You can see how much so when he and The Edge are mesmerized hanging with Mr.. Page and watching him play a few chords…they looked like children in a toy store. It’s on RUclips.
So who the hell do they think bought all those Led Zeppelin albums? Only people with musical training? No it was us!!! You don’t need to be trained in music to LOVE MUSIC. You keep doing you. Love y’all.❤
Wow, someone criticized you for not having musical training or experience??? Hell, 95% of reactors don’t. I usually actually prefer that. Often well educated reactors pause every minute to share their expertise which drives me nuts. Each to his own. 😁
Thanks for playing my pick!!!... so yes I understand how you love seeing the live performances, we all do... but this is great example of why its important especially with Zeppelin to experience the original recordings as well... the creative genius starts with their creation of the song for the album. Jimmy can only play one guitar live, but he often overdubbed numerous guitars in the studio to create the effect he wanted and to give us his vision in a completed piece of music. In this case an acoustic guitar played in counterpoint at the same time as the heavy electric guitar plus overdubbed solo guitars played in harmony... PLUS Robert adding multiple voices as well... And the bass line and the drums can be heard SO clearly on the original recordings!!!... All four of them were masters in the studio.... Of course what Zep did with these songs live (sadly they never played this one) is an experience in itself.... SO, your only choice, even if you dont do it for us, is to listen to BOTH the studio and live versions, thats the BEST way to experience the mightly LED ZEPPELIN!!! Love ya and thanks!!!
They in fact DID play this song in their 2007 live goodbye concert. I have the DVD to prove it!!! A great farewell to the mighty Led Zepp decades later. :)
@@ericbeggs746 yes I was at that 2007 show and sorry as much as I love Jason Bonham that’s not Led Zeppelin! Led Zeppelin without John Bonham is not Led Zeppelin. I’m talking about during their career from 1968 to 1980 other than playing maybe one verse of it in 1970 they never played the whole song.
I adore you both endlessly because there's nothing fake here. At least you give it an earnest blind reaction and your true thoughts. It's refreshing to see reactors genuinely interested in learning not just a flashy reaction and numbers. Both have their audience. ✌️ Music is my background for 5 decades. I've also watched over 40 music reactors for 4 years. I helped 3 reaction channels reach 100K behind the scenes. I hope that qualifies me or at least brings validity to my statement that there's nothing fake here on your channel since day one. Two of your biggest strengths is being humble and self depreciating. Keep enjoying each other and the music, you are doing great.
Especially in the outro where he really just goes nuts. The bass line during the verses underpins the whole structure and melody. My favorite song of all time since it was first released. Just brilliant in every way.
Born in 63. Lived this music. Your reactions are beautiful. The best analysis comes from people hearing first time with a clean slate. Whoever critized you is brainless. Ramble on!😮
Thank you. as far as your reactions go they are pure and heartfelt. As for trained musicians and vocalists reactions, they spend more time trying to show you how smart they are which is a turn off. What makes your reactions so special is that you express how the music makes you feel instead of trying to come off as know it alls. There is something called a musicologist which is what a person is called that has no formal training but knows what they like to hear and can pick out unique sounds throughout the song. That's where I place you two. Keep them coming, you're doing great. Don't hate the haters, pray for them.
I enjoy your reactions so much!! Keep doing what you're doing EXACTLY the way you're doing it. Please pay no attention to critics and keep up the amazing work. 😎👍
Don't listen to haters! You two are VERY qualified to comment on the music, the lyrics, the musicians, and we love hearing you react to it all! Keep doing what you are doing!
Oh my goodness, I get so happy when yall do Zeppelin!! How silly, whoever said you have to be "musically educated" (or whatever they said) are just showing their own ignorance, so don't listen to them. All you need are your ears to hear the music and your voice to tell us how it makes you feel. That's all we want. You two are just the sweetest and most genuine couple on youtube and I love and adore you both for it! Don't change a thing, and keep going with Led Zeppelin!! ☮️
You don't have to have musical education to know what you love and what moves you. It was not right for anyone to criticize you for expressing yourself without being an expert. I knew exactly what you were talking about, and I always do. This has always been one of my favorite Led Zeppelin songs, and I loved your reaction to it.
That is part of what makes Zeppelin great. EVERY TIME you listen- the experience is always different. Between studio and live performances - yes, but even hearing the studio versions over time- 40 or 50 years+- you almost always hear something new that moves you.
