Yup the world was as linguistically rich at any given point as it is now, we only know about a subset of the languages that existed. PIE existed alongside other languages, probably even related ones that left no descendants as it was itself part of some language family. Just look at the Turkic languages to see how one tiny branch can comprise the vast majority of the speakers of a language family in a few centuries.
I'm not "purposefully distorting history", those are mistakes I've made. You're making a mountain out of a mole hill. And I'm not happy America exterminated Native Americans. You clearly have the wrong impression. But yes I do support Tibetan independence. Sue me.
The difference is it's too late for European descendants to leave North America. But Tibet lost its independence only 60 years ago. People are still alive who lived in a time of Tibetan independence.
It was actually spreading around , diversifying while absorbing local austro-asiatic languages. He also didn't portray the spread of the Tibetic languages (Tibetan, Burmese etc.), but that might be due to the limited available information of that period.
its because the writing system tied and reined them in. different regions, you may hear them say things differently but ultimately, they were writing the same characters so it was just portrayed to be one big blob of old chinese
I'm not sure. You chose a handful of families or languages with well-established origins, but the same can't be said for a lot of families and languages of the world. There are sometimes multiple competing theories, and you're bound to anger some nationalist. I hope you won't apply the same logic as your "Tamil-Telugu-Kannada" static frame to other languages or families.
Actually telugu is born from sanskrit it's my mother tongue many poets believe telugu is from sanskrit but This leftist propaganda of Aryan migration theory don't accept it I feel so sad for my self
@@kamalnadh2445 uh... no, it's a Dravidian language, It has a lot of Sanskrit influence and has been heavily influenced by it, but is not a descendant of Sanskrit.
@@anirudh177 all Indian languages are from sanskrit. So are all the indo european langs. This guy shows the mainstream eurocentric history. He supports ait.
There is like 50 very different languages in the Caucase. It just impossible to put them all in. It's why Alan disapear from the map when they became a minor language -> it's impossible to show all languages
Non la langue bretonne est issue d'un mélange très particulier entre les langues celtiques, saxonnes, le latin et même peut-être le gaulois D'ailleurs le breton serait même plus influencé par le latin que le français car ce-dernier à d'autres influences notamment grecques et germaniques
Vous confondez, le Breton est bel et bien celte, ici la carte nous montre les langues sur le plan phylogénique et non sur le plan des influences que la langue a subi, sinon l'anglais ne serait pas considéré comme une langue germanique.
GonoszManó HUN todays Hungarians genes dont show any close similarities within the old huns, And we both are mixed. Even the European huns werent fully Mongoloid when they were Going like a giant shadow towards the west lol Deal with it
I love this a lot as a hobby linguist and map fan! However, you should write a little comment that there are many missing languages (Cacausian, Uralic, Basque, ...).
Szerintem a nyelvünknek se a népünknek semmi köze az "uráli" nyelvekhez, sokkal több közünk van a turániakhoz. Például a mandzsu nyelvben a szótári alak "mi"-vel végződik míg a magyarban "ni"-vel. Tatárul "bolğarım" magyarul "bolgárom" a pontnélküli i az egy mély hangrendű i.
Csak azért mert átvették az ogur törököktől a számokat kereskedelmen keresztül az nem jelenti azt, hogy testvéreink. Az uráli nyelveknek több közük van az indo-európai nyelvekhez mint a török nyelvekhez. A mi nyelvünk ogur török, s a csuvas az egyetlen közeli testvérünk.
Some Turks can't accept the fact that their language came from East Asia and that the old anatolian language was indo-european lelz , is impossble that indo-european expanded to everywhere close to them and then forgot to expand to anatolia .. Stupid , and then get mad ... Just give a bad name to other Turkic speakers...
Dude please every Turk know that we came from Central Asia , most of Turks are nationalist and know their brothers very well but just stop that FAKE things because i have never seen a Turk claims to be Native Anatolian
@George Prasinos If you look on genetics , yes we are the most close race to Hittiets , because of assimilation.We are not pure Anatolian but we are not pure Turk either.We call us Anatolian Turks :P
1:34 this Is mistake. What "old Qarakhanid"? Qarakhanid is a name of a dynasty of medieval turkic khaganate in Central Asia approximately in 11-12 centuries. This state appeared there after falling of several turkic kaghanates. Maybe it's correct to call a language of turkic family in medieval as Qarakhanid, but it's definitely wrong to call some language "old qarakhanid", that existed there, ten centuries before first turkic tribes appeared there
They didn't "lowkey" take over. The Scythians and Saka were genocided and/or assimilated into the migrating Turkic tribes. No need to sugarcoat history.
the Indo Europeans let them in and taught them their knowledge and you saw how they slowly spread and killed them. It is happening all over again today. At one time we gave them the chariot, and horseback and now it is cars, planes and trains, at one time it was swords, and arrows now it is advanced military weapons. We always give them our technology and they use it against us. When will we learn.
Proud Iranian Barbaric lol? Thats why your language is mix of Sanskrit Arabic and "Proto-Turkic(Sumerian, Ellams)" That's why you use Turkic "men" for personal pronouns. How can Barbars teach you a language if they are barbar?
Average life of the alt right: sees Turk mentioned in a video, instantly thinks of Constantinople, half of europe conquered, janissaries and islam. Heartrate increases, starts sweating, smashes keyboard typing "muhh Turks are butthurt"
How can you even defend these Turkish nationalists. They give the other Turkic people such a terrible rep. I don't want people to read these propaganda Turkish comments and think all turkic people are like this. It shames me as a Kazakh.
Geras Al-Aqras most Turkic people are mixed even in central Asia. It just happens that Turkish people are one of the most Caucasian admixture at 85% on average. There are quite a bit Turkish people who look a bit Asian. They are uncommon but you can find them. There are central Asian Turks with blonde hair and blue eyes with Asian features as well. Most Turkic people are Eurasian and have been a mostly mixed race people for thousands of years. I am not Turkic by the way
By 250 AD, Old Chinese had definitely evolved into Middle Chinese. This video uses the establishment of Tang Dynasty as the starting point of Middle Chinese, but in fact, by that time, Middle Chinese had already passed its middle stage to its late stage.
Nice. I kinda hoped that north africa was part of here as well because linguistically it's very much interwoven with classical european times, as well as medieval arabic times, both are civilisations from Eurasia with Eurasian language. And I miss Basque. Good to see Dutch and Frisian split.
Great video! I just want to point out that Classical Latin wasn't the language that spread across the Roman Empire, it was Vulgar Latin since the beginning. Classical Latin is just the name of the literary form of the language written and spoken in formal and artistic contexts in Rome, and wasn't spoken in everyday life by the common people (the "vulgus", the ones who brough Latin with them to the provinces). Vulgar Latin does NOT descend from Classical Latin; rather the two descend from Archaic Latin, and coexisted side by side throughout the Empire's lifespan.
Vulgar latin is literally just another way of saying “how the common people spoke latin”, it is not a distinct Language, neither is it genuine to call it different to Classical Latin. The romance language stem from Classical Latin, nothing more, nothing less. Classical Latin vs “Vulgar” (more appropriately called local dialects of) Latin, is better the difference between British English and Standard Southern English. An overview language as opposed to dialects. Hope this helps!
I think you should know this, Occitan and Catalan languages were born from old Occitan. I say it because I do not want you to put in the pt. 2 that the Catalan is born from the West Iberian
it's an experimental video and is justified as ollie bye said that he would do more if people like this. if they would be somewhere, they will be in the history of European languages.
Can people in the comments stop denying the Indo-Europeian language family? Sanskrit shares a lot with Lithuanian, two Indo-Europeian languages without cultural or religious contact at all. And Sanskrit is NOT the first language ever spoken.
So for you the area that is now romania has not been habited for thousands of years until the avars came ...and after that all of the sudden you put hungarian there ? You should have put Thracian in modern day Bulgaria and in modern Romania Dacian , dacian dissapeard in the 4th-5th century according to conventional historians and after that in that area was already a proto-romanian being spoke (a mix between dacian , latin and of other minor languages)
Like I said in my comment, I can make more of these in the future. This could include, for example, one about Europe where I can be more specific about Romania.
