Brand and Doyle were walking away from the Ranger. They were looking at the wave that was moving away from them. The next wave was behind them and moving towards the Ranger. Cooper looked out the back of the Ranger and saw it coming.
@@WhatOnEarthh If it's not EXACTLY right - it's damn close. The major problem is that Millar's planet is WAY too close to the Black hole. Have you ever heard of "spaghettification"? That's what happens with SOME black holes (Not all) as you get near the event horizon of no return. And that is due to TIDAL effects. As something approaches a black hole, the far side of an object experiences enough difference in the gravity compared to the near side experiencing MORE gravity that it starts getting pulled apart. Our own planet experiences tides due to the sun and moon - and compared with the black hole that Millar's planet is orbiting our tides are NOTHING. There is also something called "The Roche Limit" (Named after the guy who did the math to work it out) that predicts where the tidal forces will overcome a body due to the gravity gradient effect above and break it apart. That's what happened to create Saturn's rings BTW - most likely a large moon made of mostly ice wandered too close to Saturn and got broken up to form the rings of Saturn. Millar's planet is likely JUST OUTSIDE the Roche limit for the black hole. And the tidal forces on this planet must be ENORMOUS. In addition to causing the giant waves - Millar's planet likely has MASSIVE volcanic activity. But the volcanos themselves have NO chance to build a mountain above the waves cause those waves likely batter them down as soon as they form. But Millar's planet likely has extensive cloud cover (maybe not as extreme as Venus. But LOTS) because of all the STEAM venting out from under the water from the volcanic cracks. Last point - you may note above I said SOME Black holes have giant tidal forces that'll destroy something that gets close even if it doesn't fall in. But THIS Black Hole is - ironically - TOO BIG for that! It turns out that Gargantua is a giant black hole that rivals the Sagittarius A Star Black hole at the center of our Galaxy. It turns out that if a black hole is big enough - the tidal forces comparatively are LESS extreme as you approach. I can't get into it very far here - this post is already too long as it is. But go look it up yourself. The facts are fascinating. And ironically work in Cooper's favor later in the film as he falls into the Black Hole. He is NOT torn apart because Gargantua is too big! But - if Gargatua had been a NORMAL black hole of that size, he would still be dead as he reached the singularity and got crushed down to mathematic nothingness. However - as we see later - Gargantua is merely a door set up by... future humans? Still not clear on that. So I'll go with Cooper's own idea. It makes as much sense as anything else in there.
this is almost right, but not quite so. there are multiple waves formed due to the revolution as well. gotta take that into account to. it is similar to the waves experienced by Earth due to Moon. High tide, low tide.
Would that data have been useful at all? Considering time dilation, the sensor would have at most a few hours of data. Would it have even been worth it?
@@adamrussell9389 it's not mentioned that the whole planet was submerged. Imagine if an alien lands on earth in pacific, is it reasonable to assume the whole earth is just salt water?
Natalie Gold-I'll prewatch the movie so when I talk through the whole reaction I seem clever. You can tell every movie she's watched previously because she talks through it all and "guesses" plot points early. Any movie she hasn't seen she's quiet and surprised.
that was one part that always aggravated me. They said it would take 45 minutes before the engines would drain, but then like a minute and a half later, another waves coming and they take off. no film is perfect. 🙂
I wonder what the planet is like on the poles. I am assuming the waves are like a starfruit, where the planet itself is round but the waves make a bunch of "hills" on the planet. According to a few other comments, the waves aren't actually moving, it's just the planet rotating. That said, I wonder if the poles are relatively flat because the waves should logically get more intense the closer you are to the equator.
I think our nature to just be nosey can really be our detriment. If im honest I've always been weirdly fascinated with tidal waves huge ones i would stop and stare as well. But i believe that stunned essence is frightening and exciting
Fun fact the person their looking for technically landed minutes before them… but yet she’s been missing for years for everyone else on earth. They all miss calculated how much time actually passes on that planet, they thought it was a few days for each minute but in reality it was a whole year for each minute… an they were on the planet fora total of 23 minutes.
This was a really riveting and frightening scene. Both this and the docking after Dr. Mann damages the Endurance are like, grip your seat intense scenes. My heart was pounding out of my chest in both of those.
