the fans are fkn crazy on the strix they are so directional the fans barely have to run im not even sure how much pressure they create but literally 25% less fan speed than any other card
The thicc runs hotter but also with 40% less fan speed than the strix. Is it just the way each one has their fan curve set or is there a different reason such as the thicc having a bigger heat capacity?
I'd say the xfx card is better in most aspects and if you are planning on getting the strix card (if the prices keep that way) I'd rather buy a cheap 5700. Nice review as always :) It gives us a look at both sides of the price spectrum to see if it's worth it paying more.
I got the xfx one and i love it, It's a 1080p-Ultra beast, never let me down so far. For example, In cyberpunk with everything cranked up to the maximum (except volumetric clouds and reflections at normal, and of course, no dlss or rt) gives me 57fps average. [coupled with 5 3600xt and 16 gb ddr4 3200MHz]
fun fact:on xfx cards you can see by the logos on the fans what kind of heatsink it is by comparing the color like if its grey then the heatsink is made out of aluminum if its like orange then its made out of copper
Which graphics model is better in terms of cooling and quality? A) SAPPHIRE RX 5600 XT PULSE B) ASUS RX 5600 XT TUF Gaming X3 C) MSI RX 5600 XT GAMING X D) ASUS RX 5600 XT ROG Strix OC Thanks...
Thank you for this versus review. Subbed and liked :) I'm actually in dilemma between those two GPUs. I liked XFX design and price but in ASUS I liked cooling results. I have few questions :) Do you know when ASUS ROG STRIX TOP will be released in global world? Does 5600 XT will be overkill for my i5-4690k@stock (for now, but will OC when new GPU arrive) @1080p @144hz? If yes, maybe I should go with other GPU (lowest tier NVIDIA Ampere in near future)? I'm in fear for now because I don't want to overpay for product which will be overkill for my CPU. Maybe I should go with XFX and made UV for better temperatures but only if this UV doesn't surpass my CPU capability to "feed" this GPU? Sorry for my english and again thanks for review :)
Glad you found this video useful. Thanks for subbing! I don't think you'll find a bottleneck using this GPU and CPU. Sure, you may be able to squeeze out some extra FPS with a faster, greater spec of CPU and of course if the games you play are CPU intensive then it could struggle compared to a higher spec model, however for most games this will be a great combo!
Nice video but you missed something very important. The heat difference more on fans curve. I suppoze the xfx is way more silent cause top fan speed was 34% vs 49% on asus. If someone uses 3rd party gan controller then the xfx is the winner here.
ok cool, the thicc ran at 60-75% the fan speed of the strix, so derp for sure it ran a bit hotter but also a little more quiet. i dont own any of these cards btw, just an fyi in case some1 wants to save a couple of bucks. it wouldve been far more interesting to see how far you can undervolt the cards and what memory clocks each can handle.
So the thicc fans weren't even running at the same speed as the strix card. I feel like these results would be different if you had locked both cards to the same fan speed.
Maybe. Heatsink design does have a significant role to play. But irrespective of this we're taking them as they are out of the box. No adjustments/modifications. This is what people buying the card can expect!
@@Vortez yeah that's true. I'm curious how the thic card would work if the fans were at the same speed. If you have time maybe you can run a quick test? If not no worries b
Impossible not to like this video. Exactly the both two GPU's i am watching for weeks....Yes, No, Maybe..Ahhh...or should i wait for the bomb RTX 3070?...Tired of thinking
I would wait. See what NVIDIA has to offer... And even if not, the launch of their cards could trigger an AMD pricedrop which will work in your favour. 👍🏻
@@yonkocommander5531 being more compact isnt a factor these days. Anyone who builds a mini setup is not so wise. If you have a new or 3-4 years old mid tower, then every single videocard will fit in that perfectly, and won't really affect the air flow inside. In my country the THICC III is the cheapest RX 5600 XT with the price of 317 USD. Based on this video the card running on very good temperature with much lower fan speed. Furthermore I really sympathise with XFX. My best card was an XFX R7 360. I had ZERO issue with that little boy, but my other cards produce a few issues time to time (ASUS) or died (Gigabyte).
Every cad has a unique base setup originally which can be easily customized with MSI Afterburner or other softwares. I personally prefer the XFX setup over ASUS, because I bet that 1700+ Rpm is loud as FK. 60-65 °C is pretty good temperature in that performance range, so I would definietly pick the XFX.
Depends what you mean by 'best' :) The Saph is a better value for money option overall, the ASUS has a stronger thermal design and offers slightly better performance.
I only now realized that these reviews of the models like xfx only really released the past few days. Not many reviews of these cards out there, same with the Red Devil. Why tho? Also for some reason these 2 cards havent released in many countries like Philippines is there a reason? This whole situation is very baffling.
@@Vortez My theory was maybe because they were making a second batch with the new vbios flashed already. At least that's what I think. Thx cuz I was really wondering if it was only my country without the card haha
@@RNerd Yeah that definitely makes sense and is logical, otherwise its left to retailers to flash the BIOS - would make more sense to delay releasing and ensure they are all updated before they leave the warehouse.
now XFX comes with 1750mhz memory bios right out of the box
and it's the most silent card i ever had
Nice to see live gameplay with FPS counters as comparison. I know graphs are easy but I appreciate live gameplay more.
