What’s going on with Amaravati & what it teaches about India’s urban disaster | ep 352

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 2,5 тыс.

  • @ThePrintIndia
    @ThePrintIndia  4 года назад +8

    Good journalism needs support from smart people like you. Subscribe to ThePrint here: theprint.in/subscribe/

    • @maheswarareddy4170
      @maheswarareddy4170 3 года назад +1

      I think your full support to TDP. Please look on ground level of andra pradesh

  • @elbaecc
    @elbaecc 4 года назад +216

    "No one can stop a bad idea whose time has come" - With everything that is happening around the *world* lately, this is the most accurate quote of our times.

    • @emanivinod4154
      @emanivinod4154 4 года назад

      If you see deeply Jagan Mohan can stop bad idea even on it's time.

    • @chandrasekharkandula659
      @chandrasekharkandula659 4 года назад +18

      @@emanivinod4154 Gary, who said it is bad idea? Majority of the people welcome the idea. Senior journalists like this Sekhar Gupta may be on the pay rolls of Chandra Babu Naidu or in tie up with Romoji Rao, otherwise why did he use exactly same word as Chandra Babu Naidu -Tglaq ? He can Express his opinion after fully understanding the situation. He is asking Modi to interfere with a duly elected state government. Thank God he is not demanding for dismissal of the state government under article 356.
      Bad 8dea for whom? May be for Chandra Babu Naidu who conspired to secure financially his people by involving in insider trading. May be a bad idea for those over ambitious farmers or real estate brokers.
      No government shall involve itself in real estate businesses. Do you think it possible for Amaravati to grow in next 50-60 years like Visakapatnam?
      It is in the welfare of the state that the new government decided to shift capital to Visakapatnam to establish a growth centre within minimum possible time and money.

    • @lakshman2323
      @lakshman2323 4 года назад +13

      @@chandrasekharkandula659 For you guys except Sakshi Media everything is biased towards CBN refer to Economic times Polls and Not everyone is happy and anyone with rational thinking would not agree you were asking will Amaravati develops as Vizag, If you want Invest in Vizag as it will develop quickly then it will be Hyderabad scenario, even in South Africa Johannesburg is considered Economical Capital it is neither Admistartive or Legislative there and Amaravati is primary focus is to capital of Andhra Pradesh KIA in Ananthapur and Sri City in Chittoor or given importantance and Medical and Petro Chemical Industries are given to Uttar Andhra

    • @vkd9442
      @vkd9442 4 года назад +14

      @@chandrasekharkandula659 may be u must be on payroll of criminal jagan

    • @truthseekerms
      @truthseekerms 4 года назад +16

      Chandrababu Naidu is a great visionary.

  • @nageshwaripaladugu6673
    @nageshwaripaladugu6673 4 года назад +139

    Thank you sir...for noticing the existence of Andhras !!!

    • @arpitpatra
      @arpitpatra 3 года назад +7

      Andhra is neither right wing or left wing.thats why they are ignored

    • @UnbornWarrior123
      @UnbornWarrior123 2 года назад

      They are in south... Unless you are competent being from south, you will be treated as a third grade citizen by north indians...

    • @amandeep9930
      @amandeep9930 Год назад +1

      ​@@UnbornWarrior123 Does South Indian state news channels discuss all North Indian states? Fir instance have you ever seen a show on Himachal Pradesh or Uttarakhand?

  • @sambuddhadas240
    @sambuddhadas240 4 года назад +53

    This government is nightmare of development of Andra Pradesh

  • @ushaingilala1074
    @ushaingilala1074 4 года назад +101

    Sir this is the reason why India is still a developing state. Politicians work for their vote bank and not for nation

    • @tech-AI884
      @tech-AI884 4 года назад +10

      India is country not a state

    • @elfugaming4296
      @elfugaming4296 3 года назад +1

      @@tech-AI884 but is a group of state India is federal not unitary

    • @hareeshwarr137
      @hareeshwarr137 3 года назад +4

      @@tech-AI884 first of all know the meaning of state here state means 'a federal state'

    • @tech-AI884
      @tech-AI884 3 года назад +2

      @@hareeshwarr137 hey vegunta you should learn about difference between calling state and country. When people also taken as reference you should call it as country. If only Government and land you can take it as a federal state. And india is developing country not a state. This is explaining situation of india not explaining about india.

    • @hareeshwarr137
      @hareeshwarr137 3 года назад +1

      @@tech-AI884 lol think of this usa means United states of America . USA is a federal state having multiple state together to form a nation in same way india is also United in 1947 by vallabbai Patel which is having several independent states which are ruled by several kings that's why India is called as a federal state . The meaning of state in this context is acceptable. india is a huge nation having several states as a part of it hence it is called as a federal state if you still don't agree with me take a look at indian preamble india is mentioned as a sovereign state. It is not wrong to call a federal country as a state. A state means area occupied by certain people who claim the land is theirs a country means united states here both are correct . We indians claim land from Kashmir to kanyakumar from gujarati to arunachal pradesh that called sovereignty

  • @nandhasaran
    @nandhasaran 4 года назад +40

    I'm from Chittoor...btech passed out 2019....for any job we have to move to Bangalore or chennai or Hyderabad...we need IT and software industries more than high court...which will be very much helpful for lakhs of students.....think about it Jagan sir....we are the future.....a court may be okay...but it's not useful for students.....don't play with emotions of rayalaseema people.....we students are watching everything.

    • @MrPoornakumar
      @MrPoornakumar 4 года назад +3

      Sharan chaudhary ! In this connection I must add an observation of mine. Andhra (coast) more than any region in India has contributed manpower to I T industry. They constitute the biggest slice in the Silicon Valley (I have a nephew there, another in Chicago & his wife, all three from the present truncated AP state). Every block in San Jose (pronounced San hOsay) has them. Look at the Indian boys & girls descending from suburban train (CTA, "L") in Austin station in Chicago one finds them. First they were going for Visas, to Madras (Chennai) US consulate. Then they began going to Bengaluru US consulate, as there was no consulate in the then AP. US authorities too, cross-checking the permanent addresses of Visa seekers (most from coastal Andhra) & put up a consulate in Hyderabad. In Hyderabad city, every (well-) educated family has a daughter or son in USA, involved in software development. From Amaravati or Viyayawada nearby (just thirty km).
      As you said, a hightech (Cyber) tower like structures can be constructed in Vijayawada (Machilipatnam would be better), Tirupati as well as Visakahpatnam.

    • @abcd-jk4zb
      @abcd-jk4zb 4 года назад +3

      Which is why CBN was developing IT in Vizag (my hometown) and several other places in AP.

    • @piyushmisra1839
      @piyushmisra1839 3 года назад

      Politicians don't have to work in IT or otherwise anywhere but they have to fight cases against them and so bemches have to be everywhere so they don't have to go far.

    • @mahendrakadal166
      @mahendrakadal166 3 года назад

      Mmmmm/mm monk nnmm

    • @t_gr4809
      @t_gr4809 3 года назад

      @@abcd-jk4zb ya because he has vot bank there...we don't need an other telangana situation where everything is built (all money are put into cities) by tax paid by rayalseema and only to be not useful to them in future and be looked down by local vijaywada and vizag and other coastal people who hold power there

  • @neetisha3432
    @neetisha3432 4 года назад +34

    I am from Sikkim ,north East India, and quality of life is great here ...yes we may not have good roads or other class of an art infrastructure but the quality of life and happiness index is the better than any other part of the country.

  • @bhavanirealz0612
    @bhavanirealz0612 4 года назад +47

    Yes sir we r suffering with Jagan's Tuglak ruling..Jai Amaravathi.Thank you sir.

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад +3

      What is Amaravati? You mean 29 rural agricultural villages, "the capital"

    • @hareeshwarr137
      @hareeshwarr137 3 года назад

      First do u know how a city is built?

  • @sk8kar89
    @sk8kar89 4 года назад +243

    The phrase you were looking for is "Tughlaq on Steroids"

    • @sreesweraam
      @sreesweraam 4 года назад +1

      Bro... you have no idea: what’s going on in AP.

    • @pinnacleessence1750
      @pinnacleessence1750 4 года назад +11

      @Diwakar Reddy Samuels tuglaq reddy on steroids

    • @pinnacleessence1750
      @pinnacleessence1750 4 года назад +3

      @Diwakar Reddy ni yemma p lo na veers already pors

    • @akshayKumar-xw1cy
      @akshayKumar-xw1cy 4 года назад

      Epic

    • @pinnacleessence1750
      @pinnacleessence1750 4 года назад +2

      @Diwakar Reddy neyamma ikkada noppitho moruguthondi..idhi kuda converted reddy na..leka tandri shavamtho cheseda..jathileni Samuels la

  • @akshayKumar-xw1cy
    @akshayKumar-xw1cy 4 года назад +115

    How many times he mentioned tuglaq😂😂😂

    • @sasidhar2930
      @sasidhar2930 4 года назад +9

      giving andhra people some hint hahaha

  • @klnkln2382
    @klnkln2382 4 года назад +34

    AP lost good opportunity of having very good capital city as you said rightly. They have not realized that the central funding completely stopped. Only politics is their cup of tea.

  • @abdulsamadabubaker758
    @abdulsamadabubaker758 4 года назад +69

    I only hope Jaganmohan watches your channel, Guptaji! You made 100% sense!

    • @hemanthrudrapaka482
      @hemanthrudrapaka482 4 года назад +10

      @@GM_- Then why shift capital matters less? Contradicting yourself?

    • @sriharshavardhankuchi7309
      @sriharshavardhankuchi7309 4 года назад +17

      @@GM_- You've completely misunderstood the term decentralised governance. It means giving more power to local leadership, not having 100 capitals

    • @nagaprathyush
      @nagaprathyush 4 года назад +3

      He's seethayya...he won't listen to anybody...idiot A1 CM...Jai Jagan.

