The Gift - Explained | Ryan's Theory

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
  • PLEDGE YOUR SUPPORT ► / ryanhollinger
    SUBSCRIBE ► / himynames. .
    FACEBOOK ► / ryanstheory
    TWEET ME ► / ryanhollinger
    EMAIL ME ► ryanstheorymedia@gmail.com
    CHANNEL ART:
    Jess Campbell
    jesscampbellpo...
    / jessanight
    / jessanighter

Комментарии • 470

  • @TheRisky9
    @TheRisky9 4 года назад +768

    I felt like this movie was the first movie that really understood bullying. One thing that's frustrating as a victim of bullying is how subtle the bullying often is, which allows the bully to continue to get away with it. And it's easy for outsiders to just pass it off as you being too sensitive or exaggerating.

    • @99SuperKiller99
      @99SuperKiller99 3 года назад +10

      Why doesn't this comment have more attention....

    • @theengineer9910
      @theengineer9910 3 года назад +7

      Couldnt be more spot on

    • @LeeLee19901
      @LeeLee19901 3 года назад

      Yes!

    • @anonymousanonymous160
      @anonymousanonymous160 3 года назад

      They always tag on with it too

    • @francislee4967
      @francislee4967 3 года назад +20

      @@LegendInThaMakin if its only playful teasing from one side is not acceptable, you dont know anyone's emotional capabilities unless you know the person well

  • @Akron162
    @Akron162 5 лет назад +317

    I dont think Gordon was playing a character. I think he only planned to take revenge after he saw Simon called him "weirdo" and knew he hadnt change a bit.

    • @toxicsugarart2103
      @toxicsugarart2103 3 года назад +48

      Ooo that’s an interesting take

    • @5wheels178
      @5wheels178 Год назад +6

      Yeah he's not playing a character. That level of weirdness can't be acted.

    • @jonahsd1818
      @jonahsd1818 Год назад +3

      @@5wheels178 lol 😂😂

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      Not true... they never told the sick fuck where they lived at the start of the film way before any of that shit. Yet he stalked them and was showing up... clearly didn't want to move on.

    • @Etpsenior7ohFoe
      @Etpsenior7ohFoe 5 месяцев назад

      Good theory but ion kno lol cause he was acting like he was plannin his attack earlier on when he kept comin in the house with the wife; I was waitin on him to grab her from behind or go missing in the house lol and end up tying her up or somethin lol 🤷🏾‍♂️

  • @sonadowfangirl30869
    @sonadowfangirl30869 7 лет назад +1195

    I think Gordo didn't rape her, simply because Robin did nothing wrong to him. His revenge was towards Simon and that can be done without touching the innocent party. Just planting those feelings of doubt in his mind with a very indicative video is enough.

    • @birdword111
      @birdword111 6 лет назад +103

      I agree! The reason he wanted revenge was because it would be bad enough if Simon told his dad he was gay and he was, but the point was that he wasn't even gay and that fact made it awful in a different way. Similarly, Gordo didn't rape Robyn; he just left enough evidence for people to draw that as a possible conclusion. Ultimately, the parallel is that he wanted Simon to feel upset because the baby wasn't his (and because his wife was harmed, but given Simon's personality I don't think he'd care as much about that), which would be bad enough except the baby was his and now he has been cast out of its life wondering why someone would say something about him that wasn't true. And the answer of course is because they wanted to hurt him and knew the person they would tell would want to be rid of him. Though I'm happy Robyn left Simon; he was disturbing so much so that this movie led to a discussion between my boyfriend and I about what people think the definition of psychopath is vs. what it actually is.

    • @zombiediet
      @zombiediet 5 лет назад +3

      I could have sworn he did rape her, didn’t he make him watch? I can’t remember if he turns the camera off right before you see anything or not.

    • @jgbgw591
      @jgbgw591 5 лет назад +103

      It's still extremely disturbed to drug an innocent woman and simulate what could be a rape. I've been looking for explanations because I might have missed something. Simon is a total piece of crap but it doesn't justify anything Gordon has done. To me, the end twist is only believable if Gordo raped poor Robin. Women don't automatically get pregnant so how could he construct this elaborate plan if he didn't actually assault her? He couldn't have known that she would absolutely get pregnant from that. If he didn't do it, then that makes even less sense. Rape is one of the most evil crimes in existence. This is way more evil than anything Jason Bateman did in high school or even to his work competitor. Whether Gordo faked it or did it, that's so much more wicked than anything Simon could dream of doing. IMO....unless I've missed something major.

    • @stefanrichard4986
      @stefanrichard4986 5 лет назад +49

      A simple DNA test will solve that mystery in a jiffy.
      #youAREthefather

    • @gurpreetbhamra9752
      @gurpreetbhamra9752 4 года назад +23

      Jep, he did it... That's one of the reasons Simon cried at the end
      He saw that the baby hadn't his eyes, but Gordo's.

  • @OwenLikesComics
    @OwenLikesComics 8 лет назад +625

    The Gift is one of the unexpected best films of the last few years, especially considering it was Edgerton's first feature film. The cinematography is flawless, and the film's use of space to create tension was excellent. You've reminded me to go and rewatch this, which I'm going to do haha, great job!

    • @guitarman0365
      @guitarman0365 6 лет назад +1

      joel has been in other movies before this one what are you talking about? or do mean to imply that this movie was made way way before it was released and held in vaults somewhere until studios decided to release it.

    • @santoshsivasankaran1935
      @santoshsivasankaran1935 6 лет назад +7

      guitarman0365 he means it was his directorial debut lol

    • @hosseintm165
      @hosseintm165 3 месяца назад

      Would you rewatch it now?