Pulled the trigger on the XFX. It was $115 dollars cheaper and came with the game bundle.
That's quite a big difference! Enjoy the new card.
Just ordered the Xfx as well. Got $20 off and Resident evil 3 for free
@@Silent_Shadow dude, how to get game bundle from XFX RX 5600 XT?
some sites have the game deal , and it also difference from country's
Abdul Malik Solehuddin sites like new egg and different ones offer a game bundle.
Nice video man. Ive been looking for rx 5600 xt, and found this. Thanks
Glad you liked it! Thanks for watching mate.
the fans are fkn crazy on the strix
they are so directional the fans barely have to run
im not even sure how much pressure they create
but literally 25% less fan speed than any other card
I purchased the ROG Strix version, didn't even know it had those little fan headers. that's a nice touch, might connect it to my lower case fans.
The thicc runs hotter but also with 40% less fan speed than the strix. Is it just the way each one has their fan curve set or is there a different reason such as the thicc having a bigger heat capacity?
I'd say the xfx card is better in most aspects and if you are planning on getting the strix card (if the prices keep that way) I'd rather buy a cheap 5700. Nice review as always :) It gives us a look at both sides of the price spectrum to see if it's worth it paying more.
Thanks for watching 👍🏻 yeah, this one was a fun exercise, it should hopefully be useful for those in the market for this GPU
I got the xfx one and i love it, It's a 1080p-Ultra beast, never let me down so far.
For example, In cyberpunk with everything cranked up to the maximum (except volumetric clouds and reflections at normal, and of course, no dlss or rt) gives me 57fps average.
[coupled with 5 3600xt and 16 gb ddr4 3200MHz]
fun fact:on xfx cards you can see by the logos on the fans what kind of heatsink it is by comparing the color like if its grey then the heatsink is made out of aluminum if its like orange then its made out of copper
Now the Strix 5600Xt 2nd(yes mining card) just cost only 110$,it even cheaper than the RTX 2060 6Gb(also a 2nd)in where i live Hanoi,Vietnam
Fan RPM does not matched at all. Should have adjusted that to have a fair comparison.
Already been over this.
We're taking them as they are,,, out of the box and showing what people can expect.
@@Vortez just curious, if you guy adjust the fan rpm. How was the result?
£370 for the strix version , wow I only paid £350 for my 5700xt new
You did well there!! Which card is it?
@@Vortez I bet it's the MSI EVOKE one , It' s cheap cause it has got thermal issues
mine just $270 or £210 new
Which graphics model is better in terms of cooling and quality?
A) SAPPHIRE RX 5600 XT PULSE
B) ASUS RX 5600 XT TUF Gaming X3
C) MSI RX 5600 XT GAMING X
D) ASUS RX 5600 XT ROG Strix OC
Thanks...
E) Red Devil is the answer!!.
@@richardgarcia6201 with fan issues... rigth.
very nice card and awesome review as always
Thank you for this versus review. Subbed and liked :) I'm actually in dilemma between those two GPUs. I liked XFX design and price but in ASUS I liked cooling results. I have few questions :) Do you know when ASUS ROG STRIX TOP will be released in global world? Does 5600 XT will be overkill for my i5-4690k@stock (for now, but will OC when new GPU arrive) @1080p @144hz? If yes, maybe I should go with other GPU (lowest tier NVIDIA Ampere in near future)? I'm in fear for now because I don't want to overpay for product which will be overkill for my CPU. Maybe I should go with XFX and made UV for better temperatures but only if this UV doesn't surpass my CPU capability to "feed" this GPU? Sorry for my english and again thanks for review :)
Glad you found this video useful. Thanks for subbing!
I don't think you'll find a bottleneck using this GPU and CPU. Sure, you may be able to squeeze out some extra FPS with a faster, greater spec of CPU and of course if the games you play are CPU intensive then it could struggle compared to a higher spec model, however for most games this will be a great combo!
@@Vortez Thank you for answer :)
nice review bro,thanks
isn't that the thicc 3?? not the thicc 3 ultra? the ultra still has the chrome edges.. no?
Nice video but you missed something very important. The heat difference more on fans curve. I suppoze the xfx is way more silent cause top fan speed was 34% vs 49% on asus. If someone uses 3rd party gan controller then the xfx is the winner here.
ok cool, the thicc ran at 60-75% the fan speed of the strix, so derp for sure it ran a bit hotter but also a little more quiet. i dont own any of these cards btw, just an fyi in case some1 wants to save a couple of bucks. it wouldve been far more interesting to see how far you can undervolt the cards and what memory clocks each can handle.
Strix mobo with the 2060 ko, but just pulled the trigger on the 5600 xt i'll just ebay the 2060. AMD drivers don't let me down.
How did you find the graphic card any driver issues or hot temp ?
I would have to agree!
Have a I7-3770k and radeon r9 390 8gb. Would this be a good upgrade for 1080p. Cpu is running about 60% on most game.
