Putin sacks Shoigu for all of Russia 'battlefield failures' in Ukraine | RUSI’s Natia Seskuria
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 июн 2024
- “Prigozhin was making the point that basically he was the one who was responsible for all the battlefield failures.”
Putin sacked Shoigu as defence minister in a major reshuffle as he “has failed to accomplish goals” in the Ukraine war, says associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute Natia Seskuria.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Maybe Putin should blame the person responsible for starting the war in the first place.
Shoigu wanted to retire anyways. He got promoted to secretary of Russia's national security council.
Victoria Nuland? Good idea.
You talk about Biden and Boris?
Obama and Biden. War started in 2014.
You mean the western J_E_W_S
Replaced with an economist. Vlad might have budgetary concerns.
Unfortunately for him being an economist in Russia just means you are better equipped to syphon off funds.
Russia actually had good economists. Considering all the pressures that the Russian economy is facing, the fact that the central bank has prevented an economic collapse is amazing.
Of course, long-term prospects for Russia's economic future is dismal.
He was fired because it's easier for Vova to steal the military budget by replacing a builder with a banker.
Bad news for ukraine
Zelensky appointed an economist last yr to run the military.
shoigu got promoted times radio should get its info correct
Here is a medal for gullibility, Frank.
@@stream2watch You are the gullible one. shoigu always wanted to retire even before the conflict.
@frankenda Enjoy conscription
@@alqaas1948cope orc
Collective West’s sour grapes and desperation!! The truth to difficult to stomach!!! 😂😂😂
Putler: "Everything is going according to plan!"
Severely intellectually challenged
This is fake news, Shoigu got promoted.
Stay away from windows, Sergei!
Bill Gates is not your friend 😫
Smile when the anger bots switch from maniacal gloating to annoyed explanation.
Putin enters the chat. "When you're stealing the military budget , hiring an accountant is always preferable to a builder".😂
Thats Ukraine
@@imperatorvespasian3125 READ IT AND WEEP.
Russian KIA. 510,000
Ukrainian KIA. 47,000
NATO KIA. 0
Hey people! The Secretary of National Defense in Russia is the closest position to the president, Shoigu has been promoted to a position which is second only to Putin and stands over the ministry of defense. The one facing a demotion is Patrushev.
How many times can you be Lied to if you don't know the Truth ?.....More misinformation....from TR.
He was promoted to a top job in the security, not sacked
Sure whatever you say
Indeed he was. No point saying it here however :)
@@tennantsandstella just you keep telling yourself that if it helps you cope
@@michaeldunham3385 So says the westerner who has never been to Russia and learned everything he knows from western media and politicians.
Also, everything known could fit on the head of a pin.
yes he was promoted and will be responsible for coordination of the production of advanced weapon systems. It is all part of an upgrade of capability that will completely dwarf the west's capability to wage or match any offense against Russia. To try and match Russia the West would have to restructure their arms industry and would take a decade to match them particularly as cheap energy resources and raw materials are readily available to Russia.
By the way Iran's attack on Israel was just a "demonstration" of their capability and a warning to the West that modern warfare has changed and the West hasn't kept up eg the West do not have any hypersonic capacity and lacks hypersonic defence weapons.
7 months. In a war against russia. 😔
Several centuries under the Mongolian yoke made RuZZia being RuZZia🇲🇳
Unlike the west, Russia actually gives high positions to non Russians like Shoigu. Now he got promoted secretary of Russia's national security council.
@@alqaas1948 yes, unlike the West…third world failed state shaithole KGB mafia dictatorship RuZZia🇲🇳gives high positions to not elected incompetent corrupted war criminals and dictator puppets😁🤡
@@alqaas1948 comparing a third world totalitarian kgb mafia dictatorship shaithole Ruzzia🇲🇳with free democratic western states based on checks & balances, freedom of speech and pluralism😆
comparing a third world totalitarian kgb mafia dictatorship shaithole Ruzzia🇲🇳with free democratic western states based on checks & balances, freedom of speech and pluralism😆
you mean paying the mongols to avoid a war then using the mongol army to defend itself while building its own empire?