    • @sivaramaJP
      @sivaramaJP 4 года назад +1

      @@GM_- converted or government employee

    • @purushothamreddyp4591
      @purushothamreddyp4591 4 года назад

      Abdul i can't read between the lines meaning of ur comment. What sekhar posted is 100% lies. He is a friend of chandrababu naidu

  • @vin2629
    @vin2629 4 года назад +99

    Tuglaq on 4 cups of caffeine.. Best line I have ever heard.. 😛

    • @Snskreddy04
      @Snskreddy04 4 года назад +3

      Tuglaq - capital should be center of India
      Chandralaq - capital should be center of Ap

    • @abhilashkumar1705
      @abhilashkumar1705 4 года назад +5

      @@Snskreddy04 You Have SO Much Caste Feeling

    • @Raghuvir-polyglot
      @Raghuvir-polyglot 3 года назад

      @@Snskreddy04 hahaha

    • @suryak9582
      @suryak9582 3 года назад +3

      @@Snskreddy04 Jagan 2014 lo capital ekkada undali ani cheppadu sodara?...

    • @hareeshwarr137
      @hareeshwarr137 3 года назад +1

      @@Snskreddy04 what about sathavahanas their capital is Amaravathi

  • @evidence-vs8bd
    @evidence-vs8bd 4 года назад +126

    3 cigarette shops
    2 Xerox shops
    1 🌟🌟🌟 hotel
    In our Kurnool.. yayy.. development on full swing

    • @dileepkumar5839
      @dileepkumar5839 4 года назад +9

      😂😂😂

    • @SRI27499
      @SRI27499 4 года назад +12

      All CM's come from rayalseema but they did nothing to that part...

    • @lakshmikanthreddy7010
      @lakshmikanthreddy7010 4 года назад +2

      Mundhu adhi kuda ledhu..kada..nuvvu Over dengaku

    • @SRI27499
      @SRI27499 4 года назад +17

      @@lakshmikanthreddy7010 ala compare cheskobatte palakulaki kooda cheap aipoyam brother..boothulu matladadam emundi cheppandi

    • @evidence-vs8bd
      @evidence-vs8bd 4 года назад +11

      Lakshmikanth Reddy pls don't tempt Kurnool people..
      If I start speaking profanity, your ears will start bleeding..

  • @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore
    @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore 4 года назад +29

    I am REDDY from Nellore District but i support Amaravati Capital.

    • @gopimarvathi3733
      @gopimarvathi3733 4 года назад +11

      Ashok Reddy what it supposed to do with reddy anyway?

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад

      Anna, Amaravati lo sitelu konnava

    • @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore
      @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore 4 года назад +4

      @@sagredut : neeku ala ardham ayindha brother

    • @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore
      @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore 4 года назад

      @abin sebastian : 90% people voting for Caste

    • @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore
      @Ashok_Reddy_Nellore 4 года назад +1

      @@gopimarvathi3733 : most of the Reddys voted for Jagan

  • @krishnap4653
    @krishnap4653 4 года назад +77

    Great Jagan is baap of tugulak

  • @realgaming2236
    @realgaming2236 4 года назад +94

    What to do sir,,,,this is India developing from past 70 years and will keep developing for next 700 years ,,,,but it will never be a developed nation.

    • @MiNi-nn9su
      @MiNi-nn9su 4 года назад +15

      What to do.. what to do?? Great question - well firstly we should start with having proper educated leaders. Half our sitting MLA's and Ministers have serious criminal charges against them. - and these idiots are supposed to lead India into the new age. What a load of Crap. I don't understand it. What qualifications do these people even have?
      To be a teacher, lawyer etc u need a degree. Even to be an Auto driver, u need a licence... But to be a MLA or Minister leading this country, what qualifications are actually required? ..I'll tell u, Money n Mafia - and these are the fools leading us to our 'future'.
      Easiest example - Jagan.

    • @yellareddy
      @yellareddy 4 года назад +1

      MiNi Jagan is educated and degree holder. Your hypothesis is wrong.

    • @realgaming2236
      @realgaming2236 4 года назад +5

      @@yellareddy
      Saaar can you explain difference between education and qualification.

    • @MiNi-nn9su
      @MiNi-nn9su 4 года назад +8

      @@yellareddy ..so if thats the case, is he purposely and knowingly destroying Andhra and her people. Thats much much worse.

    • @sankethp6741
      @sankethp6741 4 года назад +1

      @@MiNi-nn9su Actually AP is better than before, many of people I know got jobs, only individual hardwork and income marks development, not some buildings in city. There is no such rule that if you split governance and development it will destroy your state. Time will decide. 90 percent people doesnt have anything to do with capital or secratariat or high court.

  • @djoys7738
    @djoys7738 4 года назад +142

    Looks like .. A dream lost forever for india, for greed, cast, politics and real estate business by many.
    Somewhere people and state missing.

    • @ravithejanalamary3326
      @ravithejanalamary3326 4 года назад +5

      That's not reality
      It's just biased media brain washing people

    • @rangasai0027
      @rangasai0027 4 года назад +4

      What was build in past 5 years

    • @rangasai0027
      @rangasai0027 4 года назад +3

      Everything is Temporary ,they spent 32 crore indian rupees for laying 1 km of road

    • @rangasai0027
      @rangasai0027 4 года назад +4

      And no one has expected until the 2014 that andhra and telangana will get separated and now we are facing all this problems because our ex cm wanted to move capital from Hyderabad to amaravati suddenly, eventhough andhra and telangana have to share a capital for 10 years

    • @rangasai0027
      @rangasai0027 4 года назад +1

      What will happen if the Costa and rayalaseema got saperated again we have to face this problems again,no we don't want to

  • @pppsss5653
    @pppsss5653 4 года назад +20

    Good that Sekhar Gupta took up this issue and did a good amount of research.
    Thank you for a timely issue of discussion and agitation that is going on in AP.

  • @DP-tw3rf
    @DP-tw3rf 4 года назад +15

    Once again AP CM Jagan proved his knowledge level. He will pay toll charges for scooty, now he suggests people to take paracetamol and attend local body elections.

  • @manohargutta8965
    @manohargutta8965 4 года назад +30

    AP under the rule of real THUGLAK ☹️

    • @t_gr4809
      @t_gr4809 3 года назад

      Stfu..how can you be so selfish.. Amaravati is a big scam...it is not even a good location to bulid a city..it is perciptible to natural disasters very highly...and there will a water issue..and also don't forget that all land siezed from farmers only to be given to relatives of Chandra Babu..he literally was willing to sell everything off to Singapore so they could get some shares over there...and rayalseema people cannot accept this as they cannot put their hard earned money in Amaravati where only kamma people who are relatives of cbn hold power.we don't want another case of telengana

    • @ehahaproductions680
      @ehahaproductions680 3 года назад +9

      @@t_gr4809 it’s a sc constituency and sc’s form 80% of the population. Ur watching too much blue media (great andhra and sakshi)😆

    • @t_gr4809
      @t_gr4809 3 года назад

      @@ehahaproductions680 wat do u watch ?ABN ntv TV9 etv? I don't support either of the parties..For understanding an issue u need to think from all angles...the constituency might be 80% SC st but see the statistics of the land owners..it doesn't matter to which caste people the lands belong.. ultimately it was grabbed forcefully to benifit cbn and his inner circle....that fact went over ur head completly...u are just butthurt over who won and how it wouldn't benifit ur interests.... another fact..I'm butthurt both the times over the last two elections.. coz no matter who won ,it wasn't my interest ...it's just jagan is better than cbn atleast for some people...not for me..but I can't argue for my self interests ...in most matters deceased ysr was better in all aspects

    • @elfugaming4296
      @elfugaming4296 3 года назад

      @@t_gr4809 all angles ?? Hmmm

    • @hareeshwarr137
      @hareeshwarr137 3 года назад +2

      @@t_gr4809 then why did jagan accepted amaravathi as a capital when CBN announced it in assembly in 2015

  • @Nani_pavan95
    @Nani_pavan95 4 года назад +58

    Finally shekar gupta made it. Wow recognized AndhraPradesh!!!!

  • @njramu1
    @njramu1 3 года назад +7

    Thanks for picking up a serious issue from Andhra Pradesh in national media and discussing it to the point... Such a great analysis... Me being from city of Guntur feel very bad for missing a well planned capital city...

  • @ayushprakash95
    @ayushprakash95 4 года назад +94

    "Nobody can stop a bad idea whose time has come", lol.

  • @my9654
    @my9654 4 года назад +9

    To all the people saying why he got sudden love with South India, who wouldn't react to such a ridiculous idea that will turn not only AP but India into a laughing stock.

  • @UnbornWarrior123
    @UnbornWarrior123 2 года назад +3

    What you are seeing in andhra is right now is the reflection of our society...
    Somehow cbn try to develop andhra, but andhra people don't deserve any development at all... We andhra people are like dogs... Despite you make them a king, they are ready to give up the kingship for few bones...
    And as far as I have seen my family, relatives and village people they are very happy with the money they receive from jagan.. they don't bother about amaravati destruction, polavaram project halt and many other projects... They just want the free money from government...

    • @PavanKumar-wp6tf
      @PavanKumar-wp6tf Год назад +2

      Agree, they rather see state going to dogs than to see their opponent prevail.

  • @supreethrn2335
    @supreethrn2335 4 года назад +125

    Finally... Shekhar Gupta talks about south India

    • @reardelt
      @reardelt 4 года назад +3

      Shekhar is wrong about 1 thing. It's always better to have all the talent in 1 city so it's easier to access talent for companies. Just like USA has silicon valley, India also needs its own supercity where people flock to

    • @dirisalapriyanka
      @dirisalapriyanka 4 года назад +2

      And just blurts out the exact same words of the opposition leader who was bashed outrightly by the people of his state in recent elections. The words of whom the people of our state consider as biggest jokes.

