nice video I did you build in survival and was having trouble with it but if someone else want to build it don't forget to add 28 non stackable items to the barrel wich is the lowest in height in the build
Yeah made a slightly different version of it some time ago and it works, I have noticed servers sometimes screw with the hopper minecarts And yeah sorry I thought I missed something, I’ll add it to the description
thanks a lot 😁 it’s pretty similar to the nightingale symbol but actually it’s the Jedi symbol from Star Wars, I built it onto a massive piston door for a base I did a couple years ago, and it like splits in the middle when it opens and it’s so cool to watch
would it be possible to create something similar but without the use of water, therefore suitable to be built in the nether? I am keen to maintain my automatic storage in the nether, but I am having huge problems in mechanizing it efficiently.
Oh yeah it should be possible, just would need a bit of re designing cuz I use water to slow the minecarts so the correct amount of stuff can get pulled out by hoppers maybe I work on it this December for fun
I love the design but how do you prevent the hopperminecats from burning because there is a chance that the hopper that is supposed to pick it up is on cooldown
I assume you mean at the top of each sorter slice where it gets broken, and there all that happens is that when the hopper minecart breaks, it’s perfectly timed so that the items of the minecart spit out to the open hopper, while the minecart goes into the hopper underneath the cauldron. And since it’s only one, the hopper should never be on cooldown so it always catches it And the systems slow enough so there is never a backlog or anything is that what you meant?
Alright, you make sure that hopper minecart placed on the trapdoor only has one hopper minecart in it, and the barrel by the detector rail has 26 non stackable items in it?
I want to build this on my SMP. I could build a easy ender pearl chunk loader but what would happend If I would accidently log out while sorting? How could I fix it?
So yeah a chunk loader should work perfectly But if you didn’t have a chunk loader and you left, what I’ve seen before is that the hopper minecart getting loaded doesn’t actually leave in time, so all the other hopper minecarts coming in get blocked and start clogging up the system. -So if that happens you kind of just have to pause the system by stopping that hopper clock, and then just go in and break all the rogue hopper minecarts, in the water elevators too -Then you have to make sure that wierd hopper minecart placed on the trapdoor I mentioned in the video still only has one hopper minecart in it -Then you gotta take a quick look through the filter slices and make sure those chests with the filters aren’t like missing any items and every slot is how it should be
The one item that gets separated gets sent in a dropper line back to the shulker that was being unloaded, and makes sure the system only stops when all the items are done being sorted And if you only put in one item (I assume you mean just like 1 singular 64 stackable thing in the shulker), it unloads it to the hopper minecart, and the item doesn’t get sucked out because I only subtract 1 from a completely full hopper minecart And if it’s a non stackable item, I quickly filter it out and send it back into the hopper minecart to go to the sorters
Hey man great video, but I'm having trouble with a redstone torch keeping the rail junction at the bottom powered, so the hopper mine carts go in a loop forever at the bottom, any ideas? thanks!
thanks:) I see what your saying, never caused a problem for me for some reason I’m guessing this is the rail on top of the observer at the bottom? what you might be able to do is remove that corner rail, and put it on a block diagonal to it, to complete the track again so it doesn’t mess with the torch Or you can find a way to constantly power that corner rail and then set it right
@@nader_909 Ah i know the answer for this one. This is due to the way rails work in minecraft(also redstone too can be effected) so it happens to be the way you built your machine that rail is facing the correct way but spin the machine and it will give priority towards the rail with the torch causing the mine cart to go in circles. I would have to go copy and paste that section and test it but if had to guess your machine probably works in 2 directions and loops forever in the other 2. Its just a werid quirk of how the game gives priority based on NWSE placements of rails(and some redstone). Always a good idea when making a storage system(any redstone) to copy paste in diff directions to see if it breaks or if only works in one specific direction. I forget all the rules to it. The wiki should have more info.