Nobody believes this 🤣.
Shoigu got promoted and the new guy is an economic and managerial superstar.
A superstar like RuZZia is a superstar shaithole third world Failed state KGB Mafia dictatorship with a GNP lower than chaotic Italy
He is also a technocrat and a fan of drones and new technology in the military.
@@georgesibley7152 I watch Andrei Martinov on his podcast.
He's explained all his many skills including cyber
Times shouldn't get him on instead of RUSI propagandists.
There is a reason why in Finnish verb "Ryssiä" (Muscovy ) , roughly meaning "to totally fail something".
First of all, not Moscovia. Moscow is the capital, not the name of a country. Secondly, the USSR (Russia's successor) won the Second World War, Russia became even stronger militarily and economically thanks to the sanctions.
@@olgaromanova9549 "Благодаря невероятно успешной внешней политике путина у нас всегда будут полные холодильники! " - заявил директор Ростовского морга 🇷🇺 ...
Дело движется к концу, Моль летает по дворцу, Какая боль, какая боль, Весь мир плюёт на эту моль! Ждём дистанционную швабру, для повышения духовноскрепности в Швабростане 🇷🇺
@@olgaromanova9549 Won the second world war but at the end of the day, one wonders if Russians or Germans killed the most Russians.
@@olgaromanova9549 Mongol Muscovy🇲🇳. Learn your history, Lyudmila.
@@tomokaramolko8560 +1, Chinese academic Deng Xize : "No more Mongol-Muscovy style empire: Thoughts on the war in Ukraine, The global reaction to the war in Ukraine in fact shows that such empires will no longer be tolerated."
The Mongol-Muscovy style empire could be defined as a dominating, rapacious empire upheld by violence, especially unruly violence, and exhibiting three prominent characteristics.
First, it uses unruly violence as a regular means of resolving international disputes. While violence is common and sometimes necessary in political or social governance, rules have been set for its use under a modern lawful democratic system. Unlike in ancient times, the use of violence now comes under heavy restrictions and is “predictable”. Such an evolution also applies to international relations.
"battlefield failures?' 😂😂😂
Who is Times Radio????? Every piece of "content" seems to follow a narrative contrary to most news sources
British goverment agendas being pushed through the press. The very reason this turned into a war in the first place when boris run off to Ukraine n blew a chance of peace. Clearly boris wasnt content killing thousands over covid along with party gate.
Lo de Shoigu es una promoción con una patada hacia arriba
*Prigozyhin watching from the afterlife*
“Oh,come ON really? Now he does it?”
he got promoted he is now the second most powerful in the government
The real question is how close is his new seat is to the open window.
He is still close to shovels 🙂
Dont eat the food
How long before Shoigu leaps out of a tenth floor hotel window?
This isn't true and you know it. He has been moved to a more strategic role. He has not been sacked. What on earth is the Times doing with this channel?
👌
And you believe the narrative. That is so cute.
He's been sacked
Exactly comrade...front of the line for your extra half potato this month and a free pass to the front lines. Enjoy conscription!
you must be new to politics😅😅
Being promoted is called "sacked" nowadays? 🤡🤡🤡
He has been moved to a position of non importance. I suggest you listen to INSIDE RUSSIA where Konstantin explains it quite clearly.
@@ScienceTalkwithJimMassa Stop spamming.
Or the converse, Fenris. We know the game.
Time to avoid high buildings, Mr.Shoigu.
He got promoted to secretary of Russia's national security council. He is not completely fired from government position.
How much they paying you bro
Dream on ❤❤.
Shoigu was not sacked but rewarded to second place in command just behind Putin. He was apointed to director of all security services in Russia.
