THE RINGS OF POWER PITCH MEETING - Ryan George - REACTION
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 дек 2022
- This year, show after show came out of Marvel Studios, from She-Hulk to Moon Knight and Ms Marvel. Then there was Netflix's The Sandman.
And finally we got two shows competing for our attention: Game of Thrones House of the Dragon... and Lord of the Rings The Rings of Power. And clearly... the last one was by and large the most popular... to sleep on.
Ryan George at Pitch Meeting does his thing and pitches The Rings of Power and we give our unfiltered reaction and thoughts.
____________________
Trailer Link:
• The Rings Of Power Pit...
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~ACHARA KIRK~
Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
/ achara
~JABS~
RUclips, Twitter, Instagram: @GETJaby
___________________________________________________
SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
ruclips.net/user/subscription_c...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Song used during intro:
Acid Jazz Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Song used during intro:
Your Call High Quality by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Song Used During Outro:
Easy Jam Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b... 
Развлечения
In my English class, I asked the teacher to show the LOTR pitch meetings, and it was a class mostly focused on Tolkien's works, so now, in class, every Middle Earth based pitch meeting has been seen except this one
Watching the Rings of Power pitch meeting rather than the actual show is tight
I really love authors who go so far as to make a functional language for novels.Hats off to them
He made multiple, actually, as you may know. Also, tons of detailed maps, and thousands of years of cohesive history explaining the evolution of the people, geography, and locations of his world.
Other way around actually. He was a linguist by profession and he did come up with elvish as his own language because of that. And then he had a language but nothing to do with it, so he decided to write a book to use it in. He made the language first and then made the book so he had somewhere to actually use the language he made.
Yeah, what the other guy said, the languages came first. He made a series of novels for his languages.
The moment this dropped on Ryan's channel, I knew in advance I looked forward to Your Reaction to it, and I _loved it_ obviously...
Ryan George is one of the the _best_ reviewers in how he formulates his Pitch Meetings.....
Thanks Jaby for this reaction of pitch meeting, This was my fav episode.
Both of you take care and drink plenty of hot tea
the mere fact that Galadriel takes volcanic ash to the face and gets dusty is hilarious when you consider that mere seconds later a random horse is on fire and she's not...do her mary sue powers shield her from a thousand-degree pyroclastic flow as well as allow her to single-handedly take on an ice troll and swim across an entire ocean only to randomly come across Sauron on a raft? They still haven't explained why an all-powerful dark lord would moonlight as a beta human man in the first place.
Yeah pretty sure there are examples of what happens to people who get covered in volcanic ash from 79 ad. Little place called Pompeii with a volcano next to it
her plot armor is nigh impenetrable
Well, we know Sauron was trying to con his way into Numenor
Man that scene🤦♂Couldn't they just at least had a shot of her diving for cover, or did they think that would make her look weak.
Yeah, because its ok for Frodo and Sam to walk into the heart of a Volcano, which would act as an oven and be 1000s of degrees.
I always found it strange and frustrating that Galadriel was changed from a powerful sorceress to Eowyn, a warrior princess. On top of that they gave Galadriel a horrible personality. At least Eowyn wasn't insufferable.
"What would I be without a sword?" -Character who literally tore down mountains without a sword
This girl never hated a show or movie ever she always find a way to say there's some moments I enjoyed
because she's not afflicted with the "I need to show and tell people how much I hate things to convince them I'm smart" disease Simon Cowell popularized.
@@yannym4605 nah she's just a noncomittal centrist that refuses to have any opinion so no one could dislike her, stripping her of any possibility of a personality.
"Meh." Powerful words to live by there Jaby, almost cut a tear.
I appreciate Jaby keeping it real and just being honest when he thinks something is good or bad.
I don't know nor have seen a single person excited for season 2
the only thing i can say.. season 2 can't be as bad as season 1. Right?
@@eolsunderIts gonna continue the hated season 1 with even more diversion from the storyline that people liked, so you tell me
Fun Fact: the names were actually CORRECTLY PRONOUNCED according to the way Tolkien created them & said to pronounce them, ONE OF THE FEW THINGS... they got right....
Sometimes....They flopped around so much and tried pretty much every frigging way you could pronounce a Name, so of course sometimes they would get it right. :D
It would only work if they kept the same dialect with everything else they said, not just random names.
And it seems to be the only time where they shouldn't have taken Tolkien's work so religiously.
I think part of the problem is that e.g. Elvish is based on Finnish so it doesn't work if just one word is pronounced "correctly" if everything else is in a completely different accent.