Yeah you’re right, I did some testing and found that it was a directional thing with the rails, placing a redstone block on top only locked it correctly on the original rotation, but if it was rotated 90 degrees, then the rail gets locked the wrong way causing a loop. So yeah I just moved the corner rail to the block diagonal to it to complete the track so the torch didn’t interfere with it
Hello Nader, Great Sorter! I have build it in survival. but i have one problem When i sort more than one stack of the same item, the first minecart has 63 of the item in it,but the next two have a full stack of 64 items in it, so they dont get sorted. Any ideas how to change this ? Thanks
hmm very strange Okay first just check a couple things Does the redstone that triggers when a full hopper minecart is detected actually go off every time it has a full stack? (basically does that one redstone torch locking the hopper actually turn off) If it doesn’t trigger properly, the problem is probably some redstone or timing issue with the comparator detection of the hopper minecart, so just make sure every barrel and hopper and things have the correct amount of items, and the repeaters are the right ticks If it does trigger properly then idk really, maybe make sure there are no random items in the wrong hoppers or dispensers and if it still doesn’t fix it I can give you my discord and you can send a screenshot or something if you want
@@nader_909 thanks for the fast answer. i think i found the problem. i had set a repeater on 1 tick instead of 4 :) But the other problem i have is that the corner rail changing the direction so the minecart is doing in cycles. the redstone block on top of this rail dont solve the problem :(
Damn i found the problem, the rail acts differently depending on the rotation of the build. So maybe just remove the redstone block, and try changing the rails to look like this: drive.google.com/file/d/1JWTX0ZhHzVQXbvgQfSjt_5M7Q-EaHugs/view?usp=sharing
@@nader_909 the minecart keeps getting stuck after dropping down, because it wont get trought the sharp curves. Only happens in our small Server and works perfectly in singelplayer. Any Ideas to fix that? I tried to get the minecart cought 1 layer lower but then it wont trigger to send one item back
When i try to sort 1 unstackable item and 1 another unstackable item again after the other one got already sorted it will just break, any ideas how to fix it?
For some reason when i run it I get the hopper minecarts in the chest and not my items, I think they are getting destroyed? are there any fixes? Edit, The shulker in the unloader isn't breaking when its finished unloading
Yep, pretty sure it’s all working as long as I keep the chunk updated, if I don’t then the minecarts will Get stuck in the bubble column or the shulker unloaded will break. But if you stay in the room while it is running, it works really well on realms
you know I really should have made an indicator light But you can tell because at the top near the back of the shulker unloader part, there is a comparator from the dispenser going into a repeater going into some deepslate blocks with 4 redstone dust. When this line is on, the system is running, so what you could do is link up this line of redstone to a lamp near the front and it should work👍
@@madlymortgage dont worry i got you, heres a link to a pic in my google drive: drive.google.com/file/d/1ObSjFoC8u_HJsjpc1PtPRUdWp0HaOzcO/view?usp=sharing
The World Download is useless, you didnt set it up to be saved near the build so I spawned in near spawn which seems to be no where near the build and have no clue which direction I need to fly in to find it, so big waste of a world download
I don't know who you are , this video is in my home , but i like the video grind. Let's have a mutual subscribe. Kind of confused with this kind of advanced redstone since i only play casually and survival because of my work 😅 , but probably i will try this later. My allay sorter was broken because of the nether portal in the latest update.....
sure thing a mutual sub it is And yeah understandable about the casual play, I used to be in the same boat. And now idk if its because I don't have time for a survival world, or because ive just done so many before, I just design redstone things because its so fun. And damn a shame about the allay sorter
Man should be studying but he's out here creating greatness
shhhh you’re not supposed to tell them
(I can’t bring myself to study stats)
@nader_909 as practice you can study the stats of your video
sounds like a plan
Good design, good showcase, good tutorial + schematics, thanks so much!
Thx, seems I forgot the schematics so I’ll add them now
This is a fantastic development in minecart multi-item storage!!!
My man, ur an absolute LEGEND! Thank you for this!
