Plagiarism of TM in USA
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- In this episode, Rajiv Malhotra and Dr. Jay Glaser discuss Herb Benson, the famous person propagating the technique called Relaxation Response. Dr. Glaser talks about how Benson studied Transcendental Meditation under Maharishi Mahesh Yogi and then went off to start his own practice slowly stripping TM of some of its key features thus enabling him to call it as his own invention.
He and Rajiv discuss about how Benson decided that mantras used in TM could be replaced by any word the practitioner wanted thereby making it accessible to his target audience which was the Christians of America. Making it devoid of mantras allowed him to secularise the practice and make it palatable to the Americans.
However, Dr. Glaser opines that he believes stripping the mantras from the practice of TM would most likely reduce the efficacy of the practice as the particular sounds that comprise the mantras have measurable effects on people and that he was sceptical of the results of the Relaxation Response technique which did not need mantras.
Watch other episodes with Dr. Jay Glaser: bit.ly/DrJayGl...
To donate to Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do:
इनफिनिटी फ़ौंडेशन की परियोजनाओं को अनुदान देने के लिए व इस प्रकार के एपिसोड और हमारे द्वारा किये जाने वाले शोध को जारी रखने के लिए: infinityfoundat...
To Subscribe to Rajiv Malhotra Official:
राजीव मल्होत्रा ऑफिसियल की सदस्यता लेने के लिए: / @rajivmalhotraofficial
Join Rajiv's discussion (राजीव की चर्चा से जुडें): groups.google....
#HerbBenson #RelaxationResponse #TMPlagiarism
How can people live on lie all there life? They are taking others credited silently! As an Indian, I'm saddened by this fact
U haven't heard about #Kalyugg. Fraudsters galore
*These thieves already plagiarised ayurved, yog and kamasutra.*
Its ingrained in christianity how Christian's copied Judaism and Roman culture
so what about indians who plagarised yoga from Lanka? How ironic you're now upset about Yoga being plagarised, which Indians copied in the 1st place! Patanjali who invented Yoga was born in Lanka.
EelamTruth Dear Prabhakaran fanboy Lanka is part of India, Bharat = Tamizh.
it is standard practice in us of a. they plagiarise if they can if not steal it- publish in some doody daaddy journal and claim it as their own!!
While NetFlix shows put all gurus who wear saffron as frauds. Good combo
Thanks for interviewing Dr Glazer. Enjoyed hearing from him. As far as the Benson 'technique', when it was a best selling book, I met many people who had bought the book and tried his technique (which is not at all like the TM technique). Of the people I met, nearly 100% got headaches and never continued the practice. But many would then go on to learn TM and get the benefits. There is as you know, much long-term research showing significant benefits from TM. I doubt if you could find enough people to do any long-term research on Relaxation Response...the Harvard Benson group has lists of course, but it would not be in their interest to do such research. TM works, thinking one over and over, is unlikely to produce any results, short term or long term. PS: I wish you would interview Dr Tony Nader!
This gives new perspective on things
1. When something is digested by the West, what are the long term effects.
2. Are the practitioners regular.
3. Third are they missing something else which they would have got if going to the source.
4. Is it possible to go ahead and research the long term effects of people who are practicing relaxation response and transcendental meditation. How can the effects be compared.
5. Would such discussion help in determining the Summum bonum for human kind.
What a revelation!
🙏 Malhotra ji,u r really doing a job.
The real problem is the gap between people in ashram and the modern world systems
All these 6 years there is no single effort done of the GOV to invite the likes of Rajiv Malhotra and different guests he introduces etc.. into Gov think tanks to shape a syllabus or start an institute in consciousness studies that have cross disciplinary interaction between Yogis, neuro scientists and quantum physics guys to make it modern and a sort after where brilliant young minds can aspire to join.
great job sir....showing all this type of things in front of Indian to know about and what is reality......plz also provide in Hindi language.
And in Tamil, telegu and Malayalam!!!
Speaker is very careful in his words do not want to anger his masters
Jai shree krishn
Rishi’s vision is Vedic - Sreyas
Relaxation techniques means entering into the jungle and doesn't know how to come out of that place. Where as TM, taking cool breathe in the ocean of pure consciousness, and come out to self consciousness.
This video needs more sharing and popularizing to show the truth. Plagiarism is the worst thing that this American has done.
