Centroid of a Composite Shape - Tabular Method - Part 1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 янв 2025

Комментарии • 91

  • @nadia675123964523965
    @nadia675123964523965 4 года назад +7

    just gets straight to the fking point, excellent video has helped me greatly! keep up the good work

  • @mr.unknown9675
    @mr.unknown9675 5 лет назад +3

    sir, this is very helpful and plz make more videos on this topic

  • @okeniranolumide3663
    @okeniranolumide3663 5 лет назад +4

    pls sir. to calculate for bar x of a triangle what we use is 0ne-third of the base but now u are using two-third... i dont get sir

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  5 лет назад

      this is quite difficult to explain in words so I'll show a picture :-)
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centroid#/media/File:Triangle_centroid_2.svg
      The idea is that the centroid is one third of the distance from the right side of this image, and 2/3 of the distance from the left side.
      You will notice that, when compared with a square, the triangle has a right part with more area, and a left part with less area. The centroid should be closer to the side with the more area. ie. the centroid should be closer to the right side.
      (grammatical errors are intentional in the sentence above as I think this makes it easier to understand)

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  5 лет назад

      Oh, by the way, sir is reserved for knights and people that would be eligible to be added to this list:
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_honorary_British_knights_and_dames
      I haven't got that right yet so Cornelis will do, for now :-P

    • @mason4634
      @mason4634 3 года назад

      You most likely don't need this input anymore but you can also just do 8 x 1/3 and then subtract the product of 8 x 1/3 by 8.

  • @govindcharan7827
    @govindcharan7827 7 лет назад +1

    Very nice explaination . Loved it

  • @sofiamitsia8594
    @sofiamitsia8594 4 месяца назад +3

    isnt the centroid of a triangle the 1/3rd and not the 2/3rds as you put?

  • @siteramodel7414
    @siteramodel7414 6 лет назад

    nice MR HELPED ME A LOT GOOD EXPLANATIONS THUMBS UPPPP

  • @full-metal_jacob5858
    @full-metal_jacob5858 7 лет назад +5

    why divide by 4?
    3:00

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  7 лет назад +9

      There is an equation for area of a circle using radius: pi * radius * radius
      And an equation for area of a circle using diameter: pi * diameter * diameter / 4
      It is more common that the diameter of objects are given rather than the radius so the second formula is more useful. A google search will also provide you with the same formula as I have used.
      bfy.tw/FPDf

    • @full-metal_jacob5858
      @full-metal_jacob5858 7 лет назад +1

      superb explanation! thanks for going the extra mile!!!

  • @ahmadtheaviationlover1937
    @ahmadtheaviationlover1937 3 месяца назад

    Why is it 1/3 and 1/2 in terms of its distance?

  • @allfiredupltd9108
    @allfiredupltd9108 3 года назад +2

    Thank you so much finally after trolling through RUclips I have found somebody able to explain this to me

  • @moseskadungure7370
    @moseskadungure7370 6 лет назад +2

    nice explanation indeed

  • @تمرآيےهہ
    @تمرآيےهہ 4 года назад +1

    Please tell me from any source this question? Where can I find help?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  4 года назад

      This question was made up on the spot.
      A reference that I have used is Engineering Statics by Meriam and Kraige

    • @تمرآيےهہ
      @تمرآيےهہ 4 года назад

      @@corneliskok7794
      I did not find him in Miriam?
      In which edition of Myriam can be obtained and what is chapter ?