So the thicc fans weren't even running at the same speed as the strix card. I feel like these results would be different if you had locked both cards to the same fan speed.
Maybe. Heatsink design does have a significant role to play. But irrespective of this we're taking them as they are out of the box. No adjustments/modifications. This is what people buying the card can expect!
@@Vortez yeah that's true. I'm curious how the thic card would work if the fans were at the same speed. If you have time maybe you can run a quick test? If not no worries b
Sure. I'll run this later today and see what effect it has. Thanks for the suggestion!
@@Vortez thanks man, would you mind replying here with the results!?
wow what a video. Thanks
Dont know how but my strix 5600 is running memory at 3ghz. Haven't played with values. 1780 is base GPU.
How is the temps on rog strix?
Impossible not to like this video. Exactly the both two GPU's i am watching for weeks....Yes, No, Maybe..Ahhh...or should i wait for the bomb RTX 3070?...Tired of thinking
I would wait. See what NVIDIA has to offer... And even if not, the launch of their cards could trigger an AMD pricedrop which will work in your favour. 👍🏻
@@Vortez That's what i am thinking too. Let's wait ;-)
How do I control the lighting? or is it not possible yet? x570 rog and 5600xt rog.
aura sync
The Pulse is cheaper than both cards and perform as well as the Strix TOP 😂😂
Tolard49 it is ugly af though
@@Kostas.-. it's also more compact
@@yonkocommander5531 being more compact isnt a factor these days. Anyone who builds a mini setup is not so wise. If you have a new or 3-4 years old mid tower, then every single videocard will fit in that perfectly, and won't really affect the air flow inside. In my country the THICC III is the cheapest RX 5600 XT with the price of 317 USD. Based on this video the card running on very good temperature with much lower fan speed. Furthermore I really sympathise with XFX. My best card was an XFX R7 360. I had ZERO issue with that little boy, but my other cards produce a few issues time to time (ASUS) or died (Gigabyte).
@@staLkerhu that's fine price is definitely a factor, however all prices equal the sapphire has the best clocks and thermal performance
is it still worth it to buy the xfx model? I’m really in need of a GPU however all popular models are sold out in the UK
Yeah it’s good
@@charlie-nq6vy it’s all good thanks, managed to pick up a sapphire nitro+ SE 5700😃
Is the fan speed locked on the T3 Ultra cause i see the fans spin almost 2x as fast keeping the Strix performing a bit better????
Every cad has a unique base setup originally which can be easily customized with MSI Afterburner or other softwares. I personally prefer the XFX setup over ASUS, because I bet that 1700+ Rpm is loud as FK. 60-65 °C is pretty good temperature in that performance range, so I would definietly pick the XFX.
The comparison should be done at a fan speed with the same level of sound...at the end we dont know wich termal solution is better
is the asus rog strix better than the msi 1650 super gaming x
ASUS ROG STRIX RX 5600 XT vs SAPPHIRE PULSE RX 5600 XT which one the best ?
Depends what you mean by 'best' :) The Saph is a better value for money option overall, the ASUS has a stronger thermal design and offers slightly better performance.
Sapphire is one of the best 5600 xt out there
I only now realized that these reviews of the models like xfx only really released the past few days. Not many reviews of these cards out there, same with the Red Devil. Why tho? Also for some reason these 2 cards havent released in many countries like Philippines is there a reason? This whole situation is very baffling.
Some of them weren't available from day 1 launch and are only now just starting to become available for pre-order. Not sure on the reasoning!
@@Vortez Ah that explains it. Thanks man 👍
@@Vortez My theory was maybe because they were making a second batch with the new vbios flashed already. At least that's what I think. Thx cuz I was really wondering if it was only my country without the card haha
@@RNerd Yeah that definitely makes sense and is logical, otherwise its left to retailers to flash the BIOS - would make more sense to delay releasing and ensure they are all updated before they leave the warehouse.
Sana bumaba na ung price netong strix 5600xt sa december sana lahit 18k bibilin ko tlga to tutal 1080p gaming lng naman ako..
5700 xt asus strix vs 5700 xt xfx tic3??quale va meglio?
the cheapest
$60 for overclocked memory? LMAO. I'd pay more to get the 5700 before that
there is pro version which is cheaper.
Is it 14gbps ?
Asus rog strix or saphire pulse?
Sapphire pulse
Thanks getting the asus
2030 GPU with 20 Fans
Just to let you know the strix card in the UK is £299
Got a link?
It is on ebuyer
www.ebuyer.com/957897-gigabyte-radeon-rx-5600-xt-gaming-oc-6gb-graphics-card-gv-r56xtgaming-oc-6gd
No it isn't. That's the OC model, not the Top Edition. Even the OC is listed as £350.
Where can you buy the Strix TOP rx 5600 xt in USA?
Ha Ha Ha, more expensive than a 5700? Why would anybody spend more for less performance?
It is good if in your country the 5700 is cheaper. But (surprise) that is not the case everywhere else ;)
-Click- "Noice" 69th Like.
RX 5600 XT is a mess