Eric! I just stumbled across this video! You sound amazing and Carmine's reeds couldn't have found a better recipient :) Bravo my friend - you seem to be doing well. ~Cheers, Renee M.
Good Morning: I have 10 boxes of Vandoren 5 reeds dating back to 1977--and still NOT opened/used. Clearly your shows that even 55 years old "new" unused reeds can still work and sound great. And in your demonstration, the 55 year old reed sounded much better than the newer one. WOW...!!! Lesson learned: Unused older reeds can sound great. THANK YOU...!!!
About 10 years ago I found a partial purple box of 2.5-3 reeds I bought in1962. When I put one in my mouth it tasted the same as they always tasted. I paid about $7.50 for a box of 25. Mine play pretty good also, I don't know anyone one who had any ill effects from the taste. I still use blue (purple box) reeds I prefer them and you are correct the old ones were better. Keep up the good work. Mike
Ya, these tasted like how a closed attic smells. Stale doesn’t begin to describe them! But it sounds like you made a great find! Thanks for watching and sharing your experience!!
when they were new it was kind of a sweet taste I just thought it was how cane tasted. In those days we didn't fuss over things it was just the way it was. Mike
Ya, I don’t doubt that at all. I think these probably benefitted from the aging process, but i am sure consistency is better today! Thanks for watching!
@@ParkHouseCreations They do seem to have stratified the quality of the cane though, blue box getting the worst then by Rue Lepic 56 the best. I guess you pay for what you get.
I agree, the vintage reeds sound more vibrant, brighter with a clearer sound. I have several VanDoren boxes from about 1975 which I recently opened. Each reed varied but played well even though some were a bit stiff. One box was opened already from that time just sitting in the case unplayed. There was a lot of what look like brown saw dust in it so I’m imagining that bugs must’ve gotten in and had their way with the reeds so I discarded those 😨😮
I have some of those reeds from 1960 and only play with them and the sound is great. They are all #4 , also Number 3.5 which Anthony Gigliotti gave me. I am 82 years old and use these sparingly along with some Morre reeds which My Teacher gave to me. They are wonderful>
@@ParkHouseCreations I agree ☝️ There are many variables in sound production but one’s concept plays a vital role in the end result. I salute you !!! 🙏👍🤗
Honestly, I don’t think the flowpacks create a more humidity controlled environment than the cellophane wrapping already found around the box, but I’m sure music stores/band directors/etc. like them because they allow for a box to be easily split up without losing that humidity control. In general I think some level of humidity control is most likely beneficial for keeping reeds more consistent from reed to reed. But I hear what you’re saying! These reeds still played well without all of that, so… 🤷♂️
@@ParkHouseCreations Looks cool! I don’t know if you have heard but I have a podcast called Clarineat. You should come on some time and tell me about these videos you are doing. The production is incredible!
@@chickenmuffin Thanks for the kind words! I have definitely heard of the Podcast, I've listened to many of your episodes starting with the Martin Frost one back in 2016! I'd be happy to come on the show and talk about the videos, feel free to send me an email at parkhousecreations@gmail.com and we will work out the details!
Eric! I just stumbled across this video! You sound amazing and Carmine's reeds couldn't have found a better recipient :) Bravo my friend - you seem to be doing well. ~Cheers, Renee M.
Thank you so much for the kind words Renee and thank you again for the reeds!!
They Do Have a better Core, Colorful §ound
I like the Vintage sound better than newer reeds
Thanks for play testing them for Us!
Thank you for watching and commenting!
Good Morning: I have 10 boxes of Vandoren 5 reeds dating back to 1977--and still NOT opened/used. Clearly your shows that even 55 years old "new" unused reeds can still work and sound great. And in your demonstration, the 55 year old reed sounded much better than the newer one. WOW...!!! Lesson learned: Unused older reeds can sound great. THANK YOU...!!!