At best it will be like an American pronouncing lasagne "correctly", at worst it will be like an American trying to pronounce nộm hoa chuối correctly.
@@ashishhembrom3905 Explain?
I think this was one of Ryan's best. I got good laughs out of it.
this might be the funnies one he has ever done 😭 not just because it is easy materials haha .... but he really brought his a game here ! 💕 he is so funny
"Isn't it possible that he engineered this?"
No. Because the only way that would be possible is if he *knew* that Galadriel was going to be sent back to Valinor, which he couldn't know, that at the last second she would jump off the ship, which he also can't know, and where exactly her swimming + tides would take her, which he probably can't know.
Theoretically the Mayar who controls water may have had a hand in moving Galadriel to *a* raft/ship, but we have no idea in the show that they exist given how messed up the lore is in the show, and the fact that the raft that she was guided to (if that is the case) has fucking Sauron on it is just so improbable that its borderline impossible.
In a sense, I think the show is a success. Everybody talked about how bad Amazon’s series was that I ended up buying the actual books on ….…. Amazon.
On a side note, the appendix in the book has an entire section on how to pronounce the names and stuff. Tolkien was a genius. He created a functional language and even considered how the passing of time and mixing of cultures would change it.
I would not say it was a success if they were considering of redoing the entire thing
@@HonestOpinions4u It's more of a 'no matter what we win' situation. If people love it, great Amazon can sell a bunch of show memorabilia. If it sucks, people will just buy old Tolkien stuff... from amazon. It would be genius if they hadn't spent a billion dollars on this dumpster fire.
He was a linguist. He made the language because he was interested in languages. Then he had a language but nowhere to use it, so he wrote a book to get some use out of the language.
I get that she's not a hater but she tries so hard to like everything which makes me question her reviews
My thoughts exactly 😂
@@iamme25yago23 Not exactly true. I and many others I know have read the books many times and deeply loved them, and enjoyed the show while acknowledging that it's flawed.
I mean so you want her to be mean for no reason?
@I am me • 25y ago It's a tragedy but unwritten rule that adaptions of books are nearly always worse if not horrible compared to the original work. For instance, if they adapted my favorite book series it would probably turn out to be the worst ever adaption brought to screen yet, because of the complexity.
@I am me • 25y ago honestly for rings of power, you need to only read one book. The Silmarillion. I know they needed to buy the rights for The Silmarillion and couldnt but then shouldnt have rewritten whatever the hell they wanted with no real experience and think they know more than the author who spent his life creating it. "See we arent copying Silmarillion, not copying it, cant sue us"
Tolkien created two complete and functional languages (Sindarin and Quenya). Additionally, he created portions of fifteen or so other languages and dialects.
Rings of power is a crime
Thanks for watching it for me. I couldn't do it.
Also Tokien created fully working languages.
Love it
Star Wipe intro to Mordor 😂
It can't get better, story has been written already.
First one here guys! For the very first time!
At that point "young" Galadriel was already over 5000 years old and her daughter Celebrían (future wife of Elrond) was over 3000 years old.
To compare, during the events of The Lord of the Rings Legolas is almost 3000 years old.
In short, this show butchers the characters.
I'm glad they're reacting together to PM again 🥺It's funny cuz she likes everything 😂 Anyway, I love when she does voices and her cheeks 😳😁
It's not a fake language though. It's a real language created for a fictional setting is the way I look at it.
Yeah pretty sure there are examples of what happens to people who get covered in volcanic ash from 79 ad. Little place called Pompeii with a volcano next to it
It was created first though, since he was a linguist and made a language as a hobby. And then he decided to write a fantasy book so he would have somewhere to use it.
I think they meant to say that it was not a naturally-evolved language.
Every language is a made-up language 😂 It becomes a language the moment more than one person uses it to communicate
They weren't trying to adapt Tolkien's story. That claim's pretty misleading, imo.
They just wanted a AmazonGaladriel x Sauron 'romance', all along. Unfortunately, if they'd tried to cram that into Tolkien's original story, even Amazon's noticeably far less perceptive version of Galadriel would have gotten a bit curious about 'Halbrand' still hanging around after a few centuries.
Besides, it would have been awkward trying to get cuddly with her husband and daughter underfoot....
The oath thing isn't so much elves being bad liars as Elrond being a bad friend.
Listen, I freaking love being black, but seeing white character after white character being replaced with a minority is starting to get annoying.
Pandering is annoying
I like these videos 😁
Regarding the "I am good" moment - a bad example of it is clearly in Rings of Power.