The way you edit made it looks like they're all watching it together, and I love it. Their reactions on the wave, and their silence on some scenes as well. Ugh.. if only RUclips can allow that you upload a full movie with these peoples reactions on it. Then that would make us feel like we're actually watching it together with them.
I honestly never understood why reaction channels like these didn’t just listen with headphones in and just talked into the camera without trying to sneak clips in at all. Not only does it save an annoyingly fun time of editing but then you can just have the viewer play the movie at the same time and you can quite literally watch it together because I can never pull myself to watch one of these
@TownsendReddish because of copyright issue. But some channels do show their exclusive full reactions on other platforms like patreon. Channels like Cinepals, Natalie Gold and ReactwithJax does those.
Hathaway is so infuriatingly stupid here. First her lack of urgency is cement-headed. Then, inevitably, when she finally is helpless, and recognizes the danger, she wakes up like a damsel in distress, her colleague in danger of getting swept away.
It's funny and interesting to see how people tend to forget a crucial parameter when the fear of the wave coming shows up. They are all about "go faster" or "Doyle had plenty of time" but all I can think of is the sprint he just had to do in a space suit, in the water, and with goddamn 130% Earth gravity weighting on him... He's skeptical even before starting to run and I feel him. His muscles are feeling like they have training weights on each limbs, plus the weight of the rest... After months on this planet he could have made it but just after some space travel and few movements, i think his fate was sealed. Brand would have never been able to stand up without any sort of help.
"What the hell is wrong with her? Get up!" What's wrong with her is the GRAVITY. Not the gravity of the black hole - though they are within the relativistic time dilation effects - no. The gravity of the PLANET. It's 1.3 times the gravity of Earth! 130%. You CAN stand up and walk in that gravity - but it's TOUGH. And it will tire you out. And if you're trying to slog through knee-deep to thigh-deep water at the SAME TIME? Yeah - THAT's what's wrong. They should've turned back at least 40 seconds sooner and abandoned the data log.
@@matt_canon Also - consider that this planet is probably JUST OUTSIDE the "Roche Limit" of gravitational tidal forces that would tear it apart! The same forces that ever so slightly SQUEEZE Earth's core and keep it molten. Keep the magma semi-fluid so that tectonic forces (earthquakes and volcanos) keep refreshing the crust above. This world is probably highly volcanic! But because of the constant giant waves - there's never any chance for volcanos to get above the water before they get pulverized to bits by the waves! Probably half the cloud cover is steam from underwater vents! And maybe the surface beneath the waves that they are walking on is a sort of cooled down volcanic pyroclastic slurry instead of sand. Or - in other words - volcanic ash and debris from the waves pulverizing any potential volcanos or rock that makes it's way up from the magma under the crust. Ever gotten your feet sucked down into mud just at the edge of a stream or lake? Same thing effectively.
I recently watched this movie with my dad three existential crisis's halfway through. Also, he told me that each tick is a day. I was so surprised the time. Dilation is incredible
4000 feet tall to be exact. Kip Thorne gave the number in the source material. As someone who would be easily freaked out by a mere hundred-meter-tall wave (most tsunamis aren't even this tall), this scene has been a recurring nightmare for me for a decade.
It doesn’t take a genius to take one look at the water and ice planet and conclude that it’s completely inhabitable. They should have seen that from the air and never should have landed
Btw all those blaming doyle and brandt to be dumb and not listening to coop, dont understand the point. They were never astronauts. They were scientists. That was their obsession always. Coop was the only skilled person for space work basically. Same goes when they had to dock. Brandt had blacked out but coop didn't because being the experienced one, he had his head in opposite direction to spin.
None of them were prepared for such dangers. None of them had ever been out in deep space. All the training on Earth couldn't properly prepare them for a real threat of death. They were especially unprepared for what Mann would do to them. Brand was too focused on getting the data from Miller's ship. She miscalculated. Doyle froze. He hesitated. He paid the price.
goes to show the length the astronauts has to go through different phases of training just to get out of space. that's why there are ex special ops astronauts.
He could have been tired from the extra weight, they said that the planet was 130% the gravity of Earth. The planet's gravity could also explain why Brand could not lift the debris off her leg.