Ollie Bye i can respect that , and i generally love your work , but in this one i found a lot of blank spaces (not only Romania, but im using Romania as an example as im familiar with it the most) where it would have been very easy to fill them adding just one or two extra languages. I did not read your comment thou
Proto Indo European ↓ Proto Indo Iranian ↓ Vedic Sanskrit ↓ Maharashtri ↓ Konkani ↓ Marathi (my mother tongue) NB: I also speak Sanskrit and occasionally Hindi (standard Sanskritized Hindi).
Very little known about the native European languages before the Indo-European expansion but they were definitely there. In other words Scandinavians didn't speak Germanic language, Southern Europeans didn't speak IE language, Central Europeans didn't speak IE language. I believe the sound of the ancient, forgotten languages still remain in the regional accents. That's why French accent is so different from Italian. Qui croissant patisserie vs Mama mia pizzeria.
@@francoisdaureville323 You didn't understand my point. I am talking about the pre Indo-European languages before the R1B people moved in and the area was mainly Y-DNA I type of people. This is was more than 4,000 years ago, way before Gaulish and Frankish languages existed. To quote Wiki "Early speakers of Indo-European daughter languages most likely expanded into Europe with the incipient Bronze Age, around 4,000 years ago."
Median is NOT a Persian language! However, old Persian and Median have the same roots (Western Iranian). Median is the old language of (Kurdish, Zaza, Talyshi, Iranian Azeri...)
He never said it was Persian, a la Farsi. It was an Iranian language, of the Indo-Iranian branch of the Indo-European language family, which is a well-known fact.
Culturally Arabic, but I suppose it kind of goes along with, for example, how the English people are of Germanic ethnicity and culture despite using Arabic numerals.
@@shbhmmn How can Urdu be a Fake language. It got its name recently but it is couple of centuries old. Vedic Sanskrit》Saurasenic Prakrit》Apabhràmsa》Hindvi》Dakhni 》Rekhta》Urdu & Hindi.
@@ammaraslamhirai6549 I agree about dakhni urdu tho But dont agree about so called pure hindi and pure urdu (: and please your hyderabad food sucks its too much spicy fix it for the sake of poor people like me ):
It’s so sad and depressing seeing the ancient East Iranic Saka and Tocharian languages (and people) in Xinjiang being gradually replaced by the fuckin turkic languages (and bastards) starting in 9 century just after Chinese power withdrew from Central Asia. We will never forget you - once prosperous tiny east Iranic oasis kingdoms of Qiuci , Shule, jingjue, Yutian and Loulan, now buried deep in the harshest desert sand of Taklamakan.
0:05 right from the start Semitic languages are absent which were actually Written languages back then. But he made sure to include all these hypothetical languages the earliest written record of which were thousands of years in the future. Also completely ignores an entire Family of languages that have a written record as ancient as 1200BC (old south Arabian languages). I can go on and on, Poorly researched video.
Modern Chinese languages include about 8 or 9 languages (based on different classifications). There must be a long time of how these languages are shaped from ancient Chinese. But the details are probably not well studied yet. It would be great if you could specify them.
You forgot Latin in the Balkans. Romanian is a Romance language, not a slavic one, and other Romance languages (Dalmate) managed to survive in Yugoslavia until the end of the 19th century.
Siberia was soooo cold they had to come to Altai mountains(which are also cold ) They migrated to steppe Steppe has no water or farm land it's dog shit So they went West Asia
@ehsan_iq proto semitic and afro asiatic came to the middle East around 10000bc which is much older than any evidence of an indo European language but this guy casually puts no semetic language in the beginning ignoring the fact that all semetic languages were one language.
SAQER SAQER, the area of origin of the Semitic langages is disputed turns out. So I’ll retract my claim and reiterate it as an opinion. You should too, knowing that your answer isn’t any truer than mine.
Hunnic language was not turkic. Unfortunatelly the complete hunnic language is unknown but there are 500-600 words and few sentence (big thanks for Uchiraltu mongolian linguist) and this is very similar or same with hungarian language. I'm native hungarian speaker and i can understand 30% (!) of old hunnic words without any difficulty, examples: szerild (hun) = szeretet (hungarian) = love szirünesen (hun) = szivtelen (hungarian) = hearthless szkálta = sánta = lame talba = talp = sole atha = apa = father ecse = öcs = male little brother elüd = előd = ancestor szaghu = szag = smell deli = déli = southern kert = kert = garden lüthü = lejtő = slope orem = orom = peak tengir = tenger = sea szikesi = szikes = soil tava = tó = lake ( interesting but this hunnic word is equal with hungarian genitive case, for exmample Tavam = my lake) vezi = viz = wather vüldi = völgy = valley bagialu = bagoly = owl beka = béka = frog büka = bika = bull kutha = kutya = dog majmun = majom = monkey sas = sas = eagle sasaka = sáska = grasshopper süle = sün = hedgehog üker = ökör = ox tüve = teve = camel alma = alma = apple muha = moha = moss niwár = nyár = summer teremtild = teremtés = creation virágh = virág = flower sár = sár = mud jéj = jég = ice saves = savas = acidic szele = szél = wind zivud = zivatar = rainstorm bajnek = bajnok = champion kapu = kapu = gate küncse = kincs = treasure szava = szó = word utu = út = road vara = vár = castle etc etc etc The hun and hungarian conjugation, grammar are same: non finite clauses, lack of grammatical gender, lack of consonant clusters in word initial position. The hunnic language is an archaic hungarian language. Example for verb conjugation: ein volam (hunnic) = én voltam (hungarian) = i was (english) ti volajsz = te voltál = you were üj volaj = ő volt = he/she was minkh volánkh = mi voltunk = we were tikh volántukh = ti voltatok = you were üjkh volánukh = ők voltak = they were Hun-hungarian entences: Hegü istahainitet ai urrusaghitet, urritet. (hun) = Tiszteld istenedet és országodat, uradat! (hungarian) = Respect your God, your land and your master! (english) Vojgum Athira Istahain Wusturje (hun) = Attila vagyok isten ostorja (hungarian) = I'm Attila, scourge of God Aluvüne istahainje inejvet berüin száhátwra! (hun) = Ne vedd Isten nevét hiába szádra! (hungarian) = Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain (english) So yes the hunnic language was uralic.
Turkish Hunnic Hungarian Ata Atha Apa Ancestor, Father Taban Talba Talp Sole Tanrı tengir tenger (God in Turkish) Sea Tava Tava To (Tava means pan in Turkish but if you add "m" like tavam it means "My pan") Vadi Vüldi Volgy Valley Maymun Majmun Majom Monkey Öküz Üker Ökör Ox Elma Alma Alma Apple Deve Tüve Teve Camel Kapı Kapu Kapu Gate Künçe Küncse Kincs Treasure Söz Szava Szo Word Koku Szaghu Szag Smell Boğa Büka Bika Bull
Berkay Anıl You do realize a lot of those words are Persian in Origin. Meymun is a Persian word that is burrowed into Turkish. Same with Kanj meaning treasure. The Huns were a multi-ethnic confederation. They mainly were a Finno-Ugric People but also included Slavs and the Iranian Peoples of the Pontic-Caspian Steppe(Scythians, Sarmatians, Alans). Where a lot of the words were adopted. Turkish has a lot Persian words naturally from being the official court langauge of the Ottoman Empire for centuries.
Wasn't Sanskrit still a major lingua franca language for India well past the collapse of the Empire of Harsha and still a language of great prominence in the courts and universities of the Vijayanagar Empire ?
Tamils and aborigines of Australia look similar. Tamils are not natives to India. Their ancestors first reached south east coast of India somewhere from south east Asia.
Those area he put proto Turkic I think was Uysun(乌孙) language, where located in Jeti su river area(七河流域). In our Kazakh’s Great Juz we have a tribe called (Sari) Uysun which is the direct offspring of those ancestors. The famous ruler of that old Uysun called El jau Kunbi (烈骄昆莫) who mentioned in great Chinese historical book Han shu (汉书) written by Si ma qian (司马迁), also the famous Chinese diplomat called Zhang Qian 张骞 who lived in the time of beginning of silk way road written in his journey said Uysun kingdom was the most powerful country in the west (西域46国中最强国家）among 46 little countries, we should allied with them to fight against Hun empire(匈奴帝国）。Nowadays Chinese Kazakh living in those are called Kunes(昭苏县）, the Chinese named after the princess of Han empire who married Uysun ruler Eljau Kunbi。
Yunanı yoğurdu,cacığı,baklavayı götürür. Bulgarı Kayı Boyu'nun damgasını götürür.Yeter amk ya. Çala çala bir bitiremediniz. Adamlar Türk adını görünce direk kuduz köpek gibi saldırıyorlar.
