The question is... Which one is better. I think Zaminations because it's more clear on what the boy did. In the original it's like he did something wrong... YEAH! But in the original the boy was smarter since he ran away after shooting her
(very late response but) you would prob kill a normal zombie, but she somehow survived and he wanted to shoot her again, but ran out of ammo, and i think he didnt run cuz she is goddamn fast anyway
I'd like to see a definitive remake of this that takes the best bits of each version: From Zanimation: Keep the Eye shot at the beginning Keep her in-depth story of betrayal and how she became a zombie. Keep the Fluid animations for the chorus section only Keep the shot of her breaking the picture in half Keep the shot of the BF recognizing her and seeing her how she used to be. Keep the multiple cuts back to the guy getting savaged. From Original: Keep the tone and colour scheme of this version Keep the Janky animations that really compliment the creepiness of the zombie for everything but the chorus section. Keep the "strangle" motion and "Swirly eyed confusion" anime expression in. Keep the "Blood Tears" thing. Keep the scene where the guy is smart (and callous) enough to run away after shooting him Keep the scene where she just appears behind him and kills him while he's running Keep the overly gory "blood fountain" death while off screen. Keep the last shot of him becoming a zombie on his eye only, and make it the last shot of the video. This would tie it back to the first shot of the video. New Ideas: Near the end, when she kills him, have the guy rushing off towards a helicopter or a boat, or a plane, or anything that'll take him to safety, to raise the stakes and makes us think he's going to get away with everything he's done, and have her kill him at the last possible second.
i understand this is an old comment but the difference between the original and the zamination version is that the original creator isn't worried about the blood and gore because they don't have to worry about monetization and age restrictions.
Whereas Zamination is more of a kid friendly and bigger channel so they can't add all the 18+ stuff without being demonitized or age restricted because most of their content is more towards the younger demographic
now the original creator could do this but the chances of them actually seeing your comment on this channel is quite unlikely since it's a compilation and a reupload to a degree
Choosing is to hard for me, both have their own unique features, Zam adds more backstory, while the original is able to change expressions perfectly, so yeah, it’s a tie for me, and keep in mind, this is my opinion
The original is actually great, but what made some people prefer Zam more is that he added some scenes of his own and made some diversification in the footage and made it less terrifying and bloody, but both are good. الأصل رائع حقًا ، لكن ما جعل بعض الناس يفضلون زام أكثر هو أنه أضاف بعض المشاهد الخاصة به وقام ببعض التنويع في اللقطات وجعلها أقل رعبًا ودموية ، لكن كلاهما جيد.
That moment when the "copy" becomes better than the original. But seriously, the minecraft version is more dynamic, more happening there. We learn more from the video.
after reading through the comments on this, my thoughts are alot different to most of them. yes, zamination has cleaner animation, but the original looks almost grimy, it gives more of a feeling of an apocalypse, whereas the second video at points made me think it just looked like it took place in a normal city. it is good animation, but for the theme it feels too "clean"
In original they didn't show why she want to murder him. we dont know that he left her, what caused to turn her into a zombie, she Just say "you've been away far too long". aslo there arent any zombies, so we couldnt know WHY SHE HATES HIM Sorry for my English if I have lots of mistakes and confused moments
@@Trezviitolkopoprazdnikam late, but you realise the lyrics imply that he probably did leave her? Without watching the zamination version you can sorta tell still, his just shows it in a more obvious way.
honestly, i got some respect for Steve. a-hole in the original booked it outta there but Steve actually stayed for enough time to like, be sad or something? idk
honestly for all the minecraft version does have, i very much prefer the original. while not as dynamic in movement, it had a ceratin charm to it and the expression and so much better. The jerkiness kind adds to the whole 'she's a zombie' thing, and her starting to move again after being shot with the convulsions and pain made it more horrifying and sad.