Oh, now this is a great choice - can't wait to watch how much you both enjoy this one. One of my all-time favourite Zep tunes, the whole band is on fire for this one. Awesome reaction as always, peace and love from Canada☮
Your reactions are beautiful. The joy at each new motif as it is effortlessly pulled out and laid upon the table... The word rapture springs to mind. And I agree with both of you 100%. I have always liked Led Zeppelin and "Ramble On" has been a favourite ever since the first time I heard it.
Its never too late to discover the genius of Led Zeppelin. Now you have heard it for the first time, with each consecutive play read the lyrics, listen to the words and you will discover new layers. This one has Tolkien references, Plant was a huge fan. They weren't just talented, they were also educated.
❤❤❤🔥🔥❤❤❤ Thank you for tapping into Led Zepplin. As you can see I love Led Zepplin. So much talent in that band. It was so unfortunate that they broke up after the death of their drummer John Bonham. 3 years before that Robert Plant lost his 5 year old son from a stomach virus while they were touring. Stay safe❤❤
One thing you both definitely know, they are the greatest, nobody compares. We just know what we love, & moves us. They must have something special, millions have loved them for over 50 years. Always love your Led Zeppelin reactions, you two are the cutest couple.
You are both great and the delight you show for different music is fantastic. Lovely people like you don’t need to say anything technical about the music. I’m pretty sure most of us watch you because of who you are. No need to change. 🤗
A lot of the studio versions are best for the first introduction to the song. Then you find live version, and not one, but many, and many more. Here, his voice is layered. You cannot do that on stage. Same with the harmonica in the "Levee song". Studio and live versions are both equally great, just different experiences.
Rock and Roll is all about just feeling it... YOU'RE DOING IT RIGHT! The critical person misses the point. Rock is music for all of us: music of the masses.
Your interactions are delightful. Thx ✌🏻 Zep was my 1st concert. ❤ 1969, pirates world in south Florida.. Wow, blew me away. Fun seeing your reactions.
Zeppelin, in Jimmy's own words, were 'light and shade'. By that he meant what you are talking about Andre; how they punch really hard but also have very soft folksy songs too. This one shows both sides. Robert's early lyrics were often sprinkled with Tolkien references. I think he swallowed 'Lord of the Rings' just before writing this.
Hey guys, I was at a function one time and someone was trying to impress everyone with his wine knowledge. He basically asked me what I know about wine and I told him I know what I like. You know what you like, that's all you need.
Love ur reactions to the mighty led zeppelin.ur doing a great job. JPJ bass is awesome.him & bonzo were fantastic. Led Zep have no bad tracks .uve started down that rabbithole. Listen to Fool in the Rain/ In the Evening/ Bron y aur stomp/ lemon Song just a few. So so many.
Aww YAY SO **Excited** when i saw this i always say that **My Most Favorite Led Zeppelin Song Is The One I Am Listening To At Any Given Moment** BUT this one DOES hold a special place in my **Heart** cuz it was like i think my very 1st fav song by them when i 1st started listening to them when i was like 7-8 years old so YAY cant wait to see what you two **Lovely** beings think & feel about it! Weeeeeee **PixieHUgz&Luvz**
The person who suggested you can't criticise a song unless you are musically educated is an idiot. Of course you can, and you do, very well too. I appreciate that understanding music theory might enhance someone's enjoyment, but a purely visceral reaction is no less valid. Neither John Lennon nor Paul McCartney could read music, but that didn't stop them from creating some of the best music of the 20th Century. I would never criticise anyone for educating themselves, but the elitism and snobbery of that remark isn't worth a second thought. Keep on doing what you do and I'll keep on enjoying your output.
When I went to school, sure, all the 4th graders got to play recorders, and you could join the concert band when you are 10, but in 7th grade (12 -13 years old) we had a class in school called "Music appreciation" which was mandatory for all students. Most of the year, we listened to Bach, Beethoven, Vivaldi, Wagner, Mozart, early American rag time music, origins of blues, country, and rock music. We had the class everyday right after lunch.
Ramble On!!! Best song ❤You have to watch the Kennedy honors when heart pays tribute to Led Zeppelin and their in the audience!!! One of the best moments ever
Jack White once said "be wary of anyone who doesn't like Led Zeppelin" and I agree, it's impossible not to love them.
You can see how much so when he and The Edge are mesmerized hanging with Mr.. Page and watching him play a few chords…they looked like children in a toy store. It’s on RUclips.
@@DragnSlayr23👌
So who the hell do they think bought all those Led Zeppelin albums? Only people with musical training? No it was us!!! You don’t need to be trained in music to LOVE MUSIC. You keep doing you. Love y’all.❤
Wow, someone criticized you for not having musical training or experience??? Hell, 95% of reactors don’t. I usually actually prefer that. Often well educated reactors pause every minute to share their expertise which drives me nuts. Each to his own. 😁
Yep. And ultimately consumers have the final say. We've been proving the elitist and critics wrong for 55 years.