I like this video so much. Can you please add finno-ugric languages to the map? Also, show the approximate origins of proto-languages and splits as knots on your map. Thank you.
One problem is that the different Prakrut languages didn't came from Sanskrut but rather were separate from it. Sanskrut itself became what it is when a grammarian chose a language from North to be standardised & later someone else standardised the other Prakrut languages like Maharashtri, etc. Also Rajasthani is rather a very new name of an old language & named after the state of Rajasthan which itself was renamed from Rajputana as it was during British time. Both probably has similar meanings, as Rajputana is land of the Rajput clans or caste & Rajasthan is perhaps land of Rajas/Kings.
Rakesh Kumar Thanks for the reply. But isn't the name Rajasthan a new name (probably from the British time) while these languages are much older. Which is why I'm never convinced over the name Rajasthani for a language or even a group of languages. To me it honestly feels similar to when a friend of mine ignorantly called _Kannada_ as Bangalorian & I heard someone else call it Karnataki. So I thought _Marwadi_ is probably the name as the largest dialect while other dialects also exist & have other names. Also it's unfortunate that language of the land & it's people gets rejected by some of it's own people for an outside language.
Rakesh Kumar I've read about those articles but given the kind of pride those politicians have regarding their own language in these states including Rajasthan I doubt it'd be achieved anytime soon. If they were really serious & had genuine pride they'd have recognised it as their state's official language & started using it in government work while promoting it in schools as a compulsory language. But that's my opinion & I really don't know if a state can just recognise a language for their own use without the permission of GOI. My main issue with Rajasthani is just the name as it sounds too artificial for a real age old language cause if the state was still called Rajputana then would they still call it Rajasthani or may be Rajputani or something similar. _Maithili_ too was once counted under hindi I think but somehow they managed to get recognised while other _Bihari or Eastern_ languages continue being counted under hindi. I do wonder how they did it but others keep failing or may be they aren't really trying that hard. Yes, the _Dravidian_ bloc certainly has less of these problems as apart from the 4 main languages that have their own states only a few others are prominently known most of which I think are in Karnataka alone like _Tulu (also in Kerala), Coorgi, Kodava, etc._ but problems with the languages you mentioned is that many have their own states but its people & most importantly the politicians are less than interested in doing anything for their own language. For example, Bihar recognises hindi & later also recognised urdu but not their own language that is native to their land & still spoken by their people. Also I believe federalism for India would be a great option to protect all the languages & cultures from slowly dying out due to lack of public awareness as states will be expected to look after themselves without looking towards GOI for any permission making it easier to get things done like recognising or giving prominence to their native language in government work & education. Obviously such a thing is even more difficult.
fun fact: old malay is not the oldest malay language ever founded, this video was based on brittish empire literature which refers to Sumatran as malay while borneo is the home of malay language.
Conveniently not showing Finland, Iceland and most of Scandinavia. What happened to Sanskrit and Hebrew? Hebrew is more than 6000 years old bruh. Pretty lousy vid.
How is Hebrew 6000 years old when it says that Abraham moved out from Ur, and that the jews left Egypt around 1200BC? It just can't be. 4000 is plausible but 6000 is bullshit
It is sad indeed. The Scythians of Central Asia were absorbed. But most of the Scythian’s left before the Turks moved in. Many Scythians moved into Europe and India.
That's what all ethnicities have done to others. Indo-Europeans did the same thing to Vascons, Etruscans, pre-Greek civilizations and ancient anatolian peoples living before Indo-European expansion.
There isn’t such a thing as Old Arabic, But Arabic was a language Family: The first form was Qahtanite Arabic, (in Yemen) today called South Arabian. Today it’s many dialects. Nabatean started in Jordan. Lehyanite North KSA Thamudi North KSA Adnanite Qurashi Hejazi Arabic in Central Arabia is the one used now as classic arabic
ehsan_iq I’ve been studying this for 4 years. Arabic has many forms. The Old Arabic languages were Sabaean (later Himyarite), Thamudi, Dedanite,lihyanite, Hejazi, Qurashi and different types of Najdi. They used to be nearly different languages. Though there isn’t something called Old Arabic but there is something called Old Arabian Languages. Because the old Arabian languages were never one. Even today, Fusha Arabic we use is Qurashi and our accents like Egyptian Lebanese Khaleeji etc were all a blend of The Qurashi, neighbouring languages and if it was in the Arabian Peninsula then it would also be a blend of the old Arabian languages based on the are. Some areas like in Yemen Oman UAE and Saudi are trilingual they could speak: Fusha Arabic, One of the Old Arabic languages, And the local country dialect.
ehsan_iq Btw I studied this for 4 years In Medina very well. What u Said is correct but what u call Old Arabic are all different languages that Are Ishmaelite they were not unified into a single language called old Arabian. The Southern Arabian languages are purer than the Ishmaelite ones bcuz Ishmaelites were arabised by Qahtanites the pure Arabs of the south
ehsan_iq Your correct. But they were never one language. However, the actual pure Arabs are descendents of Qahtan bin Hud, it’s not a myth, bcuz our prophet said it he said that Ishmael was arabised by arabs and that he made a new type or kind of Arabs, and he said that Qahtanites are the purest of Arabs and are the arabisers of Ishmael. The Qahatanite Himyarite tribe of Jurhum were the people who arabised Ishmael in Mecca. It was even already known before our prophet pbuh but then our prophet proved it.
Your Aramaic and Arabic (in the Arab world) is just plain and simply wrong. Aramaic was spoken in the Arabian peninsula at some point, and Arabic was spoken in the Levant and Iraq at some point as well. There are many other languages that were not mentioned as well.
@@ckrafael6386 bahasa melayu malaysia skrang ni pon bukannya asli bahasa melayu dulu bahasa melayu tulen pure austronesian macam bahasa orang sabah sarawak. Bahasa melayu sekarang dah campur2 bahasa sanskrit, and arab sejak kedatangan Buddha, Hindu pastu Islam beratus tahun dulu sama macam bhs indon sbb bhs indon pon dtg dari bhs melayu
The video is wrong there are evidence of some other languages developed in maritime south east Asia in 9th century and there is no evidence that people in the east of archipelago use that language. And old Malay wasn't that old the first evidence of it's existence found Palembang, Sumatra written in 7th century CE, before that no one knows what we use as our language.
Bebek Dragon . Austronesian Is Almost Comepletely Mixed. All Of Austronesian Language Are Already Mixed. Taiwan And Vietnamese Is Influced By Chinnese Malay Is Influced By Arab And Persian Java Is Influced By Sanskrit And Hindi And Other Indian Language And Also Some Dutch And Malay Word Rest Of Indo (Except Papua) Influced By Dutch And Other His Austronesian Family Papua And Malanesia Is Of Course Influced By East Papua Family (Papua Family Is Most Isolated Family) Malagasy Is Mixed With Bantu People . Micronesia And Polynesia Is Mixed Lit Bit By Papua Family This Is Acoording To My Reasearch. If Its Wrong Fell Free To Reply Here
![Countries World War 3 🌍[In a Nutshell and Fight] ⚔️⚔️ [All Episodes] #countryballs #worldprovinces](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/07vt8RTZZ6Y/mqdefault.jpg)
a moment of silence for the nameless languages that were wiped out before they could be recorded
Yup the world was as linguistically rich at any given point as it is now, we only know about a subset of the languages that existed. PIE existed alongside other languages, probably even related ones that left no descendants as it was itself part of some language family. Just look at the Turkic languages to see how one tiny branch can comprise the vast majority of the speakers of a language family in a few centuries.
...
Her: Talk dirty to me.
Me: *talks in vulgar Latin*
HOSTIA NON OSTIA, GLIS NON GLIRUS YOU DEGENERATE!