I like the the Minecraft version better. Not just bc it’s Minecraft, it just shows more emotion and has more of a backstory. The animation is smoother as well
ZAMination version has more of the story telling than the original version. The original only focused on Kathy chan and not really telling the story of the lyrics like Zamination did.
i swear some details make me love the original better and some make me love the zamination one better put them both edited into 1 video like the original then suddenly animation it would be amazing
Probably a little biased over the two, I just feel a little weird about the minecraft one. I like the original more so because I don't think it translates well into minecraft. But Zamination one has no right being that well animated, I mean seriously it's so fluid, maybe that's it, watching a minecraft character move semi realistically is kinda hitting me with uncanny valley vibes. Still, both are good
The feeling, emotion, action of minecraft is not perfect with a zombie girl. A zombie but have too much emotion, action that make it 8,5/10 and song is 10
Переводчик в помощь, кому интересно мое мнение. "Zamination" меняет представление о ситуации в клипе, выставляя в итоге парня виновником в заражении девушки и смерти его самого. В оригинале же ощущение, что героиня просто встретила парня на улице, которого даже не знает и убила его. Ничего особо не понять. Так что автор молодец, отличная работа! Даже лучше оригинала)
Guys, the person who made the original was Puccagarukiss. Just.... felt like I needed to get that out there, because everyone's referring to hers as just "the original", which makes sense, but still.
I’m the zamation version:chasing him Original: yeets whole self on him* Zamation:little bit of blood Original: YASSSS BLOOOOOD IN HER EYES TOO YESSSSSSSS OOOH YEAH zamation: Steve waiting for her to be alive again Original: run. Zamation: flashback Original: just talking Who won
Letter: You would do all the things that make me hate you fool I would strangle you If I had a rope or two It wasn't always like this you used to make me smile but now that time is gone You've been away far too long when our world was torn apart by the undead I was lost to tha hunger in my head It's not like I want to have a taste Already dead, so why would I care I just want to chase and rip your face This got nothing to do With your brains Atrocious, Zombielicous That's what i'm aiming for I don't feel so smart Brains, Brains, Brains, Brains, Brains! It wasn"t always like this I wasn't this hostile But now my mind is gone You've been away far too long Struck by a pain inside my heart It fills me with dread I was glad to see you here With the dead It's not like I want to have a taste Already dead, so why would I care I just want to chase and rip your face This got nothing to do With your brains When our world was torn apart Ha ha ha... Struck by a pain inside my heart It's not like I want to have a taste Already dead, so why would I care I just want to chase and rip your face This got nothing to do(HEHEHEHAHAHA) It's not like I want to have a taste Already dead, so why would I care I just want to chase and rip your face This got nothing to do It's not like I want to have a taste Already dead, so why would I care I just want to chase and rip your face This got nothing to do With your brains.
ENG: I liked ZAMINATION the most, for the quality movement, but the original is also something! RUS: Больше всего понравился ZAMINATION, за качественный механизм, но оригинал тоже кое-что!
I love both, and each have different things that I love Zamination has more movement The original boyfriend looks a lot well, cooler, instead of looking like Steve he has a much cooler style with a white hoodie and black pants
I do love Zamination's version, not saying the MMD was bad but can we talk about how smarter the dude was in the MMD version!? Like he did NOT wait for her to just ride back from being shot. He did the SMART THING and RAN rather than stand there like an idiot waiting for her to get back up! Like, yeah he still died but he was still smart enough to run while she was incapacitated
!["Purple Girl" (I'm Psycho) [VERSION B] - Minecraft Animation Music Video](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5QlGCHVrEYU/mqdefault.jpg)
![GEEK TIMË [OFFICIAL AUDIO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ry-6RvkH880/mqdefault.jpg)
Original : comment
ZAmination : comment
Both like :)
I Love both 💕
@@justimagine709 Same UwU
Bro there’s 66 likes and only two comments
@@nooboroo6044 Lol 😂😂😂
Zamination
3:04
So glad ZAM kept that part. There's just something so mesmerizing about it.
Ikr
🔪🔪🔪🔪
zamination team like
original team comment
I choose both :)
sen türkmüsün
@@good4joanne evet
kanalına baktım türkmüssün
@@009Editss_ zamination mu güzel yoksa orjinalmi bence zamination
Minecraft Was Kinda CUTEEE
😱😱😱😱😵😵😵😵😵😖😖😖😫😫😓😓😓
Original: Good
ZAMination: The Best
Original: The Best
ZAMination: The best
It's equal :)
I like how zamination explains how she became a zombie
Agree
yea
Yep
Me too
Also explains who the guy was
Her expression when the gun was pointed at her though
Both are great :D
Y32 b019 a23 g2351:)
Lol the expression looked so Innocen
U say that one on everyone
O∆O
What people don’t realize is that the first one was animated by one person only, not a whole team.