    • @supreethrn2335
      @supreethrn2335 4 года назад +6

      @snsrsnjr any opinion against Jagan seems to be ill informed to you... This is what screwed up CBN... Jagan in the same path now 😂😂

    • @dirisalapriyanka
      @dirisalapriyanka 4 года назад +4

      @where are my potatoes ur comment also shows lot of research... none of the channels are banned. U can watch all the news channels in all parts of A.P. And FYI jagan was not convicted but accused.plz don’t think people are dumb.
      It’s so negligent of u to call people as fools and so silly of u to think that people have voted based on propaganda songs. Those days are gone. The other parties too had better sounding and motivating songs if u don’t know. People of AP were so vexed up with the previous government that they stood in long queues till midnight to vote against that. They trusted jagan who walked with them for 3648 km and stood by them...people of my state are very happy now.

    • @3333kalyan
      @3333kalyan 4 года назад +2

      @@dirisalapriyanka sorry to say ,I am not happy with him and I am Ap , no one stood in the long Q's to vote for him mam ...
      Yes , Ysrcp govt banned Tv5 and Abn channel's in cable TV ...
      Plz look at below source if you have any doubt..
      www.google.com/amp/s/www.thenewsminute.com/article/tv5-and-abn-andhra-jyothi-channels-go-cable-networks-ysrcp-behind-ban-109093%3famp

  • @ashoks5317
    @ashoks5317 4 года назад +47

    What you said is correct.We are Tugluk of the highest order.We elect people we deserve.What is the use of IAS/IPS officers.

    • @rosarosa6715
      @rosarosa6715 4 года назад +2

      Let us not speak of officers. See what the IPS association said about UP SP asking Muslims to go to Pakistan

    • @rahulkrishna8984
      @rahulkrishna8984 4 года назад

      Ashok S
      The journalist- somebody who supported it an year ago. I think it’s a national tragedy.
      1.) Evidence of Insider trading with regards to land pooling .They essentially bought off significant chunk of land prior to capital announcement.Center should investigate this misuse of power of public office.
      2.)We were humiliated in international architecture magazines by world renowned architects for the government’s eccentric and delusional behavior ( they made them watch Babhubali 😂) and irrational reasoning behind building it.Its not feasible even from engineering standpoint .
      3.) Expert committee appointment by central government was against it and warned the risks and dangers of developing a city there.
      5.) It’s one of the most fertile lands in India. It doesn’t make sense develop an urban center on a land meant for agriculture.
      To conclude It’s a biased decision to benefit only a few , the few who have delusional aspirations to be monarchs of the state .Development doesn’t mean real estate development .
      Development means improving Economic Freedom levels for all the people across the state.
      The current government should pass a law to protect fertile agricultural lands from any real estate development.
      Vizag is great for IT and financial hub , Amaravathi can be made agritech center for India. Rayalseema can be industrial and manufacturing hub . The current approach by government makes sense.

  • @drrajesh4300
    @drrajesh4300 4 года назад +28

    He(Jagan) and his family had thousands of acres near Vizag,at the time of YSR gave thousands of acres and they are planning to mine mineral ore from Vizag.. the main reason to shift capital to Vizag..

    • @purushothamreddyp4591
      @purushothamreddyp4591 4 года назад +3

      Please inform the CBI brother. Don't simply put the blame because babu is blamed for insider trading.

    • @drrajesh4300
      @drrajesh4300 4 года назад +4

      @@purushothamreddyp4591 you can go ahead with CBI or thing..he openly challenged..
      Do you know the meaning of insider trading..and do you not suspect any fowl play in shifting part of infrastructure to Vizag.. perhaps you decided not to believe..

    • @RN-er7mz
      @RN-er7mz 4 года назад +3

      @@purushothamreddyp4591 it is a fact and in and around bheemili , Jagan binami , Anil have lot of land brought once the govt came in.

    • @satyaambler
      @satyaambler 4 года назад +1

      @vinod reddy he can artificially increase the price of the land he owns by declaring it as capital & sell them of for huge profit. Even father did the same trick with fab city near Hyderabad airport in 2004

  • @raviykrishna
    @raviykrishna 4 года назад +32

    Seriously a bad idea of changing capital and 3 capitals...it makes sense that bad idea is faster implementation..but this needs to be opposed

    • @gamersunited6498
      @gamersunited6498 4 года назад

      People are thinking it's 3 capitals but its 3 parts of a capital

  • @adepallisriram6626
    @adepallisriram6626 4 года назад +34

    My Sincere thanks to you sir ji, atleast you understood correctly about problem of andhra new capital

  • @satyasubhash8869
    @satyasubhash8869 4 года назад +20

    I'm from Vizag and i was happy that it was not made the capital 5 yrs ago... It's a peaceful place here and there is no faction fighting like in rayalaseema or gondaism like in Guntur and Vijayawada...
    Our punchdrunk CM is just nuts... Amaravati was envisioned as a 1lakh crore city, i was always against the idea of building a megacity on fertile agricultural land but what ever it may be it was started and land was acquired for it, a 7.5k crore budget per yr over a 15 yr period would be more than a lakh crore and it's not difficult for a state that has an expenditure of 2lakh crores every yr to budget 7500crores/yr for a capital city that would generate wealth...
    I wish some divine intervention Stops Jagan from this disasterous mistake that will effect everyone in my state...

    • @satyasubhash8869
      @satyasubhash8869 4 года назад +6

      @@mohanraju7320 😂 looks like you've been sucking on one a loooong time bro...
      So because we are into exchanging advices now... Let me give you one...
      Please don't give your lollipop advice to anyone ever again... I'm assuming you are one of my Telugu brother... Stop embarrassing yourself brother... 🙃

    • @nagaprathyush
      @nagaprathyush 4 года назад +5

      Jagan may succeed in the short-term because everyone wants a piece of the pie...but will be a disaster in the long term for AP.

    • @satyasubhash8869
      @satyasubhash8869 4 года назад +4

      @@mohanraju7320 I'm okay as long as my city doesn't lose its sleep because of this decision bro... But what about the aspirations of all the people who gave land to the government thinking they will benefit from this Amaravati project?
      We cannot return the land to the people as it was 6 yrs ago... There are plots done drainage and roads done... They will want compensation for the land that that's going to cost more than building a city there itself...
      Plus what about people having to keep moving from one place to another... It's a drain on both time and our taxes... You try to build a bridge in Tirupati, you go to vizag for approval, someone files a case and you go to Kurnool, you try to lobby the MLAs and you have to go to Amaravati... This is not practical... Even South Africa is trying to make 3 capitals into one and we here are doing the reverse...
      People may have voted for Jagan for his welfare programs... People didn't vote for Jagan to make 3 capitals where none of em are worthwhile for major investment...
      So don't keep bringing this election narrative... Elections are done... He should just think if people will vote for him again if he takes unpopular , ill informed, and costly decisions like this...

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 4 года назад +2

      Satya Subhash I am sure you are not from Vizag ,, This is highly uninformed and illogical cut the clutter by sekharji firstly Chandra Babu Naidu didn’t even Built permanent buildings in Amaravathi , the capital city is not even 10% complete , cost of construction is huge given nature of soil there , Vizag is perfect place because you need not build anything there because city is already built ,, for a cash poor state that is a wise decision ,, Kurnool is original capital of erstwhile Andhra state with a bench in Guntur , what’s wrong in having high court in Kurnool
      Now , these things are embedded in Sri-Bagh pact in 50s when Andhra divided from Madras presidency do some home work before blabbering or name calling

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 4 года назад +1

      Satya Subhash Rohan Mahadevan Mr CBN took 33000 acres from farmers but never did any infra development after his first term he became freebies Babu , he didn’t even built permanent structures in Amaravathi , when state was divided in 2014 siva ramakrishnan committee clearly told Amaravathi is not a viable option , where did 1.5 lacks crores comes to new AP state , AP is cash poor state now so building a new Capital is a pipe dream , world bank walked out because of nature of Amaravathi soil , we don’t need one big city like chennai or Hyderabad where everything is centralized, AP people are not given share in these cities inspite of playing vital role in building of these cities now we don’t want another centralized capital city with tons of loaned money , we are with Jagan he got mandate of 51% of people of AP we are happy with what he is doing because that is practical solution than building graphics city like Amaravathi

  • @yvr655
    @yvr655 4 года назад +15

    Yes! You are right. He, AP CM Jagan is indecisive and his all plans are indefinite... Finally we can say.... we, Indians never had such a wicked CM 🙏

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад

      He is ranked 4th best performing CM in India

  • @manootwo
    @manootwo 4 года назад +43

    You missed it totally sir. Jagan Mohan Reddy and his associates need to recover money that they invested in politics so far. Now he can do real estate business in Vizag/Visakha Patnam and other towns by declaring them as capitals. It is a life time opportunity.

    • @hemanthrudrapaka482
      @hemanthrudrapaka482 4 года назад +6

      @@GM_- Two wrongs dont make a right.

    • @manootwo
      @manootwo 4 года назад +1

      @@GM_- Naidu may not be good enough for this state. People's aspirations are much higher.
      Hope Jagan government will attract more companies to invest and provide more jobs and business opportunities in Andra Pradesh.
      Hope current generation of kids need not go to other states to find a living.

    • @pavankumarkonchada3882
      @pavankumarkonchada3882 4 года назад +1

      @@manootwo I don't think so. Tech Mahendra EX CEO already stated his concerns with the current government non IT friendly Schemes in Amarvathi. Not even a single MNC is showing interest in investing in Andhra. I don't vouch for Chandra Babu Naidu because I am a huge fan of Dr. Rajasekhar Reddy who is, in fact, visionary and focused on decentralization of development whereas Babu focused on only on Hyderabad. But when it comes to Jagan Mohan Reddy, he is incompetent or else he is not a leader. he won because of Rajasekhar Reddy's legacy and now spoiling his name. to the people who still support our current govt schemes, only God can save them or save Andhra from coming annihilation.

    • @muralisarma306
      @muralisarma306 4 года назад +2

      @@pavankumarkonchada3882 CBN is a real visionary. No doubt.