Oh lo vedo quod ei est un homo di gran gratiæ et istrutionæ, ad eam porgo li mei plus auditi giovalitii!
Turpis valde, tam deformis es ut rana similis es.
Talks in prakrit(~vulgar sanskrit)
@@franchufranchu119 its wingardium leviosa u uncultured swine
I find thy lack of Finno-Ugriatic languages disturbing. Good video though!
I'm not "purposefully distorting history", those are mistakes I've made. You're making a mountain out of a mole hill. And I'm not happy America exterminated Native Americans. You clearly have the wrong impression. But yes I do support Tibetan independence. Sue me.
EmperorTigerstar Dali lama is against Tibetan independence you know ? He only wants high degree of autonomy .so you’re pretty much against him.haha
The difference is it's too late for European descendants to leave North America. But Tibet lost its independence only 60 years ago. People are still alive who lived in a time of Tibetan independence.
EmperorTigerstar it’s not too late.illegal is illegal no matter how long he stayed in. Just fuck back to Europe now,it won’t be too late,trust me.
"Kind to Tibet"
That's why the Dalai Lama fled, right? The way you're trying to out-moral me is sad. Find something else to devote your energy to.
Old Chinese just casually shifting around a bit
It was actually spreading around , diversifying while absorbing local austro-asiatic languages. He also didn't portray the spread of the Tibetic languages (Tibetan, Burmese etc.), but that might be due to the limited available information of that period.
In fact Southern Chinese didn't speak Old Chinese at first, but what language they spoke is still debateful.
its because the writing system tied and reined them in. different regions, you may hear them say things differently but ultimately, they were writing the same characters so it was just portrayed to be one big blob of old chinese
yuenhang fung you make me laugh, learn silk road history and Zheng he expedition,
Spucky 123r you know what?
OLD MALAY
So this is mainly an experimental video - I can continue with other videos about languages if you think that would be interesting.
spread of arabic in the middle east/africa
Ollie Bye it was great. I think you should make more videos about languages like this :)
I would definitely like to see a part 2
I'm not sure. You chose a handful of families or languages with well-established origins, but the same can't be said for a lot of families and languages of the world. There are sometimes multiple competing theories, and you're bound to anger some nationalist.
I hope you won't apply the same logic as your "Tamil-Telugu-Kannada" static frame to other languages or families.
I love languages. This was quite informative :)
I like how Telugu, Kannada, Tamil, Old Malay, and Formosan just sat there. Doing nothing. Very funny.
and old Chinese
Actually telugu is born from sanskrit it's my mother tongue many poets believe telugu is from sanskrit but
This leftist propaganda of Aryan migration theory don't accept it
I feel so sad for my self
60% of kannada is sanskrit
@@kamalnadh2445 uh... no, it's a Dravidian language, It has a lot of Sanskrit influence and has been heavily influenced by it, but is not a descendant of Sanskrit.
@@anirudh177 all Indian languages are from sanskrit. So are all the indo european langs. This guy shows the mainstream eurocentric history. He supports ait.
what about Georgian and Caucasian languages?
Tornike Namicheishvili
Yes, he probably forgot :/
I'm chechen ^^
That doesn't really excuse not including it, i think he simply forgot.
There is like 50 very different languages in the Caucase. It just impossible to put them all in. It's why Alan disapear from the map when they became a minor language -> it's impossible to show all languages
cesar the imperator
True.
But our languages existed before Alanic
Tornike Namicheishvili It is bullshit video i have ever seen. You must be happy to not see your language here!
Today, the Indo-European Language Family is survived by 3 major language families, these are :
*1) The European Languages:*
A) Armenian
B) Albanian
C) Anatolian
D) Greek
E) *Celtic:* Irish, Scottish Gaelic, Manx, Welsh, Cornish, Breton
F) *Norse:* Icelandic, Norwegian, Danish, Swedish
G) *Romance:* Romanian, Italian, French, Spanish, Portuguese
H) *Germanic:* English, Scotts, Dutch, German, Flemish, Luxembourgish, Swiss
I) *Baltic:* Prussian, Lithuanian, Latvian
J) *Slavic:* Russian, Ukrainian, Czech, Slovak, Polish, Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian, Macedonian, Bulgarian.
*2) The Iranic Languages:*
A) Avestan
B) *Western Iranic:* Median, Parthian, Kurdish, Balochi, Zoroastrian Dari, Farsi (Standard Persian), Afghani Dari, Tajiki, Hazaragi, Sistani, Pahlavi
C) *Eastern Iranic:* Scythian, Saka, Bactrian, Khwarezmiam, Sogdian, Khotanese, Samartian, Pashto, Pamiri, Alanian, Ossetian
*4) The Indic Languages:*
Vedic Sanskrit: Classical Sanskrit: Prakrit:
A) Gandhari: Pali
B) Shauraseni:
*Western Hindustani:* Kharibaoli (Standard Hindi), Rekhta (Standard Urdu), Dakhini Urdu, Haryanvi, Braj, Kannauji, Bundeli, Avanti
*Eastern Hindustani:* Awadhi, Bagheli, Chattisgarhi
*Dardic:* Kashmiri, Kishtwari, Shina, Chitrali, Kalash, Kohistani, Pashai
*Western Pahari:* Dogri, Kangri, Kinnauri
*Eastern Pahari:* Garhwali, Kumaoni, Nepali
*North-Western:* Punjabi, Lahnda, Saraiki, Hindko, Pothwari, Sindhi, Kutchi, Memoni
*Western:* Rajasthani (Bagri, Marwari, Mewari, Mewati, Shekhawati, Malvi), Gojari, Gujarati, Saurashtri, Bhili, Khandeshi, Romani
C) Magadhi Prakrit:
*Bihari:* Maithili, Angika, Bhojpuri, Magahi
*Bengali:* Bangla (Standard), Manipuri, Sylheti, Sunderbani, Chittagonian, Chakma, Rohingya
*Assamese:* Assami/Ahamiya/Ahomi (Standard), Kamarupi, Rajbanshi
Odia
D) Maharashtri Prakrit:
*Maratha:* Marathi (Standard), Berar Deccani, Varli
Konkani
Sinhala
Divehi
_________________________________________
*The End*
🇮🇳💟💟💟💟💟 Great Brother
What about tokharian language ??
You forgot a lot of language in India
@@iSyriux it's an extinct language family, that's why not included.
@@kxnyshk Why are extinct iranic language included then ?
The "Brittonic languages " also survive in the west of France in a region called "Brittany" in English !!
Non la langue bretonne est issue d'un mélange très particulier entre les langues celtiques, saxonnes, le latin et même peut-être le gaulois
D'ailleurs le breton serait même plus influencé par le latin que le français car ce-dernier à d'autres influences notamment grecques et germaniques
Vous confondez, le Breton est bel et bien celte, ici la carte nous montre les langues sur le plan phylogénique et non sur le plan des influences que la langue a subi, sinon l'anglais ne serait pas considéré comme une langue germanique.
No one speak Breton in Brittany lmao
@@mathis_cmr6379 And that's thanks to who? : )
@@LuisRincon-wr4dm France?
Proto-Turkic suddenly appearing from nowhere is funny
sumerians are the ancestors of ours.
i like how Hunnic was like a cannonball which wiped out a bunch of languages with its arrival
That's just how the Huns roll.
뛟䨻龘㠨滚ဪ yes hunnic strong. Do You Chinese know Mete han? Mau-Tun???
뛟䨻龘㠨滚ဪ thanks Chinese, hunnic Strong China Stronkkkk
뛟䨻龘㠨滚ဪ Hunnic was not turkic language, it was archaic hungarian so this map is wrong.
GonoszManó HUN todays Hungarians genes dont show any close similarities within the old huns, And we both are mixed. Even the European huns werent fully Mongoloid when they were Going like a giant shadow towards the west lol Deal with it
I love this a lot as a hobby linguist and map fan! However, you should write a little comment that there are many missing languages (Cacausian, Uralic, Basque, ...).
No Uralic languages?
Horváth Miklós Finnish, Hungarian, Estonian, Sami to name a few
Altay-Ural is belong to Turkic in video
Hungarian is not Uralic.
Szerintem a nyelvünknek se a népünknek semmi köze az "uráli" nyelvekhez, sokkal több közünk van a turániakhoz.