Both animations are great though in their own way!
Yes I saw the Minecraft one first but then I saw the original they are both good I love them so much
Qu5
Yes
The question is... Which one is better.
I think Zaminations because it's more clear on what the boy did. In the original it's like he did something wrong... YEAH!
But in the original the boy was smarter since he ran away after shooting her
(very late response but)
you would prob kill a normal zombie, but she somehow survived and he wanted to shoot her again, but ran out of ammo, and i think he didnt run cuz she is goddamn fast anyway
I'd like to see a definitive remake of this that takes the best bits of each version:
From Zanimation:
Keep the Eye shot at the beginning
Keep her in-depth story of betrayal and how she became a zombie.
Keep the Fluid animations for the chorus section only
Keep the shot of her breaking the picture in half
Keep the shot of the BF recognizing her and seeing her how she used to be.
Keep the multiple cuts back to the guy getting savaged.
From Original:
Keep the tone and colour scheme of this version
Keep the Janky animations that really compliment the creepiness of the zombie for everything but the chorus section.
Keep the "strangle" motion and "Swirly eyed confusion" anime expression in.
Keep the "Blood Tears" thing.
Keep the scene where the guy is smart (and callous) enough to run away after shooting him
Keep the scene where she just appears behind him and kills him while he's running
Keep the overly gory "blood fountain" death while off screen.
Keep the last shot of him becoming a zombie on his eye only, and make it the last shot of the video. This would tie it back to the first shot of the video.
New Ideas:
Near the end, when she kills him, have the guy rushing off towards a helicopter or a boat, or a plane, or anything that'll take him to safety, to raise the stakes and makes us think he's going to get away with everything he's done, and have her kill him at the last possible second.
i understand this is an old comment but the difference between the original and the zamination version is that the original creator isn't worried about the blood and gore because they don't have to worry about monetization and age restrictions.
Whereas Zamination is more of a kid friendly and bigger channel so they can't add all the 18+ stuff without being demonitized or age restricted because most of their content is more towards the younger demographic
now the original creator could do this but the chances of them actually seeing your comment on this channel is quite unlikely since it's a compilation and a reupload to a degree
I think that the zamination version has more dynamic movement, and that makes the animation more satisfying to watch
Zamination is better
@Precious Hanna Macatangay I like both
Hjhihjuujoudgdhgudyefeujfududvdhrudydggdjufgdufhifbhfjffjjejoeudos0udukeodijdkdodjdjdrkkdldlidhdnjdjfkdjdmfigjnnkoxxbdmdjhswqiolhdjkķkijhjjjkokiijikloòkokl💚💙❤💖😄
Yeah same but remember the animation was old
[;
Choosing is to hard for me, both have their own unique features, Zam adds more backstory, while the original is able to change expressions perfectly, so yeah, it’s a tie for me, and keep in mind, this is my opinion
Zaminations animation made way more sense than the original
That wasn’t only me!?
true
Yeah
I agree
Right?!
The original is actually great, but what made some people prefer Zam more is that he added some scenes of his own and made some diversification in the footage and made it less terrifying and bloody, but both are good.
الأصل رائع حقًا ، لكن ما جعل بعض الناس يفضلون زام أكثر هو أنه أضاف بعض المشاهد الخاصة به وقام ببعض التنويع في اللقطات وجعلها أقل رعبًا ودموية ، لكن كلاهما جيد.
1:58 the best part of the music
Ah yes the part where their no one singing
La la la la ala a
I-i i am your mom m-m-mom
แม่กลัวเกิน
Mine craft
Zamination: smoother and better animation
Orginal: more violent and realistic XD
How much blood do you want
Original: *Y E S*
Zamination: Perfectly balanced, like all things should be.
