James has overall better timing... but in all fairness, one thing (and maybe one of the only things) that Lars is actually very good at is octuple bass drum hits.
Nah. Yes Lars slips up in some parts (as do the other guys - see the covid charity broadcast)) but the machine gun part in One isn't usually one of em.
love how chill and relaxed this vid is. it's almost like they're watching Metallica just rehearse and dick around instead of just playing an actual concert. I dig it
*yeah it's a pretty decent instrumental. especially comes to life at a live show when the audience sings along to the melody (doesn't quiet translate on video- have to be there)*
Lars was holding up the show talking to his son in the Metallica 'Friend's and Family' room - which I was lucky enough to be in that night. Yeah, I wouldn't believe me either - but it's true. Cheers!
Do you know if the drums were overdubbed? If you look at 7:41 to 7:46 there's a time where you hear a cymbal hit and a time where you hear a snare hit and lars isn't playing either of them. Can you confirm this please? This is driving me nuts.
A drummer that wanted to be a guitar player and a guitar player that wanted to be a drummer, and now we have Metallica....... the O.G American Thrash metal band\m/
3:08 Lars calls Avi to turn up the cooling fans, 'cause it's too hot on stage. Few years later, Avi will sing with Metallica on stage as the back-vocalist. That's the career! 😁
Lars is a lot better than him face it. But i agree that he's the best guitarist of the band (I still love the bluesy rock-'n'-roll-ish style of Kirk Hammett but he's no very technical nowadays.)
Funny how Lars compliments his stagehand "Avi" as, "the hardest working man in the business" in the same breath of asking him to turn the air on back there because the premadonna drummer is a little warm behind the drum kit - poor pampered little baby is such a high maintence princess. God forbid if he should break a sweat on his royal forehead & brow! 😖🌊🌈
@@kukelhupf that is fair. I too am quite familiar with the heat projected along with stage lighting. It's just that most in the live performance line of work don't choose to take the moment to register the compliant publicly while on stage DURING a performance that they are carelessly appearing late to. All eyes were already on him, because of that very reason. He's obviously a very special kind of musician & shouldn't be exposed to such abusive & unfair work conditions. He ought to report this to his local union representative! -lol- 😂
James did this way back in 1990...whatever during the "year and a half in the life of Metallica" era. He and Lars also had a drum battle. I still have it on vhs lol
James is awesome! I wish James and Kirk would trade solos on more songs. Robert is no slouch either! Come on guys give us one more Speed Metal record with groves and riffs.
I'm starting to think that James wrote the drum lines for everything in AJFA. Very different from Lars actual style before and after that. Anytime James just fucks around with drums, the progginess sounds like AJFA
It's an extremely tricky intro. Rob is the only one consistentpy playing, so the other three have to know where to come in, and it's super-syncopated. That's how you know it's live.
7:40 what audio am I hearing? Lars is surely fucking it up playing the one part too early but the audio is fine... Why would they fix it for liveMet audio?
They aren’t loosers sure they aren’t the same Metallica from the 80s and 90s. But they’ve sold millions of albums. If you don’t have anything nice to say don’t say it. Also don’t say they are bad or you can do better because everyone knows that you can't be better than Metallica or Metallica themselves
I could sit and watch and listen to Robert play bass guitar all night without James Hetfield and lars urich and Kirk hammett just Robert on stage playing bass guitar
Wtf..... Lmao this is fucking gold, 🤣 where was Lars. This can't be an actual concert. Must've been a special appearance or something.... I died when Lars just walked out and still made them wait to put his shoes on 😫😭 looool grandpa Lars
Mucker, you mannaged to keep us in video until it ends even after some point it's not even a video, just a record. I'd say you'd be a great bussined person. Take that advice.
And that's why they don't play this masterpiece live. And that's why don't play the intros of Dyers Eve, or Spit Out The Bone, or Hardwired, and others. Anyway, they still kicking ass and still the best band on earth
@@MUSiC-world-20986 *never playback ahah he just made a mistake and it was corrected in post. there's tons of mistakes that were overdubbed (not just Lars). can't blame them really since they played a completely different setlist bar Seek every night for four nights. think they played north of 80 (think 85-ish) different songs over the span of those 4 shows which is a mindfuck and a half. probably just wanted to have the most obvious flubs ironed out for the official recording. these 4 shows still rank as one of the most downloaded live recordings on **livemetallica.com** (there's a top 8 and all 4 of them are in it).*
The video was taken with a camera on the crowd, the audio is from the official audio they put on their website, can you imagine the audio from the camera being this good?