Például a mandzsu nyelvben a szótári alak "mi"-vel végződik míg a magyarban "ni"-vel.
Tatárul "bolğarım" magyarul "bolgárom" a pontnélküli i az egy mély hangrendű i.
Csak azért mert átvették az ogur törököktől a számokat kereskedelmen keresztül az nem jelenti azt, hogy testvéreink.
Az uráli nyelveknek több közük van az indo-európai nyelvekhez mint a török nyelvekhez.
A mi nyelvünk ogur török, s a csuvas az egyetlen közeli testvérünk.
Some Turks can't accept the fact that their language came from East Asia and that the old anatolian language was indo-european lelz , is impossble that indo-european expanded to everywhere close to them and then forgot to expand to anatolia .. Stupid , and then get mad ... Just give a bad name to other Turkic speakers...
The original langauges spoken in anatolia such as urartian language, Hattian langauge werent indo-european
Dude please every Turk know that we came from Central Asia , most of Turks are nationalist and know their brothers very well but just stop that FAKE things because i have never seen a Turk claims to be Native Anatolian
Everyone know that we invaded Anatolia , we took it by blood we will give it by blood !
@George Prasinos If you look on genetics , yes we are the most close race to Hittiets , because of assimilation.We are not pure Anatolian but we are not pure Turk either.We call us Anatolian Turks :P
@George Prasinos But we claim to be Turk.So everyone except idiots know that we came from Asia.
1:34 this Is mistake. What "old Qarakhanid"? Qarakhanid is a name of a dynasty of medieval turkic khaganate in Central Asia approximately in 11-12 centuries. This state appeared there after falling of several turkic kaghanates. Maybe it's correct to call a language of turkic family in medieval as Qarakhanid, but it's definitely wrong to call some language "old qarakhanid", that existed there, ten centuries before first turkic tribes appeared there
So what to call it?
Macky Cabangon mix it with the “Old Turkic”.
George Nathanael wouldn’t be accurate.
Turkic lanuages low key taking over like 'ssst we just passing by'
They didn't "lowkey" take over. The Scythians and Saka were genocided and/or assimilated into the migrating Turkic tribes. No need to sugarcoat history.
MrSafa61 we were horse rider that's why it is normal
Taha Tuncel aynennnn
the Indo Europeans let them in and taught them their knowledge and you saw how they slowly spread and killed them. It is happening all over again today. At one time we gave them the chariot, and horseback and now it is cars, planes and trains, at one time it was swords, and arrows now it is advanced military weapons. We always give them our technology and they use it against us. When will we learn.
@@mehemetyilmaz231 Are you listening to your stupid ass? "We did genocide and we're proud of it"
You absolute fool.
Roman Empire Classical Latin: *Exists*
Gaulish and Celt-Iberian: I don’t feel so good Mr.Stark
3:23 report Avars they re hacking
AVARS SPEED HACK
They are nomad turks, always used horses thats normal
@@jasonbecker8893 r/woooooosh
@@hannibalbarca7220 r/ihavereddit
Lmao
Avestan Persian Saka Parthian Sogdian Baktrian Median Scythian Sarmtian Kharazmian are Iranic(Iranian)Languages
Proud Iranian In your dream.
ANTI -ISLAMIST
I guessed that a Turkish professor Come below to my comment, no surprise
Proud Iranian Don't steal our history you smarty-pants
ANTI -ISLAMIST
Just get out from my comment
No one give shit about your barbaric history
Proud Iranian Barbaric lol? Thats why your language is mix of Sanskrit Arabic and "Proto-Turkic(Sumerian, Ellams)" That's why you use Turkic "men" for personal pronouns. How can Barbars teach you a language if they are barbar?
Why didn't you included Japan and Korea
Elias Frahat It is very controversial
Paplocino they are part of Eurasia
The Gaylord 1 people tell me this a lot these days
And happy to meet you again :D
Their grammar and phonetics are Turkic but then they have a wtf vocabulary and a wtf way of genetics so meh noone cares
Elias Frahat they are a part of Eurasia but nobody wants a comment war so not including them is a great idea.
Average life of the alt right: sees Turk mentioned in a video, instantly thinks of Constantinople, half of europe conquered, janissaries and islam. Heartrate increases, starts sweating, smashes keyboard typing "muhh Turks are butthurt"
So accurate.
Pepe I didn't saw any "alt right" in here
How can you even defend these Turkish nationalists. They give the other Turkic people such a terrible rep. I don't want people to read these propaganda Turkish comments and think all turkic people are like this. It shames me as a Kazakh.
Guts Likes It In The Ass Your are mongoloid than being Turk. So you can be ashamed. We don't care.
Geras Al-Aqras most Turkic people are mixed even in central Asia. It just happens that Turkish people are one of the most Caucasian admixture at 85% on average. There are quite a bit Turkish people who look a bit Asian. They are uncommon but you can find them. There are central Asian Turks with blonde hair and blue eyes with Asian features as well. Most Turkic people are Eurasian and have been a mostly mixed race people for thousands of years. I am not Turkic by the way
Bro can u mention clearly about Dravidian language (Malayalam,Tamil, Telugu, Kannada,Tulu).
U forgot Malayalam
@@aniketsingh419 s bro sorry, corrected .
Also brahui(pakistan),toda etc.
@@aniketsingh419 Malayalam came from Tamil after 1000CE (the last year of the video)
I've been waiting for this forever. I wasn't disappointed.
By 250 AD, Old Chinese had definitely evolved into Middle Chinese. This video uses the establishment of Tang Dynasty as the starting point of Middle Chinese, but in fact, by that time, Middle Chinese had already passed its middle stage to its late stage.
Nice.
I kinda hoped that north africa was part of here as well because linguistically it's very much interwoven with classical european times, as well as medieval arabic times, both are civilisations from Eurasia with Eurasian language.
And I miss Basque.
Good to see Dutch and Frisian split.
This video is about Eurasia Not Africa
Why will africa be here wtf
Great video! I just want to point out that Classical Latin wasn't the language that spread across the Roman Empire, it was Vulgar Latin since the beginning. Classical Latin is just the name of the literary form of the language written and spoken in formal and artistic contexts in Rome, and wasn't spoken in everyday life by the common people (the "vulgus", the ones who brough Latin with them to the provinces). Vulgar Latin does NOT descend from Classical Latin; rather the two descend from Archaic Latin, and coexisted side by side throughout the Empire's lifespan.
Vulgar latin is literally just another way of saying “how the common people spoke latin”, it is not a distinct Language, neither is it genuine to call it different to Classical Latin. The romance language stem from Classical Latin, nothing more, nothing less. Classical Latin vs “Vulgar” (more appropriately called local dialects of) Latin, is better the difference between British English and Standard Southern English. An overview language as opposed to dialects. Hope this helps!
0:09 my mother tongue! Since 1600 BCE! I didn’t even know. But, I heard it wasn’t patronised by rules until SATAVAHANAS came.
Also, does language mean there need not be a writing system? ruclips.net/video/Tbp9AGGdJV8/видео.html
사실 한국과 일본은 유라시아 대륙에서 가장 문명이 늦게 시작된 지역이다.
대륙의 가장 가장자리에 있어서 철기 문명도 제일 늦게 보급되고
글이나 종교도 매우 늦은 지역임..
마치 1000년 앞선 아메리카 신대륙 같은 지역.
I think you should know this, Occitan and Catalan languages were born from old Occitan. I say it because I do not want you to put in the pt. 2 that the Catalan is born from the West Iberian
So you just ignored Caucasus (mostly Georgian) right? too complicated and not derived from any other major language :D
it's an experimental video and is justified as ollie bye said that he would do more if people like this. if they would be somewhere, they will be in the history of European languages.
malay, india, china and arabic really like their language. kept for soo long.
Sanskrit be like : -_-
@@indianvloggerbristy2880 hindi is so close to sanskrit.
Vedic sanskrit oldest language in the world
@@nothingexists5066 no
I like how Hungarian just appears out of thin air
Great job !
African civilisation of Japan? xD
Ok
Lol
are you trolling Adolf? lol
Danzig HD Mapper iii
RIP TOCHARIAN
lol, best comment in this comment section over all these squabbles on ethnicity.