Facts
Lol i really dont like blood i have a fear of it so i would rather not watch the original 😅😂
Point
Change it to Zammination original and other to fake
Thanos speach from infinity war
I feel like the zamination has more of a story too it
True
Yeah
2:12 zamination can turn ugly zombies into cute zombies
Rashid Muhammad nah I think the zombie looks pretty
+++
@@jeopardizerr hot
@@arman_cooldude uhh
she was kinda cute even in the original
ZAnimation is more powerful and dynamic. The animation smooth and satisfying ♥️ I vote ZAnimation version
That moment when the "copy" becomes better than the original. But seriously, the minecraft version is more dynamic, more happening there. We learn more from the video.
I'd dsy its clip,parody,more than "copy"
I’m not gonna lie, I love the original one better. Both of them looked really good though! I also like the fact the the original was more creepy- lol
The originals ones killing last scene was more brutal than i thought
If u ask me its that over kill how about try watching blood c
Btw im a weeb if u know that
That's the magic when coppa was alive'nt
yup tge original is soooooo scary i cant sleep
@@tamatelxr5027 lol it just a vid it will never come in real life
@@jmazzeramv-mation6825 I’ve seen trailers and sneak peeks for that but I am not watching that to bloody and gorey
can we just say how damn creepy the original one is?
It's really creepy but the song is nice
Anime:Zamination
Manga:original
Netflix adaptation: * old computer sounds*
Fr tho. Give me shivers down my spine
When she said “undead” it sounded like a vocaloid voice
why do i see you in almost alot of fnaf animations
Zamination: Smoother and more dynamic movements
Original: Haha blood go brrrrr
i know right?
Yeshhh
I like ZAMination version
yeah
Me too.
Agreed
YES
Yah
I generally can't choose between them, they're both unique and different in their own ways-
I absolutely love to watch both!❤️
😼😸😹👍👌✌✋
Same
It seem the original is more like the stoyy is sopost to be but the minecraft one seems like shes just more insane
Same
Zamimation has done a great job
His is so much better
This is actually terrifying
her laugh reminds me of Yandere-chan
Oh My-- Im Speechless..
But the person who voice ayano is Michael law-?
@@itzmeconfusion3169 it still sounds like yandere
Eeeh a little bit
@@alexcr623 thx u-
after reading through the comments on this, my thoughts are alot different to most of them. yes, zamination has cleaner animation, but the original looks almost grimy, it gives more of a feeling of an apocalypse, whereas the second video at points made me think it just looked like it took place in a normal city. it is good animation, but for the theme it feels too "clean"
In original they didn't show why she want to murder him. we dont know that he left her, what caused to turn her into a zombie, she Just say "you've been away far too long". aslo there arent any zombies, so we couldnt know WHY SHE HATES HIM
Sorry for my English if I have lots of mistakes and confused moments
@@Trezviitolkopoprazdnikam she was the only zombie seen in the original but zamination showed other zombies as well
@@Trezviitolkopoprazdnikam late, but you realise the lyrics imply that he probably did leave her? Without watching the zamination version you can sorta tell still, his just shows it in a more obvious way.
But not a zombie apocalypse. It could be anything that caused it.
@@Okus477 and how precisely can you tell he left her in the original?
I don’t know how, but in the capacity of this song, it became one of my faveroutes
Both awesome. I knew the original before I knew the minecraft one even existed 😂. In fact i first watched the original 2 years ago
People: Who has the cooler animation?
zAmination: yes
i like the original at the end where you can see the bois eye go down and turn red it just looks SO COOOLLLLL
THAT ZOMBIE BIT RIGHT IN TO HIS SHOLDER OWCH THE BONE MUST OF CRACKT OW
It mayed me think of world war z even if i have not watched i only know that the zombies are wall climbers and fast maniacs
@@inclusivewinter2279 *Made
honestly, i got some respect for Steve. a-hole in the original booked it outta there but Steve actually stayed for enough time to like, be sad or something? idk
2:31 that voice sounds epic AF
IKR
even at nine, I'm bloodthirsty... I LOVE THE ORIGINAL
I think zamination was better
@@bloomfairyofthedragonflame9681 Yeah, you're right... Zamination Definitely shows more about the story.
