam hoga as compared to petrol as there are a lot of moving parts in engine.
You open our eyes
Very well made video. Thumbs up!
Thanks a lot!
Sir apne Ev ke mukable petrol aur cng me extra service cost nai add kiya jese oil,and all filter,uska add karke bata te to perfect running cost nikalke ati.
Usko mainten karna bhi thoda maenga hota hai Ev ke compair me..???
Bhai short run me zaroor aapke service cost kam hoge par in cars me wo itna bada factor nahi hota. Warranty ke baad agar battery replace karne padi EV ke to wo zayada cost karega. And consumables jaise ke brakes, tyres aur brake pads to EV me bhe change honge he
if u buy cng ertiga than it will solve boot space problem and in performance u will get 10% less which is very minimum
Important Note : it's not just about Cost operation, the pleasure & convenience of Driving a Electric Vehicle is Level Next...........
Tata Tigor is a good hatchback; it is upto the person to choose the fuel option.
It's a compact sedan 😅
Very nice justification between cng and ev sir 🙏👍
Actually really great review... Keep it up
Thank You!
I am a nexon EV owner, from the price point of view it is 100% correct that Petrol-CNG is a much much better option than EVs.
Running cost is almost same for both EVs and CNGs, and you will never get a peace of mind if u are an ev owner. Lot of issues such as range anxiety, power cuts, unpredictable electronics behind the vehicle, un reliable fast charging points ( you may have a real luck to charge from a fast charging point), time consuming fast charging( almost 90 minutes)...
The breakaway point for an EV is almost 1 lakh kms compared to petrol vehicle.
Only benefit i felt is its superior on road performance.
But from all other aspects its better to buy a petrol-cng vehicle.
Really 🤔
Sabse badiya diesal h koi tension nhi just refuel and go
जो भारत का भविष्य प्रदूषण मुक्त बनाये वही ओपिनियन है
Bilkull.
Wo to thik bhai. But manufacturing and decomposing lithium ion batteries do more pollution than a diesel car do in years. We need flex fuels or green energy alternatives to achieve the pollution reduction.
Out of world but expected comparo.good job
CNG vehicle is beneficial in price and running cost
Thanks, informative video
Glad it was helpful!
What about battery replacement cost in EV? And as of now, practically you can not take EV for a road trip.
tata is providing 1lac km or 10 years warranty on battery.
@@MrThakre thanks. Any idea what is battery cost for replacement before and after warranty?
@@shailechn before warranty:free.
After 1llac km or 10 years:6-7lac.
Nexon battery cost is 7 lac so tigor should cost less..
@@shailechn 5-5.5 lakhs
Almost half the cost of vehicle. And no road trip via EV. A city car...
Some people telling me cng has burn Engine Head therefore if you long time use cng then you must checked vehicle service centre
yes my car head is open 2 time in 9 year... and around 20k cost
Average se 150km par day running hai to kon se lene chaiye petrol. CNG ev
Cng
CNG
EV
All the electric, petrol and CNG cars have their own pros and cons. Pros for petrol:- Better power.- fuel stations are easily available.- service centers are easily available. Cons for petrol:- Pollution.- The consumption of petrol is costlier. Pros for electric:- Electric cars are highly economical compared to their petrol counterparts.- Electric cars are totally pollution-free. Cons for electric:- less service availability and charging stations.- E-Cars may not have the same life as petrol vehicles because motors may not last as long as engines. However, motors are replaceable. It may be concluded that electric cars are suitable for those who have to travel only certain Kms daily. It can be considered to be suitable for traveling in a city or town with traffic. On the other hand, as an alternative fuel, CNG combusts more efficiently than conventional fuels. This, in turn, translates to lower tailpipe emissions. Now some might argue that electric cars do not harm the environment as there are no tailpipe emissions. However, the electric vehicle industry is still at a very nascent stage as the country still lacks the charging infrastructure required to support them. Moreover, you can have a test drive of the cars for a better idea of comfort and drive quality by visiting the nearest dealer in your city. You may click on the given link and select your city and brand accordingly for dealership details: bit.ly/3BbJjLi
I would recommend CNG. EV me aapko range anxiety rahega.
Need updated video now with launch of punch.ev and upcoming cng automatics from Tata.
CNG is the best
Ev has cons like battery replacement cost charging time range anxiety
True. But for daily commuting, it can be a brilliant alternative.
Bolero neo ka varient explained video bnaye plz...
EV becomes more cheaper when considering car service costs of petrol and cng
Yes, that is true. But if you own an EV for long, than the battery replacement cost will neutralise that aspect.
@@nabeelkhan4878 No, as after 7 years, just think what will be the cost of petrol
@@PrashantYadavSkywalker also after 7 years price of battery will come down drastically and price of petrol will be almost up by 60-70%
Ev best hai but range jyada nahi hai 250 300 km ke bad charging ka acha option mile na mile outstations ke liye . In city traffics ke liye best hai
Good
Fact : Ev gadi ka battery banane mein jo carbon emit hota hai woh pata hai kya jo ke petrol se bhi zyada hai check karlo.
It was helpfull
Which is better In Kia Carens, Diesel or Petrol 🤔🤔🤔
Diesel bcoz turbo petrol don't give good milage
And turbo petrol and diesel have very less price difference on road
Selecting the right fuel type depends on your utility and the average running of the car. If you drive less than 50km in a day then we recommend you to go with a petrol car as they are easy to maintain, have a longer life span and they cost less initially than the diesel car. On the other hand, diesel cars are preferred if the average daily run is more than 50km which makes it a feasible purchase. Diesel cars are more fuel-efficient and provide more torque, therefore, are preferred for a person who drives more than 50km. Whereas, petrol engine has a low service cost, more life span, generally has a well-controlled NVH level and are cheaper in cost than the diesel engines. Moreover, we would suggest you to take a test drive before making the final decision. Follow the link and select your desired city for dealership details: bit.ly/2kDxUPm
THANK YOU
I like the D AT.
CNG Car is better option because EV CAR ka maintenance high costly hoga battery replacement time par
Bai kuch samj nahe aaya
70 km per day travel distance
Thabvkon sa fuel engne le....
Tigor Cng ki performance same petrol ki performance jaisi h...there is no difference in performance..
performance ya average bhi?
@@shivamrunthala2165 average zyada h bhai CNG me
Ev
This is totally unfair result, no body will charge their ev from outside. U should have considered 1/- per km
Petrol is still cheapest type of fuel here’s why - CNG Cars are more than 1 lakh expensive you can drive a lot in 1 lakh if you buy Petrol + you’ll get quality.
Same with EV technology
105.5
Hybrid car needed in Indian market.....
Cng cars doesn't make sense anymore, look at the price 91 rupees per litre, petrol car is much better drive right and get good mileage simple...
CNG = Low cost and no range anxiety!!
Anxiety for , when the tank is blast😊😊
@@majojohny6116 😃
Petrol
Confused
👍👍😍😍🙏🙏❤❤👌👌
Sir kya ek hi gaadi mai petrol and cng aati hai
Bahot confused hu