  • @sukhpreetsingh3844
    @sukhpreetsingh3844 4 года назад +1

    sir this is really helpful for me thanks

  • @andrewrae9964
    @andrewrae9964 3 года назад +1

    nice kok

  • @travoltavatileni7494
    @travoltavatileni7494 7 месяцев назад

    Sir for the Area of the circle, the radius in 1.5 not 3. And why did Sir divide the area of the circle by 4?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  7 месяцев назад

      There is an equation for area of a circle using radius: pi * radius * radius
      And an equation for area of a circle using diameter: pi * diameter * diameter / 4
      It is more common that the diameter of objects are given rather than the radius so the second formula is more useful. A google search will also provide you with the same formula as I have used. "Area of a circle using diameter"

  • @derrickvincent612
    @derrickvincent612 5 лет назад

    Great explanation

  • @jabezmoodley4559
    @jabezmoodley4559 5 лет назад +1

    My calculator doesn't give me the correct decimals it's like .5 it doesn't like give .67 if my decimals are of a little does it mean my answers tally will be incorrect making everything wrong ?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  5 лет назад

      It depends on the percentage error that would be created by the incorrect rounding (which in this case is caused by your calculator).
      for example if the number was 100.5 instead of 100.67... this situation would have less error created by your calculation than a situation where.... the number was 0.5 instead of 0.67
      If you are sure that the error is because of your calculator, I would look into getting a new calculator. An alternative could be to use wolframalpha.com or you could use calculator apps (I can't recommend one in particular though). Some of these options would not be appropriate in a controlled assessment. Maybe someone who is watching the page could suggest other alternatives.

  • @JoeHernandez-lp2tw
    @JoeHernandez-lp2tw Год назад +1

    I would like to mention to take into account of where is your origin when using this method. My teacher for example gave me an exam where to shapes were on the left on the negative x while the other was on the right. I didn't see right and assumed everything was on the left and on the positive x range. Anyways with that mistake I made sure not to repeat that same mistake on the final :)

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  Год назад

      I definitely agree with this comment. In the example above I assumed that the origin is on the bottom left corner.

  • @jayasreekandukuri2000
    @jayasreekandukuri2000 3 года назад

    How will find the Circle diameter is 3

  • @swethaninetshitwarini9017
    @swethaninetshitwarini9017 2 года назад

    Please do more videos of this topic 🙏

  • @cameronarnold7279
    @cameronarnold7279 6 лет назад +2

    why did he divide area of circle by 4?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  6 лет назад +2

      Hi Cameron, thanks for your question. There was a previous comment that asked me the same question so I can answer this quickly.
      There is an equation for area of a circle using radius: pi * radius * radius
      And an equation for area of a circle using diameter: pi * diameter * diameter / 4
      It is more common that the diameter of objects are given rather than the radius so the second formula is more useful. A google search will also provide you with the same formula as I have used.
      bfy.tw/FPDf

  • @Tna_she
    @Tna_she 5 лет назад +2

    how do you determine the centroid graphically?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  6 месяцев назад

      This is something that I don't know how to do yet. If you have found out, I would love to know.
      For a simple rectangle, you would draw lines from both of the opposite corners and the centroid would be at the intersection point. www.quora.com/How-do-you-find-the-centroid-for-a-rectangle-How-do-you-find-the-centroid-for-a-parallelogram
      For a triangle, you would draw three lines. From the middle of the each edge, to the opposite vertex. ruclips.net/video/HoXV2mvCD28/видео.html
      For a circle, the answer doesn't come to mind at the moment.
      The graphical method for a composite shape would have to take into account the size of area for each section, then would the centroid would be closer to the section with more area... but yeah, I haven't seen a graphical method for this.

  • @MomenMusameh
    @MomenMusameh 4 года назад +2

    why we use negative sign for removed parts in composite area to determine the centroid????
    which is better to use vertical strip or horizontal strip in integration method to find the centroid ?
    ??
    which is easier to use integration method or composite area method to solve for centroid of composite area ?
    ??
    Please I want an answer to these three questions ♥ thank you

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  3 года назад +3

      *Why we use negative sign for removed parts in composite area to determine the centroid????
      When area is removed from a section, the center of the shape will move more towards the side that has more area.
      Which is better to use vertical strip or horizontal strip in integration method to find the centroid ?
      ??
      This depends on the function and which axis the section is bound by. If it is bound by the x-axis, I would use a vertical strip. If it is bound by the y-axis, I would use a horizontal strip. If it is bound between two functions, I would use whatever makes the intergration easier, or what ever allows you to minimise the number of equations you need to solve. This is easier to explain with an example.
      Which is easier to use integration method or composite area method to solve for centroid of composite area ?
      ??
      In this case it was the composite area method. If you know the function, the integration is useful as long as the integral can be solved (though you can solve for the area using numerical methods).

