Far Longer Than Forever | A Love Letter to The Swan Princess

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 668

  • @ashleynichole8687
    @ashleynichole8687 2 месяца назад +689

    My grandpa worked on the Swan Princess, amongst other pieces. My childhood was surrounded by merchandise, copious amounts of obscure animation VHS’, and full theatrical posters on the walls. He was the only father figure I had as a kid, and losing him was my first brush with grief in my childhood. On my wedding day, I had Odette’s locket pinned to my wedding bouquet with a picture of him inside.
    Thank you for taking the time to produce this love letter.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +67

      Thank you to your grandfather for helping produce such a beloved movie, and thank you for your lovely comment :)

    • @FeliciaParker97
      @FeliciaParker97 2 месяца назад +8

      What a beautiful story. I hope you don’t find it rude, but would you be willing to sell a theatrical poster or something of this sort that you mentioned? Swan Princess was my childhood and that would mean so much to me.

    • @themaybeso6117
      @themaybeso6117 2 месяца назад +5

      Thank you sharing this piece of his beautiful memory💕

    • @afn6224
      @afn6224 2 месяца назад +1

      What a beautiful story. May your grandfather’s memory be a blessing.

    • @TheMightyN
      @TheMightyN 2 месяца назад

      You have proof to show us that he did?

  • @viviennemorgan7217
    @viviennemorgan7217 2 месяца назад +157

    the quote from roger's how to offend women in 5 syllables or less will forever be funny in my mind 🤣😂😹.

    • @viviennemorgan7217
      @viviennemorgan7217 2 месяца назад

      but you should review barbie of swan lake since barbie's odette met her prince but she was given a necklace by a fairy and you should watch the rest.

    • @irenadjukanovic6317
      @irenadjukanovic6317 Месяц назад

      there will never be so much feminist progress on this planet even if we become a matriarchy on Mars that will make this joke inferior 😂🤣😹

  • @MB-tj7xh
    @MB-tj7xh 2 месяца назад +557

    The ''As constant as a star''. No other prince delivered that classical princeliness with vocals.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +29

      Yes!

    • @yc0995
      @yc0995 2 месяца назад +30

      Appropiate, considering he played phantom of the Opera for the longest time on Broadway (1999 to 2009)

  • @johnforbes4915
    @johnforbes4915 2 месяца назад +915

    The Swan Princess trilogy is my favourite animated trilogy of all time. I particularly love how Derek and Odette’s marriage is not perfect. It’s something they need to work at, but their love always brings them back together ❤️

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +93

      Yes! Exactly. I always appreciated that aspect. It's still very rare to have stories with romance show the couple actually building a life together

    • @LiliLedesma-rw2kg
      @LiliLedesma-rw2kg 2 месяца назад +9

      I agree 100 percent

    • @nelliewerger5505
      @nelliewerger5505 2 месяца назад +1

      F GG g Iy

    • @dionysus_adores
      @dionysus_adores 2 месяца назад +10

      All 3 movies were fantastic. Especially the Queen's melt downs

    • @rosiescott1531
      @rosiescott1531 2 месяца назад +29

      This could be a false memory but I seem to remember a bit in the second movie where Odette says to Derek "I remember why I married you - you're so good at saying you were wrong," and when I was a kid I was like "that's a dumb reason to marry someone" and my mum said "It's actually a pretty good start!"
      I guess they were dealing with slightly more complex relationships than I'd seen represented in kids movies up to that point.

  • @mkyasha
    @mkyasha 2 месяца назад +295

    LOL- I totally forgot about the lyric about their marriage leading to lower taxes. Oh man do I feel that now, 25 years later....

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +38

      I'd settle to lowering the prices of groceries in general lol

    • @mkyasha
      @mkyasha 2 месяца назад +5

      @@BetterWithBob Ya, no kidding lol😂😭. Going back to 2020 prices would save our household at least a couple thousand dollars (and there's only 2 of us).

    • @Passions5555
      @Passions5555 2 месяца назад +5

      ​@@BetterWithBobor lowering the rent on a single bedroom apartment 😵‍💫

    • @SuperFlashDriver
      @SuperFlashDriver 2 месяца назад

      @@mkyasha prices for groceries in 2014/2015 were under $2.00. And thanks to inflation in 2018/2019 it was near the $2.50/$3.00 mark, so inflation was already climbing since the late 2010s, before 2020 occured. How do I know this? I've kept receipts from Shoprite that showed me what I used to buy back in the day compared to now. I've collected receipts since the 2010s and it's always interesting to see what I bought back then compared to now. I still have a faded Pathmark receipt where I bought Coca-Cola Zeros and Regular Cokes 12 ounce bottles that Pathmark no longer exists where the Target is now.

  • @erin1912
    @erin1912 2 месяца назад +379

    it is so deeply validating to see so many fellow swan princess lovers in the comments- i’m in my mid 20s and my swan princess blanket is my most prized possession

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +12

      Ooh very cool :D

    • @candellina6
      @candellina6 2 месяца назад +3

      Oh, yes! I'm here for it.

    • @georgiarose4944
      @georgiarose4944 2 месяца назад +1

      23yo here. Hands down my favourite movie of all time. Im sure most little girls went through the princess stage and this films take was other worldly, even in the early/mid 2000s

  • @132karissanelson
    @132karissanelson 2 месяца назад +256

    Swan princess gave me a princess with personality, snark, and heart and a prince that was more than a set piece. I love this movie.