The pro Ruzz channels try to draw a picture of the invincible Ruzzia. In fact, it’s a Non-Giant, wich depends on the huge amount of poor people, he can stuff into uniforms!
While the propaganda channels like this one keep saying that Russia is about to collapse, have no soldiers, ammo, weapons, tanks, Putin is dying … there is bull plop all over the place. I haven’t found a channel that gives balanced reporting.
ust go and look at how beautiful and green russian cities are and compare with street after street of graffittied, boxed up businesses with massive amount of homeless in the streets. THAT shows how well your warmongering arrogant elite CARE FOR ORDINARY PEOPLE ,LET ALONE POOR ONES1
And the number of MAGA idiots it can brainwash abroad
Unlike the proud Ukrainian people queuing up to eagerly defend their homeland hopefully with you going over to Ukraine to help instead of watching BBC in your armchair
@@yorkshirelad3524how long have you supported a dictatorship
He got a promotion
...are U kidding us??...Are U, STILL, such a sucker, as to believe Kremlin propaganda??
THEY are all a bunch of corrupt, cold blooded killers!!
Bad guys reliably eventually turn on themselves.
Special Operation, not on schedule?
It seems that there are more failures on the Ukrainian side ....
I know US aid package was going thru a democratic process, but I don't understand why Europe wasn't providing arms during that time?
Chinese academic Deng Xize : "No more Mongol-Muscovy style empire: Thoughts on the war in Ukraine, The global reaction to the war in Ukraine in fact shows that such empires will no longer be tolerated."
The Mongol-Muscovy style empire could be defined as a dominating, rapacious empire upheld by violence, especially unruly violence, and exhibiting three prominent characteristics.
First, it uses unruly violence as a regular means of resolving international disputes. While violence is common and sometimes necessary in political or social governance, rules have been set for its use under a modern lawful democratic system. Unlike in ancient times, the use of violence now comes under heavy restrictions and is “predictable”. Such an evolution also applies to international relations.
Doesn't Deng Xize teach students learning teacher education? he is not a historian or a political scientist. he taught in primary schools before getting a professorship at Sechuan University
Thanks to Shoigu, the Russian army is inside Ukraine. But the army needs to develop and there should be new ideas, so a new person took the place.
After 800+ days, they are inside Ukraine huh. The barrier for success is indeed very generous in Russia these days.
@@stream2watch study the role of attrition in wars especially the American Civil War - the second one not the first one where they declared independence.
❤Ukrainian ❤
It doesn't make sense to sack him over the Russian's failures .He is a civilian, he was never in the armed forces. It's the same with the person who replaces him,a civilian. What is Putin thinking.✌️
He hasn't sacked him, he has promoted him. Like Lavrov, Shoigu reports directly to Putin. Stop spreading nonsense.
Exactly!! Western hypocrisy and vacuous propaganda!!! 😂😂😂
And appointed him to ther positions concurrently. Hardly a demotion!😂😂😂 , yet again fake, propaganda news....the times
So the SMO is going so well that you get the guy leading it to move to another job, and arrest two of his deputies for corruption? And you are trying to tell us this was intentional?
That's exactly what I just said👍
He has been moved to a position of non importance. I suggest you listen to INSIDE RUSSIA where Konstantin explains it quite clearly.
Shoigu was promoted to general secretary making him second to Putin, Why UK press so bad a journalism?
Just the usual nonsense that we have become so accustomed to hearing.
And you do not use the opportunity to elaborate, your comment looks like the typical comments made by trolls, strange that
@@doncarlodivargas5497 that is so so cool
@@russellspeed1693 - yes, to be on the payroll of Putin are really cool
@@doncarlodivargas5497 how very mature of you. Well done
@@russellspeed1693 I suggested you to elaborate, but you rather spend time and energy on this zero information commenting
This is the SEVENTH video on Shoigu by Times Radio in the past 3 days. Situation must be really bad if this is the best bit of propaganda for TR to keep re-hashing....
You could say he’s Putin the boot in…
If that's true why wasn't he sacked a long time ago?