    • @chrisloydmas8499
      @chrisloydmas8499 3 месяца назад

      @@hosseintm165the films use of space to create tension. Explain exactly wtf you mean by that beside copying it from some other movie review

  • @bobpolo2964
    @bobpolo2964 8 лет назад +393

    One of the reasons the gift was so great is because it was built around principles of the psychological thriller with a dash of horror tropes. There was so much tension built up and the audience anticipated that things would naturally end bloody, but it didn't. This anticipation is because of our familiarity with past films of this genre and the inherent tropes of tension, suspense and murder. What I liked about the gift was that nobody actually died. It was more of a realistic tale.

    • @danielbrown4423
      @danielbrown4423 6 лет назад +13

      Yes it kept me on the edge like seven with that whole box scene at the end

    • @manafon5398
      @manafon5398 4 года назад +22

      But the fish died... :(

    • @nose-bleed
      @nose-bleed 3 года назад +4

      @@manafon5398 welp they're sushi now

  • @SilverDemon456
    @SilverDemon456 6 лет назад +160

    The ultimate "gift" was for Robyn, as he helped her get out of an abusive relationship with a bully. He freed her.

    • @gurpreetbhamra9752
      @gurpreetbhamra9752 4 года назад +6

      And the baby she got.

    • @LegendInThaMakin
      @LegendInThaMakin 3 года назад +9

      But Robyn was in a happy marriage. Simon was never a bully to Robyn

    • @SilverDemon456
      @SilverDemon456 3 года назад +27

      @@LegendInThaMakin He was abusive to her.

    • @LegendInThaMakin
      @LegendInThaMakin 3 года назад +3

      @@SilverDemon456 how so

    • @SilverDemon456
      @SilverDemon456 3 года назад +31

      @@LegendInThaMakin It's been years since I watched the movie, but I think he gaslights her at one point and he psychologically/emotionally abuses her.

  • @jestergnome4717
    @jestergnome4717 7 лет назад +122

    My favorite shot was of Bojangles expression when he came back home. Probably not that important in terms of story but still powerful.

    • @MidTierVillain
      @MidTierVillain 6 лет назад +14

      Illuminalien I agree, I think it speaks to the fact animals sense certain vibes of people.. I don't know, but that shot was brilliantly added; simple but very effective imo.
      What a great movie.

    • @raineyj560
      @raineyj560 6 лет назад +10

      Yes, particularly how Simon walked away with no affection towards BoJangle. The way the doctor didn't give Simon the baby.

    • @janeenharrison1953
      @janeenharrison1953 Год назад +1

      I don't get it, why did Bojangels look so mad?

  • @attrey273
    @attrey273 4 года назад +276

    “You see what happens when you poison other people’s mind with ideas?”

    • @organic.eatsss
      @organic.eatsss 3 года назад +7

      gave me the chills

    • @giafiorari4483
      @giafiorari4483 2 года назад +3

      This was my favorite 👏 it's a perfect lesson learned

    • @Tempe401
      @Tempe401 2 года назад +6

      Straight out of a saw movie lol

    • @sidology1.0
      @sidology1.0 8 месяцев назад

      This aged nicely 👌🏾

  • @JesseDumontt
    @JesseDumontt 5 лет назад +117

    If he asks her for a DNA test, she'll hate him even more because that raises a ton of questions of why he would be asking that... Very suspicious don't you think? He would have to tell her why, and tell her about "the gifts" from Gordon at the end, like the videos, audio records, etc. And she of course, already fed up with him, his lies, and bullying, would hate and resent him even more because he said he apologized and that everything went well with Gordo (when obviously it was the exact opposite of going well, he assaulted him and other things). She would definitely hate him even more than she already does. Clearly she is done with him at the end, but if she found out about that, she would hate him even more and would realize Gordo clearly has SERIOUS problems and just how screwed up Gordo has become all because of Simon. Remember, she also knows about the Danny thing, like Simon telling lies and ruining Danny's life just so he could take his job. He's an asshole. I don't think he's getting that DNA test. So he's left wondering if that is really his baby or not (the eye colour doesn't matter, Robyn has brown as well, so if the baby has brown, doesn't mean it's Gordo's for sure, which still leaves him wondering). I mean, to us, we of course are 91.3% certain he wouldn't rape Robyn, as most of us agree he actually liked Robyn, he just wanted revenge on Simon. He actually gave off creepy vibes from from the start, which was intended lol, but he actually did have good intentions. He genuinely did. It was only once he saw the thing on Simon's fridge of him calling Gordo a weirdo (so he still sees Simon, rightfully so, as a bully and the same old person) and the recordings, that he became pissed. That letter did say he was gonna let bygones be bygones and that he truly only had good intentions (the letter after the scene where he invited Simon and Robyn over to that mansion he claimed was his wife's, but clearly wasn't). He did pretty much what Simon did to him which is crazy. Think about it. It was about rape (something he didn't actually do, just like how Gordo wasn't actually molested, it was a lie, wow right, clever), and Simon feeling how Gordo feels, isolated and with nothing left, life down the drain. As someone said, Gordo's ultimate gift was getting Robyn away from her lying, abusive (physically, but not to her, and mentally, to her and others), piece of shit husband. Super clever movie, Jesus.

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      Tell her... the dipshit literally filmed himself coming crimes bahaha and gave them the film... no really up for debate.. plus he was already stalking them right from the start before anything had happened. They never told him where they lived

    • @toniahnicole2370
      @toniahnicole2370 4 месяца назад +1

      You broke this down very good

    • @seanjohn2870
      @seanjohn2870 8 дней назад

      He doesn't have to ask her for a DNA test. All he has to do is have the babies DNA checked against his, and she wouldn't even know he had run the test. People do it all the time.