    • @KarmaLostAnArm
      @KarmaLostAnArm 2 месяца назад +4

      i mean she had it in the childhood song, afterwards she lost it, i still like some things about the movie but the two main characters were done pretty dirty

  • @carrie1159
    @carrie1159 2 месяца назад +123

    evil odette's black dress has lived rent free in my mind for the past 20 years. if I ever get invited to a fancy event it's 100% what im going to wear and i wouldn't even question getting it custom made. probably would even dye my hair lighter tbh.

  • @racheldoesfandom
    @racheldoesfandom 2 месяца назад +314

    "DUCK!" "WHAT?!"
    Fantastic video on a very underrated animation from my childhood. Ah, nostalgia!

  • @lorrenelise3434
    @lorrenelise3434 2 месяца назад +689

    I will not take the quest for Camelot slander 😂😂😂

    • @himbotits
      @himbotits 2 месяца назад +93

      Agreed! Its pretty flawed but I think it holds up, like I feel like all you need to do is examine the writing around Garrett just to get a glimpse of some of the genius in the film. Like how when he first meets Kaylee he doesn't even bother to turn around to face her while talking to her, and the gradually moves to turning towards her but staring straight ahead, to finally putting in the effort to tilt his face towards her direction. Its a very subtle way of showing his developing relationship with her, and the fact this only works with him being blind makes it an extra nice touch. (Also I love the moment where Kaylee is standing right in front of him oogling him and how cute he is, and he literally has NO idea, he's literally blind to it and its so funny and cute idk)
      Also to give Kaylee some love, she was clearly written for the army brat girlies, I found her very relatable as kid as someone who loves my dad a lot. I also appreciate the fact that she wasn't an inherent badass. She wanted to leave to train to be a knight, she has zero knowledge on how to fight or anything like that, no one has taught her those things, all she can do is daydream. I feel like a lot of people give her shit for being weak when I don't think that that is her fault. Also the fact that she has a nervous habit of talking too much, its fairly realistic and is a great tool for setting up the initial tension with Garrett since he has to depend on hearing more than she does.
      Also one more gush for the road, but if you slow down the first fight scene in movie, which happens SO fast, you can tell how purposeful the fight choreography is, and the way it shows how Kaylee's father died. He's the only one who suffers a fatal blow, getting bashed on the side of the head with a mace, while everyone else is able to block or parry him, or just get a head butt. The fact that they don't realize immediately how badly he got hurt is also fairly realistic, again given how quickly the fight happened.

    • @18Hongo
      @18Hongo 2 месяца назад +61

      ​@himbotits A couple of other points:
      1. Ruber really is just "THE VILLAIN", and he OWNS IT. He's unhinged, he does the robot at one point, his magic potion that creates the metal soldiers was just "bought from some witches" - he really is just "the bad guy", and boy, does he make it work. "I was in the neighbourhood, and I thought I'd invade"; it's almost as if they let tumblr write Ghengis Khan fanfiction.
      2. When Kaylee sees Ruber standing in her house with her family held prisoner, the first thing she does is try to kill him with a mace. Even the mass-produced girlboss characters of today aren't THAT brazen.

    • @peregrination3643
      @peregrination3643 2 месяца назад +23

      I loved it as a kid. One of the best. I rewatched it as an adult though. I rewatched The Prince of Egypt and The Land Before Time around the same time. Quest for Camelot doesn't quite have an all ages appeal that the others pulled off for me. Still, I give it credit for the strong impression it gave me as a kid and as someone who loves medieval fantasy with adventurous yet warm female characters. And a blind loner forest guy who knows nature by feel is also just as awesome and classic.

    • @Dorlainedainwenz
      @Dorlainedainwenz 2 месяца назад +4

      Agreed!

    • @hannahmetzger4880
      @hannahmetzger4880 2 месяца назад +9

      I watched it awhile ago on RUclips, it was _really_ good!! Really sweet, really wholesome and fun. I loved Kaylee and Garrett's romance and the way they defeat Ruber. The only thing I didn't like so much was the two-headed dragon character (especially his introductory song;the animation for that thing was just _whack),_ but even then, that's _really_ just more of a nitpick for me than anything else :P.

  • @QuinnthePrincess
    @QuinnthePrincess 2 месяца назад +492

    Thank you! I’ve been saying this about Odette for years! She is a strong character and her being feminine doesn’t take away from her intellect or courage. I especially like how we get to see her character develop through the two animated sequels. She’s always been my favorite non Disney princess 🦢✨

    • @Toonwalla2010
      @Toonwalla2010 2 месяца назад +26

      Yeah she was always a great feminine and strong female lead. My only issue with her in the OG film was that the transition of her from being upset with Derek's botched proposal to pining for him felt so rushed and glossed over. I kinda wish they had given her one or two lines explaining why she still loved him, or that she knew he just made a mistake because it feels so out of left field for her to suddenly change her mind about being with him in ten minutes.

  • @JeffreyDeCristofaro
    @JeffreyDeCristofaro 2 месяца назад +321

    I've always admired animated films and animators that dared to stand up to Disney... even if they weren't entirely successful, they could still always remain gems that could leave an impact on others in ways that Disney couldn't.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +36

      And Richard Rich went to multiple studios and backers to try and get it off the ground, and they all said no and to go to Disney, but he opted to do it independently

    • @nicklundy9965
      @nicklundy9965 2 месяца назад +24

      ​@@BetterWithBob in a perfect world he and Don Bluth could have been an unstoppable team in the 90s but DreamWorks was right around the corner. Disney has a knack for pissing off former employees. You should see what they tried to do to Ferngully and those 2 bizarre Filmation pseudo-sequels Pinocchio and the emperor of the night and Happily ever after.