These idiots have no idea how Russia works, they are pushing NATO propaganda
So basically, Putin sacked this man because he needed a scapegoat to blame.
The only reason Shoigu got the position is because he was Vlad's drinking buddy in Eastern Germany during the USSR days.
He wasn't even sacked ...he was promoted to a higher position that's was Times Radio ain't mentioning
@@robbiekop7 And you believed them. That is so cute.
It’s nothing to do with the actual battlefield failures, at least this isn’t the main reason. There’s a lot going on in a background and apparently Shoigu was gaining too much power and Putin saw him as a threat according to some analysts. Also news about the treason just came…
That's why Putin had his Ally pretend to do an uprising and then faked his death after to maintain a look of power.
Shoigu was going to actually do a real coup so Putin did a fake coup instead so he could control and squash it and win an optical victory and make people not willing to support Shoigu.
Erdogan in turkey did the exact same thing a little while. Staged a fake attempted coup against himself.
This put Russias security on high alert, and rallied putin supporters. Making a real coup by shoigu impossible
Shoigu is loyal to Putin. Shoigu is now the secretary of the security council. It's just that the army needs to develop.
🤖 detected ⬆️
@@olgaromanova9549 "Shoigu is loyal to Putin." Surely that is above your paygrade to know, vatnik.
so why give him more power. Putin and Shoigu are fishing buddies. The National Security Council rule Russia even Putin has to defer to them.
Why is pootin not leading the battle as the 'tough guy'?
Hes in his bunker with brown pants on.
Because he's not a tough guy. He's all talk and no walk. Remember how he RUNAWAY from Moscow when Prigozhin approached the city. He did the opposite to Zelenskky. He fled crying. "I don't need ammunition. I need a ride".
You're so going to change your pants in a couple of months...
@@DarkCriimes He's still in place, not traveling around the country begging for money.
So to this day the Russian army is capturing new territories and the Russian army is defeating the armies of the NAO countries and their weapons.
According to the forecasts of Russian military analysts, NATO is preparing to fight with Russia therefore, the country's military budget will be significantly increased. Putin appointed Doctor of Economic Sciences Belousov at the head of the Ministry of Defense for control and prudent use of budget money
What on earth are you talking about .......he wasnt sacked 😂.
The only one thats making battlefield errors are zelensky and ukraine, to ve more precise losing.
He has been moved to a position of non importance. I suggest you listen to INSIDE RUSSIA where Konstantin explains it quite clearly.
@@ScienceTalkwithJimMassa He's over all the military. And it doesn't mean he's been no good, that's why Putin put someone else in charge, it's a reshuffle like many governments do when they start a fresh after election .
Shoigu wanted to retire, but Putin wanted him, need I say more .
The western idiots need to grow up .
Even inside Russia Shoigu is regarded as corrupt and incompetent. I have no idea why Russia's online trolls are trying to defend him.
Russian online trolls here are bizarre. Then one goes on Dva ch and realises that Russians themselves do not believe their own bot narrative. They have been subjected to paid posters for decades and they are fed up.
He wanted to retire anyways even before the conflict started. No point in keeping a man as minister of defence who doesn't want to be in that position.
He is stil in charge of international military affairs and is been promoted to the inner circle that rules Russia.
@@georgesibley7152 Nice grammar there "George Sibley". Occam's Razor tells us that he in fact has been put in a symbolic position, and he won't actually need to spend any time at all in ofis. Siberia comes later, when this debacle is over.
@@stream2watch I bet everything you 'know' about Russia comes from western politicians and media. And could fit on the head of a pin.
But do tell us all, that food you brought at the store was it grown with Russian ammonium nitrate?
Was it transported on a ship or truck using fuel from Ural oil?
Did that electricity you used get generated in a power plant using uranium refined in Russia?
I've already seen your posts and you have ZERO clue as to the answers of these questions.