    • @nravichaitanya
      @nravichaitanya 4 года назад

      @@GM_- Had CBN done so then why did his party loose in his livable area? It's just a trick of Prasanth Kishore to defeat TDP.

  • @ashokbabu3068
    @ashokbabu3068 4 года назад +56

    he is the who supported jagan before elections. it seems now he realized. that he supported tuglak.

  • @bvkirankumar
    @bvkirankumar 4 года назад +51

    The current CM doesn't have knowledge. only revenge

  • @biiki34
    @biiki34 4 года назад +7

    Very good analysis.....I'm from Andhra....What Mr .Jagan is doing is a political vendetta....He wants to do against previous government wish....This is a bad move by Andhra CM.....He is ignoring development and new capital Amaravati for his own political gains....This move is very bad for Andhra....

    • @akshitbajaj1364
      @akshitbajaj1364 4 года назад +1

      He should just have renamed it to Jaganpur or Jaganwada or something similar and kept the project going

  • @ShivaFarmingVlog
    @ShivaFarmingVlog 4 года назад +65

    Certainly I agree ur statement .NCBN created healthy environment for investor's But Jagan destroyed that

    • @Snskreddy04
      @Snskreddy04 4 года назад +7

      Shiva Mudavath that why he lost in that area

    • @kalyanv6119
      @kalyanv6119 4 года назад +11

      Yes CBN created healthy environment for Kamma people only... His son Lokesh him self lost election. CBN is most corrupted and cunning politician ever in India. He is curse to telugu people.

    • @sree223
      @sree223 4 года назад +4

      @@Deepakk12345 they must be paytm batch, they doest care what happens to state, they just care for 5 rs

    • @sree223
      @sree223 4 года назад +4

      @@mrsramesh6253 🤣🤣🤣I believe you must be student or normal employee without any knowledge on business people mentality, they care about profits they don't care who's ruling,bbut they should be business friendly, that's all they look for, if ur statement is true, he could have asked them to stop investing in Telangana also na??? 🤭🤭🤭

    • @vijaykumarv3295
      @vijaykumarv3295 4 года назад +4

      @@Deepakk12345 Now educated people talking are thinking more about caste in andhra than the illiterates..

  • @avisspeaks..4046
    @avisspeaks..4046 4 года назад +37

    Shocked to see this on South Indian state by shekhar gupta ji

    • @srinivas3358
      @srinivas3358 4 года назад +5

      Paid journalist

    • @trinadhreddy734
      @trinadhreddy734 4 года назад +3

      Because he paid by chandrababu naidu...n he quoted the same thing in pressmeet. Cunning tactics by our ex chandrababu

    • @avisspeaks..4046
      @avisspeaks..4046 4 года назад +1

      @@trinadhreddy734 he is the most unbiased journalist of our days.. Please don't compare him with yellow media agents

    • @ghousebasha4458
      @ghousebasha4458 4 года назад +2

      Ground reality is most people of rayalaseema Nd uttar Andhra are not happy with making another Hyd mistake

    • @radtkl5008
      @radtkl5008 4 года назад +2

      Reddy gallaki anni red gane kanipistayi meeku state kante kulam kavali CBN reddy ayithe manchivadu ayyevadu idiot

  • @sumitbiswas6673
    @sumitbiswas6673 4 года назад +27

    Md bin Tughlaq on 20 cups of caffeine! 😆😆

  • @tunguntala
    @tunguntala 4 года назад +11

    Well said very good analysis, regarding Ports and Airports
    Some wrong decision taking by AP CM MR. Jagan
    Off course I am vizianagaram, near to VISHAKAPATNAM
    We required investment and job opportunities
    That helps people not Court, assembly,etc.

  • @mithunxlr8910
    @mithunxlr8910 4 года назад +32

    Local elections are coming in Andhra Pradesh.... let's see how people are taking the present government's governance......since our INDIA IS DEMOCRATIC

    • @anamaneniramadevi1343
      @anamaneniramadevi1343 4 года назад +3

      Common man innocently asking why ex cm left hyd, we should share hyd and as a capital, that is their knowledge, they want biscuits

    • @venkateswarluk5133
      @venkateswarluk5133 4 года назад +1

      @@anamaneniramadevi1343 Common man also asking why AP was not allowed to share Hyderabad income with TS. So, what is the benefit of staying in Hyderabad and pay taxes there that go to TS when AP is already short of cash. I am from AP and don't support any political party. Current YCP govt. behaving exactly like TDP in its first 4 years of govt. (arrogant, not concerned with the state development and not connecting with the public). So, YCP will be thrown out in 2014 as TDP disposed of in 2019 unless it starts doing some good for the state instead of focusing too much on abolishing the policies of the previous govt.

  • @susangomes9373
    @susangomes9373 4 года назад +44

    Jagan Reddy is stupid,modern day Md bin Tuglak. Amaravati capital construction stopped,senseless decisions like changing capital of Andhra Pradesh, all development activities which were started by CBN are stoped.All the construction workers lost their jobs and livelihood. How these poor people can survive?Hundreds of crores of Rupees poured into the incomplete constructions are locked up and the Builders are weeping. Speculation of real estate triggered in Donakonda, Cuddapah, Kurnool, Visakhapatnam etc due to unofficial information leaked about starting 4 or 5 capitals.If this news turns out to be false, people lose heavily and commit suicides too.

  • @krishnakishore7835
    @krishnakishore7835 4 года назад +30

    Finally, someone from the National capital reporting the facts. The last 7 months of Jagan governance's is in a destruction mode. No sane person would split the three branches for governance across three cities with no proper infrastructure. The protests happening in the last 8 days in Amaravati were not covered by national media at all. 33,000 acres were pooled from farmers and now they are let to rot by splitting the capital #SaveAmaravatiFarmers #SpreadDevelopmentNotHate

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 4 года назад +1

      Krishna Kishore This is highly uninformed and illogical cut the clutter by sekharji firstly Chandra Babu Naidu didn’t even Built permanent buildings in Amaravathi , the capital city is not even 10% complete , cost of construction is huge given nature of soil there , Vizag is perfect place because you need not build anything there because city is already built ,, for a cash poor state that is a wise decision ,, Kurnool is original capital of erstwhile Andhra state with a bench in Guntur , what’s wrong in having high court in Kurnool
      Now , these things are embedded in Sri-Bagh pact in 50s when Andhra divided from Madras presidency do some home work before blabbering or name calling

    • @vivekgupta6649
      @vivekgupta6649 4 года назад +5

      @snsrsnjr why not you under developed and rodents of rayalaseema fuck out of andhra Pradesh.. you people want to eat taxes of coastal andhra in the name of navaratnalu but want to bulldoze amaravati??

    • @maanya911
      @maanya911 4 года назад +8

      @@Deveshi.A. The most difficult part in any project of this nature is land acquisition. CBN accomplished it in record time without spending any money. Construction of the city is just a matter of time. Unlike Sekhar Gupta, I don't have any hope that Jagan will change.

    • @MiNi-nn9su
      @MiNi-nn9su 4 года назад +7

      No sane person should have voted in Jagan. He is just another goonda who has absolutely no reason being a MLA let alone a CM. If he had any pedigree in being in power, instead of waging a vendetta on Babu, TDP and the rest of his 'enemies'.. he would spend his time on making Andhra Great again.. rather than his own personal vendettas.
      He knows he has NO freakin idea of building or running a state.. thats why all this Drama and all this goondaism.

    • @vivekgupta6649
      @vivekgupta6649 4 года назад +5

      @@MiNi-nn9su he is more of his grandfather raja reddy a factionist and warlord
      He has nothing like that of his father

  • @jailreddy7263
    @jailreddy7263 4 года назад +41

    Jagan committing another Sin for his political, Money hunger

  • @DineshSingh-mn4wo
    @DineshSingh-mn4wo 4 года назад +7

    Before elections he said okka sari(one chance).. Okka sari(one chance) as CM, but now he is saying I'm sorry I'm sorry..... People should have thought before giving him that one chance. Now we can't do anything till next elections...

  • @bhomikmathur7584
    @bhomikmathur7584 4 года назад +106

    How much development will presence of one high court bench bring to a city??🤣

    • @maanya911
      @maanya911 4 года назад +15

      Answer is none! 70 years ago when there was no private enterprise in India, govt was the most powerful and lucrative employer. At that time there was a fight for capital and high court and hence the Sri-Bagh pact between Andhra and Seema. Setting up high court in Kurnool will not bring much difference to the city or the wider region.

    • @tarungcherukuri
      @tarungcherukuri 4 года назад +48

      A few Xerox shops , tea stalls , some snacks corners and that's the development the Rayalseema people will get after making CM from their region for past 33 years (out of 65 years) .....

    • @bhomikmathur7584
      @bhomikmathur7584 4 года назад +10

      Exactly.It will achieve nothing and after 5 years they will come to people and say look how we increased the power of your city by making it the judicial capital.
      I cannot even imagine the amount of time that will be wasted in going from one capital to another.

    • @sriharshavardhankuchi7309
      @sriharshavardhankuchi7309 4 года назад +11

      Exactly, it in fact rises the cost. The executive when summoned by the court should travel all the way from Vizag to Kurnool. And it doesn't make even an iota of sense

    • @pratapreddy1134
      @pratapreddy1134 4 года назад +1

      Instead of having nothing something is beneficial right ?

  • @kranthinagothu542
    @kranthinagothu542 4 года назад +15

    Respect for you sir...since 7 days 33 village farmers on the road protesting, no national media covered this story...hatsoff

    • @npd9758
      @npd9758 4 года назад +2

      Which media agencies complained or reported when the Telecom services of reliance communications was disconnected and charged without any notice???

