That's an interesting scenario. I'm surprised Mace didn't simply go "Okay, I won't kill him. You've put your trust in me by telling me who the Sith Lord was, and you've always been there for us when we needed you. So I'll put my trust in you and help you with whatever is troubling you as I can sense you're greatly worried about something and owe. All I want to know is two things. A) Can we take him off-world where he won't be a threat to anyone? B) Can we temporarily remove his hands and feet, and give him prosthetic replacements later so he can't hurt anyone else while we can properly secure him?"
@@ca_kay I want to say no. The idea though is to chop his hands and feet, transport him like that, put him in a prison that could contain someone like him, then give him prosthetic feet and hands. Without hands and feet, he's far less capable of fighting, getting away, etc. He can't hold a lightsaber, properly walk or balance, etc. It's also a morbid joke on Palpatine's expectations. He was expecting an attempted execution (in which case he knew what Anakin would do) or a regular arrest (in which case he knew what his allies would do or what he could do to escape his prison). He wasn't expecting proposals of limbs being cut off and being sent to a black site prison where his allies couldn't help him. That's a type of thing that would make Palpatine sweat and think he miscalculated.
If I had a nickel for every time Sidious was killed by the statue of Sistros I would have two nickels which isnt much, but it's weird it happened twice.
Small error. You can’t legally arrest Palpatine for being a sith when being a sith is not illegal. The senate would need more evidence to show other crimes, like his involvement in the war.
@@ca_kayThere's no proof of his treason. It's all hearsay, and the Grand Plan have been going on for centuries. A thousand year plan will not instantly end with the destruction of the Sith, for there would be back up contingencies.
If I had a nickel for every time Sidious was killed by the statue of Sistros I would have two nickels which isnt much, but it's weird it happened twice.
Good video StarWarsQuill. The only thing that this what if missed, in my opinion, is a conversation between Anakin and Windu after Padme gave birth to Luke and Leia. I feel like the two should’ve had a talk as Anakin was leaving the Jedi Order to clear the or between the two. Apart from my nitpick, the story was well thought out and had a good ending for everyone (Palpatine being an exception) I also enjoyed your explanation of Anakin’s thoughts from the novelisation of Revenge of the Sith as it helps to understand his actions.
What if the grand admiral thrawn used the death star prototype that was stationed in the maw cluster research station to defeat the rebels and or the emperor reborn
With a fight, he had to face one of the most powerful Jedi ever recorded, and one of his heavy swings felt like could Shattered your bones, so maybe Anakin and Palpatine joining against Mace he wooould be dead, killed by both the Dark Sith Master and the Jedi Knight
What if... after learning who his father is Luke and Leia went to Naboo to explore meeting all the remaining living relatives of Padme; Aunts, Uncles, Cousins, perhaps even living Grandparents there to meet?
Or was it? First the First Order rose and a few years later, 54 years after his death by Master Windu, Darth Sidious announced his return to the Galaxy! An old Anakin and Luke, or Jinn, as I read somewhere, as Anakin had wanted to name his son after Qui-gon Jinn, went to face Darth Sidious. It was a hard fight, but finally Anakin killed Darth Sidious, although it finally cost Anakin his life! Anakin hurled them back into a cloning pod, shutting Sidious inside and holding it shut himself and stabbing his lightsaber into Sidious and causing all the machines to explode! Anakin's body flew upwards and Luke caught it as it came down. Luke returned to Naboo, where Anakin was reunited with his family where he quickly died and vanished before their eyes! This was a shock for them and the Jedi as they wanted to give The Chosen One a Jedi funeral "there's no need for that" and turning they were shocked to see Anakin standing before them, surrounded by a light blue light! "How?" "I am part of the Cosmic Force. I will always be here" Anakin said and Obi-Wan, Yoda and a man Padme recognised as Qui-gon Jinn! "I love you all, and I will always be watching you" Anakin said smiling, and the four of them vanished! Padme died about a year later, but both she and Anakin had lived long enough to meet their grandchildren and know the Skywalker bloodline would survive.
I do not believe in any in all theories about Jar Jar being a sith lord himself. That just sounds like a rediculous reason people made up to hate Jar Jar more.
He should have just force pushed him and killed Sidious Why have him take full attention away from Sidious🤔 Overall interesting video though.. the way you did it is believable. You can tell I'm doing these edits as the video goes on😂😂😂 Noone thought that the visions of Padme's death could have been part of the manipulation from Sidious? Wouldn't him being dead have taken at least part of the fear from Anakin's mind? This isn't a nitpick it's a serious question. Where does Anakin's genuine fears end and Sidious's manipulation begin? I've heard so many conflicting ideas about this, and The Bread Circus did an excellent job arguing that Anakin actually had a real person for a father so I'm maybe thinking along those lines. I like the ending.