A GOOD example of this sort of "vague character decides to be good" moment is in The Iron Giant, surprisingly delivered by Vin Diesel during the whole missile part. "Superman". Just one word, but so powerful in that animated film.
Nice examples 👍. My take on this, is that the whole thing is unnecessary and goes against the lore, considering who and what Gandalf actually is 😅, which is why I found the whole scene a bit more cringe then I anticipated 😂. Yeah... I made a big mistake watching this show 😢
Achara (sorry for any wrong spelling; what that kind of a name is that anyway?) is my 1st/2nd favorite thing about your vids.
"... I like when it _ended_." 🤣
Galadriel vs ice monster: Barely an inconvenience.
All languages are made up but I get where she was going with that. I think the very first joke about how the main character is in no real danger ever is my issue with prequels. There is no sense of danger for the main character if you know they survive already. That’s why Andor, while good as just a character piece, doesn’t ever make me fear for Cassian (plus Cassian is kinda dull compared to everyone else in the show).
The volcano thing really bugged me when I watched that episode.
galadriel : queen of cheetos.
React to his Pitch Meeting on the "300" movie! It's absolutely hilarious!
Achara's adorable, can find the goodness in even the worst of cinema lol
While it's admirable to be able to find value even in literal trash, it also sends dangerous signals. Because if we show these people that we are fine with literally anything, this is the kind of stuff we'll keep getting. Shows written by interns and acted by acting school first terms. Because why would they try if people will like it anyway?
it's too bad they didn't stick with the history in the books, they would have had many more fans yelling for more
I haven’t seen a pitch meeting for Werewolf by night yet. Surprised he didn’t do one
Probably because it's literal perfection
@@ericstorm6582 He’s done pitches for way better stuff
@@mr.stuffdoer8483 like?
@@mr.stuffdoer8483 go back to watching James gunn flop squad
@@number1fool Pitch Meetings
Achara saying the Tolkien names so eloquently made me swoon for her ngl
I can not wait to watch Heisenberg in ROP season 2
Magical tall men are tight!!
Just as Thor said "all words are made up" by extension "All languages are made up"
elven language is made up? you mean just like every other language in existence lmao.
If only Tall Magical Guy had turned out to be Saruman.
For a series called The Rings Of Power, the rings didn't even appear until the last 10 seconds of the final episode.
It's just sad that the new generations don't know, don't care, and don't respect the original writings and ideas.
It worked on me. It all does.
The names in the show is they way they pronounced it cause in the movies i remember all the names and how they actually pronounced it
Orodruin was created by Melkor sadly they cannot bring that up for some reason.
RoP burning is sweet pleasure. 😂
I have watched this reaction video more times than I care to admit. And it occurred to me when the discussion about the made-up language came up. Since all languages are made up of words, all words are made up which in turn became a language.
After the volcano ash, a lot of them should have had pneumonoultramcroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis.
They stood right in the pyroclasmic storm. They shouldn't have anything they should be burned to a crisp.
You cried when he said "i am good..."? 😧
I could watch something I completely hate overall but still enjoy specific moments outside of the overall context, there's no contradiction there. For example, Angela Bassett's performance in Wakanda Forever was amazing.
So funny 😅
it was sauron's plan to run into galadreil and not some convenient 'coincidence'
@GetJaby
No Black Adam pitch meeting reaction?
GALADRRRIIEEEHHLL
Achara..... that name does put people in a bit of a pickle trying to pronounce it, but I relish the chance. 😍
A friend of mine is looking to get published one day and he vowed that if his novels ever took off, he's not letting Hollywood adapt them.
Cart before the horse, champ
A 1 billion dollar show with no connections with viewers
8:48 that’s LITERALLY SUPPOSED TO BE GELADRIELS ENTIRE CHARACTER!!!!!!!!!!
SHE GETS RHE ELVEN RING OF WIND WHICH ALLOWS HER TO LITERALLY HIDE AN ENTIRE ELVEN CITY FROM SAURON FOR SEVERAL MILLENNIA AND SUMMON MAGIC FOGS THAT HIDE THE MOVEMENT OF ENTIRE ARMIES!!!!!!!!
Achara likes everything. 😂 Bless her heart. 😅
I read RoP will be revamped for season 2 because fans of the books and trilogy aren't happy. They're gonna try adapting Tolkien's work more closely or so they say.
They are well into the production of season 2. Only so much can realistically be changed due to cost and time.