I choose zamination his minecraft story
Yeah same his is waaay better
Original is more scarear then zamination
*scarier
i was about to say it is a minecraft animashin but thin thow no minecraft anmashis can be skary if down right like the omaga flowy in i'm flowey
True
Ye
I mean the original is amazing
The zamination I like how this person gave her bigger eyes when he was about to shoot her
honestly for all the minecraft version does have, i very much prefer the original. while not as dynamic in movement, it had a ceratin charm to it and the expression and so much better. The jerkiness kind adds to the whole 'she's a zombie' thing, and her starting to move again after being shot with the convulsions and pain made it more horrifying and sad.
Litteraly why won't you say zamination instead of "MInEcRaFT
@@honeyscotch because it’s minecraft
😁💬💩🦷👰🧎♀️🤽♀️👤👣
it would be way scarier if it was cod nazi zombie cause the screech brings more of em
I like the the Minecraft version better. Not just bc it’s Minecraft, it just shows more emotion and has more of a backstory.
The animation is smoother as well
your first video is so good the original is almost creepier
The original is cute. Scary, but cute
The one Zamination made was my fav thou. I just like the movement of Kathy-Chan in it and it just looked so cool
Og didn't look cute at all..
@@Butterflies-m2u I thought it did. Not like in cute-cute, but ghoolish cute
both are good cause if there wasn't the original animation zanimation couldn't make it simple
z
I do like the way they gave a little bit of pre-zombie and some more expressive movement in her
I think Zamination's version has more details
yeah but even a empty gun is dengerous which he didnt use to smash her skull
ironic given that Zamination's one is Minecraft style
ZAMination version has more of the story telling than the original version. The original only focused on Kathy chan and not really telling the story of the lyrics like Zamination did.
i swear some details make me love the original better and some make me love the zamination one better
put them both edited into 1 video like the original then suddenly animation it would be amazing
zanimation tells more of a story
original is just a regular apocalyptic world and a random dude
True
Probably a little biased over the two, I just feel a little weird about the minecraft one. I like the original more so because I don't think it translates well into minecraft. But Zamination one has no right being that well animated, I mean seriously it's so fluid, maybe that's it, watching a minecraft character move semi realistically is kinda hitting me with uncanny valley vibes. Still, both are good
We all know which is better
Im not gunna say any name’s
Cough! Zamination cough!
I liked both >:(
How rude they're both good!
Cough! You're right, Zamination is better. Cough!
@@dominomimi5137 exactly
I think that the original one was a little bit more violent, because there was a ton of blood on the guy!
The feeling, emotion, action of minecraft is not perfect with a zombie girl. A zombie but have too much emotion, action that make it 8,5/10 and song is 10
I respect your opinion :)
agree to disagree
If a zombie is smart enough to sing and hold gripes it's smart enough to move this way. imo oc
The minecraft is too much action than original
@@herominevn aaaaand i think i like it
Переводчик в помощь, кому интересно мое мнение.
"Zamination" меняет представление о ситуации в клипе, выставляя в итоге парня виновником в заражении девушки и смерти его самого.
В оригинале же ощущение, что героиня просто встретила парня на улице, которого даже не знает и убила его. Ничего особо не понять. Так что автор молодец, отличная работа! Даже лучше оригинала)
The Zamination one looks more mad but the original is still the scariest
Guys, the person who made the original was Puccagarukiss. Just.... felt like I needed to get that out there, because everyone's referring to hers as just "the original", which makes sense, but still.
Zamination 110%!
I just like that she's not twitching around so much and actually seems a lot more *aware* c:
zamination's animation is like there more to it to the story...
2:43
**Left 4 dead 2 female jockey laugh**
Yep.
??
I’m the zamation version:chasing him
Original: yeets whole self on him*
Zamation:little bit of blood
Original: YASSSS BLOOOOOD IN HER EYES TOO YESSSSSSSS OOOH YEAH
zamation: Steve waiting for her to be alive again
Original: run.
Zamation: flashback
Original: just talking
Who won
Both
Zamination
Sami nation has more action:)
Hello to ur channel!☺I subscribed
Two of them are great because two of the animator's did their best
I have a question... In the end did he become a zombie???