Yea but they need to do more Karen Carpenter!😢
@@michaelasay8587 not on my account. That’s for sure.
It’s a requirement of mine. I prefer emotion reactors to technical ones
Those channels that analyze were interesting to me at first but now they're annoying. Not only pausing but some rewinding over and over.
Don't pay attention to the critics. You guys do a great job.
That bass line is SO...... EFFIN....... BEAUTIFUL
Every time I hear this song, as great as all of the instruments and vocals are, John Paul Jones absolutely shreds the bass....especially in this song.
One of my favorite basslines of all times.
It roars!!!
"What Is and Should Never Be" bass is pretty awesome too.
@@jackempson3044 Completely agreed
One of Led Zeppelin's finest arrangements - acoustic and electric guitars, bass, drums and voice.That is it. Perfection
I love the smiles on both your faces whenever you react to Zeppelin, especially whenever Robert’s vocals let rip!
Thanks for playing my pick!!!... so yes I understand how you love seeing the live performances, we all do... but this is great example of why its important especially with Zeppelin to experience the original recordings as well... the creative genius starts with their creation of the song for the album. Jimmy can only play one guitar live, but he often overdubbed numerous guitars in the studio to create the effect he wanted and to give us his vision in a completed piece of music. In this case an acoustic guitar played in counterpoint at the same time as the heavy electric guitar plus overdubbed solo guitars played in harmony... PLUS Robert adding multiple voices as well... And the bass line and the drums can be heard SO clearly on the original recordings!!!... All four of them were masters in the studio.... Of course what Zep did with these songs live (sadly they never played this one) is an experience in itself.... SO, your only choice, even if you dont do it for us, is to listen to BOTH the studio and live versions, thats the BEST way to experience the mightly LED ZEPPELIN!!! Love ya and thanks!!!
They in fact DID play this song in their 2007 live goodbye concert. I have the DVD to prove it!!! A great farewell to the mighty Led Zepp decades later. :)
@@ericbeggs746 yes I was at that 2007 show and sorry as much as I love Jason Bonham that’s not Led Zeppelin! Led Zeppelin without John Bonham is not Led Zeppelin. I’m talking about during their career from 1968 to 1980 other than playing maybe one verse of it in 1970 they never played the whole song.
Many thanks for your support! And for making our life better when sending those awesome songs our way! 😍💚
I prefer your appreciation rather than education or expertise. Great reaction!
One of the greatest bass lines in history. Brilliant composition.
Experience Led Zeppelin and enjoy. There is no need to break down every instrument. Let it touch your soul.
No other band could employ dynamics like Zeppelin. This is a great example of their mastery of that sensibility.
John Paul Jones on bass and keyboards. A musical genius.
You don't need a musical education to enjoy music! So, keep on enjoying it. I certainly enjoy your reactions!
Dominika, you are rambling on about Ramble On. It doesn't get any more perfect. ❤ your enthusiasm.
THIS is the ideal music reaction. It's exactly what you would want in one. Pure joy from music, there's nothing else like it.🤘☮️
I adore you both endlessly because there's nothing fake here. At least you give it an earnest blind reaction and your true thoughts. It's refreshing to see reactors genuinely interested in learning not just a flashy reaction and numbers. Both have their audience. ✌️
Music is my background for 5 decades. I've also watched over 40 music reactors for 4 years. I helped 3 reaction channels reach 100K behind the scenes. I hope that qualifies me or at least brings validity to my statement that there's nothing fake here on your channel since day one.
Two of your biggest strengths is being humble and self depreciating. Keep enjoying each other and the music, you are doing great.
My favorite Led song. Gotta love the Tolkien references
Robert was somewhat obsessed with Tolkein and Vikings. He even called his dog Strider.
They were and still are the best.
You know a great band when you hear them!, and Led Zeppelin is that, for sure!
All that matters is if the music moves you!
Who else makes you smile like that!!? Nobody. ❤😊
That JPJ bass line is pure filth
Especially in the outro where he really just goes nuts. The bass line during the verses underpins the whole structure and melody. My favorite song of all time since it was first released. Just brilliant in every way.
Led Zeppelin is the Goat
Born in 63. Lived this music. Your reactions are beautiful. The best analysis comes from people hearing first time with a clean slate. Whoever critized you is brainless. Ramble on!😮
I keep saying it but the joy on your faces,especially to Zep is priceless and makes me smile every time. You guys are priceless !!!