  • @MidTierVillain
    @MidTierVillain 6 лет назад +490

    The ending; Simon has to live with it- he can't ask for a DNA test, because that would push her over the edge with his lies, bullying, and deception.. Simon can't tell her what happened either due to her mental health was always hinted at being on the edge- hence the pills, the past about Simon searching the house for her pills hinting at her having issues with addiction and stressed out. Plus, she lost a child before and causing a strain on their relationship before. Plus, Simon destroyed the other guys life within the new job to get the position.. he wove a web of lies that he got tangled up in. The ending was perfect, because now his life has ended up sorta the same as Gordo, or rather feeling the same pain, suffering, and outcasted.
    Now the question is, would Simon forgive Gordo after all that? Especially how he treated Gordo even after everything was said an done; when he went to Gordo with that hideous apology; then assaulting him further.. Gordo didn't rape her, nor does she know anything of what he's done to Simon- but! She does know Simon furthered lied to her; so now she fully has separated from him at the end.
    Simons whole life has went down the drain, and Gordo has gotten the revenge he seeked.
    This was like Seven in some ways- a great movie never the less too. Bravo! What an unexpected find that I've skipped over many of times. All around great movie!

    • @kathleencaruanasmith8143
      @kathleencaruanasmith8143 6 лет назад +17

      Above Beyond i agree with this annalysis.
      The only part i'm not too sure of is the part about simon not being able to take a d.n.a test coz it would push robyn over the edge with his lies.
      Robyn has already hinted that she's going to leave simon so its not like this would break up the marriage coz she's already basically said she's leaving him.
      Also simon has only just found out about that video so its not like he lied about it. Its not like he knew what gordo had done and not told robyn.

    • @danielbrown4423
      @danielbrown4423 6 лет назад +3

      It reminded me of nocturnal creatures

    • @leatcanned
      @leatcanned 5 лет назад +3

      or he shows Gordo up by being a better man then he was and raising a better mini-Gordo, even going as far as to encourage Gordo to know him, but letting him know he will never be the kids father, thus Simon is still Simon, doing wrong even when he does right. A true twisted person but not one who is easily trapped.

    • @Apudurangdinya
      @Apudurangdinya 5 лет назад +2

      The gift 2 : christmas special

    • @banquetoftheleviathan1404
      @banquetoftheleviathan1404 4 года назад +4

      That's not a good enough reason to not get a test, your money and future are on the line here. I almost got roped in to such mess and you better damn bet i made her take a test

  • @nedmarshall1068
    @nedmarshall1068 8 лет назад +192

    This channel deserves substantially more subscribers

  • @kaitdean7188
    @kaitdean7188 4 года назад +78

    I feel like this movie resonates with anyone who was bullied and the cycle of abuse it creates.

  • @JohnSmith-pl4sf
    @JohnSmith-pl4sf 3 года назад +20

    This movie taught me that the effects of bullying from childhood can last into adulthood... Bullying has long term effects...

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      Yea being picked on total justifies raping someone not involved

  • @adiahaalexander9359
    @adiahaalexander9359 8 лет назад +71

    SPOILERS!!! Although if you watched the review it's already been spoiled for you. I don't think he actually raped the wife. I think that was just another way he wanted to f*%k with the main characters mind. He seemed to want to punish those who deserve it and she didn't do anything to deserve that. If you pay attention to what the chiropractor says to the wife when she goes to him for answers about what happened, he says "I've made peace with the past AND Gordo" which to me suggests he actually apologized to Gordo for his role in the rumors and since Gordo wasn't trying to destroy his life it seems like he forgave him for it. I think the scriptures Gordo left also prove that.

    • @MsBlu-fs1hn
      @MsBlu-fs1hn 8 лет назад +7

      THANK YOU people are just so close-minded

    • @b.a.lawlor1540
      @b.a.lawlor1540 7 лет назад +19

      IMO He didn't rape Robyn because he had nothing against her personally, it was all about revenge toward Simon, and obviously liked her for being kind to him! Think he knew she was always on his side and would never hurt her! This film was a mind game with total revenge toward someone who fu## up his life!! Good for you Gordo! Awesome film, 9 stars

    • @virgiliacoriolanus5093
      @virgiliacoriolanus5093 7 лет назад +23

      One thing I noticed--is that Simon is the one who tried to act all buddy buddy with Gordo when they first met again in the store. He's the one who invited him over and acted like they were besties in HS, not Gordo. You can argue that if Simon hadn't acted like he hadn't ruined Gordo's life, then Gordo wouldn't have gone after him. Maybe. But I just found that so fake and typical.

  • @krijones
    @krijones 7 лет назад +220

    All really astute! But one thing that doesn't ring true to me is the idea that Robin is left with the assurance that the baby is Gordo's. Are we to believe that Gordo confessed to Robin in the hospital--telling her that he broke in, drugged her, and defiled her--and that she still prefers him to her husband? I never heard that being implied and assumed that only Simon knew about the video, at least where we left off.

    • @kathleencaruanasmith8143
      @kathleencaruanasmith8143 6 лет назад +56

      Kristen Jones me too i dont understand that at all !
      There was absolutely no hint of this whatsoever. Robyn didnt even have any kind of reaction !!
      If gordo confessed to robyn then i have to say she takes shocking news better than anyone i'v ever seen or maybe she's still on those pills lol

    • @heetseeker8017
      @heetseeker8017 4 года назад +27

      Thanks for confirming I didn’t miss anything. When the guy said that in the video I was like what??? I’m with u guys I think he mis-read the ending. She wouldn’t have been okay with that.

    • @sonalidas000
      @sonalidas000 4 года назад +11

      He didn't impregnate her by the way. It's revealed in the alternate ending. He made the video that away to leave Simon assuming and suffering all his life.