    • @npd9758
      @npd9758 4 года назад

      @ARATI G
      These media houses started reported only when the farmers started protesting.
      But this issue has been prolonging ever since Jagan Reddy took over the AP govt.
      See the link below which was posted 3-4 months back which was posted in a youtube channel called Filter Kaapi
      ruclips.net/video/DyfCIlUXfj0/видео.html
      Also the comparison with Reliance Communication is not in any case irrelevant considering the reporting of media agencies,
      FYI none of the media agencies at that time had reported about its closure & Reliance had already closed its retail outlets three months before its closure without any notice. Many customers who had opted for automatic payment had their account debited even after their services were disconnected. Unlike these farmers, were the concerns of these customers raised by the media. The amount involved along with the lack of communicating address of the telecom company made it difficult for consumer court in pursuing this case.

    • @nagaprathyush
      @nagaprathyush 4 года назад

      @@GM_- - this is what is needed...lol, TS agitation was a success because they were clear about Hyderabad. AP will never succeed, it seems.

  • @sukanyasharma138
    @sukanyasharma138 4 года назад +27

    Thank you for keeping this conversation about urban governance, planning and informality going Sir!

    • @purushothamreddyp4591
      @purushothamreddyp4591 4 года назад

      The story posted by sekhar is sou pratisath jhoot aur jhoot ke siva kuch naheen. Pl read my comment

    • @venkateshguduri763
      @venkateshguduri763 4 года назад

      ruclips.net/video/E20BSZe3EPg/видео.html

  • @snehasishdasgupta2174
    @snehasishdasgupta2174 4 года назад +51

    "Tuglak on 20 cups of double caffine"....😂😂😂.... I agree .. The PM should councl the CM on behalf of the nation.

    • @venkatreddy-zz2ox
      @venkatreddy-zz2ox 4 года назад +1

      That's not true bro. Please learn the facts. Amaravathi is a disaster for AP.
      AP people struggled for 70 years to build and develop Hyderabad and at the end we were kicked out of Hyderabad. The same mistake is being repeated in the form of Amaravathi.
      Amaravathi is a village, fertile lands on river basin. How is it justifiable to invest 3L crore of public money in one village to build a city when there are established cities.?
      Seems like the presenter is a sold dog of caste driven yellow party.

    • @nyashodhar
      @nyashodhar 4 года назад +5

      @@venkatreddy-zz2ox You seem to be well fed with the Tuglaq idea. Amaravati is a location that is accessible to everyone in state via road, almost equidistant to all corners of AP, with access to a major railway junction (Vijayawada), 5 state capitals are connected directly to Amaravati by National Highways, access to an Airport(Gannavaram), access to a sea port (Machilipatnam) and has no land blocking issues, has industrial zones already defined, access to major water resources. It is being built between 2 existing small cities (Vijayawada and Guntur) and has a scope to be converted into a mega city belt (imagine Mumbai - NaviMumbai - Pune). It is a visionary idea. Green cities and well planned cities are easier to build in open land than to break down existing cities or clutter up existing cities. So, with all these factors taken into consideration, Amaravati is a really good idea.
      Now coming to Jagan's 3 capital idea -> Vizag has land locking issue, not close to any fresh water resource, so development has little scope. Just putting high court in Kurnool won't do anything to that city. Most of the action will happen in the benches in Amaravati and Vizag anyway. Legislative capital is in Amaravati for no good reason. This increases unnecessary travel costs, security costs, infrastructure costs etc for government. Pain for people to go to government in Vizag, pain for govt officials to travel. Vizag is not as major junction for railways as Vijayawada nor by roads. So, get your head off of the Tuglaq plan and be open to other side of the argument.

    • @venkatreddy-zz2ox
      @venkatreddy-zz2ox 4 года назад +1

      nyashodhar when you talk about accessibility, Ongole is the best with plenty of government lands. There’s no need to buy fertile lands. Can you name a city where govt had spent Lakhs of crores just to convert a village into city.? Major cities are built on the shores. Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, London, New York etc. FYI Vizag is on the shore of Bay of Bengal. There are always temporary challenges, but can be sorted with time.
      Have you been to Amaravati any time? Govt would have to face challenges to lay roads as they had to demolish homes. Do you know how long it took to build kanakadurga flyover?
      There are many imp challenges in the state like health and education. Only tuklags like you will invest lakhs crores to build a city ignoring imp challenges and rest other 12 districts.
      As a tax payer, I would not prefer my amount to be invested at one place benefiting few selfish real estate agents.
      Hyderabad is a lesson for AP people. I don’t want the same mistake to repeat.
      You are so narrow minded to judge that no good happens to kurnool with high court. We know what is good for us.

    • @sagaryln
      @sagaryln 4 года назад +2

      @@nyashodhar what accessibility are you talking about ? delhi is capital of india and what if people of kerala or people of mizoram or nagaland complain its not accessible to them.
      don't use the word accessibility when it comes to capital city. did you read sivarama krishna report ?, it clearly state not to establish in amaravathi as it will impact lots of farmers and it asked to establish between vinukonda and danakonda. it also stated not to envision for a huge city as its not required for andhra and we cannot afford, it clearly asked us to decentralize development. chandra babu and his goons used it as a opportunity and played caste based politics and distributed lands within themselves.
      once again i am not a fan of jagan, jagan is an idiot and a much bigger criminal than CBN. but one should not forget the fact. Jagan is clearly using these reports and shifting capitals. why not? Jagan is making the same mistake as CBN, instead of leaving amaravathi as it is and confine it only to govt works and focus development on remaining areas like vizag, rayalaseema etc, he and his goons started acquiring lands in vizag which are much more profitable than amaravathi.
      both parties are playing caste based politics and both are stupids. but one must not turn blind eye to what CBN did. now JAGAN can do anything as he is being backed up the reports not generated now, the ones that got generated when CBN is chief minsiter.

    • @sagaryln
      @sagaryln 4 года назад

      yeah even PM is also tughlak, did you forget what he did with our currency ?. Thats also tughlak policy. what can one tughlak council the other tughlak :)
      unless we people realize and elect proper leaders, these crappy things are bound to happen. also before commenting on andhra pradesh, please try to realize what kind of injustices happened to the state. it got seperated by idiots from telanagana and congress and stupid BJP watched and enjoyed as it knows congress is going to loose in both the states.
      once state is divided, Andhra was left without a city of administration and no funds were allocated, our former chief ministers stupid caste based politics and a vision of mega city to be built from scratch wasted lot of money, despite warning from various reports not to construct a capital there. what kind of an idiot visions for mega city to be built from scratch in the current world. so his mistakes costed him dearly and we elected an other goon who is using former reports that the capital is not suitable in that region and he shifted the capital to a new region just to make money of using real estate and land pooling schemes.
      so people are fools here, andhra is the only state that got impacted by centre as well as state govts.

  • @peddiganesh2987
    @peddiganesh2987 3 года назад +2

    Now all YCP fans will say this channel is yellow media 😂😂😂

  • @PraveenKumar-kt1qr
    @PraveenKumar-kt1qr 4 года назад +26

    Jagan is a disaster for A.P economy ..... It's truth . I'm from Vizag ... & Many companies stopped construction . He even stopped polavaram dam ...

    • @ram-ju5gu
      @ram-ju5gu 4 года назад

      Are you in india or somewhere on Mars saying polavaram stopped works are going on now

    • @DP-tw3rf
      @DP-tw3rf 4 года назад

      Polavaram Reverse. Anna canteens closed, praja Vedika collapsed. Amaravati banned

    • @ram-ju5gu
      @ram-ju5gu 4 года назад

      @@DP-tw3rf polavaram reverse ithe flood apudu works cheyaleru aa time lo reverse tender ipoyay epudu works started , anna canteen election ki 3 months mundhu started now today only i saw rajjanna canteen opened i wonder who or when they started means 8 months afyer election , adhi restaurant lo with all variety average cost 80 kani anna canteen lo ame pedataro telusu ga 65 rupees for contractor 5 rupees kakunda remaining 60 government means our money andhuke apindhi oka chinna room kattadaniki crores anta , inka asalu illegal building ithe peaks mee village vache river medha nenu vachi house kattukunta sarle elago katesam kadha ani nuvvu vadiley neku water avarasam le aa building matram government ki Adina purpose kosam vadukuntaru le water flow ki narrow chesi kattina house illegal construction ani court notice echina house heavy water vaste fast flow lekha reverse lo vunna chala mandhi prajalu houses muligipotay ante ame parle evaru muniga danini matram alage vunchali ane mee knowledge ki hats off bro

    • @ram-ju5gu
      @ram-ju5gu 4 года назад

      @@DP-tw3rf after division capital kosam ithe vizag super ani nenu anukunna kani Amaravati pettaru crops lands tesesi i feel sad but now farmers echaka epudu change anedhe main problem direct vizag petti vunte asalu ee issue radhu Amaravati farmers should given what they demand let's see what happens

    • @DP-tw3rf
      @DP-tw3rf 4 года назад

      ramareddy satti how Rayalaseema people will come to Vizag. How far it is for Nellore people. Where should all the people go. So you want Rayalaseema people to choose Bangalore and Nellore and prakasham people to choose Chennai. Already Bangalore is full of Rayalaseema people. If Vizag becomes capital everybody will look towards Hyd safer from free of cyclones. Even if they make Kurnool as capital acceptable but not Vizag far away from entire andhra. Only it will benefit Orissa and Chattisgarh.

  • @susangomes9373
    @susangomes9373 4 года назад +6

    Jagan Mohan Reddy modern-day Tughlaq.