About 10 years ago I found a partial purple box of 2.5-3 reeds I bought in1962. When I put one in my mouth it tasted the same as they always tasted. I paid about $7.50 for a box of 25. Mine play pretty good also, I don't know anyone one who had any ill effects from the taste. I still use blue (purple box) reeds I prefer them and you are correct the old ones were better. Keep up the good work. Mike
Ya, these tasted like how a closed attic smells. Stale doesn’t begin to describe them! But it sounds like you made a great find! Thanks for watching and sharing your experience!!
when they were new it was kind of a sweet taste I just thought it was how cane tasted. In those days we didn't fuss over things it was just the way it was. Mike
I was playing them in 1972 on and I have to say the reeds they make nowadays are made so much better. You do sound better on it than I thought though.
Ya, I don’t doubt that at all. I think these probably benefitted from the aging process, but i am sure consistency is better today! Thanks for watching!
@@ParkHouseCreations They do seem to have stratified the quality of the cane though, blue box getting the worst then by Rue Lepic 56 the best. I guess you pay for what you get.
I agree, the vintage reeds sound more vibrant, brighter with a clearer sound.
I have several VanDoren boxes from about 1975 which I recently opened. Each reed varied but played well even though some were a bit stiff. One box was opened already from that time just sitting in the case unplayed. There was a lot of what look like brown saw dust in it so I’m imagining that bugs must’ve gotten in and had their way with the reeds so I discarded those 😨😮
I have some of those reeds from 1960 and only play with them and the sound is great. They are all #4 , also Number 3.5 which Anthony Gigliotti gave me. I am 82 years old and use these sparingly
along with some Morre reeds which My Teacher gave to me. They are wonderful>
IMMEDIATELY, the old reed sounded HUGE! Your tone just exploded! Sounded really strong!
Thanks Peter and thanks for watching!
Thank you!
My clarinet teacher c. 1973 who played with the San Francisco Symphony used Vandoren strength 5.
That’s cool! I get the impression that it was definitely a popular strength back in that time period!
Thanks for the video.
I appreciate you watching!
The truth is not the Reed , it’s just that u are an amazing clarinettist 🎶
Thank you Lory!!
@@ParkHouseCreations I agree ☝️ There are many variables in sound production but one’s concept plays a vital role in the end result. I salute you !!! 🙏👍🤗
💪💪🎉🍾️🍾️🍾️congratulations on the 1k subscription!!
Thanks Junnan!!
I wish sometime you review Chedeville Umbra, Elite and SAV..
They are on the list, but I am afraid it will be a while. I currently have 3 reviews planned that I am slowly catching up on!
@@ParkHouseCreations Hope these come first! And I'm mostly interested in open facings of them..
what does this say about the necessity of the sealed flopacks of modern reeds?
Honestly, I don’t think the flowpacks create a more humidity controlled environment than the cellophane wrapping already found around the box, but I’m sure music stores/band directors/etc. like them because they allow for a box to be easily split up without losing that humidity control. In general I think some level of humidity control is most likely beneficial for keeping reeds more consistent from reed to reed. But I hear what you’re saying! These reeds still played well without all of that, so… 🤷♂️
your videos make me play more
I’m glad to hear that!
Wait a minute is that a Vandoren 2Tone mouthpiece?
Hey Sean! It's a red marbled mouthpiece made by Lee Livengood!
@@ParkHouseCreations Looks cool! I don’t know if you have heard but I have a podcast called Clarineat. You should come on some time and tell me about these videos you are doing. The production is incredible!
@@chickenmuffin Thanks for the kind words! I have definitely heard of the Podcast, I've listened to many of your episodes starting with the Martin Frost one back in 2016! I'd be happy to come on the show and talk about the videos, feel free to send me an email at parkhousecreations@gmail.com and we will work out the details!
Who knows this lesson?
New isn’t always better
You deserve at least a 100k subs
I agree
Thank you! I appreciate the kind words!
NO !!!