The lost 20, were 20 jedi MASTERS who left the order. In your timeline Anakin was still not a master, therefore he would not have been considered a member of the lost 20
What if Fives *escaped* Coruscant? Instead of trusting Skywalker and/or Rex, he instead trusts nobody and is able to flee Coruscant. Where would he go? Would Palpatine have him killed still? Would he recover and procure evidence?
This is A Correct Alternate Story of Star Wars in Episode 1 The Jedi Council don't trust Anakin Skywalker Even Grand Master Yoda and Mace Windu never trust Anakin Skywalker When Qui-Gon Jinn Died in Naboo He tells to Obi-Wan Kenobi to trained Anakin Skywalker in Episode 3 Mace Windu shouldn't listen to Anakin Skywalker if he doesn't Trust Anakin Skywalker and Order 66 will be revealed if Mace Windu fight Chancellor Palpatine and Anakin Skywalker
Anakin NEVER betrayed windu !!!!! Anakin stopped windu from assassinating the Chancellor . Weather he was right or wrong in theory , windu did not have the authority or Senatorial permission to arrest or kill the Chancellor . Windu allowed his arrogance and superiority complex to take over ( not to mention his own dark side and his religious zealotey. )
What If Kit Fisto survived and was around when Mace Windu defeated Palpatine and Anakin arrived in the Chancellor's office
What if Jar Jar ran into Palpatine’s office with a bomb wanting help, blowing up himself, Anakin, Palpatine, and Windu.
Real
Lmao 🌚
The funniest part is, this would absolutely happen in TCW but Anakin would somehow survive it
XD
I love the mace windu content bro. He’s so underrated. So thank you.
:)
@@starwarsquill can you do a video on what if the emperor sensed Darth Vader's betrayal in return of the jedi.
That's an interesting scenario. I'm surprised Mace didn't simply go
"Okay, I won't kill him. You've put your trust in me by telling me who the Sith Lord was, and you've always been there for us when we needed you.
So I'll put my trust in you and help you with whatever is troubling you as I can sense you're greatly worried about something and owe.
All I want to know is two things.
A) Can we take him off-world where he won't be a threat to anyone?
B) Can we temporarily remove his hands and feet, and give him prosthetic replacements later so he can't hurt anyone else while we can properly secure him?"
Would prosthetics actually stop him from using force lightning and such, though?
@@ca_kay I want to say no.
The idea though is to chop his hands and feet, transport him like that, put him in a prison that could contain someone like him, then give him prosthetic feet and hands.
Without hands and feet, he's far less capable of fighting, getting away, etc. He can't hold a lightsaber, properly walk or balance, etc.
It's also a morbid joke on Palpatine's expectations.
He was expecting an attempted execution (in which case he knew what Anakin would do) or a regular arrest (in which case he knew what his allies would do or what he could do to escape his prison).
He wasn't expecting proposals of limbs being cut off and being sent to a black site prison where his allies couldn't help him.
That's a type of thing that would make Palpatine sweat and think he miscalculated.
@@KonstanziaKenway Even if that is true, it is strictly against the Jedi rulebook to use that technique.
@@ca_kay Tell that to Master Yoda and his legendary force ball twist technique
@@KonstanziaKenway It's more like, you CAN do it, but doing it against a defeated opponent would get you kicked out of the order REAL fast.
7:15
Damn, this is twice now on this channel that Sistros has aided in the death of Sidious. That statue is dangerous, lmao
Haha
If I had a nickel for every time Sidious was killed by the statue of Sistros I would have two nickels which isnt much, but it's weird it happened twice.
Small error. You can’t legally arrest Palpatine for being a sith when being a sith is not illegal. The senate would need more evidence to show other crimes, like his involvement in the war.
It was under suspicion of treason, not being a Sith. Him being a Sith just lended to the belief in his treason.
@@ca_kayThere's no proof of his treason. It's all hearsay, and the Grand Plan have been going on for centuries. A thousand year plan will not instantly end with the destruction of the Sith, for there would be back up contingencies.
Mace windu stood on business in this story 🔥
Well done! Love that twist in the end with Darth Jar Jar 😅
I commented an idea for a what if for, The Star Wars Galaxy, what if Jango Fett lived?
If I had a nickel for every time Sidious was killed by the statue of Sistros I would have two nickels which isnt much, but it's weird it happened twice.
*SISTROS WILL RETURN*
Good video StarWarsQuill. The only thing that this what if missed, in my opinion, is a conversation between Anakin and Windu after Padme gave birth to Luke and Leia. I feel like the two should’ve had a talk as Anakin was leaving the Jedi Order to clear the or between the two.
Apart from my nitpick, the story was well thought out and had a good ending for everyone (Palpatine being an exception) I also enjoyed your explanation of Anakin’s thoughts from the novelisation of Revenge of the Sith as it helps to understand his actions.
Darth Jar Jar choked on a sandwich and died 1 month after Sidius died.