Its amazing how nature operates in different planets. Some planets are just uninhabitable due to how powerful and dangerous nature is in some planets. Like for example miller's planet would be impossible to build civilization let alone cities, due to the fact that it's all water with natural gigantic waves that can wash away a whole entire town/city
On a positive side it's very guy killed was killed quickly. And if not, due to the nature of that environment it is very unlikely there are any predatory lifeforms underwater. So, in some way he had a happy ending.
Slowly being dragged underwater and thrown around knowing there's nothing you can do about it? Or if you do survive then dying of, Ironically dehydration or starvation? Very happy ending
Problem is gravity in that planet is different from ours so can you imagine that literally a mountain tall tsunami going pass on you just imagine the pressure of that...or even worse it lifts you up to that height and falling down from there dying slowly.
I can't watch this scene without being irked by how lazy the writing is. In order for Doyle to die, he has to stand still *for no reason* and watch Brand trying to get back to the ship, wait till the last second, then move when it's too late.
just found your channel really cool stuff ... also going to need two final interstellar vids one of murph finally figuring it out with help from dad in the 5th dimension and the final cooper seeing murph after decades again and him stealing the ship to go find brand
You should do the Charge of the Rohirrim in LOTR Return of the King, one of the greatest moments in cinema history and guarantee plenty of great reactions. Love the vids!
I had never seen it until about a year and a half ago, was hanging with my boys and they asked me if I’d ever seen it, and it’s one of the best movies I’ve ever watched.
2:38 If one looks very closely, they can see that its not only a wave, but one that coming TOWARDS them. If only they realized that then.
Brand and Doyle were walking away from the Ranger. They were looking at the wave that was moving away from them.
The next wave was behind them and moving towards the Ranger. Cooper looked out the back of the Ranger and saw it coming.
Fun fact.
The black holes pull is so strong that it keeps the giant wave in one spot and the planet is rotating beneath it
So basically the wave isn’t actually moving but the planet rotating makes it seem like it? Bro that is cool asf
No way, I got chills.
Is it even scientifically possible?
@@WhatOnEarthh If it's not EXACTLY right - it's damn close. The major problem is that Millar's planet is WAY too close to the Black hole. Have you ever heard of "spaghettification"? That's what happens with SOME black holes (Not all) as you get near the event horizon of no return. And that is due to TIDAL effects. As something approaches a black hole, the far side of an object experiences enough difference in the gravity compared to the near side experiencing MORE gravity that it starts getting pulled apart. Our own planet experiences tides due to the sun and moon - and compared with the black hole that Millar's planet is orbiting our tides are NOTHING.
There is also something called "The Roche Limit" (Named after the guy who did the math to work it out) that predicts where the tidal forces will overcome a body due to the gravity gradient effect above and break it apart.
That's what happened to create Saturn's rings BTW - most likely a large moon made of mostly ice wandered too close to Saturn and got broken up to form the rings of Saturn.
Millar's planet is likely JUST OUTSIDE the Roche limit for the black hole. And the tidal forces on this planet must be ENORMOUS.
In addition to causing the giant waves - Millar's planet likely has MASSIVE volcanic activity. But the volcanos themselves have NO chance to build a mountain above the waves cause those waves likely batter them down as soon as they form. But Millar's planet likely has extensive cloud cover (maybe not as extreme as Venus. But LOTS) because of all the STEAM venting out from under the water from the volcanic cracks.
Last point - you may note above I said SOME Black holes have giant tidal forces that'll destroy something that gets close even if it doesn't fall in. But THIS Black Hole is - ironically - TOO BIG for that! It turns out that Gargantua is a giant black hole that rivals the Sagittarius A Star Black hole at the center of our Galaxy. It turns out that if a black hole is big enough - the tidal forces comparatively are LESS extreme as you approach. I can't get into it very far here - this post is already too long as it is. But go look it up yourself. The facts are fascinating. And ironically work in Cooper's favor later in the film as he falls into the Black Hole. He is NOT torn apart because Gargantua is too big! But - if Gargatua had been a NORMAL black hole of that size, he would still be dead as he reached the singularity and got crushed down to mathematic nothingness. However - as we see later - Gargantua is merely a door set up by... future humans? Still not clear on that. So I'll go with Cooper's own idea. It makes as much sense as anything else in there.