That's what happened to ST Discovery. They tried to appeal to people that knew the lore, but that isn't a replacement for competent writing done within respect to the original material. The writers and showrunners still proceeded as they intended to, regardless of any adjustments. So, we got a turd with sprinkles.
I just found the show Okish. A lot of good cgi and great music also but..................... that was it unfortunately.
Its gonna run for million billion years for million billion dollars ....
I enjoyed it more than most not because it's good, but I literally wasn't thinking. Not one thought just mindless watching and finished satisfied.
Do Kong Skull Island Pitch Meeting
Galadriel the barbarian haha
Is this the guy from buzzfeed unsolved
Jaby the budget for this RINGS OF POWER was 1 Billion, how is writing still shitty and where did the money go?
just because something is expensive doesn't mean it's good. Usually that is because the people you gave the money to don't know what they are doing, so they aren't talented enough to make it good, no matter the money. Hey Jaguar car brand is expensive, but they aren't good. They fill up used car lots like litter people get rid of them so fast.
Jaby x Achara ship💖😊
well technically, aren't all languages made up?
That entire show was one big example of what not to do because everything they could get and do wrong was done.
I hope the guys who were in charge of it never ever get work in producing media ever again. I really truly hope they never get put in charge of anything again!
The names are very Welsh sounding.
"it's a made up language"
Um, which language isn't? 🤣
I mean, we know Galadriel doesn't die, so I really prefer they don't piss around trying to pretend she's in any danger.
Uhmm she could atleast show signs of any struggle... Character development.. questioning her beliefs... Changing or facing consequences for horrible choices in an organic way .. things you see in well written shows
There's a difference between "Knowing they survive" and being a Mary Sue to the point that she casually does literally impossible things. We know she doesn't die but then the writers maybe shouldn't make her swim across an entire ocean and stand in a pyroclasmic storm. That's just awful, incompetent writing by a bunch of people who never read Lord of the Rings and obviously don't give a shit.
@@EskChan19 "being a Mary Sue"
It's fucking Galadriel. You may as well call God a Mary Sue.
Casian Andor
Didn't you know, the elves were Spanish hence they roll their 'R's... Galadrrrrrriel. Morrrrrgoth... Arrrrrr matey! 🦜🏴☠️
It’s a made up language.
Thor: “All words are made up.”
Names are important. They have power. They shouldn't be dumbed down just so someone is capable of using their brains and taking the time to learn how to pronounce them.
Mango achara, chilli achara or mixed achara?
Well, actually the Southlands changing to say Mordor was a pretty cool transition. That's the only cool thing I liked about the show. 😅
I watch these to be funny reaction of a pitch meeting. For actual movie reviews I just go to Jeremy channel
Except it shouldn’t have been a choice for Gandalf to be good, he was literally sent to Middle Earth with a mission…
Most of those names are not dificult to say at all, they do the "exotic" ascent on purpose in the series to try to make then sound special, and they just make it worse xD
Give a reaction to mei hoom moosa movie please
Achara, all languages are made up 😂 i love her! Hey, i still liked the show, but every single thing Ryan said s facts
Thanks for being Honest... It's bad. BAD.
Lmao its hysterical how english speaking people have problem with pronouncing Tolkien names. We others dont
God that was so funny, and you guys were entertaining as well! Lord, this series SUCKS! I watched 1-6 over the course of , like, three months, and I just can't be bothered to go back to see the last two. I just don't care what happenes to everyone. Elrond and the Dwarf were the best storyline, and even major parts of THAT irritated TF out of me. God, for a Peter Jackson treatment of extra-trilogy material!
Why is Jaby so backwards? LOL. Everybody hated episode 1. Many people , including myself, were going to give up on the show after the first episode. But from Episode 2 onward. it got better and better each episode. Episodes 6,7,8 many people put on par with House of the Dragon.
I thought the guy who played Adar did a good job. Why recast?
so jaby was supper happy that the show ended, but liked Thor 4 ??, that was a really great movie, people talking to hammers and hammer being jealous of axe.
Elvish is a conlang but EVERY language is made up by definition.
React to Warrior Nun. Its an amazing fantasy show full of badass women, Blood, Superpowers, Action, awesome fight scenes, romance... 100% in rotten tomatoes making it the highest rated tv show in netflix history
Achara is difficult & Arnold Swahzysnszkdldohanzbdksm is so easy to pronounce
Are there any diehard Tolkien react channels that watched it so that I can see how bad I was at watching the show? I never read to books to know he was Sauron, which apparently was the whole point.
Just Some Guy is a hardcore Tolkien fan and he did tear this show to shreds.