@@TheMightyPenrak ikr
Indo-European FTW!! ✌️
Francesco Marafini 🖕
Why are you angry dude above?
I'm not with francesco btw.
that's not an identity
Can people in the comments stop denying the Indo-Europeian language family? Sanskrit shares a lot with Lithuanian, two Indo-Europeian languages without cultural or religious contact at all. And Sanskrit is NOT the first language ever spoken.
Sanskrit is the language of god.
Sacred Vedas are written in Sanskrit.
Vedas contain hymns and prayers dedicated to Hindu god.
So for you the area that is now romania has not been habited for thousands of years until the avars came ...and after that all of the sudden you put hungarian there ? You should have put Thracian in modern day Bulgaria and in modern Romania Dacian , dacian dissapeard in the 4th-5th century according to conventional historians and after that in that area was already a proto-romanian being spoke (a mix between dacian , latin and of other minor languages)
Like I said in my comment, I can make more of these in the future. This could include, for example, one about Europe where I can be more specific about Romania.
Ollie Bye i can respect that , and i generally love your work , but in this one i found a lot of blank spaces (not only Romania, but im using Romania as an example as im familiar with it the most) where it would have been very easy to fill them adding just one or two extra languages. I did not read your comment thou
Proto Indo European
↓
Proto Indo Iranian
↓
Vedic Sanskrit
↓
Maharashtri
↓
Konkani
↓
Marathi (my mother tongue)
NB: I also speak Sanskrit and occasionally Hindi (standard Sanskritized Hindi).
Very little known about the native European languages before the Indo-European expansion but they were definitely there. In other words Scandinavians didn't speak Germanic language, Southern Europeans didn't speak IE language, Central Europeans didn't speak IE language. I believe the sound of the ancient, forgotten languages still remain in the regional accents. That's why French accent is so different from Italian. Qui croissant patisserie vs Mama mia pizzeria.
Not really is because french was influenced by gaullish and frankish more than spanish and portuguese
@@francoisdaureville323 You didn't understand my point. I am talking about the pre Indo-European languages before the R1B people moved in and the area was mainly Y-DNA I type of people. This is was more than 4,000 years ago, way before Gaulish and Frankish languages existed. To quote Wiki "Early speakers of Indo-European daughter languages most likely expanded into Europe with the incipient Bronze Age, around 4,000 years ago."
Median is NOT a Persian language! However, old Persian and Median have the same roots (Western Iranian).
Median is the old language of (Kurdish, Zaza, Talyshi, Iranian Azeri...)
He never said it was Persian, a la Farsi. It was an Iranian language, of the Indo-Iranian branch of the Indo-European language family, which is a well-known fact.
man
i subscribe to you 4 years ago when are only 880 subs
i can say one thing
YOU DOING GREAT JOB HERE :D
No Basques? And what about the Uralic languages?
Wow so Urdu and Persian are Indo European languages with Arabic influenced alphabet
Culturally Arabic, but I suppose it kind of goes along with, for example, how the English people are of Germanic ethnicity and culture despite using Arabic numerals.
for fuck sake there is nothing as such urdu language its a fake language
@@shbhmmn How can Urdu be a Fake language.
It got its name recently but it is couple of centuries old.
Vedic Sanskrit》Saurasenic Prakrit》Apabhràmsa》Hindvi》Dakhni 》Rekhta》Urdu & Hindi.
@@ammaraslamhirai6549 I agree about dakhni urdu tho But dont agree about so called pure hindi and pure urdu (: and please your hyderabad food sucks its too much spicy fix it for the sake of poor people like me ):
Yeah it's very weird. I understand Hindi so I can understand Urdu but can't read it lmao
Lmfao, Gotta love how cool and smooth the Hunnic language is moving across the screen !
TURKIC LANGUAGE COMEBACK
koine greek is the same with medieval greek. I think you did a good job as far as i can tell
It’s so sad and depressing seeing the ancient East Iranic Saka and Tocharian languages (and people) in Xinjiang being gradually replaced by the fuckin turkic languages (and bastards) starting in 9 century just after Chinese power withdrew from Central Asia.
We will never forget you - once prosperous tiny east Iranic oasis kingdoms of Qiuci , Shule, jingjue, Yutian and Loulan, now buried deep in the harshest desert sand of Taklamakan.
Turks are descendants of Sakas so there is no problem about it.
太守苏定交趾 Scythians(Saka) are already Turkic lol
saka people spoke indo-european language, not turkic language.
Ulu Önder Gazi Francisco Franco Han Hazretleri oh yeah,Turks are even descendants of the Kurds .
ANTI -ISLAMIST saka and tocharian peoples were a part of the indo European family group.
No ,there’re not European you dumbass.
0:05 right from the start Semitic languages are absent which were actually Written languages back then. But he made sure to include all these hypothetical languages the earliest written record of which were thousands of years in the future. Also completely ignores an entire Family of languages that have a written record as ancient as 1200BC (old south Arabian languages). I can go on and on, Poorly researched video.
Korean and Japan language looks like Turkic language (I know its very different but something looks familiar)
they have the same grammar
And then here comes the denial people and comments
Triggered
According to many linguists, Yenisei is related to the Athabaskan languages of North America, such as Navajo.
Still waiting for pt2
Wow
@@OllieByept2: all languages evolved into computer code 100011101010101 language.
Modern Chinese languages include about 8 or 9 languages (based on different classifications). There must be a long time of how these languages are shaped from ancient Chinese. But the details are probably not well studied yet. It would be great if you could specify them.
many just evolved from middle chinese, not even from old chinese.
Part2?
Why didnt you show the Hungarians moving in from the styeppes? Also there were Old Uralic languages it could also just fit in the screen...
European Robin hungatians mix to huns and ugric
@@beknurerzhanov1175 nah, the Avars were mexed with the huns, not the hungarians.
You forgot Latin in the Balkans. Romanian is a Romance language, not a slavic one, and other Romance languages (Dalmate) managed to survive in Yugoslavia until the end of the 19th century.
Not bad, but little bit indoeuropean centralism. Altaic people from the Mars or Sirius:D?
Siberia was soooo cold they had to come to Altai mountains(which are also cold )
They migrated to steppe
Steppe has no water or farm land it's dog shit
So they went West Asia
Afghanistan language was Persian. Pashto came into existence in 16th century. Correct it!
Can you please mention the sources you used? It will proove your work is scientific and help people seeking for further studying of the material.
Before the Sinitic expansion to Southern China, there should be Austroasiatic and Tai-Kradai speakers there, yet you didn't mark them on your map.
I'm having a hard time finding the "butthurt Turks" 90% of the comment section is mentioning.
Hahah xD
check your own comment
WOW here in iberian peninsula we are the last tribes who had pre-indoeuropean lenguages
This is so stupid where is the southern Arabian languages and other Semitic languages?!!
Raed Alshehri
مالة داعي كل دا التعصب الأخ مطلع فقط على اللغات الهندية الأوربية بينما اللغات الاخرة ما يعرف عنهم شيء
@ehsan_iq proto semitic and afro asiatic came to the middle East around 10000bc which is much older than any evidence of an indo European language but this guy casually puts no semetic language in the beginning ignoring the fact that all semetic languages were one language.
The title is Eurasia not Eurasia and Africa.
SAQER SAQER, I assure you it originates from Africa.
SAQER SAQER, the area of origin of the Semitic langages is disputed turns out. So I’ll retract my claim and reiterate it as an opinion. You should too, knowing that your answer isn’t any truer than mine.
Ummayads conquered Iberia in 750 C.E, yet, at that time it says Vulgar Latin in Iberia... really not once Arabic appears there?
euskera?
It's the basque word for basque. 'Basque' comes from latin, Euskara is what they call themselves
too small to add, not a member of a large language family, even Japanese wasn't added
Balti just living in their lands not caring about world afares.
Where is korean
Korean have exist since before jurchen
isn't korean jurchen?
@@yumiryin8197 Korean is different from Jurchen
임희상 oh okay,I thought they share similar genes and turkic language..
Genghis Khan what is wrong in being mixed ?
Hassan Bassim everyone is mixed. Chinese are caucasian mixed with austronesian and mongolian.
I come from a family that is mix of Kannada-Telugu-Tamil. Very dravidian ancestry I see I come from that I learned from this video.