    • @daddysgon9705
      @daddysgon9705 3 года назад +3

      In the conversation between gordo and Simone, gordo said “now are you gonna tell her it should I?”, which I’m guessing implies that gordo didn’t tell her anything, but then looking back to when he said look into the eyes, he after looked into robyns and maybe that said something

    • @mikebills3120
      @mikebills3120 3 года назад

      @Aishwarya Janakiraman right? thats what I dont understand lol just get a DNA test

  • @thefearofg0ds758
    @thefearofg0ds758 2 года назад +8

    This movie is a long series of uncomfortable situations. For an introvert or someone who suffers with social anxiety it's practically a horror movie

    • @fuzzytop4746
      @fuzzytop4746 2 года назад +1

      It’s a thriller so it’s basically the same thing to your brain just not the actual killing. I think the easiest difference is horror=predictable and thriller=unpredictable

  • @DagnieJ
    @DagnieJ 6 лет назад +23

    The Gift 100% left me feeling sick.

  • @caustic9947
    @caustic9947 5 лет назад +6

    When I first watched this movie and got to the video scene, I had to pause the video because I was honestly shaking. I have no idea what it was about that part- the silence, the mask, idk- that unsettled me so much, but I had to stop the movie to breathe.

  • @jenniferhalf1650
    @jenniferhalf1650 6 лет назад +42

    God thank you. I was having a hard time finding a good explanation of this movie and I finally found it!

  • @codyhastings5717
    @codyhastings5717 8 лет назад +68

    You're the most articulate person I follow on RUclips.
    You deserve fame. I'll promote you where and when I can.

    • @jacksoutofthebox
      @jacksoutofthebox 4 года назад

      joker Darker woah there, looks like we found another Gordo...

  • @briannalee1998
    @briannalee1998 7 лет назад +127

    Just saw the Gift. This movie scared me more than any horror movie I saw lol. At the beginning I thought Simon or the wife would end up being a bad guy, but instead I ended up loving and rooting for Robyn to get away from her controlling emotionally abusive husband. Simon was horrible and at the end it seemed like he was getting what he deserved. I hope Gordon didn't actually rape Robyn because if so, then Gordon is more evil than any of them and Robin was punished worse than Gordon which she doesn't deserve at all. I'm just glad she's leaving him, but that better not be Gordon's baby. I agree that if he did rape her it is out of character because it seemed like he didn't want to hurt her and only wanted to hurt Simon, but I don't think Robin thinks the baby is Gordon's because no sane women would be okay with that if he actually raped her and gave her the baby. She knows it's Simon's, but wants nothing to do with him.

    • @MidTierVillain
      @MidTierVillain 6 лет назад +16

      Brianna Brickey I agree, Gordo didn't rape her- he actually cared for her; hence when Simon showed up to "apologize" to him, Simon said his wife suggested: in turn Gordo said something about it hinting at the fact Robyn truly was the one that cared for him throughout and wanted to make peace. He didn't want to hurt her, just expose Simon for the true piece of shit he was and still is.. what an excellent film!
      Remember what Simon said about some ppl from High School never changing? I think that small piece of dialogue said it all.. Simon never changed, he was still the same bully damaging others lives because he could to further his own success- hence to what he did to Donald.
      What a great movie that was!!!! I just love every bit of it, and to think I looked past it so many times.. shame on me! Loved it!

    • @DreDayX
      @DreDayX 4 года назад +10

      Nah I actually hate him he shouldn’t have been touching his wife idgaf if he didn’t or not he is a fucking creep and bitch that’s why I bully weirdos like that

    • @gungnir5031
      @gungnir5031 4 года назад

      @@DreDayX exectly lol.
      Except for the bullying part. Maybe just leave them alone lol

    • @xposebandwagons7777
      @xposebandwagons7777 3 года назад +1

      @@DreDayX very proud of yourself huh you’re a real loser you reap what you sow

    • @kujo4388
      @kujo4388 3 года назад +2

      Ma’am did you watch the movie? He broke in, drugged her and molested her...

  • @swivelmaster
    @swivelmaster 7 лет назад +77

    IMO the actual gift was not for Simon. It was for Robyn.

  • @tajw5241
    @tajw5241 8 лет назад +6

    Subtle, desolate, and disturbing the gift is one of the best thrillers I've seen in years Great vid Ryan

  • @thejon93rd
    @thejon93rd 8 лет назад +18

    This is a truly outstanding film. The entire cast are all-around excellent throughout, the cinematography is telling and the writing is nothing short of brilliant. Speaking of brilliant though, your videos never fail to impress, Ryan, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on a film like Take Shelter. Easily one of the finest films I've ever experienced with two of the best performances I've ever seen (by Michael Shannon and Jessica Chastain respectively) at it's core.

  • @skittleswhs
    @skittleswhs 8 лет назад +35

    Why cant more films be like this?

  • @Fimbleshanks
    @Fimbleshanks 6 лет назад +4

    This channel has fast become my favorite for film analysis videos. The range of films you talk about is broader than most of the other channels I've seen, and includes many of my favorite films, such as this one. The Gift is a movie I continually get fired up about, no matter how many times I see it. That said, I seem to have forgotten the part where Robin thinks it's Gordo's child. For some reason, despite how huge a revelation that is for her, I just don't recall it happening. I guess I'll have to go watch it again!

  • @thatgirlreacts5465
    @thatgirlreacts5465 3 года назад +9

    So you’re saying Gordon told her he raped her and she thinks that’s okay because at least her child isn’t the son of a bully? That’s ridiculous.