Keep it up bro 🔥
love the video
I think it is the first easy to build reliable multi-item sorter out there
I wana build it in my survival world
Love the video
:) yeah i tried to make it as easy to make as possible for what you get out of it
I now know how to build a Fast, Compact and Reliable Multi-item Sorter in Minecraft 1.21 🔥🔥🔥
you are a legend!!
nice video I did you build in survival and was having trouble with it but if someone else want to build it don't forget to add 28 non stackable items to the barrel wich is the lowest in height in the build
Yeah made a slightly different version of it some time ago and it works, I have noticed servers sometimes screw with the hopper minecarts
And yeah sorry I thought I missed something, I’ll add it to the description
@@nader_909 No worry it's works really well! super happy with this addition in my world :D
ah I’m glad it works👌
Sorter looks awesome and simple enough! Great work may need to take a look in game
Btw is that the nightingale simbol in the back,?
thanks a lot 😁
it’s pretty similar to the nightingale symbol but actually it’s the Jedi symbol from Star Wars, I built it onto a massive piston door for a base I did a couple years ago, and it like splits in the middle when it opens and it’s so cool to watch
@nader_909 oh damn you right It was hard to see on the back 😂
Sounds like an amazing entrance to a base 👌
@@mikecroakphone yessir, not sure if ur interested in seeing it but here it is at 17:35 ruclips.net/video/2On4hCsAEBA/видео.html
Great Video
This is a good addition to the FABMISS 4.0 similar design
true that’s a great design too
would it be possible to create something similar but without the use of water, therefore suitable to be built in the nether? I am keen to maintain my automatic storage in the nether, but I am having huge problems in mechanizing it efficiently.
Oh yeah it should be possible, just would need a bit of re designing cuz I use water to slow the minecarts so the correct amount of stuff can get pulled out by hoppers
maybe I work on it this December for fun
I love the design but how do you prevent the hopperminecats from burning because there is a chance that the hopper that is supposed to pick it up is on cooldown
I assume you mean at the top of each sorter slice where it gets broken, and there all that happens is that when the hopper minecart breaks, it’s perfectly timed so that the items of the minecart spit out to the open hopper, while the minecart goes into the hopper
underneath the cauldron. And since it’s only one, the hopper should never be on cooldown so it always catches it
And the systems slow enough so there is never a backlog or anything
is that what you meant?
@@nader_909 yea I think so, thanks
Oof, such a pain to see this great chest sorter after making a gigantic chest room with just single item filters
ah you know sometimes the massive room with single item filters has its own charm
love the work!! i might missed detail about sorting stacks. Mine just go to the non-selected chest in the middle. Any tipps?
thanks:) I’d love to help, not sure I quite understand though, does like every full stack of items go to the middle chests?
@@nader_909 yesss
Alright, you make sure that hopper minecart placed on the trapdoor only has one hopper minecart in it, and the barrel by the detector rail has 26 non stackable items in it?
@@nader_909 working perfectly now:)) i wonderes because someone said only 25 non stackable items, but thank you
@@nader_909 now the rail is changing its direction, so that the minecart drives in a circle
I want to build this on my SMP. I could build a easy ender pearl chunk loader but what would happend If I would accidently log out while sorting? How could I fix it?
So yeah a chunk loader should work perfectly
But if you didn’t have a chunk loader and you left, what I’ve seen before is that the hopper minecart getting loaded doesn’t actually leave in time, so all the other hopper minecarts coming in get blocked and start clogging up the system.
-So if that happens you kind of just have to pause the system by stopping that hopper clock, and then just go in and break all the rogue hopper minecarts, in the water elevators too
-Then you have to make sure that wierd hopper minecart placed on the trapdoor I mentioned in the video still only has one hopper minecart in it
-Then you gotta take a quick look through the filter slices and make sure those chests with the filters aren’t like missing any items and every slot is how it should be
ya know this is pretty good
What actually happens to the 1 item that gets separated from the start? And what about when I only put in 1 item to sort?