Hunnic language was not turkic. Unfortunatelly the complete hunnic language is unknown but there are 500-600 words and few sentence (big thanks for Uchiraltu mongolian linguist) and this is very similar or same with hungarian language. I'm native hungarian speaker and i can understand 30% (!) of old hunnic words without any difficulty, examples:
szerild (hun) = szeretet (hungarian) = love
szirünesen (hun) = szivtelen (hungarian) = hearthless
szkálta = sánta = lame
talba = talp = sole
atha = apa = father
ecse = öcs = male little brother
elüd = előd = ancestor
szaghu = szag = smell
deli = déli = southern
kert = kert = garden
lüthü = lejtő = slope
orem = orom = peak
tengir = tenger = sea
szikesi = szikes = soil
tava = tó = lake ( interesting but this hunnic word is equal with hungarian genitive case, for exmample Tavam = my lake)
vezi = viz = wather
vüldi = völgy = valley
bagialu = bagoly = owl
beka = béka = frog
büka = bika = bull
kutha = kutya = dog
majmun = majom = monkey
sas = sas = eagle
sasaka = sáska = grasshopper
süle = sün = hedgehog
üker = ökör = ox
tüve = teve = camel
alma = alma = apple
muha = moha = moss
niwár = nyár = summer
teremtild = teremtés = creation
virágh = virág = flower
sár = sár = mud
jéj = jég = ice
saves = savas = acidic
szele = szél = wind
zivud = zivatar = rainstorm
bajnek = bajnok = champion
kapu = kapu = gate
küncse = kincs = treasure
szava = szó = word
utu = út = road
vara = vár = castle
etc etc etc
The hun and hungarian conjugation, grammar are same: non finite clauses, lack of grammatical gender, lack of consonant clusters in word initial position. The hunnic language is an archaic hungarian language.
Example for verb conjugation:
ein volam (hunnic) = én voltam (hungarian) = i was (english)
ti volajsz = te voltál = you were
üj volaj = ő volt = he/she was
minkh volánkh = mi voltunk = we were
tikh volántukh = ti voltatok = you were
üjkh volánukh = ők voltak = they were
Hun-hungarian entences:
Hegü istahainitet ai urrusaghitet, urritet. (hun) = Tiszteld istenedet és országodat, uradat! (hungarian) = Respect your God, your land and your master! (english)
Vojgum Athira Istahain Wusturje (hun) = Attila vagyok isten ostorja (hungarian) = I'm Attila, scourge of God
Aluvüne istahainje inejvet berüin száhátwra! (hun) = Ne vedd Isten nevét hiába szádra! (hungarian) = Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain (english)
So yes the hunnic language was uralic.
Zselyke the Hun They are Turkic. Greeks were calling them as Tourk there is a historical article in Greek language that Huns were calling as Tourk in.
Zselyke the Hun some words are same in turkish
deve, ata, tenger, balta, yel, boğa, elma
camel, father, sea, axis, wind, bull, apple
Turkish Hunnic Hungarian
Ata Atha Apa Ancestor, Father
Taban Talba Talp Sole
Tanrı tengir tenger (God in Turkish) Sea
Tava Tava To (Tava means pan in Turkish but if you add "m" like tavam it means "My pan")
Vadi Vüldi Volgy Valley
Maymun Majmun Majom Monkey
Öküz Üker Ökör Ox
Elma Alma Alma Apple
Deve Tüve Teve Camel
Kapı Kapu Kapu Gate
Künçe Küncse Kincs Treasure
Söz Szava Szo Word
Koku Szaghu Szag Smell
Boğa Büka Bika Bull
Berkay Anıl
You do realize a lot of those words are Persian in Origin.
Meymun is a Persian word that is burrowed into Turkish.
Same with Kanj meaning treasure.
The Huns were a multi-ethnic confederation. They mainly were a Finno-Ugric People but also included Slavs and the Iranian Peoples of the Pontic-Caspian Steppe(Scythians, Sarmatians, Alans). Where a lot of the words were adopted. Turkish has a lot Persian words naturally from being the official court langauge of the Ottoman Empire for centuries.
AJ Ace A-N ataturk removed persian and arabic words bro now, our language 83% oghuz %17 foreign words
Wasn't Sanskrit still a major lingua franca language for India well past the collapse of the Empire of Harsha and still a language of great prominence in the courts and universities of the Vijayanagar Empire ?
Sanskrit was never lingua franca; various dialects of prakrit were.
Tamil a Indian language is the oldest and I'm proud to be Indian🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Tamil and sanskrit have the same origin. This Indo Aryan(European) theory is false.
@@prateek752 Source?
@@prateek752🤪😆
@@StichyWichy21 rss fake theories
Tamils and aborigines of Australia look similar.
Tamils are not natives to India. Their ancestors first reached south east coast of India somewhere from south east Asia.
Finno-Ugric languages: are we a joke to you?
At the thumbnail: the languages didn't discover africa and japan yet
Rakesh Kumar Well..
Eurasia = Europe + Asia
Asia has Japan and Korea
I am just too triggered, I have to make my own!
WOW YOU DON'T KNOW KOREA?!? >:(
So many languages but not one can describe how dead i am on the inside
Where is Basque?
Lucas Henrique ,n.e. Spain .
I'm seeing no Basque there, even at the end of the video
also its just such a minor damn language that i can't say i'm surprised he didn't add it in
Those area he put proto Turkic I think was Uysun(乌孙) language, where located in Jeti su river area(七河流域). In our Kazakh’s Great Juz we have a tribe called (Sari) Uysun which is the direct offspring of those ancestors. The famous ruler of that old Uysun called El jau Kunbi (烈骄昆莫) who mentioned in great Chinese historical book Han shu (汉书) written by Si ma qian (司马迁), also the famous Chinese diplomat called Zhang Qian 张骞 who lived in the time of beginning of silk way road written in his journey said Uysun kingdom was the most powerful country in the west (西域46国中最强国家）among 46 little countries, we should allied with them to fight against Hun empire(匈奴帝国）。Nowadays Chinese Kazakh living in those are called Kunes(昭苏县）, the Chinese named after the princess of Han empire who married Uysun ruler Eljau Kunbi。
Greeting from BULGARIA.IYI🇧🇬IYI
ЕВГЕНИ СТЕФАНОВ IYI is symbol of Kayı branch of Oghuzs lol and Last year a party found which is named IYI party.
ЕВГЕНИ СТЕФАНОВ you do realize IYI is a symbol of one of the old Turkic kayi tribe right?
This symbol is of Roda Dulo of the old Bulgarians Khan Kubrat and Khan Avitohol are of the genus IYI Dynasty Dulo🇧🇬 IYI 🇧🇬
ЕВГЕНИ СТЕФАНОВ nice bro but cmon. That is a nomad clan for sure
Yunanı yoğurdu,cacığı,baklavayı götürür. Bulgarı Kayı Boyu'nun damgasını götürür.Yeter amk ya. Çala çala bir bitiremediniz. Adamlar Türk adını görünce direk kuduz köpek gibi saldırıyorlar.
asterix and obelix as gaul-gallic languages fall out and fades away
Shouldn't Arabic have replaced Aramaic by the 800s at least ?
Yeah
Yes
The history is soo complicated espacialy how sycthian dissapeared ? Or Turned into Turkic Language ?? İs there any Relation ?
@Artem Kuznetsov persians ?
@Artem Kuznetsov Turks have a lot of caucasia more than persian
The Anatolian DNA different from persians Anatolian Turks West Asia means mostly indigeneous Anatolian or Maybe caucasian Persian is lower possiblity
@Artem Kuznetsov for example my brother has blue eyes and blonde hair and 1.87 cm very tall
Turks also have Northern Germanic DNA
@Artem Kuznetsov the blacksea People in Turkey Very similar people with Ukrainians
Maybe add Finno-Ugric in the next one?
The Culture Corner or korean or japanese
Shame on Indian govt that they haven't recognised Rajasthani language yet... And imposed Hindi instead.
I like this video so much. Can you please add finno-ugric languages to the map? Also, show the approximate origins of proto-languages and splits as knots on your map. Thank you.