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      Right why the fuck are these dumb fucks showing sympathy for a fucking rapist bahahaha like are people fucking stupid af. And people are mad that Simon attacked gordo... like if some stalked my family and threatened my wife's life I would do alot worst

  • @viagotanega9898
    @viagotanega9898 4 года назад +2

    Just saw this insane movie and found this incredible channel. WOW, the tension building towards the end was maddening and the way it climaxed left my mouth wide open. Joel Edgerton is a powerhouse of talent.

  • @daddysgon9705
    @daddysgon9705 3 года назад +4

    When he said “people deserve good things” it gave me a thought, which I’ll get into in a second.
    See, people are saying gordo is a good person and wouldn’t touch robin, however that line got into my head. Robin was so sad because of the miscarriage and not being a mother, and since robin is clearly a good person, what if Gordo wanted to give her a “gift”, and the way he said congratulations just made me think he is the father, and that the fact that simon fell to the floor in the last scene makes me believe that theory, but also he probably still kept the truth, like Simon did.
    10/10 great movie 🙌🙌

  • @katehaynes5735
    @katehaynes5735 3 года назад +6

    This movie is dark and suspenseful, which I love in general, but what really speaks to me is FINALLY getting back at your bully! I had a classmate who teased my from mid 8th grade through high school graduation ABOUT MY BRAIN CANCER and the hat I briefly wore to conceal my 1/2 bald head slowly regrowing my hair. (You can't have brain surgery with a full head of hair.) It's not like he didn't know I was out of school for cancer treatment.... I was so excited for both 10th and 20th reunions because I was finally strong enough to let him have it, but of course he was not there... The Gift is the best I can do! If anyone sees Jimmy Scribner, do me a favor and let him have it.

    • @jinaedinisci159
      @jinaedinisci159 7 месяцев назад +1

      Glad you're still here. Bless you & may you continue to have good health 🙏🏿

    • @katehaynes5735
      @katehaynes5735 7 месяцев назад

      @@jinaedinisci159 Thank you!

    • @S.T.A.L.K.E.R.420
      @S.T.A.L.K.E.R.420 26 дней назад

      The male bullying a female? Wow what a weak man…

  • @plissken94th57
    @plissken94th57 Год назад +8

    The end was left ambiguous for a reason, Gordon wanted to destroy Simons life with a lie the same way he destroyed his, but before he tried it, he wanted to see if simon can admit to his wrongdoings and could have actually changed. But he never did, which is why he did what he did.

  • @marcelc2820
    @marcelc2820 6 лет назад +2

    Your enunciation always keeps me on the edge of my seat.

  • @SamaritanPrime
    @SamaritanPrime 8 лет назад +10

    Geez... no wonder Uncle Owen was so bent on keeping Luke on the farm.
    Seriously, Young Owen Lars was portrayed by Joel Edgerton in Star Wars, Episodes 2 and 3.

  • @jakeboos9860
    @jakeboos9860 8 лет назад +8

    Great video. This was one of my favorite films of last year and thought for a directorial debut from Joel Edgerton it was amazing.

  • @beccf.s.8012
    @beccf.s.8012 2 года назад +1

    I just watched this movie for the 1st time about a month ago. I rewatched it today. I am amazed by Joel’s (Gordo) talent. He wrote and directed this movie. I loved how Jason’s character keeps developing in front of our eyes and you discover who the true villain is. Although two wrongs don’t make a right, it’s easy to say Gordo went too far. Not everyone has the capacity to forgive and leave behind without a true apology and reparations. Especially when you see the person who destroyed you still not caring and recognizing how wrong they did you while they don’t seem to be getting hit by karma. Simon had many opportunities to make amends but, as a true abusive person, he wanted to take no responsibility for how he affected Gordo’s future and didn’t want to be bothered by make things right the best he could at the present moment.

  • @ComboSmooth
    @ComboSmooth 5 лет назад +10

    threw me off with the last things you said... robin never thought that it couldve been Gordo child from what i remember

    • @rockinman
      @rockinman 3 года назад +4

      yeah.... the last things he says in this video are 100% wrong... as if she would prefer to raped while unconscious and have gordo's baby than simons baby? get real. I keep re-listening to Ryan saying that hoping I heard it wrong.

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      @@rockinman right bahaha why r people acting like a rumor and rape are equal. Dumb fucks

  • @reelgirl8544
    @reelgirl8544 6 лет назад +28

    An extremely insightful and viable theory, Ryan. I found myself nodding in agreement on nearly every point you made. That said, I think Gordo's ultimate gift was to free Robyn from her twisted husband. Now, I have a question that has been nagging me that perhaps you might be able to answer: was the information in the dossier on Gordon that Simon had under lock and key, along with the one on Simon's rival colleague, Danny, also fabricated? Because there was some pretty alarming information in there that, if it were true, would make the possibility of Gordon raping Robyn not so out of character. Contrary to what other reviewers have said, I think Gordon was highly intelligent and would know exactly how to cover his tracks. (I think he might even have tipped off Danny regarding Simon's involvement in getting Danny sacked.) Even if Gordon had impregnated Robyn, it might be tricky to prove it wasn't a consensual act.
    I absolutely loved The Gift. Psychological Thrillers are my favourite genre of movies and this is right up there with the best. Many thanks from a new subbie.☺😉

    • @ayaanaz4m
      @ayaanaz4m 2 года назад +1

      I read through all of what you commented, and I just have this one tiny question.. Why would it be tricky to prove it wasn't concensual?

  • @datboi0074
    @datboi0074 8 лет назад +2

    OH MY GOSH, I was just watching this movie yesterday, and was thinking, "why hasn't Ryan made a video about this"?!?!?!