Love Tama, but if you’ve ever used those god awful hollow aluminum signature sticks…yee ho le! …Still no excuse for one of the most bankable drummers ever to not nail single note snare fills in time
I had two pairs of Aheads and they both broke within two weeks respectively. They really aren't as good as they're chalked up to be. The only good thing they have going is the attack
@@Soloyologaming Well depends on how hard, how often and how fast you play. I buy Vic Firth's 2B sticks. One pair lasted 3 weeks and another lasted 3 months. I played mostly Thrash as hard as I could with the first pair.
*never playback ahah he just made a mistake and it was corrected in post. there's tons of mistakes that were overdubbed (not just Lars). can't blame them really since they played a completely different setlist bar Seek every night for four nights. think they played north of 80 (think 85-ish) different songs over the span of those 4 shows which is a mindfuck and a half. probably just wanted to have the most obvious flubs ironed out for the official recording. these 4 shows still rank as one of the most downloaded live recordings on **livemetallica.com** (there's a top 8 and all 4 of them are in it).*
James has
Taken my kit
Taken my tom
Taken my kick drum
Taken my snare
Taken my ride
Taken my crash
Left me with a cowbell and a chair
Love it 😂😂😂
"If you know the lyrics, feel free to sing along" 💀
Hetfield has taken my set,
taken my snare,
and left it with good sound.
Hell!!!
He looks like hes playing on kids drums😂😂🙏🙏
😂😂😂😂😂
But they sound awesome!! 🤘🤘🤘
James plays the one breakdown better than Lars does now
James has overall better timing... but in all fairness, one thing (and maybe one of the only things) that Lars is actually very good at is octuple bass drum hits.
Nope
Nah. Yes Lars slips up in some parts (as do the other guys - see the covid charity broadcast)) but the machine gun part in One isn't usually one of em.
@Anthony Lopez, don’t be a fool...
I know it's kinda unusual to see and it's cool in general but let's be honest that his machine gun double bass part is sloppy
love how chill and relaxed this vid is. it's almost like they're watching Metallica just rehearse and dick around instead of just playing an actual concert. I dig it
James should put on his guitar, strap a drumset to himself and just be a 1-man band already.
it would sound like the and justice for all
Wow Kirk was really the only one who wasnt phased by the 8 count and even mocked James by playing on the 4 again ahahah
Usually in terms of fking with notes in between, it’s the other way around
That's my favourite instrumental song from Metallica!! Such a shame they've performed it only twice!!!!!
*yeah it's a pretty decent instrumental. especially comes to life at a live show when the audience sings along to the melody (doesn't quiet translate on video- have to be there)*
@@FotherMucker00 I love Orion though, such an amazing song
Lars was holding up the show talking to his son in the Metallica 'Friend's and Family' room - which I was lucky enough to be in that night. Yeah, I wouldn't believe me either - but it's true. Cheers!
Nice little back story!!!
Do you know if the drums were overdubbed? If you look at 7:41 to 7:46 there's a time where you hear a cymbal hit and a time where you hear a snare hit and lars isn't playing either of them. Can you confirm this please? This is driving me nuts.
@@Joy2Rode *pro tools magic. can't blame'em... they played 80 something **_DIFFERENT_** songs at 4 shows in 7 days.*
A drummer that wanted to be a guitar player and a guitar player that wanted to be a drummer, and now we have Metallica....... the O.G American Thrash metal band\m/
And a bassist that played bass like a guitar
Fck, this song drives me insane every time i tune in . . . this is my 4th playback in the last few minutes and im still tripping on it
I loved that you kept recording... ...But... ...Hated... ...The... ...Way... ...You... ...Were... ...Telling... ...Us... ...Why... ...You... ...Had... ...Stopped... ...Just... ...Saying...!
Interesting seeing James giving the band cues to all the changes and looks at them like “hey get ready.”