Not one mention of Shoigus dismissal on the Russian propaganda site that I follow. Just the usual bluster about how scared NATO should be, how strong Russia is, and how it owns the entire continent, and how it's neighbouring countries should live in fear. It's obviously a very sore spot especially in the light of his colleague being arrested for corruption. Who knows how much Shoigu is worth?
So who on here fell for this bs? 😂 If you did you are very gullible and misinformed. He was actually promoted.
Seems like just as we have the Millitaty Industrial Complex (MIC), we also have a Bellitle Putin Complex (BPC). As long as it's negative, humilliating and bellitling, it gets airtime without fact checking no matter how ridiculous. Heck if you appear on shows often enough, you're feted as a 'Russian expert', never mind time and time again, year after year events prove you wrong.
What would be really fun to see is an Arab country like Kuwait playing against a women's team (from any proper country) and losing big. ;)
Now Poopin needs to find someone else to change his diapers.
Promoted to a beautiful farm in Siberia where he can run around and play with all the other mediocre managers in retirement.
Shojgu rip 2024🤫 🏊🚴🏃🏖️🚙🛁🚽🛏️🪒???
You're lying. There are no miscalculations. Shoigu has just been promoted to head the entire military industrial complex in Russia. That's a promotion not a demotion
Well Spotted.
If you believe that, I have a bridge to sell you.
Just keep telling yourself that if it comforts you
Enjoy conscription
This is Fakes Radio
Shoigu was promoted, not sacked.
Re shuffled to Secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation, The propaganda on this channel is incredible.
Ruzzia have already lost the geopolitical war, NATO has increased its membership and are closer to their border which was one of Putlers main concerns.
Shoigu (who's a reindeer herder by trade) failed upwards from corrupt Minister of Defense to corrupt Secretary of Security. What happened to (former?) Putin ally Patrushev is a mystery, though he's expected to avoid open windows for the foreseeable future.
Your COPE is real. Minister of defense was the 2nd most powerful job in the country because he controlled the army. Now he's going to put in Putin's broom cupboard and be forgotten about. 😂😂😂
@@richardmarsden5610. Shoigu wanted to retire even before the conflict. He didn't seek to be the eternal Minister of defence.
@@martinpankhurst2683 Ukraine will never be in the EU or nato 😂
Hes been moved up to the security council you clowns😂😂😂
Credibility fail... Again...
He has been moved to a position of non importance. I suggest you listen to INSIDE RUSSIA where Konstantin explains it quite clearly.
@@ScienceTalkwithJimMassa 😂😂😂 I suggest you stop swallowing the propaganda whole...
There's any problem of reshuffling ? in the West when there's a change of faces people get histeric and start seeing movies ? After all Putin farts and the West go immediately to smell it
All this talks is nonsense 😂
10 “uuuhhhsss” per sentence. Can’t listen, sorry.
what failures?? Russia is currently eating Ukraine alive. He was actually promoted to Russia's security council, a direct adviser for Putin..
It’s like the entire planet believes the USA owes them a security blanket.
Are the untapped gas fields in the Donbas region currently in Ukrainian control, or Russian? Trillions of cubic feet of gas, one of the largest coal mines in Europe, steel works, and agriculture lands.
Both sides know they need it.
Edit forgot the nuclear power plants which are crucial to both sides, most of Russia has no running electricity
so Russia has the largest reserves of natural gas that supplies their electricity-generating stations. statistics show that in 2021 100% of Russian homes had electricity. yet they have no running electricity?
@@georgesibley7152 you've never been to Russia have you? You realise how big the territory is, how secluded areas are.
I'm calling you out based on facts I know are facts. Stick your poll.. You're lying 🤥
@@georgesibley7152 those gas fields could feed Europe on the cheap, or Putin keeps them and continues to charge Europe for it. The grain feeds some of Europe, Africa, and Asia. What are you talking about!?
Not the smartest huh?