What if the grand admiral thrawn used the death star prototype that was stationed in the maw cluster research station to defeat the rebels and or the emperor reborn
What if the Jedi allowed connections?
Great story of Windu taking over fighting Palpatine and winning the way he did. Glad Anakin never turned.
When will Darth Jar Jar become a video game character? 😁
With a fight, he had to face one of the most powerful Jedi ever recorded, and one of his heavy swings felt like could Shattered your bones, so maybe Anakin and Palpatine joining against Mace he wooould be dead, killed by both the Dark Sith Master and the Jedi Knight
What if Kit Fisto was still alive when Anakin showed up
What if... after learning who his father is Luke and Leia went to Naboo to explore meeting all the remaining living relatives of Padme; Aunts, Uncles, Cousins, perhaps even living Grandparents there to meet?
Luke would become very rich then I guess haha
This is basically the same thing but what if mace caught anakins blade before it cut his arm off
Or was it? First the First Order rose and a few years later, 54 years after his death by Master Windu, Darth Sidious announced his return to the Galaxy!
An old Anakin and Luke, or Jinn, as I read somewhere, as Anakin had wanted to name his son after Qui-gon Jinn, went to face Darth Sidious. It was a hard fight, but finally Anakin killed Darth Sidious, although it finally cost Anakin his life! Anakin hurled them back into a cloning pod, shutting Sidious inside and holding it shut himself and stabbing his lightsaber into Sidious and causing all the machines to explode! Anakin's body flew upwards and Luke caught it as it came down.
Luke returned to Naboo, where Anakin was reunited with his family where he quickly died and vanished before their eyes! This was a shock for them and the Jedi as they wanted to give The Chosen One a Jedi funeral "there's no need for that" and turning they were shocked to see Anakin standing before them, surrounded by a light blue light! "How?" "I am part of the Cosmic Force. I will always be here" Anakin said and Obi-Wan, Yoda and a man Padme recognised as Qui-gon Jinn! "I love you all, and I will always be watching you" Anakin said smiling, and the four of them vanished!
Padme died about a year later, but both she and Anakin had lived long enough to meet their grandchildren and know the Skywalker bloodline would survive.
What if Rahm Kota trained Anikin? What if Chewbacca was born a jedi?
Meesa been thinking that a bombadass sequel is due, wheresa Jar Jar Plagueis reveals himself, forcing Anakin back into his role as the Chisen One.
I hope and pray Disney doesn't decide to make a windu show I can only imagine how bad they would screw it up
I do not believe in any in all theories about Jar Jar being a sith lord himself. That just sounds like a rediculous reason people made up to hate Jar Jar more.
All hail Darth Jar Jar!!!
He should have just force pushed him and killed Sidious
Why have him take full attention away from Sidious🤔
Overall interesting video though.. the way you did it is believable.
You can tell I'm doing these edits as the video goes on😂😂😂
Noone thought that the visions of Padme's death could have been part of the manipulation from Sidious? Wouldn't him being dead have taken at least part of the fear from Anakin's mind? This isn't a nitpick it's a serious question. Where does Anakin's genuine fears end and Sidious's manipulation begin? I've heard so many conflicting ideas about this, and The Bread Circus did an excellent job arguing that Anakin actually had a real person for a father so I'm maybe thinking along those lines. I like the ending.
The lost 20, were 20 jedi MASTERS who left the order. In your timeline Anakin was still not a master, therefore he would not have been considered a member of the lost 20
What if Ki-Adi-Mundi became grand master?
What if Fives *escaped* Coruscant? Instead of trusting Skywalker and/or Rex, he instead trusts nobody and is able to flee Coruscant.
Where would he go? Would Palpatine have him killed still? Would he recover and procure evidence?
That’s interesting! Thanks
This is A Correct Alternate Story of Star Wars in Episode 1 The Jedi Council don't trust Anakin Skywalker Even Grand Master Yoda and Mace Windu never trust Anakin Skywalker When Qui-Gon Jinn Died in Naboo He tells to Obi-Wan Kenobi to trained Anakin Skywalker in Episode 3 Mace Windu shouldn't listen to Anakin Skywalker if he doesn't Trust Anakin Skywalker and Order 66 will be revealed if Mace Windu fight Chancellor Palpatine and Anakin Skywalker
Anakin NEVER betrayed windu !!!!!
Anakin stopped windu from assassinating the Chancellor .
Weather he was right or wrong in theory , windu did not have the authority or Senatorial permission to arrest or kill the Chancellor .
Windu allowed his arrogance and superiority complex to take over ( not to mention his own dark side and his religious zealotey. )
Or what if no jedi died and killed anakin
The Lost 20 were Jedi Masters who left the order. Anakin could not be one of them as a Jedi Knight.Otherise a good job with this story.
what if count Dooku used to death start on croissant during the clone war?
With 666 likes i cant bring myself to give another like 😂