Namaste
I really appreciate ur work... I listen to u... u r amazing🙏🕉🔱
🕉️🌻🙏Lots of Bharatiya people may be even looking away in direction. This discussion may make some to rethink and turn towards Dhyaana.....Dhaarana.... and so on.🌻🙏
🌦🌻🌺🍄🐲🐉🌴🦔🐿🦢🦚🐈🐊🐅🐆🐝🌵🌹🌾🐇
what can be done about this?
yeah, no nothing . Make sure this does not repeat ..
👍
EXPERIENCE OF ONE PERSON (Phil Goldberg) who was involved in the study......................As Robert says I was in Cambridge in the late 60s-early 70s. I was actually a subject in Benson's first TM study. As I recall, he did not learn TM himself, but maybe someone can ask Keith Wallace to confirm that. I also had to write about Benson in "American Veda." I haven't listened to the Glaser interview yet, but I hope he discusses the complicity of the media and scientists in not questioning Benson's assertion that his Relaxation Response had the same benefits as TM and that substituting "one" for Sanskrit mantras was inconsequential (never mind the puja, personal instruction, follow up, etc.). It was very unfortunate, but over time at least knowledgeable researchers have pretty much stopped assuming all meditation techniques are the same.
Jai Shri Krishna
Why I stopped TM.....
Pooja...... Initiative...
Pooja for So-called gurus photo...
Atmosphere inside TM association
More like a cult....
I suggest for self exploration
Qigong... Meditation in motion
Every thing is that Primordial energy.... Chee....
Your Soul is Chee....
I like rajiv malhotra and all the hindu new age gurus and propagationists but we cannot ignore there r still discrepencies practiced and still fuedaliatic mentalities are there. They cannot ignore them. They have to work against these. Why thr r no sanskrit speakers or learners from other communities no dance specialists from other communities because in oldem days these all things were kept out of reach from other communities even today we can see that in this new age
Thieves in the house. Everyone will have their judgement day. Rather sad the intellects doing it.
great
Beautiful episode Rajiv Sir! Sir, India's demography is vastly changing now because of massive conversion and population jihad, love & sex jihad of Hindu women and illegal infiltration from Bangladesh directly sponsored and patronage by non BJP ruled state government largely. Please do a program on it Sir. 🚩🇮🇳
*Hindus adopt "pathagiri" to save your life.*
US should not allow plagiarism on these subjects, the subjects which are related to universal development should be open source.
🕉️🕉️🕉️🕉️🙏🙏🙏🙏
*Hindus be "pathagiri" ready for your existence.*
Where's the full video
You can view other parts of this discussion here: bit.ly/DrJayGlaserPlaylist
@@RajivMalhotraOfficial hello, Mr. Rajiv Malhotra has had a conversations with various gurus, I am a practitioner of shivyog shambhavi and other mediations, they have had various seminars with doctors in the u.s and other countries on cure is possible campaign and cosmic medicine, and have been facilitated by Rutgers, new York Nassau county etc. and are having various research projects, there is also a current ongoing research on sample size of 1000 people by psychologists and scientists about effects of meditation and the yoga of immortals practices. with regards to dangers like digestion and informing the guru about various other things, if possible I would like Rajiv ji to contact shiv yog foundation as well.
cureispossible.org/
shivyog.com/
@@RajivMalhotraOfficial Sir, Do post the full video also along with the shorter ones. The shorter ones break the flow. Sometime we end up watching them out of sequence also.
*Hindus need "pathagiri" to survive.*
Well sir one thing I can't understand why Indian gurus so obsessed with foreigners.you name any Indian guru at present moment and you find large following.why can't they see, what you are.discussing right now. They came and took knowledge and depart, start their own business out of it. Or simply digest it.
You missed the whole point: The BIG HEADLINE is that I spent 40 years trying to prove that a very very famous Harvard scientist now famous for his technique with US patents, ACTUALLY TOOK THIS FROM VEDIC TRADITION AS HE LEARNED FROM MAHARISHI. Why do we have so many folks who don't know what the point being made is??? Same old ghissa-pitta few things they can say. What an insult to decades of research.
@@RajivMalhotraOfficial Thanks for interviewing Dr Glazer. Enjoyed hearing from him. As far as the Benson 'technique', when it was a best selling book, I met many people who had bought the book and tried his technique (which is not at all like the TM technique). Of the people I met, nearly 100% got headaches and never continued the practice. But many would then go on to learn TM and get the benefits.
yeah coming from a guy who worships Nithyananda🤣🤣🤣