  • @k4x4map46
    @k4x4map46 5 лет назад

    Great stuff thanks...

  • @toxicgee6811
    @toxicgee6811 Месяц назад

    Why do we have the center of the circle as 2 while we're given a diameter of 3 😢
    Cause what I know is that the center of a circle is determined by the radius

  • @LuckyStrange
    @LuckyStrange 4 года назад

    Why did you multiplied 2/3×8

    • @CornelisKok
      @CornelisKok 3 года назад

      Sorry for the delay.
      That was because the centroid is 1/3 away from the right angle side and 2/3 of the length from the acute angle side. What is important is the location of the centroid of the triangle in relation to the co-ordinate system; the formula isn't the most important thing to focus on in this problem.

  • @mohamedmenasy2253
    @mohamedmenasy2253 5 лет назад

    Very useful

  • @jessealmontetanjusay8886
    @jessealmontetanjusay8886 5 лет назад

    Why'd you multiply 1/3 to find y of triangle instead of 2/3?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  5 лет назад +2

      Sorry if this doesn't make sense or does not answer your question. I'm finding it quite hard to find out what may be your current concept, but I'll do what I can.
      There is a list of useful formulae for finding centroids available at the following link: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_centroids
      The formula shown in this link shows where the centroid is located in relation to the bottom right corner. In this case, our measurement is from the bottom left corner of the triangle.
      From that formulae we see that the centroid is located closer to the right angle corner '1/3 of the height' as measured from the bottom right, and '2/3' of the height as measured from the top right.
      One possible thing you may need to consider: the y co-ordinate is measured from the reference point on the bottom left corner of the triangle, and in the vertical direction
      the x co-ordinate is measured from the reference point on the bottom left corner of the triangle and in the horizontal direction.

  • @haiderabbasi5233
    @haiderabbasi5233 6 лет назад

    If we take the corner circle of radius 3 then is diameter will be 6 so as the height is 4 it will exceed the figure, which is not possible. If I’m wrong reply me ASAP.

    • @CornelisKok
      @CornelisKok 6 лет назад

      Just confirming that you are incorrect in the case of this video. The video shows a circle with diameter of 3, so it would fit in the space shown above.

  • @tebogomokoena4371
    @tebogomokoena4371 4 года назад

    Why divide by 4 on the area of a circle hole?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  4 года назад +1

      There is an equation for area of a circle using radius: pi * radius * radius
      And an equation for area of a circle using diameter: pi * diameter * diameter / 4
      It is more common that the diameter of objects are given rather than the radius so the second formula is more useful. A google search will also provide you with the same formula as I have used.
      bfy.tw/FPDf

    • @den-kun1482
      @den-kun1482 Год назад

      ​@@corneliskok7794Hello sir! I'm not sure but I think you put the radius (3) instead of the diameter which was supposed to be 6 in the formula pi(d/2)²

  • @3k__kk
    @3k__kk 4 года назад

    What Sources centroid of composite shapes???

  • @samkelobuthelezi1165
    @samkelobuthelezi1165 3 года назад

    Can you please do more videos

  • @AntoMatc97
    @AntoMatc97 7 лет назад

    good explanation

  • @shaunakkhair5097
    @shaunakkhair5097 7 лет назад

    Why the circle's area is taken as negative?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  7 лет назад +2

      Hi Shaunak, the question is made up of a triangle and rectangle with a circle hole removed. The circles area is taken as negative because it is removed from the triangle and rectangle section.