The one item that gets separated gets sent in a dropper line back to the shulker that was being unloaded, and makes sure the system only stops when all the items are done being sorted
And if you only put in one item (I assume you mean just like 1 singular 64 stackable thing in the shulker), it unloads it to the hopper minecart, and the item doesn’t get sucked out because I only subtract 1 from a completely full hopper minecart
And if it’s a non stackable item, I quickly filter it out and send it back into the hopper minecart to go to the sorters
@@nader_909
ah makes sense. cool design btw
thx :)
Hey man great video, but I'm having trouble with a redstone torch keeping the rail junction at the bottom powered, so the hopper mine carts go in a loop forever at the bottom, any ideas? thanks!
thanks:)
I see what your saying, never caused a problem for me for some reason
I’m guessing this is the rail on top of the observer at the bottom? what you might be able to do is remove that corner rail, and put it on a block diagonal to it, to complete the track again so it doesn’t mess with the torch
Or you can find a way to constantly power that corner rail and then set it right
@@nader_909 Ah i know the answer for this one. This is due to the way rails work in minecraft(also redstone too can be effected) so it happens to be the way you built your machine that rail is facing the correct way but spin the machine and it will give priority towards the rail with the torch causing the mine cart to go in circles. I would have to go copy and paste that section and test it but if had to guess your machine probably works in 2 directions and loops forever in the other 2. Its just a werid quirk of how the game gives priority based on NWSE placements of rails(and some redstone). Always a good idea when making a storage system(any redstone) to copy paste in diff directions to see if it breaks or if only works in one specific direction. I forget all the rules to it. The wiki should have more info.
Yeah you’re right, I did some testing and found that it was a directional thing with the rails, placing a redstone block on top only locked it correctly on the original rotation, but if it was rotated 90 degrees, then the rail gets locked the wrong way causing a loop.
So yeah I just moved the corner rail to the block diagonal to it to complete the track so the torch didn’t interfere with it
i have a problem the hopper minecart gets stuck on the normal rails after it drops down after picking up the items from the shulker box
Sorry for the late response, do you mean the slanted rail it falls onto after picking up items from the shulker box?
Yes but i think i found a Solution i changed the orientantion from West to south and it worked since
If the storage was chunkloaded would you be able to leave the area without it breaking?
Yup, just need to cover everything
Hello Nader,
Great Sorter!
I have build it in survival. but i have one problem
When i sort more than one stack of the same item, the first minecart has 63 of the item in it,but the next two have a full stack of 64 items in it, so they dont get sorted.
Any ideas how to change this ?
Thanks
hmm very strange
Okay first just check a couple things
Does the redstone that triggers when a full hopper minecart is detected actually go off every time it has a full stack? (basically does that one redstone torch locking the hopper actually turn off)
If it doesn’t trigger properly, the problem is probably some redstone or timing issue with the comparator detection of the hopper minecart, so just make sure every barrel and hopper and things have the correct amount of items, and the repeaters are the right ticks
If it does trigger properly then idk really, maybe make sure there are no random items in the wrong hoppers or dispensers
and if it still doesn’t fix it I can give you my discord and you can send a screenshot or something if you want
@@nader_909 thanks for the fast answer. i think i found the problem. i had set a repeater on 1 tick instead of 4 :)
But the other problem i have is that the corner rail changing the direction so the minecart is doing in cycles. the redstone block on top of this rail dont solve the problem :(
Damn i found the problem, the rail acts differently depending on the rotation of the build. So maybe just remove the redstone block, and try changing the rails to look like this: drive.google.com/file/d/1JWTX0ZhHzVQXbvgQfSjt_5M7Q-EaHugs/view?usp=sharing
@@nader_909 Great Thanks!!!! The sorter is now working!!! Great work and thanks for the fast reply
glad it works :)
is this sorter a java or bedrock build?
Java, let me add it to the description
hm, system isn't worling, i downlaoded and paste the litematica project, it will not sort the items or even break
Nerver mind, i screwed up, i did not paste with entities, and the minecart inside the glass was missing ❤
Nice Design, but i can't get the minecart into the glass and onto the trapdoor. How did u do it?
At the end of the video I showed how to do it, I’m sure that’s all you need to be able to do it?
@@nader_909 Oh thanks a lot, my bad
all good hope it works👍
@@nader_909 the minecart keeps getting stuck after dropping down, because it wont get trought the sharp curves. Only happens in our small Server and works perfectly in singelplayer. Any Ideas to fix that? I tried to get the minecart cought 1 layer lower but then it wont trigger to send one item back
Wait so you are saying when it drops down onto the slanted power rail, it gets stuck?