@@logandarklighter Yo thank you for explaining all of this effortlessly, it makes a lotta sense!
this is almost right, but not quite so. there are multiple waves formed due to the revolution as well. gotta take that into account to. it is similar to the waves experienced by Earth due to Moon. High tide, low tide.
Never understood why getting that data was so important when clearly the planet is uninhabitable.
Because Brandt was a schmo
Because they needed to understand the effects of time dilation and its relation with gravity.
Would that data have been useful at all? Considering time dilation, the sensor would have at most a few hours of data. Would it have even been worth it?
@@adamrussell9389 well thats a very good point.
@@adamrussell9389 it's not mentioned that the whole planet was submerged. Imagine if an alien lands on earth in pacific, is it reasonable to assume the whole earth is just salt water?
One tequila shot for each "OMG"
DO NOT DRIVE!! 🚫
Natalie Gold-I'll prewatch the movie so when I talk through the whole reaction I seem clever.
You can tell every movie she's watched previously because she talks through it all and "guesses" plot points early. Any movie she hasn't seen she's quiet and surprised.
Every tick in the background which is 1.25 seconds is a day passing on earth! That's how relativistic time gets!
It doesn't add up when over 23 years have passed. More like every second a month passes by
They also said they had to wait an hour for the engines to dry. Which would be at least 7 years
that was one part that always aggravated me. They said it would take 45 minutes before the engines would drain, but then like a minute and a half later, another waves coming and they take off. no film is perfect. 🙂
Heard it more than 30 times😂
@@YoureMrLebowski you must have missed the part where they blow the cabin pressure through the engines to flush the engines out.
They are indeed mountains. Just Mountains of Water. Jeez imagine living in that place. Literally Tsunami planet.
I wonder what the planet is like on the poles. I am assuming the waves are like a starfruit, where the planet itself is round but the waves make a bunch of "hills" on the planet. According to a few other comments, the waves aren't actually moving, it's just the planet rotating.
That said, I wonder if the poles are relatively flat because the waves should logically get more intense the closer you are to the equator.
i have never been more afraid of water by seeing sheer size of the wave on miller`s planet
3:54 brilliant, *brilliant* transition edit. 👏🏻👏🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻
I think our nature to just be nosey can really be our detriment. If im honest I've always been weirdly fascinated with tidal waves huge ones i would stop and stare as well. But i believe that stunned essence is frightening and exciting
Fun fact the person their looking for technically landed minutes before them… but yet she’s been missing for years for everyone else on earth. They all miss calculated how much time actually passes on that planet, they thought it was a few days for each minute but in reality it was a whole year for each minute… an they were on the planet fora total of 23 minutes.
This is how NASA shuttle lands. They spiral to shed speed. The attention to details of Interstellar writing, direction and production is outstanding.
I remember how scary it was when I first watched this scene. Something about this wave in this movie got me 😨😱😱
it's a mountain! i felt the same anxiety watching this scene.
how wonderful a movie can make you feel that way, right?
This was a really riveting and frightening scene. Both this and the docking after Dr. Mann damages the Endurance are like, grip your seat intense scenes. My heart was pounding out of my chest in both of those.
The way you edit made it looks like they're all watching it together, and I love it. Their reactions on the wave, and their silence on some scenes as well. Ugh.. if only RUclips can allow that you upload a full movie with these peoples reactions on it. Then that would make us feel like we're actually watching it together with them.
Skill issue tbh
Copyright: Holder of property and fun
goggle box looking
I honestly never understood why reaction channels like these didn’t just listen with headphones in and just talked into the camera without trying to sneak clips in at all. Not only does it save an annoyingly fun time of editing but then you can just have the viewer play the movie at the same time and you can quite literally watch it together because I can never pull myself to watch one of these
@TownsendReddish because of copyright issue. But some channels do show their exclusive full reactions on other platforms like patreon. Channels like Cinepals, Natalie Gold and ReactwithJax does those.
"common, robot, fasteR"
Hathaway is so infuriatingly stupid here. First her lack of urgency is cement-headed. Then, inevitably, when she finally is helpless, and recognizes the danger, she wakes up like a damsel in distress, her colleague in danger of getting swept away.
This was an awesome compilation
I absolutely love your Interstellar videos, and I loved this one the most.