  • @flappletarts
    @flappletarts 2 месяца назад +37

    The amount of fluidity in the expressive swaying of Roger’s hair is just…. It’s just hair but my god whoever animated that put their whole ass heart into it

  • @marieg3787
    @marieg3787 2 месяца назад +133

    My kindergarten teacher played this movie once during “nap/quiet time” (year 2000/2001) and I was so enthralled by it I demanded my grandma rent it so I could watch it again and again and again.
    My other favorite non-Disney animated musical is Quest for Camelot and I won’t take that slander lying down. 😂

    • @wimsylogic65
      @wimsylogic65 2 месяца назад +12

      I loved quest for camelot As well. Yeah it felt corny, But the main character love interests even as a kid, Made me really happy to see them grow together.
      Garrett, Was a far better Male love interest Then A lot of so-called princes. I definitely like him better than The Swan princess's Prince character.
      The dragons were funny. The bad guy really gave this true, psychotic , evil Villain energy.
      people don't give this movie enough credit.

    • @solsirhibragusowl2221
      @solsirhibragusowl2221 2 месяца назад +2

      My movie twin!!!❤

    • @sakunaruful
      @sakunaruful 2 месяца назад +1

      Quest for Camelot and Cats Don’t Dance for non Disney musicals.

  • @elezeiaz
    @elezeiaz 2 месяца назад +47

    I actually LOVED Thumbelina is a kid. It was so different. And that song "You'll be sure to do impossible things, if you follow your heart" got me threw relentless bullying in school. Swan Lake & Anastasia was my other favourites. Strong & determinted women that to every cost, follow their heart. Yeah I see why I am the way I am now as an adult xD

  • @Shadow866
    @Shadow866 2 месяца назад +397

    There is only the Swan Princess, the two sequels and THATS it!

  • @himbotits
    @himbotits 2 месяца назад +103

    The Swan Princess and Anastasia are both on the top of the list of my favorite films of all time, completely unironically. I absolutely adore them with my whole heart. It makes me very happy to see someone else show this movie some love. I actually love Derek as a character, his biggest problem is the fact that he's basically a himbo and kinda dumb. Like sometimes you can just see in his face he has zero clue what's going on and its SO funny to me. I think my favorite moment of this is with Princesses on Parade, I feel like its less of him waiting for Odette, and him genuinely being confused by the song number that's happening around him and not being sure how to react. He has some of the best facial animations in the movie as well, he's very expressive and it makes him fun to watch for that reason.
    The human animation in general is just really good, and like you pointed out as well, the fact that all the background staff are unique is a nice touch. I feel like women back then often got the copy paste treatment, and it would have been so much easier to have the white dress dancer in "Parade" all have the same face, but the fact they designed and then animated all of them to look different makes me give so much respect to the artists working on the film. I haven't seen the sequels in a while but this video makes me want to check them out again. I certainly watched them a lot on VHS back in the day!

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +9

      Ooh that's a good point about the dancers in Princesses on Parade

    • @SuperFlashDriver
      @SuperFlashDriver 2 месяца назад +1

      Interesting....I sadly have to go with "Flight Of Dragons", since that one is my absolute favorite animated film of all time in the 1980s.

  • @carlachaffin6936
    @carlachaffin6936 2 месяца назад +162

    I was 9 when this movie came out. I was fortunate to see it once in theaters, and i was obsessed. I couldn't wait for the VHS release. They used to have book orders for classrooms at my school and i was delighted to own the novelization of the movie, i still own it actually. I vaguely remember a conversation with my classmates and they were being exposed to more adult material than i cared to watch, and i was made fun of for liking this film. It prompted me to write a essay as a journal entry that we wrote in for class, stating my protection of my innocence and being careful of the entertainment i cared for. My teacher loved the entry so much that she asked my permission to copy it and keep it. Thats my memory of The Swan Princess.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +11

      Oh that's awesome :D I didn't even know there was a novelization

  • @MissVictoryJane
    @MissVictoryJane 2 месяца назад +81

    Thank you! I've loved this movie since I was little. Odette's and Roger's immediate calling out of Derek's shallowness definitely shaped my early expectations of how strong women are and how you should expect to be treated by a partner. Also that princesses on parade song is the freaking best

    • @stephanieferguson723
      @stephanieferguson723 2 месяца назад +1

      I love all the music but Princesses on Parade is extra special to me as it is sung by the same actor I saw the first time I went to Phantom of the Opera. He was great!

  • @TeenDream888
    @TeenDream888 2 месяца назад +38

    my sisters and I borrowed this VHS so much from the library (we were the _only_ ones that did), that after a year the library gave it to us for free instead of including it in their annual book sale.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +4

      Aha do you still have it?

    • @TeenDream888
      @TeenDream888 2 месяца назад +6

      @@BetterWithBob yes, I snuck it out of the house when I went to college many years ago and it's up on one of my bookcases. crazy to think I can just go online to watch it now.

  • @jennynoelle6782
    @jennynoelle6782 2 месяца назад +108

    Oh, wow. You actually brought up the original tragedy and how Odette and Odile were played by the same ballerina. So many people just see the modern iterations, including this film, and assume the story (in all versions) just is that way by default, rather than evolving into that over countless retellings.

  • @Rachel-xu4br
    @Rachel-xu4br 2 месяца назад +79

    "This Is My Idea" is one of my favorite songs from a Princess-type musical due to the fact that it does a lot (which you've already explained well), but also the fact that it did something Disney just started to do, which was to show a really developed and/or established long term connection between the two characters who are intended to be together (romantic, or not). Prior to this, the Princess formula was a meet and and greet, then marriage. They would've been the first, but BATB coming out in 91' due to having to release it under "compressed timeline" which was 2 years and had major story changes. The version we have today managed to be in development after Swan Princess started and finished before it's release.