@Gacha This yes
👍👍👍👍👍👍
i kinda like how zam made it feel like the girl wasn't a zombie and he just was hallucinating or something
0:33 is legit the best part
so, do you want this zombie girl to be cute or creepy?
animators: *yes*
Letter:
You would do all the things
that make me hate you fool
I would strangle you
If I had a rope or two
It wasn't always like this
you used to make me smile
but now that time is gone
You've been away far too long
when our world was torn apart
by the undead
I was lost to tha hunger
in my head
It's not like I want to have a taste
Already dead, so why would I care
I just want to chase
and rip your face
This got nothing to do
With your brains
Atrocious, Zombielicous
That's what i'm aiming for
I don't feel so smart
Brains, Brains, Brains, Brains, Brains!
It wasn"t always like this
I wasn't this hostile
But now my mind is gone
You've been away far too long
Struck by a pain inside my heart
It fills me with dread
I was glad to see you here
With the dead
It's not like I want to have a taste
Already dead, so why would I care
I just want to chase
and rip your face
This got nothing to do
With your brains
When our world was torn apart
Ha ha ha...
Struck by a pain inside my heart
It's not like I want to have a taste
Already dead, so why would I care
I just want to chase
and rip your face
This got nothing to do(HEHEHEHAHAHA)
It's not like I want to have a taste
Already dead, so why would I care
I just want to chase
and rip your face
This got nothing to do
It's not like I want to have a taste
Already dead, so why would I care
I just want to chase
and rip your face
This got nothing to do
With your brains.
🧠🧠🧠👍
One thing I hate that the original got 2 million views in two years and the zamination one got more than 4 million views in few days......
ENG: I liked ZAMINATION the most, for the quality movement, but the original is also something!
RUS: Больше всего понравился ZAMINATION, за качественный механизм, но оригинал тоже кое-что!
Oh Hello:)
hello :)
Hello there
Hiiiiiiiii
When someone steals the chicken nuggies: 1:59
2:52 when u finally get them also it’s the original
I can’t tell which one is more creepier
original
Original like look at her move and her face everything
Idk they are both equal and later I will tell you why
in my opinion, the original is creepier. In the chorus, imagine a lady just walking up to you like that with white eyes-
@@jayjayrah7237 then it means she's a zombie- just imagine that
Oooooooohooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Wow I’m surprised this got recommended to so many people
I liked more the zamination and greetings from Bolivia 🇧🇴
Now I'm sure I will have nightmares
Please don't
That’s not even scary
I like in the original the guy doesn’t just stands there.
То чувство, когда пародия/копия лучше оригинала)
Да)
Ля,не то слово=>
Ага 👍😋
i love the way when she chase him
Thanks for making this! I wanted to watch the original and zamination comparison. :D
❤👍💙👍💚👍
When she fliping realized she could've juped that bush to escape and run for it and tgfo there
Well original one is more scary and BRuTaL
Zamination one is cute and have a complete story and also Realistic
I love both, and each have different things that I love
Zamination has more movement
The original boyfriend looks a lot well, cooler, instead of looking like Steve he has a much cooler style with a white hoodie and black pants
Do you love is movie
Z animation does a really good job in animations
I do love Zamination's version, not saying the MMD was bad but can we talk about how smarter the dude was in the MMD version!? Like he did NOT wait for her to just ride back from being shot. He did the SMART THING and RAN rather than stand there like an idiot waiting for her to get back up! Like, yeah he still died but he was still smart enough to run while she was incapacitated
I have to admit I like the Minecraft one more
The real version looks even creepier then the zaminations one could ever be
Yea
I like the original since I have watched it more times
Plz no hates and I don't want your options
@@Rex_Thanos I respect your opinion ! I prefer ZAmination, but I will not hate your opinion
There both great but i like zamination more tho
Omg this COOL zamination vs original
And i thought the minecraft version was scary
Dude i am 9 and i wasnt scared of zombies untill i saw the original of this now i am scared even thou zombies arent real
Garen Krikorian Ah yes, zombies
@@inclusivewinter2279 calm down. zombies arent real, they cant hurt you
@@BountiedFish didnt you realize thats what i said
@@inclusivewinter2279 its a joke
Tbh the when the girl became the zombie she looked much cuter, in zaminations style ofc
Just imagine the original having an updated Animation-
Ikr it’s an unfair advantage because some people are saying how zaminations is more smooth although that ones newer