  • @jguo52
    @jguo52 7 лет назад +1

    I loved this film. Was such a pleasant surprise from the first time director. I still had an image of him as the mindless jock from Gatsby when I watched the film and was so impressed

  • @philippacarew1129
    @philippacarew1129 5 лет назад +2

    You talk the way I want my film studies essays to sound

  • @romefortunato9240
    @romefortunato9240 5 лет назад +9

    3:29 isn’t that Roy from the office

  • @leightonmilton5162
    @leightonmilton5162 3 года назад +4

    The Gift is a film you need to watch with someone else as it leaves you asking questions. Hence why I’ve ended here. I understood the impact of bullying and the web of lies that Simon tangled himself in. The thing that bothered me the most was his fear/hatred of monkeys. Seemed to be a common thread throughout the film, yet never really explained why. Gordo must of known about it as he wears a monkey mask in the tape 🤷🏻‍♂️ I’m probably overthinking this, it’s just bugging me 😅 I’m pretty sure he could of just shown her the final gifts (the voice recordings and video) and say Gordo was stalking you... but then I doubt she would listen because of all the lies Simon has told. Ugh, this film boils my brain 😄

    • @TheHopperUK
      @TheHopperUK 11 месяцев назад +1

      Robyn tells Gordo about Simon's phobia of monkeys when she's first showing him around the house. Thematically I think it's that monkeys and apes are symbolic of primal, brutal instincts and Simon is trying to weave an identity for himself that is sophisticated and mature and doesn't resort to brute violence. He's not succeeding but he's trying.

  • @ShaneMM0
    @ShaneMM0 4 месяца назад

    Gordos character is 100% a sociopath. His internalized pain and anger based off his idea of unfairness is connected to a sense of his delusional entitlement, which is why he refuses to let things go. All the signs of a sociopath. Including him being a loner and not having his life together. Is a psychopath vs a sociopath

  • @Scorch428
    @Scorch428 4 года назад +8

    I thought the ending was undermined by the fact that Simon could just get a paternity test...it wasnt like he was never gonna know if its his or not..

    • @Scorch428
      @Scorch428 4 года назад

      They shoulda set the movie in the 80s or something, whenever they didnt have paternity tests

    • @c.kirchhoefer
      @c.kirchhoefer 4 года назад

      Just the thought of robyn getting raped or touched was enough to ruin Simon

    • @pickettpride6980
      @pickettpride6980 4 года назад

      True, he could basically do the mail away cheek swab dna test on himself & the baby. Robyn would never know.

  • @lungafilmz3214
    @lungafilmz3214 8 лет назад +7

    Amazing interpretation of the film

  • @jefaspirit
    @jefaspirit 4 месяца назад

    I loved that Robyn made the decision to no go home with Simon! Good for her! Unfortunately, now she has to deal with Simon (or Gordo) for the rest of her life because of the baby. Poor baby. He was born in such toxic circumstances. I hope the mom is relentless enough to keep those two brutes away from her and the baby, but the courts might force her to share custody with the dad. Poor Robyn and baby. She better be super wealthy to battle them in court.

  • @Ericmann99
    @Ericmann99 6 лет назад +8

    To be honest I'm a bit surprised. I watched this film the other night and enjoyed it but didn't think it was anything especially... special. A solid thriller for sure, a great example of the genre 100%, but not anything really exceptional or transcendent. But the thing that really got me was the discussion about whether or not Gordo actually raped Robyn (the wife). The film purposely leaves it ambiguous. in the end there's as many hints that say he did it as say he didn't. So really as a viewer it is impossible to say either way... AND THAT'S THE POINT! To say "I don't think he raped her" for whatever reason is to miss the point. The film itself doesn't hint either way, if anything there may be evidence that he did rape her, but that is not the point. The point is that there is no clear answer, the fact that there's a hanging thread is the point. The truth is that there is beauty in the unanswered question, and like most things it seems that most people miss that beauty.

  • @TheHopperUK
    @TheHopperUK 11 месяцев назад

    Saw this movie just recently. I like how the movie takes Jason Bateman's natural charm and likeability and nudges it just a little too far, when it becomes glibness and manipulation. Clever.

  • @ericshiel
    @ericshiel 5 месяцев назад

    In my opinion, this is Jason Bateman’s best film performance, outside of his spot on Ozark. It didn’t feel like Jason Bateman, it felt like an entirely different person, such a joy to watch

  • @reidmich182
    @reidmich182 5 лет назад +2

    Great video. However, definitely don't agree that Robin thinks the baby is Gordo's . I don't know if I missed something, but that seems totally wrong .

  • @jameshall5911
    @jameshall5911 8 лет назад +2

    Wow, I think I completely misunderstood the film when I saw it last year, looks like I'll have to revisit it...

  • @jerseyjay607
    @jerseyjay607 4 месяца назад

    Gordo in no way grapes Simon's wife. His plan was completed with the illusion that due to Simon's behavior and lack of humanity it could have happened. Simon down and broken on the floor at the end, head in had, shows that Gordo got his revenge in teaching Simon this lesson.

  • @pat8593
    @pat8593 4 года назад +10

    get a dna test. the end.

  • @JamesGang76
    @JamesGang76 5 лет назад +4

    in the vid at the end u made it seem like Robin knew it could have been Gordo's but how would she know?

    • @rockinman
      @rockinman 3 года назад +3

      yeah thats just wrong... as if she would be okay with that? no wayy

  • @avip671
    @avip671 8 лет назад

    Ryan ive been a subscriber since the very beginning and this is your best written video yet

  • @RosieSquall
    @RosieSquall 8 лет назад +6

    I loved your interpretation, it's well constructed, well presented and very interesting. Now I have to watch the movie.

  • @pdogg7484
    @pdogg7484 2 года назад +1

    @rayanhollinger to say “Gordo is not a sociopath” your special. if anyone thinks poor Gordo, he was bullied, then your special too. Simon is an asshole but doesn’t merit any of gordon’s actions. the past was done. this movie normalizes Sociopathological revenge in the name of victimhood. victims of bullies should grow stronger and let go if necessary but seeking revenge in this form makes you no better, i’d say worse. i pray for the young generation, your minds are being molded by some real toxic ish and labeling it something else.