  • @shadeblackwolf1508
    @shadeblackwolf1508 2 месяца назад +96

    I think the song that really captures the identify of this trilogy is practice, practice, practice. unashamed fun, but always with a reason for being.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +8

      Ooh that's an interesting perspective

  • @Ree00902
    @Ree00902 2 месяца назад +37

    I love this movie and Odette was my model for all my "princess" ocs after seeing it as a child. I also agree that her growth from "cute 6-year-old in frilly dresses" to "awkward preteen w/freckles trying to figure herself out" to "teenage girl experimenting with her femininity" to "grown woman comfortable in her skin" was impeccable and conveyed in "This is My Idea" perfectly. I often reference that song as a good opening hook/scene for novel writing XD Thank you for sharing this vid!

  • @pongo5000
    @pongo5000 Месяц назад +6

    Me and my friend quote this movie so much, we love it. We wanna say fine? Nope it's always "Fineeee with me. Just FINEEE WITH ME"
    We wanna say waste of time? Always "All these years of planning, WASTED!"
    We ask what else? The reply is always "What else is there??"
    See a cute creature? *gasp! "The GREAT ANIMAL"
    And sometimes just cause we feeling dramatic "THE VOW I MADE WAS FOR HERRRR"
    😂😂

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  Месяц назад +2

      @@pongo5000 that is peak everything 😂

  • @samdehoyos024
    @samdehoyos024 2 месяца назад +82

    I adored this movie as a kid. I've since introduced my children to it. It will live on as it deserves.♥️

  • @wvnne9012
    @wvnne9012 2 месяца назад +49

    I love basically all the movies mentioned, but I do have to say, Swan Princess was one of the few princess movies that had a romance I actually bought into and enjoyed, even as a young child. And you're so right about the title card. Goosebumps. Every time.

  • @Moeller750
    @Moeller750 2 месяца назад +46

    I remain convinced that queen Uberta (objectively the best animated queen) is based on Queen Margrethe II of Denmark, who is also famous for her wide smile and extra fashion sense

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +7

      Ooh I had no idea

    • @Moeller750
      @Moeller750 2 месяца назад +2

      @@BetterWithBob I don't know if it's true, it just feels true, you know

  • @AmericanAurochs
    @AmericanAurochs 2 месяца назад +20

    Silk Hiding Steel is an incredibly sexy descriptor, thank you very much for that!

  • @sketchzeppelin7148
    @sketchzeppelin7148 2 месяца назад +38

    I was a little girl when this movie was released. I saw it in theaters and begged my mother to buy me every piece of merch I saw. I was surprised to find out later it was viewed as a failure. It was a lot of fun for an 8 year old girl and her sisters. I'm glad there are others who also get into the music and the characters.

  • @withinwithout6263
    @withinwithout6263 2 месяца назад +6

    As someone who absolutely adored both The Swan Princess *and* Thumbelina as a child, how dare you, sir!

  • @lifestylecreep
    @lifestylecreep 2 месяца назад +17

    Watching this movie as an adult, I enjoy it more and more with every subsequent watch and gain a deeper appreciation for the splendid animation. I also credit it for being the catalyst for my undying love of the Enemies-to-Lovers romance trope and epic heist scenes for the greater good. 🤣

    • @georgiarose4944
      @georgiarose4944 2 месяца назад +1

      OH MY GOD! My love of enemies to lovers MAKES SO MUCH SENSE NOW

  • @Nakiami
    @Nakiami 2 месяца назад +44

    I'm so ready. One of my favs as a kid. I however was very confused when I saw a whole booth at my local comic con when they were rebooting the series. But we don't talk about those ones.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +7

      Is that the CGI sequels or another reboot?

    • @Nakiami
      @Nakiami 2 месяца назад +3

      @@BetterWithBob yeah the cgi ones

  • @CuteLitteBat
    @CuteLitteBat 2 месяца назад +5

    Finally a video that doesn't bash this hidden gem. As a kid I loved this movie and it's sequel more than most of my Disney movies. I'm so glad there are people here who also love it.

  • @nilbog972
    @nilbog972 2 месяца назад +11

    I just had a daughter.. I can’t wait to watch this with her and her Father one day.

  • @AliciaNyblade
    @AliciaNyblade 2 месяца назад +21

    This film was a childhood favorite of mine and in a lot of ways, I think it's just as good if not better than some of the Disney Rennaissance movies. Derek and Odette were my introduction to "enemies to lovers" and I've loved them and the trope ever since. Odette is the genuinely strong, well-rounded leading lady modern Disney is trying, and failing miserably, to create. She is indeed "silk hiding steel" (LOVE that description, by the way).
    Derek is also a great character, too. I love that you pointed out how, even though the film is named for Odette, it's really the story of Derek's growth. Also, Howard McGillin's voice is absolutely gorgeous! I've loved it since I first saw this film as a kid and, years later, I saw Howard on Broadway as the Phantom in "The Phantom of the Opera", another spectacular performance of his. He's one of my favorite musical theatre performers.
    And lastly, Rogers is an absolute icon.