When i try to sort 1 unstackable item and 1 another unstackable item again after the other one got already sorted it will just break, any ideas how to fix it?
So just to understand what to look for, you sent in a shulker with 1 unstackable and then a shulker with one more unstackable, and it breaks?
yes, i think the Minecart got sent without that item because it couldnt pick it from shulker but i can be wrong
I’ll test it real quick in mine and see if it’s an issue there too
@nader_909 okay
Oh yeah I found a problem, I’ll make a video tomorrow on it showing how to fix it
does this auto detect 16x and 64x stackables? so i can have sort both into one chest
Indeed it does, just make sure to watch that part in the video about how to setup the filter chest when using 16 stackables
For some reason when i run it I get the hopper minecarts in the chest and not my items, I think they are getting destroyed? are there any fixes? Edit, The shulker in the unloader isn't breaking when its finished unloading
ok first question is this on a server?
(also check my other videos for updates to this design)
@ yeah I’m on a realm, I was hoping it would still work, I watched the other stuff but I think it might be broken cus I’m on a server
edit, i fixed er, i appreciate the direction
ah nice so it’s all working?
Yep, pretty sure it’s all working as long as I keep the chunk updated, if I don’t then the minecarts will Get stuck in the bubble column or the shulker unloaded will break. But if you stay in the room while it is running, it works really well on realms
How to know if It is done sorting?
you know I really should have made an indicator light
But you can tell because at the top near the back of the shulker unloader part, there is a comparator from the dispenser going into a repeater going into some deepslate blocks with 4 redstone dust.
When this line is on, the system is running, so what you could do is link up this line of redstone to a lamp near the front and it should work👍
@@nader_909 Could you please add this 🙏. I am not really getting where I can put this lamp, can you please explain further
I am trying to post a imgur link, but youtube doesn't allow me
@@nader_909 I have posted a video here on youtube, could you look if this is how you meant
@@madlymortgage dont worry i got you, heres a link to a pic in my google drive: drive.google.com/file/d/1ObSjFoC8u_HJsjpc1PtPRUdWp0HaOzcO/view?usp=sharing
Hi, can i get schematics please?
right I forgot again my bad I’ll add them now
@nader_909 thank you ❤️
@@tooman111 done :)
Bump, just started a channel of my own! :)
Does it work for paper server 1.21.1?
sorry, it should, but I have not tested it on servers because I have no test servers that I can try it on
@ no problem, i already build it. But dont used it yet, ill let you know if it works ✌🏻
The World Download is useless, you didnt set it up to be saved near the build so I spawned in near spawn which seems to be no where near the build and have no clue which direction I need to fly in to find it, so big waste of a world download
oh yeah let me make another one
drive.google.com/file/d/1-ibUtDhwZ8tjKJuxZQ_9-IgnvCWZ6p3S/view?usp=sharing
@@nader_909 Thanks!
Is it bedrock
na sadly not, I’m pretty sure the hopper minecart timings would be slightly different in Bedrock which would mess up some things
How realistic is it to build in survival? 💀😭
I’ve seen ppl build worse 💀
Be aware of item despawning
oh yeah that’s true, in a rare case of just like 5 shulkers of one single item it’s probably possible
@@nader_909 are you in discord?
@@nader_909 are you on discord?
I don't know who you are , this video is in my home , but i like the video grind. Let's have a mutual subscribe.
Kind of confused with this kind of advanced redstone since i only play casually and survival because of my work 😅 , but probably i will try this later. My allay sorter was broken because of the nether portal in the latest update.....
sure thing a mutual sub it is
And yeah understandable about the casual play, I used to be in the same boat. And now idk if its because I don't have time for a survival world, or because ive just done so many before, I just design redstone things because its so fun. And damn a shame about the allay sorter
Kind of stupid how allay suddenly follows you teleporting to the portal while being trapped inside a hopper , in previous update they didn't do that.
oh right yeah I forgot about that change