  • @DP-tw3rf
    @DP-tw3rf 4 года назад +38

    Jagan's intention is to blame TDP and revenge on CBNs plan nothing elsr

    • @desertrose6516
      @desertrose6516 4 года назад +1

      D P so you think insider training is okay? Interesting perspective

    • @DP-tw3rf
      @DP-tw3rf 4 года назад +6

      Desert Rose They could have proved if it was

    • @RN-er7mz
      @RN-er7mz 4 года назад +2

      @@desertrose6516 can u stop the current lobbying and insider trading in vizag

  • @MorganFine
    @MorganFine 3 года назад +3

    I think Jagan Mohan is not living in this century he is still thinking like a backward African

  • @koothrapalli9
    @koothrapalli9 4 года назад +30

    Jagan Reddy is "Tuglak on Steroids"

  • @upadisetty
    @upadisetty 4 года назад +42

    Ego of jagan is bigger than wellbeing of State

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 4 года назад +1

      uma mahesh This is highly uninformed and illogical cut the clutter by sekharji firstly Chandra Babu Naidu didn’t even Built permanent buildings in Amaravathi , the capital city is not even 10% complete , cost of construction is huge given nature of soil there , Vizag is perfect place because you need not build anything there because city is already built ,, for a cash poor state that is a wise decision ,, Kurnool is original capital of erstwhile Andhra state with a bench in Guntur , what’s wrong in having high court in Kurnool
      Now , these things are embedded in Sri-Bagh pact in 50s when Andhra divided from Madras presidency do some home work before blabbering or name calling

    • @vickyn2005
      @vickyn2005 4 года назад

      Exactly.

    • @upadisetty
      @upadisetty 4 года назад +4

      @@Deveshi.A. I loved Hyderabad 10 years back. Now I hate to live in Hyderabad. Because it has become over crowded, it causes stress.
      Vizag is organically developed and is peaceful place. It should be developed as financial and intellectual capital like Mumbai.
      What it needs is convention centers, sez, startups etc.
      Now when you turn it into political capital by installing state executive machinery, it will bring crookedness and remove tranquility this place has enjoyed so far.
      Think with common sense, do you want the administrative department at center of the state or other end of state?
      Administrative department and high court are needed by people of the state and their ideal location is at the center so it is easily accessible from every corner of the state.
      Putting them at the ends is a tuglakh idea.

    • @suryak9582
      @suryak9582 3 года назад

      @@Deveshi.A. bro they might be temporarily serving the purpose. But that does not mean that those buildings will not be used later. No one is saying AP will spend too much money in Amaravathi on day 1...It will take time and as it gets developed investors will be attracted to it... Hyd is attracting investments because of the ground work by CBN..If there is corruption in Amaravathi, this is golden chance for Jagan to prove it and throw CBN behind bars.No one objects that if CBN did corruption.. "Cost of construction is huge" - does it not sound funny that Jagan/YCP saying this after winning the election?.. If they have felt Amaravathi is not a suitable place, YCP should have opposed it strongly or during election campaign they should have convinced people about 3 capitals. Did they do that ?... When South Africa itself want to git rid of 3 capitals, is it a wise idea for us to follow them?... Say PK or someone else becomes CM next time and want to switch capital again, does it not cause fluctuations?.. who will be willing to interest here if there are this kind of fluctuations?... 3 capital is just to cause fights among people...Just check how Hyd land prices got increased after 3 capital were announced.. Pls dont fall pray for this kind of stupidity acts by current govt..

  • @Him-hk2yz
    @Him-hk2yz 4 года назад +7

    How does balanced regional development come from putting high Court in Kurnool. How will high court develop Kurnool. Regional development comes from spreading out factories and industries and not by splitting capital.

  • @srinivasgoud9785
    @srinivasgoud9785 4 года назад +8

    When u are planning to come to Amaravati Sir, farmers are protesting from one month's and 7 farmers died in these days. Amravati looking like POK with full police force. No national media is daring to show the worst situation of Andhra. Whole india unable to see the poor farmers protest from one month

  • @krismaganti1268
    @krismaganti1268 4 года назад +2

    I really appreciate your excellent analysis on new Andhra government's narcissistic move, Jagan coming to power and able to destroy a very futuristic initiative, is a proof of system failure and people who voted for him are just as narcissistic as himself.

  • @influrocket2926
    @influrocket2926 4 года назад +12

    People will move to big cities for opportunities and as Indians it's their rights. Even if new cities are built there is no guarantee that they will not end up as ghost towns of China. The best shot for India is to build satellite townships around bigger cities or somehow create a low cost model for high-rises.

    • @vk_sharat
      @vk_sharat 4 года назад +7

      You seem to be uninformed. China's problems are rooted in different causes. The people market's excitement for Amaravati was genuinely visible on ground.

  • @apurvavaidya12
    @apurvavaidya12 4 года назад +73

    God please save India this is so depressing.

    • @nijilanand
      @nijilanand 4 года назад +6

      Don't ask God he send you so you can do it for him do it for yourself for country.

    • @nachiketdhende8681
      @nachiketdhende8681 4 года назад +1

      Nobody can save India.Too much population.

    • @standman007
      @standman007 4 года назад +1

      I agree with you

    • @apurvavaidya12
      @apurvavaidya12 4 года назад

      @@nijilanand I am doing what I can do but I cannot be Home minister of this country right now

    • @chandraObula
      @chandraObula 4 года назад +1

      Better yet ask God to kill prestitutes alone

  • @surajkraghavan2190
    @surajkraghavan2190 4 года назад +25

    I beleive Naidu should be back in andhra as cm.... if he could build todays cyberabad he can also make amaravathi another model city!!

    • @prathapreddy6639
      @prathapreddy6639 4 года назад +3

      Who told cyberabad build by babu.??

    • @kranthinagothu542
      @kranthinagothu542 4 года назад +5

      @@prathapreddy6639 Me thathayya kattada ?

    • @hemanthrudrapaka482
      @hemanthrudrapaka482 4 года назад +3

      @@kranthinagothu542 Raja reddy garu katti untaru.

    • @savyasachionline1238
      @savyasachionline1238 4 года назад +4

      @@prathapreddy6639 Nuvvu mundhu caste pichi vaduluko prathap. Bagupadathav

    • @pratapreddy1134
      @pratapreddy1134 4 года назад +1

      Suraj K raghavan ya I donot know who built it but there is an interesting point over here Cyberabad is the extension of Hyderabad but if u luk into amaravathi it is a rural area it is around 30 km interior to national highway building extension doesn’t cost u much but building capital in remote rural area and more over it is a low lying land need to dig 100 ft to build a building

  • @karunachandra6906
    @karunachandra6906 4 года назад +8

    As long as people are still interested in cast based politics there is no need for development of infrastructure in the state or country.

    • @surendramullapudi6283
      @surendramullapudi6283 4 года назад

      That is what is right brother... As an andhra i want it to be best in India but unfortunately it is disturbed in based of caste... I want AP to be supreme and best...

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад

      @@surendramullapudi6283 your dream will come true bro, AP is going to be best performing State by 2024 and you will see Jagan wining back to power with 58% vote share

    • @_sayan_roy_
      @_sayan_roy_ 3 года назад

      @@sagredut You are saying this because you are a Reddy.

  • @police1500
    @police1500 4 года назад +12

    Excellent analysis sir. No one, even in Andhra can explain in this manner. Congrats.

  • @raviraut8313
    @raviraut8313 4 года назад +18

    Jagan shows inexperience in vision, administration and legislation. He must learn from history

    • @vishnureddy4327
      @vishnureddy4327 4 года назад

      First you must know the condition of Andhra before commenting vision of CM

    • @raviraut8313
      @raviraut8313 4 года назад +1

      @@vishnureddy4327 what vision is that can you not build any world class city when you get a chance.After Independence only Chandigarh is world heritage city, Andhar get chance. You talk about vision first understand all 3 city have same facilities it just on paper legislative, economy etc. So this is not loss of money

    • @vishnureddy4327
      @vishnureddy4327 4 года назад

      @@raviraut8313 i respect your view of World class city.. but think ok financial situation of Andhra Pradesh brother.. it is already having 2.5 lakh crores of debts.. in such situation to build a new city it has to spend 1.09 lakh crores as Stated by previous govt. In the last five years they spent only 5000 crores by borrowing money from somewhere .. even for that 5000 crores every year 700 crores of interest is adding.. so now think what if 1 lakh crores have to spend for the capital.. how much interest of money will add every year.. the total amount of building a capital will goes upto 2 to 3 lakh crores over the years along with interest. A state already having a 2.5 lakh crores debts .. and spending another 3 lakh crores only for capital becomes huge burden for the state.. they can't even spend money for basic needs for the rest of the state of that happens.. kindly understand of state situation brother. Even we want a world class city as our capital.. but our financial situation will not support that..we need to think of future Andhra Pradesh.

    • @vishnureddy4327
      @vishnureddy4327 4 года назад

      @@raviraut8313 3 capital idea is not about building 3 capitals brother.. it is making use of already present infrastructure there like roads water facilities..etc

    • @raviraut8313
      @raviraut8313 4 года назад

      @@vishnureddy4327 you are so emphatic on Economics, buddy if I tell you that in maharashtra there's is double debt than Andhara still they Devlope suburban which sustain job growth. They Devlope education hub from WDB. Jaggan is ally in Centre why he will not request the fund like UP, Bihar where expenses is two times more than gross revenue.

  • @abhaysiddhanth7723
    @abhaysiddhanth7723 4 года назад +5

    Thank you so much gupta saheb, I am so grateful to you to make this video and display the tenacity of the idea of the state government. I hope people take inspiration from your video and garner some support so that, there can be pressure built. In today's dark age of journalism, there are very few who take up issues from the recommendations on comment section and present such a wonderful speech.

  • @saikumarosj
    @saikumarosj 4 года назад +8

    You have missed the main point, why vizag should not be the executive capital and what are the disadvantages by making vizag as major capital instead of Amaravati...

    • @saisrinath6
      @saisrinath6 4 года назад +3

      Only disadvantage is "paid artists like shekar gupta" will have no work making stupid videos like this

    • @rajamgarigiristeja3213
      @rajamgarigiristeja3213 4 года назад +1

      What is the disadvantage that amaravathi has to shift capital??

    • @mangalamoddu
      @mangalamoddu 4 года назад +2

      Guys...jus visit to Amaravathi once and then share your opinion. Let's not have multiple capitals. We don't have issue if vizag becomes capital. I am from Vijayawada. Let's have one capital only ...these guys are jus playing with public feelings...let's not fight for these junk politicians...