  • @tabruc4186
    @tabruc4186 2 месяца назад +39

    I love this movie, I love Odette, but I could never stand Derek once he grew up and thought Odette's sudden switch to waiting for him to show up and save her was odd considering she had just rejected him after the only thing he could think of to praise about her was her beauty. I do wish they had made it less sudden and shown her falling for him again as a swan or something after he had so disappointed her with his shallowness. They were cute as kids, but rather than pivoting to the 'we're in everlasting love' and ignoring the way they had last seen each other, I think they should have at least mentioned it because I get she was in a desperate situation, but it was like she just completely forgot about it so it was weird

  • @letarivera203
    @letarivera203 2 месяца назад +32

    Sorry But Thumbelina is fantastic I still die laughing at that movie with my nieces and nephews . That being said Swan Princess does not get the love it deserves.

  • @ShakespearsCyst
    @ShakespearsCyst 2 месяца назад +4

    So refreshing to hear someone have positive things to say about Anastasia.

  • @ladycarys3008
    @ladycarys3008 2 месяца назад +8

    Anastasia and Swan Princess were, hands down, my favorite cartoons as a kid. I love both the style and story, but the true success was the music. Both of them are musically spectacular, to the point were i used my little radio to record the sound on a cassette to listen to at bed time. I still know all the songs by heart.

  • @kindlyoffer1350
    @kindlyoffer1350 2 месяца назад +29

    I loved the Swan Princess as a kid. There are a couple of criticisms I'll always have, like how Dereck and Odette were such strong-willed, energetic children but as adults (at least for the second half of the first movie) they both appeared rather bland and formulaic, not to mention the obvious Sleeping Beauty rip-offs like the dance scene and Rothbart becoming a dragon, but the story, the songs, Rothbart's pizzazz, and the fact the sequels (save the awful CGI ones) continue the story rather than just remaking the first in a different skin, making their marriage feel real and not a perfect love story, giving them flaws and challenges to overcome as a couple, made me feel like I was watching real peoples lives, not just colourful bright songs with barely a plot to push VHS sales. I'm glad you made this. This series has a place in my heart too.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +21

      I'd argue that their strong wills manifested in different ways as adults. Like Odette refuses to give into Rothbart's demands, which one could interpret as her knowing she's saving her kingdom and its people from being under his control, and staying under the enchantment being a great personal sacrifice. And Derek refuses to give up on searching for Odette even when his mother and counsellor are insisting he just marry someone else, training relentlessly to be able to fight whatever beast kidnapped her, but I can see your point

    • @kindlyoffer1350
      @kindlyoffer1350 2 месяца назад +7

      @@BetterWithBob I just mean that I would have liked to know that she hadn't spent all the time between the first night she is changed into a swan and the next time we see her, as you said, months or possibly years in the future, doing more than sitting around singing and waiting for Dereck. She was proactive after this scene, searching for the map and such, but a few lines implying she'd spent her time during the day as a swan doing something, like flying around, trying to map out a way back home, or to some form of civilisation so someone could pass along a message to Dereck would have been appreciated. When she was a kid, she liked wrestling, hunting and boxing, I would have liked to see that grit in more than just her being sassy towards Rothbart.

  • @cameronnorris2055
    @cameronnorris2055 2 месяца назад +14

    I got the dvd as a birthday gift as a kid, I watched it multiple times a day for days at a time.

  • @MSSProductions1
    @MSSProductions1 2 месяца назад +22

    ALWAYS loved loved loved the swan princess, even got invited to the anniversary screening. I will defend this movie to death and i will die on all the hills

  • @annek9027
    @annek9027 2 месяца назад +19

    holy cow! so happy to see this video today. this was my favorite movie growing up, i used to watch it soooo often. i think this is what cursed me to be a hopeless romantic but i don't regret a thing

  • @evieveenhof9552
    @evieveenhof9552 14 дней назад +2

    I also love how Odette outfits are evolving with her, while Derek who seems to not grow up, doesn't change his outfits til he changes

  • @mackenzierivercasey6752
    @mackenzierivercasey6752 Месяц назад +2

    It turns out that Don Bluth just so happened to make all of my most cherished childhood movies! The fact that Disney got rid of him is a shame....because the list that was given were some of the most heartfelt and rewatched movies in my home growing up. Oliver and Company! The Quest for Camelot? Anastasia!? Are you kidding me!? Those were one of the best ever made in time!!!!!!!!!!

    • @beethovensfidelio
      @beethovensfidelio 28 дней назад

      Disney didn’t get rid of Don Bluth.
      Don Bluth left Disney, and given where Disney was at in the 1970s, I don’t blame him for leaving.

  • @nalurodriigues
    @nalurodriigues 2 месяца назад +29

    23:33 I hate that. I'm often in distress and I'd be VERY GRATEFUL if my boy could just solve it all with a magic spell or some sword killing my boss but that's life for y'all, I guess.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +7

      Hell, I'd be happy if someone else impaling a giant beast in my name would solve all my problems lol

  • @athenaryals3273
    @athenaryals3273 2 месяца назад +4

    I loved this movie as a kid. Most of all I loved the earnestness and sincerity. I still love that

  • @jspictures9393
    @jspictures9393 2 месяца назад +4

    I didn't watch this film for so long because of how much I love and loved the Swan Lake Ballet. Changed my mind later. God I love this movie 😍😍😍😍

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +1

      I saw the film first and later read about the story in a book that had the plots of a few famous ballets and was like "oh...this is familiar" lol

  • @haas3ca
    @haas3ca 2 месяца назад +14

    This was my favorite movie as a child

  • @Kittiesdressedinpink
    @Kittiesdressedinpink 2 месяца назад +13

    Fantastic analysis and discussion. One of my fave movies and I agree that films like this won in the long term.