I really like this kind of language videos and would love to see more of it on your channel :D
From Semitic, Indo Iranian, Tibeto Burman, Austronesian, And Altaic
One problem is that the different Prakrut languages didn't came from Sanskrut but rather were separate from it. Sanskrut itself became what it is when a grammarian chose a language from North to be standardised & later someone else standardised the other Prakrut languages like Maharashtri, etc.
Also Rajasthani is rather a very new name of an old language & named after the state of Rajasthan which itself was renamed from Rajputana as it was during British time. Both probably has similar meanings, as Rajputana is land of the Rajput clans or caste & Rajasthan is perhaps land of Rajas/Kings.
Rakesh Kumar Thanks for the reply.
But isn't the name Rajasthan a new name (probably from the British time) while these languages are much older. Which is why I'm never convinced over the name Rajasthani for a language or even a group of languages. To me it honestly feels similar to when a friend of mine ignorantly called _Kannada_ as Bangalorian & I heard someone else call it Karnataki. So I thought _Marwadi_ is probably the name as the largest dialect while other dialects also exist & have other names.
Also it's unfortunate that language of the land & it's people gets rejected by some of it's own people for an outside language.
Rakesh Kumar I've read about those articles but given the kind of pride those politicians have regarding their own language in these states including Rajasthan I doubt it'd be achieved anytime soon. If they were really serious & had genuine pride they'd have recognised it as their state's official language & started using it in government work while promoting it in schools as a compulsory language. But that's my opinion & I really don't know if a state can just recognise a language for their own use without the permission of GOI.
My main issue with Rajasthani is just the name as it sounds too artificial for a real age old language cause if the state was still called Rajputana then would they still call it Rajasthani or may be Rajputani or something similar.
_Maithili_ too was once counted under hindi I think but somehow they managed to get recognised while other _Bihari or Eastern_ languages continue being counted under hindi. I do wonder how they did it but others keep failing or may be they aren't really trying that hard.
Yes, the _Dravidian_ bloc certainly has less of these problems as apart from the 4 main languages that have their own states only a few others are prominently known most of which I think are in Karnataka alone like _Tulu (also in Kerala), Coorgi, Kodava, etc._ but problems with the languages you mentioned is that many have their own states but its people & most importantly the politicians are less than interested in doing anything for their own language. For example, Bihar recognises hindi & later also recognised urdu but not their own language that is native to their land & still spoken by their people.
Also I believe federalism for India would be a great option to protect all the languages & cultures from slowly dying out due to lack of public awareness as states will be expected to look after themselves without looking towards GOI for any permission making it easier to get things done like recognising or giving prominence to their native language in government work & education. Obviously such a thing is even more difficult.
The horse is the wing of the Turkic
You mean donkey
fun fact: old malay is not the oldest malay language ever founded, this video was based on brittish empire literature which refers to Sumatran as malay while borneo is the home of malay language.
Conveniently not showing Finland, Iceland and most of Scandinavia.
What happened to Sanskrit and Hebrew? Hebrew is more than 6000 years old bruh. Pretty lousy vid.
@anand jha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@anand jha Dafuq, are you high on weed?
How is Hebrew 6000 years old when it says that Abraham moved out from Ur, and that the jews left Egypt around 1200BC? It just can't be. 4000 is plausible but 6000 is bullshit
I'm a latvian and i'm very proud that i can represent Proto-Baltic branch! :)
turkic best
Shit
Seeing Oghur slide through Scythian like that was painful. Also, I'm pretty sure the Alans moved south to Ossetia.
It is sad indeed. The Scythians of Central Asia were absorbed. But most of the Scythian’s left before the Turks moved in. Many Scythians moved into Europe and India.
That's what all ethnicities have done to others. Indo-Europeans did the same thing to Vascons, Etruscans, pre-Greek civilizations and ancient anatolian peoples living before Indo-European expansion.
Saka's first Turkic people on earth also we call them "İskitler"
I hope you joking
هههه good joke
Scythian Avestan Sogdian are Oldest Iranian Languages and These three languages are still alive
There isn’t such a thing as Old Arabic,
But Arabic was a language Family:
The first form was Qahtanite Arabic, (in Yemen) today called South Arabian.
Today it’s many dialects.
Nabatean started in Jordan.
Lehyanite North KSA
Thamudi North KSA
Adnanite Qurashi Hejazi Arabic in Central Arabia is the one used now as classic arabic
عُـمَــر آل بــَـدَوي They probably meant Old North Arabian, dialects like Old Hijazi and so on.
abcde fghij
Darija is an accent blended with Amazigh
ehsan_iq
I’ve been studying this for 4 years.
Arabic has many forms.
The Old Arabic languages were Sabaean (later Himyarite), Thamudi, Dedanite,lihyanite, Hejazi, Qurashi and different types of Najdi.
They used to be nearly different languages.
Though there isn’t something called Old Arabic but there is something called Old Arabian Languages.
Because the old Arabian languages were never one.
Even today,
Fusha Arabic we use is Qurashi and our accents like Egyptian Lebanese Khaleeji etc were all a blend of The Qurashi, neighbouring languages and if it was in the Arabian Peninsula then it would also be a blend of the old Arabian languages based on the are.
Some areas like in Yemen Oman UAE and Saudi are trilingual they could speak:
Fusha Arabic,
One of the Old Arabic languages,
And the local country dialect.
ehsan_iq
Btw I studied this for 4 years
In Medina very well.
What u Said is correct but what u call Old Arabic are all different languages that Are Ishmaelite they were not unified into a single language called old Arabian.
The Southern Arabian languages are purer than the Ishmaelite ones bcuz Ishmaelites were arabised by Qahtanites the pure Arabs of the south
ehsan_iq
Your correct. But they were never one language.
However, the actual pure Arabs are descendents of Qahtan bin Hud, it’s not a myth, bcuz our prophet said it he said that Ishmael was arabised by arabs and that he made a new type or kind of Arabs, and he said that Qahtanites are the purest of Arabs and are the arabisers of Ishmael.
The Qahatanite Himyarite tribe of Jurhum were the people who arabised Ishmael in Mecca.
It was even already known before our prophet pbuh but then our prophet proved it.
Your Aramaic and Arabic (in the Arab world) is just plain and simply wrong. Aramaic was spoken in the Arabian peninsula at some point, and Arabic was spoken in the Levant and Iraq at some point as well.
There are many other languages that were not mentioned as well.
Old Malay just chilling there...
Haha..terbukti bahasa melayu yg asli bkn indo
@@ckrafael6386 bahasa melayu malaysia skrang ni pon bukannya asli bahasa melayu dulu bahasa melayu tulen pure austronesian macam bahasa orang sabah sarawak. Bahasa melayu sekarang dah campur2 bahasa sanskrit, and arab sejak kedatangan Buddha, Hindu pastu Islam beratus tahun dulu sama macam bhs indon sbb bhs indon pon dtg dari bhs melayu
The video is wrong there are evidence of some other languages developed in maritime south east Asia in 9th century and there is no evidence that people in the east of archipelago use that language. And old Malay wasn't that old the first evidence of it's existence found Palembang, Sumatra written in 7th century CE, before that no one knows what we use as our language.
@@haffah6218 Bahasa murni Austronesia hanya bisa ditemui di Taiwan dan Polynesia sekarang, bahasa Sabah dan Sarawak juga masih tercampur.
Bebek Dragon . Austronesian Is Almost Comepletely Mixed.
All Of Austronesian Language Are Already Mixed.
Taiwan And Vietnamese Is Influced By Chinnese
Malay Is Influced By Arab And Persian
Java Is Influced By Sanskrit And Hindi And Other Indian Language And Also Some Dutch And Malay Word
Rest Of Indo (Except Papua) Influced By Dutch And Other His Austronesian Family
Papua And Malanesia Is Of Course Influced By East Papua Family (Papua Family Is Most Isolated Family)
Malagasy Is Mixed With Bantu People .
Micronesia And Polynesia Is Mixed Lit Bit By Papua Family
This Is Acoording To My Reasearch. If Its Wrong Fell Free To Reply Here
The hell?Proto-Turkic is much older than that!
Yes, probably, but there is no evidence
Nice! Ohh Bengali and other Indian Language is part of Indo-European Language! PART 2 Upload Plz
Pictish was Indo- European