3:08 Lars calls Avi to turn up the cooling fans, 'cause it's too hot on stage. Few years later, Avi will sing with Metallica on stage as the back-vocalist. That's the career! 😁
Is he the same guy who sang backing vocals at the AWMH Helping Hands concert last year?
@@b3fr1enderbetr4yer8 and second S&M too
when u are the best guitarist and drummer of the band
Doubtless
And with the best stage presence
Lars is a lot better than him face it. But i agree that he's the best guitarist of the band (I still love the bluesy rock-'n'-roll-ish style of Kirk Hammett but he's no very technical nowadays.)
You can see James improved from the 80s
Holy hell, with a little bit of practice he might actually make a decent drummer.
Edit: I'm talking about James.... obviously.
Funny how you had to make sure everyone knows you're talking about James
Funny how Lars compliments his stagehand "Avi" as, "the hardest working man in the business" in the same breath of asking him to turn the air on back there because the premadonna drummer is a little warm behind the drum kit - poor pampered little baby is such a high maintence princess. God forbid if he should break a sweat on his royal forehead & brow! 😖🌊🌈
@@m.c.ruckus2032 To be fair, as a drummer myself you do tend to sweat quite a lot, especially on stage with all those lights acting as heatguns.
@@kukelhupf that is fair. I too am quite familiar with the heat projected along with stage lighting. It's just that most in the live performance line of work don't choose to take the moment to register the compliant publicly while on stage DURING a performance that they are carelessly appearing late to. All eyes were already on him, because of that very reason. He's obviously a very special kind of musician & shouldn't be exposed to such abusive & unfair work conditions. He ought to report this to his local union representative!
-lol- 😂
Are you SURE you're talking about James? I mean, with a little practice, Lars might be just as good as James! 😆
Woah... this happened almost 10 years ago, and that just reminded me Metallica is turning 40 this year... damn...
James did this way back in 1990...whatever during the "year and a half in the life of Metallica" era. He and Lars also had a drum battle. I still have it on vhs lol
He would have been a legendary drummer just like he is on a guitar.
James is awesome!
I wish James and Kirk would trade solos on more songs.
Robert is no slouch either!
Come on guys give us one more Speed Metal record with groves and riffs.
How many people have been smoking pot there if they could smell it on stage even?
Great lyrics, by the way.
Honestly only takes one person, shit reeks especially in a place that's enclosed.
@@AarPlays no air-conditioning, huh?
But as far as I know, the more enclosed, the better the effect.
@@AarPlays my thought, exactly.
He's just as good as Lars and he doesn't even play the drums every show/practice.
Post a video of you playing drums.
@@kickinbackoutdoors2602 No you're a towel
@@AquariusC lol, ok. But until you can play better than Lars, shut it.
@@kickinbackoutdoors2602 dude just said het plays as good as Lars where tf did he says he plays drums good or Lars is terrible?
@@Stuntmanforlyf it was a shot at Lars. Read it again. ;)
James was trying to speed up the song to put Lars in trouble hahaha
I'm starting to think that James wrote the drum lines for everything in AJFA. Very different from Lars actual style before and after that. Anytime James just fucks around with drums, the progginess sounds like AJFA
Nope
these guys are so real, its hilarious - I love this band so much!
*this was only the 2nd ever live performance of Suicide & Redemption*
That's my favourite instrumental song from Metallica!! Such a shame they've performed it only twice!!!!!
So sad that they played this song only twice times :(
I think the first was better btw. Have they played it again since then? That was quite a while ago.
1:40
James: How many pepole does it take to get Lars dressed?
Guy in the crowd: All of them!
It was funny as hell when I 1st heard this performance. Even funnier when I finally see the performance itself
Love how even a band as big as big as Metallica messes up like that
It's an extremely tricky intro. Rob is the only one consistentpy playing, so the other three have to know where to come in, and it's super-syncopated.
That's how you know it's live.
@@MKDumas1981 it's really easy lol. it sounds way harder than it is to actually play
@@gnoogie: Well, yeah, if you know where they are. 2, the e of 3, and the & of 4.
1:40 "all of them" lol
LOL
So this is the lost vault of videos from the 2011 shows.
Haha they banter here more like their old shows. I love it. Thanks for the upload! Very much enjoyed it.