  • @nicklundy9965
    @nicklundy9965 2 месяца назад +7

    I wore the vhs tape out because of the end credits and the music video. Same with Space Jam. I love Far longer than forever but Eternity is the song that has stuck with me.

  • @lunalight34
    @lunalight34 2 месяца назад +4

    Thank you for showing so much love to this movie. It gives such a warm, fuzzy feeling knowing that there are so many other people still singing "Far Longer Than Forever" 🖤

  • @BradLad56
    @BradLad56 2 месяца назад +4

    Clavius has the BEST villain song out of the entire trilogy and I will die on that hill if I have to.

  • @thedrunkenelf
    @thedrunkenelf 2 месяца назад +3

    I LOVE the swan princess, I had it on VHS and used to watch it over and over

  • @herecomemacOnTT
    @herecomemacOnTT Месяц назад

    Good lord this movie was absolutely one of the movies i had on repeat as a child. Far Longer Than Forever will probably play at my wedding ❤

  • @DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose
    @DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose 2 месяца назад +20

    I didn't grow up with The Swan Princess (*my* childhood Swan Lake adaptation was Barbie's), and I definitely think the story could use improvement in some areas, but I'm happy for you, Bob, to hear how much love you have for it (complete with an incredible, viewpoint-changing analysis of Odette's character). 🤍 Plus, the fact that Prince Derek is voiced by Howard McGillin, the longest-running actor to play the Phantom (Erik) on Broadway, continues to bring my POTO-loving heart much joy. And *thank you* Bob for informing me that he wasn't the only one! (Hey Davis Gaines). 🥰🌹
    And even though it's just Bridget in disguise, Odette looked *so* good in that red and black dress, and I love how it contrasts with the real Odette's blue and white dress. ✨
    P.S. Congrats to you being quoted on its Wikipedia page! 😆👏

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +3

      Ah it is technically Odette lol. Did you notice the reporter in the 25th anniversary clips was cosplaying in it?

    • @DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose
      @DJtheBlack-RibbonedRose 2 месяца назад +2

      @@BetterWithBob I did indeed, she looked lovely! And it reminds me how much I would genuinely like to see a second chance stab at this story via live action (that fan-made trailer was too good to ignore).

  • @Thewolfartist24
    @Thewolfartist24 20 дней назад +1

    I think the swan princess is a great movie. The team and director did an amazing job.

  • @KaidenHernandez-w1p
    @KaidenHernandez-w1p 2 месяца назад +4

    Ok, I have always loved The Swan Princess, its songs have stayed rent free in my head for years...Guess I have some sequels to watch now! 😆

  • @killjoy8372
    @killjoy8372 Месяц назад

    Man, i didnt think i remembered this movie too well or had any specfic feelings about it, but every time a song is brought up i go "omg i loved that song!" and im now realizing i loved this movie and watched way more than i thought i did

  • @teddyj9482
    @teddyj9482 2 месяца назад +12

    “That first did half an hour short animated passage of The Book of Mormon”
    Shows clips from an animated passage of The New Testament.

  • @pocketsnacks
    @pocketsnacks Месяц назад +1

    I'm so glad the backgrounds in this movie are getting some love, they are GORGEOUS!

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  Месяц назад

      I couldn't appreciate them for so long until now XD

  • @drgskates
    @drgskates 2 месяца назад +14

    I have always loved The Swan Princess. The original trilogy were some of my favorites to watch, and I always enjoyed the Princesses on Parade song because they animated crystals/diamonds/glitter so well. I loved how much she fought for herself and defied Rothbart.
    Also, Rogers' line is iconic, and I bring it up all the time lol (especially now with all the manosphere-mansplainy crap).

    • @hameley12
      @hameley12 2 месяца назад +2

      I completely agree. It took me forever until I got to university, art school to learn of all the skills set you need in order to recreate this type of art style. By then companies started dabbing into 3D and I was left disappointed. The backgrounds, the foreground, the individual hand painted cells and choreography as well as the writing. Especially the sparkles, diamonds and Odette's transformation. I really wanted to draw like that.
      It took me a year and a half to find another art school that taught these techniques. This will always be on my desk, on my top twenty best films to look back to when I need inspiration when I have an artistic block or writer's block. 😊

  • @noodletoots
    @noodletoots 2 месяца назад +1

    I have unabashedly adored this movie since day one. It fuelled my childhood obsession with swans, and the soundtrack is still on regular rotation when I listen to music.
    A highlight of my adulthood was stumbling through a local convention and seeing a Swan Princess booth, complete with original merch and original cels from the first movie, and chatting about them with Seldon Young. Still low-key kicking myself for not buying something when I had the chance.

  • @awhallowmyth099
    @awhallowmyth099 2 месяца назад +11

    I love the Swan Princess. Two and three were my favorites, though I enjoy all three. With regards to villain songs, Zelda's song in III is groovy as hell. Not to mention that Rogers' weird 80s ballad to Zelda is pure comedic gold. 😂

  • @candellina6
    @candellina6 2 месяца назад +3

    I love French phrases like Inginue and Fem Fatal to accurately describe the female archetypes in a story.