  • @jerseyforhawks
    @jerseyforhawks Год назад +1

    I want to believe Gordo did not, but what an uncertain feeling.

  • @Roger-il8iw
    @Roger-il8iw 3 месяца назад

    I just saw this movie on Netflix. Absolutely blown away. Well written. Very subversive. Keeps you guessing. Changes the bad guy. And the wife is smoking hot. Great film.

  • @shadowman2192
    @shadowman2192 4 года назад +2

    I’m afraid my interpretation of The Gift
    is far less profound.
    But I took this movie as sort of a cautionary tale for bullies.
    Bullies often don’t remember their victims. But the victims never forget the bullies.
    And you never know if one day.
    Maybe even years later.
    The former victim might decide its time for a little payback.
    Moral of the story being.
    If your gonna live your life mistreating people.
    Sooner or later you might just cross the wrong person.
    I had a lot of bully trouble in high school.
    But their was one who was the worst, meanest bully of all.
    And I know where he lives.

    • @Yellowjackets1900
      @Yellowjackets1900 3 года назад

      should we be worried?

    • @rockinman
      @rockinman 3 года назад +4

      @@Yellowjackets1900 yes, definitely be worried. Draven sounds like a real tough guy

    • @Yellowjackets1900
      @Yellowjackets1900 3 года назад +2

      @@rockinman lol

  • @poppyfield1619
    @poppyfield1619 4 года назад +1

    I just want to know what happened to Bojangles? ? he was only in a few bits of the film?? Nobody spoke about him after he came home and we didn't see him again lol

  • @the_kindly_dolt6030
    @the_kindly_dolt6030 8 лет назад +1

    Another fantastic video! Looking forward to what you do next!

  • @gsingh7646
    @gsingh7646 3 года назад +2

    Just watched this and it was amazing. Does anyone know any other similar psychological films?

  • @J____L
    @J____L 8 лет назад +2

    Great video as always! Keep up the stellar work!!

  • @TimMosleycar3hur
    @TimMosleycar3hur 2 месяца назад

    DNA test, and if the test said it wasn't Simon? Then I think Gordo gets charged with a SLEW of offenses.

  • @bakshaya5309
    @bakshaya5309 4 года назад +3

    So does gordo tell robin that it is his child ? I’m confused

  • @tomdrake3787
    @tomdrake3787 7 лет назад +2

    Very well done, loved your breakdown of the film

  • @eveheart2876
    @eveheart2876 3 года назад +1

    Woah 🤨😧🤭I need to watch this again at a slow pace.

  • @stevenbrown1225
    @stevenbrown1225 5 лет назад

    It almost sounds like a modern take of Carnel Knowledge. That film scarred me for life.

  • @baritony8763
    @baritony8763 4 года назад +1

    I enjoyed it awhile back.But I forget--- what was the implied or actual gift?

  • @KirbyStyle2
    @KirbyStyle2 8 лет назад +2

    Please do "The Thing". I just discovered your channel and like it!

  • @spotthespy
    @spotthespy 5 лет назад +19

    My thoughts: Robin is hot.

  • @rizwanx7482
    @rizwanx7482 4 года назад +1

    I got pissed seeing this movie..cause I kept saying install better security..get a fence..get cameras..stay at a hotel for a bit..smh

  • @IsaiahMang
    @IsaiahMang 5 лет назад +4

    Its disturbing to see a lot of the comments here sticking up for Gordon for breaking into a home, drugging an innocent women and raping her.

  • @ryansean4969
    @ryansean4969 4 года назад +2

    I'm gonna just power through this

  • @tbastdgagitw
    @tbastdgagitw Год назад

    I like the idea that bullies will see this and it will bug those who can still feel guilt

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад +2

      I'm more bothered by people have sympathy for a rapist baahahha

  • @oscarkrueger3534
    @oscarkrueger3534 6 лет назад +2

    My cousin was in this movie. Only for about ten seconds, but still

  • @grantmyles8819
    @grantmyles8819 8 лет назад +2

    Great video. Just watched this last week on Netflix and it was so much more clever than I thought it would be. Cant wait for the next one!

    • @RyanHollinger
      @RyanHollinger  8 лет назад +10

      Here's a fun clever fact - at one point early in the film, Gordo picks up a monkey toy and Robyn tells him that Simon is scared of monkeys. Then when Simon play's Gordo's tape at the end, Gordo is wearing a monkey mask.

    • @167thSpartan
      @167thSpartan 8 лет назад +1

      I chuckled when the card Simon opened had monkeys on it. The monkey mask was a lot less subtle with the fuck you.

  • @schrodingerscat8621
    @schrodingerscat8621 2 года назад +1

    As I’m watching this movie, I’m watching Simon and his wife speaking with the police on probable cause. Simon works for a security company, he wouldn’t start by installing a state of the art security system in his new California home? How do I get past that?

    • @fuzzytop4746
      @fuzzytop4746 2 года назад +1

      That was one the first things that any reasonable human being would of done in this movie that would of changed everything

  • @user-vb1bq1hq5l
    @user-vb1bq1hq5l 5 месяцев назад

    2:44 thing is Gordon did not do anything. The couples natures were exposed within each other and its Simon that was hiding his inner & true self. So I wouldn’t say Gordon turned em against each other

  • @pepsidragon1
    @pepsidragon1 6 лет назад

    man you give me an all new way of thinking about these films. subscribed! :)

  • @FilmFan-iv7sz
    @FilmFan-iv7sz 2 года назад

    I saw this film today it was really good especially how by the end gordan put Simon In the same situation he did and even then Simon wouldn't admit anything

  • @pottingsoil
    @pottingsoil 5 лет назад +1

    I completely forgot about this movie.