7:40 what audio am I hearing? Lars is surely fucking it up playing the one part too early but the audio is fine... Why would they fix it for liveMet audio?
It's called as "suicide and redemption "
I dont think he is messing that part up, sometime hell swing once before he will hit like a lot of drummers do.
@@isaacmorrow7077 there’s a cymbal crash in the audio that’s not present in the video lol
@@Izat605 It was edited after the fact by whoever mixed the show for LiveMetallica.
@@MichaelDermotMusic yes, and you can hear the snare and he's not playing it haha
1:19 Lars looks like he just woke up from a nap
They aren’t loosers sure they aren’t the same Metallica from the 80s and 90s. But they’ve sold millions of albums. If you don’t have anything nice to say don’t say it. Also don’t say they are bad or you can do better because everyone knows that you can't be better than Metallica or Metallica themselves
Who cares
@@bilalgarcia7685 more people than you think
they weren't even that bad. everyone fucks up sometimes, including metallica
Exactly everyone messes up it’s part of life
AMAZING PERFORMANCE!!! LOVE THIS BAND!!!
3:12 that Avi sing with James in S&M2
When the rhythm guitarist / vocalist is better than the actual drummer
He's really not
@@filipkocis3351 now? Nah. Then? Yah.
But he is not!
James looks way too much like the cool front man to be in the back on drums
i LOVE this man!
About 7:42 Lars doesn't touch hi-hat and snare, but I'm hearing hi-hat and snare! WTF?!
I believe that part doesnt use a Hi-Hat, but the snare bit is unexplained
video and audio are out of sync
it was filmed by someone in the crowd, but the audio is official from metallica
lars fucked it up so they dubbed the audio
@@Adam-bq6ic yeh makes sense, patch it up in post to make it better for listeners after. The actual camera audio would show the missing snares
@@no-ln8wm "Out of sync" sounds way too innocent. They dubbed the audio in post to cover the mistakes.
I could sit and watch and listen to Robert play bass guitar all night without James Hetfield and lars urich and Kirk hammett just Robert on stage playing bass guitar
8:00 - my heart...
Best drummer in metallica history
Which one
James
Ah no stupid watermark thank you
Kirk's smiles are way too wholesome 😂
James is not fucking around
7:40 wtf is lars doing, he’s playing different to what actual drums you can hear, just wtf is happening
Edition.
He's just adding spice
Dubbed audio, prolly bad syncing there
Lars must've gotten James angry at some point that day lol.
Thanks for not putting that infamous watermark on the center of the video. lol
Yoooo Rob on that bass 🤘🤘🤘🤘.
Is this the same concert where they did creeping death with jason?
I think so
Yes it is
They actually did a 4 day gig where they played almost every song with special guests as well. Creeping death must had been sang on day 1
Starts at 4:35
much better watermark my guy
Wtf..... Lmao this is fucking gold, 🤣 where was Lars. This can't be an actual concert. Must've been a special appearance or something.... I died when Lars just walked out and still made them wait to put his shoes on 😫😭 looool grandpa Lars
This was one of the Metallica 30th Anniversary Celebration shows in late 2011
Must have been on the shitter lol
Love the lyrics
Mucker, you mannaged to keep us in video until it ends even after some point it's not even a video, just a record. I'd say you'd be a great bussined person. Take that advice.
8:00
Nice to hear James swearing, hehe
its a shame that you couldn't finished recording, but the audio is awesome!! thanks for share!!
7:40 ????
playback 🤷♂️🤦♂️
Can someone keep the pot down Kirk's getting hungry that was hilarious
7:43 ???????????????????
i was looking for this comment... w t f
What's wrong?
Edit: The ghost snare
@@DeathRabbit *cymbal
its overdubb
@@hetfillizer ohhh wait it's both. Didn't know Lars was a psychic
Lars cant even play that double kick fill clean anymore
Fuck, killer song
Hahahahaha that's the way its always been...waiting on Lars. You're my boy Lars.
The first 4 minutes are very good
That BASS GUITAR IS A BEAST😎😎
love the way kirk is-HEY HEY
And that's why they don't play this masterpiece live. And that's why don't play the intros of Dyers Eve, or Spit Out The Bone, or Hardwired, and others. Anyway, they still kicking ass and still the best band on earth
Boy James was pissed at Lars here.