@@EleventhMonkey
You wrote
t forgot the nuclear power plants which are crucial to both sides, most of Russia has no running electricity
statistics from various sources deny this. some do not have internal sewage but they do have electric.
i was married to a Russian Ukrainian and have travelled through Russia. as well as Ukraine many times. These days seclusion does not matter, China has developed in secluded areas. Bovanenkovo was totally secluded. but that never mattered.
RuZZia🇲🇳 is so shait. It’s fascinating how shait RuZZia🇲🇳is
this propaganda is hilarious, Shoigu Has an equally important job role, not to mention hes been hinting at retirement.
Yep, he eh, the he believe eh that it he was very eh, excellent but eh, it makes eh the video eh clip, less eh interesting.
Maybe we can have a segment on the companies that have taken over the banking and Oil sectors in Urkaine.... spoiler alert, they arent Ukrainian.
Most of the resources that are in eastern Ukraine are in Russian hands. Ukraine is slowly being strangled.
@@klawlor3659 so BlackRock and others are gaining nothing and what then is Zelensky privatising?
This is just another infantile jab at anything Russian. Shoigu has been promoted to General Secretary of the Security Council (the modern Politburo) where his focus will be the Russian MIC. Hus successor has an economic background and the two of them will further fine tune snd improve the Russian MIC which is already outperforming all of NATO combined. Anyway, carry on children.
You didn’t realise this is a propaganda channel??? 😂😂😂
Cant stand putin but this channel comes off as propoganda as opposed to news.
Russ isnt going to win no matter
Shoigu is now Shoigone! May Our Lady of Zarvanytsia, Andrey Sheptytsky, Blessed Vasyl Velychkovsky and all Ukrainian saints, First Testament Prophets (Elijah, Ezekiel, Joel, Jeremiah, Isaiah, Amos etc), Jewish holy men and women, St Michael, Raphael and Gabriel, all the angels, St Benedict, St Seraphim, St George, St Catherine, ask the Almighty to help Ukraine. May it be freed from Russian oppression. May all who have died RIP and may relatives and friends be comforted
Shoigu is fired for corruption. you are wrong as usual with your made up headlines
He was fired because it's easier for Vova to steal the military budget by replacing a builder with a banker.
You absolutly out of reality as still. Zelensky has succeses Kharkiv Tchasov Yar Avdijivka Bakhmut Mariapol Melitopel
Please take notice that this is what we want as citizens not war. One beautiful song from my culture ruclips.net/video/eTR1sPuE4IM/видео.htmlsi=bvf5apQUw-jssYJB and one from my exe's culture. ruclips.net/video/PjczUdqu7qc/видео.htmlsi=rjqhnePs2cTGZLHJ Both about flying high above an ideal world one Soviet the other British. We always loved you as Russians and want to share in a global village utopia, not be blown of the planet. We had some hope of that when I was in my 20s now....well.
😢😢my condolences to the NATO pact for the disastrous defeat by Russia,but that's not the worst...besides the military defeat, you also experienced a geopolitical defeat from Russia and China, which is much worse....NATO geniuses gained 20 million inhabitants Swedish and Finnish and lost 7 billion inhabitants, South America, Africa, Asia, the Middle East, and a good part of Europe are today on the side of Russia and China... with your aggressive geopolitics, you made Russia the strongest military power in the world and China the strongest economic power and soon a military power...
what can we say about the western media and the pentagon....
a million lies, propaganda of hypocrisy
fake reports...
all in all, NATO and the Western media are the object of ridicule around the world
Russia are the second strongest army in Ukraine. Dont even imagine you are fighting the full power of NATO. Putin himself has acknowledged you will be destroyed.
Comedian 🤣🤣
What a load of 💩
Impressive how much baseless nonsense and propaganda can be crammed in above to such uninformed text! 😅 by the way thanks for sharing your thoughts on the very media you apparently despise 😂
@@sjl197 😮😮
He was promoted! The BS is incredible..
And the moon is made of green cheese comrade.