    • @mangalamoddu
      @mangalamoddu 4 года назад +1

      @@saisrinath6 bro. It is his analysis. Jus understand the intent..it is for our state well being... Telangana politicians are making fun of Andhra situation. Let's be united buddy

    • @lovelyric90
      @lovelyric90 4 года назад +1

      Avani amaravathi rajadani cheyakamundu alochinchali ni question els undante pelli ayipoyina amayini vere abayiki enduku ichi cheyakudadu ani think chesthunatu undi

  • @kamaltejmoorthy
    @kamaltejmoorthy 4 года назад +5

    Lulu group said that they never gonna invest in AP due to govt bad behavior. reliance, adani and Lulu group canceled the MoUs of worth more than 1lakh crore

  • @shivarammannem3006
    @shivarammannem3006 4 года назад +4

    India need more journalists and analysts like this person. I never heard of this kind of analysis from any journalist.

  • @tusharsohale6894
    @tusharsohale6894 4 года назад +16

    One of the fastest growing cities in India is Nagpur. Devendra Fadnavis and Nitin Gadkari should be given credit for transforming a sleeping city to a future metropolitan city.

    • @adrrpa168
      @adrrpa168 4 года назад

      Nagpur should be second capital of india

  • @drkolli
    @drkolli 4 года назад +5

    Well told Shekhar Gupta Sir & Thanks a lot for clearing the clutter on this issue...
    We are so unfortunate to have this shadow of Tuglaq as our Chief Minister who not only takes these stupid decisions but has been doing revenge politics 🤦🏻‍♂️
    The saddest part is During the tenure of previous govt, we use to fight against the Central Govt fr all our incentives & special status but now we are looking at the same C Govt with the hope that atleast they interfere & Save the life of Amaravati and the state of Andhra Pradesh 🤐🤐
    This isn't just destructing the Amaravati but this is destruction of the trust of thousands of farmers who gave 33K acres og their land through land pooling in a democratic Nation.....
    #SaveAmaravati
    #SaveAmaravatiFarmers
    #SaveAndhraPradesh

  • @achyuthreddy0666
    @achyuthreddy0666 4 года назад +32

    వైజాగ్ లో హుదూద్ తుఫాన్ వస్తే రూపాయి కూడ ఇవ్వలేనివాళ్ళూ వైజాగ్ ని అభివృద్ధి చేస్తాంరాంట 🤦‍♂🤦‍♂
    #YSJaganMarkGovernance
    #SaveAmaravatiFarmers
    #SaveAndhraPradesh

    • @nagaprathyush
      @nagaprathyush 4 года назад

      @@srikanthmadu7514 - stop seeing caste only and read the content/comment... *facepalm*

    • @srikanthmadu7514
      @srikanthmadu7514 4 года назад

      @@nagaprathyush I have read the comment but he wrote mark Governance ot put me dilama

  • @SG-qh2yc
    @SG-qh2yc 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for comparing 3 capitols idea to Tuglak^3. But our AP Tuglak thinks he is smart.

  • @penguin3448
    @penguin3448 4 года назад +8

    Andhra Pradesh is going back

  • @K_d199
    @K_d199 4 года назад +14

    Shekhar ji just for your update , As a tribute to VAJPAYEE ji our last govt changed the name of NAYA RAIPUR to ATAL nagar

    • @K_d199
      @K_d199 4 года назад

      @macdonald tramp or modi nagar😆

    • @GabbarSeTakkar
      @GabbarSeTakkar 4 года назад

      Vajpayee ki maa ki phuddhi

  • @Naveenkumar-wj4nc
    @Naveenkumar-wj4nc 4 года назад +3

    Every one is saying cm jagan is taking wrong step
    Let's look what happen in Amaravati till now
    Most of the land is in the hands of TDP leaders.
    Not a single permanant building is there in amaravati.
    Central govt is not giving affordable money to built Amaravati which takes 100000 crores said chandrababu naidu itself
    We need to concentrate development on across the state instead in Amaravati itself
    We can't built the capital, it has to grow itself
    Vijag city has all the capabilities that capital needs
    But cm jagan has to give assure to Amaravati formers also

  • @avisspeaks..4046
    @avisspeaks..4046 4 года назад +18

    Sir, please make a walk the talk show with Jagan and make him understand all these for the sake of Andhra pradesh

    • @KneelBeforeBlue
      @KneelBeforeBlue 4 года назад +3

      You think he'll understand

    • @digitalgraphics4176
      @digitalgraphics4176 4 года назад +1

      *AMARAVATI is TEMPORARY & GRAPHICS, it's NOT & CANNOT BE CALLED PERMANENT CAPITAL*

    • @avisspeaks..4046
      @avisspeaks..4046 4 года назад +1

      @@KneelBeforeBlue yeah u r right, his head is filled with power..

    • @upadisetty
      @upadisetty 4 года назад +1

      @@digitalgraphics4176 a city is not built in 4 years.
      Now that fundamentals are created for the city, it need to be developed for future generations with innovation, employment, etc.,
      Now what will happen is destroy peacefulness of Vizag.

    • @kirankumar-hd9qm
      @kirankumar-hd9qm 4 года назад

      @@digitalgraphics4176 talking about "GRAPHICS", I am fed up of this word even frm educated people (I hope so), so I hope u bulit or buy something even without having a 3D/ 360°view and another word TEMPORARY so when ur abt to built a new High Structures for time being they accommodated to a New Smaller Buildings

  • @hemanth208
    @hemanth208 4 года назад +6

    Thanks for the video. Please take the issue to next level by focusing more on it. It's not a state issue, it's impacting business sentiments all over India.

    • @gfhh4853
      @gfhh4853 4 года назад +2

      PPAs revision by the current AP CM has significantly degraded the investment sentiment. Many investors are wary regarding new renewable energy projects, not only in AP but india. This uncertainty in guise of poltical vendatta should stop. THE harm to the nation may not be undone.

  • @rajeshkoppaka9858
    @rajeshkoppaka9858 4 года назад +4

    Well said sir really CM YS. Jagan rule is just like tuglak rule in AP.

  • @RajKumar-jo3kk
    @RajKumar-jo3kk 4 года назад +23

    If any one really want to see how to build a Greenfield city from scratch in India come to NAYA RAIPUR where both opposition and government work combine to make it happen.

    • @tejasmohite2651
      @tejasmohite2651 4 года назад

      This country will prosper only when people hold politicians accountable

    • @rembrantwithagrenade171
      @rembrantwithagrenade171 4 года назад

      Googling it...

    • @RN-er7mz
      @RN-er7mz 4 года назад

      It is impossible in Andhra Pradesh where people are suffering with caste scabies

  • @sounakroy1079
    @sounakroy1079 4 года назад +4

    Love your words of advice for Jaganmohan Reddy...

    • @rajudog392
      @rajudog392 3 года назад

      He doesn't know the ground realit

  • @tejagadu
    @tejagadu 4 года назад +3

    I am from Visakhapatnam...I wish more investments ....projects....industries/ companies come to Visakhapatnam and I guess there won't be much benefit by establishing executive capital in vizag

  • @Bklv2915
    @Bklv2915 Год назад +1

    Amaravathi is destroyed by......😢😢

  • @dasaradhd4910
    @dasaradhd4910 4 года назад +10

    ​How vizag will be develpment due to secreteriat shifting to vizag and spending another 2000 crores at vizag to establish new infrastructure.

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад

      Don't be in hurry, just wait n watch, Vizag will overtake almost all cities in India in 10 years. It would be the best city to live in

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад

      @Lok Raj who said Vizag is bigger than Chennai but it is better than Chennai, infact it is the most attractive and comfortable city in India to live in

    • @sagredut
      @sagredut 4 года назад

      No big time invester will go to velagapudi as of now, shifting capital to Vizag and pumping in 2000 crores would add an edge for already rapidly developing Vizag

    • @my9654
      @my9654 4 года назад +4

      @Lok Raj He is a Reddy and of the same caste as the CM so of course he will blindly agree with him.

    • @suryak9582
      @suryak9582 3 года назад +2

      @@sagredut bro you are saying as if its a game in casino...Only Casino wins eventually not the people..!

  • @kamalkuku2009
    @kamalkuku2009 4 года назад +67

    Jagan is wasting crores of rupees and years of planning

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 4 года назад +6

      kamal kukreja This is highly uninformed and illogical cut the clutter by sekharji firstly Chandra Babu Naidu didn’t even Built permanent buildings in Amaravathi , the capital city is not even 10% complete , cost of construction is huge given nature of soil there , Vizag is perfect place because you need not build anything there because city is already built ,, for a cash poor state that is a wise decision ,, Kurnool is original capital of erstwhile Andhra state with a bench in Guntur , what’s wrong in having high court in Kurnool
      Now , these things are embedded in Sri-Bagh pact in 50s when Andhra divided from Madras presidency do some home work before blabbering or name calling

    • @udaysankar22
      @udaysankar22 4 года назад +8

      @snsrsnjrvizag had a worst water crisis this summer. Ysrcp members have large share of lands in both Visakhapatnam and Vijayanagar and so they are planning capital in bhimili(boundry between vizag and Vijayanagar).

    • @madhuhitesh88
      @madhuhitesh88 4 года назад +1

      Wow everyone in the comment section is eligible to be CM

    • @meghasandesam
      @meghasandesam 4 года назад

      How many years that Jagan came in CM seat?

    • @drrajesh4300
      @drrajesh4300 4 года назад +4

      Yeah he wasted so many crores..
      He even painted government bodies with his party Colors
      He even released secret GOs to build his house.. which is not official government CM house..
      He has palaces everywhere in South India.. Hyderabad, Chennai, Bangalore, Kadapa, Amaravati..each one not less than a 5star hotel

  • @jennythomasmathew
    @jennythomasmathew 4 года назад +17

    This is not entirely accurate. Atleast in the case of Bangalore, it's because of massive corruption that it is over burdened. Permits for high rises and other structures are given without any kind of infrastructure development planned or provided in the area. Illegal developments abound over lake beds and other fragile areas. Hardly a handful of areas like HSR and parts of BTM were actually planned.
    It's not because Bangalore cannot grow but because of voters political apathy.
    Sab chaltha hai! Solpa adjust madi attitude. This is what happens when there's only 30-40% voter turnout in a city.