  • @chelnahtheegghead
    @chelnahtheegghead 2 месяца назад +2

    YES!!! So, so glad someone has mentioned the wonderful Swan Princess sequels and the Comedy Queen that is Uberta. :))) (Also, great video! Lots of great background/detail on the production of the movie.) Edited to add my favorite quote from the movie: "All those years of planning: _WASTED!"_

  • @Awwwdree
    @Awwwdree 2 месяца назад +1

    Damn, the nostalgia hit when I heard those notes and saw the water form for the opening title. My sister and I had this movie on VHS growing up, and we ADORED it! I remember buying it on DVD some years back and I gave it to her when I moved away. We quoted it, sang the songs, named our childhood turtle Speed, and we greatly appreciated the love story with Odette having agency. That way she responds to Derek, "Thank you, but what else?" and later says to her father, "I need to know he loves me for just being me," it definitely influenced us to not settle for less than that when it came to dating and serious relationships later in our lives. Thanks for making this video, I have nothing but love for this movie!

  • @Nyctm91
    @Nyctm91 2 месяца назад +5

    Another brilliant video! First off I got so excited that you chose this movie cause it was a huge part of my childhood but you are so informative! I just love your videos

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад +1

      Thank you for your lovely comment :)

  • @ButterscotchBiscuit
    @ButterscotchBiscuit 29 дней назад

    This was one of my favourite films as a kid. I loved Odette as a heroine.

  • @abigailtodd7114
    @abigailtodd7114 2 месяца назад +4

    The swan princess is my favorite princess movie. Love the music. Love the animation. And I was a dancer so of course swan lake is near and dear to me. ♥️🦢

  • @paulstaker8861
    @paulstaker8861 2 месяца назад +2

    The swan transformation is perfect. Just... perfect.

  • @diamondinmyeye6160
    @diamondinmyeye6160 2 месяца назад +2

    Never owned this one, but I definitely rented it often as a child. It is still remembered fondly for me and I do have Far Longer Than Forever in my music library.

  • @123wink321
    @123wink321 2 месяца назад +5

    Quest for Camelot is one of my fav. When I was kid I would watch three movies on repeat. Pocahontas, Anastasia and Quest for Camelot. It has many good songs. I love those dragon twins, very funny. Main guy is blind and a badass, how often you see that in kids movies? His song I stand alone? OMG, my fav of them all!
    Female lead proactive and fun. Bad guy is scary as heck and his pet is actually kinda cute. And his evil minions? how they make it that a human or animal is being fused with a weapon, so smart and clever.
    The movie about missing your father, loosing him too early, but wanting to follow his legacy, to be someone he would be proud of if he still was here. Learning that you cant do everything alone, and kidness leads to more kidness.

  • @Wobside
    @Wobside 2 месяца назад +2

    Swan Princess, Thief and the Cobbler and the Princess and the Goblin were always guilty pleasures of mine as a kid. This just reminded me of my love for them.

  • @fearlesssfcappuccino
    @fearlesssfcappuccino 2 месяца назад +1

    Such a great look at The Swan Princess!! Totally agree and such great points. Underrated for sure

  • @LaBellesGrace
    @LaBellesGrace 2 месяца назад +1

    This is the review for this movie I didn’t realise I needed to see so badly. You worded it all perfectly. 👏

  • @wimsylogic65
    @wimsylogic65 2 месяца назад +3

    I love thumbalina. One of my favorite movies growing up. In some ways I loved the don bluth movies more than some Disney movies.
    I also loved this Swan princess. She was always one of my favorite princesses.
    I always related to her character.

  • @pipedream2556
    @pipedream2556 2 месяца назад +1

    I genuinely never consodered the ways in which Swan Princess looked at the original story of the Swan Lake ballet and decided to make the most of it with a mix of trope subversions and theme expansion. Like, its genuinely a well planned adaptation of a story thats quite hard to fill out into a film-length feature without bloating it with filler. Its genuinely clever to use the prince needing to fall for the disguise a part of his character growth and the romantic developments, same with Odette clearly being made a swan bc Rothbart is thinking of her like how people who havent been attacked by a real swan think of them as graceful delicate pure beautiful things to be observed and appreciated - hes as unorepared for what a real swan is capable of as he is for how tough Odette is, and it again feels like they really analysed the contents of Swan Lake's plot and figured out what they could do interesting things with!
    So yeah im really glad that i saw this video, i always loved this film but didnt realise how many details i hadnt really thought about as a kid

  • @thatponighoul
    @thatponighoul 2 месяца назад +4

    Of course this finds me while I'm going through another bout of Swan Lake obession 🦢

  • @mariafreel1910
    @mariafreel1910 Месяц назад

    Well, I feel vindicated! I remembered loving this as a child. I rediscovered it about 8 years ago, and MY GOD did it stand up!

  • @merilahna
    @merilahna 2 месяца назад +1

    of all the vhs tapes my grandma used to have at her place, this movie and its two sequels used to be my absolute favorites. i could never really properly put it into words why that was, and even later on just chalked it up to nostalgia instead of them being "good, actually", so im honestly really glad this video put it into words for me. a lot of this resonated. thanks for the great video!