4:43 haha
Why does he have to play one?! He shoulda played St Anger intro. Haha
*07:43** oopsie*
Exactly!! What's going on?! In the video Lars Ulrich isn't hitting the crash but you can hear it!!
@@MUSiC-world-20986 *never playback ahah he just made a mistake and it was corrected in post. there's tons of mistakes that were overdubbed (not just Lars). can't blame them really since they played a completely different setlist bar Seek every night for four nights. think they played north of 80 (think 85-ish) different songs over the span of those 4 shows which is a mindfuck and a half. probably just wanted to have the most obvious flubs ironed out for the official recording. these 4 shows still rank as one of the most downloaded live recordings on **livemetallica.com** (there's a top 8 and all 4 of them are in it).*
yup. but whos the one who fixed the audio?
@@meabobo *pro tools and probably Mike Gillies aka metmixer (he used to record/mix the livemet stuff on pro tools back then)*
@@FotherMucker00 he is their protools engineer
Now greg fidelman is the one who mixes
cool performane and song!
How can the audio be that good? It sounds like a bootleg straight from the mix... surely not the camera
07:39 WTF BUG LARS???? WTFFFFFFFFFFFF FUCKING PLAYBACK IN DRUMS????
holy shit youre right wtf
good catch
I came here to see if anyone else saw it lmao!!!
The video was taken with a camera on the crowd, the audio is from the official audio they put on their website, can you imagine the audio from the camera being this good?
Probably dubbed before going up on wibsite for sale, which is a shame.
Why the hell were you ask to stop filming at the end who said that you can't film its not like smart phones wern't around in 2011 whats up?
Love Metallica
Why he playing "one"?
Maybe it's a Metallica track, it needs to be checked...
I came for the comment section and most of all, it's what i expected.
The actual fuck is Lars doing here, it's as if he hasn't even practiced the song.
He probably hasn't practiced. He does a lot of the backend stuff.
2:18 xD
7:40 wtf lars....
@Andy Don Overdubbed cymbal 7:43
@@Jez3134 what the balls
THE DRUM NEEDS A GUN LICENSE HA HA
He is better than Lars 😅
Lars going off at 12:04 👍 Glad he didn't skip that ala Moth Into flame
I called this a real content 🤘
James I love you iam fam de you from Honduras
James was more solid than Lars with one double bass
He didn't speed up or slow down but he didn't nail the sextuplets either.
92 san diego all over again haha
james got better and lars worse lol
kirk loves pot
yoooo james is better than lars
It’s a bit embarrasing to see how good James are at drums if you compare it to Lars on guitar
@Andy Don yes, but I meant if you compare James’ drum skills to Lars’ guitar skills
Love Tama, but if you’ve ever used those god awful hollow aluminum signature sticks…yee ho le! …Still no excuse for one of the most bankable drummers ever to not nail single note snare fills in time
Those sticks are made by ahead tho.
@@marshaltito7369 …Good call, I knew that but I see how it reads as being Tama “ sticks”
I had two pairs of Aheads and they both broke within two weeks respectively. They really aren't as good as they're chalked up to be. The only good thing they have going is the attack
@@Soloyologaming Well depends on how hard, how often and how fast you play. I buy Vic Firth's 2B sticks. One pair lasted 3 weeks and another lasted 3 months. I played mostly Thrash as hard as I could with the first pair.
И все токи, они очень хороши и велики, и публика их любит.
No joke, he plays it better than Lars.
holy fuck. 7:40 - 7:55 is complete play back from the drums. 😱
Only for 7:43-7:46, the rest is fine
*never playback ahah he just made a mistake and it was corrected in post. there's tons of mistakes that were overdubbed (not just Lars). can't blame them really since they played a completely different setlist bar Seek every night for four nights. think they played north of 80 (think 85-ish) different songs over the span of those 4 shows which is a mindfuck and a half. probably just wanted to have the most obvious flubs ironed out for the official recording. these 4 shows still rank as one of the most downloaded live recordings on **livemetallica.com** (there's a top 8 and all 4 of them are in it).*
@@FotherMucker00 okay, I see
at 7:43 lars is not playing but the sound of the drums still!!!!! is that a playback of lars?
Overdubbed fill
Overdubbed snare hits
Nice one James!