It's funny and interesting to see how people tend to forget a crucial parameter when the fear of the wave coming shows up. They are all about "go faster" or "Doyle had plenty of time" but all I can think of is the sprint he just had to do in a space suit, in the water, and with goddamn 130% Earth gravity weighting on him... He's skeptical even before starting to run and I feel him. His muscles are feeling like they have training weights on each limbs, plus the weight of the rest... After months on this planet he could have made it but just after some space travel and few movements, i think his fate was sealed. Brand would have never been able to stand up without any sort of help.
"What the hell is wrong with her? Get up!"
What's wrong with her is the GRAVITY. Not the gravity of the black hole - though they are within the relativistic time dilation effects - no. The gravity of the PLANET. It's 1.3 times the gravity of Earth! 130%. You CAN stand up and walk in that gravity - but it's TOUGH. And it will tire you out. And if you're trying to slog through knee-deep to thigh-deep water at the SAME TIME?
Yeah - THAT's what's wrong. They should've turned back at least 40 seconds sooner and abandoned the data log.
100% agree, I also imagine the ground below the water was muddy, swampy or like the shifting sand beneathe the waves on a beach.
@@matt_canon Also - consider that this planet is probably JUST OUTSIDE the "Roche Limit" of gravitational tidal forces that would tear it apart! The same forces that ever so slightly SQUEEZE Earth's core and keep it molten. Keep the magma semi-fluid so that tectonic forces (earthquakes and volcanos) keep refreshing the crust above.
This world is probably highly volcanic!
But because of the constant giant waves - there's never any chance for volcanos to get above the water before they get pulverized to bits by the waves! Probably half the cloud cover is steam from underwater vents!
And maybe the surface beneath the waves that they are walking on is a sort of cooled down volcanic pyroclastic slurry instead of sand. Or - in other words - volcanic ash and debris from the waves pulverizing any potential volcanos or rock that makes it's way up from the magma under the crust. Ever gotten your feet sucked down into mud just at the edge of a stream or lake? Same thing effectively.
I remember watching in cinema and everybody was shouting 🤣
Shouting what?
3.48. Hat's off lady ! Very freaking well analyzed !
These girls are easily impressed and boy do they get involved.
Doyle is such an idiot! Why was he just standing there watching the robot go for her instead of heading back himself he wasnt doing anything anyways😢
I recently watched this movie with my dad three existential crisis's halfway through. Also, he told me that each tick is a day. I was so surprised the time. Dilation is incredible
There is NO WAY they could survive that wave...but I love the scene and the movie
I really loved the soundtrack on this scene
the way it's gets louder and louder until they show you the mega wave saying: you are f*cked
Those giant Tsunami looked like they were a few thousand feet tall!! Totally inhabitable since theres tsunamis every hour lol
4000 feet tall to be exact. Kip Thorne gave the number in the source material.
As someone who would be easily freaked out by a mere hundred-meter-tall wave (most tsunamis aren't even this tall), this scene has been a recurring nightmare for me for a decade.
TARS nd CASE, greatest Robot heroes
It doesn’t take a genius to take one look at the water and ice planet and conclude that it’s completely inhabitable.
They should have seen that from the air and never should have landed
It's like the waves from my nightmares!!
amazing cinematic experience.. totally GREAT!
Btw all those blaming doyle and brandt to be dumb and not listening to coop, dont understand the point. They were never astronauts. They were scientists. That was their obsession always. Coop was the only skilled person for space work basically. Same goes when they had to dock. Brandt had blacked out but coop didn't because being the experienced one, he had his head in opposite direction to spin.
None of them were prepared for such dangers. None of them had ever been out in deep space. All the training on Earth couldn't properly prepare them for a real threat of death. They were especially unprepared for what Mann would do to them.
Brand was too focused on getting the data from Miller's ship. She miscalculated.
Doyle froze. He hesitated. He paid the price.
Also, the sheer terror at seeing a couple hundred foot wave would make anyone freeze up
goes to show the length the astronauts has to go through different phases of training just to get out of space. that's why there are ex special ops astronauts.
"TURN Ba- TURN Ba- TURN Ba- "
Still can't figure out what the fuck Doyle was doing just standing there
He may have froze. His fear may have frozen him for a minute.
This was his first trip, too. None of them were prepared for such a disaster.
He could have been tired from the extra weight, they said that the planet was 130% the gravity of Earth. The planet's gravity could also explain why Brand could not lift the debris off her leg.