  • @lfr8666
    @lfr8666 2 месяца назад +1

    So much of the dialog and song lyrics in this movie will be with me until the day I die. I loved the whole concept of This Is My Idea as a kid, showing the leading pair as growing up together as frenemies slowly gaining mutual interest in each other -- a definite departure from the disney fairytale romance formula. And I didn't appreciate at the time, but Odette is a damsel in distress done well: she is proactive and unwilling to let others control her life, be they well-meaning meddling parents, the pressures of political alliance, the doofus she loves but will not settle for if he doesn't respect her, or a murderous despot-wannabe. She would definitely have rescued herself had the curse rendered it physically impossible.
    I also wish we had more time with Odette clarifying her feelings for Derek after his screw-up, but I get why we didn't. It's similar to the dynamic in Beauty and the Beast, where she has already become who she was meant to be, and it's the male lead who still needs to grow up.
    Not that Derek's a bad guy, just... thoughtless. Takes things at face value, expects things to just go his way and balks at obstacles, and doesn't know how to articulate deeper feelings, especially when put on the spot. But to his credit, actions speak louder than words. After that immortal chewing out from Rogers, he was all set to PROVE his affection for her, even without the sudden kidnapping. I liked this movie as one of the few kids' movies with a romance that takes time and work.
    I always loved the hunt scene where Odette is trying to lure Derek to the lake without getting shot. The tension, the dramatic irony, the sunbeams, the music. That scene's great!
    I liked this iteration Rothbart as an antagonist. His song was bad (another in the long line of songs that took the wrong lessons from Aladdin's genie) but Palance's voice worked well and conveyed menace, even with the occasional goofy line. And the Great Animal scared me as a kid. It's a great design, especially the facial expressions in some moments.
    The arrow-catch may be physically impossible, but it was such a great finisher to the final battle. Loved that planting and payoff, and letting other characters contribute to the climactic fight.
    Odette's animal friends were endearing and memorable, but the side character who always stuck with me was Bromley, Derek's friend who hadn't grown out of his teenage-ness, but stuck with Derek through the courtship, through training to hunt the Great Animal, and proved himself by escaping from that prison moat and giving Derek that last arrow.
    Thanks for the reminder that this movie was a gem.

  • @TheNerdyCowgirlReads
    @TheNerdyCowgirlReads Месяц назад

    The swan princess is one of my all time favorites! Couldn’t wait to show my kids!

  • @ashleighzoda738
    @ashleighzoda738 Месяц назад +1

    The only thing I remember from these movies was being so moved from the prince’s grief when he thought he lost her near the end. No other animated movie had this intensity of emotion (and from a male character no less). I actually cried with him even though I knew she was going to come back.

  • @capppieee7912
    @capppieee7912 2 месяца назад

    Thank you for making this video.
    Loved this movie. Literally my childhood.
    It was also my childhood dream to walk down the aisle while Far longer than forever is being sang in the background❤❤❤

  • @niteglys
    @niteglys 2 месяца назад +1

    I liked the villain song in swan princess. He's evil and has fun doing it, no tragic backstory required

  • @glupik1234
    @glupik1234 Месяц назад

    i watched these religiously when i was a kid. i think the aspect that i liked the most and something that made these movies seem more 'deep' to me than a standard disney princess movie was the fact that odette and derek actually *had* a relationship and didn't just come together like these cute hugging salt and pepper shakers in the end of the story.
    That and the sound design (both music and sound effects) coupled with the animation.

  • @KateKatastrophe
    @KateKatastrophe 2 месяца назад +1

    I watched this movie so much as a child i got a dvd copy in my early 20s from my family as a birthday gift.

  • @krystenreid8106
    @krystenreid8106 2 месяца назад +1

    I am so happy I found this. I have had to hide my love of this film considering it just a guilty pleasure.

  • @Wildcat_Media
    @Wildcat_Media Месяц назад

    We had the Super-Duper-Special Edition VHS (the one with the gold clamshell case and extra behind the scenes feature at the end) and the soundtrack on cassette tape that I swear my mom was ready to burn because we listened to it so much. This is the kind of sappy romantic fairy tale that I ADORE. It deserves more recognition and I’m glad to have found your excellent review/discussion of this lovely film.

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  Месяц назад

      Ooh I didn't even know that edition existed :O

  • @alb9129
    @alb9129 20 дней назад

    I loved that we saw Odette as a child and a tomboy because that was quite like me when I was younger, I loved that she grew up and was beautiful and feminine! I think it is possible to be both. This movie holds such a special place in my heart thank you for this video :)

  • @orionsbelt25
    @orionsbelt25 2 месяца назад

    My grandparents have an RV in an RV park in Vermont and it used to have an older tv that only took vhs tapes. Swan Princess was one of three movies up there on vhs, so we'd watch it pretty often since my sisters and I would go up to stay weekends at the RV park pretty often over summer breaks. I have a lot of nostalgia for this movie and this video might push me into a rewatch

  • @journeyjulie3973
    @journeyjulie3973 19 дней назад

    This was my favorite movie as a kid!!

  • @monkey39128
    @monkey39128 2 месяца назад +7

    I love this film and the sequels are fun as well even if they're not as good as the first one.

  • @SunshineBell-t3f
    @SunshineBell-t3f 2 месяца назад

    THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU. I totally forgot, but this was my FAVORITE thing to watch as a little girl. Def going to go watch it right now.

  • @vrv7727
    @vrv7727 2 месяца назад

    Nice to find another fan of this underrated gem! My siblings and I loved watching this on home video (we kept re-renting it) growing up. :)

  • @isabelnavarro980
    @isabelnavarro980 2 месяца назад +1

    If I never knew you was a deleted song!? I always thought it was in the movie. Wow that’s crazy it really should be in the movie, it adds a lot of

    • @BetterWithBob
      @BetterWithBob  2 месяца назад

      It was restored for the 10th anniversary DVD :) And agreed lol

  • @lindapenttinen3382
    @lindapenttinen3382 2 месяца назад +2

    I owned two first sequels of this film and watched them religiosly as a child, they were one of my favourities and were probably the first tiny sparks for my journey of writing fantasy genre ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @aeriszona
    @aeriszona 2 месяца назад

    I love that The Swan Princess is being talked about more, this franchise was my favorite as a kid and I’d rewatch each movie repeatedly so much so that i knew all the dialogue and song to a tee. Amazing video btw!!