  • @ArthurHammerr
    @ArthurHammerr 2 года назад

    I saw this movie drunk, and 6 years later I watched it sober. It's better when you're sober.

  • @rithiktonk1900
    @rithiktonk1900 4 года назад

    I randomly got this Movie on Prime.. and I loved it

  • @Pinko_Band
    @Pinko_Band 6 лет назад +4

    This is an irrelevant question to the content of the video, but is your accent considered Northern or Southern Irish? I've met others with your same accent but I cannot remember which region of the country they were from...

    • @JimElford
      @JimElford 6 лет назад

      John Thompson Northern Irish

  • @RobertoDiego737
    @RobertoDiego737 3 года назад +1

    Can someone please explain to me the part on the house that Gordo got, when he invited Simon and his wife over for dinner? Did Gordo break into that house while the people were away? I just always wondered about that part.

    • @xeneeleven
      @xeneeleven 3 года назад +4

      They explained that he had access to the garage where he rented a Cadillac or something along those lines

    • @Suzuha_Amane
      @Suzuha_Amane 2 года назад

      it was the house of his ex-wife who left him

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      @@xeneeleven holy fuck some of u are dumb as fuck

    • @PieroMinayaRojas
      @PieroMinayaRojas Год назад +1

      Pay attention to the movie lol

  • @annerison
    @annerison 3 года назад +3

    This film really blurrs the line between good and evil, and it is excellent. Robyn is the protagonist, since we see most of the movie's events through her eyes. Simon and Gordo are the villians. The use of Bible verses in the film, drive home the fact that she was an innocent in all this, but it doesn't matter because both good and evil exist in the world and that is the reality.

  • @CalebTheSchmuck
    @CalebTheSchmuck 4 года назад +2

    This movie knows that dna tests exist, right?

    • @kujo4388
      @kujo4388 3 года назад +2

      And the police

  • @30atwill91
    @30atwill91 8 месяцев назад

    I thought his wife was being ridiculous for switching up on him just because he was a bully in high school, kids bully and get bullied, it’s just part of life and being young and dumb, and obviously he grew out of it and seemed like a good dude who really loved his wife, but when he made up those lies about his co-worker to take his job and get him fired is when I realized his heart is truly corrupted and he’s a foul person, and that’s when I agreed with his wife not wanting to be with him no more.

  • @canofwd4022
    @canofwd4022 5 лет назад +2

    This was a short story I read in English class

    • @fresh2393
      @fresh2393 4 года назад

      What was the name of the short story?

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад +1

      U read a story about rape.. wtf country do they do that in schools in

  • @TheAgentmigs
    @TheAgentmigs 8 лет назад +1

    This seems like an amazing movie though. I'll have to give it a shot because I can tell its sooo unsettling.

    • @RyanHollinger
      @RyanHollinger  8 лет назад +4

      If the fact I spoiled it ruins it for you, you might want to try The Invitation (on Netflix I believe). Nowhere near as good, but it has a lot of similar stylistic choices and some notable surprises.

    • @adiahaalexander9359
      @adiahaalexander9359 8 лет назад

      Wow I'm surprised you like the Invitation, I thought that was a really stupid movie. I predicted what was going to happen about 5 mins into it which made trying to finish it long and boring. Oh and the acting was annoying.

    • @kathleencaruanasmith8143
      @kathleencaruanasmith8143 6 лет назад

      Adiaha Alexander omg your so right about the invitation !
      It bored me to death !
      I was really surprised by how much of a let down it was to me.
      I sat through the whole film thinking there better be one hell of a shocking revelation to make up for this boring ride i'm on !
      The characters were annoying too which didnt help either.

  • @UncutDatingTruths
    @UncutDatingTruths 3 года назад +2

    *spolier alert** At first you feel like sorry for Simon like he might be a regular guy but when you keep watching and he confronts him in the parking lot and how he got the other guy fired you see how much of a POS he really is

    • @codyrodriguez1056
      @codyrodriguez1056 Год назад

      I would do way worst to anyone human trying to stalk and threatening my family. Good to know you have an empty nutsack

  • @markmoriwaki3158
    @markmoriwaki3158 3 месяца назад

    Central intelligence character for Jason Bateman x 🔥

  • @manniesreactionchannel3808
    @manniesreactionchannel3808 7 лет назад

    The gift was a brillant film, and it had nice plot and twist.... the whole storeline was unexpected.... and the fact he lack in empathy.

  • @lilzae4848
    @lilzae4848 3 месяца назад

    This movie was tuff asf so underrated but this was a great movie can't even be mad at Gordon, Simon got what he deserves Karma a bytch. Great ending now if they wanted to do another film it would make sense that Gordon and Simon ex got married

  • @TheZackHaber
    @TheZackHaber 2 года назад

    Thanks for this. I have yet to see an analysis address Gordo (probably) stealing the dog. What does that say about his character?

    • @rollingdudes8859
      @rollingdudes8859 2 года назад

      Very True!!! It shows that GORDO will hurt anyone or anything to get back at someone FOR THE SAKE OF REVENGE!!! WRATH is one of the SEVEN DEADLY SINS and hurting innocent people along the way is the reason why!!!

  • @chriscunningham8703
    @chriscunningham8703 4 года назад

    Loved this film... Think its very underrated

  • @Meta1head100
    @Meta1head100 6 лет назад +2

    This is a great video, but Robyn didn’t know that Gordo did/didn’t rape her.

  • @djth666
    @djth666 8 лет назад +1

    Really good review!!