    • @cyberrecluse7024
      @cyberrecluse7024 4 года назад +2

      I couldn't agree more...
      SM Krishna was the last time this city had some governance.

    • @ishthiaqshaik1083
      @ishthiaqshaik1083 4 года назад

      Actually bengaluru is better because it is relatively new and now it's declining

  • @PYRAMIDHEAD1051
    @PYRAMIDHEAD1051 4 года назад +5

    15:32 "This is Muhammad-bin-Thuglaq on 20 cups of double caffeine coffee " , this is something which i have n't heard before.

  • @sangamprasadarao154
    @sangamprasadarao154 4 года назад

    Me. Shekar Gupta sir, as a layman I would like to ask few questions,
    1) Do you have a complete idea about the geographical area, social and economic differences among the people of North coastal, Rayalaseema and the main region so-called Andhra?
    2) Is it a wise decision that destroying the most productive , fertile lands and making a concrete jungle for purpose of real estate business by giving the colouring of constructing a world class capital which is not possible with the economy what state is getting at present?
    3) Already state has huge dept. Is it not additional pressure on the people of A.P to spend more than one lack crores rupees to construct a capital while most of the people are still migrating to other parts of the nation for work?
    4) Have you ever questioned Mr. Chandrababu Naidu, the former C.M , why he shifted to Amaravathi when he had a right to continue in Hyderabad for 10 years?
    5) The people of every region wish their area should be developed.
    6) Which is Tuglak decision ? Either accumulating the money, power and development at one place or decentralisation of the development and administration to different regions?
    7) Is developing a capital with low cost where the infrastructure is already existed easy or building a capital from the scratch where the construction cost is very high?
    8) Have you ever tried to analyse the conspiracy behind the capital construction?
    9) Have you ever questioned Mr. Babu why he ignored the suggestions of Sivarama Krishnam committee?
    10) Try to understand the aspirations of the people of other regions too and then make such videos. Don't make foolish comments for the benefit of corrupted politicians .
    Thank you.

  • @sadhupramod9
    @sadhupramod9 4 года назад +1

    People who oppose jagan here are just favouring chandrababu without knowing ground realities... Where are you when call money sex rocket was happening, do you know why crda limit was consistently increased,do you know the meaning of insider trading. Jagan know how to develop andhrapradesh. CBN just wasted time with greedy real estate friends, and unnecessary tie up. With pawan.. even he lost with that. This is the best time to wake up and ask central parties (BJP, Cong who are responsible for DARK bifurcation)... for industrial incentives... Capital.. no use for a common man .
    Jagan must demand industrial incentives for A.P... Hyderabad like other major cities it was developed in software industry because of P.v narsimha and manmohan singh by giving incentives,abolishing sarkarraj and many more

  • @tarungcherukuri
    @tarungcherukuri 4 года назад +34

    Revenge and vengence are driving the government. What else is expected from Jagan , a hard core factionisst and financial terrorist??

    • @savyasachionline1238
      @savyasachionline1238 4 года назад +7

      @snsrsnjr I am from Vizag. If Jagan wants to develop Visakhapatnam, there is no need to make it a capital. It is already a developed city. Like CBN, Jagan can continue to make it a FinTech hub. And coming to Rayalaseema, how can a high court spur economic growth for that region? Administration should be centralised, development has to be decentralised.... you fool..

    • @sriharshavardhankuchi7309
      @sriharshavardhankuchi7309 4 года назад +8

      @snsrsnjr People voted for a change. But what they got in the end is nothing but vengeful politics, populist schemes with no long term growth plans & policies without enough deliberation
      "No company is going to choose Amaravathi over Hyderabad" - By this logic, when Hyderabad was created, no company should have preferred Hyderabad to Mumbai or Bangalore or Delhi
      "Foolish uninformed northies and caste biased southies are the biggest obstacle in prudent governance" - Prudent Governance ? What is prudent in this ? It is nothing but vendetta politics
      "you guys are almost acting like communists...when things are not economic scrap them" - Bro, that's what you are doing. You yourself said "Wasteful expense". What SG is asking in the video is just do what the entire world is doing. Having a good capital. There are hundreds of countries/states in the world that have one good capital and prospering, but Jagan wants this split capital by showing an exception i.e., South Africa
      "We are not kingfisher or jet airways to screw banks" - Anna, it's Jagan who is screwing the growth of businesses in the state by his cancel of contracts and nonsensical policies

    • @sriharshavardhankuchi7309
      @sriharshavardhankuchi7309 4 года назад +2

      @snsrsnjr It's you who is stupid. You didn't counter any of my arguments with logic, but simply by ad hominem attacks. You clearly know by "creation of Hyderabad", I meant the development of IT sector by CBN. But you chose to play on words and try to potray your stupidity by saying IT came naturally to Hyderabad. Jagan isn't developing any city now, he's just using Vizag as a capital, making it crowded, that's it. Vizag is already 9th biggest city in the country and having a good capital city at Amaravathi (it may take time) develops Vizag too as it can be used as a gateway for trade. What Jagan doing now is killing businesses and completely antithetical to what you're arguing. Come out of your blind bhakti

  • @sounakroy1079
    @sounakroy1079 4 года назад +5

    That activist statement is truest and bravest ever by anyone in public life. These activists must be confronted now.

  • @XAWoke
    @XAWoke 4 года назад +17

    You should have also covered more on when the so called critical stakeholders / lenders were pulled out of this project and progress made so far by the previous government in first 5 years. Despite the mega city promise ruling party was just limited to 1 out of 17 in Guntur and 1 out of 16 in Krishna.

  • @letsbye
    @letsbye 3 года назад

    Dear Guptaji,
    A cut the clutter analysis on the economic situation of AP state is much needed from you. We are being left in the dark, with biased analysis of main stream media, dictating their own versions.
    We owe you one for this.

  • @avinashtadi8569
    @avinashtadi8569 Год назад

    Thank you for this episode. When I saw this episode few years back, I was angry on Print channel and the editor for not supporting the new idea. But now it makes sense to me

  • @arjunkharbanda
    @arjunkharbanda 4 года назад +23

    Chandigarh is amazing but not a proper capital for both Punjab or Haryana
    Punjab is working from Mohali
    Haryana is from Panchkula

    • @arjunkharbanda
      @arjunkharbanda 4 года назад +6

      @snsrsnjr if Punjab is doing so well why every other guy is migrating to Canada? Today after finishing school every one is enrolled in ILETS and and Jalandhar has become the hub of ILETS centers .
      Also that was point of this video that we should invest and create better infrastructure so that the Load become less on Metros.

    • @YashKansalx
      @YashKansalx 4 года назад +2

      snsrsnjr you have parents money what about the drivers

    • @srenywaz
      @srenywaz 4 года назад +1

      snsrsnjr Agree. This guy sings the tunes of Cong, so he is always biased. He tries to be smart that’s all. He is slowly injecting his views to the people to dilute their minds. If he succeeds one per day, a victory for him. Ask this guy to really- means for “real” roam and live in the slums. Please do it and then give your bhashan. Be a politician to talk politics - that’s how it works.

  • @email2nishanth
    @email2nishanth 4 года назад +5

    Bifurcation destroyed Andhra Pradesh. This Thuglaq ruler is scavenging on it now.

  • @kodalisagar704
    @kodalisagar704 4 года назад +13

    To all the paytm paid Prashanth Kishore dogs / YCP slaves, This capital is intended to finish in 20 years with world-class infrastructure which India has never done before. The city was designed by engineers of Singapore and America who previously built Apple headquarters. Remember Rome was not built in a day.

    • @forever_momentss
      @forever_momentss 4 года назад

      kodali sagar this labour batch will not understand this

  • @shivar6062
    @shivar6062 4 года назад +3

    You must be influenced by CBN, you know nothing about Andhra Pradesh. You just collected the data from yellow media and telling what exactly they wrote. If analysis is found to be correct just give me answer to this questions.
    1. CBN is saying that Amravati is a self financing capital, in that case why it needs 1 lac crore to develop it and also blaming central govt for not granting funds. Is it compulsory to invest 1 lac crore to construct Amravati in this budget deficit Andhra Pradesh, was it not a Tuglak decision.
    2. As per the bifurcation act, Hyderabad will be the common capital for 10 years, in that case what is the reason behind leaving Hyderabad this much early, is it to construct temporary buildings in Amaravati by wasting crores of people's money. If he had construct permanent buildings in his tenure, today Jagan wouldn't have that much guts to take this decision.
    3. As per the sreebhag agreement if capital in Rayalaseema then High court will be in coastal Andhra and vice versa, as per that agreement judicial capital suppose to be in Rayalaseema(karnool).
    4. You might heard this Andhra is the rice bowl of india. three crops of paddy are grown in a year where the land is available via land pooling, in that case why fertilized area like Amravati has chosen for Capital region instead of donakonda or Nuzivid forest region. Wasn't a Tuglak decision?
    As a journalist your analysis shouldn't be biased, never expected from you sir.

    • @aneeshkumar6276
      @aneeshkumar6276 4 года назад

      you definitely influenced by ur caste, you know nothing abt andhra and its people,,,,u only know abt reddies and ur caste feelng

    • @shivar6062
      @shivar6062 4 года назад

      @@aneeshkumar6276 thank u bro

  • @gauravchitre7201
    @gauravchitre7201 4 года назад +1

    Mr Shehar Gupta, you are a great journalist I have always admired you and love to see your cut the clutter episodes. So plz remember it's not Bombay anymore, it's Mumbai. You are the last of the responsible journalists we have around so plz be responsible enough in mentioning names.

    • @suryak9582
      @suryak9582 3 года назад

      Is there something wrong in calling Bombay?..I am not aware of a reason sincerely !