It never occured to me how easy it is to make a YT channel of yourself reacting to movies you already watched 💀.
Its amazing how nature operates in different planets. Some planets are just uninhabitable due to how powerful and dangerous nature is in some planets. Like for example miller's planet would be impossible to build civilization let alone cities, due to the fact that it's all water with natural gigantic waves that can wash away a whole entire town/city
They couldn't predict giant waves from the gravitational pull of the black hole?
One tick= 1.25 second (1 day on earth)
video...
%1 wave
%99 o my god
:)
Anne Hathaways character was utterly horrible in this movie
Nolan's fault. He cannot write woman character
Doyle reached earlier too...got killed by the plot
LOL 🤣🤣🤣
Ha-ha! 😂
On a positive side it's very guy killed was killed quickly. And if not, due to the nature of that environment it is very unlikely there are any predatory lifeforms underwater. So, in some way he had a happy ending.
Slowly being dragged underwater and thrown around knowing there's nothing you can do about it? Or if you do survive then dying of, Ironically dehydration or starvation? Very happy ending
Problem is gravity in that planet is different from ours so can you imagine that literally a mountain tall tsunami going pass on you just imagine the pressure of that...or even worse it lifts you up to that height and falling down from there dying slowly.
Poor Doyle..
All the women asking the lady in the movie 'what is wrong with you'? Hate ta tell ya ladies, but...
What happened to the docking scene reaction? It was so good.
ah, a keen eye. i'm making an updated version.
@@YoureMrLebowski nice! Watching these are so fun, almost like watching the movie for the first time.
Чёрт!Каждый эпизод этого фильма продуман до мелочей)
You should do a reaction about cooper when he's inside the Black hole.
I feel its one of the most interesting scenes in the movie
Good work
🥺🥺🥺🙏
get to the chopa naoow
FYI, it wasn't a wave, it was a tide.
I can't watch this scene without being irked by how lazy the writing is. In order for Doyle to die, he has to stand still *for no reason* and watch Brand trying to get back to the ship, wait till the last second, then move when it's too late.
You really did a very good video…congrats buddy
just found your channel really cool stuff ... also going to need two final interstellar vids one of murph finally figuring it out with help from dad in the 5th dimension and the final cooper seeing murph after decades again and him stealing the ship to go find brand
agreed
I can't even describe how much i hated anne hathaway's character after this scene, i didn't watch rest of the movie for like 6 months or so lol.
movie magic.... makes my head spin watching this movie. more ways then one
You should do the Charge of the Rohirrim in LOTR Return of the King, one of the greatest moments in cinema history and guarantee plenty of great reactions. Love the vids!
I second this
Yes absolutely agree
Tf are you talking about? One of the greatest moments in cinema history? Out of how many moments? Top 100000?
"My friend you bow to no one" is also a great one
Totally agreeee 🤝🏼
That reaction of that soundgarden blue shirt girl looks like she is over acting 😂😂.see her expression looks too much fake😂
Such NPC reactions xd, or maybe its just me knowing science too well and not being surprised by this stuff. Great movie tho
I'm Afraid of waves since 2004
"People pretend they've never seen Interstellar")))
You wouldn't believe how many people i've met who've never even heard of this film
@@haraldjensen1839 wtf...
@@haraldjensen1839 That's kinda true unfortunately. It didn't make a lot of money at the box office. Wish I could see it in iMax again.
I had never seen it until about a year and a half ago, was hanging with my boys and they asked me if I’d ever seen it, and it’s one of the best movies I’ve ever watched.
Lol. OMG OMG OMG!!
Or The Prestige final scene reaction, great moment also
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
You should do "The Game" - 1997 - , with Michael Douglas, the final reveal
If they say oh my God again, someone is getting punched
😆
Oh my God!
I’d like to see you do the “I Could’ve Done More” scene from Schindler’s List.
Ending reaction plzz .. !! 🙏🏻
Wow, great editing. 👍
Por favor un vídeo de la Carga de los Rohirrim de TLOR, te quedan demasiado increíbles
Interstellar ending reaction mashup!!! 🤯
Black Hole
More man
Holy shit, the Over Reaction is strong with this one. Was Simone up for a week on speed?
she does drink alot of coffee. ☕️