“Nobody else was better than Led Zeppelin”! EXACTLY,
Thank you. as far as your reactions go they are pure and heartfelt. As for trained musicians and vocalists reactions, they spend more time trying to show you how smart they are which is a turn off. What makes your reactions so special is that you express how the music makes you feel instead of trying to come off as know it alls. There is something called a musicologist which is what a person is called that has no formal training but knows what they like to hear and can pick out unique sounds throughout the song. That's where I place you two. Keep them coming, you're doing great. Don't hate the haters, pray for them.
This is a great song......one of my favourites for sure !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Plant is the greatest singer, he uses his vocals, prefect for every song. You can tell he loves what he’s doing, & he feels & makes us feel it too.
I enjoy your reactions so much!! Keep doing what you're doing EXACTLY the way you're doing it. Please pay no attention to critics and keep up the amazing work. 😎👍
Folks you both truly feel the mighty Zeppelin, Dominica is a proper fan xx
Don't listen to haters! You two are VERY qualified to comment on the music, the lyrics, the musicians, and we love hearing you react to it all! Keep doing what you are doing!
This song is so beautiful
In my top 3 or 5 or 10…
Who knows of Zep songs?!?!
Can not go wrong with this band!!❤️
Your reaction are REAL y'all feel the music. Zeppelin Groupings
Oh my goodness, I get so happy when yall do Zeppelin!! How silly, whoever said you have to be "musically educated" (or whatever they said) are just showing their own ignorance, so don't listen to them. All you need are your ears to hear the music and your voice to tell us how it makes you feel. That's all we want. You two are just the sweetest and most genuine couple on youtube and I love and adore you both for it! Don't change a thing, and keep going with Led Zeppelin!! ☮️
I just love you two! Great reaction. Imo no two Led Zeppelin songs are the same.
You don't have to have musical education to know what you love and what moves you. It was not right for anyone to criticize you for expressing yourself without being an expert. I knew exactly what you were talking about, and I always do. This has always been one of my favorite Led Zeppelin songs, and I loved your reaction to it.
Love u two , so cute
That is part of what makes Zeppelin great. EVERY TIME you listen- the experience is always different. Between studio and live performances - yes, but even hearing the studio versions over time- 40 or 50 years+- you almost always hear something new that moves you.
That bass line... JPJ then lets it really rip as the track fades out.
My favorite Led song.
Every Zeppelin song is different, but you always know it's them when you hear it!
Who the f wud criticize these guys? Their like
..the nicest people ever!
Don't listen to people that are rude. 50+ year's listening to Zepp I still hear different sounds to this day. They are the GOATS.
You’re exactly right. It is an unbelievable bass song
Anyone who loves this song as much as me is a friend of mine.
Best ever...love it guys!!!
Oh, now this is a great choice - can't wait to watch how much you both enjoy this one. One of my all-time favourite Zep tunes, the whole band is on fire for this one. Awesome reaction as always, peace and love from Canada☮
You two are the best🤩 Love your down to earth reactions. Keep rocking!
Of all their great songs this is my favorite.
I absolutely ❤ when you both react with....ooohhh!, its the best! Much ❤ to you both!
Love Led Zeppelin!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
You guys are so much fun THANK YOU!
Your reactions are beautiful. The joy at each new motif as it is effortlessly pulled out and laid upon the table... The word rapture springs to mind. And I agree with both of you 100%. I have always liked Led Zeppelin and "Ramble On" has been a favourite ever since the first time I heard it.
Its never too late to discover the genius of Led Zeppelin. Now you have heard it for the first time, with each consecutive play read the lyrics, listen to the words and you will discover new layers. This one has Tolkien references, Plant was a huge fan. They weren't just talented, they were also educated.
Musical masterpiece. 👏👏
❤❤❤🔥🔥❤❤❤ Thank you for tapping into Led Zepplin. As you can see I love Led Zepplin. So much talent in that band. It was so unfortunate that they broke up after the death of their drummer John Bonham. 3 years before that Robert Plant lost his 5 year old son from a stomach virus while they were touring. Stay safe❤❤
One thing you both definitely know, they are the greatest, nobody compares. We just know what we love, & moves us. They must have something special, millions have loved them for over 50 years. Always love your Led Zeppelin reactions, you two are the cutest couple.
Absolutely right!
You are both great and the delight you show for different music is fantastic. Lovely people like you don’t need to say anything technical about the music. I’m pretty sure most of us watch you because of who you are. No need to change. 🤗
A lot of the studio versions are best for the first introduction to the song. Then you find live version, and not one, but many, and many more.