    • @bryanandujar3683
      @bryanandujar3683 6 лет назад +1

      thank you for this answer

  • @rubeushagridplayslol
    @rubeushagridplayslol 2 года назад

    isn't it supposed to be cm not mm

  • @ashnilabhatt6242
    @ashnilabhatt6242 5 лет назад

    How to know wether area is negative or positive

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  5 лет назад

      If material is taken away from the section, then the area is negative.
      If material is added to the section, then the area is positive.
      (I'd like to use a different word to "material", but it is the most understandable word in this context)

  • @zetsu9823
    @zetsu9823 6 лет назад

    Why circle area is negative?

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  6 лет назад

      Hi Skoosh brr, the question is made up of a triangle and rectangle with a circle hole removed. The circles area is taken as negative because it is removed from the triangle and rectangle section.

    • @zetsu9823
      @zetsu9823 6 лет назад

      @@corneliskok7794 thanks sir

  • @eliemutia4620
    @eliemutia4620 3 года назад +1

    thank youuuuuuu

  • @malikatalwrood510
    @malikatalwrood510 6 лет назад

    I have a near example you can help me find a solution? Belize😫

  • @anujnair3379
    @anujnair3379 6 лет назад

    When to use formula 2h/ 3 to solve

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  6 лет назад +1

      Hi Anuj, there is a list of centroids for common shapes available from wikipedia: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_centroids
      The equation h/3 is used for finding the distance from the right angle side to the center in the vertical direction. 2h/3 is usually used for finding the distance from the other side. I'm finding this quite hard to explain in text so the first image in the following link may help you: www.engineeringintro.com/mechanics-of-structures/centre-of-gravity/centroid-of-triangle/

  • @exral8797
    @exral8797 3 года назад

    thanks mate

  • @gajulavenkateswarlu3717
    @gajulavenkateswarlu3717 5 лет назад

    Good sir place make more videos

  • @Hasnaindynamics
    @Hasnaindynamics 4 года назад

    Why negative atea

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  4 года назад

      Hi Hasnian Ali,
      In this question, area is negative because it represents a section of the shape that is being taken away.

    • @travoltavatileni7494
      @travoltavatileni7494 7 месяцев назад

      @@corneliskok7794 Why did sir divide the area of the circle by 4?

  • @mohammadzaher2737
    @mohammadzaher2737 6 лет назад

    شكرا

  • @shifazahera7099
    @shifazahera7099 6 лет назад

    But for area of circle is pi.r^2

    • @CornelisKok
      @CornelisKok 6 лет назад

      Hi Shifa, you are correct. It is also (pi.d^2)/4
      ruclips.net/video/koxdduRGOLk/видео.html

    • @shifazahera7099
      @shifazahera7099 6 лет назад

      Cornelis Kok ...ok actually i didn't observe that u have take diameter ok .. thank you

  • @harishjaiswal2832
    @harishjaiswal2832 6 лет назад

    Triangle formula is 1/3 *B*H

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  6 лет назад +1

      Hi Harish, are you referring to the area of a triangle, the centroid of a triangle, or some other concept?

  • @mdlsaabfashion3812
    @mdlsaabfashion3812 6 лет назад +1

    its not a good explanation sir g for civil

    • @CornelisKok
      @CornelisKok 6 лет назад

      Thanks for your comment! What is missing?

    • @waleedjaved9905
      @waleedjaved9905 5 лет назад

      What are u smoking mate ? This guy explained everything really good.

    • @TheHonchoofAllSpearheads
      @TheHonchoofAllSpearheads 5 лет назад

      atif wafa bcoz ü will nvr understand even the simplest thing?

  • @Sabza015
    @Sabza015 4 года назад

    Tf going on

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  3 года назад

      If we cut this shape from a piece of cardboard, I'm trying to find the place where we could balance that shape on the tip of a pin

  • @princehenry1382
    @princehenry1382 5 лет назад

    Why is the area of the circle negative ??

    • @corneliskok7794
      @corneliskok7794  5 лет назад +1

      In this question, area is negative because it represents a section of the shape that is being taken away.