Here, his voice is layered. You cannot do that on stage. Same with the harmonica in the "Levee song". Studio and live versions are both equally great, just different experiences.
Rock and Roll is all about just feeling it... YOU'RE DOING IT RIGHT! The critical person misses the point. Rock is music for all of us: music of the masses.
I love Dominicas reaction when Robert lets rip with the vocals. Its pure delight/excitement. I wish i could bottle it and sell it!! ❤❤
Timeless.
Don't need a musical education to feel the music, and yes, nobody better than Zep
My favorite people on you tube. Love you guys!!!
Your interactions are delightful. Thx ✌🏻 Zep was my 1st concert. ❤ 1969, pirates world in south Florida.. Wow, blew me away. Fun seeing your reactions.
Love Ya to both of you!
When we were young we had a drinking game.You drank everytime Robert says baby...lol
Your very experienced you acknowledge total brilliance
The greatest rock group of all time. ☮🎸❤🙏
Btw you two have humility. I'm pretty sure whoever said that does not. And they'll never have it.
Zeppelin, in Jimmy's own words, were 'light and shade'. By that he meant what you are talking about Andre; how they punch really hard but also have very soft folksy songs too. This one shows both sides. Robert's early lyrics were often sprinkled with Tolkien references. I think he swallowed 'Lord of the Rings' just before writing this.
There are no words! The GOATS! 😎🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Love your reactions! Thanks for sharing your experience with us!
John Paul Jones bass line on this is sublime. Best bassist ever !!!!
Hey guys, I was at a function one time and someone was trying to impress everyone with his wine knowledge. He basically asked me what I know about wine and I told him I know what I like. You know what you like, that's all you need.
You don’t need to be a rocket scientist to know what you like….I always enjoy your opinions
This and THANK YOU are two of my favorite Zeppelin tracks!❤❤❤😂
Love ur reactions to the mighty led zeppelin.ur doing a great job. JPJ bass is awesome.him & bonzo were fantastic. Led Zep have no bad tracks .uve started down that rabbithole. Listen to Fool in the Rain/ In the Evening/ Bron y aur stomp/ lemon Song just a few. So so many.
I’m 69 been listening to to zeppelin since I was a kid have a brother five years older so that’s why
Like without even starting the video :D
Thank you for giving a shout out to John Paul Jones on the bass. He absolutely rips on this song. Just incredible
I love your show!!!
Ramble on, and keep on rambling. By the way, I should mention how much I like you guys.
Merchants of Alba!!!!!
you two are excellent at this.....bravo
Just keep loving the music ❤️
"Nobody else was better than Led Zeppelin." Your training is proceding very well, young Padawan.
Aww YAY SO **Excited** when i saw this i always say that **My Most Favorite Led Zeppelin Song Is The One I Am Listening To At Any Given Moment** BUT this one DOES hold a special place in my **Heart** cuz it was like i think my very 1st fav song by them when i 1st started listening to them when i was like 7-8 years old so YAY cant wait to see what you two **Lovely** beings think & feel about it! Weeeeeee **PixieHUgz&Luvz**
Listening to them, is like watching a great movie! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
You may not know musical terms but I love your reactions... You're both sweet guys!
Love you your reaction. Just enjoy your journey
As a novice bass player, I love the bass in this song..
The person who suggested you can't criticise a song unless you are musically educated is an idiot. Of course you can, and you do, very well too. I appreciate that understanding music theory might enhance someone's enjoyment, but a purely visceral reaction is no less valid. Neither John Lennon nor Paul McCartney could read music, but that didn't stop them from creating some of the best music of the 20th Century. I would never criticise anyone for educating themselves, but the elitism and snobbery of that remark isn't worth a second thought. Keep on doing what you do and I'll keep on enjoying your output.
I love how Led Zep took a lot of inspiration from J.R.R. Tolkien.
When I went to school, sure, all the 4th graders got to play recorders, and you could join the concert band when you are 10, but in 7th grade (12 -13 years old) we had a class in school called "Music appreciation" which was mandatory for all students. Most of the year, we listened to Bach, Beethoven, Vivaldi, Wagner, Mozart, early American rag time music, origins of blues, country, and rock music. We had the class everyday right after lunch.
Our school was in very rural farmland area of central Pennsylvania. Not a big city private school. Just public education.
Ramble On!!! Best song ❤You have to watch the Kennedy honors when heart pays tribute to Led Zeppelin and their in the audience!!! One of the best moments ever
That's Bonham tapping on one of Jimmy's guitar cases in the beginning (tap tap tap tap0
Love you reactions, have subscribed. 👍